12 ms·
I Was Paralyzed by Severe Depression. Then Came Ketamine
- perardi 5y agoIt probably goes without saying, but don’t try this at home with ketamine you score off the grey or dark web. I am generally a fan of the occasional self-prescribed party drug, but if you suffer from severe depressive disorder, you should not do this without proper supervision. (And no, doing a bump off someone’s mailbox key is not proper supervision. Fun! Not medically wise, though.)
- tayo42 5y agoWhy? If you test it and have the same dosage it seems to be the same thing? isn't ketamine treatment just taking it and letting the chemical work. Why would your supplier being any different matter?
- after_care 5y agoSelf medicating drugs with high abuse potential is very risky. Having tightly controlled doses, intervals between doses, settings for administering the doses can offset much of the abuse and addiction potential.
- smabie 5y agoWhile I have known a couple of people who've gotten addicted to ketamine to their detriment, the vast majority of users have no such problems. Like everything else in life, upsides have to be weighed with the downsides. For people who can't afford clinical ketamine treatment and are depressed, I don't see anything wrong with just buying some ketamine on the black market.
- splithalf 5y agoThe same can and often has been said of cocaine. Not that the two are the same, but everything you said is the same, vast majority have no problems, it’s great, you’ll love it etc....
- smabie 5y agoI mean, honestly haven't met that many people who've had a problem with cocaine either. Opiates on the other hand, that's a different story.
- cies 5y agoDo you have a source on this? I dont believe we'd have any more addicts when we'd go with total legalization. Portugal is a great example (albeit they did not legalize but decriminalize). This fear mongering on "freedom to use what every you like" should stop. It serves no purpose but keeping prisons full and street drug in bad quality. Why would we want to pay so much tax for that? Every politician who claims to be in favor of "freedom", but cannot deal with the freedom to use what ever you like is a fraud.
- TulliusCicero 5y ago> Self medicating drugs with high abuse potential is very risky. Granted, but is it more or less risky for a person to remain severely depressed, if regular medications don't work?
- aidenn0 5y agoPeople recovering from a major depressive episode are at a very high risk of suicide. People who are currently depressed are usually insufficiently motivated to kill themselves. If we think ketamine therapy will soon be covered by insurance it may be lower risk to wait.
- TulliusCicero 5y agoOkay, but one of those is a transition phase and the other is steady state. Anyway, do you have a source for that?
- WarOnPrivacy 5y ago> isn't ketamine treatment just taking it and letting the chemical work. Generally, no. Self-administering a psychotherapeutic drug, while isolated and without training, can have the lowest likelyhood of a positive outcome. Having an experienced guide or trained therapist present - someone to provide appropriate nudges/direction/counseling or sometimes just for company - this is where we often see experiences with huge, lasting benefits.
- tayo42 5y agowhy are you saying "we"? The point of the ketamine treatment is because of an interaction in your brain's receptors, at least that's the theory. If its just chemical why is counseling necessary?
- WarOnPrivacy 5y ago> why are you saying "we"? Shorthand. You can substitute 'is', if that helps. > If its just chemical why is counseling necessary? It isn't just chemical.
- tayo42 5y agoWe makes it sounds like your actively involved in giving this therapy and then in this case speaking from a position of authority. Nothing Ive read suggests there is some talk therapy or integration side to this. Like some guides say close your eyes and listen to music. Almost everything I've read talks about its interaction with glutamate other chemicals.
- perardi 5y agoHave you…done ketamine? Ketamine can be intense. I would not like to take a clinical dose of K, while in a depressed state, sans supervision.
- tayo42 5y agoi actually have... https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28749092/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28749092/ > Ketamine is most commonly administered in the dose of 0.5 mg/kg, but some patients may respond to doses as low as 0.1 mg/kg, and others may require up to 0.75 mg/kg. This is about 40mg for someone my size. Its not a khole
- cupcake-unicorn 5y agoI did ketamine IV treatment and was told in the clinic about 1/3 have a good response, 1/3 have a partial response, and 1/3 have no response. Sadly I didn't have a response :( The IV thing is problematic and nasal spray should be more widely available and available at ERs. It's being underused and has a lot of barriers around it as of now.
