18 ms·
Rich people do have trouble understanding what it's like to be poor
- alboaie 6y agoObviously, you can't undestant what you do not experience yourself ( at least a bit). And saddly this lack of insight could justify hunter/prey dynamics and win/loose approaches as social games. However,because most society members are inevitably loosers in such games then these games are unstable and backfire periodically ( but could take even hundres of years until a culture fails and resets the evil games)
- danaris 6y ago> Obviously, you can't undestant what you do not experience yourself Sure you can. That's what imagination and empathy are for. I've never been truly poor myself (though I did grow up what I would term lower-middle-class), but I can understand it, because I've read about it, I know the basic concepts of what the differences are between my situation and that situation, and I'm good at putting myself in someone else's shoes and seeing things from their perspective.
- andyana 6y agoNo, you can try to understand, but you have no way of knowing how it really is. As a male, I can try to understand pregnancy. There is no amount of learning that would beat the experience of a mother.
- ddingus 6y agoI grew up poverty myself. While I do not entirely disagree with you, poverty is an experience available to all of us. Women have pregnancy to themselves. That does blunt your point some. I also believe people can come to understand well enough to matter when they seek that understanding. The raw nature of it may remain elusive, the part of your point I consider strong, but what it means is a different, shareable thing. And I have shared it to great effect. Many have. In my view, one of the most important things struggling people can do is share their stories. That does add up. Others can feel something of it and can reason better about it. A national dialog of this kind is missing and too many of us need what a dialog like that can mean.
- FriedrichN 6y agoA more distant but very wealthy family member once said that people wouldn't be so poor if they just saved up money. That perfectly illustrated the difficulty rich people have understanding poor people to me. I was really young, but that really stuck with me.
- aspaviento 6y agoI remember a politician complaining about having difficulties with a salary of 6000€/mo. Some people live in a bubble so far from the real world that almost seems fantasy.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoIt depends on your liabilities and other aspects like age. 6,000 EUR per month is $7,300 USD per month is tough if you’re a new pharmacist in the US and need to repay $300k of student loans and make up for 4 to 6 years of lost income and catch up retirement savings, as an example.
- danaris 6y agoEven this shows a basic lack of understanding of what "tough" means for someone who is actually poor. As soon as you put "saving for retirement" as something that's even possible, you're no longer in the realm of what's genuinely "tough". "Oh, those people making three times what I do a month have it so tough! After paying way more than the minimum on their student loans and putting aside a large chunk of money for retirement, they might only have a thousand dollars or so of truly disposable income!" "Tough" is when "disposable income" is a fantasy, and you're regularly having to choose between whether to pay your heating bill or buy enough food for the rest of the week.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoAnd a poor person in Sudan will say poor person in US will not know what tough is. The comment I responded to was about a politician complaining about a certain payrate. To which I wanted to show that it is possible to have to have to be stretched thin (mentally), and the politician is not thinking about having to cancel their third overseas vacation. Yes, they’re not on the very last rung of the ladder, but slipping off your rung also causes worry.
- austincheney 6y agoPoor Americans often don't understand what it's like to be poor. Spending extended time in a severely damaged third world country absent all security opens all kinds of perspectives.
- elliekelly 6y agoAnd how would you suggest poor Americans afford the plane ticket necessary to achieve those perspectives? Just because there are people in the world who have it worse doesn’t mean poor Americans should just deal with it.
- austincheney 6y agoIf poverty were an easily solved problem then it wouldn't be a problem at all and we wouldn't be having this discussion. That is the gap between sympathy versus empathy and differences in economic opportunity versus disadvantages of social pressures/reinforcement.
- gonzo41 6y agoPoverty is a choice. Its not unsolvable. In Australia we had economic support that was pretty generous during COVID. Poverty pretty much vanished. Then it got expensive, the support ended and it's back. Poverty is a choice.
- mardifoufs 6y agoBut maybe it ended because Australia couldn't just keep paying forever, thus again proving that poverty isn't just solved. The entire reason why Australia was able to do it in the first place was because it was understood it would be a temporary measure caused by an emergency.
- gonzo41 6y agoYes, society has chosen not to deal with poverty like an emergency. It chose. And Australia can afford it. Money is just a construct! but seriously it is and feeding people is cheaper than building useless submarines for the navy and we're not stopping that. And just on your point, the government has discretion over it's own spending, it didn't need to vote to give people money like in the states. The Australian government can turn on and off the tap when it likes it's not restricted as heavily as you'd think.
- nceqs3 6y agoFantastic substack post on being poor: https://residentcontrarian.substack.com/p/on-the-experience-of-being-poor-ish https://residentcontrarian.substack.com/p/on-the-experience-...
- Consultant32452 6y agoI think this suffers from a causation direction bias. Maybe people with the choice mindset wind up in positions of wealth and power because of this mindset. I can only speak anecdotally, but the hand full of millionaires I know all grew up lower middle class, and they all have choice mindset. I think the worst kinds of people create a false dichotomy here where either everything is choice or everything is a product of externalities. It does seem to me that choice mindset leads to better outcomes within whatever context the person is in. It’s extremely unlikely to result in a poor person from a third world country running a Fortune 500. But within their context they are likely to have better outcomes than people who externalize credit/blame.
- tclancy 6y agoIsn’t this exactly what we are talking about? You’re assuming the same “choices” exist for everyone.
- Consultant32452 6y agoI explicitly stated the opposite when I talked about people living in different contexts.
- temptemptemp111 6y agoPeople from Caucasia?
