19 ms·
Justice at Spotify
- giuliomagnifico 6y agoHere some photos of the demonstration: https://www.hotpress.com/music/union-of-musicians-and-allied-workers-organise-protests-at-spotify-offices-around-the-world-22845456 https://www.hotpress.com/music/union-of-musicians-and-allied...
- aetherane 6y agoThe proposed Singapore protest is illegal in Singapore (protests are limited to Hong Lim park with permission from government). I hope people participating realize this and don't get arrested.
- punnerud 6y agoThis point is illegal in Norway, because you can’t make noise without applying for it first: “At the action: DO make noise. We are musicians after all.” Recommending people to do something illegal is also illegal, so it seems that the creators of this webpage is already breaking Norwegian law. And Tordenskioldsgate 2 in Oslo/Norway is just a coworking space, so you only find employees from Spotify there a couple of times a year on events or meetings.
- cratermoon 6y ago'You express a great deal of anxiety over our willingness to break laws. This is certainly a legitimate concern.... One may well ask: "How can you advocate breaking some laws and obeying others?" The answer lies in the fact that there are two types of laws: just and unjust. I would be the first to advocate obeying just laws. One has not only a legal but a moral responsibility to obey just laws. Conversely, one has a moral responsibility to disobey unjust laws. I would agree with St. Augustine that "an unjust law is no law at all."'
- kpmcc 6y agoThere are some folks trying to build an alternative that is better for musicians. https://resonate.is/ https://resonate.is/ Last time I checked it was still pretty niche but the idea (graduated pricing to stream to own) is solid.
- TheCraiggers 6y agoI'm not sure I'd call it solid, but it's an interesting take. However, I believe there's a very good reason that the various markets have went to the subscription model- there's a difference mentally between paying to stream all you want for a month and paying for each song, even when its fractions of a penny. Whenever a song you don't like starts playing on your stream, you realize you just paid for it. That's a negative experience, and those stack up. It doesn't matter if it can save you money in the long run. Remember, we're dealing with the masses here- the same lowest common denominator that caused A&W's 1/3lb hamburger to fail because people thought it was smaller than McDonald's 1/4lb hamburger.
- ArkanExplorer 6y agoAs a creator, relying on these platforms is problematic because they are the #1 target for Government taxation. Depending on the country, 20% of customer spend is swallowed up immediately by sales taxes. Another 30% is potentially swallowed up by Google and Apple. The solution is really to go direct-to-consumer, through things like Crowdfunding (unfortunately Patreon now charges VAT). Though of course this adds a lot of overhead. Alternatively, petition Governments to be leaner, and to increase retirement ages to 70 (pensions are the single major and fastest increasing Government expense), and to lower taxes (including sales taxes) with the savings. Pressure on Google and Apple (via regulation) to reduce commissions is another avenue.
- glatteis 6y agois that really the problem here??? i would think spotify uses its market dominance to drive down what they give back to the artists. also, evading tax is not a good idea. it's there for a reason.
- epse 6y agoWorking till 70? Gosh I don't think that's realistic
- yunohn 6y agoThis is already the case in some countries. For eg, the Netherlands revises the retirement age every year, and is currently at 68yrs. The public suspicion is that they do this to avoid paying pension, most of which has been squandered by the government.
- Milner08 6y agoThats the stupidest idea ever. No thank you. I do not want to work till 70 and I am sure no one else does either. VAT is there for everyone, you can't avoid it because you are a 'creator' thats insane.
- eertami 6y agoGoing after the pensions is probably the single quickest way to find yourself unelected. Old people vote, and there are a lot of them. Also direct-to-consumer hardly absolves you from following tax law. I agree that sales tax is bad, but only because it is regressive and disproportionately taxes the poor. Raise income taxes and abolish sales tax.
- breck 6y ago#abolishcopyright. Musicians if you’re listening, find a different way to earn a living than depending upon the enslavement of ideas (and by extension, individuals). Copyright is abhorrent, and needs to go. There are better ways.
- dpatterbee 6y agoThis is an interesting take I haven't heard much before. Could you expand on what the alternatives are?
- dontblink 6y agoMostly merchandising and touring.
- falcolas 6y agoHow does an author do this? An artist? How much money can the 20th musician in a day doing a tour expect to really make? An orchestra? How about movies? They'd cease to exist (barring a few youtube-quality productions).
- breck 6y agoIt's an exciting time for alternatives. Patreon, Twitch, Cameo, OnlyFans, et al, are providing ways to connect with your community and earn a living through their support, which is not only very important during shutdowns when live events are harder, but will be a long term trend. On the production side costs continue to drop, and if we #abolishcopyright cost of living across the world will drop dramatically, so will be easier to balance the budget.
- toyg 6y ago> if we #abolishcopyright cost of living across the world will drop dramatically I sincerely doubt that. Food and shelter won't magically cost less because there is no copyright.
- 6y ago
- 3saryHg6LP2e 6y agoThe record labels are a bigger problem than Spotify; they set the streaming prices and take a big cut.
