12 ms·
China’s $4k electric cars tap huge market Tesla can’t reach
- rasz 6y agoin case anyone is wondering - $4500-5500 13.0kW motor 9-13kWh battery mobility scooter dressed in car shaped shell with a "quality somewhere between economy car and a public bathroom". https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=11ExTYIEJm0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=11ExTYIEJm0 tldr: great alternative to a scooter.
- BossingAround 6y agoInteresting. The lack of security is probably why I don't see them in the EU (would be surprised if they were legal to sell as cars). That said, I personally don't own a car for ethical reasons, and I'd love this small one for shopping or just small trips on the weekends.
- christkv 6y agoThe French have this car https://youtu.be/uUEKtOGmpVI https://youtu.be/uUEKtOGmpVI
- tibbydudeza 6y agoIt would be perfect for us now just running the usual errands as since WFH we rarely travel outside our city borders on the national highways.
- TheDong 6y agoI'm curious to hear about the ethical reasons you have for avoiding car ownership. What are they?
- foepys 6y agoA typical car is standing around 90% of the day, if not more. It's a waste of space that could be used for trees, walkways, cycle lanes, etc. If we pooled our resources together and made renting cars easy and accessible, we'd have more space in cities for the people living there.
- rapsey 6y agoThe thing is that during those 10% most or at least a lot of them are on the road.
- foepys 6y agoCommuting nowadays is broken. People commuting by car are hauling around 4 or more empty seats at 30 km/h along a highway full of other people doing the same, going into the same cities often into the same office districs. We could get rid of a lot of cars if we didn't drive around 4 empty seats and filled just one. Or if we lived closer to where we worked but that's seems like a more complex problem.
- imtringued 6y ago> Commuting nowadays is broken. People commuting by car are hauling around 4 or more empty seats at 30 km/h along a highway full of other people doing the same, going into the same cities often into the same office districs. We could get rid of a lot of cars if we didn't drive around 4 empty seats and filled just one. Unfortunately, highways require a certain minimum vehicle size. The best you could possibly do is have a short coupe with 2 seats. It wouldn't significantly influence the size of the vehicle but waste more resources for the few times where you need a 3-4 person vehicle. The savings to be had are way too slim. However, driving a pick up truck for your commute is absolutely a waste of resources because there are smaller and more aerodynamic cars that are commute worthy. >Or if we lived closer to where we worked but that's seems like a more complex problem. It's the only solution. Building a von Neuman architecture style city is absolutely stupid for society since the world is inherently parallel. There is no logical reason to have massive central work place districts. Each office building is a cpu core and each residential building is a memory chip in its own right. We don't need to put all the cpu cores next to each other and put the memory somewhere else. A distributed development pattern is significantly more efficient since data and computation are next to each other.
- foepys 6y agoWe have even smaller vehicles currently powered by 50ccm ICE in Germany. You only need a scooter license for them and they are being driven mostly by elderly or disabled people that either cannot get or don't want to pay about 1.500€ for a full drivers license for cars. There aren't many of them on the road, I'd say less than 0.1%, but they do exist and I see one at least once a week. Another advantage is that they don't need to get inspected every other year by the authorities (TÜV) and due to the standard 50ccm two-stroke scooter motor they are really cheap to maintain.
- aww_dang 6y agoWhat are the brand and model names?
- foepys 6y agoAixam is one manufacturer and based in France as I'm now finding out. The models are relatively expensive, though, because they are not produced in high numbers. https://www.aixam.com/ https://www.aixam.com/
- riffraff 6y ago> driven mostly by elderly or disabled people how odd, in Italy small ICE vehicles in this category (which I believe is called "Light quadricycles" or L6e) seem to be marketed mostly to kids from affluent families. .
- llarsson 6y agoThat demographic makes for a more positive marketing campaign. Look at ads for fashion that actually targets older people. It will also feature people in their early thirties, at most. Everybody still knows exactly what the intention is.
- riffraff 6y agoI know what you mean, but I meant that it's mostly young kids who "buy" them, it's become almost a stereotype.
- 7_my_mind 6y agoif hypothetically one could ban cars from cities and only allow such low powered transport, it would be quite an efficient safe and clean form of transport
- Leherenn 6y agoI don't know, I'm not sure they are really solving something. Local residents can probably rely on public transports/walking/cycling to move within the city. People from outside probably need a car to reach the city itself, but if you can't use those low powered cars on high speed roads then there's no point in having one. Better a "full" car that gets you to a public transports node on the edge of the city and then you switch.
