27 ms·
Amazon knew seller data was used to boost company sales
- LatteLazy 6y agoI keep seeing stories like this that prey on readers' ignorance to push an unfair agenda. Retailers using their data as an advantage to improve sales of own brand products, at the cost of suppliers, is totally standard. It's happening right now in every supermarket (and plenty of other places). Pretending otherwise is silly. Amazon having a policy of not doing that is exemplary. Amazon failing to meet that in one case is amazon meeting it in 99.9999% of cases. But people are very quick to see the devil in amazon while others (Walmart for instance) are much worse and get a free pass...
- spaceribs 6y agoAmazon should be nationalized. All these 3rd party companies want is a "farmers market", a stall to sell their wares. Give them the municipal software infrastructure they need to do so and maintain it as a public good.
- LightG 6y agoIt's a catch-22 ... would Amazon be this innovative had it been nationalised? At what point do you nationalise? Is there a next technology which will be stifled if it was nationalise? Does nationalisation sttifle innovation? I've been wrestling with these questions as I actually don't like Amazon for all the reasons that have been well publicised ... but their customer service is excellent. Which sets me against a string of recent bad experiences with local suppliers, getting stung, and thinking ... well, if Amazon treat me better, why shouldn't I move away from local suppliers and stick with the monopoly? Which goes against a lot I believe in. I guess the problem is it's putting a lot of trust in Amazon. Which is itself an argument for nationalisation. I don't know.
- suprfsat 6y agoJeff Bezos will testify in front of congress that he will cease to be innovative if required to pay taxes.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 6y agoSounds like extortion to me.
- batch12 6y agoHow so? Whether or not amazon innovates should have no bearing on a decision by congress to levy additional taxes against them. If amazon decides to become shittier as a result, someone else can fill that void.
- missedthecue 6y agonot sure which party you're talking about here
- tremon 6y agoDoes this imply he sees his ability to evade taxes as his only worthwhile innovation?
- 8note 6y agoI think it implies that amazon can't both spend everything that would be profit on innovation while also paying the same money on taxes
- sneak 6y agoAmazon pays mountains of payroll taxes, as they are one of the largest employers in the world. The "Amazon pays no taxes" meme is a false one.
- spaceribs 6y agoI think the meme is "Amazon pays no federal taxes on it's profits", and that is a correct statement.
- nerbert 6y agoAmazon the marketplace isn’t terribly innovative. It’s a marketplace supported by fantastic logistics, and most of it is backed by USPS anyways. There’s only so much you can do to remove the pains from buyers, sounds like we’re there.
- smhost 6y ago"Innovation" refers to practices like staying in the red for a decade and bypassing antitrust laws by owning (rather than monopolizing) markets. It has little to do with technological innovation.
- andrepd 6y agoPrecisely. Much of the "innovations" and "efficiencies" touted (by Amazon and by many other players) are actually not any material/physical/technical improvements, but financial games, buying competitors, operating at a loss, regulatory evasion, monopolisation, etc.
- smhost 6y agoI mean, business/financial innovation is a legitimate kind of innovation. I'm not harping on Amazon for that. I just think that discussions about "loss of innovation" smuggle in some irrational fears about loss of technology when there are no real reasons to.
- choward 6y agoRight. I wonder how much competition Amazon has eliminated over the years with their shady business practices. That competition may have driven innovation even further.
- mschuster91 6y ago> It’s a marketplace supported by fantastic logistics, and most of it is backed by USPS anyways. Not any more, USPS was only used for shipping anyway. Amazon has shifted to vertical integration wherever they can - they run everything they can, from air freight (with https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amazon_Air https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amazon_Air) over their infamous warehouses to last-mile delivery with either in-house staff or "contractor" schemes set up to avoid labor regulations.
- 49531 6y ago> Does nationalisation stifle innovation? I would argue that it does not. We have a lot of innovations from the last 100 years that have come from state-run projects / endeavors. The more I think about it the more it looks as though private ownership stifles innovation if there isn't a direct profit motive for it.
- pydry 6y agoBeing a monopoly of any kind stifles innovation. It's often better for the state to react to private monopolies/oligopolies by entering the space and competing with a bare bones service. This has worked in banking, telecoms, land development, housing, etc. It often works better than taking over the monopoly directly. It's one of the reasons (IMHO) Singapore has such an effective private market. Often private companies lobby for laws restricting the level that they can compete - this is a signal that it's an effective tactic. If USPS were given a mandate and the cash it could absolutely build a marketplace that could compete and it would probably kick start Amazon into being a better and cheaper retailer. Unfortunately it's being whittled down to a husk of its former self.
- ceejayoz 6y agoAn apt comparison - most of the farmers’ markets around here have been ruined by resellers, too. No, those Driscoll strawberries in March didn’t come from upstate New York farms.