- kevincox 6y agoExactly. If the record labels thought the price was unfair they wouldn't see the rights to Spotify. The unfortunate part is that the artists have basically no power when bargaining with the record labels.
- lettergram 6y agoLet's be honest, you aren't required to use a record label. Record labels just advertise, which definitely blow up some musicians. In contrast, take the rapper Tom McDonald, his music actually hit the top 100 charts[1][2] and he's not signed to anyone. Just him and his girlfriend creating music. Was trending as the #1 download on iTunes for a couple weeks, etc. Artists make a deal with the devil, make more money, then complain. Yet, with today's ability to distribute - it's not required. I do think there should be an update to the spotify payout system, but Spotify doesn't have negotiating power; they need the record labels. With the record labels Spotify can get improved music, etc. Spotify is paying for the privilege that's why the smaller artists aren't making very much (the premium payments go to record labels). [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fake_Woke\ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fake_Woke\ [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2l6JUNFAJ9o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2l6JUNFAJ9o
- curryst 6y agoIn fairness, Tom MacDonald gets a lot of external publicity from conservatives; he's mostly a right-wing political rapper. I've seen a big rise in conservative rappers on YouTube. I've got a conspiracy theory that the GOP is funding them like a record label. If so, it's a sweet deal for artists. The GOP cares far more about cultural effects than they do the money from the music.
- 6y ago
- Macha 6y agoThe ask is 1p/stream. I'm not sure that that's actually sustainable without a massive rise in spotify prices, given the proportion of free users and even paid users that listen to more than 1000 tracks a month. If spotify raises prices, consumers go back to piracy. I'm not sure this will have the effect they want. Let's imagine a radio station. Something medium sized, about a million listeners. They play a track. Are they paying 10,000 per play, which would be the equivalent rate? I suspect not.
- 101008 6y agoIf this is not sustainable for the artists, how is this different than piracy? I'd say it is even worse, because people is paying but the money goes to a middleware company that is not paying the right price. It is like buying CDs from the street sellers.
- Milner08 6y agoRight, but the money has always gone to a middleman, be it record companies or Spotify. If Spotify gets any more expensive I can guarantee people will go back to privacy, music will become less accessible and those niche bands that Spotify knows I may like will never get found. I understand the need to get paid more, but I am not sure killing Spotify is the solution.
- meiraleal 6y ago> I understand the need to get paid more, but I am not sure killing Spotify is the solution. If Spotify doesn't compromise, killing it would be the only solution, but this union doesn't have the power to do that initially. But this will never work because you have a infinite stream of new musicians wanting to be listen without receiving money for that.
- s0xTester 6y agoKilling Spotify would be terrible. New musicians want their work out there....without Spotify(or similar) it will be back to just blasting out your music for free online everywhere so you can get bug. Spotify at least gives them some revenue while they increase their fandom.
- macspoofing 6y ago>Pay us at least one cent per stream I bet if Spotify adopted it, the publishers would still want a cut of that.
- bogomipz 6y agoMusic publishers work for the songwriter. Songwriters hold the publishing. Record labels are the copyright holders. Streaming companies license from the latter.
- bmmayer1 6y agoDoes anyone know if this so-called union is an actual union? As in, do they collect dues, do they represent a substantial % of artists, and do its members already collectively bargain with Spotify and similar publishers? If Spotify says no, do these demands have any teeth?
- jedimastert 6y agoActually, I believe it would be a guild, as artists are not actually employees of any particular label or service, but just contractors. I also thing Guild is a far cooler name, but that's beside the point! As for your actual question, no I don't think they are. They seem more like an advocacy or lobby group https://www.unionofmusicians.org/#about https://www.unionofmusicians.org/#about
- rmrfrmrf 6y agoIt looks like yet another cosplay of 20th century labor politics, but with the typical 21st century twist of diverting the fight from those who wield power to... the paying customers, for whatever reason.
- mike_d 6y agoWell they ripped off the (copyrighted) Mr. Yuck logo owned by the UPMC Children's Hospital of Pittsburgh. Stealing from children to complain about theft.
- juancn 6y agoPenny per stream? That's an awful lot in most countries. If I stream a record twice I cover my spotify premium fee (US is more expensive than Argentina or India, because people can pay more). Copyrights create artificial scarcity, if you don't like it, just don't put your music on the platform, you have an effective monopoly. Most music is not that valuable, prices used to be high due to cartelization of the publishers and because the media was difficult to produce (records, CDs). Cassettes started changing that, and the internet completely destroyed it. There's no going back. If prices go up, piracy will too, and you'll likely end up making less money.
- petey283 6y agoBut isn't this part of the negotiation process? Start with a higher demand and work your way to a more reasonable position.
- Galanwe 6y agoThe problem here is not the platform itself (Spotify). It'd the overall concept of needing a middle man to distribute your work. I believe blockchain can be a good remedy for unnecessary middlemen. Audius [1] is a good example applied to the music industry. [1] https://audius.co/ https://audius.co/
- Hamuko 6y agoBlockchain is the snake oil of the Internet age. No matter what ails you, blockchain is the cure.
