22 ms·
Current RNA vaccines protect against worrying coronavirus variants
- o-__-o 6y agoSo, then I would assume this means people with antibodies from the initial wave of infections are also protected
- ghc 6y agoInterestingly, the mRNA vaccines produce superior immunity compared to getting infected, due mainly to the two dose regimen. For similarly long-lasting natural immunity you'd probably need to get infected with covid twice.
- petertodd 6y agoDo you have a source for that?
- ghc 6y agoMy wife is an immunologist who works on this at BioNTech. She explained it to me that this is expected and the data matches it. She explained why as well but there's a big gap in my undergrad-level understanding of bio and her phd + years of experience in the field, so it went way over my head I'm afraid.
- jjk166 6y agoThere's also the benefit that with the mRNA vaccines (and the adenovirus vaccines as well), your body is developing antibodies specifically for the spike protein, which is highly conserved. Your body's immune response to actual covid may, just by chance, focus on a less strongly conserved target.
- selcuka 6y agoI was under the impression that it's the other way around; spike protein is not conserved between variants [1]: https://theconversation.com/new-coronavirus-variant-what-is-the-spike-protein-and-why-are-mutations-on-it-important-152463 https://theconversation.com/new-coronavirus-variant-what-is-...
- garmaine 6y agoIf you track each and every mutation as a variant, then here are thousands of them. Changes in the spike protein have the largest effect though, so we track those specifically, and clusters of changes to the spike protein are what get official designation as variants. Because that’s what we care about.
- tialaramex 6y agoThat article is explaining that it's particularly worrying that some variants do have changes to the spike protein, not that this is common (it isn't). Mutation causes random changes, the selection process eliminates those that render the mutated version less fit. The focus on the spike is because most random changes to the spike also make it useless, the virus becomes impotent. Such mutations won't thrive of course, and so we hardly see them at all, but they are happening. In contrast, many random changes elsewhere might not prevent the virus from working. They might say, make it less able to survive outside a body, which would give it a disadvantage against variants that don't have that change, but if they also mean the immune system of a previous host doesn't recognise them, that's a big advantage to counteract that. We see lots of these variants because they "work", but since the spike is the same existing vaccines ought to be effective. So this is why it made sense to focus on the spike, even though as this article shows it isn't a magical panacea.
- o-__-o 6y agoWhat about the probability from having had a very bad infection?
- b0sk 6y agoNot necessarily [1]. COVID vaccines particularly give you far higher neutralization titers than a prior infection. [1] A glaring counterexample to your hypothesis is Brazil (Manuas) where prior infections (as high as 60%) didn't stop the P1 variant from ripping through.
- petertodd 6y ago> COVID vaccines particularly give you far higher neutralization titers than a prior infection. Do you have a source for that?
- icedchai 6y agoHere's one: https://www.contagionlive.com/view/immune-response-from-mrna-covid-19-vaccines-is-more-robust-than-natural-infection https://www.contagionlive.com/view/immune-response-from-mrna...
- petertodd 6y agoThe study itself says that the immune response to the vaccine is not as diverse as a natural infection. That's how the study tried to figure out who had been infected: "Natural exposure induces a dominant Ab response against the nucleocapsid protein (NP), but since NP is not in the vaccine, there is no vaccine induced response against it. In this way vaccinated people who had a prior natural exposure can be classified because they have Abs to NP." Simply looking at one aspect of immunity - detectable antibodies in the blood - is a very incomplete way of looking at the overall level of protection. For example, it's well known that mucosal immunity is important, and injected vaccines have a hard time inducing that kind of immunity: https://theprint.in/opinion/why-a-mucosal-covid-vaccine-has-a-better-shot-at-ending-the-pandemic/589821/ https://theprint.in/opinion/why-a-mucosal-covid-vaccine-has-... It's also concerning that there is evidence that while people who have been vaccinated are much less likely to be infected. If they do get infected, they are more likely to be infected with one of the variants than unvaccinated: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/bioproject/PRJNA728463 https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/bioproject/PRJNA728463 The immune response developed to our vaccines is quite specific - they only generate the spike protein - which leads to a much less diverse response than a natural infection. Finally, the study you quoted can't really compare apples to apples anyway, as it's defining prior infection as simply having some level of antibody response, without considering how mild or severe those infections actually were.
- senectus1 6y agothe big diff between a vaccine and a previous infection is that the vaccine doesn't damage your body in the process of training your body to attack it. Covid can wreck havoc on your body and leave it in a weaker state.
- o-__-o 6y ago20 million people already had the virus. I’m one of them. Are we the red headed step child that we have forgotten about? Let me change the perspective: when I get the flu because I stupidly did not get the flu shot that year, I don’t rush out and get the flu shot after the fact. I’m wondering why I would do the same with this vaccine when there are lots of evidence that first rounders are not likely to be infected even by variants (assuming low viral load)
- loveistheanswer 6y agoI've been asking this same question and have yet to hear a very convincing answer. The best answer I've heard is: it will give you "extra immunity". Which begs the follow on question, if we're so concerned about topping off our immunity, why shouldn't people get vaccinated and revaccinated every month or two?
