17 ms·
Venus could have been habitable for billions of years (2019)
- xwdv 6y agoThat’s enough time for a civilization to have been born, lived, and died. Unfortunately there’s probably no way to find evidence of their existence by now it seems? Some day they may say Earth could have been habitable for billions of years.
- samatman 6y agoThat's practically guaranteed. Eventually, the Sun will expand so much that Earth's atmosphere will boil clean off. A mega-civilization with enormous power could move Earth, buy some time, but nothing lasts forever.
- selcuka 6y ago> buy some time, but nothing lasts forever That reminded me of The Last Question by Isaac Asimov. Quite enjoyable if you haven't read it already: https://www.multivax.com/last_question.html https://www.multivax.com/last_question.html
- JumpCrisscross 6y agoI remember, when I first read this story, thinking how quaint this notion was: "In his father's youth, the only computers had been tremendous machines taking up a hundred square miles of land. There was only one to a planet. Planetary ACs they were called." Yet here we are, consolidating our planet's computing power to a handful of cloud computing providers.
- eloff 6y agoWhy move earth when you could just throw up some shade? By then things would be so different it's impossible to imagine what humans might do or be capable of our interested in - if we're still around.
- mrkstu 6y agoShade won’t help much when the sun is a red giant star…
- eloff 6y agoWhy not? Shade continues to function the same. If placed at the Lagrange point between Earth and the Sun (supposing that's not too close to said red giant), you wouldn't even need that much.
- samatman 6y agoThat's why I made reference to a generic "mega civilization". We're talking hundreds of millions of years from now, the only safe bet is that "humans" as we understand them won't be around. That would be as weird as the vernacular language of a people being an English we would understand, in 100,000 years! Our descendants might be a mega-civilization. Our creations might be, or rather the descendants of our creations. We might get wiped out by an alien von Neumann probe, get wiped out and then get von Neumann probed, or ordinary colonization, or, maybe we'll uplift the rats and they'll overthrow us, or dolphins will come back on land and grow thumbs! It's a lot of time, is what I'm saying.
- lumost 6y agoIt's a bit extreme to make that leap. Multi-cellular life only emerged on Earth ~600 million years ago, after the supposed habitable period of Venus. It's unclear for how much of the 4.6 billion year history of the earth multicellular life could have emerged and just how improbable the evolution of multicellular life is. There are certainly events such as the symbiosis of mitochondria which appear to have occurred only once in the history of life on earth.
- andrewflnr 6y agoComplex multicellularity and cellular endosymbiosis have both occurred multiple times on earth. Those aren't the hard part. Further, there's no reason to assume that having mitochondria (rather than just having an intrinsically more efficient metabolism) is optimal, much less necessary, rather than a path-dependent accident of Earth eukaryotes.
- zabzonk 6y ago> both occurred multiple times on earth Citation?
- vmception 6y agoAny Biology & Ecology 101 book from the last decade and a half.
- zabzonk 6y agoProvide a link to one.
- mannerheim 6y agoThere are several kingdoms with multicellular life. Plants, animals, most fungi, some protists (many protists are more closely related to animals, fungi, or plants than they are to each other for that matter). See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eukaryote#Five_supergroups https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eukaryote#Five_supergroups Note e.g. that animals and fungi are closely related on this diagram, but there are unicellular fungi (notably yeast). I would guess that this means the common ancestor between animals and fungi would have been unicellular. At any rate, both are far from plants, and other protist species unrelated to all of these are multicellular. Endosymbiosis is generally accepted to also have occurred with chloroplasts. I believe there are also contemporary observed cases of protists consuming photosynthetic organisms and becoming immobile.
- andrewflnr 6y agoIf we could get heavy rock-moving equipment on the surface and blast through the lava, maybe we could find out. Or if we got lucky and landed a probe on a high spot that escaped the lava and found either fossils or artifacts. All that to say, not likely in our lifetimes.
