9 ms·
Huh? Buying art with an NFT is just a way to give artists and/or art auctioneers money for their art. That's it. Oh and it can be used for other things like e
by nerdponx 6y ago
Huh?
Buying art with an NFT is just a way to give artists and/or art auctioneers money for their art. That's it.
Oh and it can be used for other things like event ticketing, software license keys, etc.
An NFT is just a way to record (in an immutable distributed ledger) that a specific, uniquely-identifiable token was transferred from A to B.
People have always paid stupid amounts of money for art, and in the last 100 years increasingly art that doesn't require years of training/practice and advanced craftsmanship. Why is this any different?
It sounds like you just don't want to be involved in the art market, which nobody in their right mind wants to be involved in anyway.
Complaining about NFTs is like complaining about "blockchain" or "the internet" or whatever.
- stickfigure 6y ago> Why is this any different? Because if you buy a painting, you can hang it on your wall.
- djitz 6y agoBuy an NFT and make it your desktop and mobile backgrounds. You’re welcome.
- andreilys 6y agoYou don’t need to buy an NFT to make it your desktop or mobile background.
- everly 6y agoRight and you can also buy a cheap print of an expensive, famous piece and hang it on your wall. In fact, people do it all the time! Doesn’t diminish the value of the original.
- finexplained 6y agoExcept that in this case the bits are literally identical.
- jackvezkovic 6y agoSo, if we in the future are able to clone a Mona Lisa perfectly, will it be as worth as the original? Does it decrease the value of the original?
- iamacyborg 6y agoNo, because the original was made hundreds of years ago by a now globally recognised artist. A jpg is just a jpg.
- mint2 6y agoPerfectly as in the exact paint compounds, the effect of that order of brush strokes and timing, and then aging. Such that no art expert or chemical/forensic analysis can tell them apart other than the label saying which is which? That doesn’t not sound at all feasible. But if it were, then sure the prices would have to be close for the original and new one. It sounds impossible to do, and extremely easy expensive to make a copy like that of a real painting. It’s stupidly easy and simple to do with a digital work.
- miracle2k 6y agoAny number of artworks are being sold which allow for reproducibility, say photographs. Expensive limited edition prints are a thing. In most of those cases the particular physical manifestation you acquire is entirely a construct. Even for an original painting, the fact that you desire that particular manifestation (over say an improved one which the original artist may now be able to do) is a construct. If a painting needs restoration, you may find that some elements are no longer original; this will not diminish its value. If over the years we replace all the parts of the Mona Lisa, it will still be the Mona Lisa (see also: the Ship of Theseus).
- 6y ago
- tantalor 6y agoIt diminishes you, it's tacky.
- Rule35 6y agoRight, art is only for the rich who can experience the original in person. My evil school with that art history textbook...
- foobar33333 6y agoNo but getting an obvious replication is just a little weird. There is plenty of art of identical and higher quality than the famous pieces within affordable prices.
- Rule35 6y agoYou seriously think so? Or is that for the uncanny valley where it's obviously just a replica, but not just a poster? A lot of art, for many, is that others see the same thing through different eyes. Looking at the Mona Lisa or a Rembrandt, means that I'm experiencing what millions have but uniquely. Shared experiences create bonds, even across time and space. It's also perhaps a bit humbling in a way another similarly good painting from now wouldn't be because of the temporal distance it comes from.
- rodonn 6y agoYou can do this without buying the NFT also.
- maxerickson 6y agoDoes most of the money actually go to artists?
- cmrdsprklpny 6y agoIf the artist is themself selling the art as an NFT, I believe so.
- rodonn 6y agoYes, but there is a big problem of people other than the artist creating NFTs for other peoples art. There is nothing in the NFT process that guarantees the money is going to the "right" person.
- TigeriusKirk 6y agoFrom the original sale almost all of it goes to the person who minted it, minus a small fee (around 5%) for the platform. That should be the artist, but of course there are people minting art that isn't theirs. There's efforts to catch and remove that, but a lot slips through. From secondary market sales, the artist can get a royalty if they choose and the secondary transaction is on the same platform. Typically around 10%. The same platform requirement is an issue and hopefully a future NFT standard smart contract will build in a royalty option/.
- ALittleLight 6y agoHow do you remove tokens minted by people other than the artist? Who removes it, and what stops that person or those people from removing legitimate tokens?
