25 ms·
Jeff Bezos comes out in support of increased corporate taxes
- slater 6y agotranslation: the lawyers have found manifold ways of avoiding even new taxes currently in the works!
- honksillet 6y agoDon’t forget also using the tax code and lobbying to gain competitive advantage!
- rektide 6y agotaxes are what poor people/companies pay. ok failing bad with this post. I'll refer to these comments instead, which express the same idea: > That or their smaller competition will have a harder time dodging it than they will. also, we should raise the corporate tax rate. and income tax rates on high earners. and try to fix the hideously broken state of affairs that result in these individuals having far less tax burden than they ought in far too many cases.
- arsome 6y agoThat or their smaller competition will have a harder time dodging it than they will.
- betwixthewires 6y agoThe lawyers finding loopholes is yesterday's game. In the 21st century, the lawyers write the loopholes and take them to congress to get passed.
- stephenr 6y agoDidn’t he just step down. So worrying about Amazon is not his problem any more. $20 says he’s suddenly in favour of corporate taxes because he fears the alternative: wealth taxes.
- echelon 6y agoWouldn't corporate tax also be another moat to prevent other businesses from reaching Amazon's scale? And isn't Bezos trying to rub shoulders with politicians?
- stephenr 6y agoPossibly. But that also depends on how corporate taxes are implemented. I have no clue what his aspirations are, I don't follow this type of news very much at all, I just remembered that he stepped down and now suddenly he thinks companies should pay more (or in Amazon's case, some) tax.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kelnos 6y agoI expect a huge amount of his net worth is tied up in Amazon, so Amazon is still very much his problem.
- csomar 6y agoI think he fears more that Amazon (or other big tech companies) are smashed into smaller entities.
- ultrarunner 6y agoI am not a tax lawyer— is there anything stopping Mr. Bezos from simply voluntarily paying more in taxes than he owes? Or even just Amazon turning down the tax breaks for e.g. locating a distribution center or office center in a new jurisdiction? Support of a policy would seem to go a lot further if he was already voluntarily attempting to achieve its goals (presumably funding more public services). Without that effort, it seems more like a desire to subject everyone else to a policy that he feels he can weather.
- Barrin92 6y ago>is there anything stopping Mr. Bezos from simply voluntarily paying more in taxes than he owes? This is about taxes Amazon owes, not Bezos. Bezos already is giving vast fortunes away through his charities. And yes there are two things that stop Amazon from giving away free money. 1. A fiduciary duty to their shareholders, 2. competition. Bezos is completely right to state that, if people want to see more contribution from large firms, have it done through proper legislation and taxation.
- aero-glide2 6y agoBezos is also giving away around $2 billion a year away for Blue Origin. As a space fan, the top two richest men funding space companies makes me so happy!
- idownvoted 6y agoOn one hand: Good for him. I hear he also does a lot of charity work. On the other hand: Wait wasn't it Amazon who cheated on taxes like no other company (compared in size)? After the union shenanigans, his biasedness in the elections or well deserved PR desasters such as the contest for a new headquarter (what a surprise it went where it can influence policy most), I'm a bit allergic to being nudged to see his moves as all too altruistic. Increasing corporate taxes raises the burden across the board, for competitors and possible future ones. Meanwhile Amazon can afford to have its accounting adjusted to mitigate the impact more efficiently than any competitor could. It cements his position.
- astrange 6y ago> On the other hand: Wait wasn't it Amazon who cheated on taxes like no other company (compared in size)? It's because Amazon has low profit margins compared to other companies its size - AWS is profitable but the retail business isn't very much, and investors don't want them to make more money because they like free shipping too much. The remainder is lost to R&D credits. If people want Amazon to pay more taxes, then Washington state should have an income tax. Pretty straightforward.
- throwaway_kufu 6y ago> I hear he also does a lot of charity work. I know I shouldn’t mix the individual with the public company he founded and I don’t want to be that person that says he only does it because the tax incentives. He is a person after all and I’m sure he deals with more social pressure as a result of his status and like all people has issues that strike a cord internally. Still there is something deeply troubling about people acquiring so much wealth that put them in that situation in the first place when he wouldn’t be there without his workers and yet significant numbers of them are on food stamps paid for by taxpayers...when his company paid $0 taxes.
- chillfox 6y agoI really wish people would stop seeing large companies paying low taxes as cheating and "loop holes". It is neither and it makes us blind to the cause of the problem. The politicians we vote in deliberately create laws that allow large companies to pay little to no tax. It is not an accident or a sneaky corporation that outwitted a dumb politician, it is by design.
