21 ms·
> We could really use laws that force, once again, some sort of separation between production and distribution. Piracy is competition to bad content behavior.
by WarOnPrivacy 5y ago
> We could really use laws that force, once again, some sort of separation between production and distribution.
Piracy is competition to bad content behavior. It's a meaningful consumer response to monopoly, balkanization and other anti-consumer practices.
- skystarman 5y agoWe for the most part have exponentially more and better content in tv and film, and for MUCH cheaper and with more convenience than 10-15 years ago. But still people insist that they must pirate because the "studios" for some amorphous reason related to preexisting hatred of corporations or whatever. Some people would just prefer to not pay for shit I guess. I just wish they'd be more honest about it than the mental gymnastics used to defend piracy.
- nkozyra 5y ago> But still people insist that they must pirate because the "studios" for some amorphous reason related to preexisting hatred of corporations or whatever. This is not a good faith reading or interpretation. The frustration is in the fragmentation; having to subscribe to multiple services to get the content you want because it's otherwise siloed. Hitting that point - having to subscribe to 3 or more services to get a small subset of that service's offerings is driving people back to piracy.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- skystarman 5y agoYou don't have to subscribe to 3 or more services to get a "small subset" of the service's offerings. You get ALL of their offerings. The idea that you should pay less than $8 for Disney Plus because you only want to watch Mandalorian when you actually get access to literally dozens of extremely high quality titles is just fucking dumb. The previous option was pay $14 per person to go to a theater and that's the only thing you get to watch. Or pay $120 a month for cable. It's all just ludicrously deranged mental gymnastics to justify the fact you don't want to pay for anything. Which you can do, that's fine, just be honest about it!
- nkozyra 5y ago> It's all just ludicrously deranged mental gymnastics to justify the fact you don't want to pay for anything. This is incredibly backwards. I want to pay for what I want. That's how it works with literally every other product on earth, including the movie theater you brought up. I don't have to spend $80 for 4 movies when I only want to watch one. I don't have to spend $20 on bananas, apples, grapes when I only want a mango.
- ankalaibe 5y agoSuch laws already exist, to some extent. The issue is in the number of back doors providing large corporations to behave ruthlessly.
- paganel 5y agoOr we could fall back to watching movies made from the ‘30s to the ‘50s, that’s what I have been doing for more than half a year now and it has been wonderful for my mental well-being (they really knew how to make comedies back then, even after the Hayes code).
- vimy 5y agoAny recommendations?
- brink 5y agoSome Like it Hot is hilarious.
- WarOnPrivacy 5y agoThe intruder with William Shatner https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ci4dQ2QzBhE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ci4dQ2QzBhE The story depicts the machinations of a racist named Adam Cramer (Shatner), who arrives in the fictitious small Southern town of Caxton in order to incite white townspeople to racial violence against black townspeople and court-ordered school integration.
- godfreyantonell 5y agoShatner doesn't get his due. That guy's got chops.
- andrew_ 5y agoAnything Marx Brothers is hilarious
- dangerbird2 5y agoWord of warning that Day at the Races has a "minstrel show" scene that's pretty offensive even by 30s standards. Other than that, the Marx Brothers are easily the greatest comedy troupe in American history, and their films are still some of the funniest ever made
- JohnJamesRambo 5y agoHow about something legal instead?
- eldaisfish 5y agopiracy and the subsequent success of platforms like steam and spotify prove time and again that it boils down to a delivery issue, not a human desire for illegal sourcing. Same issue with sports streaming. Why pay six different services to watch a 720p legal stream when i can watch a stream from Russia in 1080p with questionable ads?
- 2muchcoffeeman 5y agoYep. I keep Prime for the shipping but I took a break from Netflix and just pirated Army of the Dead. If they want to be consumer hostile, we should be hostile as well.
- WarOnPrivacy 5y agoI've paid for content and watched it on pirate sites anyway because they're better organized - and they don't bury some titles to promote others.
- ryandrake 5y agoYes. A single service, with a single bill, that makes available every movie, TV show, or album ever produced. That's it. If you can provide this you can have my money. This is not a technical problem anymore. It's a business problem. The company who can make these nebulous "licensing problems" and "distribution rights issues" go away can make a fortune. I don't care that Company A can't distribute the digital version of Company B's product because Company C has the exclusive rights to it and Company D only has a license with Company A to distribute optical discs. That shouldn't be something the end user has to worry about or be limited by. These media execs are so smart, why can't they untangle this problem? I'm not going to subscribe to a dozen different services each with their own bill, their own account, their own password, their own rules and terms. Easier to hoist the Jolly Roger and move on with my life.
