15 ms·
Egypt prepares to start move to new capital, away from the chaos of Cairo
- ohduran 6y agoHaven't this people read Seeing like a State?
- voldacar 6y agoalmost certainly not. that book would be like bug repellent but for bureaucrats and central planners
- DC-3 6y agoThese projects are usually driven by vanity not reason. They don't always fail though - Australians may want to weigh in but as far as I know Canberra works alright?
- yesenadam 6y agoIt was planned around 1900, and "the Sydney–Melbourne rivalry was such that neither city would ever agree to the other one becoming the capital. ...Eventually, a compromise was reached: Melbourne would be the capital on a temporary basis while a new capital was built somewhere between Sydney and Melbourne." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Canberra#20th_century https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Canberra#20th_centu...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lisardo 6y agoBrazil undertook a similar project and moved the capital from Rio de Janeiro to Brasilia in 1960. This was a big mistake. Brasilia is like giant robot very far away from the people and with no connection with society. Brasilia has the highest income per capita in Brazil and it doesn't produce anything. Rio Janeiro, the old capital, was left with no alternative and has been decaying ever since.
- mc32 6y agoIndonesia is doing something similar for some of the same reasons as well as due to subsidence. Brasilia was hundreds of Km from the original capital, this move is 45Km away. It will probably produce some stratification but also relieve pressure from Cairo.
- fakedang 6y ago> relieve pressure from Cairo. * relieve pressure for the elites in Cairo
- mc32 6y agoThey expect to have six million people on the new city. If six million are elite, then they have a pretty good ratio of elite to commoner in Cairo. Anyhow, lowering Cairo’s pop by six million should make it more livable traffic and smog wise.
- fakedang 6y agoYou're going to believe the numbers of what is essentially a vanity project?
- Ericson2314 6y agoLowering population is not how cities become better. Building more floors and more public transit is.
- mc32 6y agoNot if it's overcrowded and unhealthy. Cities improve by obviating slums/shanties and overdensity and by modernizing.
- Ericson2314 6y ago"overdensity" as people per land area or per floor area? Because I pretty firmly believe the former doesn't exist.
- christkv 6y agoUseful to avoid the mob and easy to defend militarily I guess.
- programmertote 6y agoThat is likely the main reason. In Myanmar, they did the same a little over a decade ago. By moving up north to a newly built city with 20-lane highway and lots of bunkers to hide (I only saw photos of them being built and they are most likely for the military government and their families to hide out before they move away if something happens), the military thinks it can buy some time and defend better in case of civil war or foreign invasion.
- james_pm 6y agoThis project literally is the foreign invasion. > Some international financing has been secured for rail links, and a $3 billion Chinese loan has helped fund the business district, built by China State Construction Engineering Corp (CSCEC).
- yhoneycomb 6y agoWhen the west does it → aid, human rights, charity work When the east does it → foreign invasion
- ReadFList 6y agoWhen the west does it → Colonization When the east does it → Charitable Chinese living to Communist ideals, totally not trying to subjugate a country economically when they can't pay back loans. It's actually a bit of both.
- programmertote 6y agoI agree. It goes both ways. I think the above commenter is either a Chinese or an empathizer. I recent had a back-and-forth conversation with someone from China on Reddit and it really surprised me that the person seems to think his government's actions are all good/fair: https://old.reddit.com/r/worldnews/comments/m535p0/at_least_39_reported_killed_in_myanmar_as_chinese/gr0tlap/ https://old.reddit.com/r/worldnews/comments/m535p0/at_least_... A few of my friends from Myanmar are descendants of Chinese families, they say that whenever they read Chinese online forums, they see this selfish/apathetic approach (only my business/my money/my family/my race matters) again and again. I think a lot of people in China are brainwashed to see both sides and they are now conditioned to take the side of "the west is always blaming us" (which is partly true, but partly false as all things go in life).
