18 ms·
What is Chia cryptocurrency and why is it bad news for hard drives?
- i_have_an_idea 6y agoI hold no Chia or crypto at all, however, from what I am seeing around me, Chia is going to be really, really big.
- gruez 6y agoFrom people hoping to mine and then immediately sell it, or from people who are planning on buying and holding?
- i_have_an_idea 6y agoI don't know what their plans are. Just from the amount of buzz I'm hearing around me. Reminds me of the early days of Ethereum.
- Hjfrf 6y agoWe can always hope that trading Chia is made illegal, along with proof of work algorithm based currencies in general. Governments so-far failing to regulate existential threats to themselves is honestly odd.
- gruez 6y ago>Governments so-far failing to regulate existential threats to themselves is honestly odd. Is it the job of the government to hang onto power at all costs?
- rocqua 6y agoIt is, sort off, the inherent goal of a (nation-)state. At least, that is a common and rather accurate historical and geopolitical model.
- arcticbull 6y agoOfficially, no, but it is an emergent property of their other responsibilities. For instance, a government cannot maintain law and order without power, and a society without law and order is the definition of a failed state ([edit] well, more specifically one in which the government has lost its monopoly on violence). It's not an unreasonable interpretation to therefore say any non-failed state must retain power.
- christiansakai 6y agoBank bailouts in 2008 justified? Save the rich, screw the poor and the middle class. At least the society is peaceful.
- arcticbull 6y agoMmm not to me no, I believe in a capitalist system that lets losers lose. However the argument was ordinary folks would pay.
- gverrilla 6y agomaybe it's not the job, but it's the nature of governments
- CharlesW 6y agoChia is not Proof of Work, FWIW. Their technical and business whitepapers are helpful resources for learning more about what they call "Proof of Space and Time".
- i_have_an_idea 6y agoWe can hope, but, if you're going to need hard drives in the foreseeable future, you might want to go buy them now.
- atat7024 6y ago> Governments so-far failing to regulate existential threats to themselves is honestly odd. Factions within governments all around the world are using it to their own ends.
- christiansakai 6y agoWhy?
- i_have_an_idea 6y agoJust the amount of buzz and interest I'm hearing. One data point (which is the only one I can share without revealing personal info on this public site) is that my local hardware store sold out of 8TB+ HDD drives and, according to the employee there, that hasn't happened in many years.
- theshadowknows 6y agoI asked this recently but the topic died before I got many answers. Basically, I’m not a cryptocurrency denier. I just don’t understand it. Do people want cryptocurrency because they want to spend it on stuff? Or do they want cryptocurrency because they want to sell it for other currencies? In other words, at what point will a cryptocurrency stand on its own as something that’s worth a pair of shoes? Instead of being something that people invest in to eventually sell for dollars with which they they buy shoes? Again- I know I just don’t understand. My original question: 1 point by theshadowknows 4 days ago | parent [–] | on: The Last Days of Satoshi: What Happened When Bitco... Bitcoin and other crypto/alt currencies are so interesting to me. Partly because I do not understand them: If I mow your lawn and you pay me in the locally accepted fiat then I can use that fiat to buy hotdogs and fuel for my lawn mower because the gas station itself will accept that fiat. The gas station will accept that fiat because its vendors, creditors, and employees also accept it. And the chain goes on. If however I mow your lawn and you pay me in bitcoin I'll need to find a gas station that accepts it. Many likely exist. But, how many of their vendors, creditors, and employees also accept it? Some, no doubt, but I'd wager not all would. So, even though these currencies no doubt represent massive potential they're still somewhat limited in terms of adoption. Obviously this is becoming less true over time which I think is a good thing - competition isn't something fiat currencies tend to have to deal with, but they sure could use it. My real misunderstanding is 'why' people accept these currencies in the first place. In other words - people accept a United States dollar because it is worth one United States dollar. However, it seems that most people accept bitcoin (or bitcoin fragments) not because they are worth some percentage of bitcoin but exactly because they are worth some amount of United States dollars. Is that true? Is the primary reason that bitcoin has become more popular that an investor can spend 10,000 fiat on it - wait a year - and then extract 15,000 fiat from it?