- jheriko 6y agothere is going to be some of that for sure. i expect people reading this comment will not understand your point to mean "some" and will probably read it as "all". despite the length of your comment to the contrary, they won't parse and extract the meaning but, probably without even noticing it, rely on biases and shortcuts to interpret the meaning more rapidly (and wrongly). i'm pretty confident you are not suggesting it is responsible for 100% of the signal here, just some <100% of it. as a counterpoint i'd offer up those people who have been traumatised by their living conditions. they often adopt a choice mindset and it is harmful to them. so no, actually a choice mindset and taking responsibility in a horrible environment doesn't actually help. i say this with some bias as someone who has adopted that kind of mindset and watched those not taking responsibility for themselves perform better in many areas precisely because they excessively (from my perspective) seek help from others and ignore responsiblities. i have a number of experiences where i've ended up supporting someone extensively, because they come to me "in a difficult situation" only to realise i'm less capable of supporting them then they are of me in terms of resources and opportunities. its quite mind blowing at the time, but i try to understand how it happens - my suspicion is that their bar for 'failure' is so damned high that they will actually not use their piles of resources for psychological reasons alone.
- Bukhmanizer 6y agoI’d like to see the unpaywalled article. Unfortunately the abstract linked doesn’t go into any details about the methods.
- lettherevara 6y agoHere you go: https://wormhole.app/wMor1#0qgFKqfKPovugqgwh0CxEg https://wormhole.app/wMor1#0qgFKqfKPovugqgwh0CxEg
- fnord77 6y agoI grew up poor. We were on food stamps. Most of my adult life I have been making an upper-middle class salary. I have forgotten what it is like to be poor other than some unpleasant memories.
- notacoward 6y agoEven though I just wrote in another comment about how growing up poor has shaped me, I feel this too. I try to remember, and to pass on what I remember because I think those lessons are important, but I'm also keenly aware that it was a long time ago in a different place. In a way, the most important thing I know and that many around me don't is that there's something to be learned about what it's like to be poor in this time and place. Knowing that a particular piece of knowledge exists at all is the first step to learning it.
- DayDollar 6y agoI remember anxiet of all situations were unexpected costs might come up. Car driving- better not get stopped by a cop.Car better not fail. Car better not run out of gas before end of week. Turning all things around, going bulk cheap over "I-want-this".
- mkl95 6y agoA former coworker whose parents are rich told me once she didn't understand why young people in our country are not so eager to have kids anymore. I replied that most young people are unemployed and skint including most of my friends, which makes it difficult for obvious reasons. She replied that she did not even have €50000 (about $61000) in her bank account when she had her first kid.
- spaetzleesser 6y agoI remember there was an Interview with former presidential candidate Mitt Romney's wife who talked about how difficult their college days were. She said that they had been so poor that they had to sell some stock from Romney's trust fund... I think it's pretty natural not be able to relate to the circumstances of another person's life (I myself have trouble thinking abut how it would be to live on $50000 or less per year) but it's really dangerous that a lot of the decision makers in politics and business have no idea how to life is for people with less money. The left wing parties who traditionally looked out for the working class are now led by people who have never been working class. That's not a good trend.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- stephc_int13 6y agoI think that this is true. This is also true that you can't understand what it is of being powerful or rich when you're not. In a general way, it is very difficult to imagine living in other people's shoes, we live on the same planet, breathing the same air, we have 99.9% the same DNA, but our experience of life and our environment can be widely different.
- iiqof 6y agoI agree what you say, although I might add that the harm potential by a "not-understanding rich of the poor" is much greater than a "not-understanding poor of the rich"
- stephc_int13 6y agoPeople who are in a position of power always have more opportunities to hurt others. But sometimes, in rare occasions, during revolutions, the rich might not be in a position of power.
- strken 6y agoA lot of the opportunities to escape poverty involve the kind of mindset the wealthy have - calculated risk taking, the entitled confidence to turn up to an interview for a job you suspect you can't do, looking on money as an abstract and rational thing, post-scarcity thinking, the knowledge that it could be possible and socially acceptable to ask wealth people for business loans, and so on. This is in no way blaming those in poverty for not magically knowing how to ace job interviews or detect which risks are worth it, but pointing out that in both cases, X not understanding Y hurts the poor more than the rich.
- zepto 6y ago> the harm potential by a "not-understanding rich of the poor" is much greater than a "not-understanding poor of the rich" This seems superficially true, conjuring up a group of callous rich people using their power to make decisions that disproportionally harm poorer people. Obviously this does actually happen. However, it’s equally true that not understand the nature of wealth causes the poor to make less than optimal decisions, both on a micro scale, and a macro scale. I don’t mean there is some simple path out of being poor by making better decisions, but I do mean that not understanding wealth means that poor people often can’t tell the difference between a good opportunity and a bad one or how much work it takes to find one. It also means that poor people end up supporting political ideas that don’t make lasting a difference. I say this as someone who grew up poor, is no longer poor, and can see now that I have had access to more people with money how much better I’d have done if I had known more about how wealth works earlier in life.
- jheriko 6y agothere is a much more general thing here of 'simple theory of mind' where you assume too much similarity between self and others. we even do this to ourselves when remembering our pasts.
- Sharlin 6y agoAlso known as "generalizing from a single datapoint". And if not from literally a single datapoint, then from the datapoints implicitly cherry-picked from around you, aka your social bubble.
- nipponese 6y agoAs a parent, it seems teaching empathy without direct experience, is difficult, if not impossible. One solution that can work if forcing a person into direct contact with someone experiencing the problem. I see this class politics, and I see this in my job as a Product Designer.
