26 ms·
Cheerleader’s Snapchat rant leads to ‘momentous’ Supreme Court case on speech
- ashneo76 6y agoI bet one of the other cheerleaders mom's took her rant as fodder for an agenda to move her own daughter up the rank in the cheer squad. Or schalorship ranks and pressured the school to take action.
- kangaroozach 6y agoShe made a side-deal to be on the team. Seems like they are litigating the validity of that deal and nothing more. [The coaches said Levy’s snap violated the team rules she had agreed to, including showing respect, avoiding “foul language and inappropriate gestures,” and a strict policy against “any negative information regarding cheerleading, cheerleaders, or coaches placed on the Internet.”]
- istjohn 6y agoMy experience as a student in a US public school a dozen or so years ago was that it functioned as a borderline fascist institution, to an extent that I think would be quite surprising to the rest of the world. Every day began with the Pledge of Allegiance recited in the classroom, facing the US flag, hand on chest. Permission was required to use the restroom during class. Class changes were anounced by automated bells in the hallway, at which time students stampede to their next class within 6 minutes, including any necessary pit stops, such as a restroom break. This is high school, where students typically attend until 18. Schools loom so large in students' lives; and when school attendance is compulsory for all, and public school the only option for many; and when these institutions so easily sacrifice respect for individuality in favor of keeping order inexpensively; I am all for ensuring students can enjoy their full speach rights when they come home at the end of the day.
- nindalf 6y agoIt’s a bit disingenuous of the ACLU to claim that schools should stamp out cyber bullying and in the same breath claim that schools should have no influence on off campus activity. Guess what? The cyber bullying occurs off campus. And now, thanks to the ACLUs efforts, the bullying will be protected speech. At least have a little honesty. The ACLU should be up front with their biases that they’re a civil liberties first organisation. They only care about those liberties, regardless of its effect on other matters. Don’t sit there claiming “yes we also care about cyber bullying” because your current work guts the only mechanism for curbing it.
- tanbog3 6y agoI'm lucky no permanent electronic record of the crap I said as a 14 year exist. I feel bad for kids today, I really do. You should be able to say the odd swear word without ending up at the Supreme court...
- carpedimebagjoe 6y agoI'm on the side where the kids should be able to say anything they want if the schools weren't in the picture. Fuck censorship, fuck prior restraint, and fuck schools prying into the personal lives of kids off-campus. You can't shout fire in a crowded theater. If she's told she represents a school-sponsored club 24/7 it's one thing to make them look bad by mixing her brand and their brand, but it's another to have it be a surprise banishment or some random school official telling her what she can and can't say to her friends or publicly.
- ihunter2839 6y agoMaybe it's just me, maybe it's just a snapchat "feature", but one of the first things that struck me was the idea that this young woman sent the rant out to something like 250 people, of which a nonneglible portion was from her school (and had additional ties to the cheer group). Comparing this to my own experiences - I know I said plenty of things in high school which would have landed me in hot waters had they reached the wrong ears. But they didn't, and while there was certainly some luck involved, there was also discretion at play. I kept my personal opinions personal and limited to other individuals or groups that I could trust. So I guess my question is - does discretion play a role? Is there a difference if I whisper to a friend that I'd love to kick somebody's ass or if I post the same idea to a public social media space where it can be seen by a larger audience? What if I yell it out real loud during a break? What then? It will be fascinating to see how this case plays out, as I can see valid arguments on both sides of the table. Free speech is key, but if we want schools to have any chance of succeeding there must be a way to protect students who are being unfairly targeted.
- xyzzy21 6y agoWhat's more amazing (reading the case) is that the school was losing at each step and still was insisting on wasting government on appeals. Willfully bankrupting the school out of mere ego and hubris!
- egberts1 6y agoIt is only a Supreme Court preview because the school is a (local) government entity and that the coach is a government employee. This event CAN STILL be “cancelled” with the same scenario if it were a private school instead of a government school. First Amendment applies only to government entities and its employees. Caveat!