- matkoniecz 6y ago> Is the primary reason that bitcoin has become more popular that an investor can spend 10,000 fiat on it - wait a year - and then extract 15,000 fiat from it? It seems to be true.
- joecool1029 6y ago> Do people want cryptocurrency because they want to spend it on stuff? Some of us did. Last month marks 10 years since I was introduced to the community and registered on the bitcoin-otc. We bought and sold all sorts of random crap (food items, laptops, gadgets, one regular even paid people bitcoin to have them buy him lunch. A brief time existed where some of the more idealists expected bitcoin to replace Paypal. That obviously didn't happen. Starting with Satoshidice gambling the network performance started to crap up and fees began to climb. Eventually it became worthless for any sort of fast/cheap transacting and everything centralized onto a few exchanges. Every asshole in the world has proposed ways to improve this issue, but with all the money sunk into bitcoin and a lot of arguments we aren't in a better situation today. Now every naive person from 20-some year olds to 70-year olds are hitting me up and asking what I think of NFT's and the shitcoin of the week because they saw some heads on Bloomberg gushing over it and I'm just tired of it all.
- m00dy 6y agoDo they have a benchmark for how many tps that Chia can handle ?
- CharlesW 6y agoBram Cohen has been quoted as estimating ~20 TPS at Layer 1.
- arcticbull 6y agoGreat, now nobody's going to have CI so we can get 3TPS on BTC, nobody's going to have GPUs so we can get 12TPS on ETH and now nobody's going to have SSDs so we can have 20TPS on Chia. The future is now.
- rovr138 6y agoJust bought a new Synology NAS this week and started putting together disks and they're scarce and the prices are through the roof. Couldn't find what I was planning on buying. What I found was through the roof. I bit the bullet and bought 4 new ones. Not enough to fully populate the NAS, but at least it'll give me some space for now to do what I need. We've seen scarcity and what it does for prices after the flooding in.. 2010?(ish).
- Tepix 6y agoDid you look at large external USB hard drives' prices?
- rovr138 6y agoI did. I basically ended up getting external seagates that I’m planning to schuck after doing a ‘burn-in’ test. Still high for what they were.
- MrFoof 6y agoI just did some NAS upgrades a month ago and feel as if I dodged a bullet. I'm curious what you ended up paying. I bought drives on sale, and got nine 16TB external drives to shuck (one is a spare) for ~$2250 USD taxed and shipped. I will warn you though that burn-in testing is going to take a while. I did a very exhaustive test[1]... and two drives at a time over USB3 it took about twelve calendar days to test them all before I put them into service. -- ----- ----- ----- ----- [1] Write out block pattern, read back. 2 hour break. Head thrash random writes/reads for 2 hours. 2 hour break. Head thrash random writes/reads for 2 hours.
- rovr138 6y ago$399.99 for 14TB seagate expansion ones. Still waiting for them to arrive. Everything else cheaper I found was out of stock. NAS has 6 bays, I only bought 4 to get a RAID 6 setup and I'll expand when I find better prices. If anyone has links, I'll take them!
- mrfusion 6y agoCan anyone explain the algorithm a bit?
- joecool1029 6y agoHere's the whitepaper: https://eprint.iacr.org/2017/893.pdf https://eprint.iacr.org/2017/893.pdf Unfortunately, it's a lot harder to follow than Satoshi's at least for me.
