8 ms·
Yeah, the industry just seems not to have bitten. Which is a shame, because the technology really is just plain great. Play a AAA game on a $180 chromebook wi
by ajross 6y ago
Yeah, the industry just seems not to have bitten. Which is a shame, because the technology really is just plain great. Play a AAA game on a $180 chromebook with basically identical resource consumption to watching Netflix.
But... the big studios don't want it because they don't want to lose control of distribution. The indie folks couldn't be wooed away from Steam, because Google just isn't going to match Valve's creator services community. Google isn't willing to drop the kind of cash MS or Sony do to buy themselves exclusives...
Frankly the best thing for the industry would be to spin it off and sell it to Valve. A Steam/Stadia would rule the world.
- liaukovv 6y agoIt's not like the proposition is good from user point of view either. You "buy" a right to rent games, which right can be terminated by google for any reason, or no reason at all. Even if you really bought a game and google would give it back to you when they inevitably shut down the service, you still wouldnt be able to play it, since the whole point of stadia is to not own the hardware.
- creshal 6y agoSteam is a rent model too, but nobody seems to mind. It helps that Steam also works offline, or on an alleged DSL connection out in the sticks, or when you're visiting your parents who still have the same awful wifi router you told them to get replaced 15 years ago, or …
- dvdkon 6y agoThe main difference to me is that Steam is an established platform with a reputation for not pulling games for no reason and also the fact that there's always "extralegal" ways to play that same game if Steam does pull it. That's not the case with streaming-exclusive games (and sometimes iOS games, sadly).
- WesleyHale 6y agoExactly, and steam isn't going anywhere anytime soon, so I don't have to worry more about the game itself becoming dated or unsuccessful and pulling down their servers way before Steam decides does.
- cocoricamo 6y agoAnd if my memory serves me right you can still download games that are in your library but not available in the store anymore.
- tomc1985 6y agoIt's a licensing model, not a rental model. You're not paying anybody a monthly fee to play, you have all the files locally, and the threshold for revoking your license or otherwise losing access to a title is extremely high. Even games with components that have expired licenses are kept on the account, your access is never really revoked -- even a VAC ban won't lose you your library. You can't mod a Stadia game...
- Kuinox 6y agoSteam is not a rent model. Steam recently got sued because you couldn't resell your games, nor your account. You are now allowed to sell your steam account because you owe the games.
- 41b696ef1113 6y ago>Steam is a rent model too, but nobody seems to mind. Ehh, I prefer to buy from GOG when I can for that exact reason.
- ergot_vacation 6y agoSteam is explicitly NOT a rental model. You buy games, and then you have them, on your hard drive, to play whenever you like. You could be banned from Steam, Gabe could personally make a youtube video telling you to fuck off, and you could still start up Steam in offline mode and play all the games just fine. The only thing you could THEORETICALLY lose is the ability to re-download games in your library, but to my knowledge this has never happened aside from accounts getting hacked etc. Stadia, meanwhile, works like Netflix. Stop paying, or just anger the Stadia gods in some way, and all your games go away. I like owning things I pay for. Many other people do to. So it's gratifying to see that this one time, we don't have to have our rights trampled on. Good riddance to bad rubbish.
- csunbird 6y agoActually, after a while being in the offline mode, Steam will ask you to go online, as far as I know.
- fragileone 6y agoAsks or forces? Because as far as I'm aware you can play offline indefinitely.
- csunbird 6y agoDepends on the game. Some games with DRM wants (requires) to call back home after a while.
- kevingadd 6y agoIt's technically possible for Valve to pull access to your entire library and games that use Steamworks DRM will no longer work in that circumstance, but as far as I know it's very rare for them to do it at this point. They used to do it if you issued a chargeback, but they had to stop doing that since it was in violation of various government and payment processor policies.
- tokai 6y agoHaven't tried a game on steam that couldn't be opened without steam running. Just go to the games folder and run the executable.
- anonymousab 6y ago> Steam is a rent model too, but nobody seems to mind. A long time ago, there was an official statement to the effect of "if steam goes down, we'll release a patch to unlock your games" or something to that effect. I think that was before third parties could even sell on Steam. Could also be apocryphal, or photoshopped emails and screencaps and the like. It almost certainly doesn't hold true today. But at the very least, you can download your steam games today, and if it shuts down at some point in the future, you can modify or crack those local files and executables to be playable; multiplayer systems notwithstanding. There's a path forward. With Stadia games, there is nothing without original publisher or developer intervention.