- umvi 6y agoFor those who can't read the article, here's a summary: > Brandi Levy sent a profanity-laden post to her friends on Snapchat in 2017, venting her frustrations with cheerleading and her school. When coaches at the Pennsylvania school discovered the post, she was barred from the squad for a year. The case will determine whether schools have the right to punish pupils for what they say off-campus. It is being viewed as a major test of the US Constitution's First Amendment, which protects free speech rights. As for my own thoughts... I'm hoping the outcome of this case can be used as a litmus test for related bannings/cancellations when people express an opinion "off-campus" (so to speak). Edit: More info about the case here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mahanoy_Area_School_District_v._B.L https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mahanoy_Area_School_District_v.... Edit2: Looks like HN can't handle URLs that end with a period. Clicking the link above won't work; you have to manually terminate it with a period before loading (should end with "B.L.", not "B.L")
- optimalsolver 6y agoIs being on the cheerleading squad a natural right?
- LanceH 6y agoIt's a qualified right, which she qualified for. A state actor doesn't get to dictate acceptable speech outside of that activity.
- scoopertrooper 6y agoSo it's fine for a police officer to attend klan events on the weekend?
- LanceH 6y agoThe analogy would be the officer (the state actor) refusing service to someone who exercised objectionable speech.
- underseacables 6y agoAs someone who grew up before the Internet perhaps I have a less than optimal view of the issue. I think that in the case of non-threatening speech, the school has no business disciplining students for off campus speech.
- FalconSensei 6y agoExactly. Isn't that the whole point of free-speech?
- tantalor 6y ago"Free speech" does not mean free of consequences.
- ecshafer 6y agoFree Speech precisely means freedom from consequences. That phrase is perhaps the most insidious phrase that is often repeated on the internet. To believe that free speech should be met with "consequences" if it crosses some line is illiberal, and immoral. The principle of free speech is one we all ought to attempt to live up to, and that principle goes far beyond what the first amendment may protect. Take that phrase to its logical extent. Should certain speech mean imprisonment? Should it mean execution by the government? Alienation and banishment from society? Attacked and lynched by a mob? What about political affiliation? Philosphical or religious beliefs? Those are all consequences that have, and are used against people who exercise their natural rights. Those are the natural outcomes of limiting free speech. Limiting free speech is the end of a free, liberal society.
- RankingMember 6y agoIn the context of the US Constitution, it only means that the government can't suppress your speech (with certain narrow exclusions). This doesn't mean that private companies can't muzzle you at their will or you can't make yourself a pariah by being publicly hateful.
- 908B64B197 6y agoI stopped reading the article when I realized the student was 14 at the time of the post. Anything posted by someone at that age, especially on a temporary medium such as snapchat, should have an implicit "for entertainment purposes only" label on it along with a EULA that says that unless it might cause immediate danger to someone else that it should be treated as satire.
- newacct583 6y agoBut the case is about a school punishing her for it. I mean, sure, YOU can choose to ignore this 14 year old as irrelevant satire, but the school can't. Taking kids' communication seriously and teaching them how to interact with the broader world in a civil way is literally what schools are for. And that includes incentives like punishing them when they act like an asshole. The question is whether this mandate schools have (which we all agree they have!) extends outside school grounds, and how far. Now, maybe it does and maybe it doesn't (I for one am a little conflicted here and don't have a clear opinion). But whether it does or not has nothing to do with whether we should take student speech "seriously".
- lindy2021 6y agoThat's clearly inconsistent. You don't let 14 year olds vote, drink, drive, or own a gun. They are expected to make mistakes. Chastising them for a private comment made outside of school is inconsistent with their obligations. The problem is you have these dying institutions riddled with power hungry sycophants who feel empowered with this wave of cancel culture.
- 908B64B197 6y ago> but the school can't Oh yes it can. And should. > The question is whether this mandate schools have (which we all agree they have!) No we don't. It's literally the first amendment. Student was exercising her first amendment rights. School has a right to tell her that they don't agree with the opinions she expressed but certainly not the authority to punish her. Else it's a slippery slope [0] [1] [2] [0] https://nypost.com/2020/08/06/georgia-students-punished-over-snaps-of-crowded-school-no-mask-in-sight/ https://nypost.com/2020/08/06/georgia-students-punished-over... [1] https://www.cnn.com/2020/08/08/us/georgia-teen-photo-crowded-school-first-amendment-free-speech-trnd/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2020/08/08/us/georgia-teen-photo-crowded... [2] https://www.popsugar.com/family/Student-Punished-Sharing-School-Lunch-35776519 https://www.popsugar.com/family/Student-Punished-Sharing-Sch...