- Igelau 6y agoField Notes, Terran Expedition 6, Chief Archivist Blaxarll: "Terran life took a sudden dramatic shift after the fall of Hominid dominance. The turning point appears to have occured when the sacrificial demands of Blockchain worship spiraled out of control after fuel-based offerings were supplanted by info storage based offerings. This, in and of itself, was not terribly harmful, but the model was used by the Cult of Aquaricoin. The so-called Water Miners enshrined a marketplace for non-fungible indulgences depicting popular figures. This was backed by a Proof of Potable Water algorithmic catechism, and swiftly resulted in total extinction for the species. It is this researcher's opinion that we are fortunate the Terran Hominids had only just discovered space travel, for they very well could have extinguished the resources of our own homeworlds for such religious decadence."
- rektide 6y agothis is one of the best things i have ever read thank you
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- surround 6y agoIt took me a while to actually understand how proof-of-work mining works because seemingly every article one the subject gives too abstract of an explanation. Turns out it's not that complex if you understand what a cryptographic hash is. Just take a block (a list of recent transactions) and take a SHA-256 hash if it over and over with slight variations until you get a hash that starts with enough consecutive zeroes. I'm having the same issue with understanding proof-of-space. Could someone give a technical explanation for those of us that understand basic cryptography (but aren't professional cryptographists)?
- wmf 6y agoThere are multiple flavors of proof of space and they seem to be based on quite complex math to the extent that a simple explanation may not be possible.
- maks25 6y agoI don’t think I have ever heard of proof of space, is it the same as proof of stake?
- warkdarrior 6y agoCompletely different things. In Proof of Stake, the network (roughly!) allocates rewards for validating transactions based on the amount of coins you have, i.e., your stake in the network. In Proof of Space, the network allocates rewards based on you proving that you are really storing the data you were supposed to store. If you fail to produce a proof for some data item the network expected you to have stored, you lose the reward. More info: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proof_of_space https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proof_of_space https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proof_of_stake https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proof_of_stake
- Dylan16807 6y ago> In Proof of Space, the network allocates rewards based on you proving that you are really storing the data you were supposed to store. Sort of? But you're usually not really storing data for proof of space. That's a different kind of system.
- Havoc 6y agoI can see Eth existing in 10 years time. I can't see Chia existing in 10 years time. Crypto verse in general feels like a 50/50 bet...but the storage based stuff feels like significantly worse odds
- gverrilla 6y agowhy u think that? curious
- lousken 6y agooh great, another item that will be impossible to buy soon thanks, miners the sooner someone introduces the law to ban all proof of work crypto, the better - or at least banning companies from taking or using PoW crypto would be a good start
- spaginal 6y agoYou are right, hard drives should only be available to mega international corporations like Google and Facebook to make money off of.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- arcticbull 6y agoThe India model is right -- give people 6 months to sell off their assets and make it illegal.
- ChrisClark 6y agoWhy would Chia be the threat here? Filecoin(IPFS) is already a threat, it already has a capacity of 4.81 EiB of data, 4810 PetiBytes! (Is that how you spell it? In contrast to Petabytes) And to store 1 GiB of data per year it only costs the user $0.00082 USD. That shows harddrives are already being gobbled up by miners at an incredible rate. Has this made a noticeable rise in storage prices? Anyone know of any data that can show that?
- Dylan16807 6y ago> And to store 1 GiB of data per year it only costs the user $0.00082 USD. How can filecoin possibly be that cheap? Providers like B2 and wasabi are 6-7 cents. Sia spent a while in the single digits is currently around 10. This is less than a tenth of a cent?
- wmf 6y agoI think Filecoin miners are currently being heavily subsidized by mining rewards so they don't need to make a profit on storing data. At those prices, I wonder if storing data is more trouble than it's worth.
- john_minsk 6y agoWhat is this space used for? Generally curious
- KingMachiavelli 6y agoSupposedly Filecoin is storing 'real' data, so it's not using any more storage than AWS or any cloud provider would. Is that not the case? At this point I wouldn't be surprised if the the number of 'real' data stored was only a fraction of the total network size. Chia is just storing 100% useless data outside of its use by Chia itself. i.e Filecoin's and similar coins should have value directly tied to their use to store data while Chia is just another crypto that has no 'intrinsic' value outside its use as a currency and computation platform.