- Loughla 6y agoSeriously, though. Between reselling and 'owner/operator businesses' (read: pyramid schemes selling oils, scents, candles, and makeup), the local farmer's market is just an absolute train wreck anymore. Local farmers who used to sell at the farmer's market have moved to subscription boxes, from what I can tell.
- syshum 6y agoYea I am going to go ahead and say No to that.... Amazon has issues, but "nationalizing" it would not ease those issues in fact in most ways it would make them worse.
- spaceribs 6y ago> Amazon has issues, but "nationalizing" it would not ease those issues in fact in most ways it would make them worse. Change my mind then? What would be worse in that situation?
- jpxw 6y agoWhen was the last time you used government-run software? Was it a good experience?
- jononomo 6y agoAmtrak is great. I generally like government-run services. Have you tried dealing with your local cable monopoly? It's a nightmare -- why not get the government involved so things work more smoothly and there is more competition?
- amalcon 6y agoLess than a month ago, to sign up for my COVID vaccine. Yes, it was a good experience.
- spaceribs 6y agoYes actually, I recently signed up for my vaccination online via the GoVAX system, was flawless and painless: https://massvax.maryland.gov/ https://massvax.maryland.gov/ I've used plenty of for-profit software that did essentially the same thing but which fell flat on it's face in terms of UI/UX.
- jfrunyon 6y agoAll the time. Yes. I've also had bad experiences with plenty of private companies.
- wolfretcrap 6y agoAmazon is far from only being software atleast in India. They've such a volume here in India that since Amazon has got here, traditional LTL logistics soared in price wayyy higher Amazon has completely revolutionised logistics here in India, you'll have hard time sending a box from point A to point B cheaper than what Amazon offers. We are at a point where Amazon sells things much cheaper shipped to your door than a shop near you. (If you don't live in a metro city highly likely, the price which Amazon offers, local shops simply can't beat them) And in India something like 60-70% people live in small towns and villages, traditional family owned distribution networks are failing to compete with Amazon, yes the ones which power most of the shops in the town. I maintain, the traditional family owned distribution networks were even more exploitative (screwing over both customers and their workers) in India atleast compared to what Amazon offers. Amazon delivery agent here are guys from low economic class and often from villages nearby. I am glad my purchases are helping these people survive than the "several property owning shopkeeper near me" competing with me in the real estate market while simultaneously ripping me off on the price on various tools. Few years ago I was working for such family owned distribution networks and I never seen such miseries in life, truckers were often not paid at time, often driving trucks which hardly get any service (dangerously), the axel could become rocket anytime while on road. Amazon has only brought best practises to us, they've regular vehicle maintenance schedule, drivers get paid on time. Amazon delivery agents are some of the happiest people I've met despite working so hard, they are always smiling while delivering stuff to me. The distribution agents were regularly fired without payment (it's not completely organized sector so lots of labor operate in grey area, where if they don't get paid don't have any legal recourse and most likely no one will believe if they ever worked for the person they are claiming to have rendered their service to. I am glad, the nepotistic and exploitative power nexus of family owned distribution networks is dying. Easy return was never available in India, and you risked getting "death stares" from the shopkeeper if you ever returned anything to him because of quality issues of the product. Other than this, most of the times I had seen "young girls" walking into market and getting "40% discount" by some thristy shopkeeper and they wouldn't do same for a guy ever, atleast this form of descrimination is dying with Amazon. And honestly speaking, if a lot of Amazon executives in Bangalore and Gurgaon are getting rich, it's well deserved for what they've done for the nation. I forgot to mention, we've many Amazon competitors but primarily Flipkart - well, getting them to replace/return anything has been tough for me, maybe because I live in a small town, I don't say but I get all my packages in 2 days from Amazon (without prime), while Flipkart takes 5 days here minimum. What would I like to see Amazon change? 1. Make it possible to sell low value items which cost less than 200 and aggregate it before it's shipped to customer and charge customer shipping on aggregate weight shipped for these small combines. Sometimes it's very difficult when you've to order small items and pay 150-200 shipping on each item. These can be "no return combine", I will not bother returning such low value item, so Amazon saves overhead and additional costs. 2. Please revolutionze hardware space for retail buyers, stuff like "steel sheets, MDF, nail, bolts, nuts" - we don't have any Homedepot or Lowe's, we really need it and my hope is only on Amazon. Other countries like US has Homedepot where u can get most of the hardware fittings while this space is seriously lagging in India, everyone uses different naming for a spare part, etc...we don't even have anything like "McMasterCarr".
- amelius 6y agoStallman said it too: https://stallman.org/amazon.html https://stallman.org/amazon.html > We should not allow a company to have a share over around 10% of any market. If in a certain field a single dominant company is beneficial for society, that means it is a natural monopoly, and should be served by a regulated utility.
- rualca 6y ago> We should not allow a company to have a share over around 10% of any market. If a company was already at said 10% limit and you wanted to buy something out of them because to you their offer is by far so much better than any of the alternatives, in your opinion what should happen?
