19 ms·
Probably an unpopular opinion, but I don't think most people who buy a Linux phone actually want a Linux phone. They want an open-source phone. The Linux philos
by phendrenad2 6y ago
Probably an unpopular opinion, but I don't think most people who buy a Linux phone actually want a Linux phone. They want an open-source phone. The Linux philosophy isn't important to them, they essentially want open-source iOS (with all of the polish and out-of-the-box doodads). They want the ability to make modifications, and they want the freedom and transparency that open-source gives them, but they don't necessarily want to open a PR against the camera app if they want it to more closely match the polish of iOS.
- samatman 6y agoYou're probably right but— why buy a Linux phone then? There's LineageOS and F-Droid, or even Replicant if you're all-in on free software and don't mind running on a Galaxy 8. I'm maybe not the guy to ask, I have curiousity and professional interest in open source phone stuff but I've had an iPhone since the 4, and plan to spend a total of less than 5 hours a year debugging my phone for the foreseeable future. I'm not sure that pruning apps off my homescreen or rebooting a few times a year to solve some heisenbug really counts as debugging, but it's already closer than I care to be.
- SilverRed 6y agoBecause when you rely on the android ecosystem, the rug gets pulled out more and more. LineageOS works on less and less new and common phones and SaftyNet blocks you from more and more features. Android also comes with a bunch of anti features like an api to block the user from taking screenshots. Its better to completely replace the OS with something Google doesn't control.
- jhasse 6y agoName one SafetyNet app that works on the Pinephone or the Librem 5.
- sofixa 6y ago> Android also comes with a bunch of anti features like an api to block the user from taking screenshots. When it came out there's a malware campaign that tries to extract MFA codes from Google Authenticator by taking screenshots, there was a lot of criticism towards Google for not setting the flag that activated that API and made screenshots impossible, and it's a good solution, there's no viable scenario in which you'd want to screenshot your MFA TOTP codes. I admit that i'm sometimes annoyed with it's use in banking apps, but IMHO it's a needed feature for security.
- PurpleFoxy 6y agoWhy do random apps get access to the screenshot feature? Why would there ever be a reason to prevent a screenshot when the user presses the hardware buttons for a screenshot?
- akvadrako 6y agoWhy are you calling security an anti-feature? Lineage support will hopefully get better with the new Android split between system with drivers and userspace.
- f1refly 6y agoBecause when my device stops me, the user, from doing something I want, thats an antifeature. In this case I want to take a screenshot, and the device prevents this.
- akvadrako 6y agoJust remove the restriction from the app. If you are in control of your phone it isn't hard.
- SilverRed 6y agoIt actually is hard. When I looked in to it the only way to fix the issue was using xposed modules which did not work on my version of android/phone and is a security risk because I now have to load some untrusted module as root so I can get the phone to stop blocking me from what I'm trying to do.
- akvadrako 6y agoWhy don't you just disable the flag in the app which blocks screenshots?
- f1refly 6y agoIt'd be way easier if I could turn if off device-wide instead of trying to work out how to modify the obfuscated app my bank provides.
- TheCoelacanth 6y agoSecurity is when the device stops people other than the owner from doing something the owner doesn't want. This is the opposite. The device is stopping the owner from doing something that someone else doesn't want.
- kelnos 6y agoI think the issue with LineageOS (and CM before it) is that they're always playing catch-up, both in terms of porting to the latest version of Android, and in terms of supporting new hardware. Want to run Lineage on your brand-new phone? Nope. Want the latest version of Android a few months after it's released? Not gonna be LineageOS. (To be fair, most Android manufacturers take more than a few months to get the latest version of Android out to their users, assuming they do it at all.) You can say "so what, it still works!" but I think there are weird psychological effects at play when you can make a direct comparison like "Android 37 was released 8 weeks ago but LineageOS is still on 36!" It makes Lineage feel like a second class citizen. In contrast, if you have a phone that is designed specifically to run a custom non-Android-based OS, there's nothing to directly compare it to. Sure, you can say things like "I wish my FoobarOS phone had Google Pay like Android does", but you still inherently get the fact that they are completely different platforms and won't have app/feature parity. I used to run CM years ago, but quit even before the LineageOS fork/transition, because I was always looking at the latest-and-greatest Android releases (even for my particular phone hardware) and feeling left behind. And it was even worse when things should have worked but didn't because of some peculiarity of CM, or things like apps refusing to run on rooted phones. I'm really considering getting a PinePhone just to try it out. I know that I will miss Google Pay and some other things, but I'd be going into it not expecting those to be there, and expecting it to be a different platform with a different experience and different features.