- throwaway_kufu 6y agoThe same fellow who pitted cities and states against one another in a bidding war to obtain billions in tax credits for HQ2...and ultimately because the deals were so good he already reneged on the number of jobs promised by creating 2 new HQs resulting in 1/2 the jobs and investment while double dipping on the tax credits. Bernie said it best a single Amazon Prime membership is more than Amazon paid in taxes in 2017 and 2018 combined.
- astrange 6y ago> and ultimately because the deals were so good he already reneged on the number of jobs promised by creating 2 new HQs resulting in 1/2 the jobs and investment while double dipping on the tax credits. They lost the NY tax credits because they were so cartoonishly aggressive that AOC got the whole thing canceled by tweeting about it. Then they built it anyway without any credits.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- refurb 6y agoThey didn’t build it anyways. AOC takes anti-business position and was surprised when business go elsewhere.
- astrange 6y agoThey're building a large office in Hudson Yards, just not as large of one.
- refurb 6y agoNot an HQ by any means. Just an office.
- dx034 6y agoHQ is really just a name. You can call your smallest office the HQ if your CEO sits there, it has nothing to do with the number of employees. What's interesting to the government is where taxes are paid. But for large companies that got little to do with where workers are located.
- TeeMassive 6y agoIn the post-Covid era this will most likely be the last nail in the coffins for a huge portion of Amazon's competitors. Bezos knows this well.
- gentleman11 6y agoCorporate taxes are weird. All that money just goes into investing into the business. You should just tax the money as it goes out to investors and employees
- antaviana 6y agoIn fact that’s the idea of the tax system: tax the people according to their capacity. Corporate taxes were introduced as a means to pay some money in advance in their joirney to tax the people. That’s why in many countries the cascading of corporate tax plus dividends/savings tax is close to the marginal income tax rate of high income people. In other words, the initial goal was to essentially tax people’s income but corporate tax was introduced as a measure to prevent some of the wealthier people from not paying any income tax at all.
- gentleman11 6y agoIt’s harmful to the economy. They should just plug those tax loopholes
- sunsipples 6y ago"increase the taxes I avoid paying" bezos, probably
- spfzero 6y agoAmazon is in the category of companies that do business primarily in the US, and do not depend on global supply chains to bring its product to market (though they retail some). They are not competing with foreign companies to the extent that many manufacturers are. If you tax a US company that manufactures something easily manufactured in a lower-taxing country, you better not tax them at a higher rate than their competition, or you will eliminate them, and their jobs, and their stockholders equity.
- jl2718 6y agoSure, tax his competition out of business. Great idea. He’ll keep paying nothing. Mom and pop shops don’t have foreign data centers to push profits into.
- passivate 6y agoAs we demand corporations pay their fair share, the government needs to also show us that they can make effective use of the money. Will the Biden admin address the obscenely bloated discretionary military spending? https://imgur.com/a/Z0uiOcu https://imgur.com/a/Z0uiOcu
- watertom 6y agoAh, the Casey Kelso of the Internet: "I have this thing where I say stuff don't really mean."
- 1290cc 6y agoOf course he wants to increase corp taxes, this will make life incredibly difficult for his competition or new upstarts to challenge Amazon. He has already planned for this and how it will kill his competition. Amazon can afford to find the loopholes but hes right that most of his competitors can't.
- totetsu 6y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tUkXMZ0vtBE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tUkXMZ0vtBE regulatory capture as Werner Herzog put it.
- IvanaSays 6y agoSuch a humanitarian!
- rich_sasha 6y agoI don’t need higher tax rates, I want these taxes to be paid as they are, I’ll take that.
- spfzero 6y agoThat is a good point. There are so many loopholes left open that the typical large corporation pays far less than the existing rates. Small companies that can't play fancy games with offshore tax rates are the ones that get hurt.
- turbinerneiter 6y agoThis means higher taxes for small companies, like local stores, who don't have the lawyers to avoid them; and still no taxes for Amazon, which simply doesn't pay them.
- Jerry2 6y agoWhat he doesn't mention is that an increase in corporate taxes will mostly impact SMBs and not giant "Big Tech" companies that have all kinds of ways of avoiding them and employ hundreds of people in their finance and accounting departments who are tasked with minimizing taxes. It's your ma&pop stores that will take the brunt of it. In the same way that the new "Stimulus package" now requires that payment processors report any transaction over $600 on a 1099-K Tax Form, it's always the little guy that is mostly affected by the changes in tax law because little guys have no lobbyists and don't have an easy access to lawyers to fight the IRS.