- alfonsodev 6y agoThe price would regulate itself by offer/demand balance and you would still be able to buy it if you can afford it. With no limits, they can actually create artificial lower prices that competition can’t match, and they become exponentially more powerful and dominating. And sometimes you end up as a customer having less options and lower quality.
- pc86 6y agoPrice dumping is already illegal.
- andrepd 6y agoExplain Uber then :^)
- rualca 6y ago> The price would regulate itself by offer/demand balance and you would still be able to buy it if you can afford it. No, not really. I shopped around. I picked the best for me. I want to buy from that company but it is already at your 10% limit. What then? Can I actually buy what I want?
- jpxw 6y agoFor one, large government software projects are almost always disastrous, even in developed countries. Secondly, that isn’t what sellers want. Many sellers use Amazon to fulfill their orders. Amazon is far more than just a “market stall”.
- rualca 6y ago> Secondly, that isn’t what sellers want. Many sellers use Amazon to fulfill their orders. Amazon is far more than just a “market stall”. This. Amazon is basically a huge logistics network. Their business is not selling you products, whether from their own generic brands, from high-end Veblen goods companies like Apple or from cheap chinese dropship artists. Their business is to process payment, and get that package delivered to your front door. To Amazon, their products is just a way to generate output through their logistics network.
- spaceribs 6y agoBased on the article, the verticality of their business seems to indicate they are not merely in logistics...
- ceejayoz 6y ago> For one, large government software projects are almost always disastrous, even in developed countries. The same tends to be true for large corporate software projects. As a fairly recent example: https://www.theregister.com/2019/04/23/hertz_accenture_lawsuit/ https://www.theregister.com/2019/04/23/hertz_accenture_lawsu...
- logicchains 6y ago>The same tends to be true for large corporate software projects. Yes, but it's not true for Amazon, the topic of conversation.
- ceejayoz 6y agoIsn't the topic of conversation that Amazon's successful software projects have had potentially disastrous side-effects?
- n0us 6y agoIt would be really interesting to see the USPS in the USA open a market like this
- mk89 6y agoI disagree. There are more and more services providing logistics, delivery, payments, etc. And they are quite reliable. Just 2 years ago I was entirely relying on Amazon as a good ecommerce. As of 2020/2021, to be honest, there is nearly no difference with some individual retailers (which don't use a 3rd party platform to sell their goods like Amazon or Ebay). Lots of websites have improved, logistics, delivery, customer service, payments, ..etc etc. They key, in my opinion, was the logistics + delivery. That's what Amazon was exceptionally good at. Now that the infrastructure is nearly the same for everyone, why would you share your profits with Amazon and risk to be out of the business in 1-2 years?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dv_dt 6y agoWhat are the Amazon level logistics and delivery service that is available to a smaller retailer? I see some nascent choices but they really aren’t that close.
- guerrilla 6y agoI agree but there's one practical problem with this: other markets (e.g. the EU) need to nationalize or reproduce it too or else the US is getting significant geopolitical leverage.
- londons_explore 6y agoIf the US nationalized Amazon, I think you can be pretty sure that other countries would also nationalize their local Amazon divisions (ie. Amazon FR would become property of the french government)
- Nasrudith 6y agoWhy would they repeat the US's mistakes immediately after watching it blow up on the US? People have agency and the response to a sudden theft by the government for being too successful would be to get the hell out of there as the US is no longer stable. The other subsidiaries wouldn't surrender ownership to a distant bandit government just like all of the other times it happened. Everybody but communists know that Nationalization is a goddamned terrible idea doomed to failure - you can see it by not being in their political platforms at all. Only those with dogmas to consider the action a goal in itself advocate for it.
- spaceribs 6y agoThe goal is to democratically own ostensibly public infrastructure, do you have a better way instead of whining about communists?
- mellavora 6y agoWe have that in Luxembourg. Problem is finding the site. You have to know it is there.
- batch12 6y agoWhy should the federal government steal Amazon? Surely, it is possible for the government to build another service. I will admit that this is a clever way to kill Amazon. I find the idea of a government running my compute infrastructure to be a terrifyingly bad idea and would seek out someone else. Edit: Replaced AWS with Amazon
- FridayoLeary 6y ago>Give them the municipal software infrastructure they need to do so and maintain it as a public good. oof. Amazons actual website is frankly horrible, but i shudder to think how terrible it would be if it was run by the government. I'm cringing at the thought. There would just be an endless stream of news about gross mismanagement, incompetence, wasting taxpayers money ad nuseaum. No. The only thing that could possibly be worse then Amazon in its current format would be if it were run as a government enterprise. And to the whataboutism; "who says Amazon doesn't have those problems etc, it's different. I don't have to be bothered so much by the internal affairs of a private company. A government company otoh, it would just be all over the news.
- swiley 6y agoNo. As it is I can still go to other sellers if I want to, if Amazon were nationalized then you might not have any other choice.