- Rule35 6y agoEither you don't, and can't, or you build a special script with a revocation list run by trusted 'Oracles' who would essentially notarize a legal claim by the artist into a blocklist of image hashes, or a whitelist of who can mint NFTs for those hashes. Those Oracles would ideally be known parties who could be sued under the laws of their jurisdiction for lying.
- ahepp 6y agoHow is the token associated with the work?
- Kiro 6y agoThe token (according to the ERC-721 standard) contains a URL to a hosted JSON which contains a URL to the hosted image. So to access the actual image you need to go through two different servers.
- TedDoesntTalk 6y agoSerious question: What happens in 20 years if the domain registration for that URL is not renewed, or the website hosting that JSON is gone?
- Rule35 6y agoWhat happens if you drop your print in a puddle and it's destroyed, but you still have the proof of authenticity in your pocket? While the artist is alive, they'll probably replace it at cost. But after the artist is gone the certificate does nothing. (It still proves your status, like the NFT, but otherwise is worthless.)
- nerdponx 6y agoUse IPFS.
- mrgordon 6y agoThis doesn’t solve the problem at all. Many of the NFT sites are hosting their own IPFS and many of the images have already gone missing from the IPFS because no one is hosting that file still. https://twitter.com/checkmynft/status/1371633090318249984?s=21 https://twitter.com/checkmynft/status/1371633090318249984?s=... https://twitter.com/scanlime/status/1371509988179464196?s=21 https://twitter.com/scanlime/status/1371509988179464196?s=21
- 6y ago
- palebluedot 6y agoHere is one thing I have a hard time wrapping my head around, and how I think it is fundamentally different from something like a painting: The thing that is "non-fungible" is the token, not the actual art. The underlying digital asset is actually fungible with copies of it. With a painting, there are prints and reproductions of the Mona Lisa, but they are all fundamentally different in some way - the exact brush stroke texture, etc. NFTs have this feeling of valuing the receipt, not the art. As if I walked into a gift shop at The Louvre and bought a Mona Lisa slick poster print, but then valued the gift store receipt more than the more-or-less completely replaceable poster.
- nerdponx 6y agoIt's like buying a piece of land. You don't physically take the land home, you just acquire new and specific rights depending on your legal jurisdiction. Are you buying the property, or just the deed to the property?
- mejutoco 6y agoAcquiring the land makes you the legal owner of it, backed by the law of the country and its military. Owning the nft has no legal consequence at the moment. Who will enforce any right on your behalf?
- miracle2k 6y agoWhich rights? Legal rights that the artist wants to sell alongside the token can be legally enforced. Beyond that, the ownership of the token is enforced by the blockchain, and that ownership token is the thing people value.
- sneak 6y ago> Legal rights that the artist wants to sell alongside the token can be legally enforced. For the first sale. I'm not sure current contract law permits any legal rights to follow the token in subsequent sales.
- Grustaf 6y agoBecause without NFTs there would be no way to give money to the original artist, right.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- weare138 6y ago>Buying art with an NFT is just a way to give artists and/or art auctioneers money for their art. That's it. But we could already do that. It's a solution to a problem no one had. A NFT would only be useful for proving ownership if it will hold up in court, which I doubt it would without accompanying proof of purchase.
- Rule35 6y agoIt's literally impossible for someone without the purchaser's key to pretend to be the purchaser. That's 1000x what a receipt proves. Whatever their flaws, NFTs are perfect proof of ownership of the token...
- sio8ohPi 6y agoNFTs provide proof of ownership of the token, but no guarantee the NFT wasn't issued "fraudulently". C.f.: https://www.reddit.com/r/NFT/comments/m3y4go/my_art_stolen_and_sold_as_nft_what_can_i_do/ https://www.reddit.com/r/NFT/comments/m3y4go/my_art_stolen_a...
- Rule35 6y agoSo? You can buy "counterfeit" or "stolen" art at many galleries. But if you care about the artist enough to want to donate I imagine you're more familiar with their work than all that.
- nerdponx 6y agoIsn't this literally the only thing an NFT guarantees anyway? It is precisely a "non-fungible token" and nothing more. Anything you can do with a non-fungible piece of paper, you can do with a non-fungible token. Anything you can't do with a non-fungible piece of paper, you can't do with a non-fungible token. I'm blown away by how many people are upset that other people are doing stupid things at the confluence of new technology and excessive spending money.
- Rule35 6y ago
- FridgeSeal 6y agoHow is an NFT in any way better than a signed proof-of-purchase?
- nerdponx 6y agoNot any better, unless you value having the exchange recorded in an immutable distributed ledger. Some people value that.