21 ms·
Why are modern 50mm lenses so damned complicated?
- gerikson 6y agoRoger Cicala is probably the best photo gear blogger around these days.
- lmilcin 6y agoI have a bunch of full frame lenses. Recently I looked at some very old ones I haven't used in a long time. I thought they are faulty (soft). After some diagnosing I found that it is not the fault of lenses but rather in the meantime I have started looking at images at 1:1 in Lightroom and gotten used to ridiculously sharp images from new cameras. Have you ever watched an old TV show and despaired how unwatchable it is because of low quality of image? Yes, that's the same thing -- our tastes change.
- reader_mode 6y ago>Have you ever watched an old TV show and despaired how unwatchable it is because of low quality of image? Yes, that's the same thing -- our tastes change. I've had the opposite reaction - I'd watch something I've seen before in 4k remastered or something and it would be a worse experience because the extra details reveal the low quality tricks you can get away with on lower reproduction quality. I've even noticed poor acting a lot more on higher def. It took away from immersion IMO.
- bostik 6y agoHah. I've had that experience but with sound. Long time ago, when dinosaurs roamed the Earth and AMD K8 was the pinnacle of technology, I invested in a basic home theater setup. A decent AV receiver, a subwoofer, two studio-quality monitor speakers. A friend warned me that the speakers I had picked were "crisp, but unforgiving". All of a sudden DVDs sounded wonderful. The audio tracks in TV programmes became clear. The warnings made no sense. Until I watched a classic TV show episode from 1980's. Bad mixing. Flipped stereo channels. Stuffy voiceovers. Everything sounded ... wrong. Suddenly, it all made sense. I understood.
- PaulHoule 6y agoIn images they call that the difference between being "scene referred" vs "display referred". There is no generally accepted theory of stereo sound, instead there are at least three theories: (1) a method for mastering sound recordings intended to be played by two speakers that are right next to each other (two sides of a TV, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sound_Retrieval_System for some theory) (2) mastering sound records so that 'left means left' and 'right means right' which means your speakers are on opposite sides of the room and you're near the middle. That can cast sounds effectively to the left and right but falls down casting them to the middle (3) Ambisonics, which doesn't really work because the coherence in natural sound sources badly damages the timbre of natural sounds and the concept of 'represent natural soundfield' doesn't really mix with 'record instruments individually in dead environments', 'add reverb', and 'repeat' which is how 'quality' sound in the judgement of the industry is attained. One way to think about a 5.1 system with a modern layout (FL, FC, FR, R, and L, nothing in back) is that you put the FL and FR close to the FC, expect to play back type I content on the FL and FR, and play type 2 content on the L and R. Often DVDs were mixed under the assumption that they couldn't trust the receiver (e.g. no center channel); blu-rays sound a lot better not just because they allocate more bits to sound, but because the mixing is more aggressive... they don't feel they have to copy dialog on the L and the R because they know many people don't have a working C.
- bostik 6y agoThank you for that. I was only vaguely aware of (1) and in retrospect have had an intuition about (2). I am delighted to be one of today's lucky 10000: https://xkcd.com/1053/ https://xkcd.com/1053/
- liminal 6y agoI'm reminded of Scott McCloud's abstract vs realistic dimension in Understanding Comics. Basically, abstraction allows us to focus on the relevant details, while realism adds a lot of details that aren't relevant to the use case (in this case, it's following the story/emotions). Here's a write up of that section of the book here (but the whole book is amazing!): https://theteachingtree.wordpress.com/2014/04/08/comics-and-the-big-triangle/ https://theteachingtree.wordpress.com/2014/04/08/comics-and-...
- evandev 6y agoTurn off motion smoothing on your TV. It's also called the "Soap Opera Effect".
- saiya-jin 6y agoThis so much. People either don't use it and then its unwatchable with it (my case), or get used to it since its default setting on TV and +-don't notice it after some time. Every time I go back visiting parents, which have TV with this on, anything on TV feels surreal and not in a good way. Which isn't bad, watching TV instead of interacting with my parents is stupid waste of time anyway and TV itself actively helps with that
- FredPret 6y agoWhat a hilarious bug-and-yet-a-useful-feature on the part of their TV
- pier25 6y agoI have a 65'' OLED TV and 24fps content is unwatchable without motion smoothing. When the camera pans, the "jumps" between frames are too distracting. I only use it at about 10-20% though, not at 100% which I think is the default setting and I agree is vomitive.
- astrange 6y agoThere's two levels of motion smoothing, one from 24 to 60fps and one from 60 to 120fps. The second is important for OLED to avoid judder (uncomfortable panning). I think the people complaining about the first are whiners and as a digital video expert I will allow you to leave it on.
- sumtechguy 6y agoWhat is more fun is the latency those effects add to images. Found that out the hard way playing some twitchy 'have to be just right' on the controls games. In my case it was almost 1/4-1/2 of a second. Even with all of the settings 'off' there is still a decent latency on the screen (down to about 70ms) which is just enough to mess me up on some games but not all.
- jclardy 6y agoI had this experience watching the Hobbit in high frame rate - it felt like I was watching a play, a bunch of actors on a stage.
- pier25 6y agoI watched the second Hobbit movie in 48fps and it was a horrible experience. Everything looked fake, which is how I imagine it actually looked in real life. Props seemed made of plastic, makeup looked like makeup, etc. Also, when there was a cut to a new scene, for a few seconds my brain thought the movie was playing faster. Like those old black and white movies of the early 20th century.