- refurb 6y agoNo. Antibodies to an infection can be a variety that target different parts of the virus. The vaccine produces antibodies to a specific stretch of the spike protein. So everyone who has the Pfizer vaccine has a similar (but not identical) group of antibodies. Those infected with Covid-19 have a more diverse set of antibodies that may or may not protect as well against varients.
- adrr 6y agomRNA vaccines produce antibodies targeting just the spike protein( S protein). There are other proteins on the virus like the M protein. Antibodies produced during an infection may target other parts of the virus so you can’t compare the two.
- selcuka 6y agoIsn't it the spike protein that is usually different between these variants? In that case antibodies that target a different part should even be more effective.
- cmckn 6y agoThe vaccines target specific (and multiple) regions of the spike protein, so a given mutation of the protein is not likely to make a vaccine null and void (hence the current success of the vaccines against variants). A "natural" COVID infection could lead to similar protection, or less; but it's not likely that a natural infection gives you some kind of AAA protection. Being infected can also hurt you, after all. There is literally no downside to receiving the vaccine if you've already had COVID, so I would encourage everyone to get vaccinated regardless :)
- tialaramex 6y agoIt's not quite no downside. It may be inconvenient (especially if you live in a country where you can't necessarily get time off work to seek medical treatment) and you're quite likely to have a sore arm. Some people experience fever, headaches, or other annoying symptoms for a day or even longer. I had a powerful craving for a kebab, at like 0400 when all the kebab shops are closed, maybe a coincidence, but maybe not. If you told me I can get a free Coke, but I have to take an hour off work and then my arm will be sore for two days, I think I'll pass on your "free" Coke. Now, of course the excellent chance of becoming immune to a respiratory infection that's killing loads of people is a much better offer than a Coke. So I agree people should take up this offer, get yourself vaccinated - but we shouldn't claim "literally no downside".
- TheGigaChad 6y agoSorry doomers, you will have to get out of your houses.
- boringg 6y agoGreat news. Wish we could see the impacts of pfizer in the indian population against some of the other variants coming out there (and helping them out as well).
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- daenz 6y agoUntil it doesn't? I am far from an expert (so please correct me if I'm wrong), but isn't this like saying "the dam can stop any amount of water" ?
- belltaco 6y agoThey're talking only about currently worrying variants, not all future possible ones.
- un_montagnard 6y agoThey don't mention the B.1.617 variant.
- daenz 6y agoSure, but if there are already 5 major "variants of concern" in 1.5 years, why are we declaring a premature victory against the variants?
- dragonwriter 6y agoWe aren’t “declaring victory”, premature or otherwise, over anything; the results of research that are important in understanding the current, evolving landscape are being published.
- daenz 6y agoI was referring to the headline, which very much has a "mission accomplished" spin to it: >Pfizer Covid vaccine protects against worrying coronavirus variants It reads as: "Don't be worried, Pfizer has the variant problem solved."
- dragonwriter 6y ago> I was referring to the headline, which very much has a "mission accomplished" spin to it That’s really reading a lot into what is a simple, concise, factual headline. There are a set of currently-worrying variants (about which there had been much public concern about the effectiveness of current vaccines), and the Pfizer vaccine is effective against them. That headline is very much not a “Mission Accomplished” banner.
- Lammy 6y agoI hate headlines that try to tell me how I should feel about something. It seems like it would be equally informative without the “worrying”.
- dougb5 6y agoEpidemiologists use the term "variants of concern", so maybe "concerning" would have been a better word. https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/variant-surveillance/variant-info.html#Concern https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/cases-updates/vari...
- Clewza313 6y agoThere are hundreds if not thousands of variants by now. The ones that matter are the ones that spread more easily and/or make people sicker, aka the "worrying" ones.
- UncleOxidant 6y agoThey probably should have said "variants of concern".
- ncallaway 6y ago"worrying" is an identifiern of the variants. If it protects against the 2 least significant variants, that's less interesting of an article. Unless it protects against all variants the headline would likely be inaccurate without the "worrying" qualifier. I could agree with a criticism that "worrying" should be replaced with a better identifier of the specific variants being discussed, but I don't have a replacement proposal. And dropping the word "worrying" seems like it might be factually wrong (it also might not be, I don't know)
- asveikau 6y agoIt's not telling you to whom it is worrying. You made the mistake of assuming the headline meant "to you" but it is not stated. It is certainly worrying to someone.
- pmoriarty 6y agoHow does the Moderna vaccine compare?
- M4v3R 6y agoSince it’s based basically on the same mRNA technology (and has the same reported efficacy) I would assume it works as well as the Pfizer one. No hard data to back this up, though.
- deanclatworthy 6y agoThis is a false assumption as they have different mRNA instructions. As you point out, wait until there is data and treat the vaccines independently.