- bluefirebrand 6y agoSteam doesn't require me to pay several hundred dollars a month to have an internet speed fast enough to play a game without lag. I just run it on a piece of hardware I already own anyways.
- deadmutex 6y agoThere are also people who don't have the hardware to play latest games like Cyberpunk, but live in an area with a good internet connection.
- drivingmenuts 6y agoI think it’s more the case that Steam is a known quantity by both players and developers. There aren’t many surprises ther and Steam hews closely to its core competencies. The few times they’ve tried to expand their horizons, there’s been noise, but it soon fizzled and they went back to what they do best.
- symlinkk 6y agoNo different than Steam
- anoncake 6y agoMaybe in principle. But Steam is Valve's cash cow and very unlikely to be cancelled anytime soon. Stadia is a Google product.
- tmerr 6y agoI wonder if there are any examples of Google previously spinning off companies and selling them. It's hard to imagine it given how entrenched most products are in its internal software ecosystem
- 0xB31B1B 6y agoLots, boston dynamics is the one that comes to mind most recently. Google is efficient with m&a
- ragebol 6y agoBoston Dynamics did not originate at Google
- jsnell 6y agoNiantic (Pokemon Go) is the only one I can think of.
- birdyrooster 6y agoThey bought Skybox, renamed it Terra Bella and then spun it off into a sale to Planet in about 3 years time.
- supergirl 6y agowhy would you pay $180 to play over the internet when you can pay $400 and get the latest playstation?
- liaukovv 6y agoThese days latest playstation goes for 2k
- cdogl 6y agoIf you can get your hands on one. Here in Australia a few friends and I have just given up for the time being.
- oneplane 6y agoBecause that $180 also allows you to take it with you, and do other things, i.e. making money so you can afford the free time to play games.
- ChuckMcM 6y agoHmm, perhaps the movie studios who lost access to distribution are whispering in there ear?
- ragebol 6y agoCould Valve implement their own Stadia-alternative?
- olex 6y agoThey do have Steam Link to build off of, which apparently runs really well even over slower connections. So it's possible.
- ajross 6y agoThey have the technical chops, but not the capital goods. At the end of the day Stadia works by equipping a bunch of local datacenters with specific hardware and maintaining those with high reliability across a global market. Running the framebuffer through a video encoder isn't really the hard part. And the part that is the hard part is absolutely Google's domain of expertise.
- fragileone 6y agoTo be honest I'm not sure why they haven't done it yet and are letting GFN take their customers.
- Animats 6y agoWhich is a shame, because the technology really is just plain great. Is it, though? You're really renting a server. Other companies who rent you remote game servers have gone broke, because it wasn't cost effective. Google can afford losses to get market share, but at some point the price has to go up.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- MisterBastahrd 6y agoImagine you're bigcorp and you sell a game which features multiplayer PVP combat as your central feature. You can optimize your entire engine to kingdom come and back, but if there are still latency issues, your developers get the blame. Outside of some AAA RPG and adventure games, most of the rest of the truly big games feature PVP content as their main selling point. Fifa, Call of Duty, Madden, Halo, Destiny, Fortnite, Apex Legends, DOTA, League of Legends, etc... they all live and die on network latency. They are the biggest of the big and if your platform doesn't have them AND run them well, you're dead. Hard to get someone to invest in your product knowing that your product is going to suck for the games people really want to play. I'm still not sure why Amazon hasn't bought Discord and Valve. Discord makes perfect sense as a complement to Twitch, and Valve would ensure that they basically own the entire PC gaming space.
- poisonborz 6y agoBecause Valve majority owner is famously Gabe Newell and he won't sell to anyone.
- young_unixer 6y agoThe industry did want to bite and all the ingredients were there. The only reason Stadia didn't succeed is that Google fucked up in the most ridiculous ways.
- birdyrooster 6y agoIt just doesn’t look or feel as good as the native experience and the only people saying the tech was great are not serious gamers. Casual people don’t care enough to try Stadia and serious gamers can tell how shitty it is.
- bombcar 6y agoExactly. They need to buy and offer for free certain games to get people to try it.
- fragileone 6y agoYeah I've compared Destiny 2 on multiple platforms now and Stadia latency is awful.
- tmpz22 6y agoSpecifically Google Marketed it as a full priced full featured platform with a pitiful initial catalogue of a couple games (namely Destiny). They also went completely dark for periods of months here and there, typically around the winter holidays, which frustrated what initial users they did get.