- devdas 6y agoThat is what trains and buses are for.
- willvarfar 6y ago"Moped cars" are a big thing in Sweden too, as 15yos can drive them just like they can drive a scooter. They are typically small diesels and currently cost about €16k+ new, though, so are in an entirely different price class (if not tech class). There are some cheaper and some electric alternatives starting to arrive on the market. Right now, the electric alternatives don't have much range.
- beaunative 6y agoThat shell is all most might need, to go shopping or run any errand in the city. It's much safer than a scooter and carries much more. Obviously you probably shouldn't be driving it in the highway, but how often does that happen?
- franklampard 6y agoAnd bad whether and stuff. Would you ride a scooter in rainy days or in this?
- franklampard 6y agoWeather
- sudosysgen 6y ago13kW is way beyond scooter territory and more like entry level motorcycle territory. It's a good alternative to a smart car, it has uses cases much beyond that of a scooter by nature of having, say, a roof.
- Retric 6y ago13kW or 17.4 hp is anemic for a motorcycle and your moving a larger vehicle. It’s a golf cart which often use 12HP engines that’s slightly boosted to handle a windshield.
- simfree 6y agoThe driving experience of an ICE engine versus an electric motor of the same horsepower is not similar. They have much different acceleration curves and driving experiences.
- Retric 6y agoAcceleration at low speed is one thing, but near top speed EV vs ICE makes minimal difference. An underpowered car is going to be slow either way. What people notice about EV’s is really an artifact of being cars having extremely overpowered engines but ineffective transmissions to maximize the use of that power.
- sudosysgen 6y ago17hp is reasonable for a small motorcycle. You only need more power if you are going on highways, and this vehicle doesn't. For comparison, it's about twice as much as the Honda Grom, which is certainly beyond a scooter. It's as much power as a Honda Rebel 250, a CBF250, an MT125, a Yamaha Vixion, an ST250, etc..., and those are gas engines that will generally only provide like 50-70% of their power. Electric golf carts generally use 3-5hp engines. That's because for small engines, the electric advantage of always delivering the same amount of power is a huge deal. 18hp was enough for many cars. It is fine for city driving. It goes up to 100km/h, it's fine. Also, the peak power of the motor is actually 20kW, 13kW is the sustained power, which again is more than enough for city driving.
- betwixthewires 6y agoLol watching the video and the guy says "there isn't even a park! You get reverse, neutral and drive, that's it! Your park is the hand brake! I didn't even know that was possible!" Someone who's never even seen a standard transmission car has no business reviewing cars.
- culopatin 6y agoIt’s fine if they haven’t driven one, but at least read a little.
- cameronh90 6y agoOf course manual gearboxes have park. It's known as 1 or R depending on which way you're facing... ;)
- ben_w 6y agoNot something I was taught to do for my UK license in ‘09, IIRC.
- cameronh90 6y agoIt's one of those things I picked up from when older people taught me how to drive. Presumably from when hand brakes were more likely to fail than on modern cars. Maybe if someone crashes into the car while it's parked. Either way I still do it. And turn my wheels towards/away from the kerb on a hill as appropriate. Probably useless but if you have a fail-safe, may as well apply it.
- jozvolskyef 6y agoForgetting the handbrake is a common cause of minor accidents. Half the automotive 'fail' videos on the internet are people forgetting the handbrake. The habit of never leaving the engine on neutral greatly reduces the probability of this kind of an accident.
- 6y ago
- TLightful 6y agoThere are some decent $5-$10k small EV's in China that will mop up customers who can't reach Tesla levels of affordability. And with the advent of Hyundai Ioniq 5 and other cars coming on stream in the premium space, Tesla can suck a fat one.
- neonate 6y agohttps://archive.is/KsHYA https://archive.is/KsHYA
- sunstone 6y agoI wonder how it does in the government safety ratings?
- nowherebeen 6y agoIt probably has the same safety rating as a scooter. These cars aren't meant for highways, but are great for urban commutes within a few kilometers. The perfect use case is if you need it just to get groceries.
- i_have_an_idea 6y agoI don't dispute the use case for urban commuters and short distances, however, these things should absolutely have airbags. You can be the safest and most responsible driver, but some crazy a*hole can still slam into you head on with a SUV. Airbags should not be a cost cutting option.