- eptcyka 6y agoLineage runs on phones that have far superior hardware spec wise to the Pinephone and Librem 5. And I'd wager there's more people working on Lineage than there are working on Librem's and Pine's phone OSes combined.
- khimaros 6y agoPixel 2+ with GrapheneOS, RattlesnakeOS, or CalyxOS provide pure AOSP experience sans Google and track latest Android releases within days. Depending on your needs you can control your own image build pipelines and still get verifiable boot and automated OTA updates.
- 6y ago
- ekianjo 6y agoCan you actually buy a phone with LineageOS and proper hardware support?
- jhasse 6y agoYes.
- ekianjo 6y agoSOmething that will be supported in the years to come by LineageOS? I'd very surprised.
- jhasse 6y agoWhy? If you look at the list of supported devices there are lots of older models. I'm currently using the latest LineageOS on a Galaxy S4 (8 years old) and it works perfectly. If you want commercial support have a look at https://esolutions.shop/ https://esolutions.shop/ (/e/ is based on LineageOS).
- akvadrako 6y agoNot a good phone.
- zepto 6y ago> They want the ability to make modifications, and they want the freedom and transparency that open-source gives them Do they really? iOS isn’t just not open source because we don’t have the source. It’s also not open source because it isn’t developed in the open or intended for a community to work with. It seems like the thing you are saying people want just isn’t real. This isn’t to say you are wrong - but if you are right, it just means the people who are buying these phones don’t just don’t understand open source.
- ragnese 6y agoI definitely agree that I don't want a "Linux phone". I just want an open-as-possible phone that isn't 100% user-privacy-hostile. I couldn't give two flips if it is the Linux kernel that accomplishes that, but I think it's pretty obvious that Linux is our only reasonable hope.
- jay_kyburz 6y agoI bought one because I was hoping to tinker with things, and also I wanted to be able to do things that iOS won't allow. (like have a filesystem) I had imagined that because KDE was so solid on my desktop that it would be really solid on the phone, but I think the phone is not just fast enough. I was really happy with my feature phone, but had to give it up because I kept pocket dialing the emergency services. I wish I could find a shell that was as simple. I would love a shell that was as fast and responsive and had the features of my Nokia 3310. I love these phones https://www.nokia.com/phones/en_in/feature-phones https://www.nokia.com/phones/en_in/feature-phones The only thing they are missing in my opinion is a browser.
- kgwxd 6y agoThe Linux philosophy is important to me in a desktop, but I don't think I'd really care about it on a phone. If it were eventually to be both, then I would, but I never really believed in that goal. If I'm going to use a computer in desktop mode, I'd rather just have a proper desktop, with hardware that is unrestrained by the smaller form factor.
- throwaway12757 6y agoI was really hoping that Ubuntu Touch would have filled this market. I was excited for it to come out and then it never did. I just wanted a phone that works as a phone and then I can plugin to a dock and I get a full linux desktop experience. It's still a thing, but nowhere near what it was when they were trying to launch an actual phone. https://ubports.com/devices/promoted-devices https://ubports.com/devices/promoted-devices
- seba_dos1 6y agoYou can use a Librem 5 in this exact way. I do it - it's fast enough to run an IDE and do some programming (as long as the thing you work on compiles in reasonable time), check e-mail, IM and social media, do some light browsing etc. I have GIMP, Inkscape, Audacity and LMMS there, which together with Qt Creator are pretty much all the tools I need for my gamedev work - and now I can do that on my phone attached to a screen, keyboard and mouse. Jamulus, Mumble, mpd, even some lighter games and emulators - it all works, straight from Debian repos. It's pretty fun. I have even ran a full Plasma Desktop on an external screen this way - and it worked surprisingly well even despite of GPU acceleration not being available there because of a bug.
- ralusek 6y agoOpen source phone with polish? So, Android?
- mpd 6y agoAndroid is an open source OS, but not a "phone". It's the core, but you need more than that to boot it on a particular device.