- whalesalad 6y agoEvery time a business gets this successful someone will inevitably come out of the woodwork and say "the government now needs to own this, there is no other option" - wat?
- Black101 6y agoshould they also nationalize their cloud services?
- jonnycomputer 6y agoOr broken up. Its AWS and its online retail are each sufficiently large enough to be anti-competitive on their own.
- niyikiza 6y agoWhenever someone suggests that something be nationalized, I ask myself "Why not create a public version of it?". If the answer is "it cannot compete with the private ones", maybe that's why running it privately is necessary.
- josefx 6y agoJust look at how well this works out for every town trying to set up its own broadband when Comcast and others fail to invest. Lawsuits raining down for every possible reason, shared public resources blocked for months, misinformation campaigns to convince people that public broadband is a waste of their money and anyone involved in it should be kicked from their office. Its like competing in a five hundred meter sprint if the winner of the last twenty races had a shotgun. His time sucks, but he doesn't need to actually run as long as nobody else makes it to the finishing line.
- Workaccount2 6y agoAmazon doesn't need to be nationalized, it does need to be broken up though. The dividing lines in the organization are so clear you could practically tap it with a hammer and it will fall apart into nice individual pieces.
- aliyfarah 6y agoAgreed 100%. Should be merged with UPS. I also believe NBA should be nationalised. All teams should be owned by cities and revenues used to fund schools etc
- sumedh 6y agoCant Costco, Walmart also do the same thing, why is Amazon being singled out here?
- wolfretcrap 6y agoThey already do. And anyone selling through any platform where they've all data let it be supermarket chain or e-commerce platform, should understand the risk that their data can be used to compete with them if you realize risk is not worth pay off, prefer selling on own website - it's not hard these days. No I mean, yes it's still hard to get eyeballs on your product but to list in Amazon, you need to pay Amazon tax.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 6y agoDifference is that sellers have options because none of these are monopolies. It's not abusing your size at that scale and thus not antitrust. The same rules don't apply to everyone because not everyone owns an entire market.
- sct202 6y agoThe difference is that Amazon said they don't use third party data to boost their own sales. In traditional retailers like Costco, if you are a product maker and supply Costco, you don't own any data from the sale of the product--Costco owns that data. In fact, you will have to pay for that data from data brokers (Retail Solutions Inc for example) if you want it.
- namdnay 6y agoLike every supermarket chain in the world?
- choward 6y agoWhat stores are you going to that have third party sellers? A better analogy is a mall.
- Moeancurly 6y agoSee: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slotting_fee https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slotting_fee
- count 6y agoNearly every grocery store in the US has third party sellers. They pay the store for shelf space, provide their own stockers, etc. It's not as different as you'd believe, because you've 'heard' of the brand names doing it.
- namdnay 6y agoI guess the best analogy would be a department store with third party stands as well as their own label stuff
- fnord77 6y ago"we have a policy against this, but we violate it all the time"
- fmajid 6y ago“I am shocked, shocked, that gambling is going on in here.”
- LatteLazy 6y ago2nd sentence in the article: >“I can’t guarantee you that that policy has never been violated,” 4th sentence in the article: >identifying one case in which an employee used the access to improve sales. So only violated once...
- ErikVandeWater 6y agoIs there a maxim for this? When a group of people are highly incentivized to do something bad, they'll conspire to do something bad. Don't call me a conspiracy theorist.
- cblconfederate 6y agoIt's basically Murphy's law
- gdulli 6y agoHuman nature
- kishinmanglani 6y agoLiterally every retailer ever does this. From Macy’s to Target to Walmart to Shoprite
- libertine 6y agoDoesn't make it right though. Every brand must estimate their competitors market shares, sales volumes, media spend, and actively track promotional activity - while retailers have a massive slice of this information, namely Amazon. Not only that they control their own "shelves". In my point of view they shouldn't be allowed to compete if they are using competitors data without their consent... and that's the catch, it's Amazon data as well, so the only solution is: either Amazon is a market place or a retailer.
- mk89 6y agoWell, it's something that is slowly backfiring. It's under the eyes of everyone, and not enforcing such policy will only make it even worse for Amazon itself that eventually will end up selling only non-branded products. Finally it will be only another e-commerce like "ebay" used to be, and something else will replace it. Just enjoy the ride until you can. PS: speaking out of experience, I had one time a talk to a director from an important online shop (top 3 in the country in that specific field) and "this sort of things" was exactly the reason why they chose to use MS Azure instead of AWS. Imagine how deep it can go. And I totally support that. PPS: I don't understand the downvote. Please, be specific on why you disagree instead of just clicking on random symbols.
- ahiknsr 6y ago> I had one time a talk to a director from an important online shop (top 3 in the country in that specific field) and "this sort of things" was exactly the reason why they chose to use MS Azure instead of AWS. Imagine how deep it can go This seems to be very common. https://www.forbes.com/sites/bobevans1/2018/07/18/walmart-cio-we-picked-microsoft-for-huge-cloud-deal-to-accelerate-digital-transformation/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/bobevans1/2018/07/18/walmart-ci...