- atatatat 6y agoThe financial planning bit is meant to come before one has a list of expenses to "figure out" (like home+leased car+children).
- UncleMeat 6y ago"Just don't have kids" is, IMO, one of the most incredibly insensitive approaches to this problem. It reminds me of all the people telling gay people to "just don't have a relationship". Having an entire class of people who work hard but are too poor to raise children is a failure of society - not a failure of financial planning.
- refurb 6y agoNo. Not raising kids in poverty is a matter of social responsibility. I would also argue that most people don’t want kids until they have a certain level of financial security.. That’s why family planning was so successful in decreasing birth rates.
- baq 6y agoSo what do you recommend to people who are in a poverty cycle but want to feel they’re free humans, not economic slaves?
- mcguire 6y agoYou mean they're poor and they think they're real human beings!? /s
- baq 6y agoI know people to whom the /s doesn't apply...
- godfreyantonell 6y agoSad but true.
- nanis 6y agoWealth is a stock measure, income is flow. You accumulate wealth out of what you can set aside out of the flow. Some of us immigrants do not come to this country with an existing stock of wealth either back home or here. We are also not in the favored group of immigrants. We have human capital which we are trying to convert to financial capital for the next generation. Then, when we sort of "make it" here, people who have family homes worth close to million and up (you can draw on that home equity, you know), people who know people (either family or others) who can "help" them with down-payments etc label us rich based on the flow we are receiving right now. These people tend to themselves make in the $150K range, in my experience and do not realize that the wealth they have was already accumulated in the less punitive environment of the 80s and the 90s. I do not begrudge anyone for what they have. But I do find people who got a "hand-me down" apartment in Manhattan after growing up in a nice house in Westchester lecturing me about "the rich" and "the poor". Except that my ability to make it in today's corporate environment depends on their political sensibilities.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoI think this is an excellent comment. What makes me very sad is that during the past 14 months the divide between those who own assets and those who don't has reached gargantuan proportions. I mean, in my raging inferno of a housing market, over the past couple of years home prices have easily doubled. So a 400k house from 2018 now sells for 800k. Yes, if I want to move to another house in my area I'll pay similarly astronomical prices, but that just means it's about a wash for me, and of course I have many more options like moving to a cheaper locale or a cash out refi. But if I (or my parents) don't already own a home, it means my chances of ever owning a home in my area just went to about zero. People made vastly more money just sitting around in their houses in the past couple years than I made in my job as an "essential" worker over the past decade. I just don't see how this ends well.
- fortran77 6y agoTaxes even that out a bit. The person with an 800k house pays twice as much in property taxes. In many states, the amount that the state can raise taxes on someone whose house may have "increased" in value is limited.
- temptemptemp111 6y ago"hey we need AI/VR for this!" - hahaha
- jonnylynchy 6y agoI agree that there are rich people who know little about what it's like to be poor or even middle class. But not all rich people were always rich. I grew up poor, and was poor as a young adult. After working 2 jobs, going to school and trying to keep my family together on next to nothing, I was able to climb my way up and get to "middle class". Despite being poor for a while, my kids were happy and they didn't know anything different. When we were able to finally afford cable, my oldest daughter couldn't believe she could watch cartoon network. It was the best feeling knowing that I was able to provide some level of comfort to my family without struggling every month to know how we were going to afford basic utilities and food. We moved to an apartment near an affluent area where my kids would be able to go to a good school. There we met some very wealthy people. Casual conversations with these people regularly included topics such as going on vacation to Hawaii for a month, going to a ritzy steakhouse for dinner regularly, etc. I was surprised at how these people just expected others to be able to afford the same luxuries. At the same time, I also met some wealthy people who didn't talk like that. After getting to know some of them, I learned that some actually earned their way there. They grew up poor, worked hard, went to school, worked harder, had some luck by being in the right place at the right time with the right set of skills, and eventually became wealthy. What I learned during this time is that rich people are not always rich because someone handed it all to them. Some are very much in that category though. You can always tell by their conversations. Rich people who have never been poor or even middle class will converse about things casually that poor people can only dream about, while those who did not grow up rich reserve those conversation topics and are sensitive to other financial situations. This is why I think the 1% is a sliding scale to some extent. It's not a static group of people so we have to stop demonizing all rich people.
- BlameKaneda 6y ago> I also met some wealthy people who didn't talk like that...I learned that some actually earned their way there. They grew up poor, worked hard, went to school, worked harder, had some luck by being in the right place at the right time with the right set of skills, and eventually became wealthy. I have to ask, but how many of these people have had the mindset that "X is poor because they're not working hard enough" or "I worked hard which is why I'm not poor, why can't Y be that way?" If I had to guess, a good number of them have had those thoughts in the past, but whether or not they still think like that or they've moved on (and have admitted---to themselves or to others---that it's a negative viewpoint) is hard to say.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hn8788 6y agoI had a co-worker who thought he had a typical american childhood because he didn't consider his family wealthy, even though they had millions of dollars of networth over 30 years ago. Him and his 3 bothers went to a very exclusive private school that was 50k a year per child, but since his classmates were mostly "old money" that were from family worth 10s to 100s of millions of dollars, he was picked on for being the "poor" kid, so still thinks of himself as having a middle class family. He was also the only person I've seen who made me consider that "afluenza" might be a real thing. He would get super bad stomach aches and diarrhea any time he ate fast food because he was mentally conditioned to believe it was disgusting. He even went to the doctor about it, and was told it's all in his head, it's just the thought of eating poor people food made him ill.