- NikolaNovak 6y agoSecond that; Hobbit in particular seemed like a mid-budget British made-for-TV show. I get that it's all psychological, that I'm used to deliberate Hollywood motion-blur look... but I still couldn't bear it. But clearly we learned something or there was something special about Hobbit, because that hasn't necessarily been my experience with all 4k / high-frame shows or movies...
- stormbrew 6y agoI think to a large extent people overestimated how much this feeling, specifically in the Hobbit films, came from the high frame rate vs. how much came from other artistic, creative, and budget choices they made. I saw them in both normal frame rate and HFR as they were coming out and it looked kinda low-budget, weirdly lit/color corrected, and generally just clunkier than the LotR films did in the moment.
- infofarmer 6y agoSweat. Beads of sweat on everyone. They were invisible at 720p and in cinematic projection, but 1080p and especially 4K remasters at close range at home reveal more about human skin than I cared to know.
- iamacyborg 6y agoI don't know how true this is but I always found it interesting that new makeup was developed (HD foundation) as a result of the switch towards high definition tv/cinema formats.
- dylan604 6y agoThere was also a resurgence in Soft F/X type filters until the Photoshop in a Can type of makeups came out.
- jaywalk 6y agoIt's 100% true. HD changed everything from the makeup to how sets are constructed, painted and lit. Even at the level of your local newscast.
- N1H1L 6y agoDid it also change air conditioning? I have been on sets thrice in my life, and everytime it has been uncomfortably hot.
- viraptor 6y agoIt reminded me of a trivia: shows shot in Melbourne gave actors ice to put in their mouths - because everyone knows Australia is always hot and sunny so you can't show the steam of their breath. (when they filmed on a cold day)
- andreareina 6y agoIn photo studio work we call the continuous (as opposed to strobe) lights hot lights for good reason. I imagine the lighting requirements for film/video isn't too much different. This was ~10 years ago though, don't know how LEDs have changed things.
- pier25 6y agoI'm a 4K HDR fanboy, but IMO most movies shot in 35mm film should remain in 1080p. 70mm film looks great in 4K though (2001, Nolan movies, etc). It's a shame there is no 1080p HDR content. 35mm movies would benefit a lot more of higher color bit depth that higher resolution. Anyone knows if this is a codec limitation?
- jaywalk 6y ago1080p HDR does exist (video games, mostly) but the lack of it is basically tied to the fact that there are no consumer TVs that can do HDR but not 4K.
- dylan604 6y agoI think 35mm->4k scans can look amazing. There's a lot going on though with film to digital scanning. The film stock itself has a lot to do with it. From the condition it has been stored as well as the actual type of film stock. The choice in a physical scanner also makes a difference. Single pass realtime captures vs slow speed triple flashed scans. Single pass is usually on a CMOS type sensor, where the triple flashes are typically on a CCD sensor. There's a whole list of things that are involved that makes one 35mm->4k transfer not like the next. Typically, you as a consumer, will be receiving an H.264 or H.265 stream that your cable box or streaming device decodes. These have all been updated with levels/profiles to allow for things like 3D, 4K, HDR, and 10bit encodes. The shoehorn used to shove new features into these formats has been put to heavy use.
- pier25 6y ago35mm -> 4K can look amazing in terms of color, but I've yet to see a film where the added detail is not mostly film grain (exaggerated by sharpening). Do you have a good example?
- dylan604 6y agoThis was the point of the type of film stock used. The film grain is why pretty much everyone will wince when you ask to do a 16mm->4K. Hell, 16mm->HD was rough. I don't have any examples on hand. But with large amount of time I have found myself with over the past year to watch a lot of content, I too have noticed even some of the last episodics to be shot on film (2005-2010 range) are very noticeable. I have also seen some features from the 90s that looked really clean in comparison. Lots of things go into that, from how much the camera department "cared", what film stock was used, what film processor was used, etc. Towards the end of mass film production, there were fewer and fewer labs left. During they heyday, the soups used in the processing where in constant use. As demand lowered, the soups kind of stagnated especially in the shops financially strapped. Film is fickle to be sure.
- seanicus 6y agoThe Thing is probably my favorite movie and the practical creature effects are still largely considered the gold standard of the craft. But in 2K the artificiality is getting a lot more noticeable and while I will certainly be getting it in 4K I'm starting to realize that maybe 720p is the best way to view it for the sake of full immersion. YMMV.
- aconbere 6y agoContrasting that to the digital remaster (presumably first for DVD) which is AMAZING. They did an incredible job restoring the image.
- Dylan16807 6y agoWhat resolutions have you watched it in? Since DVD itself is way below 720p.
- agumonkey 6y agoWhat I feel is that digital medium is too pristine, I dearly miss analog limits that gave glare and blurry trails on spotlights. Even tone often added to the pictures (another instance is Kodachrome). It wasn't a defect imo
- xgulfie 6y agoI was watching F.R.I.E.N.D.S. in HD and there is the occasional out-of-focus shot you would never have noticed at the intended resolution
- realityking 6y agoSame with early seasons of House. Really interesting to see what you used to be able to get away with.
- m463 6y agoI think HDR can sometimes look ... different. Maybe it's like the early 3d stuff where you got weird motion artifacts until they figured it out. I watched Gemini Man in 4k HDR and some of the scenes seemed a little like a video game. I think there was sort of an "uncanny valley" sort of thing where you could see detail into the deepest shadow and it looked fake. On the other hand, 2001 in 4k was awesome.