- Galanwe 6y agoI get that you seem bored by the hype around blockchain, but that does not make anything blockchain related bad. In this particular issue, I think blockchain is a great solution, as it allows to publish content, gather fees from listeners to artists, without the need of an intermediary.
- Eridrus 6y agoSo I wanted to try put this into perspective since "a penny per stream" is intentionally meant to sound insignificant. This seems like it would roughly double Spotify's costs: https://www.republicworld.com/technology-news/apps/how-much-does-spotify-pay-per-stream-comparing-spotify-with-other-streaming-services.html https://www.republicworld.com/technology-news/apps/how-much-... And Spotify is already paying out 75% of it's revenue to royalty holders: https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-features/spotify-profitable-how-happen-910456/ https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-features/spotify-pr... So unless you believe that Spotify is bad at business and there's an extra ~75% of revenue Spotify could pull out of a hat, this is basically impossible to satisfy without cratering the total revenue by doubling prices, which is probably not in artist's interests.
- wilde 6y agoSpotify doesn’t want to take the risk, but there’s probably money on the table from all the small gyms, coffee shops, etc that should be paying commercial rates.
- jsiepkes 6y agoI don't know about other countries but in the Netherlands companies already pay an additional fee which ends-up with the royalty holders [1]. Meaning you have to pay a special license fee when playing music in venue's such as stores, cafe's and even a common office work space. [1] https://www.bumastemra.nl/en/everything-for-music-users/types-of-users/ https://www.bumastemra.nl/en/everything-for-music-users/type...
- aksss 6y agoI think that technically one is supposed to do that in commercial spaces in the US as well, but there’s an enforcement issue. Small businesses aren’t really at the mercy of roaming enforcement agents, but there are services businesses can subscribe to that cover the costs of royalties for playing in commercial spaces.
- m000 6y ago
- emilecantin 6y agoThey only hint at this, but I think a user-centric distribution model would be much better: define a percentage split (let's say 30% for Spotify, 70% for artists), and split that percentage of revenue between the artists THAT THE USER LISTENED TO. I think that they currently use a global split, which over-represents "users" like stores, gyms, etc.
- jlelse 6y agoThat's what Deezer proposed: https://www.deezer.com/ucps https://www.deezer.com/ucps
- Aissen 6y agoIndeed, it would be much more interesting. Deezer might be on track to implement it in France (not sure when?) but a recent study (in french) gives a lot of information on its potential impact: https://cnm.fr/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/CNM_UCPS_SyntheseFinale.pdf https://cnm.fr/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/CNM_UCPS_SyntheseF...
- DocTomoe 6y agoMeanwhile, I have spent quite a bit directly to bands using band camp, buying music and vinyl there. In the end, if Spotify is not a sustainable business model for you as a musical artist, maybe it is time to look for alternatives, especially those where they do not directly compete with mega-acts?
- blfr 6y agoWhat is the average number of streams per user on Spotify? According to Last.fm, I listened to 55k songs last year, vast majority of it through Spotify.
- philderbeast 6y agomany of the demands listed, while well intentioned, are ill considered at best. Take the first demand for instance, pay $0.01 per play. on the face this sounds fine, until you look at the economics of this. Spotify Premium is $9.99, that means for every premium user there is only 999 plays per month at BEST if you don't consider any other overheads, before that payment is exhausted (not including things like discounts for 12 month plans, student and family pricing). This is not to say artists shouldn't get paid more, but how many people would take say a 10x price increase to fund this level of payment? That's not to mention they also want to remove the income stream of artists paying for increased plays on the platform (pushing more cost to the user) again, the demands may be well intentioned, and many should just be adopted such as crediting all labour for a recording, but obviously no-one has looked at the economics' it would take to actually realise the level of payment being asked for here and thought about if consumers would be willing to pay that price.
- RHSeeger 6y ago> Pay us at least one cent per stream > Spotify generally pays between $. 003 and $. 005 per stream Is Spotify making so much money that paying 3 orders of magnitude more money per stream is a realistic option?
- Reason077 6y agoThey're not asking for "orders of magnitude" more, but 2-3X more. The current average royalty is 0.38c per stream, and they want 1c per stream. That said, apparently most of Spotify's revenues already goes to pay artists, so it would not be achievable without significant increases in Spotify's fees. This would in turn reduce user numbers, leading to fewer streams, more users turning to piracy, etc.
- RHSeeger 6y agoThe places I'm looking show much, much lower numbers. > Spotify generally pays between $.003 and $.005 per stream https://www.businessinsider.com/how-much-does-spotify-pay-per-stream https://www.businessinsider.com/how-much-does-spotify-pay-pe... > Spotify paid the artists $0,0032 per stream https://soundcharts.com/blog/music-streaming-rates-payouts https://soundcharts.com/blog/music-streaming-rates-payouts It's also worth noting, we're not talking about the total amount payed per stream, we're talking about the amount that makes it specifically to the artists. From the article being discussed > To pay the median American monthly rent ($1,078) an artist needs to generate 283,684 recurring streams monthly. Those number directly align with 0.38c per stream going to the artists (283,684 * 0.0038 = 1078). And since everywhere else seems to indicate that somewhere around 3-5/100th of that amount actually goes to artists, I'm curious what the disconnect it.