- Simon_says 6y agoNo, fast food is actually just disgusting lab-made pseudo-food, if you’re accustomed to fresh, whole, real food. I loved fast food growing up, but after a couple year stint eating only fresh foods, I went back and literally couldn’t stomach it anymore. It tastes good going down. (At the time) I had no conditioning or preconceived beliefs that it was disgusting, but within an hour my stomach felt queasy and I threw it up. After half a dozen times experiencing that, I gave up on fast food entirely.
- hn8788 6y agoBe that as it may, he wouldn't get sick when he didn't think he was eating fast food. We'd go to a diner for breakfast sometimes, and since he perceived it as a nice family-run place, he wouldn't get sick, even though their food was still processed garbage that showed up frozen in a truck every morning.
- chasebank 6y agoThere's a stark difference between frozen food off of the Sysco truck and McDonalds.
- 6y ago
- mindslight 6y agoI definitely attribute people's actions to their own willful choices. But I think a corollary is that the more intelligent you are, the more you see how objectively bad people's choices really are, regardless of their class. Taking everyone's bad decisions as serious character flaws would be untenable, so I have to give up and just be tolerant. As such, it's easier for me to sympathize with a poor person who makes bad decisions due to inescapable financial stress (even though I've never been there myself), than someone upper middle class who has mortgaged their entire life to keep up with the Joneses. The latter seems to have much more opportunity to slow down and choose differently.
- voidfunc 6y agoOh man this resonates in a weird way... I don't know jack shit about being poor. I grew up extremely well-off in the late 80s and 90s. My college education was paid 100% by my parents without a loan. We had nice cars and belonged to country clubs. Even in my first job where I was only making 35K/yr my parents gave me quite a bit of help so it was easy. I have a few friends that are poor... I feel for their issues, I always try and help out when asked, but I also know to keep my mouth shut about problems the poor face or how I think they should solve the problem because my solutions are usually so detached from the reality of their grinding life that it comes off as patronizing and unempathetic. My dad gets it, he grew up as a poor kid in an Italian immigrant household. First kid to college and then he did really well after that in business. He understands it in ways I'll never know. He mostly keeps his opinions to himself on the matter but I've never heard him rattle off any easy solutions or tropes like "they just need to work harder" because he knows his mother and father busted their butts and never stopped being poor. It was only when he became an adult and started making money that he could help them live comfortably. My mother (love her) she grew up middle class during the American Dream years of the 50's and 60's and has never known poverty either, but she has strong opinions on it... always of the variety of they are "lazy" or need to "work harder", or the solutions are impractical or grounded in a reality that hasn't existed since the early 70s. I think my Dad has given up at this point changing her mind as they're both well into their 70s, but yea I never want to be like my mother.
- mlac 6y agoVolunteer & serve on the board of a non-profit that focuses on meeting a community need. Did you know that diapers are not covered in the United States by government assistance? So the current setup is that we have a lot of diaper banks across the United States that provide diapers to those in need. Diapers are sold as single items in corner stores in low income areas at extreme markups, and sometimes parents can only afford one a day. If the baby poops or pees right after the change… Well. Yeah. I serve on the board of one [1], and we’ve had events that have given out 100k diapers to those in need in a day. The frustrating thing is that there is no sustainable model here - the diaper banks get donations from companies and and we can buy them using donated money / grants for a discount, but we obviously don’t charge those who need them for the diapers (and I do not believe we can sell them as a bank). I think there are two main pain points for people who do not have a lot of money: 1) There are economies of scale as you “level up” in income - cost per diaper gets much cheaper when you can buy from Sam’s club vs. paying $1 per at the corner store. Even shopping at Sam’s is out the window because it assumes you have a car to get there… 2) the “fixed costs” of life are fairly standard. It takes a salary of $85K for the happiness to have marginal returns, and I think this is because you hit the point where your basic needs are met for an American lifestyle and everything else is gravy. It covers medical (within reason), insurance, transportation, some fun thing, housing, food, etc. and gets you to the level where you can finally get ahead. [1] https://www.wpadiaperbank.org/ https://www.wpadiaperbank.org/ [2] https://www.businessinsider.com/personal-finance/money-buys-happiness-depending-on-income-level-2021-1 https://www.businessinsider.com/personal-finance/money-buys-...
- portemonnaie 6y agoI miss the part where they show that the rich people's "choice mindset" is wrong? Are we just going to accept at face value that poor people have no choices whatsoever and are simply victims of society (and of course capitalism, I guess)? To me, that sounds a lot like religion. Of course you can not assume that everybody could be equally rich, and only their choices are to blame if they are not. But the other extreme, that people are just born to be poor no matter what choices they make, is equally silly. What if the "I have no choice" mindest of poor people is partly to blame for their predicament?
- Miner49er 6y agoThe article doesn't say they have no choices it says they have less/limited choices. And this is simply a common sense fact. The more resources/power you have the more options you have. I can buy so many more things and combinations of things with $100 vs $1, for example.
- portemonnaie 6y agoSure, but I don't think most rich people think poor people have just the same choices. That's not implied when they think choices make people poor.
- webmaven 6y ago> The article doesn't say they have no choices it says they have less/limited choices. When you are poor, sometimes all of the choices available to you are bad ones. And when you are constrained to making an endless series of 'least bad' choices, is it any wonder that at some point you inevitably go for some instant gratification to ameliorate your intolerable circumstance, at least for a while?