- elihu 6y agoIf there was a civilization on Venus anything like our current civilization on Earth, I expect there would still be evidence of it, even in that hostile environment. If nothing else, there'd probably be unnatural formations of ground from mines or freeway construction or whatever.
- teeray 6y agoLife After People was a good series about this. IIRC, the only thing left of humanity after some appreciable amount of time (say a couple millenia), would be the pyramids. Evidence might be on Venus, but we might have to look thoroughly to find it.
- herendin2 6y agoThe oldest known undisturbed area of the Earth's surface is only about 2 million years old It turns over very fast in geological time https://www.livescience.com/3542-oldest-surface-earth-discovered.html https://www.livescience.com/3542-oldest-surface-earth-discov...
- elihu 6y agoA fair point. I wasn't thinking about tectonic subduction, which would hide pretty much all evidence that anyone was there. Though I think that article is talking more about having the same surface exposed to the air for a long time, without being worn down by weathering or covered in silt. You could have an area covered in dirt or partly eroded away, and still be recognizably an artifact of civilization for a long time. I don't know if such things would last billions of years though. Also, I expect weathering and erosion would happen a lot faster on Venus, what with the high heat and extreme winds that are more like a flowing ocean current than what we'd think of as "wind".
- herendin2 6y agoHave a look at the Silurian Hypothesis. If one can examine things very closely, literally on the ground, then the window of detectability might extend to hundreds of millions of years, even billions perhaps. But from orbit, there's not so much hope of detection after a million years
- GekkePrutser 6y agoExactly what I thought. Maybe there was a civilization and they totally messed up their planet like we do now. Only half joking by the way.
- sintaxi 6y agoI must be the only person on the planet who thinks humans are doing a phenomenal job taking care of Earth. Within a couple hundred years we went from struggling to survive to thriving with significant pollution, to rapid iteration on the energy sector with environment being a top priority. That all happened very quickly.
- jMyles 6y agoMars, shortly before sunset, a few billion years from now. Martian: "Are you saying seriously believe that people used to live on Earth? And that the only thing they managed to send here from their civilization are spores to grow these mushrooms?"
- duxup 6y agoOr maybe someone's asked that about Mars before we did? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silurian_hypothesis https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silurian_hypothesis That one kinda blows my mind.
- zabzonk 6y agoIt could have been habitable, but probably wasn't - if it had been, life there would almost certainly have resisted the greenhouse effect, as it probably will on Earth, though almost certainly not soon enough to save us monkeys.
- vmception 6y agoWe don't know if it wasn't inhabited and we don't know if it is currently uninhabited.
- zabzonk 6y agoOf course, which is why I said "probably".
- GekkePrutser 6y agoWell we know that it's not inhabited by 'life as we know it' right now at the very least. Because that's just not going to survive there. It'd be a pretty far stretch to come up with something that can.
- mannerheim 6y agoThere is a habitable zone on Venus in the upper atmosphere, so it's not completely out of the question.
- junippor 6y agoThat's been thoroughly debunked.
- mannerheim 6y agoNote that a habitable zone does not necessarily mean there's any life actually there. You are probably thinking of the reports last year of phosphine in the upper atmosphere where the quantity turned out to be overstated by a significant amount. On the other hand, there is a sweet spot in the Venusian atmosphere where the temperature is low enough and the atmosphere provides enough protection from solar radiation that microbial life could conceivably survive (which is not the same as saying there is any life there); there are certainly plenty of Earth microbes that live in environments just as inhospitable if not more.
- duxup 6y agoGrowing up I absorbed all the space stuff I could find. But it wasn't until recently that I realized that the solar system didn't just form into some static natural state where it largely didn't change until say the sun was finished with it's lifespan. Rather it evolves, changes, planets are habitable, then not, moons are formed and break up, even frozen planets are geologically active and are changing, Saturn's rings are relatively recent and etc. Not sure how I didn't pick up on that.