- smabie 5y agoMaybe try purchasing a gram or two on the street/dark web? Not ideal, but if it has the potential to change your life for the better, the risk is probably worth it.
- cleverpebble 5y agoketamine has a lot of potential for abuse, especially for those with severe depression. it is why it is only allowed to be administered in a clinical setting.
- smabie 5y agoKetamine has much lower potential for addiction than, say, alcohol or opiates.
- Marciplan 5y agoI know you’re trying to be helpful, but please do realize everyone has a different sensitivity for addiction. Just suggesting OP should then get it elsewhere can become the opposite you’re trying to do
- bduerst 5y agoYeah, and making comparisons to alcohol and opiates isn't exactly a high bar to begin with.
- aidenn0 5y ago
- pmoriarty 5y agoI've heard that Ketamine treatments cost something like between $400 to $1000 per treatment, and insurance often doesn't cover it (as it's off-label use), so it has to come out of pocket for patients. This seems completely insane, especially as the cost of ketamine itself is supposed to be negligible, and what you're paying for is the therapy.. but the therapists role in the treatment is itself virtually nonexistant.. they just hang out and let the medicine do the work (or, in the case of lozenges that patients take a home all they do is write a prescription). When you factor in that most people who treat their depression with ketamine have to come back again and again every week or two (possibly for the rest of their life), this is a HUGE money maker for ketamine clinics and I don't see how it wouldn't send any but the richest among us in to the poor house. I've heard some psychiatrists and psychedlic therapy advocates express concern about this and say they want to find some way of making sure that everyone who needs help gets it, regardless of their financial situation, but I don't know if anything ever came of that. AFAIK ketamine treatment is still not covered by insurance. All the ketamine clinics springing up like mushrooms after the rain seem like a big money grab, and I can't believe they couldn't make the treatments orders of magnitude cheaper.
- perardi 5y agoI won’t pretend there isn’t big fat profit in there, but I have to think the cost has more to do with this being an IV infusion. You’re more paying for the medical care, including being under observation.
- pamplemoose 5y agoKetamine should be a fairly cheap treatment, but there are lots of ways that many involved will try to extract money out of 'doing good'. Check out this take [1] by Slate star codex. [1] https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/03/11/ketamine-now-by-prescription/ https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/03/11/ketamine-now-by-prescr...
- Turing_Machine 5y agoScott Alexander (the SSC guy) has recently said some cautiously positive things about Zembrin for depression and social anxiety. It is OTC, and apparently quite safe.
- xkeysc0re 5y agoIf you're interested in the history of ketamine (and its subsequent use by the intelligence apparatuses of several nation-states), I cannot recommend this podcast highly enough https://soundcloud.com/inpatientradio/psychotropic-golgotha-a-social-history-of-ketamine-and-the-global-intelligence-apparatus https://soundcloud.com/inpatientradio/psychotropic-golgotha-... I think the most intriguing thing I took away from it was that the Esalen Institute was one of the first ketamine clinics - while at the same time hosting backchannel talks between KGB and CIA agents.
- mjfl 5y agoI got ketamine for a wisdom tooth removal. I definitely had a psychedelic experience, with the nurses around me seemingly moving back and forth in time, but to be honest I'm not sure how something like that is supposed to effect my longterm mental health. It's just not that big a deal. I'm personally skeptical of this.
- smt88 5y agoThis is an anecdote from someone who is not depressed (as far as you've stated). It means nothing about ketamine's effectiveness.
- tartoran 5y agoYour experience is completely different. You were not depressed, were you? What did you expect it’d for you then?
- pmoriarty 5y ago"I'm not sure how something like that is supposed to effect my longterm mental health." No one knows. It's one of the biggest and most interesting open questions regarding psychedelics: how and why do they work? What there is a lot of evidence for is that they seem to help a lot of people with very severe depression. The people involved in such studies tend to be ones that have had severe depression for a very long time and have tried many different treatments without success, some including trying electro-convulsive therapy (ECT.. or what used to be known as electroshock therapy), and some of which had had multiple suicide attempts... and psychedelics have helped a significant number of such people -- not everyone, but many. Another big open question is why it helps some people but not others.
