6 ms·
The spin on this situation is dumb. What it amounts to is that KPN hired Huawei on a contract basis to administer its equipment, and as a result those contract
by ajross 6y ago
The spin on this situation is dumb. What it amounts to is that KPN hired Huawei on a contract basis to administer its equipment, and as a result those contract administrators had... administrator privileges on the Huawei equipment. Now, obviously telco equipment can be used for spying, but there's absolutely no allegation of wrongdoing here at all.
If there is any finger to point, it's at KPN for hiring an untrusted contractor and giving them sensitive access.
- Gys 6y ago> for hiring an untrusted contractor So you agree Huawei cannot be trusted. I think that is the whole point of the discussion.
- simion314 6y agoNot OP, but must probably this is just part of the anti-China propaganda , I think it started with the false accusations from Bloomberg... so I expect that any Huawei related news is false until some actual evidence is presented to the police or something.
- hn8788 6y agoHuawei doesn't really deserve the benefit of the doubt, a lot of their early success was due to hacking Cisco and Nortel then building competing products based on stolen information, all while the Chinese government was restricting non-Chinese telecom vendors from operating in the country.
- simion314 6y agoI personally don't like to be manipulated by media. So for this case I am just saying be aware not to be a tool/pawn is some big player's game, I suggest you either do more digging , wait for some real evidence - but downvote if the mention of the Bloomberg fake article or innocent until proven guilty is a something wrong that needs to be hidden.
- jryle70 6y agoYou're contradicting yourself here, as you don't want to be manipulated but are already convinced that this is part of anti-China propaganda. Also, innocent until proven guilty should only apply to regular people, not state actors. Many historical events are only declassified after 50, 60 years, or never at all. Believe a story or not is your judgement, but asking for proofs are either naive, or just looking for excuses.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- simion314 6y agoI mean the title and the content do not match . So the title was created to push a certain agenda , so what? is it propaganda or just the old pure evil capitalism that pushed the editor to change the title into some false accusations? I did not said that Huawei is not spying, mayb ethey do but I am still waiting for the evidence. Similar on how I wait for evidence that Google is reading our politicians emails and blackmailing them - is not enough to hear some conspiracy and then upvote it like a tool because I hate Huawei or Google.
- geofft 6y agoYou shouldn't trust any provider under the jurisdiction of an anti-liberty nation-state: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Room_641A Not sure why Huawei is unique here.
- kube-system 6y agoThe US and the Netherlands are both allied members of NATO. That's why Huawei is a different story.
- geofft 6y agoAre you saying it's worse for China to (be granted sufficient access by the Netherlands that, in theory, if they wished to abuse that access, they could) spy on communications in the Netherlands than for the US to spy on communications in the US?
- ipaddr 6y agoFrom a NATO point of view yes. China spying on the Netherlands would be worse than the US spying on itself.
- kube-system 6y agoI'm saying that the it's a reductionist oversimplification to say that it doesn't matter who the Netherlands picks for their telecom infrastructure because "everyone spies". Different countries have different relationships with each other, and the entire point of an alliance is to cooperate and establish trust.
- sidlls 6y agoI can't speak for the OP, but I'd say that, yes. The US's spying activity is an overreach (to put it mildly) and I don't agree with the extent or purpose in many cases. We also don't really have a well functioning democracy, in my opinion, due to the capture of the government by private corporations. But what we do have is still a democracy, and it is absolutely lightyears above and beyond the genocidal, anti-liberty government of China.
- arss 6y agoEven if they are at fault for not doing their due diligence that doesn't remove the fault of someone spying
- jsiepkes 6y ago> Now, obviously telco equipment can be used for spying, but there's absolutely no allegation of wrongdoing here at all. That's incorrect. The report made by Capgemini stated that there were clear boundaries as to what Huawei was allowed to access but they violated those boundaries. Apparently also a list of numbers under surveillance by Dutch intelligence was found in possession of Huawei. Which was clearly well beyond those boundaries. Just like a sysadmin can read the mail of the boss doesn't mean your allowed to.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoThough I can't read the actual report, this article does not support your claims. >Apparently also a list of numbers under surveillance by Dutch intelligence was found in possession of Huawei. Which was clearly well beyond those boundaries Wouldn't the ones running the network need to know which numbers were under surveillance to provide the intelligence agency access?
- AlphaSite 6y agoIt could be done at arms length through an API. Then it would become an issue of reading data they shouldn’t be.
- Joker_vD 6y agoUnless people inventing such API thought that the domestic telco equipment will be operated by foregin companies. And I somehow suspect they've thought exactly the opposite: that they can rely on domestic providers be domestic firms, easily supervised by the domestic law enforcement agencies.
