7 ms·
Laser Bear Honeycomb lidar
- Firerouge 6y agoSo this has got to be prohibitively expensive for home gamers if the request for information form's minimum order size listed is <100. Is there anything comparable for hobby project lidar scanning? Not necessarily wide angle, since you can always use a turntable, but capable of generating moderately dense point clouds.
- verdverm 6y agoThe latest Azure Kinect has a megapixel depth sensor, costd $400 iirc Video is 4 MP lots of nice open source to go with it these days
- shusson 6y ago> minimum order size listed is <100 not to mention they don't even specify how you can power or connect to the sensor.
- azernik 6y agoUsually that's in the datasheet they send during initial negotiations.
- malcolmwhite 6y agoIn my (coworker's) experience with this sensor, they don't send a datasheet or give any specs on power, but they will replace your demo unit when you ruin your first one by trying to power it with PoE.
- azernik 6y agoheaddesk Fucking hardware vendors
- jonas21 6y agoIf you have one of the new iPhones with lidar, there are a few apps (like Scaniverse [1]) that can generate dense point clouds and textured meshes. [1] https://scaniverse.com https://scaniverse.com
- dogma1138 6y agoI personally can’t wait till iPhone sensors come on a package that can be easily connected to a Pi or a Jetson these will leak into the generic supply chain in 1-2 refreshes.
- samatman 6y agoHope so but this depends on how patent encumbered they are, right? Like maybe you can just buy the part off Aliexpress but if no one is willing to put it onto a breakout board, let alone into a product, that's less broadly useful.
- dogma1138 6y agoChinese companies don’t care much for patents, you already have things like the HQ Pi camera with a decent Sony sensor simply because those are now more readily available. I don’t think the module itself is protected by patents that would prevent breakout boards especially from Chinese companies, you can buy replacement parts that Apple claims are counterfeit but in reality they are identical to the originals because they come from the same supplier just not from the same supply chain. The only question is how easy would it be to connect those sensors and make use of them if a lot of the logic that is required to drive them is buried in the Ax SoC from Apple it would be difficult if they use a rather standard protocol then it would rather simple.
- mike_d 6y agoThe Chinese government cares deeply about patents for companies that drive significant GDP.
- dljsjr 6y agoTypically the LIDARs that are on autonomous vehicles are pretty low "resolution" compared to smaller LIDAR packages like a Hokuyo or depth sensors like a Kinect. It wouldn't be good for fine detail scanning.
- echelon 6y agoAzure Kinect isn't great at resolution, either. Its depth sensor is an embarrassingly small VGA resolution, which sucks for realtime photogrammetry. Point cloud scenes look like sludge. Are there any "real time" depth sensors with high spatial and sensor resolution? I've been looking at FGPA-based solutions like Nerian Scarlett, and this seems to be closer to what I want [1], but still not quite good enough. [1] https://nerian.com/products/scarlet-3d-depth-camera/ https://nerian.com/products/scarlet-3d-depth-camera/
- dljsjr 6y agoThe reason I put resolution in quotes is that I wasn't referring to the image/buffer resolution but rather the ability to resolve fine details. For example, Hokuyo LIDARs can resolve details w/ ~millimeter resolution at close range (less than 10m). Another way to think about it is if you want to map your point cloud as a set of voxels in an octree, the smallest voxel is about 1m x 1m x 1m. Conversely, large LIDARs for vehicles like Ibeo and Velodyne and such typically map things with a resolution in the range of centimeters or larger. When you're looking for large things like other vehicles, people, obstacles, etc. then you can make those tradeoffs in the sensor design and fall back on things like vision for small feature detection in a more cost effective way.
- BugsJustFindMe 6y agoMinimum range 0. Maximum range?
- verdverm 6y ago500 meters or greater most likely, based on what Waymo equipped vehicle specs say
- coder543 6y agoVelodyne LiDAR sensors are 200m or less, it seems, so I highly doubt Waymo has a 500m sensor in this form factor. Glancing at articles from when this Waymo product was originally announced a couple of years ago, I saw some equally unhelpful speculation of “no more than 50 feet.” If it was 500 meters, surely they would say, because that would be really good.
- verdverm 6y agoTheir forward facing on vehicle 5th gen claim is 500m, from about 1 year ago. The lack of number on the webpage does leave one to speculate based on other sources...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- fastball 6y agoYep but the forward facing on Waymo vehicles is not the Laser Bear Honeycomb.