- flobosg 6y ago> This is a false assumption as they have different mRNA instructions Depending on what you mean by “mRNA instructions” that might not be the case. Both vaccine mRNAs encode exactly the same variant of the spike protein.
- rantwasp 6y agoyes, but no. while it’s technically the same protein, the way it was optimized differs (not by much but it’s different). the vaccine itself has the instructions to produce something that resembles the spike protein (to which your immune system goes in overdrive and generates antibodies)
- flobosg 6y ago> while it’s technically the same protein Not technically, it’s actually the same protein/polypeptide sequence in both cases, 100% identical, including the proline mutations that stabilize the prefusion conformation. You can check that easily by translating and aligning in silico both coding RNA sequences. > the way it was optimized differs (not by much but it’s different) I’m assuming that you’re referring to the codon optimization step that the RNA sequences underwent. While both coding sequences were optimized differently, this has no effect on the final protein product.
- vmception 6y agoI literally saw the opposite headline about Pzifer versus a strain in India today The actual article said "modest antibody evading capabilities“ I hate that the internet has become this way
- sigmaprimus 6y agoI agree, unfortunately there have been so many half truths and misleading articles both online and on legacy media that I find myself not knowing what or who to trust anymore. I have an appointment to get my first jab in 43 hours from now and I am bouncing back and forth between getting it and cancelation. Five years ago I would not be having these doubts but it seems like everyone has alterior motives. I wish the social media giants would just stop all the censorship and allow the discussions to take place. I appreciate that they are trying to stop disinformation but I just can't think of one time in the past that the ones stifling free speach have ever been on the right side of history.
- vmception 6y agoIf you already have an appointment the only debate should be whether you will need an additional third booster shot in the future if the strain in India breaks out and is different enough. The key thing you should notice about the COVID vaccine detractors is their inability to distinguish between vaccines and the wildly different technology between the different vaccines, alongside their inability acknowledge the geopolitical hurdles for any of their conspiracies. If a German-company made vaccine is part of an insidious plot, then should you get the Oxford one developed in the UK? If Bill Gates is influencing vaccines in some strange scheme, does the conclusion mean you should trust the Russian Sputnik vaccine more instead due to the geopolitical impossibility of a Bill Gates plot being involved? The absurdity basically cancels itself out, just get the shot you are offered.
- reedjosh 6y ago> acknowledge the geopolitical hurdles Each of those vaccines come from a UN/WHO member country. Geo politically power is wielded by globalist financial elites. These elites generally believe the world is overpopulated. Bill himself is well known for his this belief. Bill as an example runs a charitable foundation that only ever seems to make money. These conspiracies are not constituted of a flat earth and aliens. They are of human hierarchies, corruption, and psychopaths.
- drenvuk 6y agoThis does not mention the variant in India: B. 1.617. Excuse my language but fuck the author and this article. They went out of their way to list multiple other variant names but left the word "India" and "B. 1.617" out entirely while proclaiming "Pfizer COVID vaccine protects against worrying coronavirus variants". Is there another strain that's more worrying right now or even on the day that this article was published?
- simonCGN 6y agoIt it a Biontech vaccine. Pfizer is only the manufacturer. After all, you also do not call the MacBook a Foxconn Laptop.
- kjeetgill 6y agoI get where you're at but if you go to the pharmacist and ask which one they have they're going to call this one the Pfizer one.
- xeromal 6y agoWe're past that now. It's known as Pfizer in the official language of too many cities and countries.
- simonCGN 6y agoNo, we are not past that. Just because it is used wrongly it does not mean that it needs to stay that way.
- SimeVidas 6y agoWhat happens on the internet, stays on the internet.
- xeromal 6y agoShit happens. Every tissue in the US is called kleenex even though that is a brand. Lots of people call all kinds of skewers Doner Kebab even though that's incorrect. It's speech and sometimes it doesn't fit our nice rules.
- xboxnolifes 6y ago> Every tissue in the US is called kleenex even though that is a brand. The only people who call them that are at least 50. Everyone I know except my grandmother calls them tissues. Things change. Shit happens.
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- williesleg 6y agoShut it down and face diaper now!
- jb1991 6y ago> BioNTech CEO Ugur Sahin told CNBC last month he is “confident” the company’s vaccine, which was developed together with U.S. drugmaker Pfizer, is effective against the variant from India. https://www.cnbc.com/2021/05/11/india-covid-explainer-what-we-know-about-the-bpoint1point617-variant.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/05/11/india-covid-explainer-what-w...
- koheripbal 6y ago"effective" like "protects" are nebulous terms. The reality is that vaccines target multiple proteins and one protein mutation usually does not even evade that specific protein from matching (much). It's a sliding bumpy scale with each mutation reducing the effectiveness of the vaccine some small random amount. It's very likely that all the current vaccines confer sufficient immunity to all current variants to a degree that will prevent serious Illness and likely even transmissibility. But the real takeaway here is that, like flu, we are looking at yearly covid boosters for everyone for years to come.