- Tabular-Iceberg 6y agoWhat was her initial conflict with cheerleading team? I think an unsubstantiated temper tantrum is a perfectly reasonable cause to suspend her from the team. The real cause for concern is their blanket policy against any form of criticism whether warranted or not: > The coaches said Levy’s snap violated the team rules she had agreed to, including showing respect, avoiding “foul language and inappropriate gestures,” and a strict policy against “any negative information regarding cheerleading, cheerleaders, or coaches placed on the Internet.” It seems like they're justifying the suspension by saying something far more incriminating. What exactly are they trying to hide? A culture of undue pressure, bullying, maybe groping? Cheerleading has after all turned into quite a sexually suggestive form of entertainment.
- themgt 6y ago"Placed on the internet" is imprecise but my interpretation would be "posted in public on the internet/web". If Snapchat is equivalent to "placed on the internet" presumably so would be simply saying something to someone 1-on-1 in a voice-over-IP phone call. Can a public school make participation in extracurriculars (often key to future college applications and thus your life/employment prospects) contingent on never even in a private context criticizing the school's management of said activities? That strikes me as an extremely expansive power open to all sorts of abuse, and almost certainly unconstitutional.
- bombcar 6y agoThe "cheer industry" is a incredible cesspool of dirty tricks and corporate malfeasance that would make the tech industry blush for shame. https://www.commercialappeal.com/in-depth/news/2020/09/18/cheer-empire-profit-company-created-cheerleading-regulators-pays-salaries/3468551001/ https://www.commercialappeal.com/in-depth/news/2020/09/18/ch...
- rdtwo 6y agoYeah cheerleadeing is a scam
- chizhik-pyzhik 6y agoA better summary can be found at the wikipedia article https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mahanoy_Area_School_District_v._B.L https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mahanoy_Area_School_District_v....
- joshuaheard 6y agoWhile I support the general proposition that students should not be punished for off-campus speech, there is more to this case. My daughter is a cheerleader, a voluntary association within the school, which has a strict code of conduct. There are rules against public intoxication, sexual promiscuity, and disparagement of the school. So, it is a case of a student violating a voluntary association's code of conduct and being removed from that association. I think this is distinguished from a normal school/student free speech relationship. I look forward to reading the court's opinion.
- kube-system 6y agoIt's irrelevant whether it's voluntary or not, it matters whether it's an establishment of the state.
- tantalor 6y agoNo. Schools are obviously allowed to limit speech inside the classroom. The question is whether that right extends outside.
- kube-system 6y agoI was responding to the above assertion that the voluntary nature of the program is relevant, in regards to the situation in the parent comment. I wasn't referring to the case in the top-level post.
- joshuaheard 6y agoActually one of the issues in the case was whether she waived her 1st Am rights by voluntarily joining the team. https://casetext.com/case/us-v-levy-22 https://casetext.com/case/us-v-levy-22
- kube-system 6y agoDid you post the wrong link? Looks like that's about a case regarding distribution of heroin in the 80s? I have not seen any analysis that suggests that the school district has used that argument, but I'd be interesting in reading it. The analysis here[0] (which is the most detailed I've seen) suggests that Mahanoy is arguing that this off-campus speech is causing on-campus harm. [0]: https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/cert/20-255 https://www.law.cornell.edu/supct/cert/20-255
- rbanffy 6y agoAs I'm not American, this whole cheerleading thing feels very weird to me. It's weird to see the role of boys to play sports while the girls cheer doing elaborate choreographies. Does anyone else feels it weird from a different cultural framing?
- CheezeIt 6y agoThere’s also a band in the stands that marches in formation on the field at halftime.