- tazjin 6y agoJust a minor comment (I currently live in Egypt): > Control centres will monitor infrastructure and security electronically, roofs will be covered in solar panels, payments will be cashless Good luck with that - a huge number of places don't even put prices up because everything is negotiable and cash is king. If they only want the kind of Western-style stores with explicit prices in this area, then this could be restated as "we don't want the poor part of our population here". Cairo (and to larger degree, Giza) have a very intense, unique feel inside the city and I don't think this move will change anything about that.
- throwaway0a5e 6y ago> If they only want the kind of Western-style stores with explicit prices in this area, then this could be restated as "we don't want the poor part of our population here". We both know that's exactly what they want.
- rover0 6y agoEven if there are workarounds for this specific problem, the signal being sent is clear.
- M277 6y agoIt's not just the fixed pricing, but everything is more expensive there. Much more. The poor part of the population couldn't even dream to live in the new capital. There's a theory that the recent minimum wage increase for the government sector was actually because some government workers now have to live there, but they financially can't.
- 0xcoffee 6y agoWe have cashless markets over here and they just key in the price. Cashless != fixed price
- riskable 6y agoHey now... Just because a payment is cashless doesn't mean you can't haggle the price down. I've been in plenty of shops where you bring the item to the counter and the cashier enters the price directly into the register. No bar code necessary! Even if you use a barcode there's no reason why the price can't be entered in directly or modified at the behest of the cashier. In the West we just don't trust our cashiers enough to do that sort of thing so we lock out that power ("Manager assistance needed at isle four!"). What the world needs right now is cashless payments that don't have absurd (>0.1%) transaction fees. I used to work at First Data (largest credit card processor) and you know how much it costs them to execute a credit card transaction? NOTHING. It's literally nothing. It's not even a factor of, "we have this many servers in this many data centers and here's how much the electricity costs, divided by the total number of transactions in a given day." Why? Because every customer that uses First Data still pays a monthly fee that more than makes up for the cost of all the employees, data centers, software, etc etc. If all First Data ever collected was that monthly fee they'd still be profitable (assuming all they did was handle credit card transactions).
- m0llusk 6y agoThis reminds me of the old joke: A weary traveller reaches Cairo and makes his way along the crowded and bustling streets. Upon finding a small hotel he enters and tells the clerk "I just want a nice quiet room." The clerk looks astonished and exclaims "In Cairo?!"
- ceilingcorner 6y agoNo comments on the political motivations of this move. In the 1800s, Parisian neighborhoods were demolished to make way for wide boulevards, as they were harder to barricade and easier to move troops through. Similar situation in Cairo. Moving the government to a far off, easily protected location means mass protests are dramatically less effective.
- exdsq 6y agoEgypt has had an idea of splitting into several large cities each specialising on a particular thing (science, governance, etc) since the 90s. This could just be the start of that plan.
- Schiendelman 6y agoAnd that itself is a great way to kill innovation and advancement. The core reason cities are good at economic growth is the mixture of dissimilar ideas.
- exdsq 6y agoI believe it’s what they’ve done in China which seems to work well, with Shenzhen (their research capital) being 2000km south of Beijing
- fakedang 6y agoYet Beijing is still home to some of the best universities in the country and the world. Honestly I've heard of Shenzhen as the manufacturing capital or the tech capital, but it's the first time I'm hearing of Shenzhen as a research hub. China is also not segregated by cities' expertise but by provincial policy. For example, some cities, like Hangzhou had a very preferential treatment towards tech, by virtue of the provincial investment fund being invested in tech companies compared to the usual state-owned steel mill crap.
- Barrin92 6y agoThe reason cities are good at economic growth is because of agglomeration. If anything if you look at the actual characteristics of innovative communities they are very homogeneous, not dissimilar. See Silicon Valley or the Manhattan Project, or the Prussian bureaucracy, or Soviet scientific communities. Most innovative communities aren't some bleeding-heart melting pot but actually look like cults weary of outsiders.
- jjice 6y agoWell I feel pretty dumb now. I have been wondering the name origins of the "libcairo" for a while now.
