18 ms·
Switching from gas to electric is something I can do all on my own. Switching from gas car to cycling is something that would require major investments from my
by jedberg 6y ago
Switching from gas to electric is something I can do all on my own. Switching from gas car to cycling is something that would require major investments from my city and developers.
Both are noble goals, but let's not let perfect be the enemy of good. Switch to electric now, and also encourage new roads and new developments to be bike friendly, so that switching to a bike is something that will be viable in 20 or 30 years for most cities in America.
Edit: To clarify, the investment I'm referring to is rezoning entire cities and tearing down single family homes and replacing them with mixed use buildings to bring commercial spaces closer to residential spaces. Most American cities have commercial centers and are then surrounded by residential, with very little mixing of the two. For example the closest place for me to buy food is .75 mile away, but the closest supermarket is 1.5 miles and I have to cross two major roads and a Freeway to get there.
- agumonkey 6y agoHey, without cars we would need no lanes.
- jtdev 6y agoHow will good be moved? How will the infirm get around? I admire the cyclist ideal that they are fixing the problems of the world by not driving/owning cars... but it seems like a very superficial, quasi-moralistic solution that's really not likely to have the impact that is desired/needed.
- lotsofpulp 6y agoLower one’s expectations of quality of life and consume less.
- jedberg 6y agoI don’t want to lower my quality of life so far that I can’t get an ambulance or have to be homebound once I can no longer walk.
- estebank 6y agoMore people on bikes means fewer cars. Coupled with frequent public transport means that your ambulance will not be stuck in traffic and that the bus that lets you not be homebound will take as long as the car you currently drive to get to the same places. And if you still need to drive, you will still be able to, it just won't be the only option available.
- lovegoblin 6y agoThe comment is an excellent exercise in reductio ad absurdum.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- TomSwirly 6y agoI live in a bicycle centered city and we have excellent ambulance response _because_ there is less traffic. Disabled people have various mobility devices that go on the bike paths. The quality of life is a lot better here.
- jonvk 6y agoThere's nothing like cars to lower quality of life. They are noisy, require huge areas to be paved over, thus removing prime property in cities from more useful purposes. Particulate matter emissions from the engines, but also from brake and tire wear are unhealthy[1][2]. We don't let kids play outside anymore because we are afraid they will be hit by drivers. We kill animals after they hurt one person, yet we fear to cross a street anywhere for fear of being hit by someone recklessly driving a few tons at speed and defend the right to drive as though it were primordial. And really, who finds a street lined with parked cars and stuffed with traffic inching forward esthetic. A few cars are hugely useful to grant mobility to the few people who cannot get around otherwise, provide emergency services, and move bulky goods. I'm not saying plumbers shouldn't be able to arrive with their truck full of tools, just that the overabundance of cars really lowers the quality of life of the vast majority of people. 1. https://publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/bitstream/JRC89231/jrc89231-online%20final%20version%202.pdf https://publications.jrc.ec.europa.eu/repository/bitstream/J... 2. https://cfpub.epa.gov/si/si_public_file_download.cfm?p_download_id=525701 https://cfpub.epa.gov/si/si_public_file_download.cfm?p_downl...
- lotsofpulp 6y agoI agree with all of that, but people mostly perceive that they can't live in a large house on a large plot of land. Spread out living with requisite car transportation also creates a stratified society where you don't have to be near those you do not want to be near, which people might also perceive as a benefit.
- zip1234 6y agoBikes do not decrease quality of life. More exercise, more fresh air, and better health are all quality of life increases.
- umvi 6y agoWe need fewer roads and cars, not zero roads and cars. Think 2 lane road vs. 6 lane road.
- stemlord 6y agoYes it would require radically rethinking how a lot of cities are designed, definitely a distant goalpost
- stfp 6y agoNo dude, there would still be cars for these use cases, come on. All we need is some protected bike lanes, maybe like 10% of the space allocated to cars.
- estebank 6y agoMore people on bikes doesn't mean all people on bikes.
- TulliusCicero 6y agoGoods and disabled people and emergency vehicles combined are probably < 10% of traffic within cities. The objective isn't to get rid of all car lanes, just replace some of them.
- dsomers 6y agoHonestly these are such lame points that I hear again and again. I lived in Toronto, bad bike infrastructure, and now live in Amsterdam with great infrastructure. People here with limited mobility use electric wheelchairs in the bike lanes and therefore have more and cheaper and safer mobility options than in Toronto. A person in an electric mobility scoter can safely go from the city centre to the airport on the edge of the city. They also have the option to take a cab or a car of course, cars are still an option but they are not priorities over bikes here — you’re also totally ignoring that it’s dangerous for some disabled people to even use cars — but mobility scooters can be a safer option. Deliveries come in the morning on trucks, but that’s less necessary with more electric cargo bike being used every day. Cars suck.