- intergalplan 6y agoIn fact, the primary band program at my high school seemingly only existed to fulfill this role. I ultimately dropped it because I was sick of doing unpaid work for the football program outside school hours. I'm pretty sure the extreme emphasis on marching-compatible instruments in high school music programs is entirely due to this, in fact. I wonder how many 17-year-olds play the tuba or trombone or clarinet in Europe, versus the US, for instance? In an ideal world I'd see all non-specialist students at that level learning piano/keyboard, or maybe guitar or ukulele. Something with good general utility, acceptable when played solo even at not-great skill levels, and relatively easy to reach a point where you can lead a sing-along. Nice, physical, evident mapping of notes and theory to the instrument, too, unlike wind and brass instruments.
- watwut 6y agoI would guess that fewer kids in EU play instrument. And when they do, it is either classic or self taught hobby. Here, basically you can't start officially in high school. You are deemed too old. No one cares that you play, unless you are from family that actively encourages it.
- em-bee 6y agocheerleading is like nurses and teachers. male cheerleaders do exist, they are just a small minority. we are arguing for more male teachers and nurses, and we could just as well be arguing that there should be more male cheerleaders.
- js2 6y agoOn the one hand: > The coaches said Levy’s snap violated the team rules she had agreed to, including showing respect, avoiding “foul language and inappropriate gestures,” and a strict policy against “any negative information regarding cheerleading, cheerleaders, or coaches placed on the Internet.” On the other hand: > Some cheerleaders complained about Levy’s message, and the coaches decided to suspend her from the squad for a year. This entire thing could've been avoided with a reasonable response. Like a reminder about the team rules. Maybe a one week suspension. A full year suspension is insane. That said, she obviously had no choice but to agree to the rules, so that's no defense against a First Amendment violation.
- ses1984 6y ago> That said, she obviously had no choice but to agree to the rules, so that's no defense against a First Amendment violation. Not sure what you mean by this, cheerleading is optional, right?
- fighterpilot 6y agoSo is advanced math, using the library, and so on.
- balozi 6y agoEven better yet the issue could be avoided if the school did not make up and therefore have to enforce bad rules in the first place. When the people disregard bureaucratic rules, more often than not it is the rules themselves that are the problem.
- chmod775 6y agoWhy the fuck did anyone at that school even care what a 14 year old said? That is not normal behavior for adults. At that age I could've exclaimed something along those lines to my teacher's face and they'd just have laughed at me and asked me to calm down. If I pulled that at work I'd be asked whether everything is alright. Apparently nowadays the appropriate response to a child throwing a tantrum or having a mental breakdown is to have one as well.
- Igelau 6y agoThat's what shocked me about this. I can't believe how doggedly the schoolboard pursued this up the chain. Being told "sorry you're upset that a teenager flipped the middle finger but you can't just kick her off cheer squad for it" is the point where anyone who isn't a lead-contaminated Boomer would just shrug and walk away.
- Igelau 6y agoD_wnv_te ratio here is a decent indicator of the proportion of readers who are out of touch with the experience of being a teenager in an environment run by administrators who are violently hellbent on making sure no one is allowed to do anything they did as teenagers. Either you get it or you don't, but I'm not sorry for using HN's "B-word". Before you click the button, do some introspection.
- a1369209993 6y agoFWIW, I downvoted you for the grossly unjustified implication that this sort of unconscionable malfeasance on the part of school administrators is in any way "shocking", unbelieveable, or specific to "lead-contaminated Boomer"s, rather than a predictable result of putting small-minded fascistic pricks (of any generation) in that sort of position of authority.
- Igelau 6y agoNoted. Next factor in: [1] the fascistic pricks of my generation (who are still most of today's fascistic pricks) happen to be what I said they were, and [2] I never said all Boomers were lead-contaminated or that this was historically unique to only them. Now we don't even disagree on semantics.
- neonate 6y agohttps://archive.is/qZqEV https://archive.is/qZqEV
- random314 6y agoIf the school uses public funds, isn't she protected by the first amendment?
- blaser-waffle 6y agoSo will the SCOTUS uphold the "not a cheerocracy, it's a cheertatership" rule?
- MelvinButtsESQ 6y agoI'm reading she essentially agreed to a contract in the form of the "team rules" and then violated those rules for which she was held accountable. This isn't a free speech issue, it is a contractual issue.