- mjfl 5y agoThe placebo effect has similar outcomes https://www.newscientist.com/article/2269908-benefits-of-microdosing-psychedelic-drugs-may-be-due-to-placebo-effect/ https://www.newscientist.com/article/2269908-benefits-of-mic...
- 5y ago
- marikio 5y agoIf you're interested in the intersection of startups/tech x psychedelics would love to chat: marik@tabularasa.ventures
- mindwok 5y agoThe recent wave of psychedelics being used to treat mental illnesses has been really interesting. I'm somewhat skeptical of the effects so I'm keen to see what long term research has to say, but I've read a few experiences like this about various psychedelics and it gives me enormous amounts of hope that there might be some answer to what seems like a problem we've been banging our heads against for the last few decades without any good answer. Even if a small percentage of people have experiences like the author, I think that easily makes it worth pursuing this avenue.
- sibeliuss 5y ago> I'm somewhat skeptical of the effects Can you elaborate?
- mindwok 5y agoSure! I just think the field is immature and dominated by anecdotal evidence, and especially only short term evidence. Plus I think there's some survivorship bias, people who don't have live changing experiences on these drugs rarely post about it and even when they do I doubt it'd end up in the New York Times. I'm just trying to temper my expectations.
- getpost 5y agoIf by "anecdotal," you mean personal stories, not medical studies, that's no longer true. There are many studies comparing psychedelics with conventional treatments for depression and PTSD (eg below). Psychedelics have been repeatedly shown to work faster, 'better,' and provide longer-lasting relief than conventional treatments. Indeed, some studies selected treatment-resistant cases, so results apply to cases in which mainstream treatments have already failed. Additional monitoring and analysis are always needed, as with any medical treatment. Depression can be a fatal illness, so avoiding effective treatment until the field is more "mature" may cost lives. 3,4-methylenedioxymethamphetamine (MDMA)-assisted psychotherapy for post-traumatic stress disorder in military veterans, firefighters, and police officers: a randomised, double-blind, dose-response, phase 2 clinical trial https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29728331/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29728331/ Psilocybin with psychological support for treatment-resistant depression: six-month follow-up https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29119217/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29119217/ Here's a counter-example to my claim, FYI. Trial of Psilocybin versus Escitalopram for Depression https://www.nejm.org/doi/10.1056/NEJMoa2032994 https://www.nejm.org/doi/10.1056/NEJMoa2032994
- serf 5y agoI'm paralyzed, the result of a traumatic spinal cord injury. I offer no advice on how to write this kind of stuff, but i'd like to bring up the point that my situation , as someone who is paralyzed, is totally different than the situation of someone who is clinically depressed. Paralysis might be a nifty way to explain the 'inability to act' in non-clinical situation, but 1) it's confusing when talking within medical contexts and 2) it equivocates experiences between those that fall under the adjective -- I don't know anything about clinical depression, and I have my doubts that this experience taught the author anything about clinical paralysis. I have spoken to blind friends with similar attitude towards headlines that say things like "Doctors blinded by surprise lack of supplies.". It's not an uncommon sentiment. Generic adjectives exist to describe this general inability to fulfill needed tasks or ability criterion -- yes, I know that popular use of the words allows this context, but in the interest of those that might read this stuff, understand that it's confusing and in some worst cases potentially insulting.
- derefr 5y agoTo be clear, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akinetic_mutism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Akinetic_mutism is a thing — without enough dopamine in your motor cortex, you're "paralyzed" in the sense that there's nothing you (or anyone else) can do to force your body to respond — sometimes even going as far as your body no longer having autonomous reflex responses to reflex-inducing stimuli, similar to someone who's been rendered unconscious. I'm not a neurologist, but I imagine there's a spectrum there, where other less-severe neurological problem-states (like depression) can get you part of the way to akinetic mutism, and thus you may be fully "paralyzed" in the above sense some of the time, or partially "paralyzed" all of the time.