- Koliakis 6y agoI don't understand this comment. Am I not allowed to use Linux if I haven't ever committed code to an open source project? I've been using Linux for 15 years. Are you taking away my Linux card and am I being banned from the platform? Because your argument makes no sense at all as to why I might want a Linux phone. I want a Linux phone for the same reasons why I use a Linux laptop and PC. Freedom, control over my computing environment and my data, that sort of thing. Taking a step back, there is no mobile OS out there that provides the things that I want. The closest that I've seen is Linux for the PinePhone. So, yeah, I want a Linux phone. It's not that my initial premise was "I want a Linux phone". It's "I want control and I want to have the freedom to do what I want with my device, so what system currently offers that kind of freedom while being feasible on technical and usability levels?"
- OJFord 6y agoI want a Linux phone. I like open source too, but I'm not serious about it, I want to be able to fix things or file an issue on GitHub or whatever if necessary, but I don't have the energy to worry about proprietary blobs. Having control of my phone and its configuration like I do my Linux desktop is what I want, but I'm slightly resigned to perhaps not getting it because of app support (I tried Anbox on my desktop, it was buggy and slow, with a fraction of the RAM I dread to imagine) - so I've been thinking about and occasionally working on a Terraform provider for Android instead. So far I'm using it to install all apps, no Play Store at all; I'd like to have it handle settings too. So yes, it is Linux more than OSS that appeals to me here, because it's control more than openness that interests me in it. (I suppose some wouldn't see a distinction, and that's partly why it is more important to others.)
- rahimnathwani 6y agoWould you be happy with a FreeBSD phone?
- Shared404 6y agoOnly if I can install a program without needing a developer account with the manufacturer.
- speed_spread 6y agoNo! On the other hand, a TempleOS phone would make my day, and the CIA's.
- NexRebular 6y agoA lot happier than with a linux phone. Would love to have an illumos phone too, but won't get my hopes up for that happening any time soon...
- Koliakis 6y agoIs somebody working on one?
- 6y ago
- kelnos 6y agoI don't know how representative I am, but I just want something that respects my privacy and doesn't try to monetize my every interaction, while being open enough that I can run what I want on it (apps, not OS). Android fails at the first and iOS fails at the second. I like in principle that Android is open source (minus all the proprietary junk getting jammed into Play Services). I or someone could verify that it's not sending my data to a sketchy third party, but only to a point. Unless the OS and all apps are completely open source, any closed source component could be secretly betray me. Ironically, though, I trust Apple a lot more to write privacy-respecting code even though it's all proprietary. But on Android I do what I can to mitigate these issues, by running as much tracking- and ad-blocking software as I can (a thing that isn't really possible on iOS, at least not to the same extent). And I do have some apps sideloaded that I'd miss if I had an iPhone. But I still assume that Google is not being a good steward of any data it gleans from my Android usage, and that sucks. I don't care too much about the ability to make modifications. The hurdle to jump to go from a stock to custom ROM is pretty high nowadays, as I expect most financial apps (and probably some others) to aggressively detect enabled root access and refuse to run. And the process of building your own OS images to make tweaks is not particularly fun, and can be a mess to clean up if you make a mistake. It's critical to me that my phone doesn't have downtime, so I'm less likely to mess around with it. The problem with the current crop of "Linux phones" is that (while they do respect privacy, don't try to monetize every interaction, and are open enough to run what I want on them) they don't have anywhere near the polish of iOS or Android, and are (understandably) missing key applications that I use daily. So anything I use will have trade offs. For better or worse (probably worse) I've chosen the easier path of Android, at least for now. Having said that, I do think I want to get a PinePhone, not to use as my primary mobile device, but as something to tinker around with. Maybe it's something that eventually could be a primary device, at least for some situations, but I don't see that as being the case without a lot of work, and a lot of customization that I have to do myself, which I don't really care to do all that much.
- harrisonjackson 6y agoThat was my first thought. What does a linux phone offer a user (feature/usage-wise!) that my jailbroken iphone didn't? ...back when I felt the need to jailbreak at least - now with altstore, ios improvements, or my own dev-ish - I am good.
- pogo99 6y agoIt allows me to run any linux desktop program, which includes programs that can be run with wine, anbox or even a virtual machine. If it's fast enough i wouldn't need a PC at all. So I would say that is the long term goal: convergence. Linux has a major advantage over other operating systems in this regard.