- kube-system 6y agoContract law is not ultimate. If your contract violates other laws, or is missing elements of a valid contract, then it could be invalidated.
- tclancy 6y agoYou need to be 18 in PA to legally sign a binding contract as best I can tell. https://law.jrank.org/pages/11848/Legal-Ages.html https://law.jrank.org/pages/11848/Legal-Ages.html
- agloeregrets 6y agoSuper iffy for two general reasons: 1: She could not legally sign that contract 2: The cheerleading team is ultimately an extension of the government (as it is part of a government institution). By literal means, the state is punishing someone for what is ultimately private, off-campus speech. A lawyer with goals in life would see that as a case worth fighting.
- klondike_ 6y agoRelated case: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morse_v._Frederick https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Morse_v._Frederick >...the Court held, 5–4, that the First Amendment does not prevent educators from suppressing student speech that is reasonably viewed as promoting illegal drug use at or across the street from a school-supervised event.
- morsch 6y ago"Fuck school, fuck softball, fuck cheer, fuck everything." Wait, that's it?!
- agloeregrets 6y agoYup! There was a case of a student making a joking fake myspace for a Principal that landed the student in jail for a year and a half, happened half an hour away from this place.
- rychco 6y agoThis is the part that makes me absolutely furious. This is the most innocent rant a teenage girl could possibly post.
- screye 6y agoEvery 2nd teenager I know used to make statements like these on a daily basis.
- standardUser 6y agoI said roughly the same thing this morning over coffee.
- Y_Y 6y ago> I know a man who is rock hard – he's firm in his pants, he's firm in his shirt, his character is firm – but most of all, his belief in you the students of Bethel, is firm. Jeff Kuhlman is a man who takes his point and pounds it in. If necessary, he'll take an issue and nail it to the wall. He doesn't attack things in spurts – he drives hard, pushing and pushing until finally – he succeeds. Jeff is a man who will go to the very end – even the climax, for each and every one of you. So please vote for Jeff Kuhlman, as he'll never come between us and the best our school can be. That's the student body election speech that was ruled not to be protected in _Fraser_, one of the main precedents in this case.
- will4274 6y agoThat speech was given in person, in the school building, where other students were required to attend, during school hours. This speech occurred on snapchat, outside of the school building, outside of school hours, with no requirement that anybody pay any attention at all. That speech is funny tho.
- harshreality 6y agoThere's a gigantic difference, a hard distinction, so big it hurts, between prohibiting disruptive, norm-violating speech on campus within a school function (a central focus of the _Fraser_ decision), and prohibiting speech outside of school on social media. At school, the school administration is acting in loco parentis in regulating the behavior and speech of students. There are limits to how much it can regulate garden variety free speech, particularly non-disruptive speech or political opinions, but it can regulate it. The nature of the speech is different. In _Fraser_, the language was specifically crafted sexual innuendo. In this cheerleader case, the language in question on snapchat was a garden variety swearword (f-) expressing frustration, not specifically sexual in context. Every high schooler, every middle schooler knows that word. A substantial part of the decision in _Fraser_ revolved around the audience being minors and how the sexual language was potentially damaging to them. I think even that _Fraser_ decision was wrong... I agree with Stevens's dissent that it's not the school's or a federal court's business to decide what rhetorical sexual innuendo is or isn't damaging to minors unless it's clearly interfering with the "educational process" (a phrase mentioned in the relevant disciplinary rules, not some artificial scope-restriction Stevens made up), or unusually disruptive. The cited record mentions school staff opining that the assembly was not substantially more disruptive than other assemblies, despite some embarrassment and obscene mimicry of the innuendo. A student assembly isn't sufficiently connected with the educational process to merit the extra censorship you'd expect to be enforced in a classroom, which is what the cited school's disciplinary code contemplates. As pointed out elsewhere, the cheerleader's signed "agreement" not to disparage the team or classmates as a requirement for being on a team is not likely to be valid for a public school. The fact that the school can more strictly regulate speech when a student is actively representing the school at an event, or in a classroom, is not relevant here (or in _Fraser_, for that matter). If school staff believe special behavioral criteria for attendance or membership at the school or on a school team is necessary, they should quit and join a private school where that kind of thing flies.