- refurb 5y agoAgreed. A friend who almost died before getting a liver transplant was talking to his neighbor who had just moved in. His neighbor said he was a “California transplant”. Very insensitive.
- pkAbstract 5y agoAs the neighbor just moved in, I'm guessing they were unaware of your friend's liver transplant. If this was indeed the case, I find your friend's situation difficult to sympathize with. . If you did the slightest bit of digging, I think you'd find that 99% of people mean no offense, and would be deeply apologetic if their "transgression" were brought to their attention. If you're sensitive enough, you'll find yourself offended all the time.
- acituan 5y agoDevil is in the details, the fact that the author remembers their state of mind is odd. Because currently most of the clinics co-administer a benzodiazepine (midazolam) with ketamine, which actually is used for its amnesiac effects. Also, although assumed to be transformational, there are now indicators that ketamine’s anti-depressive effects might be tied to the opioid system of the brain, rather than the psychedelic, altered-state experiences, which most patients don't remember anyway. Finally, the article peculiarly omits if they have been in ongoing ketamine therapy since that time frame. Phrasing neither denies or confirms this; > In May 2021, 15 years after dropping out of high school, five years after beginning ketamine treatment, I graduated from college. Don't get me wrong, I'm happy that they have found a treatment that works, and it might as well be rational to use this therapy to ratchet out of a deep disease state. But we also need a balanced account of the durability of the effects, its downstream consequences and therefore a better idea of its mechanism of action. Without such an account, uppers like amphetamines and cocaine would also be considered to "treat" depression, except for terribly short durations and with unsustainable side-effects. To what degree ketamine is different, we are yet to find out.
- in3d 5y agoHuh? Most clinics definitely do not co-administer benzodiazepines. What’s your reference to patients not remembering their experiences? What’s your reference to ketamine being tied to the opioid system? Never heard that. In fact there is a lot of research that shows it works differently. Honestly, your comment seems totally misinformed. It’s like you’re just confusing ketamine with some other drug.
- acituan 5y ago> Most clinics definitely do not co-administer benzodiazepines. You're welcome to call and conduct your own survey, I have no way to document mine for you. Clinics don't tend to detail their procedures at this level online but I found a random internet one for you: https://www.universityhealthsystem.com/~/media/files/clinical-pathways/ketamine-administration-guideline-080114.pdf?la=en https://www.universityhealthsystem.com/~/media/files/clinica.... You should check page 8, item b "Prior to administration of the first bolus, patients will receive midazolam 1 mg IV push." > What’s your reference to patients not remembering their experiences? That's what versed (midazolam) specifically does. It is used in other outpatient procedures like endoscopies too. > What’s your reference to ketamine being tied to the opioid system? Never heard that. Literally the first Google result for "ketamine opioid" is https://med.stanford.edu/news/all-news/2018/08/ketamines-antidepressive-effects-tied-to-opioid-system-in-brain.html https://med.stanford.edu/news/all-news/2018/08/ketamines-ant.... There is tons of other primary research too. > Honestly, your comment seems totally misinformed. Sorry to hear you feel that way but I know what I am talking about. I wish you researched a bit more on your own before writing your comment.
- elevenoh 5y agoKetamine allows me to view my reactions to every/all stimuli without a default/reactionary emotional impulse. It's incredible for identifying & working on your emotional 'triggers'. Aside: many folks aren't aware ketamine is fairly non-recreational (e.g. zero euphoria)
- rmac 5y agoNon-recreational? :)
- opheliate 5y agoOther than E, ketamine is the most popular party drug at my university. Saying it’s non-recreational just seems flat out wrong.
- elevenoh 5y agoHave you done Ketamine? It's the least recreational drug I've done.
- Dma54rhs 5y agoWhat the heck is this dangerous misinformation? It's a great choice of recreational drug in the rave scene since the dawn of times.
- elevenoh 5y agoKetamine is less recreational than most antidepressants, benzos etc. IMO. So label it what you will. But try it & see for yourself.
- giantandroids 5y agoI'm paralyzed, by the paywall.
