6 ms·
Interestingly, if landlords were allowed to use larger security deposits, some would choose to do this instead of raising the monthly rent. My friend is looking
by gnicholas 6y ago
Interestingly, if landlords were allowed to use larger security deposits, some would choose to do this instead of raising the monthly rent. My friend is looking to rent out an ADU, and the first idea was to have a sizable security deposit in order to filter applicants who fully intended on paying rent from those who would be more likely to use the eviction moratorium.
But apparently California tightened the rules around security deposits in 2020, which actually exacerbates this problem. Landlords used to be able to ask for up to two month’s rent as a security deposit, but now they can only ask for one month's rent.
This leads to upward pressure on rents, as landlords adjust the only lever they have left. I wonder if applicants can/do offer to prepay several month's rent, to signal that they are serious long-term tenants who have the ability and interest in paying rent (even if they legally could avoid payment).
- TuringNYC 6y agoThis comment is spot on. Rent premiums are often not greed, but just a risk premium and buffer-collection for a catch all of issues from future non-payment to other BS.
- imtringued 6y agoPrices are negotiated. Two parties must agree on the price. If there is a "greedy" landlord overcharging people there must also be a person "willing" to pay the overpriced rent. Of course there are cases of vacant properties but I don't think this is a problem for most rental markets.
- TuringNYC 6y agoI'm pretty sure vacant properties are a problem in every market, it is just a matter of grayscales -- how many days do you keep units empty waiting for a creditworthy tenant. Perhaps the unit is empty 10 days, perhaps 15. Willingness to keep a unit empty is part of the negotiation -- a landlord is saying "I'd rather keep the unit empty for another couple of days than take a rent that wont adequately-compensate for the 4% chance i get nothing for 10months (i.e., eviction)" Of course, even eviction timelines vary vastly from one jurisdiction to another
- Supermancho 6y ago> Prices are negotiated. Two parties must agree on the price. Yeah, that's true of hostage negotiations too. The issue is one of choice and efficiency. Moving is a larger risk (via cost, opportunity, travel, etc) than changing rent or services performed, usually.
- offtop5 6y agoThat's horrible to hear, I was only able to get my first apartment in California since I could offer a double deposit. Chicago on the other hand has fantastic housing supply and so many rules on security deposits, most buildings just don't do it. Access to housing permeates every aspect of a culture, people are significantly nicer when they can afford a place to live. Has your friend been able to get out of California ?
- gnicholas 6y agoChicago does have a large supply of housing and land that can be converted into housing. This helps keep the cost of housing closer to the cost required to construct units. In CA, the cost of a home has almost nothing to do with the input costs other than land. There are areas that could be built up (tons of land just west of 280), but which is protected by environmental laws or restrictions. Full development of this land would lead to traffic nightmares, for sure, but one could imagine that some of it could be developed as we move toward more efficient modes of transport.
- roguecoder 6y agoSan Francisco also has 26 skyscrapers to Chicago's 130. 80% of the Bay Area is zoned exclusive for single family, to Chicago's 41.1%. It's not landscape and it's not rocket science: it's zoning. San Francisco could build up, letting people live closer to their work & be much better for the environment than encouraging sprawl, but chooses not to. Y'all decided to make housing expensive, so it is.
- gnicholas 6y agoZoning is absolutely a big part of this. Though I would expect SF to have fewer skyscrapers than Chicago even if it weren't for zoning differences, given the earthquake risk. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/06/03/us/earthquake-preparedness-usa-japan.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2019/06/03/us/earthquake...
- 6y ago
- gugagore 6y ago> exacerbates this problem To clarify, the problem you're talking about is that it's risky to be a landlord, and maybe more so now than a few years ago. > as landlords adjust the only lever they have left At least some landlords also have the option of pulling the lever labeled "sell the unit".
- _carbyau_ 6y agoThis is me. Low end 1 bedroom apartment, moratorium on eviction = suddenly no rent paid. Here in Australia there was significant $ from Government for those in such a position, including rental assistance. We got nothing. And I am not about to hound a person financially at the bottom who likely lost their job and had enough shit already. But no point messing around with the lowest end market now that we can afford not to. Sell it.