- hansjorg 6y agoCould also be possession of database with intent to select.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoWouldn't that API then just give someone else (presumably the intelligence agency) unrestrained access to all phone lines? Someone outside should be responsible for providing access, you can argue Huawei shouldn't have been chosen but I find it hard to blame them for doing their job.
- emodendroket 6y agoI feel we need to read all these stories with a skeptical eye because, frankly, Huawei's become a political football, and there is a very strong motivation to cast events in the most unfavorable light possible by officials who are working backwards from the conclusion. Perhaps they do have some kind of spying master plan but I have found a lot of the fanfare for these stories hasn't held up to scrutiny.
- pydry 6y agoReminds me a bit of the Bloomberg saga also, where theoretical compromises were somehow "confused" for real ones when a journalist talked to a spook: https://9to5mac.com/2021/02/15/bloomberg-spy-chip-2/ https://9to5mac.com/2021/02/15/bloomberg-spy-chip-2/
- ncann 6y agoThis is something that irks me as well. Every time Huawei is mentioned in a conversation, the topic of spying is inevitably brought up, but as far as I know there has been no concrete case found that they did indeed do any kind of spying act through their equipment. If someone can actually link me something that can prove this claim I would be very interested to read it.
- matthewdgreen 6y agoI agree that there is a lot of spin on these stories: efforts to paint bad and sloppy network security decisions as evidence of actual malice. I am sympathetic to the national security agencies who are likely driving this reporting, though. Giving untrusted foreign companies access to your communications infrastructure is generally a bad idea, and the evidence (from Western countries’ own actions) is that this kind of access will eventually be abused. But the problem is that there appears to be an effort to paint these security screwups as something more concretely malicious than they are, in order to sway public opinion. From my perspective it does not make a lot of sense for Huawei or China to engage in overt spying at this stage of the game, even if (assuming the worst intentions) that is something they plan to do. Right now all of the incentives for that company are to gain the trust of customers during these early stages when everyone is looking for a reason to throw up protectionist barriers. A decade from now when Huawei systems are ubiquitous and the competition has largely been put out of business, then maybe the situation will be different. But why kill the golden goose by doing something stupid now? That doesn’t mean there wasn’t bad behavior. Maybe people are behaving irrationally. But I tend to see sloppiness behind these stories rather than actual malice.
- kube-system 6y ago> Now, obviously telco equipment can be used for spying, but there's absolutely no allegation of wrongdoing here at all. Of course. But, security posture is an important thing to consider. This may be an obvious thing to many people on this forum, but it is not obvious to much of the general public.
- varispeed 6y agoYour comment sound kind of like victim blaming.
- geofft 6y agoIf there was no actual spying, then there's no victim. If someone gets pickpocketed on the subway, saying "You should have protected yourself better" is victim blaming, sure. But if someone doesn't get pickpocketed and then points out how there was a foreigner sitting right next to them who could, theoretically, have pickpocketed them, should they have chosen, and while the foreigner didn't pickpocket them this time, you know how those foreigners are... then "Why didn't you just get up and sit somewhere else if he bothered you" is a particularly polite form of what you perhaps ought to tell them.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- novok 6y agoAnd that's pretty much the situation of every telecom in europe and probably many more countries https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/5g-elephant-in-the-room/ https://berthub.eu/articles/posts/5g-elephant-in-the-room/
- swiley 6y agoWhat's upsetting is that these organizations are given exclusive use of something that is essentially public (certain electronic sounds in the air) and they were very careless with it. It has nothing to do with Huawei and everything to do with KPN (and most other telcos) being negligent.
- camillomiller 6y agoWell, what you just read is a counter-propaganda piece, so that’s no surprise that it was spun that way.
- NicoJuicy 6y agoThat's not what it's saying ( i speak dutch) First of all, it's not a spinoff. KPN his the report because it was afraid for it's existence. Second is that Huawei could listen to KPN'S internal communications ( = their network) that includes a lot of government calls.
- krageon 6y ago> untrusted contractor As far as I'm aware, practically every European telco hires Huawei engineers to maintain their infrastructure in this way. It's therefore not reasonable to call them an untrusted contractor, as they are evidently very trusted.
- DyslexicAtheist 6y agoit is a very big deal since none of these people are LEO's: "Huawei also knew which numbers were tapped by police and intelligence services." massive boon to the CCP IC to have access on a foreign's country ongoing investigation etc. (the in Canada detained CFO comes to mind but the potential is much bigger than this)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]