- surfsvammel 6y agoCouldn’t one make the argument “there is no use because Big Tech have so many lawyers” no matter what the new policy is? If taxing the big companies is the aim, how does one gauge the policy suggestion? (I am not Americans just watching this curiously from outside) Edit: spelling
- otikik 6y agoWell one policy could be "tax companies with more than x lawyers".
- sofixa 6y agoThey'd just outsource them to a legal firm
- ekam 6y agoThis doesn’t work at all, many companies don’t have lawyers of their own but keep big law firms on retainer. And companies could just offload more onto JD-advantage employees/ law student interns anyways since they’re not “lawyers”
- terminalcommand 6y agoThey have both in-house counsels and work with external law firms. A reason for doing this is to avoid liability. Some big companies retain multiple law firms and ask the same advice a couple of times. If an overworked attorney who barely gets any sleep ever misses a point or drafts his/her advice vaguely in a way that would enable their evil plans, they rely on that single opinion. If there are any problems they don't assume any liability, because hey they got a legal opinion from a respectable law firm. Nobody needs to know/can prove they obtained multiple opinions on the same matter because of legal privilege. In return, big law gets paid a lot of $$$, because of the risk of providing such opinions under considerable pressure and trickstery.
- WalterBright 6y agoThe WSJ says that about 6% of Federal income tax comes from corporations, the rest from individuals. About 38% comes from the top 1% of individuals. Chasing corporations out of the country in order to raise that to 7% doesn't seem like a good idea.
- oblio 6y agoI keep hearing this, but how would that work? The US has what, a 250 million strong middle class with the highest purchasing power of any country over 20 million? Would companies actually back out if this tax increase would somehow be coupled with a threat of blocking their business in the US? For sure they wouldn't.
- WalterBright 6y ago> For sure they wouldn't. Companies outsource and offshore all the time when it is cheaper to do so. The US is a magnet for business. Trump lowered corporate tax rates and business boomed. The biggest companies in the world are all US. Why imperil that? > coupled with a threat of blocking their business in the US That's not practical, too many ways around it.
- brutal_chaos_ 6y agoSo Jeff Bezos is trying to earn back some good will. Bezos/Amazon is horrible to employees, and now we have a distraction that makes him look good. Such nonsense should never be news. In short: this is a stark example of a distracting puff piece that exists only to fool the public.
- tomcooks 6y agoGlad that someone can still read between the lines.
- matsemann 6y agoI wonder if he can have the same "redemption arc" that Gates have had. But I doubt it.
- dx034 6y agoI already wrote it somewhere else but can you really compare Bezos and Gates? Microsoft wasn't really popular back then (many people here will have hated it) but Gates was never really unpopular as a person. His treatment of workers was also not a reason for his public image.
- zephyr____ 6y agoAlternatively some see lobbying for increased taxes as a sign of bad will.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- briantakita 6y agoThe best way to eliminate the competition is to regulate the industry & increase taxes.
- throwawaysea 6y agoI don’t begrudge Amazon or any other company for paying as few taxes as is legally possible. I also am not in favor of unions as they are currently implemented in US law, where workers are forced to join unions and labor competition is reduced. I also think much of the media coverage of Amazon is unfairly biased against them. However, even to me, this moment where Bezos is supporting increased taxes seems highly suspicious. I simply don’t trust Bezos’s motives to suddenly support such policy. One possibility is that he sees it as an inevitability so he might as well support it and reap some goodwill with politicians. Another possibility is that infrastructure spending (which increased taxes would fund) benefits his business disproportionately. Another possibility is that this wouldn’t hurt Amazon much but would be the final blow for struggling small and medium size businesses that can’t compete with the juggernaut tech giants. Most likely it’ll take the form of Amazon avoiding taxes by (legally) claiming credits and deferrals where possible, while smaller businesses without the same massive capital, tax avoidance opportunities, and armies of accountants/lawyers will pay the new increased tax rates here and now. What we really need is updated anti trust laws and stringent enforcement. Where companies can’t be split up easily due to products dependent on network effects, we should regulate them like a public utility. We need to ensure healthy competitive markets.
- supermatt 6y agoIts all very well and good to state "we pay every penny we owe,", when you use creative accounting to get around "owing" in the first place. These loopholes, exemptions, "grants", etc need to be closed - THAT is fixing the problem - not increasing taxation for those that act honestly. That said, why are corporations taxed less than individuals when they are otherwise considered a legal person (but with increased indemnity!)? Thats should be addressed too, IMHO.
