5 ms·
Tardigrades survive impacts of up to 825 meters per second
- tromp 5y agoThat's roughly 3000km/h. At higher speeds, impact tore them apart and they didn't survive.
- spiritplumber 5y agoWhen you put all your points into endurance.
- Aeolun 5y agoI Don't Want to Get Hurt, so I'll Max Out My Defense
- virtue3 5y agoamazing anime.
- meowster 5y agoI didn't know about it, thank you for the recommendation. The premise does seem interesting, I'll have to give it a try. I haven't watched any Anime in a long time, would anyone be open to providing some suggestions? Anime I liked: Planetes (which I've seen mentioned in several HN comments in the past as it's hard sci-fi!), Full Metal Panic, Full Metal Alchemist, Last Exile, Geneshaft, Space Cowboy, Read or Die. Some ones I have but not watched: R.O.D. the TV, The Third, Black Lagoon, Steins;Gate, Trinity Blood.
- virtue3 5y agoIf you like hard sci-fi ish anime: Akira (just in case you haven't seen it). Legend of Galactic Heroes (it's on crunchyroll, the new one, hardcore anime space opera stuff) Jujutsu Kaisen was absolutely killer the last two seasons. (typical shonen but done really well) Code Geass (mecha plus nation state subterfuge) One Punch Man (really really funny).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bongoman37 5y agoWhat does that mean? you need to specify impact on what or some kind of acceleration measure. Impact on a meter of down feathers would not be the same as impact on water or concrete or diamond.
- Aeolun 5y agoIf you read the article, you’ll find out it’s sand.
- oolonthegreat 5y agoapparently it was made on sand, to answer the question of tardigrades traveling through space on asteroids and crashing on a planet.
- ourmandave 5y ago1845.47 mph That's faster than the muzzle velocity of 7.62 nato rounds (1772 mph).
- Zenst 5y agoTardigrades seem too of become the crash test dummies of science, seen stories of them being frozen, heated, starved.... Which made me ask - are they intelligent "Does a Tardigrade have a brain? Tardigrades have a dorsal brain atop a paired ventral nervous system. (Humans have a dorsal brain and a single dorsal nervous system.) The body cavity of tardigrades is an open hemocoel that touches every cell, allowing efficient nutrition and gas exchange with no need for circulatory or respiratory systems." from https://www.americanscientist.org/article/tardigrades https://www.americanscientist.org/article/tardigrades Which is all interesting as AFAIK we still don't know for sure if they feel pain. Not that I'm siding with any side of the ethics in this respect - just fascinating how that line is defined and changed over time. Makes you wonder how we would view such science in a few hundred years. That all said, one question I do have - did they have some expected modelled result and this was science to see how their calculations compared to refine a model, or was it just science to measure results without any expectations or idea upon the results!
- tomcam 5y agoWould like to understand the downvotes on this
- pc86 5y ago"Please don't comment about the voting on comments. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- okamiueru 5y agoThoughtful discussions should trump that, surely? Downvotes can be a reflection on many things, and wondering which or what, seems to be a fair thing to wonder about. Context is king. After all, the voting system exists to foster positive discussions. What do you suggest is the alternative correct phrasing then? Or are certain honest and curiosity based questions forbidden on HN?
- sombremesa 5y ago
- MeteorMarc 5y agoStill, though, the tardigrade prefers to avoid large accelerations and rather uses spacetime jumps https://screenrant.com/star-trek-discovery-ripper-tardigrade-monster-navigator/ https://screenrant.com/star-trek-discovery-ripper-tardigrade...
- johnchristopher 5y agoUgh, spoilers.
- bartread 5y agoThat's interesting but I don't think it's anything like a conclusive answer on whether tardigrades can travel between habitable worlds on asteroids, meteors, comets, and other objects travelling through space. Plenty of meteors break up in the atmosphere, with only small fragments reaching the ground at much slower speeds (significantly less than 825 meters/second by the time air resistance has decelerated them), and so the question then becomes what forces would they experience as the meteor entered the atmosphere and broke up, and could they survive those? Sure, if you're talking about a large asteroid impact that reaches the ground, it may not be possible for them to survive, but most of the objects that hit earth's atmosphere are not large asteroids (e.g., bolides, potentially comets, etc.). Presumably, at least in theory, they could also carry frozen/sleeping tardigrades?
- Zenst 5y agoYou raise another aspect that is overlooked. How fast can are tartigrade travel when encased in ice (an instance already shown that it can survive).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- karmakaze 5y agoI think the useful measure is acceleration (or deceleration). A tardigrade (as a human) could withstand deceleration from any speed if done gradually. > The researchers found that the tardigrades shot from the gun at speeds up to 825 meters per second could be resuscitated after removal from the cylinder. Those experiencing higher-speed impacts were torn apart and did not survive. What's of interest is the acceleration that can be tolerated m/s^2. Accelerating a cylinder (presumably with a mass much greater than the tardigrades) could be considered to be similar to having the tardigrades accelerated to 825 m/s then having it hit a hard metal surface, if for example the cylinder was made of such a metal and it was decelerated from 825 m/s to zero with the tartigrades then hitting the wall of the cylinder end. So it comes down to the surfaces around the tartigrade upon impact, it could be much softer than metal, glass, etc.