- joombaga 5y agoI think we're at or approaching a tipping point. For a long while I've not been able to justify the effort it takes to maintain automatic content downloads and a streaming server. But that maintenance cost isn't higher when I want content from an additional platform. If I'm gonna pirate an Amazon/MGM exclusive then I'm gonna cancel Netflix, Hulu, Paramount+ and Apple TV+ too.
- w0m 5y agoPiracy was the Easiest/Only way to get content until ~2008ish. Since then; Netflix and (...x streaming platform) made it easier/better to Pay for the content than pirate it. It does feel like we're approaching a tipping point now in the other direction with all of these streaming fiefdoms. My household has Netflix, Hulu, D+, and Prime streaming now - that's already too many and needs pairing IMO.
- clajiness 5y ago> Since then; Netflix and (...x streaming platform) made it easier/better to Pay for the content than pirate it. I'd argue that Sonarr, Radarr, etc, have made this process far easier and better than paying for it.
- lostgame 5y ago>> Piracy was the Easiest/Only way to get content until ~2008ish. Since then; Netflix and (...x streaming platform) made it easier/better to Pay for the content than pirate it. Fragmentation still hurts this to an extreme, and - worse - God-awful region locks. As a fan of obscure, cult and independent cinema in particular it’s a wasteland of titles strewn across 5 different services, and being Canadian, piracy is just a fact of life for us. Nothing beats the convenience of typing in what you’re looking for and actually finding it right away. That pretty much defines convenience. It’s what I expect. I don’t want to Google what platform my current obscure interest is on, only to maybe find out because I didn’t bother with Paramount+ I’m going to have to torrent it anyway. :P It’s literally just one extra search to find what streaming platform it’s on - which is an inconvenience* - when I can just do a quick Torrent search, and have a nice high quality copy of pretty much whatever usually within (on my connection) about 5 minutes. By the time I make my popcorn, the torrent is done, I stream it through my Plex on my Roku, and Plex even gets the metadata for me. It’s kinda scary how good it is. And talk about how inconvenient region locking is to the point where VPNs actually advertise* the ability to get around this inconvenience as a point of sale. Piracy’s convenience and case for existence has only gotten seriously stronger as more and more competing streaming services open. If there was a way to combine search results for services into one like overall UI that would then just direct you to the content even that would be better, but anecdotally most people I know are tired of the fragmentation issue.
- nradov 5y agoAnother meaningful consumer response is just to not watch the movies. No one actually needs them. Take your dog for a walk or read a book or play a video game or whatever. I've never understood why some people feel like they're entitled to watch particular movies.
- LaundroMat 5y agoAsking for a friend of course, but what would be the best setup for a Netflix/Prime/...-like experience for own media for a family of not-too-digitally-savvy users? That friend uses Kodi (and a NAS) now, but it's still a bit arduous to use for his family. She wants profiles, availability on any device over wifi and 4G and movies and series only.
- joshstrange 5y agoI couldn't speak directly to this of course but some kind of Plex/Sonarr/Radarr/NzbDrone/NzbHydra/Deluge/Jackett running in docker containers with a GPU or Intel QuickSync for transcoding is something... Maybe throw in Tautilli for monitoring and something like Ombi (There is probably something better now) to make requesting easier and you are off the races. I mean, in theory of course.
- kyriakos 5y agoThis. And do yourself a favour and rent a seedbox where you can run all the above and stream from anywhere. Costs less monthly than the electricity costs for running them in your home.
- joshstrange 5y agoWhile this can be true the local option can be quite attractive for the 90%+ use-case of watching at home. Not to mention the costs of storage in the cloud. Best deal I found was a Hertzner server for $30/mo with 6TB (2x3TB). I used that for a while but in the long run, local is king. I have gigabit fiber symmetrical so that does have to be factored in (if you have crappy upload and want to provide for remote access then a seed box might be ideal).
- kyriakos 5y agoI have a basic nas at home which I periodically download content to from the seedbox so I'm getting away with just 1tb capacity online at around 11euro per month. Have plex running on a raspberrypi which just indexes from both seedbox and nas and serves to TVs around the house without transcoding.
- divs1210 5y agoTHIS. Forcing consumers to sign up to 10 platforms to watch 10 movies will no doubt lead to a shift back to torrents. YouTube is pretty good in this regard, as it allows paying for renting a single movie for a weekend for a reasonable price.
- tarr11 5y agoAmazon allows this too.
- dorfsmay 5y agoAlthough very limited in its content, at least in Canada. My understanding is that it's because of old exclusivity contracts with cable providers. And indeed, our process is: "Can we rent it? No, fine let's fine a pirated copy". Not going to get cable for one night to watch this one movie. Everybody's losing by hanging on those old outdated systems.