- theknocker 6y ago>problems that wouldn't exist if education "professionals" would grow up
- chickenmonkey 6y agoI'm wondering about how this impacts criticising the school. If the school does X, can the school punish students for discussing this action and criticising it? Feels like this allows schools to crack down on criticism.
- supergirl 6y agohow was there such a gap in the law that it has to go all the way to the supreme court to resolve this?
- throwaway823882 6y agoThe reason the kids are penalized is not because it disrupts the school. It's because it destroys their authority. Schools cling desperately to authority because they are unwilling or unable to use different methods to teach.
- throwaway_kufu 6y agoThere is validity in the idea that off campus speech on social media can interfere with on campus activities, but I think the slope is far to slippery to allow the government (yes public schools are the government) to extend to all students and all times because social media posts can disrupt the learning environments. Kids already check their constitutional rights at the door of the school, and they can regulate their own platforms, but there is no way the courts can allow schools unmitigated power to rear children on behalf of the government 24/7 in all mediums of expression. The bullying argument by the school is rich, because that is exactly what these adults are doing, they are bullying a kid into keeping quiet about the schools behavior. Sure kids can be bullied on social media off campus but the school doesn’t need to regulate that, the law provides remedies, and if the bullying extends from an off campus social media post to an on campus violation then the school can step in at that time and punish that behavior.
- fossuser 6y agoIt's one thing for a school to exercise editorial control over a student paper (previous SCOTUS case), but it's quite another for them to try to control student speech outside of school. A lot of public schools in the US are miserable places with dumb and often hostile adults. I agree that they are the ones bullying the student here - I hope the school loses.
- throwaway_kufu 6y agoThey can definitely regulate the use of the word fuck in the school or in class, I am fine with that, but I know others that would disagree. You could definitely change the facts just slightly, where a student posts something on social media during school hours while on campus...then is it fair game for the school to regulate/punish? I have to admit myself I’d want to know the context, but it really shouldn’t matter, either yes they can regulate the speech or no they can’t. I think SCOTUS cherry picked this case, so they wouldn’t have to take a case with more compelling facts like a social media post while at school by a student bullying another student. Then again the justices are older, and disconnected from a generation that grew up connected to social media.
- kodah 6y ago> “Wherever student speech originates, schools should be able to treat students alike when their speech is directed at the school and imposes the same disruptive harms on the school environment.” This reads like harm prevention rhetoric with a thin veil of authoritarianism.
- adventured 6y agoIt makes sense, as culturally the US is collapsing rapidly into a cesspool of nanny state authoritarianism in every possible manner. I can't figure out why anybody would want to live here, it's an increasingly despicable, suffocating culture. We're starting to see the first hints of an American firewall on expression and speech. It has gotten drastically worse over the past 10-15 years. Every time I watch a movie made before approximately 2010, I laugh about the fact that almost no good movie (any IMDB decent rated movie) made prior to then could be made again today, due to the authoritarian SJW cancel culture, everyone must be protected from being offended at all times. Padded intellectual prisons for all. The biggest hint of the US intellectual infantile collapse and how far along it is, is that "hate" speech is increasingly taken serious as a notion. Anyone that refers to "love" and "hate" as intellectual concepts that should govern human rights or speech, is a terrifying and dangerous mental infant. Hate is a particularly vague term to use to govern speech, which is the entire point, so the people in control can decide what can be said and what can't be (including restricting criticism directed at those in power; restrictions all authoritarians will always pursue).
- supergirl 6y agoit's in her interest to be banned from cheerleading anyway. so many better sports or other things to do with that time. I don't get why cheerleading is so popular. a "sport" that just sexualizes little girls, parading them at half times. if there was ever a sexist tradition that doesn't die, it's this one -- women training to "cheer" male teams where cheer means doing sexy dances at half time to entertain the men drinking beer in the audience
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- paxys 6y agoCan't say about legal rulings and precedent about free speech, but I can't remember it ever being okay to, for example, swear in front of teachers outside school. Especially in small enough towns, conduct outside of the school always came back to bite you in the ass since everyone would hear about everything. And I imagine social media has amplified this x1000.