- emanueldima 6y agohttps://lists.freedesktop.org/archives/cairo/2003-July/000184.html https://lists.freedesktop.org/archives/cairo/2003-July/00018...
- buro9 6y agoI mean... Egypt has form: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_historical_capitals_of_Egypt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_historical_capitals_of... Althought it has been a while since the last move.
- ivanvanderbyl 6y agoHere's an video overview of the project and all three stages of development. The yet unnamed City is expected to be finished in 2050. B1M https://youtu.be/P0fkucDtTRE https://youtu.be/P0fkucDtTRE
- akgerber 6y agoThis is supposedly a 'new capital' but it's really more of a new district on the current fringes of Cairo connected by rail service that will likely take less than an hour— more to the nature of Shibuya/Shinjuku (which only became busy districts after WWII) versus the old Chuo of Tokyo as opposed to Brasilia hundreds of miles away from the old cities. And Egypt is growing fast enough that the intermediate areas will probably get built out.
- jungturk 6y agoIt echoes the development of Putrajaya in Kuala Lumpur. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Putrajaya https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Putrajaya
- Ericson2314 6y agoOr Paris to Versailles :/
- fbn79 6y agoIf you are interested about human rights in Egypth: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Giulio_Regeni https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Giulio_Regeni https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Detention_of_Patrick_Zaki https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Detention_of_Patrick_Zaki
- jillesvangurp 6y agoJust entertained myself staring at some Google maps satellite imagery. I'm not sure how up to date that is. But a couple of observations: - This certainly is a huge scale setup. Very ambitious. - From a transport point of view, it looks like this is accessible by car only. Lots of highways; large distances, etc. - It looks like it is obviously designed to keep "undesirables" out. It looks like an easy to defend by design very exclusive large scale resort. As others are pointing out; that probably is no accident. - I know megalomania when I see it. This is definitely looks like it. But then all the great capitals in the world have some of that in their history. I've been to Rome, Washington, Paris, etc. And I live on what got built on the ruins of the Third Reich (Berlin). Same deal, different eras. So, who are we to blame the Egyptians for a bit of megalomania? The ultimate in megalomania is probably the nearby pyramids. And they remain a popular tourist destination. - It's a desert. Presumably it gets warm there. Is that even going to stay livable in the next decades? E.g. the Saudi's are planning to move some of their cities to more coastal regions. I guess AC is not going to be optional there. But still, it does not look like a pleasant place to hang out. I guess, they can desalinate water and pump it inland to green up the area a bit and keep it cool. That would be an interesting project in it self and an interesting use of e.g. clean plentiful energy potential the country definitely has. - This looks like some serious spending is happening. And given the local kleptocracy; one wonders who is getting rich here. And given the warm relationships with e.g. the US also who benefits over there? Following the money often yields interesting results.
- AdrianB1 6y agoThe desert part can be a positive. I lived in Jordan when I was a kid and the coast (Aqaba) weather was worse than the desert: at Aqaba the humidity made the heat much harder to support, while in the north (Amman) it was dry and more pleasant and my skin and t-shirt were always dry. Also in the desert solar energy is plenty and cheap, with many sunny days. That energy powers the AC that is needed in that region no matter what.
- ricardobeat 6y agoIndeed it's quite sad to see a whole new city built from scratch, and designed to car-centric models from the 60s. Cramped buildings with little space for life to happen, wide crossroads. A 10km block of grass does not alleviate those problems.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoBeen tried in Egypt before. Didn't last.
- mprovost 6y agoSure, Alexandria was only the capital for 973 years.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoConveniently forgetting the other 18 capitols in ancient times, that lasted just a Pharaoh or two (including Thebes 3 times). And then the 4 'modern' capitols.
- Arrath 6y agoI wonder if this will end up as much of a cluster as Canberra.