- asddubs 6y agowine alone wouldn't allow you to run x86 apps
- pogo99 6y agoI suppose you would have to use qemu userspace emulation at least.
- heavyset_go 6y agoThere's definitely a way to use Wine along with binfmt_misc to run x86 apps on ARM or other architectures. edit: Hangover lets you run x86 programs via Wine on ARM platforms: https://github.com/AndreRH/hangover https://github.com/AndreRH/hangover
- swiley 6y agoMost of those need apps re-signed all the time and can't do push notifications. iSH almost looks usable and then you try compiling something or cloning a git repo and your iphone will get hotter than a pinephone watching youtube (and whatever you do can be fairly precisely measured in ~15 minute increments because it takes ages.)
- jolmg 6y agoAt least personally, I want a phone that works similarly to my Linux machines. I have scripts that maintain a synchronized configuration across all of them, and I don't want my phone to be some snowflake that must be treated specially. I want access to the same applications; I want to be able to run strace on random processes to understand what they're doing; I want to be able to organize my files under $HOME the same way I do in my other machines. I want a Linux phone (ideally of a similar distro). It being open source is just part of that. This is also the reason why I'm not really attracted to PineTime, despite it being open source. If by polish you refer to aesthetic stuff like animations and whatnot, I don't really care about it.
- rodolphoarruda 6y agoI want a phone I can own, like my sofa. It is out there in my living room just waiting for me to do whatever I want to do with it. My Android phone doesn't work that way. The company behind it expects me to do certain tasks with the phone. Some tasks are open for gradual adoption, other aren't, meaning they are mandated. After all those years, I'm beginning to dislike that.
- rainyMammoth 6y agoGood point. And the company behind Android mainly wants to ensure they can get as much data from you as possible. You will never fully be able to disable the data upload to Google.
- krmboya 6y agoA primary requirement I've had over the past few years when purchasing a phone is whether it is supported by Lineageos. Less data is collected hopefully, without gapps installed.
- LMYahooTFY 6y agoInteresting how this seems to be the common belief, but AFAIK AOSP does not do this, while ironically Lineage uses Google for connectivity servers and fallback DNS.
- LMYahooTFY 6y agoSource about android uploading to google? Pretty sure AOSP does not do this.
- rpdillon 6y agoThis analogy perfectly captures how I feel, and it's so elegantly concise. I suspect I'll be borrowing this in future conversations...thanks!
- Terretta 6y ago
- heavyset_go 6y agoI've had a Nokia N900 and the few Palm/HP Pre models that were released, the former ran Maemo and the latter webOS. Both OSes were based on Linux. I want a Linux kernel, because even though today I'd list the modern niceties like namespaces, containers, WireGuard, NFS 4.2+, back in the Maemo days, having a Linux kernel still paid dividends. All of the standard networking and WLAN debugging tools you had on desktop Linux were available in your pocket, FUSE meant you could use sshfs, etc. The userland was the same GNU userland you'd find on most Linux distros, you could use X11 forwarding via ssh, GTK apps worked, and you had apt as the system package manager. I want that again. Android doesn't come close, and neither does iOS.
- danans 6y ago> I want a Linux kernel, because even though today I'd list the modern niceties like namespaces, containers, WireGuard, NFS 4.2+ NFS on a phone? What's the use case for that? Isn't it easier at that point to use small linux laptop?
- heavyset_go 6y agoI have my media collection shared via NFS over my VPN. I want to use MPD locally on my phone like I could on Maemo. Also, if I'm at a friend's place who has a Roku, Chromecast etc, I can already cast media from my NFS collection easily from my Linux laptop via VPN. I want to be able to do the same thing with my phone.
- jorams 6y agoI have a pretty good setup for MPD on Android. It's not perfect, but quite nice. https://www.joram.io/blog/android-streaming-mpd/ https://www.joram.io/blog/android-streaming-mpd/
- heavyset_go 6y agoAwesome, thanks for sharing this.