- Reason077 6y ago> "The places I'm looking show much, much lower numbers. > Spotify generally pays between $.003 and $.005 per stream" This seems consistent with the 0.38c suggested in the www.unionofmusicians.org website. "$.003" = 0.3c, right?
- andrew_ 6y agoHas music become a commodity, and if so, should it face price regulation such like other commodities?
- aksss 6y agoNoise is a commodity.
- AbraKdabra 6y agoPeople acting on emotions rather than actually doing the math and seeing that one penny per stream will make Spotify prices skyrocket and if no one uses Spotify, well, they will be in a worse situation.
- RHSman2 6y agoIt's just crazy. Musicians are getting the equivalent of an ad per stream. As a musician/composer that does it for the love I put it many, many hours on each song. Its frickin' outrageous that people get as good as nothing and it seems as the more successful you are the better the deal you get #pyramid Also, the CEO of spotify is just horrible.
- jgeada 6y agoThe "work" that the artist did once is producing a lifetime of revenue by taxing everyone else's work. The artist isn't lifting a finger in the work that Spotify (or any other music platform) is doing. Why are they expecting to get more?
- RHSman2 6y agoWhat? An artist’s work isn’t just once. They ‘lifted’ their fingers to get their skills and then created something unique. Just like coding well isn’t a nice thing but very few coders make anything of their own. They are the session musicians.
- FireBeyond 6y ago> Musicians are getting the equivalent of an ad per stream. Except when I listen to an album, I'm often listening to 15 "ads" (tracks) in a row so I'm not really seeing the equivalence. Especially when there are albums I listen to in their entirety multiple times a month. At least I use Tidal, which may have its faults but has historically paid out the most to artists.
- cashewchoo 6y agoA penny a stream is honestly way more than "a play" of music has cost. I'll admit I'm off the beaten path with how I do music but this is my setup: 1. I buy the CD release of music because I like to collect them, and the art is cool (I listen to folk metal and they usually do some cool stuff with album art and the front of the CD). 2. I rip them to FLACs and store them on my plex server 3. I stream them to my phone/etc. So I'm really used to paying something like... {cost of cd} / {lifetime play count}. Which honestly is probably a lot higher than what a single stream of music earns the artists but a lot lower than 1c per play. Just as an example, let's take Sonic Firestorm by Dragonforce. I probably started listening in 2007 or so. 14 years. I listened to the entire CD probably at least 3 times a week for the entirety of high school. So 4 years of high school times 52 weeks a year times 3 plays a week times 9 tracks per play is 5616. I'd guess I paid 12 bucks for the CD (it's 10 on amazon right now). So that's 0.00214 dollars per play. And that's just high school. Though admittedly that's one of my favorite albums, but I do think Alestorm and Ensiferum and several other bands are up in that play count too for my 4 years of college. And I don't think many bands want to make the argument of "yeah but we're one of those bands you're gonna buy our CD for 12 bucks and listen to 3 times and then we end up in the back of your CD holder because every time you flip through you're like 'nah not really feeling them right now' for weeks on end". So... I dunno. I'm all for paying artists more. But I would really prefer the way we do that is decrease the (massive) cut that goes to the labels and send more to the artists. I've been buying my CDs on bandcamp as much as I can recently because as I understand it, bands capture a lot more of that sticker price that way. At least it seems like they do. I get CDs from residential addresses in Norway, anyway.
- kjakm 6y agoI would be interested to see what would happen if Spotify changed the free account to something really small (and maybe annual). For example $10 a year. I'd guess that's still small enough that most people will pay it. There are a lot of comments saying Spotify can't raise prices - but Netflix has repeatedly raised prices successfully. I'm now paying them double what I originally did when I signed up.
- Macha 6y agoAnd when you signed up, people likely just signed up to netflix and left it at that. Looking at my local pricing, the lowest plan (€7.99) is $2 cheaper than the single plan that was available when I signed up (€9.99), and the equivalent plan to what was available then is (€12.99). So that's a 33% increase in 5 years, which is much less dramatic than the 100%-200% increase spotify would need for the suggested payouts. There's a lot of account sharing or rotating streaming service or plain old fashioned piracy (the "dodgy box", formerly a pirate satellite receiver and now usually a kodi box with a frontend to some pirate stream provider, has been more common in Ireland the last few years than since digital TV was just coming in and competing with free to air broadcast TV).
- CivBase 6y agoAs I understand, artists haven't made much from record sales or radio deals historically. Most of that money goes to publishers. Instead, artists used those mediums to boost their popularity and made most of their income from merchandise and live performances. If I had to guess at what's going on here, I'd bet this is driven more by publishers than artists. Music publishers are becoming increasingly irrelevant as platforms like Spotify enable artists to distribute their work more directly at similar margins. Artists are probably just the poster child used to garner sympathy for the cause from the public.