- nova22033 6y agoAmazon is a direct competitor so it makes sense for Walmart to not give them more money via AWS.
- freeone3000 6y agoEveryone in retail is a direct competitor to Amazon. It makes sense for anyone with a physical storefront to avoid AWS.
- anotha1 6y agoUpvoted, but I disagree that it's backfiring. Backfiring would imply things are changing or getting worse for them. And I'm certain that we're not at "peak Amazon." Worse, Americans especially are becoming numb to top down abuses. Not only am I worrying that this is not backfiring, but I'm also worried about the precedent we're setting by being so tolerant to it.
- chuii123 6y agohttps://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploads/sites/113/formidable/4/BRAWLSTARS-hack-generators-no-survey-gangang.pdf https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploa... https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploads/sites/113/formidable/4/free-BRAWLSTARS-hackhack-gems-generator.pdf https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploa... https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploads/sites/113/formidable/4/free-gardenscapes-hack-2020-dying-die-gems.pdf https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploa... https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploads/sites/113/formidable/4/free-GENSHIN-crystals-generator-tool-legit-bugs.pdf https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploa... https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploads/sites/113/formidable/4/free-homescapes-deym-good-generator-hack-only-work.pdf https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploa... https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploads/sites/113/formidable/4/gardenscapes-free-generator-gang-love.pdf https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploa... https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploads/sites/113/formidable/4/genshin-impact-crystals-generator-tool-online-2021.pdf https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploa... https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploads/sites/113/formidable/4/homescapes-free-generator-hack-hack-2021.pdf https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploa...
- chuii123 6y ago<a href="https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploads/sites/113/formidable/4/BRAWLSTARS-hack-generators-no-survey-gangang.pdf">free https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploa... rbx</a> <a href="https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploads/sites/113/formidable/4/free-BRAWLSTARS-hackhack-gems-generator.pdf">free https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploa... rbx</a> <a href="https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploads/sites/113/formidable/4/free-gardenscapes-hack-2020-dying-die-gems.pdf">free https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploa... rbx</a> <a href="https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploads/sites/113/formidable/4/free-GENSHIN-crystals-generator-tool-legit-bugs.pdf">free https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploa... rbx</a> <a href="https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploads/sites/113/formidable/4/free-homescapes-deym-good-generator-hack-only-work.pdf">free https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploa... rbx</a> <a href="https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploads/sites/113/formidable/4/gardenscapes-free-generator-gang-love.pdf">free https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploa... rbx</a> <a href="https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploads/sites/113/formidable/4/genshin-impact-crystals-generator-tool-online-2021.pdf">free https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploa... rbx</a> <a href="https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploads/sites/113/formidable/4/homescapes-free-generator-hack-hack-2021.pdf">free https://mays.tamu.edu/humana-tamu-analytics/wp-content/uploa... rbx</a>
- jorgenveisdal 6y agoI wrote about this a while back: https://medium.com/blue-poles/how-amazon-screws-third-party-sellers-a-five-step-guide-8ed6f3c3c113 https://medium.com/blue-poles/how-amazon-screws-third-party-...
- varispeed 6y agoAmazon should be split into separate independent companies - logistics, AWS, marketplace and whatever else they do now. We need laws that will limit growth of companies to become too big to fail and have all the money to buy laws, destroy competition and in general do as they please without consequences. It's a loophole in capitalism that has to be closed. Big businesses should follow the same rules as your mom and pops company. If small business often pay over 40% in various taxes, the same level of taxes should apply to big companies. Nice start would be looking into avoidance schemes big companies use and make them pay all they have avoided over the years. Use that money to lower the tax for small business and continue until the playing field is level.
- ch4s3 6y ago> too big to fail How is Amazon "too big to fail" in your opinion? That phrase "I think they're too large", it means that a business is so central to the functioning on the broader economy and to several other industries that their failure would tank the whole economy. Think Boeing or JP Morgan Chase Bank. > and have all the money to buy laws, What exact laws has Amazon bought?
- varispeed 6y ago- Well, imagine what would have happened if AWS closed overnight. It would not only affect the economy, but also governments that run their infrastructure on AWS. - What I meant by that is also the money can ensure that new laws are not introduced, or investigations not carried out. Have you seen reports of Amazon Basics, where they ask sellers to hand over their leads and then months later Amazon introduces pretty much the same product undercutting the seller? I would imagine if that was done by a small company, they would have been closed down. Yet when you are big, anything goes.