- ra7 6y agoThey claim >300m range: https://blog.waymo.com/2020/03/introducing-5th-generation-waymo-driver.html https://blog.waymo.com/2020/03/introducing-5th-generation-wa...
- porphyra 6y ago
- mvzvm 6y agoPoor waymo, having to pivot to selling peripherals it developed ever since dad cut the purse strings. I wonder how this bodes for their long term plan? From what I understand, Alphabet is getting less and less bullish on a lot of these moonshots.
- pastullo 6y agoIs it? Waymo seems to be doing pretty well, it has the largest fleet of autonomous cars and from what i remember by far the most extensive testing program on real streets. This looks more like an attempt to spread the R&D cost on lidar by selling to third parties. I guess as more and more companies sell their lidar solutions, it becomes more of a commodity and less a differentiation factor, like self-driving software for example.
- clapper 6y agoThere's an awful lot of hiring for a peripheral merchant.
- omarhaneef 6y agoFrom a purely economic perspective, this is probably a good strategy even if they had a huge budget. Each component should compete in the market place. If there are better components out there, your divisions should be able to buy them instead of internally developed ones. If a competitor can use your components better and build something better, they should etc. If a competitor can provide better intermediate products using your components, buy them and incorporate them in your system. You only have to be one of the best at one thing, and you should be the one of the best at a few things, and you could be one of the best at many things.
- bengale 6y agoSeems more like a better way to gather information on larger projects working with similar hardware.
- paxys 6y agoThe moment Sundar became CEO of Alphabet it should have been clear that the whole experiment was a failure. It is probably too much work to dissolve the entity and fold all the moonshots back into Google, but that's effectively how things are running now.
- stcredzero 6y agoThere's one entire category of applications, which is going to drive disruption that's going to obsolete LIDAR. Namely military applications. Active sensors aren't viable anymore for military applications outside of severely asymmetrical conflicts. Active sensors will advertise their position to seekers and guided ordinance. Passive sensors are going to be required for military autonomy, and military R&D will guarantee these will supplant active sensors like LIDAR. Let's say that Tesla goes 100% pacifist, and declares that no Tesla technology, like Dojo, will ever be used for military purposes. Just the fact that Tesla FSD had solved computer vision and the fact that Dojo exists will guarantee that someone will replicate those things for military applications. Active sensors could still become so cheap, however, that they will be used in applications where each unit must be very cheap and therefore can't have the onboard processing for full-blown autonomy AI and computer vision. LIDAR could then be used to reduce unit costs for those super low unit-cost applications. These LIDAR would be much smaller and much lower power than the LIDAR for autonomous cars.
- threeseed 6y agoExcept that Tesla hasn’t solved computer vision and may never. Also Dojo isn’t some magical technology. It’s an FPGA platform which we have available today on AWS and hasn’t changed the game for deep learning use cases. It’s just edge optimised. LiDAR however has changed the game. It works well and costs are rapidly coming down.
- stcredzero 6y agoExcept that Tesla hasn’t solved computer vision and may never. Want to wager? Have you seen the FSD beta videos? Looks like they've pretty much solved it for autonomous driving. Also my experience when using Tesla FSD with Navigate on Autopilot. It pretty much looks inevitable at this point. Also Dojo isn’t some magical technology. The magic, is how they won't have to label manually. It will automate the labelling. LiDAR however has changed the game. It works well and costs are rapidly coming down. Just like Scotty Kilmer when he says, "changed the game." Using cameras + AI will leapfrog it for applications like autonomous driving. What will be left, are applications where you can't afford too much processing. I agree with you that LIDAR will get cheap enough for that. Also, you don't even address my main point about military applications and active sensors. I'm kinda proud of that bit of reasoning.
- layoutIfNeeded 6y agoIs this how they gonna wind down Waymo?
- ncallaway 6y agoMaybe. It never hurts to be the one selling boots and shovels in a gold rush, though.
- paxys 6y agoWaymo has long been considered to be leading the self driving gold rush, and if they themselves are bowing out and selling tech to their competitors then it doesn't paint a rosy picture for the future.
- ncallaway 6y agoSure, I agree that they've been in the ground digging for a long time. But, if they can transition to both being digging and selling shovels and boots, that's definitely a better position for them to be in.
- paxys 6y agoI don't think the two are compatible. For example if running a self-driving taxi service is viable and profitable then Google will be doing everything in its power to corner the market, rather than also selling the tech to Uber & Lyft and competing with them.