- DavidVoid 6y agohbomberguy made a pretty decent video about this a few years ago [1]. From around the 10-minute mark he talks about how many horror/thriller films worked much better on VHS than they did in the cinema, because on VHS there weren't enough details to make out if there was a monster lurking in the background or not, and you also couldn't see how unrealistic the old cgi effects were. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xbZMqS-fW-8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xbZMqS-fW-8
- jxramos 6y agoI had the opposite reaction too. One weekend an old friend was watching Back to the Future in High Def. It took away from the experience, it was like watching a play the resolution was so sharp. I couldn't enter into the fiction of the story any longer, it prevented the suspension of disbelief because it was so realistic. I think that grainier lower quality medium facilitated the imagination somehow, much like reading a book does.
- hellbannedguy 6y agoYea---I feel there's a happy medium. People here blame it on age, but very high resolution always screams it was shot on video. I don't need to see every pore on an actor's face. I'm usually wanting to get away from reality when watching a movie, or a tv show too. I am very content with the visual quality film gave us. I love black, and white film for the same reasons, and others, even more.
- acomjean 6y agoThey do some real time image processing now, I noticed when I went to a taping of the view. You can see the two screens on the camera (taking during a break). I'm not sure what they're doing exactly. https://www.flickr.com/photos/acomjean/35581239466/in/photostream/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/acomjean/35581239466/in/photos...
- alasdair_ 6y agoThe 4K issue may actually be the “soap opera effect” https://www.digitaltrends.com/home-theater/what-is-the-soap-opera-effect-in-tvs-and-how-to-turn-it-off/ https://www.digitaltrends.com/home-theater/what-is-the-soap-... Basically, we (over the age of about 25 anyway) are used to associating 24 FPS with “high quality” content like movies and higher FPS with cheap content like soap operas.
- wl 6y agoI'm in my 30s I associate 24 fps with jerky pans and unwatchable action sequences. And if we're talking 2:3 pull down in something that was never intended for theaters, I think, what a pointlessly detrimental affectation.
- hilbert42 6y ago"and it would be a worse experience because the extra details reveal the low quality tricks you can get away with on lower reproduction quality" I'd especially emphasize the 'tricks you can get away with' in low resolution television. A few months ago I was watching a rerun of an early 1960s B&W sitcom on a TV sub-channel running at normal 1080 HD resolution. The program was My Favorite Martian which is a spoofed up science fiction comedy series. The program features a Martian who can disappear and levitate objects so it's not unusual to see things either moving or floating in midair. Anyway, the tricks employed to levitate things were embarrassingly obvious in standard HD/1080 resolution as it was dead easy to see that they had been suspended on nylon fishing line. When the show was first aired the most common TV standards were 405, 525 and 625 lines so the series producers were betting that the limiting resolution of these TV systems would hide the lines—which clearly they did. BTW, as a young kid I used to watch the show [on 625 B&W], and if I'd have seen that fishing line then I've made a big deal out of the fact. Incidentally, the early series were in black & white and filmed on 35mm film which meant the original negatives would have been dazzlingly sharp in comparison to the then TV systems. It's interesting to note the present video quality of this series—unlike so many others from the time—is excellent (and that includes the later color episodes). Clearly, the recent transfer/digitization was done from negatives have been archived well. It's especially obvious in the color series which are of exceptionally good color quality given the passage of time (there's not a trace of fade, cross-coupling of color dyes or color bleed which plagues so many old films).
- dheera 6y agoInterestingly, I tried several modern Canon lenses about 8-10 years ago and very quickly sold them because they were all not only producing subpar images compared to almost all my lenses from the 1960s-1980s, but they were also made of f-ing plastic and had an incredible amount of backlash in the rings.
- dylan604 6y agoCanon's L-series (red bands) have metal casings. The glass is also nicer, the barrels are rated much higher for dust/moisture protection. This is reflected in their much higher price tags.
- dheera 6y agoI tried a couple L lenses and they were plastic, felt cheap as fuck, and horribly difficult to focus. Even tried a 50mm f/1.2 L and returned it within an hour of unboxing it. That thing, despite costing 3X as much, felt like a cheap toy in comparison to a Rokkor 58/1.2 or a Nikkor 50/1.2 (both of which are 1/3 of the price in perfect condition), and at the end of the day I still liked the rendition and hand feel of my Contax-Zeiss Planar 50/1.4 slightly better. I don't use autofocus, pretty much ever, so that isn't a consideration. But I do want quality precision mechanics, and I feel that shouldn't be much to ask for. My old lenses feel like quality scientific instruments, in comparison, and have long focus throws that allow me to focus very accurately. I now own a Canon body and zero Canon lenses except for an FD 300/2.8 that I modified to fit EF.
- ISL 6y agoMany of the Ls are metal on the inside. A tough lightweight plastic shell can have major advantages (lighter, impact resistance, etc.) For a great example of a sharp modern L, check out the 16-35 f/4 IS. I'm not an ultra wide photographer by nature, but that lens impresses me each time it is called-upon. Choosing lenses, in the long run, is such a personal choice. My favorite first came to market in the early 1990s (and spent this morning with it) -- glad you have found good fits, too :).
- bitL 6y agoNow do the same with Sigma SD1 and quality lens and you'd be frustrated with the "sharp images from new cameras" the same way you consider old ones "faulty". Some things can't be unseen once you see them the first time.
- frostburg 6y agoI really like my DP3m, but (with static subjects, which honestly you need with the Sigma, too) modern multi-shot implementation (especially the Panasonic one) get pretty close.
- bitL 6y agoYeah, Sigma is clunky, 60% of my shots end up out of focus, but the best shots I get are simply unbelievable. Zooming in to a pixel level is way better than anything else I saw, including 100MP medium format ones, the pictures feel alive. Never experienced anything like that with another camera.
