12 ms·
Thoughts on a “HDD shortage” from an industry insider
- hdhrnnrkrkf 6y agoSample size 1: every 3 months I need to buy a large hard drive (14TB+). I buy external USB ones since they are the cheapest. Since it was due, in the last couple of weeks I was scanning prices in Romania daily, in case I get lucky with a discount. In the last week, prices surged 60-100%, and stock disappeared for 4 TB+. I panicked and after a lot of scanning I managed to buy a slightly smaller one than I needed with just a 20% surcharge. Prices on Amazon UK are also out of control. So now we are out of chips, CPUs, GPUs and hard drives. What a time to be alive :) PS: I would love to hear Backblaze take on this shortage.
- Ericson2314 6y agoShortages are good. It's the perfect time to set up manufacturing capability, so nationalists can be happy. It's a good time to push for hire wages, workers should do it. If there is some alternative industrial process, now's the time to try it. This is no 70s oil moment, because there's no indication fewer widgets are being produced than prepandemic.
- smolder 6y agoThis doesn't change that the shortages are caused by processes with infinite appetites. The demand grows with the supply, for hardware used by cryptocurrencies. To me it looks like the polar opposite of sustainability, which is distressing.
- oceanplexian 6y agoI just don’t get the sustainability argument.. Who decided that all computing must be for a sustainable or meaningful purpose? Cryptocurrency, as wasteful as it might appear, is like a drop in the ocean compared to the data centers of Google, Facebook, Microsoft, etc. Likes on Facebook provide much less value to society than a distributed currency that circumvents central control over the financial system. Second, Crypto doesn’t exist in a vacuum. How much “energy” does it take to disassemble a mountain and suck out precious metals or diamonds? How much energy does it take to manufacture all the coins and paper money the world over? And how many innocent people have been gunned down for the petrodollar or some other dispute over fiat currency?
- mytherin 6y agoBitcoin alone is estimated to use around 129 TWh of electricity [1], compared to 12 TWh for Google or 200 TWh for literally all other data centers [2]. Hardly a drop in the bucket, unless that drop is the size of 10 buckets. Surely not even the most hardcore cryptocurrency enthusiast would argue that crypto provides anywhere near the utility of the rest of the entire internet. [1] https://www.visualcapitalist.com/visualizing-the-power-consumption-of-bitcoin-mining/ https://www.visualcapitalist.com/visualizing-the-power-consu... [2] https://www.deccanherald.com/business/why-bitcoin-uses-10-times-more-electricity-than-google-963164.html https://www.deccanherald.com/business/why-bitcoin-uses-10-ti...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- TeMPOraL 6y ago> Cryptocurrency, as wasteful as it might appear, is like a drop in the ocean compared to the data centers of Google, Facebook, Microsoft, etc. It isn't, as 'mytherin points out. > Likes on Facebook provide much less value to society That's absurdly untrue. For all the warts of big social media players, they still provide tremendous social value - rich long-distance communication, organizing ad-hoc groups of people (including, in particular, meatspace ones), improved exchange of news worldwide, making things easier for local commerce, ... I could go on. And while these services can, and are, being misused, they are still at least doing something useful. > than a distributed currency that circumvents central control over the financial system. Except it doesn't. But even if it did, this isn't necessarily a good idea in the first place. > How much “energy” does it take to disassemble a mountain and suck out precious metals or diamonds? Less than it takes to run Bitcoin, and it's also a one-time expense. > How much energy does it take to manufacture all the coins and paper money the world over? Not that much on an ongoing basis. It's also O(n) with respect to the amount of extra money you need in circulation. A trivial cost compared to what the upkeep would be if we tried to run the world economy on Bitcoin. > And how many innocent people have been gunned down for the petrodollar or some other dispute over fiat currency? People kill other people for profit. That's a fact of life, independent of the way money is represented. That they don't kill each other over crypto says only one thing: that right now, cryptocurrencies are completely irrelevant to the economy. If crypto ever sees any serious adoption, a proportional body count will follow. (Also, I imagine the number for Bitcoin is already greater than zero, given that cryptocurrencies are disproportionally popular with criminals compared to general population.)
- gruez 6y ago>It's the perfect time to set up manufacturing capability, so nationalists can be happy. >If there is some alternative industrial process, now's the time to try it. wouldn't this take years? >It's a good time to push for hire wages, workers should do it. This is just speculation on my part, but I suspect hard drive manufacturing is much more labor intensive than capital intensive. Therefore I doubt this will translate into higher wages.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- newsclues 6y agoI think it’s a logistics problem, so adding more supply via new factories (unless local) won’t resolve the problem if the goods can’t be shipped.