- ncallaway 6y ago"If running a self-driving taxi service is viable" If is doing a lot of work in that sentence... If it's not profitable (or may not be for a while), then they'd sure like to at least be selling components to others working on the problem.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bostonpete 6y agoThis is 2 years old, right...? https://venturebeat.com/2019/03/06/waymo-is-selling-lidar-sensors-for-robotics-security-and-agriculture/ https://venturebeat.com/2019/03/06/waymo-is-selling-lidar-se...
- vitus 6y agoSigns point to yes: https://web.archive.org/web/20190308225112/https://waymo.com/lidar https://web.archive.org/web/20190308225112/https://waymo.com...
- Jabbles 6y agoWho do you think their largest customers will be?
- ncmncm 6y agoEven Google writes "everyday" as a noun, now. Sigh. (Clue: "everyday": adjective; ordinary. "every day": noun phrase; all days.) Anyway, Google marketing dept does. Or did, one may hope.
- kevmo 6y agoMicrovision is bad at PR, but they appear to be winning here. https://www.nasdaq.com/press-release/microvision-inc.-announces-progress-on-its-automotive-long-range-lidar-a-sample-2021 https://www.nasdaq.com/press-release/microvision-inc.-announ...
- blackguardx 6y agoEven so, Microvision is better at PR than they are at making products! I suspect this is a dying gasp to bump up their stock price. They barely have any engineers after their last layoff.
- fnord77 6y agoI like how the MVIS stock spiked to almost 1000 twenty years ago, then cratered to a penny stock until it got pumped recently.
- tsumnia 6y agoOne of the mods in their subreddit willingly bought and tore apart a Microsoft Hololens to prove that it was using Microvision's products [1]. It happened at the time of the mass COVID scare, but I think it got its resurgence from the latest EV push / GME squeeze. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OmiQvjQuFqQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OmiQvjQuFqQ
- kjksf 6y agoSpaceX: you want to launch a satellite into space? Here's how much it costs and here's a web page to order a ride-sharing mission. Waymo: want to buy a lidar from us? Tell us about yourself...
- ur-whale 6y ago> Tell us about yourself. Cultural DNA is hard to shake.
- ra7 6y agoI imagine they do it because they don't want to sell to a competitor.
- monkmartinez 6y agoNeedless friction. A competitor is going to get one if they really want it.
- alisonkisk 6y agoThe ride-share is available at https://waymo.com/waymo-one/ https://waymo.com/waymo-one/ (SpaceX doesn't sell their rocket parts.)
- Judgmentality 6y agoThat's still an apply-to-be-accepted beta program, not something the public can actually use/purchase.
- porphyra 6y agoThe Ouster OS0 and Hesai PandarQT are generally much better choices since they... * match the field of view of the Laser Bear Honeycomb (OS0: 360 x 90 deg; PandarQT: 360 x 104 deg; Waymo: 360 x 95 deg) * produce 10x as many points per second * are available for sale to customers who wish to use them in autonomous vehicles * have no external moving parts that are liable to get gunked up with wet leaves * have longer range Although the main drawbacks are that the Ouster OS0 has only single return and the Hesai PandarQT has dual returns, compared to the Laser Bear Honeycomb's several returns.
- cup_of_joe 6y agoThe naming for this product sounds like the marketing dept. just concatenated the most popular options from a word cloud
- lgats 6y ago[2019] please https://web.archive.org/web/20190424045352/https://waymo.com/lidar/ https://web.archive.org/web/20190424045352/https://waymo.com...
- nosmokewhereiam 6y agoNobody tilts their lidar heads 45 degrees. With velodyne 32, we achieved better resolution when mapping highways by doing so. Why don't I see that ever? Is it solved or done better horizontally?
- neighbour 6y agoThis title reads like a password generated by a password manager.
- oliv__ 6y agoIs this an April fool's joke?
- stingrae 6y agoEveryone is complaining about hiding pricing. Hiding pricing is standard practice for most electronic components that you would integrate into an electronics project. It's a method of select customers that won't need a lot of support or will give the volume that makes it worthwhile.
- dasudasu 6y agoPretty much, yeah. At my hardware-focused corp, we have specific supply chain people that will argue about price all day. It's just a different business world than retail.
- gingerbread-man 6y agoAm I crazy, or is this a reference to one of the cheat codes on Age of Empires?
- jit_ray_c 6y agoThe entire waymo website including the lidar page has been revamped right after this discussion. In case anyone want to revisit the cool new site http://waymo.com/lidar http://waymo.com/lidar