- MrFoof 6y ago>Filecoin(IPFS) is already a threat, it already has a capacity of 4.81 EiB of data, 4810 PetiBytes! (Is that how you spell it? In contrast to Petabytes) 4.81EiB is ~5.54EB. Filecoin has been around for ~81.5 months. That's an average growth rate of only ~68PB/month, but we can of course assume that the current growth rate is higher. For example, last year there was a period where it grew 250PB in a month. Chiacoin has supposedly added ~200PB to its mainnet in the past 24 hours. That growth rate is also still climbing. Seagate has been quoted as having an current HDD manufacturing capacity of ~350EB per year. The general assumption is that between Seagate, Western Digital and Toshiba there's likely a total manufacturing capacity of close to 1000EB a year. Of that 1000EB, a large percentage goes to OEMs and SIs, another large percentage goes to direct customers (Alibaba, Amazon, Apple, Facebook, Google, Microsoft, etc.), and the remainder goes into the sales channel (retail, VARs, etc.). OEMs, SIs and direct customers have contracted supply and pricing, whereas the sales channels do not. Channel is likely 30-40% of current production volume. So that's 300-400EB a year of capacity across all manufacturers going into the sales channel where end users can buy from. -- ----- ----- ----- At 0.2EB/day of growth, that is 18-24% of all channel volume being consumed just by new Chia farm plots. At that rate, that'll cause channel supply issues very, very soon for certain. Once channel supply becomes exhausted, prices will rise since the demand is there. The issue is... what ends up happening to the sustained growth rate? If it were to reach something like 1.0EB/day in growth, that is basically all of the normal channel capacity being spoken for just by Chia farm plots. That's an actual disaster for end users. Manufacturers can't respond to those demand spikes instantly. They can respond some, for certain, but if some component hits maximum manufacturing capacity, you need to expand or build new factories (whether the manufacturers, or contract manufacturers within the supply chain for certain components). Building new factories is not quick. Not just construction, but ensuring that the demand will be sustained so you don't end up with these huge capital expenditure factories going idle when demand wanes.
- Glench 6y agoFolks here might be interested in Chia's smart contract language: https://chialisp.com/ https://chialisp.com/ Basically the designers saw how easily many Ethereum/Solidity contracts were hacked and saw that stateful side effects were the main culprit so they made their language have no side effects! Pretty cool.
- hanniabu 6y ago> they made their language have no side effects Yeah, I doubt that
- cossovich 6y agoIt's not that they "made" their language have no side-effects, it's more that they made a choice to use a lisp/functional design for the language which gives the advantages of that family of languages languages... advantages like limited side-effects and formal approaches for proving "correctness" of programs. It's a really clever design choice IMO for a smart-contracts language.
- qwtel 6y agoI've been wondering if non-turning complete languages might be the way to go for many smart contracts, which often resemble vending machines more than what general purpose languages are used for. Those should be captured by pushdown automaton or even a finate state machine and the corresponding languages (but except from regex, I'm not really aware of any..). My CS knowledge got really rusty, but I think it should be possible to put tight bounds on the computational cost of these, as well as statically guarantee that certain states cannot be reached, both of which would be very valuable in this case.
- ketamine__ 6y agoTezos has a similar pitch (having a better language that is less bug prone) and is a ghost chain now.
- SuchAnonMuchWow 6y agoBut what you really want for smart contract is a language with integrated formal verification. The ability to formally prove some properties of your smart contract is much valuable than functional vs imperative paradigm. Functional programming might makes it easier to detect flaws in your programs, but when there is billions at stakes and no recourse in case of a bug, you really want your program to be flawless.