- bcrosby95 6y agoCompanies won't invest in factories if they think the demand is temporary. Because by the time they come online the demand will be gone.
- vladvasiliu 6y agoMy sample size of 1 shows little to no move, although I wasn't looking at drives as large as you. In my case I was having my eyes on 5 TB 2.5" drives. I don't need them, I'd just maybe like them, so I haven't pulled the trigger, but I have them set aside on Amazon France. The price has stayed within a few euros of 110 € for the last 2-3 months.
- nicbou 6y agoSame here for the same product, but in Germany.
- hdhrnnrkrkf 6y agoMy advice would be to decide today if you want them or not. They are not going to get cheaper, and could get significantly more expensive in days.
- gruez 6y agoI'm not sure how pricing works where you live, but to get optimal pricing I usually have to wait a few months, or maybe even a year (black Friday). Given that all time lows for hard drive prices haven't budged much in the past few years, why buy every few months rather than stocking up when prices are low? Anyways for my data point: there was some external hard drives on sale for 5-10% higher than "optimal" prices. >and stock disappeared for 4 TB+. That's strange because those drives have terrible TB/$ compared to 10+TB drives.
- hdhrnnrkrkf 6y agoOpportunity cost. By keeping my cash in bitcoin I can now buy (well, not with this shortage) 5 times more hard drives than last black Friday.
- SECProto 6y ago> By keeping my cash in bitcoin I can now buy (well, not with this shortage) 5 times more hard drives than last black Friday. Probably only 4 after you pay the appropriate capital gains taxes, I'd hope. :)
- Semaphor 6y agoIf they have to. Not sure how it works in Romania, but in Germany you can sell coins held for 1 year or more without having to pay taxes.
- humaniania 6y agoMy advice is to ignore anonymous new accounts making inflammatory and fear mongering statements.
- hdhrnnrkrkf 6y agoOpen Amazon and look up hard drive prices and availability. This one is easy to fact check.
- humaniania 6y agoThey appear to be normally priced and readily available.
- nonameiguess 6y agoI just checked my Amazon order history right now. Last time I bought a Samsung Evo Plus 1 TB SSD was last August, 2020, for $189. Price right now if I buy it today is $159. Last HDD I bought was a 12 TB Seagate Ironwolf for $269, in October 2020. Today's price for the same drive is $325. It is out of stock, but says I can get it May 18th.
- andrepd 6y agoThat's a very limited dataset, no?
- ramshanker 6y agoCPU, GPU and Hard Drive.... guess we can have more dumb devices for now instead of everything IoT.
- giantrobot 6y agoWait until I unveil IoTCoin, it'll use PoIoT to verify the blockchain. Keep an eye out for my ICO! /s (or is it?)
- joeyh 6y agoHNT Hotspot Miners are uncomfortably close.
- hogFeast 6y ago> Prices on Amazon UK are also out of control ...they are not. Sale last week for 8TB at £14/TB. I would say that prices are marginally higher than they were a few weeks ago...average prices are probably £16/TB at the top consumer end but supply is fine, this price is not particularly high historically, it is not unmanageable for individuals, SSDs prices are cratering (hint: buy stuff that doesn't have massive TBW, these consumer drives are unusuable for Chia...prices of this stuff has dropped by 20-30% in the past few months), and there is ample supply on other sites too (I believe the issue with Amazon is that they just ran some huge discounts on the external drives popular with consumers..they will be restocked in a week or so). Also, you can pick up used stuff too. The supply of used drives with lots of life left is basically endless. And no-one is mining with 4TB drives.
- rovr138 6y agoIn 2012 there was a shortage due to a flood. They rented a truck and hit up all Costcos (I think it was) from Florida to I don't know where buying all of the drives they could. There was a limit on how many so it was a mission to do it. Edit to add a link and change "Around 2010" to 2012, https://www.backblaze.com/blog/backblaze_drive_farming/ https://www.backblaze.com/blog/backblaze_drive_farming/
- rincebrain 6y agoI would strongly suspect that corporate bulk orders are not currently affected, so Backblaze won't care until it gets much, much more dire.
- stefan_ 6y agoYou could probably take this and replace HDD with SSD or RAM and it would be just as correct.
- bt1a 6y agoI don't believe these terms are interchangeable, especially when this writeup is in response to Chia. Is it possible SSD or RAM have a similar bottleneck like read/write heads? Yes, but I don't know the answer.
- akiselev 6y ago> Is it possible SSD or RAM have a similar bottleneck like read/write heads? Yes. You could replace "read/write heads" with "chips" and it'd apply just as easily to SSD and RAM. Texas's freak weather shut down Samsung's Texas fab which caused a shortage of SSD controller chips, for example. After the February outage, I don't think they started to tape out again until April.