- portemonnaie 5y agoSchool is being paid for, even in the US, I think? Just keep your head down, do your homework, don't do drugs, don't get in trouble, and your odds for escaping poverty are probably quite good.
- bachmeier 6y agoThere are a couple things to understand about being poor. It's not about lack of money (though obviously having lots of money means you're not poor). It's about insecurity. I grew up in farm country in the 1980s. Nobody had money, but I didn't feel poor. When I moved to other parts of the country, that's when I encountered poor people. They had to worry about crime, schools for their kids, and being homeless. When you skip meals because you have to put two gallons of gas in the car so you can get to work the rest of the week, that's when you're poor. Or when you're under constant stress because you're worried about what's going to go wrong next, and when you spend all your time on stuff like where you'll spend your last $12 because that's all you've got. It's hard to understand what it's like to be poor because you don't even realize that's part of the deal. The other thing is that there's a saying along the lines of getting wealthy being mostly the same for everyone, but every poor person is poor for different reasons. One example is a guy I knew in the 1990s that worked hard at a low-wage job. He got hit by a car while walking across the street. The driver got away and left him laying there. He couldn't work for months. The non-poor person's solution is to move in with their parents or to have their parents send them money. Maybe put things on the credit card. Maybe take money out of savings. He didn't have those options. How do you financially recover from something like this if once you go back to work, you're making the same low wage?
- zepto 6y ago> The other thing is that there's a saying along the lines of getting wealthy being mostly the same for everyone What does this mean?
- bachmeier 6y agoMy understanding is that it's a reference to being easy to give advice on building wealth since it's all the same story about saving and getting a return on your savings. This is in contrast to being poor, which can involve lots of things, like bad decisions, bad luck, bad birth...
- bradleyjg 6y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anna_Karenina_principle https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anna_Karenina_principle
- allenrb 6y agoA couple of weeks ago, I found myself on a ladder in a basement, doing a bit of plumbing. And I thought, “Isn’t this odd? Here I am, rather well-off, cleaning out the drain for an elderly black gentleman.” And it was more satisfying than most of what I’ve done at a keyboard. To elaborate, for quite a few years I’ve owned rental property in poor-to-working class parts of town, first houses and then apartments. If you’re a hands-on landlord, you will learn more than you ever wanted to know about money in America. Sure, some tenants are total flakes who would be late on rent after a PowerBall win. Most of my tenants have worked hard, gotten by with little, and struggled to make ends meet. Many of them hesitate to tell me when something needs to be fixed in their home. Often they’re concerned that I am too busy. I tell them they have every right to expect stuff to work, that it’s a part of what they’re paying for. And it makes me wonder how bad things are with other landlords. Going back to the plumbing story, I think every wealthy hedge-fund manager, etc, ought to get their hands dirty this way. It’ll either teach some humility, or let us see who the real jerks are. The latter can be first up against the wall…
- Jiro 6y agoThat's an example of seen versus unseen bias. The drain was directly in front of you, and you talked to the person who owned it, so it's easy to understand that someone benefits from it. If you do a job that indirectly makes things 1% better for ten million people, it's hard to have an example you can look at. You may be improving the world more, yet feel like you're improving it less, because humans don't really understand indirect effects except intellectually, and that isn't very satisfying.
- webmaven 6y ago> [I]t makes me wonder how bad things are with other landlords. Pretty darn bad. One landlord I had was constantly playing musical chairs with appliances (stoves, refrigerators, air-conditioners) that were replaced with ones that never stayed working for very long before having to be swapped out and repaired (shoddily) again. Another got rid of tenants at the end of their lease (never longer than a year) no matter what in order to raise rents to whatever (they thought) the market would bear. They preferred having half of their units empty over not raising rates. Another considered anyone complaining about another tenant or being complained about to be a 'problem' necessitating removal ASAP, and forget about your security deposit.
- TacticalCoder 6y agoI have both my father and my uncle who became dirt poor just by making terribly poor life choices so I've got a very different take on this. They had good jobs but couldn't help screwing it up by: gambling, buying sportcars, overall trying to bite more than they could swallow (houses too big, with monthly mortgage too expensive), etc. In both cases it ended up with foreclosures / lawyers etc. My brother and I are now sending monthly money to our father because of his bad lifechoices. And by poor I mean: living in a rusty, broken, RV hidden behind trees, illegally hooked up to electricity (not paying for it) and dumpster diving to find food for his dogs (because of course he was dirt poor but he had to have dogs and rabbits). I've got friends who have serious issues meeting month's ends yet they buy 5x what I buy online. Every single time I arrive at their home they've got new pointless gadgets bought on Amazon. There are people spending a fortune, compared to what they make, on packs of cigarettes and daily booze. When you don't have enough money you don't have a ghetto dog, you don't buy cheap gadgets on Amazon, you don't drink your daily bottle of vodka/whiskey/packs of beer, you don't smoke a pack a day. You don't take a mortgage on a car from a category you can't afford just to keep up with the Joneses when a smaller car would do. Well, you can... But there are choices and I refuse to accept that there are zero choices. You'll simply never convince me because I've seen it firsthand. Now I don't tell those around me how they should handle their personal finances but I cannot but think about the many poor decisions I see being made. And I'm not saying everybody has lots of room: but there are many poor people out there who are poor simply because of their dumb life choices (like my father).