- ch4s3 6y ago> Well, imagine what would have happened if AWS closed overnight What are the circumstances under which the switch is hypothetically turned off at every AWS data center all at once? It just doesn't seem like a realistic scenario. Most ways in which Amazon could fail would involve either a bankruptcy spinning out aws into one or more holdings, or years of decline where people switch off of AWS anyway. Sure, if all of those data centers blew up, then yes it would be catastrophic for a few months. > What I meant by that is also the money can ensure that new laws are not introduced, or investigations not carried out I see where you're coming from, but it seem a little thin and unspecific. The Amazon Basics thing seems like a bad example. It's the same model grocery stores, Walmart, Lowes, and department stores have used for decades. And no one ever really complained before. In some cases Amazon is white labeling products from the brands they're now competing with. So those companies still capture a lot of the revenue.
- bsch 6y agoI'm a third party seller and I just left Amazon. When you buy a book, for example, are you aware that 40% of the sale goes to Amazon? Many sellers sell cheap items at a steep loss just to keep their sale metrics up. A couple bad reviews, etc. and your business is kicked off with little explanation and cold or no way to appeal. Third party sellers are not treated well and I'm not surprised Amazon steals seller data metrics
- TheCapn 6y ago>A couple bad reviews, etc. and your business is kicked off with little explanation There's got to be a dark underbelly to Amazon going on at the same time. My wife is bored enough that she's taken up a fight with Amazon over some bluetooth earbuds she returned. The earbuds themselves just simply didn't work; they'd do things they're not supposed to and not things they are supposed to so she posted a review saying such. The seller started contacting my wife trying to bribe her to change her review to 5 stars. My wife updated the review as such saying the seller is trying to coerce her to change her review but she won't budge. Amazon has now removed my wife's review saying she's "harassing" the seller despite having emails to prove the seller is the one who won't stop contacting her even though she's explicitly requested such. So my wife is battling Amazon asking them to re-instate the review or give her a real reason why it was removed. It really is to the point where I won't buy from Amazon anymore unless I have no other choice. I don't trust a single thing about their review system. I don't trust a lot of products being unopened/untampered.
- BlueTemplar 6y agoYeah, as another perhaps anecdotal example, I've recently been forced to buy a book from Amazon because I literally couldn't find it anywhere else. Despite the book being listed as "New", I received a book that was not only pretty old, but also had clearly been stolen from a library, with stamp marks and everything. I'm not going to leave this alone, contacting the library and exposing this fraud is going to go pretty high on my pile of "to do" things...
- cwkoss 6y agoAmazon has structured their reviews to enable unethical behavior by sellers. Any review which comments on the seller or seller's behavior is removed because the product page is supposed to be a page of seller-agnostic reviews of the product. There is a separate page of reviews for each seller, but it is buried to the point that no-one looks at it. It makes it leaving reviews about sellers doing unethical things like paying for reviews fruitless: either you put it on the product and it is removed quickly, or you put it on the seller and no one sees it.
- cblconfederate 6y agoI am constantly amazed by the level of trust that people give to tech companies. how did they earn this
- mschuetz 6y agoIt's just a lack of viable alternatives.
- pas 6y agoA trustless (eco)systems is usually not efficient. So the cost-benefit analysis points to almost-blindly trusting Amazon, reap as much of the benefits as you can. And don't be surprised when it turns out that Amazon abused/exploited your trust.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Gasparila 6y agoThought exercise because I legitimately struggle with this. Is this fundamentally different than Costco using sales data to choose which Kirkland products to launch/sell? If so, how? If not, then why do we not pursue Costco with the same gusto as Amazon? To me this behavior by Amazon seems worse, but I can't figure out why.
- poidos 6y agoI'm not sure if it's fundamentally different, but maybe you're just (like I am) more inclined to perceive Amazon as a "bad" company. Costco has a lot of goodwill with the public.
- MengerSponge 6y agoImagine if a Costco sales rep offered to swap something in your cart with the Kirkland clone, or if they suggested the Kirkland product as you reached to grab something else off the shelf.
- notyourwork 6y agoAre businesses in the business of increasing efficiencies (more revenue, more profit, lower costs) or are they in the business of doing what is in the best interest of consumers or both? I don't think your example really holds weight. I goto Costco because they offer products I want at a price I like. If during shopping they were trying to give suggestions to better deals I'm not sure as a consumer I get to complain about it do I?
- cptskippy 6y agoI've never had amazon offer to swap anything from my cart.
- tylerrobinson 6y agoAren't traditional grocery stores doing the same thing but using price, sales, positioning, name, and label imitation? When I reach for Quaker Oatmeal Squares, and Wholesome Oatmeal Squares Cereal is right next to it, for cheaper, also in a blue box?
- bruhhh 6y agoof course they knew! They also know about all the FAKE REVIEWS that infested Amazon, and they're not doing anything about it because it boosts sales. Not only that, but I got banned from reviewing on Amazon after I posted a review that the product's reviews are probably fake (after checking on fakespot and receiving a trashy product).
- murphy1312 6y agoare there no antitrust laws in the US, so that amazon could be split into marketplace, own products and aws? Thats what should have been done long ago and no need to stop at amazon either.
