12 ms·
It's for reasons like this that I'm always sad and dismayed the Chevy Volt wasn't more popular. Yes, all electric is the future, but right now, and for about th
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
It's for reasons like this that I'm always sad and dismayed the Chevy Volt wasn't more popular. Yes, all electric is the future, but right now, and for about the past 5-6 years, the Volt is/was the perfect car for a lot of people:
1. For me, my commute is about 12 miles one way, so my Volt has enough electric capacity for my commute plus 1 errand on a single charge. 95% of my days are 100% electric.
2. I never have "range anxiety" - if I do go slightly over my limit the gas engine kicks in. I use a tank of gas about every 4-6 months.
3. Since my car's electric range is only ~38 miles, I can fully charge in about 8-9 hours overnight on a plain 110v outlet - no custom installation required for a home charger.
I bought a low-mileage used Volt - it was a great deal and the best car I've ever owned.
- dataflow 6y ago> I bought a low-mileage used Volt - it was a great deal and the best car I've ever owned. For how long?
- irrational 6y agoHow long what? How long will it be the best car he ever owned? How long will it be a great deal? What are you asking?
- dataflow 6y agoHow long has he had the car. Or alternatively how old is the car. If the car has only worked a couple of years I'm not exactly shocked if it's still working well... for any car.
- sgt 6y agoTry buying a 7-series BMW around 2006 and say the same 5 years later.
- dataflow 6y agoExcept I wouldn't say the same thing 5 years after a 2006 car...?
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoIt's a 2015, I bought used in 2017.
- chemmail 6y agoThis is why Toyota is pushing Prime cars rather than EV, rightfully so. But looks like people will go for the hype of the EV instead. I have been into EVs since the Volt and have two right now, and it is too soon for mass adoption still.
- zrail 6y agoWe picked up a PHEV Pacifica minivan earlier this year and I love it for all the same reasons. I can do all of the around town errands on electric and at the same time when we take longer trips it's perfectly happy running on gas for as long as we need.
- compsciphd 6y agoI drove my volt cross country (and up and down, SF->Yosemite->Vegas->Grand Canyon->Salt Lake City->Yellowstone->Montana->south dakota->nebraska->kansas->st louis->memphis->atlanta->savannah->charleston->DC->NYC in a single trip and it handled it all with aplomb. Especially in the west when you had so many cars struggling with the long climbs, my volt just was cruising by them with ease.
- mmaurizi 6y agoIn an ideal world I think you're right, but practice has shown that many buyers of plug-in hybrids never actually plug them in. This was especially when they are bought for large fleets - which makes some sense to me, after all, when it is your companies car, not yours, and its on the company's dime when you either fill up the gas once a week or charge it every night, why do the thing that is more annoying?
- Hello71 6y agoit feels like it should be easier to plug in a few times a week rather than drive to a gas station, stop the car, exit the car, insert card, enter pin/zip code, open gas cap, remove nozzle, insert nozzle, pump, wait for pumping, remove and return nozzle, close gas cap, take receipt (optional at some stations), return to car, start car, and leave. yes, you have to stop and start the car when plugging in at home, but you already have to do those things, whereas driving to a gas station is additional stopping and starting.
- EricE 6y agoMazda was rumored to be working on a Volt like EV, but with a Rotary (Wankel) engine as the range extender. Wankels are ideal for this since they are incredibly small and light compared to the power they produce. And a range extender would be their ideal use case. Most issues with their seals happen from too low or too high of RPMs - when running a charger the engine can stay in its ideal RPM zone. EDIT: It is no longer a rumor - thanks to another commenter I lost who linked to this: https://www.thedrive.com/news/40168/2022-mazda-mx-30-ev-the-rotary-is-returning-to-america-kind-of https://www.thedrive.com/news/40168/2022-mazda-mx-30-ev-the-... While others may be content waiting around for sufficient charging infrastructure or blaming the customer I'm not. If I go EV it will be one with a range extender. Or I'll just keep my gassers until the infrastructure catches up. It took 50 years for the highway network and gas station infrastructure to build out for gas powered cars - we have just begun to start with EVs and range extenders are the perfect transitional key that will generate the need for the charging networks while still providing practical ways for people to as effortlessly get around as they do with their gas car today. You can't make the users experience worse than moan and complain people aren't flocking to your bright, shiny new thing. And that's the big problem with electric only cars right now - there is no good solution for longer trips where you need more energy quickly. I don't care if the majority of peoples trips fit well within an all electric car's operating parameters - the outliers must be addressed too.
- ezfe 6y agoI've got a Subaru Crosstrek PHEV with 17 miles of range - I love it, since my commute is ~14 miles. I chose this specific card for the proper 4WD and a few other reasons, but the Toyota PHEV offerings also stood out to me.