- foldr 6y agoI think a lot of this must be psychological. Anyone can generate an extremely high res image nowadays by using a longer focal length and stitching four images together with a consumer grade SLR. Expensive bits of gear can be superior to that method in terms of the workflow (and sometimes results, given the limitations of stitching) but they aren’t magical. I know some will vociferously disagree with this statement, but I’d like to see that backed up by proper side by side comparisons. We know for sure that people do rationalize the purchase of expensive gear with reference to spurious properties (such as the mythical “medium format look”).
- copperx 6y agoAre you saying that the medium format look isn't real?
- foldr 6y agoLight rays don't know the size of the sensor that they're headed for. So clearly the size of the format can't affect the 'rendering' or whatever other subjective property people want to attribute to MF. Imagine masking off the sides of a MF sensor with tape: you now have a full frame camera which must necessarily retain the 'medium format look'. Or similarly, imagine mounting an MF lens on a full frame camera (which you can in fact do). Aside from the crop, the rendering of the image must be the same. The preceding considerations show that the medium format look, if it exists, must be a property that goes away as soon as you crop the photo. But none of the candidates for this alleged look (e.g. 'rendering' of out of focus regions) has that property. In principle, medium format should offer shallower depth of field. However, in practice, medium format lenses rarely go beyond f2.8 whereas crazy ~f1 lenses are available for full frame. So if you really want ludicrously shallow depth of field you're probably better off with full frame. All this being said, it's obviously the case that any given medium format lens might look different from any given full frame or crop sensor lens. Perhaps there are even generalisations about the 'look' of commonly used MF lenses vs. commonly used FF lenses (though I have never seen any evidence for this). In-lens leaf shutters can also make a real difference, and are more common on medium format cameras. On an anecdotal level, I'd add that I shoot a bit of 4x5 film as a hobby and the photos 'look' the same as the photos I take on my phone with its tiny sensor (apart from the expected differences such as resolution, grain, depth of field). This site has some side-by-side comparisons of FF and MF: https://srussenschuck.com/review-fujifilm-gfx-50s/ https://srussenschuck.com/review-fujifilm-gfx-50s/
- subhro 6y agoIn the other news, /me is supremely happy with his Schneider 300mm 8x10 Large format and Hasselblad/Zeiss medium format lenses. The world is not just 35mm in size.
- foldr 6y agoOld lenses are generally fine when stopped down to sensible apertures in my experience. What’s new is the expectation that lenses should be ultra sharp wide open. Expensive lenses are a very niche enthusiast market now, so the design criteria aren’t especially rational. An exception would be old kit zooms from the film era, which really are awful, since they were designed for people who rarely even went up to 8x10 prints. Modern kit zooms are usually very sharp lenses, though.
- lmilcin 6y agoHalf of reason I even bother with full frame is wide open. Any smartphone these days can give perfectly good sharp photos. I lug the beast around to get shots you can't get with a smartphone.
- foldr 6y agoShooting wide open is fashionable because it’s a sign of expensive gear. Once artificial bokeh is perfected I expect people will stop obsessing over blurry backgrounds.
- velosol 6y agoI can't speak for lmilcin, but wide open is also critical in low light to minimize ISO noise or to even have a stop or 2 down from the widest to have a little width in the focal plane while still capturing action. Agreed on the shots where you're at 1.4 and pushing the limits of your shutter speed.
- jeromenerf 6y agoI hope not. My Nikkor 135mm dc is quadrupled in value since I bought it :) DC stands for “defocus control", as distorting the bokeh forward of backward.
- skhr0680 6y agoI picked up an old stock 105mm last year, case included. I love how it makes people look, it's a great bridge between vintage and modern lenses. How do you feel abbout the DC function? I've found R settings don't really focus correctly with AF, so it's best to focus manually. Is that the case with the 135mm version too?
- antihero 6y agoDepends on the lens really, a Super Takumar 50mm f/1.4 will happily compete in sharpness at f/8 (if I take well lit photos with mine it becomes the 24MP sensor that is the limiting factor in detail), but will indeed be significantly less performant at f/1.4. Even a decent Helios 44m will create gorgeous and impressively sharp images. These lenses stopped down are better more for artistic photography as they have interesting bokeh patterns and lots of character.
- jcims 6y agoCouldn't there be a volumetric description of lens focusing ability/sharpness/distortion similar to that of the polar sensitivity plot of a microphone?
- astrange 6y agohttps://www.dpreview.com/articles/1351719699/roger-cicala-field-curvature-for-fun-and-profit https://www.dpreview.com/articles/1351719699/roger-cicala-fi...
- cwmartin 6y agoArchive link since the original appears to be down right now: https://web.archive.org/web/20210510151205/https://www.dpreview.com/news/9236543269/why-are-modern-50mm-lenses-so-damned-complicated https://web.archive.org/web/20210510151205/https://www.dprev...
- amelius 6y agoHow are these lens systems designed? Do they use "black box" optimization methods like gradient descent, simulated annealing or even genetic algorithms to find the optimal configuration of lenses?