- xondono 6y agoWell, the primary difference is that cloud providers go through HDDs almost as consumables, while RAM and SSD are generally more long lasting. Contracts are set up in similar ways, but HDDs in general have more constraints baked in those contracts.
- humaniania 6y agoTIL all it takes to be a reputable "industry insider" is an anonymous reddit account.
- okareaman 6y agoSays 'humaniania'
- hyperman1 6y agoThe scary thing is, I don't know if I can trust him less than any 'reputable newspaper'. At least if this he says dumb things, someone on HN will call him out. The reputable source has only one voice, it will say anything that brings in extra money, and lots of invisible third parties will try to influence it.
- humaniania 6y ago"The scary thing is, I don't know if I can trust him less than any 'reputable newspaper'." Do you not know how professional journalism functions? You can verify decades of history with very limited retractions. There's good reason why people trust the New York Times.
- hyperman1 6y agoCan't comment on the NYTimed, as I am not from the USA. But there is a huge rift between usefull and not wrong. There is the whole Gell-Mann amnesia thing. There is the basic selection of which news is important and which facts are relevant for it. There is the bias in reporting. Each of these can make an article untrustworthy without needing any retraction.
- wnevets 6y agoDo you really need to be an "industry insider" to make any of their observations? Nothing they said seems to require they be actual "industry insider".
- 6y ago
- nuclearwast 6y agoIt's 2011 again... It took ~7 years before price went back to what they were.
- Scoundreller 6y agoThe flood that shutdown that Thai HD motor plant was the start of SSDs' takeover.
- hdhrnnrkrkf 6y agoI'm not so sure, in 2012 me and a lot of friends switched to SSD because it made the computer so much faster, not because there was a HDD shortage. And the tech press at the time was full of articles about how amazing SSDs are and how everybody should get one.
- Scoundreller 6y agoThey were always better, but the price delta narrowed a lot because of HD price increases. If you only had space for 1 drive, you did have to choose between small capacity with high speed vs. High capacity and slower speeds. Plus (real or mythical) reliability issues with new tech.
- hdhrnnrkrkf 6y agoBut nobody was talking about the price delta then. The narrative was "for 300 bucks you can make your computer so much faster, best investment ever". No mention about increasing HDD prices, nobody cared.
- Scoundreller 6y agoIf you’re made of money sure. For others, $300 for storage is a lot, but if it’s vs $200 vs $100, that has an impact on willingness to pay $300.
- beervirus 6y agohttps://old.reddit.com/r/chia/comments/n2lren/thoughts_on_a_hdd_shortage_from_an_industry/ https://old.reddit.com/r/chia/comments/n2lren/thoughts_on_a_... Fixed link.
- hsbauauvhabzb 6y agoThanks, I can’t view the original on my phone without the app because ‘Reddit can’t verify the community is not 18+’ which is a thinly veiled user hostile move-to-our app play. Shame on them.
- koofdoof 6y agoChange the URL to old.reddit.com to dodge the age-gate (for now).
- h2odragon 6y ago"we expect a supply shortage lasting years again" but NFT's are still a better investment opportunity than a new hard drive manufacturer.
- bitL 6y agoHm, based on this I ordered 1x16TB and 2x14TB HDD drives right away (the maximum allowed at that seller, ~60% surcharge to the price from a week ago). If HDDs/SSDs end up as obtainable as GPUs, we are going to experience some serious troubles... I somehow managed to get 3x3090FE but that was just super lucky timing. I am not sure what grad student Deep Learning researchers are going to do?
- ansgri 6y agoMaybe they finally turn their attention to models of manageable complexity and stop trying to create magic with models of enormous size that even in theory benefit only Big Adtech. Even mass surveillance requires rather small models.
- Firehawke 6y agoIt's interesting that that's precisely where we are with video cards-- the easiest way to get one is to buy a prebuilt system from any of the big names. It's really not much of a stretch to see HDs go to exactly that same pressure point.
- bitL 6y agoIt's also next to impossible to get workstation boards with many PCIe slots and now that spreads even to "creator" boards. I guess mining is going to eat it all.
- Haemm0r 6y agoOur IT guy told us, that (about 10pcs) the Dell machines he ordered (T5810 or something similar) a couple of weeks ago will ship in July earliest(although the online shops states better delivery times). So there could be some shortage too or at least logistical problems...