- lsiebert 6y agoInteresting. There are a bunch of variants, but it seems like there are three main ways of handling crypto. Bitcoin is proof of work, which of course requires a lot of electricity. Some coins, like Neo/CutCoin are proof of stake, which basically let you stake some money, which I guess you can't spend and use that to handle transactions, so instead of running mining rigs, you just stake the money and earn a return. Ethereum is planning to move to proof of stake. Kinda like how your FDIC insured bank can loan your deposit out. Chiacoin, is proof of space and time, IE proof of assigned storage through the use of stored data, plus a verified delay function (slow to calculate, fast to verify hashing basically). The latter part needs only one processor, so whoever calculates fastest is accepted, so you aren't running a bunch of miners racing to benefit. I'm not sure that I see the benefit of proof of space and time except in the case of things like filecoin, where you are basically paid for storing stuff on your hard drive without changing it. Chia coin is, if I understand things correctly, just sticking random numbers on a SDD to "farm" them. I mean the VDF stuff is cool to be sure, but it seems like in the case of Chia it's just wasting memory space with random numbers rather then incentivizing storage of existing data. Is there a better system than proof of stake, in terms of just not being absurdly wasteful in terms of energy or storage capacity? For the purpose of responsible disclosure, I do have less than $20 bucks of ethereum atm, and that's the only amount of any coin mentioned above. I have no investments in the companies behind any of the above coins.
- Graffur 6y agoI am fascinated by the POS coins you chose to list. Why list neo and cutcoin over Cardano? I've never heard of either!
- christiansakai 6y agoAnd Cardano's Proof of Stake is groundbreaking. I don't know why the commenter chose to list those coins.
- RaiausderDose 6y agowhy is it groundbreaking? how does it work vs ETH try at PoW?
- dang 6y agoRecent related threads: Thoughts on a “HDD shortage” from an industry insider - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27008295 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27008295 - May 2021 (106 comments) SSD makers start warning that mining products like ChiaCoin will void warranty - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27001848 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27001848 - May 2021 (381 comments) Chia surpasses 1 exabyte of hard drive space - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26975734 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26975734 - April 2021 (151 comments) New Chia coin crypto with Proof of Space may create shortage of storage device - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26879278 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26879278 - April 2021 (19 comments) Chia Blockchain mainnet successfully launched today at 14:00 UTC - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26515025 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26515025 - March 2021 (14 comments)
- RealityVoid 6y agoI am... Suspicious of all the chia articles popping up on HN. I have not seen the same kind of buzz happening in other crypto spaces about it. And I am also suspicious about the claims that chia is the one that is such a threat to data storage supply, considering there are other crypto currencies with a similar approach. Overall, I am inclined to say that this is a submarine and HN is falling for it. Regardless, more to the point of the article, the argument and moral panic rings hollow. Chia just incentives other people to store data for people who want to store data. The place, overhead and mechanism of data retrieval is different, but, still, someone wants to store the data there and they pay for it. So how then is this more of a threat than cloud providers for example? Later Edit: I mistook Chia as having a similar approach as Filecoin, but, on closer inspection, it seems that they do not store data people want they just store data to prove it's stored and use that to distribute mining rewards. So I was wrong at this end. Still, I maintain my opinion this is a submarine.
- mike_d 6y ago> I have not seen the same kind of buzz happening in other crypto spaces about it If all the usual crypto charlatans aren't "to the moon"-ing it, that is a strong indicator of value for me. The reason it is getting play on HN and other tech focused outlets is because it is an interesting new project from the designer of BitTorrent, who clearly knows a thing about designing protocols.
- cozzyd 6y agoIs Chia's real play investing in HD companies?
- xhrpost 6y agoTo be honest I kind of wish someone would build a proof-of-bandwidth crypto. Miners would overtake data centers with cheap transit, driving the build out of more long-haul network. Some would then move to different neighborhoods just to get FTTH access, enabling more incentive for last-mile build out.
- causality0 6y agoExcept what happened to GPUs would happen to bandwidth. We'd all be fucked.
