4 ms·
It seems overly complicated. Just raise the air exchange per person and or per volume by a significant factor and mandate a very fine particulate filter. You
by colechristensen 6y ago
It seems overly complicated.
Just raise the air exchange per person and or per volume by a significant factor and mandate a very fine particulate filter. You could do many measurements and lots of theory but nobody is going to engineer their buildings like cleanrooms anyway so the results of a lot of science wouldn’t be so good regardless.
- londons_explore 6y agoI'd like to see "air quality inspection" be part of a fire safety inspection. Just have the inspector crack out a CO2 and PM2.5 meter during the inspection. Set legal limits and have a fee for exceeding them. Make it apply to existing buildings too, so building owners can choose to trade off increased HVAC costs Vs reducing the fee Vs costs of retrofitting better ventilation. Obviously the measured numbers vary a lot day to day, so if a building owner isn't happy with values measured on the day, let them take an average over a week or something.
- cam_l 6y agoAgree and love the idea about testing.. there are no other inspectors (in oz at least) as incorruptible as fire safety inspectors. I had the experience a couple of years ago of working in an office with visible smoke from a meat smoker working downstairs. The owner and employer had 'independent' tests done with no issue found. Fuckers. I do reckon there is a rather disgustingly unequal relationship between people that own or build a building and people that have to deal with sickness from working in a building. Overwhelmingly, upfront costs for systems which prioritise airchange, occupant health, and energy savings are more expensive to install but cheaper in the long run.
- shalmanese 6y agoThat has significant costs on the energy efficiency of buildings and would blunt a lot of the progress we're making on combating climate change. Not saying it shouldn't be done but it should be done in a smart way that balances between tradeoffs.
- lostmsu 6y agoDoes it? I thought energy expenditure to maintain indoor temperature is mostly due to heating/cooling, not due to moving air to or from heat exchanger. E.g. it is cheap to rotate the air in the building in a closed loop through a filter.
- thrdbndndn 6y agoYeah, I can't see how the operating cost would be much different. I do think the initial cost to install/upgrade to such system would be substantial, though (as in, existing systems may not have the capacity to ventilate that much.)
- Robin_Message 6y agoYou can use heat exchangers between outlet and inlet air to mitigate a good portion of the energy cost I believe.
- stkdump 6y agoIf the outflow is not compressed, you can transfer at most half of the heat and that is under perfect conditions.
- lhopki01 6y agoThat's not quite right. If the airflows are in opposite directions then you can transfer more heat. Since as the hot air cools it encounters progressively colder air ensuring there is always a temperature gradient to transfer heat. These systems are about 60%-90% efficient at transfering heat.
- disabled 6y ago> Just raise the air exchange per person and or per volume by a significant factor and mandate a very fine particulate filter. An alternative in the meantime is to use a PAPR (powered air purifying respirator), which are more efficient, last much longer (device and filter), and are much more comfortable than N95 masks. I use an Optrel Swiss Air and cover the valves of the mask with a hoodie style balaclava. It would be a good time to get one, as it is believed that it is only a matter of time before SARS-CoV-2 mutates into a variant that is capable of evading the vaccines. Also, the US CDC advice may not have been such a good idea. Look at these calculations: https://twitter.com/DrEricDing/status/1393090966928637952?s=20 https://twitter.com/DrEricDing/status/1393090966928637952?s=... Singapore has a comparable vaccination rate to the US and is going into lockdown to prevent further spread. They used Pfizer and Moderna vaccines. Just some food for thought: https://twitter.com/andrewkimmel/status/1393086704349630464?s=20 https://twitter.com/andrewkimmel/status/1393086704349630464?...
- dalyons 6y ago. Singapore is at 31% one shot(from your link), US is at 47 and rising. Of course you would still be able to get spikes in cases at only 31%, that’s expected. The mRNA vaccines are stupendously effective at stopping all variants thus far. Not sure what evidence aside from fear point to covid being able to mutate past them. We good, and it’s ok to accept that and have hope, not everything has to be fear-for-the-worst
- orhmeh09 6y agoIs 45-47% efficacy at preventing infection against B.1.351 & P.1 “stupendously effective at stopping all variants?” http://www.healthdata.org/covid/covid-19-vaccine-efficacy-summary http://www.healthdata.org/covid/covid-19-vaccine-efficacy-su...
- dalyons 6y agoI may be reading it wrong, but from your link it says 76% and 79% (pzifer & moderna) disease prevention against 351&p1. Which is still great. Note that’s just infection, the data shows the vaxxes have near 100% chance of preventing you from having more than mild/moderate symptoms. So yeah, stupendously effective, and we shouldn’t be panicking about variants.
- f6v 6y agoNow, who’s gonna pay for that?
- bsenftner 6y agoI bet it's the minimum wage workers, not receiving any bump above minimum wage, as well as the lower tier of non-minimum wage workers being reclassified to be minimum wage. You know those least able to afford it will pay for it.
- stevenhuang 6y agoDoing that without the ability to quantify the affect is also a nonstarter. How would you know it's even making an appreciable difference, or if a lower factor would perform just as well? Without the groundwork theory to rely on, you'd be hard pressed to convince new buildings to do something like that on a whim. > You could do many measurements and lots of theory but nobody is going to engineer their buildings like cleanrooms anyway so the results of a lot of science wouldn’t be so good regardless. This is a very strange and confused sentiment.
- op00to 6y agoIf you have air exchange per person, but some people are in an airflow "dead zone", then that doesn't really do you any good. You need to ensure the personal area is actively ventilated, versus the entire space as a whole.