- notacoward 6y agoI don't think anything you actually said is actually wrong, but it's adjacent to what many rich people do say - that the poor shouldn't have or do anything that just makes them happier until they're not poor. No treats, no recreation, just work at the best-paying job available as many hours as possible and save every penny. And I do have a problem with that. It's a deeply punitive and judgmental attitude, as though being poor is a moral failing that any decent person would seek to resolve as soon as possible. As I said, you didn't quite get there but you kind of brushed against it. These negative attitudes about "bad decisions" are particularly problematic when children are involved. I grew up poor, in large part because my (single) mother made some of those choices. On two separate occasions, a friend begged her to be the managing editor of a very profitable publication, with stock that would have made us actually rich. Both times, and in other cases as well, she declined in favor of running her own "boutique" business which barely paid the rent. As a result, I do know what it's like to be hungry and scared. But if she had made other choices, my brother and I might have grown up to be very different people. Less "street smart" certainly. Also less exposed to true diversity, less empathetic, less appreciative of what we do have, etc. It's entirely likely that we are better off both financially and emotionally because she made those choices instead of rushing to join the middle class as soon as possible. I've met enough other "once poor now rich" people to believe this is not an uncommon pattern. The ones whose parents did make the more socially-acceptable choice don't seem better off materially or emotionally than the ones who had to pull themselves up later. In fact, I see some seriously troublesome patterns there. I've seen people who were insulated from hardship and striving all their lives make their own bad decisions that sent them (and their families if they'd gotten that far) right back down the ladder. I've seen people who grew up in "no fun allowed" homes do worse. Those are bad patterns to encourage. Even as I write my own checks to support my "foolish" parent, I find it's better for my own mental health (and therefore that of my family) to focus on forgiveness and gratitude for what was rather than resentment over what might have been. One lesson that being poor did teach me is that everyone makes some bad choices, and some people are broken by them. Making the world even harsher doesn't seem like the solution.
- calibas 6y agoIt's kind of the "American dream" that if you're responsible and work hard, then anybody can achieve a reasonable level of success. There's an appeal to believing being wealthy is a choice, then you can believe the people at the "top tiers" of society earned their positions and deserve all that power and influence. If that's not true, then it implies that live in a class-based system. Wealthy people are the ones making the decisions at the national level, they own the media by just about any objective measurement, and even though the billionaires "earned" their billions, they were still born into wealthy, well-connected families who have direct control over the systems in which they "earned" their billions. 99.9% of the population has no chance of every achieving the level of success that a small portion of the population was born into. We live in an aristocracy, and yet both the wealthy and the poor are in denial. You can believe the system is moral though the "choice mindset", then it's not a class-based society. Then there's still freedom, equality, a representative government and a healthy American dream. Especially with the conservatives, it's blasphemous and "un-American" to suggest otherwise, to say that we're ruled by aristocrats who were born into their positions and don't represent us. It odd, because I feel like I'm the one who's being the most American, the most patriotic, and yet I hate to brag about it because I think Nationalism is a kind of poison. I believe in American ideals though, let me remind you of them. You're entitled to a respect, dignity and success regardless of your social status, race, sex, the nationality you were born into, and your profession, chosen and otherwise. You're entitled to a government that represents you, and if it doesn't then it damn well better. It's up to "the people" to enforce a representative government (the opposite of an aristocracy) by any means necessary, including violent overthrow*. These are American ideals, ideals the country was founded upon. These are the beautiful American dreams, and we Americans call them dreams because we're still working towards them. They hide some truly ugly nightmares of things like slavery and how we got the land we live upon. *Disclaimer: I seemingly called for violence, but violence is an evil thing and a last resort, something I don't encourage. When "the people" truly reject their government, even the police and military are on the side of "the people" because they're people too. Easy way to distinguish terrorism for a truly populist movement.
- zepto 6y ago> If that's not true, then it implies that live in a class-based system. It really doesn’t. It does absolutely imply that the system is broken, but it most certainly doesn’t imply that it is ‘class based’ in some essential way.
- stephc_int13 6y agoAnother common misunderstanding that I found quite irritating lately is the fallacious idea that wealth has a natural tendency to "trickle-down". By all means, the opposite is true, and I bet this can be theoretically proven. Wealth (and power) naturally trickles up. (not down!)
- ffggvv 6y agoa lot of immigrants have both the experience of starting their life poor in their home country. starting poor in america and then ending their life rich. so we do understand what it’s like to be poor. and in a way i think sometimes we have less sympathy because we can see how good decisions can lead to wealth. there’s countless stories of jewish or asian immigrants in new york working insane hours for little pay as textile workers and all of their children become doctors or lawyers.
- Miner49er 6y agoIs that actually common? Is it just anecdotal evidence or is there actually some data on this showing that it is common?
- ffggvv 6y agoyes look at income statistics and career demographics, college admissions etc… asian women have a higher average income than white men who are supposedly the pinnacle of privilege
- ta1234567890 6y agoThis is essentially talking about the same findings from The Monopoly experiment (https://www.businessinsider.com/ted-talk-monopoly-makes-people-mean-2014-8 https://www.businessinsider.com/ted-talk-monopoly-makes-peop...) In that experiment, one of the players would get more initial money and two dice rolls per turn (instead of one). Then, even though it was clear that the game was rigged in their favor, they would act as if it was their own superior game skills that allowed them to win, mocking the other players at the same time.
- raspasov 6y agoThe biggest problem in the USA is that we do not have big problems.