- formerly_proven 6y agoHow it used to be done: https://imaging.nikon.com/history/story/ https://imaging.nikon.com/history/story/ Super-experienced people backed up by a small army of people doing ray-tracing by hand. Wikipedia might give you starting points to find modern answers: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optical_lens_design#Lens_optimization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Optical_lens_design#Lens_optim... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_photographic_lens_design https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_photographic_lens_d... And if you want to get a general feel for how the modern designs work, Bill Claffs optical bench is a nice starting point: https://www.photonstophotos.net/GeneralTopics/Lenses/OpticalBench/OpticalBench.htm https://www.photonstophotos.net/GeneralTopics/Lenses/Optical... (tbh it sounds a lot like the EDA space, and CAE in general)
- ghaff 6y agoYeah, modern lenses are definitely computer-designed but if there's any ML being used, it's almost certainly very recent.
- mateo1 6y agoThere's no point in using such methods as the physics surrounding optics aren't a black box, they're well-known and understood. However lens design is very complicated, there are dozens of design parameters and trade-offs to be made, while also taking in account time, cost, materials etc. It's also not a problem that can be solved analytically for realistic use cases. Computer ray tracing has been used for decades. I'm not sure what the state of the art tools are however.
- jdjkckfkrrn 6y agoI had an old metal very well regarded 50 mm prime, 1.4 f. I also had a modern plastic 18-55 mm kit lens, high f (starting at 3.5). But the colors on the modern zoom lens were so much better. Hard to explain, but they just looked better, kind of like a DSLR photo has "better" colors than a phone photo. It was very confusing, I was expecting differences in sharpness maybe, but not in colors.
- bigdubs 6y agoA lot of that has to do with coatings modern lenses use to correct for chromatic aberration, but also how they minimize loss of contrast from light bouncing around inside the lens. It really is incredible how much a lens affects the final image.
- dylan604 6y agoIt's all about the glass. There's an old saying with cameras and lenses: buy the glass, rent the camera. Cameras change quickly, but lenses remain for a lot longer. Lots of comments in this thread talking about how they prefer the older lenses. Each series of lenses have a "look" to them that people become attached. Modern lenses are approaching 0 distortion in color/sharpness/etc. For some users, that's what they want. For others, they prefer the softer looks. So find the lenses you like, buy them, and use them on what ever camera you can.
- proudfoot 6y agoYou can fix the colors in post production.
- dylan604 6y agosometimes. shooting in RAW helps. shooting in JPEG limits your post abilities.
- vladvasiliu 6y agoI've also had this "shock" with lenses much closer in generation. I had a Canon 40D a while ago, and at first I was using a 17-40/4. I absolutely loved the colors I would get. Gradients would have a certain "creaminess" to them. Then I figured I'd change it for a 17-55/2.8, to get some extra light at night. That was pretty much when I stopped going out taking pictures altogether. I just wasn't getting the pictures I wanted anymore. Everything looked just... weird and unsatisfactory. I then sold everything a when I realized I hadn't touched the camera in a year. A few years later I got to do a similar comparison again, between the Olympus 17/1.8 and the Panasonic 20/1.7 on a Pen-F. The panny was OK, sharp, etc. But there was just something missing that the oly had. A kind of delicate rendering of gradients that just appealed to me. This was when I realized what had happened with the Canon change earlier. I had believed that I had just lost interest in photography or that for some reason I just "didn't have it" anymore. I had never thought that a lens that was rated better in practically every aspect would actually be so uninspiring to me.
- patorjk 6y agoMy Nikkor 50mm 1.8G is one of my favorite lenses. When I had a cropped sensor DSLR I used it as my portrait lens, and when I upgraded to a full frame I started using it as a general purpose lens. It creates beautiful images. I've always been curious about the versions with a lower f-stop, but the price always makes me think twice.
- distantsounds 6y agooh hey i have read many of your AOL files over the years, cheers :)
- Wowfunhappy 6y agoI came so close to buying this lens when I got a Nikon D750 last fall. I'm not really a photographer, but I was unsatisfied with the images coming out of my phone, and if I was going to get a dedicated camera, I wanted to go "all the way", so to speak. But the problem with 50mm prime lenses is they all seem to lack image stabilization. (The one exception I could find, a 45mm from Tamron[1], has bad chromatic aberration which really bothered me when I tried it out.) Maybe OS isn't essential in all situations, but not having it just seems like a needless downgrade for no benefit. 1: https://www.tamron-usa.com/product/lenses/f013.html https://www.tamron-usa.com/product/lenses/f013.html
- formerly_proven 6y agoShort, fast primes are rarely optically stabilized. That Tamron series (35-45-85/1.8 VC) is the only exception I know. While these can be stabilized using IBIS on mirrorless cameras, I have just that combination (Nikon Z6 + 50/1.8G) and the VR is less useful than you'd think, because being around f/2.0 already gets you to shutter-speeds where it's not really necessary, and a 50 mm can go pretty slow without stabilization anyway.
- EvanAnderson 6y agoSpend a few bucks and get a manual focus version from eBay to play around with before you spend more on an AF version. You'll be pleasantly surprised. At the low noise levels that you get with high ISO on a D750 you really don't need stabilization w/ an f/1.8 50mm. Turn on auto-ISO and cap it it ISO 6400 or 3200. Even in low light you'll get reasonable shutter speeds at f/4.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- azhenley 6y agoI have a collection of 50mm lenses (from the 1950s to 2018). Most of my favorite shots are actually taken with the older, imperfect ones. Some people call these "character lenses", which have flaws that can actually be quite appealing. Most of them are sharp enough and the flaws disappear if stopped down a bit. Examples of flaws include swirly bokeh in the background, a glow around high-contrast edges, and flares from lights.