- jbay808 5y agoBlockbusters used to be really good for this. You could even get a movie for a whole week for less than YouTube will rent it to you for 24 hours. Maybe they'll make a comeback?
- adamrezich 5y agowhat will users insert physical media into, these days?
- NegativeLatency 5y agoUSB ports?
- tomcooks 5y agoOne use QR codes?
- vlunkr 5y agoWell blockbuster itself no longer exists, so don't count on that one.
- DrBazza 5y ago> Piracy is competition to bad content behavior I really wish we had the bandwidth we have now, back in the Napster-era. Napster, and others forced, persuaded and cajoled the music industry to consolidate, whether they liked it or not, on Spotify, and iTunes. If we'd had easy free sharing of movies, it's not hard to envisage something similar to what we see now in the music industry forced on the movie companies. Now it's honey pot torrents all over the place. No customer wants to spend X on Shudder, Y on Netflix, and Z on Prime, plus Hulu, HBO, and your cable/satellite fee either. Paying 200 GBP/USD a month is utterly absurd. Frankly, I'm glad I have a waning interest in modern movies as I get older, and I'm actually more interested in watching old black and white movies that are "free to air" in my country.
- johnchristopher 5y ago> Frankly, I'm glad I have a waning interest in modern movies as I get older, and I'm actually more interested in watching old black and white movies that are "free to air" in my country. My mother recently gave me a sub-account to Netflix and while I was thrilled to rewatch some shows I liked (like the OA or good old star trek) I was quickly submerged by the sheer amount of YA novels adapted in TV shows or movies that are really mediocre. Now I see there's a lot of content on Netflix but I feel like I am swimming in an ocean of never ending content produced with the same recipe.
- hellbannedguy 5y agoNetflix is terrible if you have good taste in movies. I'm with you on the old black/white movies. I actually think Amazon got a great deal buying MGM. If TCM was available, Nefflix should look into buying it. They have a great library of old movies.
- alborzb 5y agoTCM was available (alongside all of Warner Bros. Media, Turner Media and DC Comics)... It's getting absorbed by Discovery [1], I imagine that a competitive bidding process must have taken place, presumably Netflix didn't see the benefits. [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2021/05/24/john-malone-sees-warnermedia-discovery-as-no-3-streamer-behind-netflix-disney.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/05/24/john-malone-sees-warnermedia...
- iso1631 5y agoQuite. I DCCed Trek and SG1 episodes in the late 90s and early 00s because they weren't available in the UK. I don't do that with Discovery, Picard, Wandavision, etc, because they are available. Then they completely cocked up Lower Decks and wouldn't take my money. Bittorrent to the rescue. There is always competition.
- kyriakos 5y agoAnother scifi fan. Good choices.
- throwaway894345 5y agoMy biggest gripe is that the prices are totally artificial. I rented The Fugitive (1993 irrc) for $5 for 2 days and it costs $20 to buy it—as much as a brand new blockbuster in HD on physical media. This doesn’t seem like a particularly free market.
- ghaff 5y agoIt actually looks like the Blu-Ray DVD of The Fugitive is $10. Though in general, older content (whether e-book, streaming movies, or purchased music) never seems to be as much cheaper as you'd think it "should" be. I imagine most of the rights holders don't want to get into a race to the bottom for non-blockbuster content so they tend to stay around industry price norms for newer material.
- throwaway894345 5y ago> It actually looks like the Blu-Ray DVD of The Fugitive is $10. Though in general, older content (whether e-book, streaming movies, or purchased music) never seems to be as much cheaper as you'd think it "should" be. I imagine most of the rights holders don't want to get into a race to the bottom for non-blockbuster content so they tend to stay around industry price norms for newer material. Right, the copyright holders effectively get to dictate the price and prevent redistribution (how does someone resell their digital [non-physical] copy to me without running afoul of DMCA and the like?). It's not a normal market, and the MPAA and similar organizations have lobbied to dictate the market rules to funnel as much money as possible to them. For example, copyright terms these days are absurdly long--70 years beyond the lifetime of the original author.
- GistNoesis 5y agoPiracy doesn't solve the more dangerous underlying problem of influencing opinions. For example all Apple TV shows are full of Apple product placement every minute or so. It's not something new, Disney creates most of their characters with merchandising in mind. Look at baby Yoda. But it also goes deeper, when it aims to spread ideologies and behaviors. Now that a James Bond villain write the show, I wonder who the bad guy will be.
- syshum 5y ago>>Disney creates most of their characters with merchandising in mind. Look at baby Yoda. They may try for that, but recent star wars is a merchandising disaster. Baby Yoda is the only real success with Cara Dune coming in second before they nuked that.