- Tepix 6y agoExactly. The proof of bandwidth would probably require you to waste that bandwidth for mining.
- ezoe 6y agoIf I were to own a transit for the purpose of profitting from proof-of-bandwidth, ignoring the regulation and law for the communication infrastructure, would I? A) Let everyone have their fair share of bandwidth B) with DPI, choke other miners so I'm relatively better in the whole miners. Also, bandwidth will be wasted just for the sake of proof-of-work instead of traditional work that have real values on its own.
- conradev 6y agoOrchid is a decentralized crypto market for bandwidth: https://www.orchid.com/ https://www.orchid.com/ You can run a node and sell bandwidth to people who want to proxy traffic through your node
- jcun4128 6y agoCurious about this idea. What happens if illegal stuff happens? Assuming bandwidth = internet. Side thought is renting out your mobile device for peripheral testing. That's something I was looking for recently video/audio specifically.
- deckplecksetter 6y agoIf only someone could invent a cryptocurrency that incentivises something good instead of something harmful.
- christiansakai 6y agoProof of Social Good. Increase your neighbor's credit score and you will earn a coin.
- Tepix 6y agoIt will be gamed.
- stonewareslord 6y agoGridcoin is designed for this. It is based on scientific research and instead of sha256 hashes of random data, coins are earned by proof of your computer doing scientific research. From their homepage: > Examples include protein structure prediction (Rosetta@home), mapping the Milky Way galaxy (Milkyway@home), and tackling problems in public health and clean energy (World Community Grid).
- Tepix 6y agoHow do you prevent malicious research projects in a decentralized system?
- faeyanpiraat 6y agoWhat would you consider malicious?
- Tepix 6y agoA project that provides credits without doing valuable research.
- Forbo 6y ago
- nyellin 6y agoDoes this inherently support Filecoin like use cases?
- Jermaine_Jabi 6y agoWhat stops me from running multiple nodes pointing at the same stored data? Or would that not be beneficial
- VectorLock 6y agoOnly one "wins" the reward.
- bombcar 6y agoThe disks store cryptographic lottery tickets - your chance of having the right one increases the more space you have. Two nodes pointing at the same batch wouldn’t.
- plank_time 6y agoIf someone could create a cryptocurrency using proof that require people to pick up garbage, the world would be garbage-free in a month.
- schmichael 6y agoPeople would litter just to create more garbage to “mine.”
- tehlike 6y agoRats of Hanoi - explains the exact thing you are saying :) https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/hanoi-rat-massacre-1902 https://www.atlasobscura.com/articles/hanoi-rat-massacre-190...
- Cilvic 6y agoOr Cobra effect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perverse_incentive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perverse_incentive
- PeterStuer 6y agoWe had (have) this here in Belgium with a very real case. Separate collection of plastics and the creation of plastics collection and recycling (organizations)companies were introduced for environmental improvement. Unfortunately, these have turned into the biggest plastic packaging lobby and have caused an explosion in the use of plastic packaging in retail. More plastic use is unfortunately a net benefit to those whose economic/financial incentives depend on it.
- valesco 6y agoI live in Belgium and I never heard of that. Do you have any source? I’m interested.
- PeterStuer 6y agoIn Dutch. https://trends.knack.be/economie/bedrijven/recyclagebedrijf-fost-plus-beschuldigd-van-belangenvermenging-en-machtsmisbruik/article-news-1704779.html https://trends.knack.be/economie/bedrijven/recyclagebedrijf-...
- atat7024 6y agoWhat does this do that Filecoin can't?