- ajross 6y agoWhat I don't understand isn't the design of the lenses, which are chasing ever-tightening windows of precision in a competetive market with high margins and discriminating consumers. Of course they're going to be overdesigned. What gets me is that lens distortion is a fully reversible convolution. It's not lossy, at all. Or rather, it's only lossy in the sense that the existing quantization in the sensor is already lossy: pixel boundaries, spectrum of the color sensors, etc... all have straightforward analogs in both space and frequency domain. Basically: why hasn't someone come out with a camera with a junky single-piece lens and a fancy image processing backend and won the market?
- tachion 6y agoBut of course they have - every major smartphone manufacturer is eating the whole consumer camera market alive for quite few years now.
- Miraste 6y agoNobody has done this with a full frame sensor, as far as I know. I'd be interested to see smartphone image processing with a sensor that size.
- tachion 6y agoThere is fairly new Zeiss camera that implemented the whole "camera OS" with Android and even included mobile Lightroom editing capabilities. I guess it's as close as it gets right now. My theory is that the main Japanese companies are extremely conservative and they don't pick up such changes easily - see how Canon and Nikon completely missed mirrorless and suffered huge market loss to Sony.
- gerikson 6y agoNikon made a mirrorless camera series (Nikon 1) that was very capable (the on-sensor AF was great). But they chose a 1" sensor (2.7x crop) Canon's M-series was similar, they didn't go all in on "pro" features, instead focussed on a consumer market that was shrinking rapidly. The problem wasn't the technology, the problem was the fear of cannibalizing their own DSLR sales.
- ben7799 6y agoI love 50mm lenses but a lot of this stuff is ridiculously academic since photography is artistic & creative in nature. DPreview largely seems to write for the crowd that doesn't even care about the art aspect and just wants validation that they have better photo gear than others. These new 50mm lenses often defeat the point cause they're enormous, heavy, very expensive, and have little benefit over the slower versions of old lenses since most of the time we don't walk around shooting everything at f/1.0-f/1.4, and when we do we're actually looking for some artistic weirdness. I've mostly had Canon.. I've owned the old f/1.8, the f/1.4, currently have the newer f/1.8, and have rented the f/1.2. Even the Canon f/1.2, it's older, and not as big/heavy as some of these more recent ones, but it's already so big it feels silly most of the time compared to the smaller/cheaper ones. It was useful as a rental for specific scenarios, and the new huge/expensive ones are likewise. They're great though if you're going to compare your gear collection instead of your photographs though.
- bayindirh 6y ago> DPreview largely seems to write for the crowd that doesn't even care about the art aspect... As a hobbyist photographer and a reader of DPReview, I can tell that you can find what you're looking for. There also guys who are in for the art, in for the studio photography or just for gear. These kind of technical articles makes me happy and piques my interest deeply, because I love to know how things work, and why they're designed this way. I'm personally aware that better gear makes my photography better, however I love to know theoretical capabilities and limits of my gear. Understanding my gear made my photography better and DPReview's both articles and forums helped me a lot TBH. For the most light and scenarios, f2.8 is very suitable from my experience, esp. with latest generation of sensors (A7III, Z6/7, etc.), however in extreme dim light (I shoot tango dancing, BTW), f1.8 is really helping. Since you're away from subjects too, DoF becomes very acceptable too. I agree that unless you've a specific need, f1.4 and f1.2 lenses are halo products. As a Sony shooter, that 2.5/40mm lens [0] is very compelling for street photography from perspective. At the end of the day, new lenses are giant leaps when compared to older ones in terms of resolution and sharpness. Older lenses indeed have character but, newer ones are not always devoid of it. [0]: https://www.sony.com/electronics/camera-lenses/sel40f25g https://www.sony.com/electronics/camera-lenses/sel40f25g
- tyho 6y agoI recently got back into photography after a decade break. Brought a nice mirrorless camera and a few good lenses (Sony A7iii, 24-105 f/4, 35mm f/1.8). I was truly blown away at the progress that has been made in handheld imaging. The difference between my old Cannon EOS 450d and my current equipment is immense. What has happened to the iPhone camera in the last 10 years has also happened to handheld cameras too, but they were starting from a much better place, most people just haven't realised as the iPhone is good enough for almost everything.
- azhenley 6y agoGreat camera. Don't discount the 3rd party E-mount lens makers, such as Samyang. If you are unsure what to get next, I suggest looking at this list of every E-mount full-frame lens: https://briansmith.com/sony-a7-a7r-a7s-lens-guide/ https://briansmith.com/sony-a7-a7r-a7s-lens-guide/
- twalla 6y agoIf you want to go even deeper down the rabbithole the Alphas are also great manual lens platforms. https://phillipreeve.net/blog/manual-lenses-sony-a7/ https://phillipreeve.net/blog/manual-lenses-sony-a7/ Plus, a comprehensive list from the same folks for all the E mount lenses: https://phillipreeve.net/blog/fe-lenses-sony-comprehensive-independent-guide/ https://phillipreeve.net/blog/fe-lenses-sony-comprehensive-i...
- azhenley 6y agoDefinitely. I recommend grabbing a Helios-44 58mm off eBay and a cheap adapter from Amazon.
- twalla 6y agoI have one of these and would second the recommendation - really cool bokeh, light and cheap enough that I don't mind bashing it around. Seems they've gotten more expensive compared to when I purchased mine though (I think I paid 50-60 USD) Generally speaking all of the M42 mount Soviet Zeiss clones will be interesting and relatively affordable.
- spoonjim 6y agoI’ll save you a click: this article basically says “to make them better.” Little explanation of what the elements do.