- imhoguy 6y agoAnd battery safety.
- xiphias2 6y agoWe'll see after self driving is working and scaling. Tesla's plan is to have less car owners and more service users.
- Daho0n 6y agoTesla's plan is also to have self driving cars, but they don't (and won't have for years to come).
- xiphias2 6y agoYes, that’s the most likely way to scale up electric car use. It would take 30 more years to get rid of gas cars. Why do you think Tesla won’t have self driving cars in the next 5 years?
- Daho0n 6y agoThe point is that Elon musk said we would have self driving robotaxis in 2020. Every expert worth his salt says we aren't anywhere near self driving cars. Only Tesla and non-experts says otherwise. Self driving requires AI or some kind of rails. We are years from any kind of intelligence.
- partingshots 6y ago$4k death traps more like. There’s no way you would ever get those approved in the US for sale.
- montzark 6y agoDeath traps because rest of the vehicles are way heavier and more dangerous (also to pedestrians). If all cars were like that it would be fine.
- Lucasoato 6y agoNo, they would still be death traps since cars may also hit other hard obstacles like walls and rocks.
- jessaustin 6y agoThey're going slower so it will be ok.
- icedistilled 6y ago20mph to a wall is going to leave a mark without crumple zones
- saiya-jin 6y agoIf they would be used for city speeds only, the risks aren't much bigger compared to scooters, in contrary. But I have 0 doubt that being priced so aggressively, US and Europe would slap such a huge tariff to protect local markets, they would be very uncompetitive.
- aww_dang 6y agoIt wouldn't be suitable for US highways. It would make sense if regulators would allow another class of vehicle for city cars.
- 6y ago
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- numpad0 6y agoOh interesting, I was just googling about it to see if I can make a 3D model of it, just for novelty.
- spiritplumber 6y agoMy mom who lives in Milan has had something similar for more than ten years and it works great. Cost a bit more than $4000 at the time, but not much more, and it's saved a lot of money in gas and taxes.
- omarforgotpwd 6y agoin February Tesla outsold this $4000 car (the Wuling HongGuang MiniEV) definitely a completely different market though. This car doesn't even have air bags
- Reventlov 6y agoReminds me of the Citroen Ami for some reason: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SBD0Q9p4bR4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SBD0Q9p4bR4
- alisonatwork 6y agoThere was a decent discussion on these a few weeks ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26232760 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26232760 And a few months before that: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24601479 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24601479
- 02020202 6y agoAmsterdam https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B9ly7JjqEb0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B9ly7JjqEb0
- throwaway4good 6y agoChina's strategic planning around electric cars is really a thing of beauty. Imagine a massive growing middle class buying gas-powered foreign produced cars instead. What would that do the Chinese economy and security with all oil imported? The strategy of welcoming of firms such as Tesla builds up a huge ecosystem of suppliers creating possibilities for China's own car companies. Whether they target a highend international market such as with the Volvo Polestar or the small electric car market. The small car market basically doesn't exist in the west. We don't find these cars safe or desireble enough. But safety and desirability of this category of cars will improve rapidly over time and ultimately they will become attractive enough to be sold in the west.
- silvestrov 6y agoFixed: The small car market basically doesn't exist in the USA. There are a lot of small cars in European big cities as it is difficult to find parking space for an "american sized" car. The sedans which Americans thinks of as "small car", we think of "too big car for the city".
- tibbydudeza 6y agoYep they don't sell the VW Polo (my daily driver) in the US. It seem compact hatchbacks/cars (a.k.a B segment) has no market.
- tw04 6y agoNo, they sell the golf which is about a foot longer. I'd still call it a compact hatchback. Chevy makes the Aveo. You can still buy a Smart car here. The mini is quite popular. There is absolutely a segment for compact cars in the US, it's just nowhere near as large because most people spend time on the highway and don't feel as safe being surrounded by larger cars and OTR trucks.
- throwaway4good 6y agoYes, agreed. The US has a strange obsession with massive cars. However it was not the european style small cars I ment when I referred to small cars but rather the 4000 USD electric cars, the article is refering to. Those you do not see in Europe at present. In fact, the only Chinese EVs I have seen are the MG ZS EV and Volvo Polestar - both big cars. The small electrics are things like the VW Up electric and the Fiat 500 electric, both European.