- TomSwirly 6y ago> How will good be moved? Same way they are now, on major roads. > How will the infirm get around? They use mobility cars or scooters in the bike lanes, is what happens in bike friendly places like where I live. Funny, I always hear this question from right wing people who otherwise have no interest in helping "the infirm". I'm sure you aren't one of those people, right? > it seems like a very superficial, quasi-moralistic solution The alternative solution seems to be "Burn all the fossil fuels, die miserably," so I welcome some sort of alternative.
- Ericson2314 6y agoPublic transit
- Aerroon 6y agoWhat do you do in winter? Or during rain?
- umvi 6y agoPut on a coat/rain jacket
- sokoloff 6y agoFor cold or rain? Sure. For 4-6" of snow, you're going to need a lot more than a jacket to cycle in that.
- Fricken 6y agoWe use snow plows up here in Canada.
- sokoloff 6y agoOn the bike paths as well? That's very progressive of Canada. We don't do that effectively here in Massachusetts.
- Fricken 6y agoOn the bike paths as well, yes. In my home city of Edmonton they are a priority. According HN I don't ride year round in Edmonton, it's impossible.
- Aerroon 6y agoThat's great for the hour after the snowplow passes, but what about after that? Snow + ice on a bike is a pretty easy crash. Even a slow speed crash on a bike can break bones, unlike cars.
- rhys91 6y agoThere's a level of risk associated with the activity, there's no denying that. Risk mitigation factors can be applied to reduce the risk to a palatable level for a lot of people. Snow tyres, riding slowly, using lights in low light etc. The opportunity is to convince more people that cycling is a legitimate option for a large group of people. Infrastructure investment instills confidence and further education for both cyclists and drivers help to manage that risk. Whilst cycling in the snow might not be your cup of tea, there's a cohort of people who could consider it as a net positive to get from A to B, exercise and put less wear into the road. And we need to support those people.
- ab111111111 6y agoWhat major investment would be required from the city or developers to set up cycling infrastructure? Painting some cycle lanes onto the roads? Marking a few car parking places as bike parking places? That's all that cycling infrastructure really is, so it's super cheap. A lot cheaper than, say, building charging stations for electric cars.
- amwelles 6y agoSomething tells me there’s a lot more to it than that.
- kalenx 6y agoSetting up a cycle lane in place is cheap, but not easy (at least in North America, people will always complain about the "war on cars"). Also, setting up a good cycle lane can be more expensive than you think. If you have a nice bike lane that spreads over 5 km but there's a 200 meters gap in it because of a bridge which was too narrow to keep the bike path, then you don't have a nice lane at all.
- BitwiseFool 6y agoI've never understood why bicyclists can't just use the sidewalk for most of the commute. I get that it becomes impractical in dense areas where people are actually walking but most of the roads I travel along have vacant sidewalks.
- EdwinLarkin 6y agoDepends how walkable the city is.The more walkable it is the more people you will see on the sidewalk.Sidewalks are for pedestrians not for fast moving vehicles.
- jtdev 6y agoYou know how many in the cycling movement view automobiles as being fast, dangerous, machines clogging up the roads? Many pedestrians view cyclists as a similar fast, dangerous (often rude and inconsiderate) presence on the sidewalk.
- fossuser 6y agoI agree - plus there's already enough culture war arguing just with EVs, now we're going to pivot to the NIMBY battlefield that is cycling? Make progress where you can. I'd love for their to be more cycling options (and things are way better than they used to be), but no reason to disincentivize transitioning to EVs too (or framing it as some battle between them).
- stfp 6y agoBut it doesn't require major investments. It's really minor investments compared to other infrastructure projects. The issue is taking away even a tiny fraction of car space basically triggers some kind of political road rage.
- TulliusCicero 6y agoThey're minor investments practically, and major investments politically. As you say, for many motorists, giving up space on even some roads to cyclists is treated like some sort of war crime. There's very much of attitude of, "we can't just have a majority of the road space -- we need nearly all of it!"
- michael1999 6y agoIt can be a real winner politically, depending on the electoral boundaries. Roads have such limited throughput that a new bike lane might inconvenience only a few hundred people in cars, while opening up the city to thousands of people on bikes. Once politicians figure out that calculation, it can go very quickly.
- TulliusCicero 6y agoThat's a fair point. But demographically, often the people most protective of car space are the ones who show up loudly at community meetings. That can have an impact.
- adamcstephens 6y agoReducing lanes, when combined with other optimizations, can actually _improve_ travel time for cars. The problem is you have to actually implement the changes in order to prove this to people.