- cratermoon 6y ago"better" is subjective, though. They design the lens to meet certain technical criteria[1] for minimizing distortion, spherical and chromatic aberration, flare, diffraction, etc. They are optically near perfect. But are they better, really? Better than classic Leica Summicrons, Kodak Ektars, Schneider Xenars, Rodenstock Grandagon-Ns, or a Speed Graphic retrofitted with a 1940s 7" (185mm) Aero Ektar? [1]https://lightartacademy.com/tutorials/defects-in-lenses-all-that-you-need-to-know/ https://lightartacademy.com/tutorials/defects-in-lenses-all-...
- whoisburbansky 6y agoWhat are folks' favorite overviews on how these lenses work? Basic optics from my high school physics classes topped out at the telephoto lens from the article, what would be a good place to start to get a better sense of how the designs in the article help with distortion? [Edit: Found https://www.lensrentals.com/blog/2011/08/lens-geneology-part-1/ https://www.lensrentals.com/blog/2011/08/lens-geneology-part..., which looks like a promising start]
- Matrixik 6y agoRoger Cicala knows a lot about lenses and pushed lens manufacturers to have better testing and quality, he created https://www.lensrentals.com/ https://www.lensrentals.com/ because he got sick with low quality checks of lenses: When I started Lensrentals I had a lot of conversations with service centers that went like this. Me: "That lens you repaired still sucks". Person at service center: "No, it’s within specs". Me: "What are the specs?" Service center: "We can’t tell you". One day, after I raised hell with a factory service manager, he patted me on the head and said, “testing lenses is complicated; you don’t have the background to understand.” Any of you who has ever seen a physician after someone says something like ‘you wouldn't understand; it’s complicated’ knows what happened next. I had no option but to spend a couple of years buying testing equipment, offering internships to really smart optical engineering students, and developing a lens testing center and methodology that was as good as anything in the industry. He is also capable of writing about hard topics in a way that most people can understand them. Anyone interested in camera lenses should read also his previous posts https://www.dpreview.com/members/1329131098 https://www.dpreview.com/members/1329131098
- salimmadjd 6y agoHis lens tests are excellent. The lens rentals blog is the best place to find them [0]. If you're in market for high quality lenses, lens rental blog is a great resource. I also like cameralabs' lens tests [1]. Not as scientific as lensrentals, however, it has real samples and images of charts for comparison, so you can get a sense for what the different resolution means in image resolution. It also tests things beyond resolution. Such as out of focus rendering, coma, sun stars, etc. [0] https://www.lensrentals.com/blog https://www.lensrentals.com/blog [1] https://www.cameralabs.com/camera-lens-reviews/ https://www.cameralabs.com/camera-lens-reviews/
- subhro 6y agoHe does break down technical stuff is average Joe language. But, one this that does tick me off is his lens analysis does not consider larger formats.
- deleted 6y ago
- dukeofdoom 6y agoI have an interchangeable lens camera and multiple lenses. But I usually leave these at home when I travel. Camera prices have gone down so much, you can do amazing things with minimal gear and budget. Minimal size and weight that still gets the job done is mostly my take on this. small specific cameras for the task at hand. I have a very similar to this, and it's very compact and gives me multiple cameras and angles. Sound quality is often more important than video quality anyway. And you can get good video quality by just using a tripod and an external mic like the rode micro. 1. g7x (mark iii) f1.8 lens and canon colors for talking head videos or pictures. Sony equivalent zv1 would be good too. 2. sony fdr3000 for walking around. Wide angle, and natural looking stabilization. or gopro. 3. dji mini drone. The only drone that is legal to fly in many places. 4. phone for everything else 5. Rode video micro (microphone) 6. Small Tripod (Ulanzi MT-16) ________ ~1kg and around 1.5k to put together I actually have more cameras but for Travel I think this is ideal. The only thing I would add is possibly a bridge camera like lumix fz82 or fz1000 for zooming.
- ben7799 6y agoExcellent points, people need to have perspective about high value traditional gear in a lot of cases today. There's a lot of perspective lost on some of this ultra high end handheld digital camera gear these days. A $500-1000 drone can easily be worth $50k worth of ground camera for landscape photography for example because it can erase massive amounts of effort and barriers to getting a shot. The expensive handheld gear can't get the shot period and can be wasted money. I have a DJI Mini and it's a fantastic photo tool, in it's case it weighs less than a DSLR/Mirrorless body. A Smartphone or very light DSLR Body/Lens kit + the drone can outperform a much heavier & more expensive kit for outdoor photography.
- proudfoot 6y agoThis is an excellent interactive primer on basic lens design for anyone interested: https://ciechanow.ski/cameras-and-lenses/ https://ciechanow.ski/cameras-and-lenses/
- dmalvarado 6y agoIt took me a long time but I finally got over the never-ending desire for ever sharper lenses. 50mm is a general purpose lens. Not like macro or super-telephoto. Sharp enough to get the gist of the image without being distractingly blurry is good enough.
- hahamrfunnyguy 6y agoI have the Canon 50mm/f1.8 aka the "Nifty Fifty". Got it a few years ago when it was still under $100. At the time, it was the cheapest prime lens you could but. I really like the photos I get with that lens.
- w0mbat 6y agoThat cheap Canon 50mm lens is great. I use a Canon 5D mk something and carry a 28mm, a 50mm, and a 100mm, all of them ƒ/2.0 or 1.8. For a lot of shots I want the specific look of ƒ/2.0 on a decent prime lens. I don't actually want an aperture wider than that.
- schrijver 6y agoThat really is a great lens. Versatile as well since on a crop camera it’s a useful focal length too. IMHO the difference with the more expensive lenses is more about durability (a fair trade off since they’re cheap) and handling (easier manual focus, distance markings) than image quality.