- Reason077 6y agoIt's curious how the advent of streaming has seemingly resulted in boom times for television and film producers, yet apparently not so for musicians. Yet we pay roughly the same per month for a Spotify subscription as we do for Netflix or Amazon Prime. Is this just because when it comes to music, the revenue is spread much more thinly, amongst more artists?
- joeblau 6y agoI was just listening to a podcast and the CEO was talking about how he wants 1 million artists to be able to live off Spotify[1]. I always find it interesting how far the company implementation of the vision diverges from what the founder says the vision is. This was also something that I saw with Uber. A question i have is what leads to this disconnect? [1] - https://castro.fm/episode/I2SAkl#47:19 https://castro.fm/episode/I2SAkl#47:19
- Kuinox 6y agoI'm happy to not pay 200€ of Spotify per year: https://www.last.fm/user/Kuinox/listening-report/year https://www.last.fm/user/Kuinox/listening-report/year
- redmattred 6y agoA lot of the money in the industry is made by private music royalty funds that buy the rights to music and earn proceeds on their usage. Its a good investment (especially during covid) not available to retail investors. There is financial innovation that could happen to improve the outcomes for artists. Many asset classes previously unavailable to the public (private reits, real estate syndications, art investing, wine investing) have been brought downmarket with crowdfunding. There is green space for a music royalty fund that optimizes for artist benefit over profits and is available to the public.
- nindalf 6y agoWhat was it like being a median artist in the 90s, before and after Napster? The music industry has always been top heavy, then and now. But does anyone have data on artist earnings? It'd be interesting to know if the earnings of the median artist have increased or decreased in the last couple of decades. I totally empathise with their demand for a cent per stream, but they could be asking for a share of revenue that doesn't exist. And if the median artist is making more now than they did before Napster, they could be asking for a cut of revenue that has never existed.
- dbsmith83 6y agoSo, if I listen to music for only ~2 hours (120 min) a day, and the average song is 4 minutes, that would be ~30 songs a day, which would be 30 cents a day. $0.30 * 30 days in a month is about $9/month...which is basically my entire subscription fee--probably more. Also, there's like 4 people per account if I remember correctly.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoso streaming music has eaten several different cakes - it has eaten the cake of radio in which I doubt the artist got 1p per play, it has eaten home taping in https://www.nytimes.com/1985/11/21/arts/issue-and-debate-royalties-on-recorders-and-blank-audio-tapes.html https://www.nytimes.com/1985/11/21/arts/issue-and-debate-roy... in which there was some money paid out for the purchase of home taping equipment but which I think would not at all reach 1p per listen, it has eaten into the album which often cost enough that people bought them intermittently as a few albums could represent a significant part of disposable income, and it has eaten into the singles market (a small record with a b-track on the opposite side - already quite killed by cassettes and CDs) The people fighting for 1p per stream want to focus on the killing of the album because in that way they look like poor mistreated artists who are just asking for crumbs considering what was taken from them. And spotify etc. want to argue they are the ones who killed the radio, and thus it should cost them hardly anything and they are already paying way too much. But at any rate 1p per stream is actually quite a significant increase in price considering what the user gets. With an album one got album art etc. Lyrics / liner notes. And a number of songs - let us say 16 songs. Nowadays you have to do your own work for the album art and lyrics, and could conceivably be asked to pay separately for them. This is all a long time ago but I would think it was $10 dollars per average CD during the heyday. (somebody here surely knows the actual number) So 62.5 pennies per song if 16 songs. Perhaps it should be 1p per stream, max cost 63p per song per user? that of course still means spotify eats the part of the market that buys more than one version per year, as someone with ADHD I have had to buy London Calling about 20+ times in my life. At some point I think I should get it for free. so 1p per song streamed, max 63p per person per song every two years. If they asked for that I would think that is maybe a bit more than its worth, but also approaching fairness. But they aren't asking for that, even though they should be able to think these things through easier and quicker than I can - so until they start asking for something resembling an actual fair deal I say screw them.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agojust noting also - if you were to make 1p per song without any of my proposed limitations or similar then given the fact that people consume the songs they loved in their 20s all their lives, if you could manage to have a couple top streaming hits for that age group for a couple years you might just be able to go fishing for the rest of your life!