- rtsq 6y agoI wonder how many of the functionaries who take a private rant of a 14 year old seriously are on some form of medication. In open source projects the administrative parts are increasingly staffed by people who appear mentally unbalanced. Some of them are taking tranquilizers because they feel "harmed" everywhere and by everyone. As a society, we need to have a conversation if we want to be governed by people with mental issues.
- ascorbic 6y agoAnyone else find it ridiculously coy that the Washington Post censors the word "fuck" in the quote that is the crux of the case. I'm sure the readers are all adults who can handle them accurately reporting the quote. Kids aren't reading the Washington Post Courts & Law section.
- pessimizer 6y agoIf you don't want to swear in your newspaper, you shouldn't have to swear in your newspaper to seem "adult." People reading the Courts & Law section are also old enough to know what the fuck "f--k" means.
- ascorbic 6y agoThey wouldn't be swearing in their paper, they'd be accurately reporting a phrase that is the subject of a Supreme Court case. It's not about seeming adult, it's about treating readers as adults who are capable of reading some naughty words in reported speech without being scandalized.
- tzs 6y ago> Kids aren't reading the Washington Post Courts & Law section. I wouldn't be so sure of that. I remember as a kid we were occasionally given homework to find an interesting current events newspaper story and bring it to class to read out loud. I remember going over all the news sections when looking for a good story, not just the sections you would have expected an ~9 year old to be interested in. I remember once finding a story in the international news section about a legislator in some other well known country that all of us kids would have heard of who had yelled during a session that some other legislator was a son of bitch, and then a fistfight broke out between them. When I brought that and read it aloud to the class and got to say "son of a bitch" in front of everyone and not get in trouble for it was the highlight of my week, and earned the admiration of all the other boys in class.
- logicchains 6y ago>I remember once finding a story in the international news section about a legislator in some other well known country that all of us kids would have heard of who had yelled during a session that some other legislator was a son of bitch, and then a fistfight broke out between them. Was it Australia by any chance?
- tengbretson 6y agoI'm trying to figure out a litmus test on how the content of what is said could make this justified or not. Like if a football player got on snapchat and said that they hope they lose the game this coming Friday and that they intended to take actions that undermined the team, would they be justified in being kicked off the team? I think so. Is there a similar line for cheerleading and did this cross it? I don't think so, but it's hard to say for sure. I don't know if it's possible to make a ruling that simultaneously defends the cheerleader's speech without also preventing the football coach from acting in this hypothetical situation.
- Glyptodon 6y agoIt's not like students have a right to participate in particular high school extracurricular activities like sports, right? Could this case end up making varsity sports not allowed to cut players, or is the expectation just that they turn cuts/bans into another "nod and wink" thing where you just aren't chosen/stay benched?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tqi 6y agoSuspending this student for this action was a gross overreaction by the coach, and the AD / school administration should have stepped in to intervene before this reached the point of legal action. It seems basically impossible to me that the Supreme Court will be able to draft a broad decision that anticipates and handles all cases gracefully. I feel like no matter how they rule, the result will be that schools will be prevented from using common sense on a case by case basis, and instead rely on some convoluted N-point test with a ton of unintended consequences.
- detaro 6y ago> will be able to draft a broad decision that anticipates and handles all cases gracefully does it have to? Can't it intentionally narrow down the scope of its decision? (which will of course give some push in one direction anyways, but leave stuff open instead of forcing specific criteria)
- StanislavPetrov 6y agoIt has always seemed ridiculous to me that schools should have any role whatsoever in the off-campus activities of their students (assuming that the behavior didn't occur on or with school property[such as a school website], while the student was under the supervision of school employees[such as a field trip] or had any involved with any school resources). Aside from being unconstitutional, our schools are struggling to perform their basic core role - education. They should be spending all their resources on figuring out how to educate students at school instead of trying to police their out-of-school behavior. That's what parents are for.