- rektide 6y agoLinux users want phones with comfortable infrastructure that is hackable, and known, and richly powerful, with a wide base of people generating creative contributions. Linux isn't popular (with the hip crowd) because merely because it's better (though it is), or because it's hackable (though it is) Linux is popular because it's a rich technical ecosystem with robust layers of technology operating together but each modifiable, lovingly adopted by power users, each opting in to trying to improve themselves & their systems. You can recreate the "ability to make modifications" (although you'll struggle to come to anywhere near the seriously integrated layers of technology Linux environments so robustly build). You can offer "Freedom and transparency" to be able to tinker. But it's the co-participation with other tinkerers, with many venerable but separate & adjustable/hackable layers, that makes Linux so rifely diverse & compelling. In short, my strong belief is: people want Linux phones. The technical ecosystem is more interesting as a whole than any array of boxes/capabilities one might tick.
- wayneftw 6y agoI just want to be able to install my own apps on iOS without paying anybody and without asking anybody's permission.
- idle_zealot 6y agoJIT in sideloaded apps would be nice too.
- macksd 6y agoI definitely want an open-source phone for all the reasons you mentioned, but I absolutely also want a Linux phone. I'd love to live in a world where BSD or Minix became The Thing™, but since it didn't I basically live and breath Linux for work and that spills over into my personal usage too. Interoperability between my phone and my laptop is huge. I recently started using KDE Connect (and okay - that doesn't have to be Linux-specific) and being able to seamlessly copy / paste between devices, etc. is a game changer for me.
- Krisjohn 6y agoI bought a Pine Phone. I want a Linux phone. I don't want "open-source iOS", whatever that is. I don't care about that kind of "polish", I want access to (a good portion of) the same "Linux software library" that I use on my Linux laptops, VMs and Raspberry Pis. Plus it's nice to be able to make a phone call from it or take a photo occasionally.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 6y agoSome polish would help. Ubuntu phone OS is just awful. The first thing I did was starting to check what else is available. That is not a step a typical use is willing to make. And sadly, pine is still not my daily driver. At this time, it is a toy. I want control over my devices, so linux phone is not a bad idea. We keep missing on execution though.
- ekianjo 6y ago> And sadly, pine is still not my daily driver. At this time, it is a toy. It was never sold as a daily driver and this was always made abundantly clear in every Pine store page since the beginning of time. Even now they only call their latest version "beta" for a good reason.
- Qwertious 6y ago>but I don't think most people who buy a Linux phone actually want a Linux phone. They want an open-source phone. Both of those are missing the point IMO. What people really want, is a phone that is on their side. iOS doesn't support open standards like Vulkan mainly because it's not in Apple's interest to support them. Not because it's in the user's interest, necessarily. What people really want is a phone that they can trust to be on their side implicitly. The nugget of brilliance in Free Software is saying "if you do all this stuff, then the power will be so tilted towards you that you will be able to trust your software to be on your side". People want something that's both polished, and won't [forego polish in one particular area for the sake of the company's interests/$$$].
- rlayton2 6y agoYes, this is the point. For example, I want a phone where I can send faked GPS data to apps that request GPS permissions (and so on).
- hellisothers 6y agoAs a developer I don’t want people sending my app spoofed data.
- abraae 6y agoAs a user I want a way to bypass your overly intrusive data collection on me.
- hulahoof 6y agoAgreed, but as a user I do want this option and so the parent post point stands - the device should be on the owners side, not the app developers.
- belval 6y agoI am the one paying for the phone so I should get to pick what information it will tell you.
- 6y ago
- SavantIdiot 6y agoI want to know that the source code on my phone has been peer reviewed. However, this does not always mean backdoors are caught. For example, the NSA injected a potential back door into openSSL. It was caught, but only a small number of people are smart enough to catch something like this. STILL: it was open source. I like that. I would buy a linux phone even if it sucked a little, knowing that I could view the source code.
- Aperocky 6y agoI don't quite understand the obsession. I have a phone, I don't use it for too many purposes, whatever software that is installed on it doesn't bother me much because there are larger pie to fry. Now desktop OS and laptop choices/ cloud native stuff is a hill I'm willing to die on, because I'm a lot more invested.
- EamonnMR 6y agoLaptops and desktops are being replaced by phones. The appeal of a FOSS phone is that it makes the world safe for general purpose computing by taking back some of the territory lost to phones.
- Aperocky 6y agoAre they? I see them as purely client end. Same reason I don't have an issue using iPad as development machine with termux.