- nanna 6y agoThere's no defence for billionaires existing. 100% income tax for anything over a billion, say I.
- mcv 6y agoHow would you prevent billionaires from moving to a tax haven, though? That is the big loophole that both billionaires and large corporations benefit from, that others don't have access to.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- niceairport 6y agoFor example you can calculate how many percent of their revenue a company made in a given country and then how much tax they paid there and demand them to pay the difference.
- dx034 6y agoA country as large as the US has plentiful ways to ensure tax compliance by citizens. It's small countries that are forced to remain competitive. People won't flee the US by the millions just because you raise taxes.
- EdwinLarkin 6y agoYes.The only billionaires that should exist are the party members of the communist party /s
- Strom 6y agoMost billionaires don't own their wealth in money. It's stock and real estate. Therefore are you advocating that no one person should be allowed to control a large company or own large houses?
- drukenemo 6y agoThere are many good arguments in this thread, but ultimately he’s part of the new game of centralisation of power globally, which involves international political institutions and giant corporations. “You rub my back, I rub yours and we both win.”
- jodje 6y agothen why are his amazon european operations based in Ireland?
- WalterBright 6y agoShould tax pollution rather than creating value. There's certainly no shortage of polluting activities to tax.
- solutionsinfi 6y agonice blog thanks for sharing https://infinitotek.com/course-category/devops/ https://infinitotek.com/course-category/devops/
- solutionsinfi 6y agonice blog thanks for sharing https://infinitotek.com/course-category/devops/ https://infinitotek.com/course-category/devops/
- anothernewdude 6y agoBe the change you want to see
- refraincomment 6y agoExactly. He could donate 99% of his wealth, and still be billionaire. Yet he won't do that, he asks others to fix the public finances. While doing virtue signalling in public about equality. His company, along with google and Facebook are the biggest tax dodgers on earth.
- I_am_tiberius 6y agoFun facts about corporate taxation (Source: https://www.managementstudyguide.com/history-of-corporate-taxation.htm https://www.managementstudyguide.com/history-of-corporate-ta...): First introduced: 1894 Reintroduced: 1913 with a rate of 1% Personally this makes me assume that corporate tax should not exist. If it worked for hundreds of years without it, it's most likely just supporting the authority and growth of the state.
- dx034 6y agoFor the longest time companies didn't exist. Any business tended to be associated with a single person who paid taxes. Companies as a separate legal entity are comparably young. So the tax didn't exist because there wasn't much to tax before, not because it's wrong to have one.
- I_am_tiberius 6y agoThat is a misinterpretation. I say this because corporate tax is an addition to individual taxes. Taxes of individuals are paid anyway via P&L overhead!!! Owners of businesses pay personal income tax (which was lower 100 years ago as well) in addition to corporate income tax (plus tax on dividends).
- blackshaw 6y agoNot true. The first real corporations in the modern sense (private legal entities that existed separately from their owners) were the English and Dutch East India companies, which were founded in 1600 and 1602 respectively. 1894 is closer to the present day than it is to the first corporations. And the general legal concept of a "company" was hardly new in 1600 - in the Western world it dates back at least as far as Roman times. The Company of Merchants of the Staple of England was founded in 1319; the Company of Merchant Adventurers of London in 1407. Merchants and explorers in the 16th century and onwards used corporation-like entities to raise and organise the funding for their voyages. > there wasn't much to tax before Those European merchants made a hell of a lot of profit.
- 6y ago
- kypro 6y agoJeff Bezos honestly makes my blood boil. The guy has been blatantly advocating for policy that hurts SMBs for years while lobbying the government to do their bidding and getting away with selling it as caring for the poor and SMBS. Here's a pattern I see play out every few years: > Media rightly call out super rich for continuing to grow richer while people are struggling and SMBs fail > Politicians rightly call out super rich and say they're going to do something about it > Super rich come out in support of raising taxes, additional regulation, etc because who cares about laws and taxes if you're rich. Proceeds to lobby politicians for policies that help them. > Media praise super rich for supporting policies and politicians that will help the super rich while either not understanding motivation or out right lying about who the beneficiary of these policies will be. > Politicians implement policies that benefit the super rich while selling it to the public as something that's good for small business / those less fortunate. > Media praises politicians implementing policies that were push for by the super rich while claiming it will help small business / middle class.
- mysterydip 6y agoAgreed. Makes more sense when you remember who owns the majority of media companies.