- ArkanExplorer 6y agoThe Indie folks are easily wooed away from Steam, just look at how successful Epic has been with their free games, which they paid pittances for (eg. Super Meat Boy for $50,000). Look at No More Robots titles on Xbox Games Pass (which is also on PC). The problem is that Google just didn't put any money into buying up rights for titles. Plus, as other mentioned, the outdated pricing model. It should have been $20/month for unlimited gameplay of any title with maybe a discount tier of $15 for 900p.
- ikiris 6y agoI honestly don't believe Google can ever be successful at a consumer product that is a paid service.
- doikor 6y agoSuper Meat Boy is a 10 year old game that probably had sales close to 0 at this point (it has been on sale for a couple bucks multiple times by now). Taking 50k now a decade after release and losing practically nothing as anyone who was going to buy it already did makes a lot of sense for a small indie dev (literally just 2 people if I remember right)
- bondant 6y agoWell it's not like Google Stadia is the only one trying to provide cloud gaming, alternatives exist: Geforce Now, Shadow, Playstation Now, Blacknut. So I don't think the industry is completely against it.
- jimmaswell 6y agoThe latency is never going to be acceptable playing an FPS or similar over a video stream. It's fundamentally a stinker of an idea for anything but turn based strategy and similar games.
- BatFastard 6y agoYou are living in the past. Latency to Stadia servers is 20ms. Much faster than anyone can react.
- rcxdude 6y agoMuch smaller differences in latency have been shown to be relevant to competitive FPS (it's not necessarily absolute reaction time but relative to your opponents that matters). That said it's unlikely to be entirely the decider for a lot of people. Also, that kind of latency is basically the best case scenario: when you factor in a not-fantastic internet connection, location, and wifi, the user experience could still wind up quite poor in a lot of games (and it's not something which all players are going to notice consciously, they're just going to feel like the game controls worse).
- toast0 6y ago20ms is a bit more than one frame at 60 fps. If you still have a NES and an analog CRT tv, the best way to feel the difference is play super mario brothers for an hour on your modern tv that probably takes at least 20 ms to process rca video and display it, then play on the CRT for a while and see how much better it feels. Some things that get especially hard to do with lag, but are easy enough for most people otherwise are jumping onto a block above your head when you're on a single block, like the ? blocks in 1-1; and sliding through a one block space when you're big, like the spot towards the beginning of 1-2. Of course, modern games are built around expecting a lot more latency in the system, but having your input a frame behind to start with, before adding render time, encoding time, decoding time, and then display processing makes for a tough experience.
- numpad0 6y ago
- vmception 6y agoOut of curiosity, are you aware that similar offerings have been available for over ten years. None of them lasting long with the exception of PS Now. The others all die a dramatic and fiery death.
- Garvey 6y agoUbisoft is launching Ubisoft+ on Stadia, available in beta in the US now. Capcom had RE Village on there same day as the other stores. EA are also releasing games on there. So it seems at least some of the big publishers aren't that against the idea.
- tmpz22 6y agoPay $60 per game + subscription fee per month + hardware fee (the controller) to play a game on a $180 chrome book.
- Jyaif 6y agoExcept if you wait for sales, then it can be less than $60. Also you don't have to pay a subscription nor a controller. Other than that, you are 100% correct.
- tmpz22 6y agoYou do need to pay a subscription for the up-scaled 4k experience which is one of the main features in Stadia advertisements.
- benhurmarcel 6y agoI've already played $200 worth of games and they sent me $100 worth of devices, and I paid in total $130. And that's without counting that I didn't have to have hardware to run the games also.
- perryizgr8 6y agoAnd lose it all when Google inevitably shuts down the service.
- throwaway3699 6y agoSteam already supports cloud gaming. I signed a legal agreement on top of the existing Steamworks distribution agreement which lets my software be distributed through GeForce now and quote "Valve operated cloud gaming services". So I assume this is something they are at least considering.