- skywritergr 6y agoIn Greece Athens wasn’t always the capital. For a brief moment of time the capital was in the city of Nafplion. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nafplio https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nafplio
- qwertox 6y agoI didn't know this was happening. So I went to Google Maps and checked it out, and it is a huge project. I understand how Dubai and similar places get to expand so quickly, but this does not make much sense for Egypt. Looking at what is being built, it starts to look familiar: huge city sectors which are multiplied in layout and construction style, a massive "design part of city once and reuse multiple times" like it so often is happening in China. https://www.google.com/search?q=china+egypt+new+capital https://www.google.com/search?q=china+egypt+new+capital then yields the answer.
- sakopov 6y agoA $2.2 billion loan to a country with a concerning GDP [1] and a third of its population in poverty is one way to expand your reach. China is really busy. [1] https://tradingeconomics.com/egypt/gdp https://tradingeconomics.com/egypt/gdp
- imtringued 6y agoChina has a huge migrant population ready to move to any newly built city. They can afford it because of the sheer population size. Not to mention they already figured out how to build functioning cities. Building a dozen more isn't a challenge. Meanwhile egypt still has to pull itself up on its bootstraps. A failed city would be a huge setback.
- the_local_host 6y agoEgypt's population is enormous as well, mostly crammed along the Nile; and the PPP GDP per-capita isn't that different the China.
- kmonsen 6y agoChina is almost 3x Egypt and the Chinese cities are more or less as rich as western cities. 8130 vs 2900
- csomar 6y agoThis is not the first time Cairo had a planned city. They have lots of them, and they have been relatively successful in attracting upper middle-class and keeping them there. The city is unlikely to fail, mainly due to the large number of civil servants / military Egypt already has (they are a 100m nation after all). So it'll get a boost, and if policies are well implemented, they can attract a few other millions.
- vondur 6y agoIndonesia is also moving their capital. I think the fact that Jakarta is sinking has much to do with that decision.
- arthurcolle 6y agoI was curious what it's name is, but apparently it's still unnamed. Maybe they should just call it "New Administrative Capital" forever! https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Administrative_Capital https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Administrative_Capital
- AmericanChopper 6y agoEgyptia sounds good.
- trhway 6y agoclassic feudal times scheme - the lord is in the castle up on the hill and the populace in the village down. The lord easily projects the power while being practically unassailable back - that asymmetry naturally allows the lord to practice unlimited unchecked power. I've never encountered similar interpretation when it comes to Moscow, yet Stalin actually did a lot of major changes to the Moscow center (as well as to the centers of other major cities) where the government is located in that "anti-street-rebellion" style of Paris mentioned by the other commenters, and the major part of society alive at the time in the USSR had experienced the Revolutions of 1905 and 1917 where street barricades and tactical "takeover of the central postal office and telephone and telegraph station" were among the key parts of the action.
- systemvoltage 6y agoI am astonished at how unpologetically dystopian this is from the name "New Administrative Capital" to completely cashless meaning you cannot live there without being tracked by Chinese surveillance. This entire endeavor seems to be funded by China on a strangling loan. Usually HN is quick to point this out. If this was taking place in Boston or Stockholm, I can only imagine the pushback. Why double standards?
- oliv__ 6y agoI agree! "Control centers will monitor infrastructure and security electronically" Come again?
- olliej 6y agoAkhenaten tried this once.
- xbar 6y agoSomething, something exodus. Sorry I'm tired. Was that funny or offensive for reasons I'm insensitive to?
- SergeAx 6y agoThe best analogy is Turkey: gargantuan clotted Istanbul vs nice and quiet Ankara. While almost 20% of turks are living in Istanbul, situation in Egypt is even worse: about 30% of egyptians are living or working in Cairo-Giza conglomerate. It's pretty almost unlivable place by Western standards, besides several districts like Maadi or Garden City. Considering vast size of Cairo, this new "capital" de facto will become another higher standard city district, which is not bad, I think. BTW, another Cairo project is new airport and giant museum right by the Great Pyramids of Giza. It also makes a great sense to reroute touristic flow from central Cairo with its popular museums but nothing particular interesting besides.