- lastofthemojito 6y agoI agree, plug-ins like the Volt make a lot of sense right now. Internal combustion engines have become incredibly reliable, and carrying around 18 kWh of batteries is a lot lighter and cheaper than carrying around 100 kWh of batteries. Software engineers like me tend to prefer the idea of making something as simple as possible though. I hate having a relational database AND Elasticsearch for full-text search. If I can get away with the database taking care of my search needs, I'll gladly rip Elasticsearch out of my architecture. Likewise, the idea of ripping the ICE and associated components out of the car feels satisfyingly simple. But, sometimes you need robust full-text search. And sometimes you need to drive a lot of miles in a short amount of time.
- rrdharan 6y agoDo you still have it? Asking because your post sort of reads like you don’t have it anymore and if that’s the case I’m curious why you got rid of it. I was strongly considering the Volt when it first came out but never pulled the trigger so always curious to hear how it worked out for the people that did.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoI still have it, still love it. Considering eventually upgrading to a used later model Volt (main diff being 50 mile electric range and CarPlay/Android Auto support).
- wlesieutre 6y agoSee also MX-30, if anyone’s looking for a new electric with gas range extender. Rotary engine! https://www.thedrive.com/news/40168/2022-mazda-mx-30-ev-the-rotary-is-returning-to-america-kind-of https://www.thedrive.com/news/40168/2022-mazda-mx-30-ev-the-...
- yaomtc 6y agoYet another crossover.
- wlesieutre 6y agoYeah, not my favorite but I can't fault them for making what they think will sell. Mazda is pretty small potatoes in the car market, they have to choose their battles. VW skipping the ID.3 hatchback and only bringing the crossoverified ID.4 to the US on the other hand, is more disappointing. It's one thing to do that with a gas car where gas stations are all over and it takes two minutes to fill up. For an electric you're making a direct tradeoff of less battery range to turn the car into a fake SUV that is never going to leave the asphalt. Boooo.
- throwawayboise 6y agoThat sounds quite intriguing. Hadn't heard of it, thanks.
- JshWright 6y agoYep, similarly the plug-in hybrid Pacifica is a great family vehicle. The ~30 mile battery range covers our "around town" driving, but we still have the ability to load the kids in the van and take a road trip without having to worry about how we're going to entertain them in random parking lots waiting for the van to charge.
- kasey_junk 6y agoNot to mention the stow and go seats. Throw a camper top on that thing and it would be car writers dream.
- secabeen 6y agoYou do lose the stow-and-go middle-row seats in the plug-in pacifica; the battery is in the hole they normally go in. You still get the rear ones though.
- fossuser 6y agoI think this is really GM's fault mixed with the broken dealership model. I went in to ask about them early on and the people knew nothing. I was confused by ads about them that talked about 'range' I thought maybe the car couldn't run only on the gas generator and it just extended it or something. The dealers were anti-selling them and directly hostile. In the end it turned out just to be stupid advertising - I'm not sure why you'd talk about a 'range' when you can fill up and immediately keep going, it's misleading. These companies have no hope against Tesla - the superchargers are excellent.
- shiftpgdn 6y agoWhen we purchased our 2019 E-tron early last year and the Audi dealership was also openly hostile about the sale. They did everything to try to put us into a different (gas) car. Manufacturers would be well served to sell their Evs directly.
- beh9540 6y agoI think the big reason for this is most dealers know there's little maintenance cost on EVs, which is where they make their money. With our Nissan Leaf, it's a struggle finding a dealer that even has an EV mechanic, and the ones that don't won't touch it if they don't have one. With that said though, I've found that sales not knowing anything about the cars they sell to be the trend of late. Even with ICE cars I've bought lately, the sales people have known virtually nothing about the car that I couldn't read on the sticker.
- fossuser 6y agoThere's a political element too (though Elon's Twitter behavior has helped reduce this somewhat - I suspect maybe intentionally). I lived in Western New York suburbia at the time and there was a strong anti-ev anti-liberal tribal sentiment that seemed to be contributing.
- EricE 6y ago>I think the big reason for this is most dealers know there's little maintenance cost on EVs, which is where they make their money. Bingo - the real rub for existing car manufacturers - their existing dealer networks. Then again from the frequent Tesla repair horror stories I see it seems Tesla would do well to court a lot more dealers/repair options.
- mdorazio 6y agoFor you it's the best of both worlds, but for most drivers it's the worst. 1. More expensive than an equivalent ICE car 2. Less environmentally friendly than an EV 3. More complicated than either 4. Harder to fix when something goes wrong because now you have two powertrains crammed in one package 5. Zero cool factor
- sharpneli 6y agoAs for the 3 and 4 it all depends on how it's made. If its Volvo style PHEV then yes, correct. It has normal ICE and gearbox on front and electric motor on rear. If it's Toyota style PHEV then no. Because then the comparison is not a gasoline car with gearbox etc but it's Toyota's classic hybrids that started with Prius. You basically just take that kind of hybrid, slap in a bigger battery and you're done. They already have electric motors in them instead of traditional gearbox. 5. Case in point: RAV4 Prime. That thing is cool.