- DoreenMichele 6y agoNot sure how I didn't pick up on that. The sheer scale of it makes it hard to perceive, so probably you aren't the only one and probably a lot of the literature has similar blind spots which implicitly signals "this isn't happening" and we pick up on that and it gets implicitly repeated until it's hard to give any kind of push back in our own minds.
- spacemark 6y agoFor sure. You'll find that our notions of our own world and societies are also very outdated on average due to how rapidly they're changing (and by and large improving). A wonderful, easy to read book on this that I recommend is Factfulness. https://www.ted.com/playlists/474/the_best_hans_rosling_talks_yo https://www.ted.com/playlists/474/the_best_hans_rosling_talk... https://www.amazon.com/Factfulness-Reasons-World-Things-Better/dp/1250107814 https://www.amazon.com/Factfulness-Reasons-World-Things-Bett...
- mc32 6y agoUntil we started sending probes out there, we didn't know much about those bodies. Tectonic plates on Earth were not confirmed till the '60s or so, so... it's not surprising.
- chrisco255 6y agoI think it's the way it's presented. We still have a sort of Newtonian "clockwork" view in primary education of astronomy.
- elihu 6y agoI wonder if one were to install a solar shade in front of Venus to block all light from the sun, how long would it take to cool to "normal" temperatures? The Earth cools pretty fast between day/night and seasonally, but Venus has a much thicker atmosphere, almost more like an ocean. And then the ground itself wouldn't cool instantly either. That's a lot of thermal mass.
- stx 6y agoWould cooling it help to reduce the amount of pressure the atmosphere has? Isn't the pressure on the surface something like 95 times that of earth.
- virmundi 6y agoWhich is also largely why it’s hot.
- eggsome 6y agoSurely it would cool below the point where Co2 becomes solid (most of the atmosphere is Co2). Imagine walking around on fields of Co2 :)
- debo_ 6y agoReminds me of the short story "A Pail of Air".
- jamiek88 6y agoI read that short story as a kid and tried to remember the title for years, you’ve just scratched that itch!
- kabdib 6y agoI read an SF story a few years ago where the idea was to sequester the carbon of Venus into blocks of diamond. A minor bit of (ahem) atmosphere in a pretty good novel . . . just don't remember the title.
- whoisthemachine 6y agoIt's interesting that multi-cellular life developed on Earth around the same time these scientists hypothesize Venus would have become uninhabitable. Unrelated... still, fun to think about. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_evolutionary_history_of_life#Proterozoic_Eon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_evolutionary_h...
- konjin 6y agoNot overly. The Great Oxidation Event nearly destroyed all life on the planet. If it wasn't for a mutation that allowed life to live in an oxygen rich environment Earth could have gone the say way as Venus.
- mixmastamyk 6y agoIt might also be thought of as a natural consequence, i.e. evolution at work.
- ramraj07 6y agoMy working hypothesis is that the galaxy (if not at least the solar system) is teeming with rocks containing Protozoa that are ready to colonise any planet with the right conditions (in a matter of thousands of years after the conditions are right) the moment they are ready. Perfectly explains everything we see and honestly would not be surprising at all. We need to start developing meaningful working hypotheses and make judgement calls instead of waiting till we have definitive proof. This was similar to how basically no one was surprised that every star out there has planets around it yet we were writing sci-fi under that assumptions for basically a century before definitive proof.
- ReaLNero 6y agoWow, that's... actually pretty sensical. The science part of me rejects it for having no evidence. But the pragmatic part of me would put its money underneath the theory. The reason The bigger question is: how did the first Protozoa form? The usual primordial soup theory of random chance? One good thing about this theory is that if there are 10^7 habitable planets at any given moment, each of them are "trying to produce life." So the chance that life gets to Earth increases multiple fold. One problem for this theory is that if it takes a thousand years for Earth to get protozoa from another planet, then we would expect to have gotten multiple different types of Protozoa. But there is basically no variety on Earth: it's all carbon, and 99% uses oxygen (a few use sulfur).