- Mauricebranagh 6y agoMurdoc
- mcny 6y agoWhat’s really amazing is how WPP and Rupert Murdoch played the “oh look at what Pewdiepie is saying on YouTube. Does {brand} want its ads placed on it? Meanwhile, they’re trying to bully YouTube into giving them all the data about YouTube visitors.
- biztos 6y agoPewDiePie is a Swedish YouTube comedian apparently, in case anyone else found that reference obscure.
- posix_me_less 6y agoTaxes are ineffective and unjust because of loopholes which the most rich people can exploit. Government should just print more money instead.
- max1984_2 6y agoIf you print money, you will typically create inflation. Which pushes prices up. Yes you can mitigate the effects for quite a while by exporting inflation and other tricks but all you are doing is kicking the can down the road. If you want a "fair" tax. You would have a sales tax. Richer people and larger companies will typically spend more money than smaller businesses or poorer people and therefore will will pay a large proportion of tax and it will be taken at the point of purchase.
- posix_me_less 6y agoSales tax is a joke to the very rich and powerful. A guy with million dollars does not have to spend 1000x more on products and services than a regular guy with 1000 dollars. He uses that big money in different ways that do not get taxed by the sales tax. On the other hand, inflation taxes every positive-valued bank account roughly the same.
- max1984_2 6y ago> Sales tax is a joke to the very rich and powerful. A guy with million dollars does not have to spend 1000x more on products and services than a regular guy with 1000 dollars. He uses that big money in different ways that do not get taxed by the sales tax. They literally do spend a lot more of products and services than a regular Joe on the street, a sales tax would be taken at the point of purchase. Flash cars, fancy furnishings etc don't just come out of thin air. > On the other hand, inflation taxes every positive-valued bank account roughly the same. Inflation wrecks (the typically meagre) savings of regular people. It does not affect the wealthy who will have diversified investments and that will include things that are a hedge against inflation such as (but not limited to) precious metals, overseas investments etc. etc. I don't wish to be rude but you haven't thought this through.
- beaconstudios 6y agotaxation is a system of rules, and the very wealthy pay people to navigate those rules. leftists make the mistake of thinking that intent == outcome. "If we tax the rich more, then the government will have more money to spend on social services and the rich will have less money and therefore less power". In reality it doesn't work that way. Adding a new rule changes the game but often not in the way you intend. Or in other words, leftists tend to make the mistake of relying on reductionist thinking rather than systems thinking.
- mlthoughts2018 6y agoIt’s really sad that you are blind to your own severe discrimination. If you think in sweeping generalizations like, “leftists make the mistake...” you really need to step back and spend time not commenting at all and work harder to gain more self-awareness about your own prejudices. I know you will not like this comment and you will want to knee-jerk reply to “refute” it, but you need to resist that urge and admit you have really significant and really troubling prejudices that come through like a megaphone to others observing you, and spend time just dealing with that.
- beaconstudios 6y agoI think you misunderstand where I'm coming from. I agree with the goals of leftists - and with many left criticisms of late capitalism. My criticism comes from wanting those goals to be achieved more effectively. In other words, I think the left has successfully identified many problems in our society but lacks the tools to fix them, and I think I have an idea of what those tools might be (systems thinking primarily). I don't particularly care about your recommendation to self-crit. I spend enough time trying to criticise my own mental models as it is. I could cite some individual leftists that I think are doing great work in the space if you would like. I know the phrases I use are over generalising here, so feel free to imply the word "some" in front of the nouns.
- blankaccount 6y agohi!!!!!!
- exabrial 6y agoHe's welcome to pay all the taxes he wants. What a turd. What he wants is small businesses destroyed by taxes.
- IdontRememberIt 6y agoLet's tax capital gain same as revenue and change the tax regulation for foundations (my wife is in this business and her blood is boiling with what she sees) and let's see how Bezos, Buffet, Gates, etc. will react...
- yellowyacht 6y ago> change the tax regulation for foundations (my wife is in this business and her blood is boiling with what she sees) What are some of the issues your wife has seen here?
- IdontRememberIt 6y agoLet's simply say that for most foundations its only real purpose is to lower someone's tax bill and the most efficient way to transmit assets to one's kids. The name of this financial structure is so misleading. Honestly I find it fascinating from the PR/Marketing side.
- gruez 6y ago>Let's tax capital gain same as revenue So if a startup grows from a $1M valuation to $100M valuation they should be taxed on the $99M? That sounds like a great way to kill entrepreneurship and venture capital.