- anonymousab 6y ago> Yeah, the industry just seems not to have bitten Assuming that the industry would do all of their work for them, and that 99.99999% of the responsibility lied anywhere other than Google themselves seems like a very Google thing to do. It is, predictably, the kind of arrogance that begets a (perceived to be) floundering product like this. The system launched with a pitiful fraction of the features they advertised that it could and would do. It launched with many important questions unanswered - often purposely, because everyone already knows the answers and those answers are bad and answering them could only hurt Google further. It still lacks many of those features, too. The story of how their reveal event's gaming history display case came to be - the one that showcased several great failures and blunders in gaming history, with Stadia as the next in line - is an excellent microcosm of the kind of decision making that went into the Stadia project as whole. EDIT: > But... the big studios don't want it because they don't want to lose control of distribution. There have been many games on streaming services that did not make their way to early Stadia. Many that may still not be on Stadia - I haven't done the research lately, so I can't say. Moving to a pure streaming solution - one where they don't have to provision and manage the hardware and all that sticky ugliness - is an absolute dream for many game publishers. Console hardware control is a small part of that dream, and it's less important than the rest. Stadia very well could have been the mass-accepted vehicle that delivered on the rest of that dream, had Google executed well. To this day, I'm still astonished that they've dropped the ball, the slam dunk, this hard. They're limping along when they very well could have had their revolution, had they done a better job.
- xyzzy_plugh 6y ago> industry just seems not to have bitten. I know folks at AAA game studios/publishers and the primary reason I've repeatedly heard is: Stadia requires that we port to Linux. Completely insane requirement. Steam, meanwhile, is making Linux gaming better than ever with their investment in Proton (which is incredible, wine has never been so good) and Nvidia's game streaming service "just works" and you bring your own games (just log into steam). Stadia is screwed from the get-go by thrusting inane requirements onto their potential partners. If they had huge market power, maybe it'd fly, but it's effectively a new console as far as publishers are concerned. Instead it should just work with PC games. End of story.
- aspaceman 6y agoIt using Linux shouldn't be an issue. You could use Wine and Proton to make the difference the same way Valve does. They purposefully hamper the systems though. So even a game like Destiny 2 is running at Medium settings on a datacenter. Just to be able to containerize it and all that noise. You're right that it should just work from the devloper's perspective. I personally think this is all possible with existing tech, but Google failed to deliver. Game devs have weird gripes about porting to Linux.
- ajross 6y ago> Completely insane requirement. They're doing ports to Xbone and Switch and PS5 already, and that's fine. But running on Linux is somehow insane? No. Porting engines across complicated SDKs and build environments is what these studios do every day of their existence, and virtually all the backends run fine on Linux already. Again, the reason the big studios aren't on board is because they don't want to be part of an app store ecosystem. It's not a technical thing at all.
- sharpneli 6y agoIt’s a financial thing. Porting to Linux costs money, that’s what it means. Depending on the engine it can be quite a lot of time. Especially if you don’t already have a Vulkan backend. Therefore if you don’t think the additional sales are worth the expense, including the opportunity cost of your devs, why bother?
- rcxdude 6y agoI think the industry is quite keen on the idea, as there are many similar services entering the space. I think the problem is stadia's model: the best value for players can be found in platforms like geforce now or the various smaller players where it's basically just renting a windows VM with a low latency connection, so they can just play their existing library (and which can be transferred to another service or played on your own PC), or in the offerings from Sony and Microsoft where you pay a monthly fee but get access to a huge library. The fact that stadia wants you to pay again for your games, which are locked into that service, have a smaller selection of games, and pay a monthly subscription is probably not worth the ability to play on a chromecast or a maybe slightly better latency, especially when there's unforced errors like some games becoming unplayable on the service for months due to bugs.
- MaxBarraclough 6y agoAgree. The problem is that Google didn't make any effort understand what people want. It's not just the payment/ownership model, it's also true of the technical decisions. They aimed for 4K out of the gate, but the sorts of people who care about 4K gaming are going to own their own high-end hardware. Stadia's potential customers don't care about 4K, they care about 1080P working really well. Here, Stadia loses to the competition. 1080P gaming from GeForce Now looks a good deal better than 1080P gaming from Stadia. The graphics settings can be adjusted to be higher than those of Stadia (where the settings cannot be adjusted), and there are fewer compression artifacts, especially in dark scenes which look awful in Stadia. To return to the payment/ownership model, GeForce Now is better not only in that it doesn't ask the customer to buy the games a second time, it's also better in that the customer can freely switch between GeForce Now and their own hardware, through the magic of cloud saves. Constrained to your laptop for a while? No problem, use GeForce Now. Stadia, on the other hand, has made a conscious effort to separate itself from the PC gaming platform. Cloud saves won't sync between Stadia and your own machine, as Stadia tries to present itself as a whole new platform, separate from PC gaming and from the various consoles. > geforce now or the various smaller players where it's basically just renting a windows VM with a low latency connection, so they can just play their existing library Not quite, as GeForce Now will only run officially supported games. > or a maybe slightly better latency Not in my experience. I've found GeForce Now and Stadia to both be very good in terms of latency.