- Someone 6y agoEven more so when combined with reducing the number of cars, which adding a bike lane can easily do. If you replace 3 car lanes with n cars/lane/hour by 2 car lanes plus a bicycle lane, car traffic/lane/hour goes down as soon as you have over n cyclists/hour on that bike lane. At that density, that bike lane looks empty (https://www.boredpanda.com/space-required-to-transport-60-people https://www.boredpanda.com/space-required-to-transport-60-pe...)
- avianlyric 6y agoIt’s worth noting that this is an article written by a U.K. author, and mostly references European cities. While obviously the same principle applies in the US, achieving higher rates of cycling in Europe is substantially easier, both politically and practically, in Europe than the US. Europe is significantly more compact cities, and public transport is usually very good, additionally many European cities have already invested heavily in cycling infrastructure.
- TomSwirly 6y agoIt's a tiny, tiny investment compared with almost any other investment a city can make. > switching to a bike is something that will be viable in 20 or 30 years 20 or 30 years? I'll be dead of old age!
- cma 6y ago> Switching from gas to electric is something I can do all on my own. There were lots of government subsidies, federally funded academic research, etc. involved in making it a practical choice you can make.
- vesinisa 6y agoDoesn't it worry you to live in a city whose infrastructure is not compatible with global emission goals? Within the next decades either of too scenarios will realize: a) your home will loose most of its market value as nobody will be able to live there, OR b) we are all royally f*ked. Neither sounds too good.
- supertrope 6y agoIt is very hard to motivate people to act on a problem decades in the making. With health problems people will continue to smoke and overeat despite their doctor warning them. Besides the time element, climate change is the ultimate example of private gain (your income and consumption) and socialized cost (literally the entire planet).
- jedberg 6y ago> Doesn't it worry you to live in a city whose infrastructure is not compatible with global emission goals? It does. I'm constantly pushing to rezone the entire city as multi-use and multi-dwelling. The city council has ignored me, and most of my fellow citizens vehemently disagree, as they believe that would devalue their property.
- vesinisa 6y agoIs moving an option?
- jedberg 6y agoI mean I could, but wouldn't it be better to try and fix where I am instead?
- vesinisa 6y agoWell it just sounds like your neighbors are not really open for change. You can of course try to change their opinions in town-hall meetings and so on, and that's commendable. Another option would be to vote with your feet and money. If you move to an area where the zoning is e.g. more dense or bike-friendlier, it will add to the property market demand in those areas. OTOH you selling your property in your current area adds a tiny bit of negative market pressure. If that happens on scale, it drives down the prices in less friendly areas and drives up the prices in climate-friendlier areas. Though I honestly don't know how realistic it is really currently to find a densely-zoned districts in American cities that are not plagued by rampant crime, run-away poverty and under-performing schools. I live in Europe, and my image of American zoning is mostly based on content of two YouTube channels: "Not Just Bikes" and "City Beautiful". You have probably heard of them, and if not I think you might find their videos quite interesting (or the "Strong Towns" initiative, if you prefer reading.) In my European home city the council is actually already taking concrete measures to increase the density of zoning and actually discourage sub-urbanization / urban sprawl, even though the scale of the problem pales in comparison to typical the American city AFAIK. One of the concrete measures I myself pledge to is to always prioritize availability of biking and public transport when moving - if not for my own sake then for the sake of my children. This is a natural choice for me since I have always lived in the city myself. I think the difference to US cities might be that in my home town the real estate prices in the city are very high because a sufficient large portion of the people who have the economical means to choose their place of living choose to live in the smaller apartments of the densely-populated city center districts, as opposed to the larger single-family housing in the suburbs. This is because the city center is actually filled with desirable services and urban culture, which just does not exist as much in the suburbs. But I do understand that bootstrapping a lively and livable downtown is not as simple as just moving there if the area is currently dangerous and undesirable. The city council has to encourage this trend for it to be a viable option for residents who want to live there.
- psychiatrist24 6y ago1.5 miles is doable by bicycle. Bridges or tunnels can be built for crossing roads and freeways.
- rtlfe 6y ago1.5 miles is not just doable, it's trivial. 10mph is a pretty easy speed on a bike, which would make it take 9 minutes. If you build up some strength and/or upgrade to an ebike you can cut that in half.
- mc32 6y agoRather than switching people who already own a car to bikes, it’s much much easier to keep people who bike biking: i.e. India, Vietnam, Indonesia, etc. and not let them adopt a car centric pony of view (as well as students in the US/Can. who are 16 going on 18 and steer them towards bikes.