- downrightmike 6y agoThey literally covered this in the book the everything store by Brad Stone. This is their game play. This is how they take over categories. Let over people to the sales and testing, then rip them off and undercut them.
- annoyingnoob 6y agoSeems like all big retailers do this. I know that Home Depot's HDX brand copies products, and you are more likely to find HDX in stock than the products it competes with.
- gok 6y agoLots of comments here of the format "every store does this." No, no other store operates this way. Walmart and Costco do not have a little flea market of third party sellers inside their stores who run their own logistics. This would be more like Amazon being both an anchor tenant and owner of a mall, and requiring that every other store within the mall provide all their sales information, then rapidly evicting all the successful stores and replacing them with knock off stores that they also own.
- Black101 6y ago> Walmart and Costco do not have a little flea market of third party sellers inside their stores walmart.com does
- gok 6y agoThat is true, I picked a bad example, although Walmart Marketplace is a very high touch service which is expressly targeting sellers that they don't want to cover themselves.
- Black101 6y agoI have some good native Indian aromatherapy products... what category do you think it would fall under?
- citrusybread 6y agoisn't this effectively how home depot and lowes are run? basically everything is on consignment, and they occasionally spin up private-label versions of tools to sell?
- kazamaloo 6y agoNot the same thing. Check out other relevant responses here, too. In short, Home Depot or Lowe's are buying products to resell. They are the seller themselves. OP's argument is that Amazon is the platform facilitating the sale -- hence the mall owner.
- darksaints 6y agoEvery single discussion around this revolves around the same facile comparison with retailers, and I'm fucking sick of it, so I'll lay it out in a top level comment one last time. These are the following ways in which Amazon is not like a (WalMart, Costco, insert retailer of choice): * Physical retailers do not have access to the same breadth and depth of data that Amazon does. For example, retailers have no reasonable nor accurate methods of determining which advertising methods bring in the most leads. They have no idea how many people look at the product without buying it. They have no idea who puts in their cart and then lets it sit there for days on end. They have no idea who puts an item into their wishlist. They have no idea which people look at it, then come back a week later and buy it. They have no idea how many competing items, let alone which ones, the buyer compared it with before buying. They can't calculate conversion rates, nor satisfaction rates. Maybe if they're lucky, they can track returns down to the purchaser (because they might require a receipt to return), but they likely don't know much about who you are or why you're returning it. * Retailers can't notice you looked at a product without buying it, then follow you around to your bank, your barber, your job, your home, relentlessly trying to convince you to buy it. * Retailers can't look at your general preferences across thousands of unrelated products, perform machine learning methods to determine your likelihood of conversion for different brands and products, and then rearrange their shelves specifically for you to optimize visibility of their products for maximum profitability. * Perhaps most importantly, retailers always have an incentive to sell their inventory. They buy it, they invest labor into presenting it, they pay holding costs to keep it in stock, they relentlessly optimize within difficult physical constraints to provide visibility to its location on the shelves, and they advertise its existence to the public. Amazon has none of these costs or incentives. If they decide to tank the listing of a competing item, they bear no cost in doing so. They are being paid for every single cost incurred, and they're making money off your stuff in FBA even when it doesn't sell. Even pure consignment stores will regularly decline to consign products that they don't think they can sell or don't think they can make enough money on to cover their costs. Amazon has no such incentive. Does Procter and Gamble hate the fact that Costco can position Kirkland Signature right next to their products? Of course they do...but they still sell their product. The same can't be said for many private sellers of niche products when Amazon launches an Amazon Basics competitor. Their listings get tanked, their recommendations disappear, their sales effectively drop to zero almost overnight, and if they made the bad decision to use FBA, they're stuck paying holding costs and eventually shipback or disposal costs in order to exit the market. Amazon is uniquely positioned to take advantage of marketplace data in ways that retailers could never feasibly do, and they bear no costs (and may even augment their profits) when they put their merchants out of business. They absolutely need to have their marketplace either shut down or completely separated from their retail space by legally regulated means.
- bogwog 6y agoIsn't it sad that all our tech giants are guilty of anti-competitive behavior? You know, things that are supposedly illegal and should have been stopped by government regulators long ago? It makes me wonder if these American businesses are really so different from the likes of Tencent, Huawei, etc and their ties to the Chinese government. Everyone knows those companies are only as big as they are because of government support. Can you really say that isn't the case with Google, Apple, Microsoft, Amazon, Facebook, etc?
- president 6y agoThey are getting there. Don't forget censorship and silencing unfavorable political speech.
- droopyEyelids 6y agoI think the difference is that FAANG's regulatory capture isn't an explicit part of how our government works, it's implicit.
- ecommerceguy 6y agoWe also use Amazon data to find/develop products to sell. I assume all sellers do.