- silvestrov 6y agowow, that's not much in case the apartment is damaged. Denmark allows for 3 months deposit plus 3 months rents upfront, so you have to be able to come up with 6 months rent total to get an apartment. (market here is very hot, so rental apartments have no problem getting 6 months rent) When you "quit" living in the apartment, you can use the 3 months prepaid rent, so you don't have to pay rent the last 3 months.
- gnicholas 6y agoFor sure. Think about the damage that can be done to hardwood floors during move-out, for example. That's one easy way that a unit can be accidentally damaged, even by a tenant who is generally very careful. Of course, you can still recover payment by suing, but that's obviously more difficult (especially if the former tenant has moved to another city/state).
- benhurmarcel 6y ago> 3 months deposit plus 3 months rents upfront You need to come up with 6 month worth of rent to start renting? That's massive. It basically means most would need to borrow that money. Is that supposed to be a good thing? I'm glad that illegal here, that's abusive. Personally I avoided any ad that required more than 2 month total upfront. Thankfully the local market allowed it. If I wanted to put a massive deposit I'd buy, not rent.
- silvestrov 6y agoA lot of people have that on hand in Denmark or can get a loan from their bank. You also don't have to pay rent the last 1 to 3 months for your previous place, so it's not as bad as it sound. People in USA live a lot more paycheck-to-paycheck than in the rest of the world.
- benhurmarcel 6y agoI've lived in France and Spain, never the US, and giving so much upfront still seem massive to me.
- alisonkisk 6y agoHow is prepaying rent different from a larger security deposit?
- gnicholas 6y agoIt has a similar signaling effect, but someone could prepay 6 months rent and then just stop paying. With a security deposit, you have that as a buffer until the person leaves. Perhaps the best way to accomplish this without having the landlord perpetually hang onto large amounts of tenant cash is to have a large deposit that slowly decreases over time, as trust increases. So perhaps it would be 5 or 6 months of deposit that is used to offset every 3rd month of rent during the first year.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cosmie 6y agoSecurity deposits are legally the tenants funds held in escrow by the landlord until the end of the lease. They tend to be heavily regulated in tenant law, with stipulations on how large they can be, what can be deducted from the security deposit upon lease termination, how long after lease termination the landlord has to return the remainder of the deposit, whether they have to be held in an actual escrow account[1], etc. Prepaid rent is just that - it's rent for some future period that the landlord is just receiving early, so doesn't come with all the legal strings attached[2]. The landlord recognizes the income when they receive it and it becomes their money to do what they want with at that point. The nuance goes beyond just semantics, too. If a tenant files for bankruptcy, the security deposit the landlord is holding in escrow is considered an asset of the tenant's estate. Whereas prepaid rent is not, unless the contract was executed super recently and the judge determines it unfairly harmed other creditors and wants to claw it back. [1] https://www.lawyers.com/legal-info/taxation/property-tax/advance-rental-income-security-deposits-and-taxes.html https://www.lawyers.com/legal-info/taxation/property-tax/adv... [2] I'm sure this isn't a universal truth - in the US alone, tenant law tends to be an overlaid mishmash of federal, state, and local regulations. So I'm sure some places attach strings to it. But many if not most places do not.
- nimos 6y agoHmmm - I just paid 2 months deposit in 2021. Googling seems to say that is allowable. "Effective January 1, 2020, landlords may not request a security deposit of more than one month’s rent for an unfurnished unit, and two month’s rent for a furnished unit, if the unit is rented to a service member." The one month limit seems specific to service members.
- Consultant32452 6y agoI knew a couple who had such awful credit they were not allowed to rent without paying the entire year's rent up front.
- gnicholas 6y agoWow, confusing language in there. But NOLO makes it clear that the service member limitation relates to both clauses, not just the last one. [1] Good catch! Seems the limit for non-service members is still 2 months, or 3 for furnished. Landlords can add 1/2 month for a water bed, curiously. 1: https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/california-security-deposits-36199.html https://www.nolo.com/legal-encyclopedia/california-security-...