- Apocryphon 6y agoI'm not even sure if most users who use Linux computers actually want Linux computers. If they do, why are there so many attempts towards recreating the macOS UI and UX in Linux, such as with Elementary OS? Or back in the '90s/'00s, attempts towards recreating the Windows UI/UX? Maybe people also do just want general open-source computing, and Linux just happens to be the one that's furthest along, its philosophy and ideology be damned. Personally, I'm hoping Haiku eventually gets further along to be usable as a Linux alternative, and it's fun to wonder what it would be like as a mobile OS.
- skinkestek 6y agoI'm one of those and have been for 20 years. Yes, KDE has copied Windows features. But: they made it better (for people like me). I didn't get Windows, but something that happened to look similar but work better. And the latest big Windows update copied a good deal of styling from KDE Plasma so they are clearly doing something interesting :-)
- axiolite 6y ago> why are there so many attempts towards recreating the macOS UI and UX in Linux I imagine it's because, when the year of the Linux desktop didn't arrive, developers everywhere decided they could make it happen if only they tried hard enough to put together the perfect UI, and so the kitchen-sink approach proliferated. > Or back in the '90s/'00s, attempts towards recreating the Windows UI/UX? I take exception to this one. In fact it was Microsoft with Windows 7 (released in 2007) which copied much of the UI of older Linux desktops like KDE and GNOME versions 1.0 (circa 1997). See: https://linuxgazette.net/165/misc/laycock/gnome.png https://linuxgazette.net/165/misc/laycock/gnome.png https://images.channelpartner.de/bdb/490847/1066x600.jpg https://images.channelpartner.de/bdb/490847/1066x600.jpg Linux desktop environments were better back then. XFce is the only tolerable one I can think of, today. Even there, I hate the defaults and preferred it in the XFce3 days when it was just an (improved) CDE clone. Fluxbox or bust!
- Apocryphon 6y agoLindows came out in August 2001. There's also ReactOS, though admittedly it's a non-Linux open source OS.
- danShumway 6y agoI guess? But Linux provides those things. Break it apart, what this is saying is, "you don't want X, you want something that doesn't exist that theoretically provides all of the advantages of X." Which, sure. I could (and do) use LineageOS right now. It's not as good. I still need to go through the Android app development process, I'm still fighting the system every step of the way. It's still a pain to de-Google things, I still have to deal with an architecture that if fundamentally designed to work best with Google services. I still have to deal with what I see as design flaws in Android itself. So I don't technically need this to be Linux. I recently bought a smartwatch that runs on an ESP32 chip and is programmed using Arduino code/C++. It's not running Linux, but it fits a lot of my needs and it will communicate well with my Linux computer. And you're right, I didn't have serious qualms about that because of the kernel. In fact, the simpler dev process was what made it attractive. However, there isn't that kind of thing for phones. If you want an Open Source phone that is easy to modify and develop on, Linux is the option that's pushing in that direction. > but they don't necessarily want to open a PR against the camera app if they want it to more closely match the polish of iOS. It's deeper than that: I want the ability to fix my own problems. I don't want to open a pull request, I want software that is understandable enough and an ecosystem that is open enough and broad enough that it is reasonable for me to fix my own problems. I (personally) can do that on Linux, but I can't (currently) do it on Android devices, they're a pain to work with and I hate them. I am used to Linux on my computers, including the fragmentation of software. Sometimes the fragmentation is an advantage because it means there's a diversity of software that is hyper-specialized rather than one or two solutions that are built to kind-of satisfy "most" people's needs. More than Linux itself, what I am used to is the idea that if something goes wrong or if I want my computer to do something, I can make it happen without asking anybody else's permission, without building a giant project that I need to invest serious time into, that I can pull things apart and build pipelines with Unixy tools. I want that on my phone. It doesn't have to be Linux, but nothing else is providing it, so it does have to be Linux unless someone else is going to build a better OS. I'm not holding my breath for that.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- drivingmenuts 6y agoI think they mostly just want a cheaper iPhone that they can mostly play with the cosmetics and have free apps. For most, the ability to improve the code is not really a thing.
- vbezhenar 6y agoI agree. I love Android philosophy, but it's getting more and more closed with every year. Just one example: call recording. It was available in the past, in modern Android versions those apps no longer work.