- catmanjan 6y agoI guess that's why people won't work harder to earn higher wages to avoid additional tax, wait, they do!
- gruez 6y agoThe point is that when investors are faced with the choice between investing in a incumbent (ie. "safe" company with limited growth potential) and challenger (high risk companies with high growth potential), such a tax would heavily favor incumbents because incumbents wouldn't be subject to the tax but the challenger would.
- frankbreetz 6y agoThis seems to not be the consensus amongst all corporate America[0]. It does seem that Jeff Bezos and Amazon have ulterior motives whenever an announcement like this comes out. See $15 minimum wage. I get the feeling that this will hurt their competitors more then them. I was in support of raising the corporate tax rate, but an announcement like this makes me rethink that. The infrastructure bill is obviously needed, where should the money come from? It seems to me the 1% should be paying for it somehow. A wealth tax? Increase the capitol gains tax? A carbon tax? It might not seem fair to say as long as Bezos hates it I'm on board, but we shouldn't be letting the richest person in the world decide our tax policy. [0]https://www.politico.com/news/2021/04/06/corporate-america-biden-infrastructure-plan-479490 https://www.politico.com/news/2021/04/06/corporate-america-b...
- ChoGGi 6y agoGood way to get rid of some competition.
- lmilcin 6y agoExcept Amazon is known to be pretty good at avoiding to pay taxes. The simplest explanation of this is 1) He doesn't think this is going to go anywhere or if it does, his message is going to influence anything. If the taxes are going to get increased, he could show he was for it. 2) Increased taxes will make it more difficult for competition to survive.
- freddealmeida 6y agoWe need a flat tax on corporates. No hiding from it. SMB's should have the lowest tax rate across the board. Tax rates should be near 15%. It would make the US a great option for building your firm. Now I think Singapore. Used to think HK. But honestly, we just want to pay reasonable taxes. But when Biden spends 6T in his first year... come on. America is no longer viable.
- andrewmcwatters 6y agoNot related to the post directly, but for years I’ve read kooks talk about all these ways that rich people avoid paying taxes. And yet none of them talk about the specifics of how they do it. The only exception I can think of is a CEO being paid $1 but compensated almost entirely in stock. Which makes no sense to me, because it sounds like it would violate minimum wage laws.
- thehappypm 6y agoWhen the CEO sells their stock to convert to cash they can actually use to buy things, they pay taxes. Stock isn't some magical way to avoid paying taxes.
- emrah 6y agoIsn't it easy enough to protect small businesses by putting a revenue threshold in these changes? While they are at it, how about also regulating "cash at hand" (like make it such that a corp can't hold more cash than a certain percentage of its revenue)
- mrlonglong 6y agoHe can start with making sure everyone subcontracted to Amazon to do deliveries receive decent conditions and benefits.
- jjk166 6y agoThe irony is that increased corporate taxes tend to mean big companies actually pay less tax. Corporate taxes are on profit, not revenue, so if a company spends all of the money it makes on investments, they owe the government nothing. Of course a profit seeking entity will want to take profits eventually, or else there is no point to investing, but if you are confident that corporate taxes will go down at some point in the future, it makes sense to invest now and take profits later. Small businesses might not be able to wait for very long for that eventual tax break, and corporate taxes can be a real burden for them, but a big company can always access capital if it needs to and can go decades without reporting a profit. If you were a billionaire leader of a massive corporation that was looking to spend billions in the next few years on capital expenses that reduce your reliance on labor, a corporate tax hike would be ideal. It's easier to get your board to go along with the big investment and it hurts any would-be competitors who needed the money. Bonus points if you convince the public that you're a man of the people.
- PoignardAzur 6y agoAm I the only one who finds it weird that, because Bezos said "I support X", a large proportion of HN finds itself mechanically saying "X is the worst thing in the world and Bezos only supports it because he's greedy and evil". I mean, I don't have any strong opinion on corporate taxes (I think they're not the most efficient way to tax large businesses, but whatever), but people here aren't exactly demonstrating great consistency. Like, the tax hike Bezos is referring to is essentially a partial reversal of the tax cuts Trump put into effect two years ago. I would be shocked if the majority of people who are saying the hikes Bezos supports are bad for small businesses would have said that the cuts Trump passed were good for small businesses back then. (Yes, there are ways "new tax hike bad, previous tax cut bad" can both be true; if you have any evidence this is the case, I'm really interested; but I'm absolutely certain the vast majority of posters here have no such evidence)
- thewileyone 6y agoLooks like AMZN HQ is going to move.