- banana_giraffe 6y agoAnd getting a prebuilt to get a video card is itself becoming hard at this point. The big names are pushing estimated delivery dates for prebuilts with 30 series cards out to June or July at this point. I suppose getting a card in July in a prebuilt is still better than not getting a card on its own. While I was digging around, it looks like some of the laptops with 30 series in them are even at the "ETA: One day soon!" point.
- nullc 6y agoIt's really important that manufacturers start responding to cryptocurrency induced shortages with auctions. The demand from the cryptocurrency users will be extremely high until they've spent a particular amount in total. They can do that with 1000 units, or with 5000 units. Obviously auctioning off units would be bad for having predictable prices for retail customers but that is irrelevant if aggressive miner buying is buying up all the supply. Moreover, shareholders at the manufacturers should be demanding it: they're leaving money on the table.
- hdhrnnrkrkf 6y agoBurning your regular customers is terrible business practice. It's not always about the money. Also, remember when Martin Shkreli increased the price of an anti-parasitic drug by 5000%? That upset a lot of people, and arguably it's what put him in jail. Of course, HDDs are not quite the same as vital medicine.
- orev 6y agoAn auction is not an arbitrary increase just because you can. It’s the exact opposite- a natural market where supply and demand reach the optimal price. Yeah it’s bad for regular customers, but if there’s no supply then what would they be able to get anyway?
- nine_k 6y agoRegular customers usually have long-term contracts and preferential treatment. Nobody in their right mind is going to show them the middle finger. But for them, availability will also be limited, and next-term prices will get higher. Also, increasing production of a highly-demanded item is not unheard of! But it will take months.
- AlexandrB 6y agoThis sounds great. Hard drive prices will start increasing until building a computer is prohibitively expensive unless you're a large scale OEM that can make bulk contracts. Another example of cryptocurrency empowering individuals.
- 99_00 6y agoI've never built a PC. I expect the crytpocurency bubble to collapse because my tech ignorant accountant friend asked what I know about building a crypto mining rig. What should I read to prepare myself to take advantage of the cheap used high end hardware that will hit the market do build a Windows or Linux system for my own pleasure.
- bitL 6y agoCoinbase had IPO, meaning serious business bought their shares, hedge and pension funds - I would be careful expecting any kind of normalcy in the next 2-3 years.
- dehrmann 6y agoCoinbase had a direct listing. There was no roadshow to line up institutional investors. I'm sure some big-time investors bought shares, but I'm sure some retail ones did, too. You know who sold? Early Coinbase investors and employees.
- m463 6y agoThat's normal. The primary moneymaking product of small startups is ... stock.
- 99_00 6y ago>serious business bought their shares, hedge and pension funds Your assuming that proves a point, but it doesn't.
- Havoc 6y agoI wouldn't count on it collapsing any time soon. Not with everyone from Visa to Time magazine jumping on the bandwagon >I've never built a PC. Definitely worthwhile. Basically lego for adults. Tons of good info here https://old.reddit.com/r/buildapc/ https://old.reddit.com/r/buildapc/
- graeme 6y ago
- jl6 6y agoBitcoin ate all the GPUs and I said nothing because I was not a gamer. Now Chia wants to eat all the hard disks, and I am pissed. I declare war on hegemonizing proof-of-waste swarms. Burn the coins. I want that disk space back.
- ancientworldnow 6y agoEthereum are the GPU's. Bitcoin utilizes ASIC's designed only for Bitcoin. This is an eventual e-waste issue, but not a GPU supply issue.
- jfim 6y agoDo bitcoin ASICs compete for the same limited IC foundry space?
- Phlarp 6y agoAntminer S19 uses a 7nm process, so yes.
- formerly_proven 6y agoNobody cares which coin of the week is used, it is time to get rid of the crypto garbage.
- spuz 6y agoThere was a period between about 2011 and 2014 when the fastest way to mine bitcoin was on a GPU and it did cause a shortage in cards: https://www.fool.com/investing/general/2013/12/11/amds-graphics-cards-are-selling-out.aspx https://www.fool.com/investing/general/2013/12/11/amds-graph...
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoAh yes, those days, I mined two bitcoins and sold them for $100, then got bored...
- mistrial9 6y ago
- herodoturtle 6y agoThere are quite a few (good) comments here focusing on the crypto aspect of this HDD supply shortage. That aside, to those of you that are scanning the comments here without having actually read the OP's reddit link - I'd urge you to read the linked page. It is an incredibly insightful summary of the HDD supply chain. (Whether it was indeed written by an "industry insider" or not is irrelevant; their analysis of the HDD market is highly informative)
- mrlonglong 6y agoSo if this isn't causing a real shortage of hard disks, why did I get stung for £70 more for my second 10TB hard disk that cost less a month ago?