- captaindiego 5y agoThere were tardigrades on the Indian moon lander Chandrayaan-2, which crashed-landed in 2019. From reading this, it seems plausible that they could have survived.
- GistNoesis 5y agoBeresheet crashed earlier in april 2019 with tardigrades on board and velocity (last telemetry at 149m height 134m/s vertical speed and 947m/s horizontal speed) which probably allow survival.
- beebeepka 5y agoKilling things in various ways... for "science"
- pc86 5y agoI've got bad news for you about science then.
- jiofih 5y ago> The researchers suggest that tardigrades would likely not survive an impact with a planet if they traveled across space on an asteroid (as some have suggested), as such impacts tend to be at higher speeds Planets have atmospheres. The terminal velocity for an asteroid on earth will be 100-200 meters per second which is well below that threshold, not sure how they arrived at this conclusion.
- mumblemumble 5y agoI would assume that they're talking about tardigrades traveling from Earth to another planet. The most likely destination from Earth, Mars, would have a much higher terminal velocity.
- tastyfreeze 5y agoNot necessarily. I assumed it was a test to explore the panspermia hypothesis that posits life propagates between planets and stars on ejecta from a planet with life.
- mumblemumble 5y agoI think that it could still be that, but with a focus on panspermia in general, not the specific case of Earth. For the specific case of Earth, wouldn't we want to instead be investigating the survivability of single-celled microbes? It seems like one could rather trivially dismiss the idea that earth was seeded with tardigrade-like organisms based on the fact that they're too evolutionarily advanced to account for six of the seven kingdoms of life we have on this planet.
- ectopod 5y agoIf a tardigrade was sitting on an asteroid, wouldn't the atmosphere blow it free? And then it could float gently down to earth.
- zardo 5y agoI think the real question is could tardigrades (or anything else) survive the ride up from Earth on ejecta.
- vibrio 5y agoI accidentally pulsed an ant in micro-centrifuge once, achieving a few thousand x g momentarily. The ant was still walking after, albeit less well. I was surprised the ant made it. Note: I am not a sadist nor an ant-torturer. The ant evidently crawled, unnoticed, into one tube of a series. I was preparing on my lab bench [A bench shared with an ant-contaminated incubator-- ants like agar-media plates]. The presence of the ant was noticed after the centrifuge pulse. A long-term follow up on the ant's status was not performed as the ant was let go after. The sample in which the ant was found was discarded and re-prepared.
- husarcik 5y agoI loved this story. Reminds me of all my failed biochemistry experiments. Perhaps, mine were also contaminated by ants.
- vibrio 5y agoThat incubator held bacterial plates for cloning. The ants would walk across the plates and sometimes leave a trail of bacterial colonies showing the path they took. Cleaning the area and turning the incubator up to 45-50 Celsius for a day or so ended the infestation. I’m nostalgic also about the science and experiences. Although not about making $13k/year while in my mid-twenties with a college degree.
- robbrown451 5y ago"on the order of 0.1 centimeter in length" You mean a millimeter? Even "a tenth of a centimeter" is better. They also could say "1800 miles per hour" in the title if they want people to be able to take it in quickly. (or 2900 kph) Maybe I'm just nitpicking, but it seems like they are trying to make it harder to take in.
- amelius 5y agoGrown tardigrades are only 500 microns tall. I suspect that smaller automatically means better in these kind of tests.
- timonoko 5y agoWhat kind of "impact" is 825 meters per second? I can survive 825 meters per second.
- timonoko 5y agoI can also survive 825 meters per second from a gun. If the gun is long enough.
- jhallenworld 5y agoA little known huge advantage that the allies had during WWII is proximity fuses in shells- these are bullets fired from guns, not rockets! They experience both the tremendous linear acceleration from the explosive charge (>10,000gs) and high centrifugal force from the rifling (rotation). The fuse is a complicated radio electronic circuit of the 1940s, meaning it used vacuum tubes. It was powered from a lead acid battery. The firing would release the acid to start the battery. Anyway, to get this delicate circuit to survive the firing, it was encased in a solid. So perhaps the tardigrades could survive the impact if they were frozen in ice instead of suspended in liquid? I read that they can survive ice...
- nikolay 5y agoI have doubt that these little critters did not originate on our planet.
- pvaldes 5y agoThe headache this time will last for a whole week. I hope they dip an aspirin in the aquarium at least.
- dd444fgdfg 5y agothat just seems cruel. we shouldn't be torturing these animals just to see how hardy they are.