- dmingod666 5y agoIncognito
- andai 5y agoMy browser's Reader View got me through.
- howolduis 5y agosince when hackernews became a platform for pharma to promote drugs?
- ptr2voidStar 5y agoI thought Ketamine was a street (illegal) drug - and people on here are talking about it being available OTC - am I missing something here?
- 6nf 5y agoIt's used as animal anaesthetic but I don't think it's generally available OTC?
- bduerst 5y agoKetamine is a schedule III drug in the U.S., meaning it's not as controlled as heroine and ritalin, but still not available OTC. It's treated the same as really strong codeine or anabolic steroids.
- sneak 5y agoIt's a common pharmaceutical, manufactured and distributed like many others. Schedule 3 in the USA, so less controlled than, say, Adderall (Schedule 2).
- calt 5y agoI actually got more interested in pranayama and breathing techniques after some experiences with N2O, nitrous oxide. It helped me quite a lot at one point, and I have a theory that some of its dissociative effects are a similar mechanism as ketamine. I would really love to do some more research on the link between the 3, but I feel incredibly out of my depth.
- txtsd 5y agoI have tried all medicines that traditional psychiatry has to offer, and none of them have worked for me. Should I aim for Ketamine next, or Psilocybin?
- in3d 5y agoI’m not a doctor but here is a decent summary: https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-lucid-mind/202105/how-does-ketamine-work-differently-other-psychedelics https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/the-lucid-mind/20210...
- say_it_as_it_is 5y agoPsilocybin needs to be taken with therapy treatment unless you're highly skilled with self-therapy. It opens pathways for change, but you still have to do the work to change your thought patterns. The work is started during the trip but follows during integration therapy.
- hiram112 5y agoMAOIs when all else fails.
- aidenn0 5y agoAll the research I've read shows MAOIs as being extremely effective, but has so many interaction effects as to make it very likely to cause problems. Like no sauerkraut if you are on MAOIs.
- pmoriarty 5y agoThere's no clear, one-size-fits-all answer to this. The antidepressant effects of ketamine seem to be more short-lived (though not in everyone... for some there is a long-lasting effect). Psilocybin therapy seems to have a more long-lasting effect, and some people only need one to three treatments to never need it again, vs ketamine for which many people need many (perhaps indefinite) treatments. Then there are legal issues to consider. In the US, at least, ketamine can be used legally as off-label treatment for depression. As far as I know that's not the case for psilocybin yet, though you could get legal psilocybin therapy if you're part of a research study. It's also possible to get psychedelic therapy from an underground therapist.. or maybe you're in a country where it's legal. I'd suggest finding out as much as you can about both ketamine and psilocybin use in treating depression. There have been a lot of studies done on both, and a lot of good information about this.
- say_it_as_it_is 5y agoIf ketamine treatment is the best thing available to you today, it's better than nothing, but is more business-aligned than patient-aligned and representative of the problem with U.S. healthcare in that it profits by treating illness rather than attempts to cure it. Ketamine treatment involves a series of front-loaded sessions (6) and periodic sessions, and costs thousands of dollars. This is a dream come true for business as it gets desperate, committed customers for an indefinite period of time. On the other hand, psilocybin-assisted therapy involves two sessions three weeks apart and a series of regular therapy sessions leading up to and following trips. Psilocybin + therapy offers the potential of cognitive changes lasting far longer than those available from ketamine. Aside from these two, MDMA-assisted therapy is having phenomenal gains for treating PTSD, and ibogaine for treating addiction (psilocybin can cure certain addictions, too).
- jokoon 5y agoWell many people experience depression at some point, but "severe depression" doesn't affect a lot of patients. Also, this comes off with a lot of survivor bias, all I can read is "ketamine made me superman". It's important to remember that modern anti-depressants regulate serotonin and act on the same receptors than psilocybin and other psychedelics that are told to treat depression. I would rather trust a medical doctor and science than follow an internet trend that encourage the use of drugs. I'm suspecting some have things to gain from drug trafficking, and so they spread information about those substance being better than listening to a doctor. Sorry but I prefer listening to my skepticism.