- spurgu 6y agoQuestion I'm asking myself is, what's the likelihood there would have ever been fossil fuel deposits with the potential to kickstart a civilization?
- andrewflnr 6y agoHumans had civilization before we knew how to use fossil fuels, we just didn't have industrial civilization. AIUI civilization mostly consists of agreeing to live and work together in groups bigger than Dunbar's number.
- spurgu 6y agoYeah of course would you'd need to redefine civilization as "inudstrial" civilization for my argumentn to make sense. Still, check out parent post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26563017 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26563017 tl;dr: we've kickstarted civilization due to our harnessing of energy. If the venusians didn't have that option they would've probably lived as cavemen and couldn't have prevented or foreseen the disaster.
- nvader 6y agoUnless the disaster was self-inflicted by the Venusians, when they unleashed the sequestered carbon by harvesting energy. This is one of the reasons this story sticks in my mind.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoI've seen two pretty common definitions of "civilization". One is agriculture; one is writing. There have been plenty of "barbarian" groups that coordinated on very large scales.
- mrfusion 6y agoWe could always have done a lot with wood and steam engines or even making wood gas or ethanol.
- Geee 6y agoMaybe they crashed their huge spaceship on Earth and killed the dinosaurs. Two of them survived and started gardening.
- etxm 6y agoIs this an EYES ref?
- koheripbal 6y agoI love thinking about an alternate reality where Mars and Venus swapped orbits so that both were habitable. Having three planets with their own unique plants and animals, and having colonization by humans at our current tech level, is a fascinating alternate reality.
- Octopodes 6y agoAll we need to do is build a Stargate on each and have them swap atmospheres!
- nojokes 6y agoA lot of CO2 and sulfuric acid is not a problem, it is an opportunity. CO2 means a lot of carbon, and oxygen, sulfuric acid means a lot of sulfur, oxygen and hydrogen. Oxygen and hydrogen is water. Carbon is life and is solid. We just need to engineer a process that can use solar energy to convert these substances into some more interesting form. Perhaps some engineered bacteria could do the trick?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 01100011 6y agoAnd it could be again... I wish we would plan ahead and try a solar shield at L1. If we cooled the planet sufficiently, the CO2 would solidify and we could get to work processing it. Venus is far more interesting than the dusty little rock we keep probing. Sure, it may take a millenium, but the sooner we start, the sooner we finish.
- rtx 6y agoOr send some microbes which convert it into oxygen. You are right Mars doesn't have enough resources to support anything.
- chii 6y agothat's an interesting proposition. If terraforming is really about engineering the right microbes to slowly (over several millenia even?) the atmosphere to habitable for humans, do we currently have the technology to actually accomplish it? Or is it still too advanced form of engineering?
- 29athrowaway 6y agoWhat was the atmospheric pressure of Venus ~700 million years ago? Right now, it's 90 atmospheres.
- atlgator 6y agoSo women may really be from Venus
- mech422 6y agoWhy is everyone so caught up on the atmospheric pressure of Venus being 90 atmospheres? That's only 3K feet of water, and plenty of stuff lives deeper then that in the oceans - so obviously things can survive the pressure ?
- jakelazaroff 6y agoI think the issue is that we can't.
- mech422 6y agoFair enough. I just see the pressure mentioned often in a context that makes it seem its a problem for 'life'.
- 8note 6y agoThe heat is a bigger problem
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- onetimemanytime 6y agoSo it becomes cool again and we can roam, digging around. What traces could we find?
- lenkite 6y agoDid some planetary body hit Venus and destroy all life 700 million years ago ? Maybe even changed its rotation the other way ?