- nataz 6y agoThe most interesting part of the HN discussion is not about the definition of what Amazon is doing, but the occasional misunderstanding of how large brick and mortar retail businesses operate at scale (see: buying shelf space/payment dependant on sales/etc). There are lots of folks on here that understand what Amazon is doing, less who understand retail businesses mechanisms. I'm not sure what Amazon is doing is legal (def will vary widely between the eu and us markets), but it is another interesting example of how doing something at scale can be perceived as fundamentally different then when it's done in a smaller way (especially as it pertains to privacy).
- addicted 6y agoIt's less doing it at "scale" and more doing it as a monopoly/monopsony. Walmart has faced similar questions as well, but as much of a monopoly/monopsony as Walmart is, it's far less than what Amazon is. Moreso in non US advanced countries that actually enforce the anti trust regulations in their laws.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- TameAntelope 6y agoIn what market is Amazon a monopoly?
- dahfizz 6y agoBeing strict about the term, none. But "monopoly" has become a colloquialism for "big company (that I don't like)". Amazon has certainly generated enough bad faith and operates at a large enough scale to galvanize the anti-trust advocates
- kempbellt 6y agoThey are popular, efficient, and usually affordable - if not cheaper than many competing outlets, but I do not see them as a monopoly by definition. Amazon has made it more convenient to use their services than their competition in many ways, but to my understanding, there are alternatives for just about everything they offer.
- m1117 6y agoNews love making their headlines in a way that people get angry.
- salawat 6y agoYou can't square access to "aggregate sales data" of inventories that are not yours with having a policy not to use third-party sellers info for personal/internal sales gains. In this case Amazon went from being a decent host and service provider to a malicious, unfair competitor. Either they divest themselves from being an active participant in their marketplace, or they put out their eyes and sequester Third-Party sales and transaction records into a bin to never get looked at except for reports to third-party sellers themselves. That's about the only way I can see for Amazon to ethically move forward.
- cowpig 6y agoCan we just rule that internet marketplaces cannot offer competing products on their own platforms? The fundamental conflicts of interest will always persist otherwise. This is going to sound radical but I think Google Search should be broken away from everything else and/or Google products should not be accessible via the search page (or allowed to buy ad space)
- neolog 6y agoIf you make something and sell it in a store, does that mean you're not allowed to sell other people's products in your store?
- cowpig 6y agoA store is bound to a physical location, whereas online platforms seem to tend toward monopoly
- idiotsecant 6y agoShould walmart be able to produce and offer generic versions of brand name items on their shelves? Why or why not?
- cowpig 6y agoI don't think they're similar. There are many stores in my neighborhood, but there's only one google, only one app store on my phone, and only one Amazon. I also think the degree to which the platform can exploit data related to producers (and consumers) is totally different with online marketplaces.
- google234123 6y agoOne Amazon? There many competing sites on the internet.
- bhupy 6y agoYou're correct that they're probably not similar, but they are different in ways that undercuts your original argument. There are almost certainly more than one search engine (Bing, DuckDuckGo) and more than one online retail platform (Shopify, Walmart.com, eBay). But unlike physical businesses, they are literally "just a click away"; whereas in the real world, you'd have to schlep to the physical location of the competing store. Moreover, the barrier to entry to actually spinning up an online retail platform is much much lower than spinning up a brick-and-mortar location (permits, employed labor per location, rent/property costs). Finally, the theoretical reach once you spin up an online retail platform is infinite; whereas one has to go through all of the aforementioned brick-and-mortar barriers for every incremental customer in the world... IMO, the concept of abolishing generic store brands strikes me as fundamentally hostile to the poor. The other day I was at a Walgreen's picking up some Neosporin ointment, and I found the Walgreen's store brand right next to at half the price. I'm privileged enough to be able to afford the name-brand Neosporin without having to think about it, but I fully appreciate that there are a lot of people that are grateful that the store brand exists. I'm sure Johnson & Johnson would love for the government to prevent Walgreen's from selling its cheaper store brand, but I'm skeptical that this would be good for anybody except Johnson & Johnson. Likewise, Amazon provides "generic" versions of commodity products. Insofar as it's difficult to compete with Amazon, it's because it's generally difficult to run sustainable businesses solely on the back of commodity products.
- xmly 6y agoWhy Shopify does not do the same thing?
- judge2020 6y agoShopify.com isn't a marketplace that millions of customers directly visit. They make enough money as-is.
- zizee 6y agoDoes this practice extend beyond retail? Do AWS product managers look at AWS usage data of their customers sass products to decide whether it's worth launching a competing service?
- gsibble 6y agoUsually if the answer could be evil, with Amazon it is. I'm sure GCP does the same. Gotta love how AWS/GCP terminate your https and can read all of your api traffic.......
- hdanirwin 6y agoWhy does this surprise anyone? What company would do anything different? This is why I’ve never made selling on Amazon anything more than a side-hustle. You’re just a pawn, totally at someone else’s mercy, and if you are too successful you’re bound to be eaten by a bigger fish who knows how your sausage is made.