- jryle70 6y agoMotorbikes, not bicycles, are the dominant transportation method in all those countries. Also, because of the hot weather and pollution it's just much more comfortable to sit in an air conditioned car. And then there is the factor of owning a car, used to be the symbol of wealth but is now more affordable.
- titzer 6y agoStep 1. Paint bike lanes. Step 2. Fine bastards who violate them.
- rtlfe 6y agoWe're really bad at step 2 in NYC. Bike lanes are just additional parking spaces.
- hereme888 6y agoStep 3. Build bike cages so you can safely park bikes w/o worrying about theft.
- dfgdghdf 6y agoPainted bike lanes do not feel safe enough to most potential cyclists so they don't lead to much modal shift.
- wj 6y agoWhat if they added posts? Either metal driven down into the road that a car would not go through or plastic ones that would deter a driver from running into them? I think that would provide more of a sense of physical separation.
- dfgdghdf 6y agoThey have been doing this in London. I think it makes a big difference! It also prevents people from parking in the bike lane.
- orthoxerox 6y agoYou need: - physically separated bike lanes wide enough for safe overtaking, with a gap between them and a parking lane that protects cyclists from open car doors and people leaving the car from cyclists - an actual network of bike paths instead of vanity paths - redesigned intersections that are safe for cyclists (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_intersection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_intersection) - bicycle storage infrastructure in apartment blocks (not everyone has a suburban garage) - bicycle storage infrastructure in office blocks
- imgabe 6y agoYou can also move. I'm not saying it's a feasible solution for everyone, or even that one should move solely to get to a more bike-friendly location, but the next time you move, maybe consider that as one of the main factors in choosing where to live. If everyone does that, the infrastructure will follow.
- onlyrealcuzzo 6y agoI'm quite tired of Americans saying - but I NEED a car. I mean, maybe YOU do. But most people can live in a lot of different areas, if not cities & states. You chose to live a lifestyle that requires a car. Which is fine. But it's a choice.
- jryle70 6y ago> You chose to live a lifestyle that requires a car I don't think this is true. People move because of job opportunity, family, weather or cost of living. Very rarely because they want a change of scene. Car is the often the requirement where they move to in America.
- alamortsubite 6y agoIt's almost as if the average American is so thoroughly inured to automotive and suburban culture that they're completely unable to imagine anything but the status quo.
- Johnny555 6y agoAren't those all pretty much lifestyle choices in the end? I chose to live where there are many jobs, but the cost of living is high (but also where I can reasonably commute by bike or transit). I could have stayed where I was and enjoyed a low cost of living, but a worse job. Whether or not to have a family is probably the biggest lifestyle choice that most people make in their lives.
- baron_harkonnen 6y agoPeople have been making individual choices to improve CO2 emissions for decades and the only thing that reduced global emissions was a pandemic. You need structural change or it all really doesn't matter. Now maybe you think that structural change is unlikely to happen, and I agree with you, but then we're in really big trouble. > let's not let perfect be the enemy of good. This is not the perfect vs the good, the is that meaningless versus the possibility of having an impact. We need to do so much more than have only bikes in cities that it is almost impossible to image we make the changes necessary to avoid climate catastrophe. If you think even that is out of the realm of possible, then there's no need to worry about what type of fuel powers your car, it quite literally will make no difference. The gas you don't use on your car will just be used by amazon delivery trucks to further reduce shipping costs and increase sales.
- josephcsible 6y ago> Switching from gas to electric is something I can do all on my own. Even this depends on where you live, though to a lesser degree. In particular, if you live somewhere that you have to park on the street, you're 100% dependent on others for charging infrastructure.
- hereme888 6y agoI agree. Good analysis. I bought an ebike for myself instead of a second car for the family, otherwise there's no way I could realistically travel the needed distances on a daily basis. The biggest hindrance to me right now is no way to park a bicycle safely. Even carrying bulky bike locks is risky in NY for someone who wanted a nice ebike.
- an_opabinia 6y ago> Switching from gas to electric is something I can do all on my own. What if you don't have a garage to charge your electric car?
- phpsuks 6y agoThats a very level-headed take. I can already see this happening in San Francisco. With the market street being closed to cars before pandemic hit. During pandemic, a lot of streets were marked "slow", so no entry to cars there and city plans to keep it that way. Some good hangout spots like JFK drive in GGP and Great highway are also marked car-free, I also heard something similar about Embarcadero in planning. City is also moving to make outdoor dining parklets permanent. All these moves discourage car ownership in every way and when you also consider transportation services like Revel scooters, Lyft electric bikes and Lime scooters, you can start seeing SF as a leader in USA. Not to mention, it is impossible to buy a used bike on CL at a reasonable price last entire year. Let's keep putting in the work SFians!