- motohagiography 6y agoI grew up thinking record companies were a confederacy of scumbags, and my attitude hasn't changed that much, but the question of what the fair price for a recorded song should be has been clouded by a mix of cynicism on the part of publishers, and magical thinking on the part of artists. Tech VC is an analogy for the risk model of record companies, where you have money from investors that needs a productive asset, and your risk/return appetite is being willing to accept that most of your bets will return zero, with just 2% of your investments yielding huge (10x+) multiples and 80% of your returns. Whether you are investing in bands making albums or entrepreneurs building startups, there seem to be direct similes for record sales, publishing rights, merch, side projects, and intellectual property. The point is artists make their money touring with shows, which is basically a job, where the record company/investor makes their big money because they get the benefit of having risked capital with leverage. A founder working for investors is analogous to a band touring in support of album sales. Your upside is probably a job with a lifestyle and a bonus. Which comes to the question of what a good price for a recording could be. Musicians generally don't take very much risk or use leverage that would yield investor-size returns. 99.9% of music is crap. The distribution curve of quality is really steep and long tailed, so if you invest in a given band, you are taking a <1% chance of ever seeing your money again. That's why record companies and VC make money. They're the producers. They're creating a portfolio spread over a wide pool of risk. If you write some songs, arguably, you have ventured nothing of value until someone discovers it. The music platforms provide this discovery. Sure, I wish I could earn the an equivalent living making music or writing as I do in tech, but since I'm not a superstar talent, I manage that expectation and accept comfortable mediocrity. As the amortized capital risked by a musician averaged across all the other musicians in their genre on a given song, the price of a stream above tiny fractions of a penny is generous. The missing feature seems to be a way to sell the licensing and publishing rights, where I can pay $100 to use it in a video. I get the sense that organizing spotify artists to complain is yet another way to hustle and exploit them, but this time for political ends instead of financial ones. edit: there is probably a producer/product-manager analogy to be made as well, but will leave it there.
- m-p-3 6y agoSeems like the artists are barking at the wrong tree. Don't get me wrong, I'm all for artists getting their fair share for something they created. Spotify has to deal with the record labels because they own the licensing rights, there isn't much Spotify can do about it themselves. The only thing I could see Spotify doing is to become a label themselves, and giving a bigger slice of the piedirectly to artists under them. But that could also bring some consequences, like becoming Spotify-exclusives, etc.
- andreshb 6y agoThey should protest the record labels, they are the rente seeker monopolists extracting the lion share of the value from both sides
- frabjoused 6y agoWould it really be the end to ask consumers for 50% more Spotify Premium to solve the problem? I would personally be willing to pay more and feel music is undervalued. I can't imagine they would lose 50% of their subscription base.
- aksss 6y agoI’ve said before that I’d give up Netflix before Spotify, so yeah maybe. But something would have to give out of principle. I think the better solution in this musician/label/distributor mess is the label takes less. That has costs and would change how discovery works, but frankly maybe for the better.
- FireBeyond 6y agoHow much of that 50% would go to the record labels? We'd pay 50% more and the artist would probably get 5% more. That doesn't seem like a good ROI. While no party is without concern, I don't think either Spotify, the artist or the consumer is the problem here. There's a 800lb gorilla standing over there.
- diegoholiveira 6y agoA genuine question: how much of Spotify royalty payments goes to the artist? I mean, many of them have agencies that get a cut of this money, or I'm wrong? I'm asking this because it could improve the artists situations if they could get the royalty directly without a middleman? Probably someone already did a research in this direction.
- z5h 6y agoI’ll make a track 1 second long, post to Spotify, and with my Spotify account I’ll listen to it non stop. I’ll earn $26000/month. I see no problem here.
- kangaroozach 6y agoThe model should be like Medium. Allocate peoples monthly membership in accordance to their listens. If one month I listen to 100 streams of Bob Dylan and thats it, then he should get my entire $7.00 instead of just a few cents for my small amount of streams. https://qz.com/1660465/the-way-spotify-and-apple-music-pays-artists-isnt-fair/ https://qz.com/1660465/the-way-spotify-and-apple-music-pays-...
- disantlor 6y agoThis seems almost too simple & good to be true. The counter points in the linked article mention that its too "computationally expensive" to calculate the payments, and the additional management costs could outweigh the benefit to smaller artists... how could that possible be true?
- Aissen 6y agoIt's one of the demands, the "user-centric" model. It's mostly because the major record labels (who have the top artists) might see a reduction of revenue. But even that was disproved in a recent french study: https://cnm.fr/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/CNM_UCPS_SyntheseFinale.pdf#page=16 https://cnm.fr/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/CNM_UCPS_SyntheseF...
- natdempk 6y agoIs there a translation of this report anywhere?
- Aissen 6y agoTry https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=fr&tl=en&u=https://cnm.fr/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/CNM_UCPS_SyntheseFinale.pdf https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=fr&tl=en&u=https:/... although it doesn't have graphics.
- natdempk 6y agoIt's simply not true. The whole business model of Spotify is that of any other internet business, selling a zero-marginal-cost good for a subscription fee. It would be more complicated to implement a per-user breakdown, and maybe slightly more expensive to run that analytics pipeline, but at scale there's no way the additional management costs would outweigh the benefit to smaller artists. The cost of that more advanced analytics job is going to be absorbed over the entire user base to the point where it effectively costs nothing in aggregate. The real counter point is probably that it was either easier to implement the current solution (from an engineering standpoint this is true, it's much easier to aggregate and scale their payment pipeline once per-geo-region) and there has been no push for change, or it favors larger artists and labels who have the bargaining power with Spotify.
- dan-robertson 6y agoI always liked the idea of nonlinear revenue, eg paying proportionally to the cube root of the number of streams. It would allow smaller artists to get a greater proportion of the proceeds.