- powerslacker 5y agoI don't think you can prove that piracy is an effective means to incentivize good behavior on the part of the media industries. Also, it seems irresponsible to openly promote theft as a 'good idea'. I understand there are arguments against calling or treating piracy as theft but at the end of the day you are taking something that isn't yours without paying for it. Encouraging people to take part in illegal activity on the internet has real consequences. I'm guilty of wanting to fight fire with fire as well — and in the past I've pirated plenty. Looking back, it wasn't a good idea then and it still isn't today.
- leetcrew 5y agomeh, it's a problem of their own making. I used to torrent tons of music. now that I can just buy unencumbered flac files (bandcamp) and stream the rest in good quality for a reasonable price, I don't torrent music. I have room in my budget for a $50/month or even $100/month service where I can stream any movie/show I want. I don't have room in my budget for 5-10 $10/month services where I have to keep track of who has what content and use a bunch of different UIs. it's not even about the money. it's that the paid service manages to be less convenient than VPN+NAS+plex.
- cacois 5y agoSo wait, your solution is to encourage all consumers to break the law and put themselves at legal risk, rather than have reasonable legislation focused on consumer welfare and encouraging competition?
- autosharp 5y agoIs not a solution but an observation. Your proposal could be a better solution but until then piracy is the next-best thing for many consumers.
- aboringusername 5y agoYes, because as of today, right now, every human on earth could decide to not visit the cinema again and instead download the content off of the internet. The laws take time, need to be tested in courts and are generally not as effective. If you're constantly under threat of losing your entire income stream and there's nothing you can do to prevent that (because the only way to prevent piracy of digital content is to ban the internet) it's a pretty decent motivator to do the right thing.
- cacois 5y agoSure, but the idea of mass collective action is always a bit of a nuclear option, because it takes a huge bit of motivation to actually make _everyone_ do anything. So, could they? Sure. Will they en masse? No. Everyone could have stolen cable back in the day and caused a decrease in cable prices and increase in customer experience. They didn't.
- sergiotapia 5y agoBeen in usenet for a while now. 4k remux all the way!
- akira2501 5y ago> Piracy is competition to bad content behavior. No it isn't. It's a workaround. This is an 8 billion dollar deal, there would have to be an impossible amount of piracy for it to count as "competition." This is precisely the reason why government regulation here is correct, as consumers, we don't have a lever long enough to have any real impact on the core problem. And we're just one side of the deal. These types of distribution setups are not just bad for consumers, but for actors, directors, producers and anyone who makes a living on any part of these productions. The knee jerk responses to avoid meaningful government regulation are always baffling to me.
- caeril 5y ago> No it isn't. It's a workaround. Sure, but it's a trivially easy workaround. Our focus of attention on matters of regulation ought to be in those areas where working around the problem is not nearly as dead simple as a torrent client, a NAS, and a Plex server.
- threatofrain 5y agoThe two solutions don't play in the same ballpark of EV either. With Torrent and NAS and Plex you're talking niche phenomena forever.
- asdff 5y agoIt's a lot easier than that now. There are apps now that package the bittorent client and website with magnet links into a single unified app ecosystem that looks somewhat like the spotify app, but with practically every movie and TV show ever produced. You don't have to wait for downloads, the client will stream the torrent for you after maybe 30 seconds of buffer. It's often much faster for me to use this app to get to a show, than to navigate the website and do the same for a service I might pay for.
- dkarl 5y agoTrivially easy for a trivially small number of people. Does everyone else have to put up with whatever experience Amazon thinks they should get?
- IncRnd 5y ago> Piracy is competition to bad content behavior. It's a meaningful consumer response to monopoly, balkanization and other anti-consumer practices. That's similar to saying that stealing candy bars is a meaninful consumer response to high prices at convenience stores.
- cheph 5y agoCame here to say this, I avoid giving money to Amazon like the plague. I will go out of my way and invest my personal time as long as Amazon gets nothing. Don't give them your money.
- teawrecks 5y agoIt's not though. If you have a system with no piracy, it's an indication that the industry could be more greedy. This is what we saw with Netflix's disruption and the drop of piracy, followed by all the other streaming services and the return of piracy. So there's an acceptable amount of piracy that they're shooting for, and that amount is the line where it's cheapest to lobby the govt to prosecute pirates than it is to give customers a better experience. That's not consumer friendly IMO.
- charwalker 5y agoIf it isn't legal, and normal democratic processes won't make it legal in the short term, then it isn't viable competition. DMCA/etc vastly favors content owners who also lobby hard to maintain their ownership by extending copyright and similar protections. Anti-competitive behavior must be countered but unless it's well funded and focused will end up like the IRS and DMCA today, going after small fish due to lack of resources to challenge those that can afford to fight like players as big as Amazon and MGM.