- proc0 6y agoPoor people in the U.S. are not really poor. This is the irony in the article and a lot of comments I see. You are acting out the same headline, but in perspective of real poverty. Did you grow up in a town with dirt roads? Did your neighbors live in cardboard and aluminum self-made housing? Did your family struggle to eat and everyone around you is so skinny that fat people are a rare sight? These are some markers of being poor, and most "poor" people in the U.S. cannot imagine this life. People talking how they are poor because of their stock wealth... poor people won't even have this on their horizon. Also, yes, my family was very poor in Latin America, and that is why I had no childhood and worked literally all my life, having little friends and romantic life. There are just not enough resources to even do what "poor" people in America take for granted.
- phobosanomaly 6y agoThere are actually many, many communities in the United States where people live on dirt roads. That's super common. I grew up on a dirt road, and my parents still live on one. Much of the rural US lives off of paved roads. With food and stuff, the thing is that in the US, you can very quickly go from having not much to having nothing. Many people do suffer from hunger and live on the edge because the cost of living in the United States relative to incomes can be very high. It's much more difficult to set up a small stall selling goods or food or something, and if you don't have proper permitting the police will shut you down. Therefore, once you get to a certain point you are really trapped. There's much less of an informal economy in the US than in Latin America, so people's ability to earn money is much more restricted and regulated. The correlate to the people you are describing in the United States are referred to as the 'homeless.' They live in small structures made of cardboard and wood and tarps. Some have tents. The police will occasionally come by and throw all of their possessions in a garbage truck. Homelessness is pretty widespread, and the degree to which it exists here is often shocking to people from other countries. Here's a photo essay that gives you some idea of what is going on in the United States in terms of the homeless. These living conditions are pretty darn comparable to international poverty. I assure you none of these people have stocks. https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2021-03-08/homelessness-and-the-pandemic https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2021-03-08/homeless... Obviously the scale of the whole thing is different between the US and Latin America, but there's lots of pretty shocking poverty in the US.
- 74d-fe6-2c6 6y agoI don't think its about trouble understanding but rather that most rich people don't care about poor people. Is that a bold statement? Not so sure, because it seems to me that also a majority of poor people don't care about other poor people. We live in rather unempathetic society were unemployed are never considered to be depressed or having an alternative take on the merit of work but instead are seen as lazy or dumb. Where fat or ugly people are considered a cosmetic liability rather than a natural part of the community. We are a bunch of egotistic, self-obsessed maniacs. And yes, there are excpetions among rich as well as among the poor. But they are few and most think of them as weak or suffering from helper syndrome rather than being blessed with altruistic and empathetic abilities.
- okareaman 6y agoI grew up working poor, then struck it rich in the software biz and became a millionaire, then got sick and became homeless. My take on it is the rich and poor both struggle with money anxieties. A significant difference between being rich and being poor is the way other people treat you. When I was rich everyone wanted to be my friend and help me out. When I was poor I suffered judgements of all types from people; scorn, contempt, pity, avoidance and generally being considered a person no one wanted to associate with. I thought it was interesting and said more about my fellow Americans than myself, but it did hurt all the same. Edit: Scrapper Blackwell - Nobody Knows You When You're Down and Out https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=626pNZB8xXE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=626pNZB8xXE
- cryptica 6y agoThis is so true. Even if you're not rich, many people treat you differently just based on whether they think you might become rich. The minute they think you're no longer in the running, they stop answering texts and emails as if you never existed. It's scary what percentage of people are like this. You never know who is who until you actually lose your money or position. These people are ridiculously good actors. In the higher ranks of society, it seems like 99.999% of people are like this; it seems to be basically impossible to meet someone who is not a psychopathic opportunist. TBH I wonder why billionaires bother to get married at all. They're probably as likely to meet a good (genuine) person as I am to meet a billionaire... Out of probably hundreds of thousands of people I met in my life, I only met 1 billionaire and that was before they were a billionaire. Aside from that, I only ever saw 1 billionaire (which I recognized) in real life but I didn't meet them (only saw them). Humans seem to be incapable to comprehend how many other people there are in the world and how good humans are are deceiving themselves and others to get access to resources.
- rufus_foreman 6y ago>> When I was rich everyone wanted to be my friend and help me out When you were rich, everyone wanted your money. I was poor, my friends are from that time. Until you've been my friend when I'm down and out, you're just an acquaintance. If you want to know who your friends are, see who comes to get you out of jail at 3 AM.
- rationalData 6y agoAs someone who left paycheck to paycheck life, I do struggle to emphasize with the paycheck to paycheck class. I didn't buy luxuries like alcohol or fast food, I didn't even have enough money for that. But this class would find a way to go on vacation, buy juice, and get takeout. I'm long gone from that problem but I'm still frugal. Until that class stops buying needless luxuries, I do struggle to emphasize.
- cryptica 6y agoThey think that you can just get out of it if you're smart and hard working. This is completely false. Intelligence is almost worthless nowadays. Stupidity is more valuable. Just look at Dogecoin millionaires. The only necessary ingredient to escape poverty these days is luck. I'm certain that if Elon Musk or Jeff Bezos started their careers 10 years ago, today they would be moderately poor engineers/developers struggling to pay their rents. When you start out as as poor or middle-class, the number of bad things which can happen to you on any given day is unfathomable. There are glass ceilings everywhere and monopolistic forces to suppress your voice and to spread misinformation which harms you in many different ways; all of it done to maintain the status quo. On the other hand, good luck compounds.
- nathanvanfleet 6y ago> If power tends to shape the perceptions of those who have it, the implications for public policy — especially around issues like poverty, crime, education and health care — are significant. Gee like politicians who get paid a good wage with benefits who are not interested in health care and the minimum wage? Who setup themselves as exceptions for many laws?