- whywhywhywhy 6y agoYou willingly handed over your work to Spotify, you signed the contracts, now you're unhappy with the deal. Spotify is a recent creation and it was nothing without musicians yet they willingly went forward with it even though it was obvious what would happen and now the obvious has happened they want a better deal. It's hard for me to muster up sympathy, they could have collectively stopped Spotify from happening but they willingly became part of it.
- dandare 6y agoThey mention "user-centric model" three times without explaining it at all :(
- prionassembly 6y agoHonest question: why are all those people not on Bandcamp instead?
- csommers 6y agoThen don’t put your band there. Oh wait: you’d be complaining about Bandcamp and no recognition then. Not everything needs to be “justice”. Quit diluting words and actions.
- johbjo 6y agoCopyright and licensing is complicated, in the sense that a track has many different copyright holders, and the record companies usually make sure to own distribution rights by contract. The composers and artists might be powerless, even though they own the actual rights (which can not be sold or transferred). This partly the reason why the major labels hold so much power. Here is a great source for learning more: http://copyx.org/lectures/ http://copyx.org/lectures/
- hellbanTHIS 6y agoHell they might already be paying a penny per stream to some major labels, and everybody else takes whatever's left over, we have no idea. Maybe Drake's label demands a penny per stream for his new album or they pull it. And then somebody else who's on a tiny label gets 0.00000000001 cent per stream because that's all that's left. They really need transparency, the labels will never be transparent so Spotify has to be. If nobody's transparent about these deals then there probably needs to be legislation. That would be obvious anti-competitive behavior on the part of music labels if that's what's going on, and knowing them it probably is.
- l1am0 6y agoOfftopic & Shameless self-plug: Help small artists by listening more to their music. "How do I find small artists on Spotify" you ask? That's what I did build https://tastemaker.cc/newcomers https://tastemaker.cc/newcomers for. It is a playlists showing you 6 new small (I call them newcomer) artists every day :D
- tschwimmer 6y agoThe hard truth in music (and in many creative industries) is that there's a huge oversupply (many musicians are willing to make music for free or very cheap) and demand has a low willingness to pay. The result is that there isn't much money to be made for musicians. In my mind, there's really no way around this fact. You can argue (as these folks are) that Spotify could take a smaller cut and give more to musicians. While this is technically true, Spotify is never going to do this. It's a strictly distributive transaction: musicians make more money, Spotify makes less. Their other options are not so good either. Musicians can build a Spotify clone that's more favorable to artists. Nominally, this sounds like Tidal. The problem with Tidal is that nobody wants to spend that much money on a subscription. Even with the high profile artist exclusives it has less than 5% market share. Beyond the business model, building a Spotify clone is difficult to execute, especially for musicians and not software folks. You can somehow lobby to outlaw streaming and go back to selling songs and albums individually. This would definitely hurt Spotify but probably doesn't help musicians too much. Potentially the top 1% of musicians are better off as they're able to capture more value but the long tail is way worse as nobody discovers their music anymore. An interesting solution might be collective action. If enough musicians banded together and pulled their catalogs from Spotify, I could see that having a big negative impact on Spotify's revenue. There are a few bands that if their catalogs were off Spotify, I'd probably cancel. This would be effective but is probably too difficult to coordinate. Overall, the problem for musicians is one of economics. Too many people willing to make music, not enough willing to pay. In other words, you can't push a rope. If you are a musician, my strong advice to you is to get comfortable with doing it for a reason other than money. Otherwise, you're in for inevitable disappointment.
- herbturbo 6y agoYeah I think it's easy for up and coming musicians to blame Spotify for their financial woes, but as someone who was an aspiring musician in the 90s I can tell you it was no picnic back then. Everyone I knew was broke, so the only way to make a record was to get signed, and that involved playing shows in front of A&R people which meant finding venues etc - all on your own dime. If you did manage to get signed and get an advance, you probably used it to buy better instruments and maybe pay rent for a month or two but it didn't last long. Then if you were lucky and the label decided to distribute your stuff, you'd make about a dollar between you for every full length album you sold. Music has never been about making money. You might as well play the lottery if that's your goal. And as a consumer of music, I am very happy to be paying $14.99 a month for access to a collection that would have been virtually impossible for an individual to assemble 20 years ago. Music has been opened up to people in a way that did not exist before Spotify. Also, a good deal of the music I listen to is stuff I had already bought on CD or vinyl years before, so those artists are getting paid twice for me listening now. Bottom line is it's always been hard to break through into making money from music. Nothing has changed except the way it's distributed.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- SpeakForMyself 6y agoWhat I see is bunch of greedy people whining for more. Have this people ever considered the need of user of Spotify? I doubt it. Subscription to Spotify can be a lot to some people already, now with these greedy, self-involved and small-minded drama bunches, I just afraid the fee will go higher... Why these people can be so shameless to blame on others for their very own problem that their work sucks? So laughable. As this is the typical liberal mindset that blame the whole world for your own problem. LOSERS!