- flowerlad 6y ago> The case will determine whether schools have the right to punish pupils for what they say off-campus. In the old days, we could separate our "school life" and "off-campus life" into neat little spheres. But these days we live our lives digitally. In this new world the spheres are not as separate as they used to be. The student may have typed the message while off campus, but her classmates may see the message while on-campus. So there is no clear geographic boundaries, and there are no "spheres" really. The same issue appears when a high school teacher publishes nude pictures of herself. She may have done it while off campus, but the students who see the picture may not see that as a separate sphere. In the digital world there are no distances. Everyone is everywhere at the same time.
- giantg2 6y agoI don't think schools should get involved in off campus speech or activities. However, we are seeing more and more of it. This case isn't even that extreme compared to others. There are people being suspended from actual school for non-threatening photos with guns or even just liking a photo of a gun. On the other hand, I don't see the problem with cutting a student from an extracurricular for actions that contradict its intended purpose or standards. If you're saying f the school and f cheerleading and the goal of the cheer squad is to promote school spirit and pride... (she wasn't suspended, given detention, or kicked off the softball team) I know I would have been benched or cut if I talked about throwing a game or not trying my hardest and those statements made it back to the coach. It's not like they were monitoring social media for this. I'll probably get downvoted, but I guess that's the cost of exercising my free speech.
- carpedimebagjoe 6y agoPolitical correctness isn't about taste or decency, it's about control through pseudo-offense, imaginary "victims," and "microaggressions." This is manipulative browbeating by implicitly threatening people's standing in society by telling them what to think, what words are "correct" now, and what topics they can't talk about anymore, even as jokes. Oh and now, let's retroactively rehash the past, tell people how horrible they were in the present, and punish them too. Keep looking for people to punish, excoriate, banish, and crucify until there's no one left. After all, no crime is too small to not earn the instant death penalty. George Carlin (RIP), Bill Maher, Jerry Seinfeld... sadly, I think they lost the war because there weren't and aren't enough comedians with enormous lower-middle orbs (female orbs run a little higher) to stand up or manspread against the tides of Karens, booers (that's not "boogers," although that would work too), shouters, and the rest of the heckler safety-pin brigade mob.
- Zee2 6y agoCertainly agreed, for the speech that has nothing to do with any school activities. Your comparison about talking about throwing a game and the coach learning about it is apt; that sort of speech is essentially the same as your boss at work overhearing that you want to sabotage your work. I feel like the coach, or boss, taking action because they don't feel their player or employee has the best interests of the team or company at heart is well-warranted. However, for speech that does not relate to any school activities (for example, taking your point of a student exercising their Second Amendment right) should not result in action against the student.
- djoldman 6y agoAssuming you have a kid old enough for a smartphone, is there software available that a parent can use to disable wifi but allow roaming data? (It's much harder to argue for your kid if they use the schools network).
- ohgreatwtf 6y agoIf I was in charge(and I should be, you should all appoint me dictator and get it over with already) we'd have a common sense solution to this problem. It's obvious what to do. There are two kinds of speech- expressive speech and active speech. Expressive speech can be a rant, a dialogue, swearing, etc. You can call people the N word. That's all expressive. it is you expressing your opinions and your views. You have an absolute right to that and nobody should be able to challenge you on this. Active speech is speech that seeks to push an action agenda or is supporting actions. When you talk about what you are doing -and- what you are doing is offensive, then your speech is an extension of your offensive actions and does not stand on it's own. As a result, it may not be protected, depending on if your actions are offensive, harmful, or even if someone just doesn't like them. For example, if an employee says "i hate working here" and you terminate them for that, then you have violated their free speech. if instead they say "bathroom strike #notworking to protest horrible job" and you terminate them for saying that, then you have not violated their free speech, you have acted upon the information presented in their words to respond to their actions or planned actions. Simple as
- dannykwells 6y agoI bet it's not even close. The Roberts court loves free speech even in far more harmful forms - see Citizens United. They will be very wary of implications of "liberal" companies governing speech outside of work too. This was a huge over reach by the school and now they're gonna lose big time.
- duxup 6y ago>that is not reasonably interpreted as bearing the school’s imprimatur Schools are involved in so many things, I wonder how anyone could interpret that.