- nathanvanfleet 6y agoThis reminds me of a story, true or not, of a king who's jester would constantly whisper in his hear "you are human and will die some day." I think that people in power need constant bias training towards this kind of thing, especially public servants.
- orthoxerox 6y agoYou don't even have to be rich to have trouble understanding the poor. I am middle to upper-middle class, and I once found myself in a delicate situation: my desktop's PSU had given up the ghost and I urgently needed a new one. My savings were illiquid at the moment and I had to pay a building contractor a few days before, almost emptying out my checking account, so I had to literally calculate how much I could spend on a PSU to afford groceries until my next paycheck without dipping into any form of credit. That was a completely alien feeling, and I still can't imagine how taxing it must be to budget everything, to juggle expenses and loans, to knowingly miss due payments, to be one speeding ticket away from literally not having enough money to feed your family and to be in that state not just for one week or one month, but for years and years.
- dasil003 6y agoThe actual studied results are straightforward and intuitive: whether you are rich or poor, humans are excellent at rationalizing their own merit. So for a rich person of course they want to believe that their wealth comes from their own agency, and for a poor person of course they want to believe that wealth is completely random. That's all fine and good, but attaching the editorial that the rich don't understand the poor kind of bothers me. Sure it's true in aggregate, and I agree with the implication that more privileged groups could stand to have more empathy for less privileged groups, but going a layer deeper I think it does individuals a real disservice to tie "choice mindset" to a moral failing. The reason it bothers me is because taking responsibility of your own choices is just a better way to live; whether or not it makes you rich it will certainly improve your relationships and mental health. And of course I understand some folks have more choice than others, but in practice I've seen plenty of rich people exhibiting victim mentality just as I've seen many poor people make hard choices and own them. In fact I'd be curious to see a longitudinal study that tested the hypotheses that poor people with a "choice mindset" are more upwardly mobile, and rich people with a "privilege mindset" are more downwardly mobile.
- a4ism 6y ago2 things on this: 1. Terrance Malik did a pretty good job of capturing the boolean of this article in knight of cups. the rich, despite this study, still have the same existential crises as us plebs. also, there's something inherent about trying to find purpose in life that even escapes the niceties of privilege. 2. those 'niceties' are currently being accounted for through policies made over 25 years ago [0]. they have been, essentially, mistaken as our prime purpose for life. when in reality, it's more that they are a sort of short cut for being 'allowed' to pursue what you perceive as your purpose [one day, collectively, we will realize that we can only provide this to x number of people for y quality of access to that pursuit]. essentially what i'm saying is that the policies were created to allow the entire system to inflate and eventually crash, while letting the rich create a nice puffy cushion for themselves to land on when it does crash. rather than say, the same thing happening but without the cushion. this is rather just typical human behaviour at scale. ray dalio has been talking about it. we're reaching the end of a 300 year cycle. no one alive has experienced it before, but it happens regularly in human history. i think it is a natural phenomenon. inheritance is more to blame than any other element. we die and our bodies go to the same place, but our capital does not. we do know that capital allows us more opportunity to pursue more 'life', and i imagine that even people who only get that chance through inheritance sometimes believe they worked for it/deserve it whatever... but we shouldn't mistake the idea that wealth is the end game. it is, in many senses, just the beginning. but it is not the only. an example of this would be having kids. or finding love etc. wealth is just tylenol. temporary alleviation of symptoms. sometimes it allows us to do more art, or have more kids, or find more lovers, but its no guarantee. what we're all seeking is a common understanding that money is a tool; for each of us to pursue life as we see it. not the perverted way we've used it [and we live in a democracy so must take responsibility for its misuse]. the attitude in this article, to me, is less about wealth, and more about ego. it's egotistical people who can't understand the poor. and we get seduced by their confidence. ayn rand is a good example of this. the preacher who ended up on welfare. when the bandaid comes off, just remember that it's not your fault, it's not society's fault, but it's our fault. fix the bugs, account for fault tolerance, and act accordingly. all that said, burning down the buildings, destroying the statues, raiding the halls of congress, is not the answer. but tampering the egos just may be. i think the only way we can do that is to not allow power or wealth to concentrate. that's the lesson to be learned. to an extent we must let it, but that's the thing. finding that sweet spot. understanding that is how the rich can understand the poor, how we can understand each other, and how we will eventually understand the greatness of that sweet spot. [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UKe38mVpHgk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UKe38mVpHgk
- BackBlast 6y agoWe focus way too much on money. There are a multitude of ways to be "rich" or "poor", money is simply one of them. You can also be health poor, or health rich. Most rich people who are truly health poor would trade their wealth to be health rich in a heartbeat. You can be time poor, no free time available. Sometimes people choose to be time poor by stuffing their schedule, other times it is an overload of responsibility via employment, school, family, and/or some other duty or expectation. Love rich and love poor. Good friends and people who care about you in your life? No family support, no friends about? Actively despised or abused by family/friends? There is the age spectrum, old/young. Though we all get that with coupled effects on a fairly equal footing, assuming we don't die young. We all have long lists of needs, we also have varying pools of finite resources. When ANY of them are severely lacking or overdrawn in our lives it is a hard experience.
- LB232323 6y agoWater is wet, man lands on moon.
- jl2718 6y ago> our research suggests that powerholders overgeneralize their greater sense of choice to others. This research is about power. The author may be taking great liberty in turning it into a flame-bait article about wealth inequality. And I’m not certain that the connection between financial wealth and physical power is tautological, despite any observations of that in a particular legal context.