- oh_sigh 6y agoJustice would be paying out revenue on a per-streamer basis. I pay $10/mo to spotify, lets say $7 makes it to artists. If I do 100% of my streams for Obscure Band X, shouldn't 100% of my $7 go to Obscure Band X? Right now, I end up a large fraction of that $7 to Taylor Swift, the weeknd, drake, etc, and not the actual performers I listen to.
- mdoms 6y agoIf it's a worldwide event maybe they should define what a "penny" is. I think it's USD$0.01 but honestly I could be off by an order of magnitude, I really don't know.
- diddid 6y agoIf artists got a penny per stream, I'd create one song and set it up on repeat 24/7. 365 days * 24 hours * 60 minutes = 525600 minutes 525600 / 3 minute song = 175200 streams 175200 pennies / 100 = $1752 So I could pay 120 bucks a year and make 1752! I like the sound of that! And with the family plan, I could pay 1.5x the cost a month but get 5x the revenue!
- hashingroll 6y agoThere has to be a catch here...
- pgodzin 6y agoIs there a reason Spotify is uniquely targeted here? What rates do artists get on Apple Music/YouTube/Tidal/etc?
- pwinnski 6y agoSpotify is the largest player, by far, and pays the least per customer. The "average observed per-stream payout on Apple Music is $0.00551 vs. $0.00318 for Spotify."[0] That said, a lot of that is because Spotify has free users, while Apple does not. 0. https://soundcharts.com/blog/music-streaming-rates-payouts#apple-music-vs-spotify-whos-paying-artists-more https://soundcharts.com/blog/music-streaming-rates-payouts#a...
- mensetmanusman 6y agoDigital data has created a fascinating situation for artists because every new piece of art/music/video/etc. will henceforth always be competing with perfect replicas from the corpus of all human creation. That means the added incremental value of a new unit of art/etc. will asymptote to zero. This is one negative downside to the many upsides of digital technology.
- Shadonototro 6y agowhen it was Apple/Google/Amazon, they all shut their mouth now a non US company is #1, they start to yell you should have complained before
- IndySun 6y agoJust wondering if there are any developers on this post working with or defending the use of decentralised, music sharing, copyleft, anti-royalty, software? And if so, do you see the irony? I sincerely hope people take my question at face value, I am aware it's a big world.
- paxys 6y agoThose are a lot of words to describe Napster
- varispeed 6y agoWhy artists on Spotify are not treated the same as Uber drivers? They are in fact employees providing content for the platform. From that perspective, Spotify should be paying at least a minimum wage for every artist signed on to the platform, plus any streaming money as a bonus. There is also a problem that some artists (from major labels) get more money than small artists for the same number of streams. I think this should be looked into by a regulator. The same way as workers doing the same job should be paid the same salary, artists should be receiving the same money per stream.
- cwkoss 6y agoNot all music has value. Music is almost never a full time job. Supply vastly outpaces demand. If I record the sound of myself taking a crap and upload it to Spotify, do I deserve to get a perpetual minimum wage for being an artist?
- FalconSensei 6y ago> They are in fact employees providing content for the platform. From that perspective, Spotify should be paying at least a minimum wage for every artist signed on to the platform the solution would be to remove all indie artists, and most of the rest too, and only keep the top 1% of pop/rock musicians.
- goatcode 6y agoAre large gatherings allowed at all the planned locations? This seems a little tone-deaf.
- intellix 6y agoReminder that Spotify have forced paying customers to beta test a new UI with significant features outright removed without the ability to opt out. There's 130 pages (1300 comments) of negative feedback and they don't care. I had been paying monthly for a decade and have since stopped until they revert my client: https://community.spotify.com/t5/Desktop-Windows/New-Desktop-Experience-your-feedback-wanted/td-p/5072418/page/129 https://community.spotify.com/t5/Desktop-Windows/New-Desktop...
- m000 6y agoThis case reminds me the French Press Association vs. Google News case [1]. The details differ, but the outcome is the same: It's not in your interest as content producer to be excluded. If it wasn't already free for you, you would probably be enticed to pay in order to gain visibility by your customer base. And frankly, I don't know what UMAW expects to get. Can really Spotify support the $0.01/stream without going out of business? Why are they making non-bilateral demands to Spotify (e.g. reveal business contracts)? And who are UMAW anyway? From a quick check of their page, the only names I could find were the steering committee, and it took several tries to find members with >1 albums on Spotify. With that level of opaqueness, it's hard to see them convince the public to throw their support behind them. And what's with the sub-committee mania? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_News#EU_copyright_and_database_right https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Google_News#EU_copyright_and_d...
- HeyZuess 6y ago> We are asking Spotify to raise the average streaming royalty from $.0038 to a penny per stream. Doing so would give artists a better chance at making a living from their art, and begin to restore the public valuation of music. The public valuation of music is that it is a commodity, and yes while it would be nice to make a living from art it would then be a product.
- RHSman2 6y agoAs a musician one has to reconcile with the difference between the magic of emotional response and the utility of that. The bigger that utility the more the people who make money from it will pay you. In this day and age it’s the streaming and the Crowd. It has always been like this but I think the gap is bigger now.