- anti-shill 6y agothe Straits Times has this same article, but without the paywall, just google the article title
- llarsson 6y agoI love the idea of a city-only electric car that is speed-capped at something reasonable. They would be the easiest to automate fully (lower risk of damaging pedestrians or others on the road) and do not pollute inside densely populated areas. Your average speed in a city center is pretty low anyway, so if it could be automated to avoid slow starts when lights turn green (I have to imagine that automated cars could simultaneously start, rather than having to make sure the car in front of you had committed to driving before you do) would actually improve the experience and average speed immensely.
- weddpros 6y agoonly 5 full page reloads before I could finally accept that f*ing cookie dialog... gg bloomberg and europe
- ilamont 6y agoA few years ago I drove one of these cars, which fell somewhere between a Yugo and a golf cart in terms of appearance, speed, passenger room, and (most importantly) safety.
- s1k3s 6y agoLove the Musk army in this thread, eager to destroy any sort of competitor this brand has. You know you guys are the ones that benefit from this kind of market competition, right?
- Justin_K 6y agoTo be fair, these companies are selling to completely different customers and market segments. It's kind of silly to compare them.
- xirbeosbwo1234 6y agoWho cares? Tesla's dead in the water anyway. How does it compete with the real players?
- finikytou 6y agorenault dacia is about to go out in europe. it is a 12kEur (after tax rebate) car. Id say its a real huge market tesla can't reach. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2VHstY5pKhw&ab_channel=YOUCAR https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2VHstY5pKhw&ab_channel=YOUCA...
- sgt 6y agoThat's incredibly good value. Although I do like big cars and trucks, it would make sense to have one of those puppies in the garage too, for shopping and short errands.
- zozin 6y agoFlame bait article. Tesla is a high-end/luxury brand trying to dabble in more affordable, but still luxurious vehicles. Those products are lower volume, but have higher margins. Imagine reading an article titled: China's Go-Kart is a Huge Market Volkswagen can't Reach. Ridiculous.
- aksss 6y agoAn electric car that is charged from coal-generated power is basically a coal car.
- trixie_ 6y agoDid you know that not all power comes from burning coal?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 6y ago> An electric car that is charged from coal-generated power is basically a coal car. It's a “coal car” that's much easier to upgrade, en masse with millions like it, to end-to-end cleaner technology than a cat with an onboard fossil fuel engine.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dmurray 6y ago58% of Chinese electricity comes from fossil fuels [0], and that's dropping fast (65% in 2019). Also, the worst thing about a coal-fired car would be particulate pollution in the city where you drive it, so generating that electricity far away from the city helps a lot there. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electricity_sector_in_China
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rsj_hn 6y agoAccording to https://www.eia.gov/international/analysis/country/CHN https://www.eia.gov/international/analysis/country/CHN 58% of china's energy comes from coal alone (which I suspect is where you get your fossil fuel figure) 20% comes from oil and related fluids 8% natural gas so 86% fossil fuels. Of the remaining 14%, 2% is nuclear and 11% is renewable. > and that's dropping fast (65% in 2019) The percentage is dropping slowly because newer forms of generation such as solar are coming online. China is using all the energy it can get from every sector, they are rapidly adding coal capacity along with everything else. China has no qualms about opening hundreds of coal plants per year, except they are also manufacturing millions of solar panels as well.
- onetimemanytime 6y agoYeah and Tesla can't tap the Boeing or Bugatti market. Different cars for different markets and budget. $4k car is great for driving a few miles or once a week. Or within city limits. Generally, you get what you pay for so a $4k can't offer what a $80K car does. Common sense.
- _ph_ 6y agoTesla certainly isn't in the market of $4k cars, but it is an interesting thought that with their new casting process, they could basically cast the backbone of a small car in one piece, lowering the assembly costs drastically. So if they ever decide to make a super-affordable mini car (perhaps for the Indian market?), it could be astonishingly cheap.
- jbluepolarbear 6y agoI remember reading a couple years ago about a light hybrid car in India. Can’t find the article, but here’s the tech link: https://www.marutisuzuki.com/corporate/technology/smart-hybrid https://www.marutisuzuki.com/corporate/technology/smart-hybr... This seemed like a better alternative to cheap electric cars. I don’t know how to convert Lahks to dollars, but the original article said around $5000 usd.