- bregma 6y agoYes [0]. About the same time we were being visited by aliens if I'm correct [1]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Worlds_in_Collision https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Worlds_in_Collision [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ancient_astronauts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ancient_astronauts
- JMTQp8lwXL 6y agoImagine the timeline if humans and our technology were around 700 million years ago, at a time when some of our sibling planets were potentially habitable.
- Pompidou 6y agoI think it would be a real nightmare. After their climate change we then would have to rapatriate every marsian and venusian human to earth, making our little rock absolutly overpopulated. Imagine then rivalries between planetary immigrant and their descendant.
- protoman3000 6y agoI recently learned about the estimated age of the universe. It’s only 13.8 billion years. So when it says Venus was hospitable for billions of years, let’s say 2 billion years, that amounts already to 14% of all there was and will ever be. What marvel did happen in this time?
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> So when it says Venus was hospitable for billions of years, let’s say 2 billion years, that amounts already to 14% of all there was and will ever be. Huh? You're saying the universe is about to end?
- brnt 6y agoI guess he meant that Venus' habitable days will never return.
- thaumasiotes 6y agoThat would be 14% of all there ever has been. In order for it to also be 14% of all there ever will be, the future would need to have zero duration.
- brnt 6y agoWe've had life for about 500 million years on earth. Maybe a billion as single celled life forms. I used to worry that in 5 billion years it'll all be over on account of the sun entering a new phase and engulfing Earth. But it appears in about 800 million years photosynthesis will no longer be possible [1], which puts an even closer limit on our time here. There's a good chance some will get off this rock, but many won't. And all that we know will be lost, and we'll need space suits to visit, no more nature to enjoy, just barren rock. We'll not be us anymore either of course, time will tell what we evolve into. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_far_future https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_far_future
- fogihujy 6y ago
- RamblingCTO 6y agoThis gives me real "Inherit the Stars" vibes!
- matthewfelgate 6y agoDo you think there could be more landings on Venus like the Russian one in the 1960s? How did the Russian probe even land and take a photo if the surface temperature is enough to melt metal?! Could you build a small rover to withstand the elements for a few hours?
- bregma 6y agoIt lasted what, 8 seconds before transmission ceased? It was definitely a success since they expected it to last about 5 seconds.
- messe 6y agoYou're probably joking, but I'll post this comment anyway, as the Venera program was actually quite impressive. Venera 7 lasted 23 minutes before failing (although landed in an awkward orientation due to parachute failure). Venera 8 transmission for nearly an hour, but wasn't equipped with a camera. Venera 9 operated for 53 minutes, had issues with the lens cap so only took pictures from one of the cameras. Venera 10 operated for 65 minutes, same lens cap issue as above. Venera 11 operated for 95 minutes, and Venera 12 operated for 110 minutes. Neither of these successfully released their lens caps. Venera 13 managed 127 minutes, and both lens caps deployed. Venera 14 which had the same design as Venera 13 only lasted for 57 minutes. Its lens caps deployed, but one landed directly underneath the surface compressibility tester arm, and returned information for the compressibility of the lens cap rather than the surface.
- gear54rus 6y agoThe last one is facsinating... the sheer amount of stuff that can go wrong on a mission like this is mind-boggling. Also the frustration they must've felt seeing the same lens cap malfunction over and over.
- LatteLazy 6y agoWas or wasn't describe knowledge. Could or may or might or should or maybe all describe ignorance. "We are ignorant of the state of venus for billions of years"
- pmlnr 6y agoI feel like I have to mention an 1951 novel: Stanisław Lem - The Astronauts ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Astronauts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Astronauts ) [ SPOILERS TO FOLLOW ] which plays with the idea that Venus was fine, inhabited, with sentient life, until recently, when they blew themselves up, throwing the planet into the state it is today.
- robofanatic 6y agoDoes this mean at some point Venus was in the habitable zone and slowly moved out of it towards sun?
- Tepix 6y agoNo. Venus is still (barely) inside the habitable zone. The sun did get hotter during its lifetime.