- lr1970 6y agoThese modern 50mm lenses are certainly marvels of optical engineering. But the future seem to belong to simpler, cheaper and lighter lens designs with optical imperfections corrected digitally. Modern phones take stunning images (in good light) with optically inferior lenses.
- Sebb767 6y agoNot really. Phone cameras have become really good, yes. But that's in well lit conditions on a phone screen. But zoom in and you'll start to see imperfections and noise. Under worse conditions they'll not be worth anything if you want to use that photo. Phones effectively killed the small camera market, but anything on the prosumer level or higher will run circles around them.
- imaginenore 6y agoUntil we have metamaterials to make super flat lenses, smartphones will suck compared to full frame or MF cameras. Especially when it comes to low light performance. Modern mirrorless cameras paired with fast 1.2 lenses basically have night vision. No smartphone comes close.
- micro_cam 6y agoThere are a couple of other big reasons related to differences between film and digital sensors. First film is much less sensitive to the angle at which light strikes it. There are some great, sharp old lens designs from leica, zeiss and others that show heavy light fall off in the corners on digital sensors. This is a big part of why even f1.8 or 2 lenses need to be more complicated. Next film grain itself has sharp edges which effectively sharpens images a bit and also limits the resolution and generally has a pleasing effect when viewed at high magnification. With digital you don't get that and lens flaws get a lot more obvious.
- dmtroyer 6y ago*very high aperture 50mm lenses.
- tristor 6y agoI've never been unhappy with my older Nikon 50mm lenses, and the Zeiss 50mm lenses are fantastic and have been for years. What I'm really happy with on newer lenses is technology like fresnel lens elements that allow us to have compact and light weight telephotos. I have a Nikon 300mm lens that weighs 1/5th of its predecessor (which I also have) and is 1/3 the length and takes better photos. It was well worth the price tag and I greatly appreciate this sort of technical improvement if it allows me to avoid carrying a tripod for birding.
- Badfood 6y agoOver the years I've needed high end gear in a hurry mostly for emergency work after hurricanes or wildfires. I have dealt with all the rental houses in the US and the one the author of this article founded is hands down the best (lens rentals., on) . Its interesting how much effect the founder can have on a business even after its grown large. You can tell if the company exists primarily to fulfill a mission or just as a money making exersize.
- _ph_ 6y agoThere is a multitude of practical reasons. First of all, modern digital sensors offer resolutions far beyond what normal film material would offer. So 35mm cameras easily beat the resolution of classical medium format film. You need lenses to match that resolution. Then there are new requirements like AF and optical image stabilisation. With classical prime lenses, focussing often would move the whole lens forward and backward. Or at least some large lens group. That makes the optical construction easier but prevents fast AF. Modern lens designs would use a rather small lens in the middle for focussing. With the reduced mass, the focus speed goes up. Image stabilization also asks for a small lens or lens group to be moved. But one big difference shouldn't be overlooked either: the abundance of compute power. Today, you can easily simulate a lens system of any complexity. Leica did actually use raytracing to optimize their lenses in the 50ies - but in the absence of computers, they had a room full of people who did the calculations manually. So with a months worth of work, they managed to calculate the path of like 5 rays through their given lens design. Which had like 6 elements. Modern prime lenses can have up to 20 lens elements, zoom lenses up to 30. For a good comparison about different lens design approaches, one should look at Leica lenses. Because Leica both still makes classical manual focus lenses for the M system, which typically have like 5-7 lens elements, and absolutely modern style lenses for their SL system, which have twice or more lens elements. In each design philosophy, they are making some of the best lenses, cost usually not the top priority :). Which makes a good base for comparisons. For example, they quite recently both introduced a new 35f2 lens for the M and the SL mount. Personally, I am quite fond of the prime lenses with few lens elements. While modern glass coatings can pretty much eliminate reflections on glass surfaces, every single glass-air boundary does create reflections. So while the modern designs are technically close to perfect, I think those designs with few lens elements have a special image rendering. Very contrasty, lots of character.
- klodolph 6y agoAs someone who sometimes shoots medium format film, sometimes shoots digital—I am a bit skeptical about claims that digital “easily beat the resolution of classical medium format film”. I shoot with a nice, but old, MF camera and prime lens on a tripod and then do wet prints (usually) or drum scans (rarely). Based on close examination of drum scans, I estimate my setup gives images of around 60-80 megapixels. Knock that down somewhat for color. This is a bit lower than the quoted resolution for the film I use, if you read the spec sheet. Rough comparison of digital vs film leads me to conclude that you can’t just compare the camera resolution against the film scan resolution. Maybe it’s the low-pass filter / Bayer filter, but a film scan will have the same image quality as a raw digital photo of somewhat larger size (say, 50%). So if you take a high-end full-frame digital camera with a 24x36mm sensor, you get 50 megapixels, and my film setup will get you around the same number of pixels when shooting color, but the film scans will be sharper. The film is 4x the area—56x70mm. So it’s close, and I wouldn’t be surprised if a top-of-the-line full-frame digital camera could beat a 645. But 645 is the smallest of the medium format sizes, and digital wouldn’t be beating it by a huge margin. It’s a bit subjective, because the transfer functions for digital and film are so different and there’s no obvious correct way to compare them mathematically. That said, digital will easily win at higher ISOs.
- u678u 6y agoDoes anyone know the margins on these lenses? I'm guessing theyre low volume high markup. I get that they're precision instruments but a few grand for some polished glass seems high.