- cwyers 6y agoI just... do not understand how smart, even _brilliant_ people, the sort of people who know enough to make something like this, can look at Bitcoin... the waste, the way it has utterly failed to achieve what it set out to do[1], everything, and thinks, I know, I want to do that, but instead of blowing up the market for GPUs it'll be SSDs. Why? To get rich? It even seems doubtful to me that the people who developed Chia are the ones who'll make the money off it, if there is any to make. [1] Who uses Bitcoin for peer-to-peer payments? And the cryptocurrency ecosystem as it exists right now, far from allowing people to transact without third parties, is driving a cambrian explosion in third parties, because most people are incapable of transacting Bitcoin themselves.
- mNovak 6y agoThe people who developed Chia hold a massive pre-mined collection, and plan to go public (as in stock, not ICO) later, so definitely seems like they could profit.
- DaiPlusPlus 6y agoThat then makes this a very transparent pump-and-dump case - going public would mean the SEC would be right on them.
- z3ncyberpunk 6y agojust like they are on the innumerable illegal activity hedge runs commit every day, right?
- tommoor 6y agoThey've been developing new technology and algorithms for many years to make chia possible, hardly a pump and dump.
- smabie 6y agoHi I work in the space email me if you want to understand my motivations
- dorkwood 6y ago> This “farming” process differs from mining in the sense that you don’t need specialised equipment to participate; anything from a laptop to a smartphone can be used to farm Chia. The more free space you have, however, the more likely you’ll be rewarded. This seems like an ad for Chia disguised as a hit piece. It doesn't help that the author's only other article is trying to pump Dogecoin.
- mNovak 6y agoCan anyone clarify for me why/how this incentivizes SSDs over HDDs? Seems if it's really just about having "proof of space", whatever HDD is cheapest would make sense? How much data gets read back how fast during validation?
- ThatPlayer 6y agoIt's the initial generation of the 'plots' that make up the proof of space that's disc IO limited. So faster SSDs for that and then moved onto HDDs for long-term. According to Chia, it uses 332 GB to generate a 101.3 GB proof of space: https://www.chia.net/2021/02/22/plotting-basics.html https://www.chia.net/2021/02/22/plotting-basics.html
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Tepix 6y agoFirst we had proof of work, now we have proof of space. Both are rather wasteful. The challenge appears to be to create a proof of something beneficial for society, like "proof of clean energy generated", "proof of not flying", "proof of vegan lifestyle" or "proof of CO2 sequestered".
- M4v3R 6y agoThere already exists a cryptocurrency that is both environmentally friendly, fast and fee-less - Nano [0]. It uses something called directed acyclic graph (DAG) and while it does require proof of work it’s only for sending transactions to prevent spam, not for mining. It was created a few years ago but only recently it starts to get more traction. I used it a couple of times and it worked great. [0] https://nano.org/ https://nano.org/
- dkarras 6y agoProof of X unfortunately has to be capable of being verifiable by a computer without human intervention.
- nikolaipaul 6y agoIs there a blockchain for webhosting?
- stuaxo 6y agoWhen do we stop this madness.
- sebow 6y agoThen don't use it, simple as. I doubt miners don't know the risks. These sort of 'non-argument' articles really joggle my neurons when it comes to "let's talk about something popular because that will drive our traffic and something something industry because that also generates traffic and interest".
- wpdev_63 6y agoI don't blame the people buying up the GPUs to mine these cryptocurrencies but the vendors who allow them to do. It is absolutely criminal that they don't filter out these miners when they sell these products. They can easily make it possibly to only allow maybe 1 or 2 of these computers are shipped to a certain address or only one graphics card per a credit card. Whatever way they choose. Even putting a captcha to knock out the robo buyers would probably be enough. They have an obligation to video game makers, hospitals, and other businesses to sell them so that people that need them for other purposes can purchase them at reasonable prices. It's also on the govt to make sure that this happens. Just my 2 cents.
- rkagerer 6y agoIs the disk space used for anything useful in parallel to Proof of Space? What would have been smarter would be to make the space allocated to Chia also serve as a decentralized, worldwide storage facility (e.g. compete with S3/Glacier). You'd get better utilization of the resource, and have an extra revenue stream for the system.