- kube-system 6y agoYes, most people probably do not realize that Toyota hybrid systems are less mechanically complicated than a comparable gasoline vehicle. Whereas a gasoline vehicle typically has a complicated gearbox, or even a belt-type CVT, Toyota hybrids do not. They instead have a simple planetary gearset that enables varying the speed of the engine by varying the speeds of the two electric motors.
- EricE 6y agomotor/generator for a range extender is very simple. No gearbox, much smaller than gas engine to drive a car. Indeed Mazda was flitting with using the rotary for the range extender - rotaries are TINY. There was an RX-7 repair shop behind mine and the guys could pick the engines up out of the engine bay by hand - couple hundred pounds tops. A rotary for a range extender would probably be a bit bigger than the average cars starter. Runs at fixed speed in the optimal power band for the engine makes it incredibly efficient as well as reliable. Yes, it adds more complexity but it also gets you something you can't get with an all electric - hundreds of miles of range in minutes with a simple gas tank fill up. Yes, it would be great if the technology was mature enough to go pure EV. But batteries and power delivery for them isn't there for the vast majority of people. So rather than stick our heads in the sand, what's wrong with transitional technology while we work on plugging the gaps? Our new inability to compromise is going to be the death of western society :p
- mcot2 6y agoIts weird they never really put that tech into the large trucks or SUV’s they sell. It could have had a much bigger impact there.
- bit_logic 6y agoThat was the great mistake by the car manufacturers. Look at how popular the RAV 4 Prime is now, they can't make them fast enough and it's selling for higher than MSRP due to demand. They just needed to put this in SUVs and trucks and it would've been very popular. People like driving SUVs and trucks, but they also don't like the low MPG and huge gas tanks. If they could do most of their short/medium trips (groceries, school, work commute) on pure EV and not use a drop of gas and still use this large comfortable SUV for road trips? It would be very very popular with the right marketing.
- mcot2 6y agoNot only that but you have much more space available for the batteries and larger cargo carrying capacity so you could really experiment with some crazy designs.
- bit_logic 6y agoI agree, the current push for full EV was too soon. Even after extraordinary efforts like Tesla + Superchargers, the range and refill experience still isn't as good as ICE (range goes down with cold weather, and Superchargers still require 30-40 minutes). The battery tech right now is the perfect fit for PHEV. The EV transition should've been like this: 1. Government requires 50 mile range (about 20kwh battery) in all new cars. PHEV quickly becomes the default for all models (cars, SUV, trucks). Battery supply is less of an issue (A single 80kwh Tesla battery can be used in 4 PHEV cars). 2. DC fast charging (250kw) infrastructure is built in all cities. A small PHEV battery (20kwh) + DC fast charging means battery can be completely charged in minutes, as fast as filling up a gas tank. Maybe DC fast charging could even be built right next to the gas pumps (fill up gas and battery at the same time) This makes PHEV work for those without charging at home. 3. PHEV works fine in all weather. Battery range drops during winter? Just use some more gas, there's no range anxiety. 4. People get used to the feeling of driving in EV mode. And they notice how nice and quiet it is compared to when the ICE warms up. Also the environmental benefits. 5. Car manufacturers and battery companies get solid state batteries ready for mass production. Now is the time for 300 miles+ full EV cars. With solid state, no cold weather problems, much faster charge rate, no fire risk, no liquid cooling system, much higher durability. This is the battery tech that can fully replace ICE.
- pa7ch 6y agoI think series EV's with a generator are great and absolutely have their place in the transition to electric. Mazda just announced one for the US. But! The charge rate on batteries is directly proportional to their capacity (given same battery tech). So a tesla 20 kwh pack would charge 10-80% about as fast as a 100 kwh battery. So I think series-evs would mostly charge at home as a result and get gas while out and about if they need range.
- mschuster91 6y ago> Even after extraordinary efforts like Tesla + Superchargers, the range and refill experience still isn't as good as ICE (range goes down with cold weather, and Superchargers still require 30-40 minutes). Actually, it is a good thing that range limits and recharge durations require breaks - it is recommended to do regular breaks, generally between 15m/2h (per http://drivingergonomics.lboro.ac.uk/faq.html http://drivingergonomics.lboro.ac.uk/faq.html) to 15m/3h (https://www.theaa.com/driving-advice/safety/tired-drivers https://www.theaa.com/driving-advice/safety/tired-drivers). I'm not sure if this is just a random correlation or actual causation, but Tesla's accident rate is way lower than generic even without Autopilot (1/1.79M miles driven vs 1/0.479M miles driven, per https://www.forbes.com/sites/bradtempleton/2020/10/28/new-tesla-autopilot-statistics-show-its-almost-as-safe-driving-with-it-as-without/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/bradtempleton/2020/10/28/new-te...).
- kumarvvr 6y agoFor the amount of space a Tesla has, is it not possible to sell a separate generator / converter set that drives the motor? I guess cost is an issue, but there will be a good percentage of buyers who would surely opt for such an addon.