- mariusor 6y agoI _actually_ want a linux phone. I want to be able to run some of the applications from my linux desktop on my phone.
- akvadrako 6y agoBut you could do that with FreeBSD.
- mariusor 6y agoI'm not sure to which phone you're referring to. Is there one that runs FreeBSD?
- heavyset_go 6y agoFreeBSD doesn't support 802.11ac
- akvadrako 6y agoTrue, or ax.
- 1penny42cents 6y agoIsn't that what the article is saying? :)
- qwertox 6y agoI'd want one so I can run some Python scripts in the background. Where I can use apt and install whatever I want from the repositories. Use ffmpeg to record audio and video and stream it in the LAN or even over the mobile network. Some of these devices already have 12 GB RAM and octacore processors, that's more than a Raspberry Pi. When these devices reach their EOL as a phone/tablet, they would make wonderful SBCs with integrated touchscreen, camera and microphone, and in the future also good AI co-processors for good on-device speech or face recognition. All this with an up-to-date OS, and not an Android version which is over 4 years old. Whatever I try with Android, sooner or later the processes get killed. What's worst is that when Chrome gets updated, any app using a WebView gets killed. Why not just let it continue running and make it use the new WebView after it gets started again manually?
- monocasa 6y agoI guess I always looked at Android's propensity to killing processes ultimately not just as a RAM saving tool, but as a battery saving tool. That whole process lifecycle thing that you have to jump through with activities and bundles and what have you is so that your app disappears not just out of RAM, but out of the scheduler too from a piece of code that can make such decisions at a complete system level. Yes, it kills processes essentially arbitrarily, but the processes should have all of the hooks and places to squirrel away state to come back from the aether as if nothing happened. Programming Android code should embrace that rather than fight it. As for webview, I think they're generally pushing a security fix and think that your app should be able to pull itself back together, the same as if a browser was refreshed.
- Siira 6y agoSome things need to run full time. Not losing the state is not enough.
- monocasa 6y agoAnd there's tons of background processing hooks for making that happen. They are detached from the UI portion of the API though. I can't think of work that needs to be performed that requires a GUI to constantly be loaded, but doesn't require that the GUI be in the foreground.
- ekianjo 6y ago> but I don't think most people who buy a Linux phone actually want a Linux phone. They want an open-source phone. Would be very strange that in the vast group of Linux users you can make a claim that "most of them want X". Seeing the amount of fragmentation happening out there, a lot of them have different priorities.
- eeZah7Ux 6y ago> The Linux philosophy isn't important to them > They want the ability to make modifications, and they want the freedom and transparency that open-source... Look at all the answers about caring about the user's freedom, privacy and security. This is exactly what Free Software is about.
- agilob 6y ago>Probably an unpopular opinion, but I don't think most people who buy a Linux phone actually want a Linux phone. They want an open-source phone. That's true, but to some degree. I'm OK with LineageOS, wouldn't care if that has Linux or BSD. As long as I can switch distro, reinstall and do not lose warranty or permanently damage bootloader.
- fit2rule 6y agoI just want to be able to write software on computers that I own, using tools I choose. Linux gives that option. None of the other phones do.
- tharne 6y agoExactly. They want a phone that, to the extent possible, is not a surveillance device vacuuming up all their data and sending it to apple and google. Obviously the phone companies and ISPs can still vacuum up data even with a linux phone, but you've got to start somewhere.
- loudtieblahblah 6y agoMy home is top to bottom Linux. Linux media server. Linux laptop for work. My wife is on Linux. My parents are on Linux (since i have to support them). Linux's rough patches on the desktop/laptop is one thing, and for me - easy to deal with. on a mobile device, the polish matters in usability in big way. Running into a problem on a phone is infinitely more of a PITA than a machine with a sizeable screen and a full keyboard attached, where remote access is easy if necessary.
- Apofis 6y agoI don't want a Linux phone because I don't really need a terminal on my phone, I have other devices for that, and the rest of the Linux ecosystem is built for server/desktop, so I don't need that on my phone either. Canonical made the best attempt at getting Ubuntu there, but it started to impact the desktop users and Canonical has limited resources. Apple is trying to converge iOS and MacOS with their iPad Pro and Apple Silicon, we'll see how that goes in the next decade.