18 ms·
What We Can Learn from Japanese Prefab Homes
- potiuper 6y agoWhere are the kanawa tsugi (金輪継) prefabs?
- Shadonototro 6y agoit's not a "japanese thing", it was done already everywhere else in the world i don't understand this pseudo fascination for japan also, it solves nothing, it is an excuse to not focus on the real problem the housing market and the insane amount of speculation around it
- Clewza313 6y agoThere's actually lots of interesting things about the Japanese housing market: it's not a speculative investment (most houses lose value), much of the housing is designed to be disposable (lifespan 20-30 years), rents are quite affordable even in the biggest cities but commutes are long and size tends to be tiny by Western standards. But I agree that prefabs aren't particularly interesting.
- jdshaffer 6y agoPretty much here in Japan the houses ARE considered disposable -- at least if you go to buy a house or build a house you quickly realize that the big chunk of money is for the land and even though building your house will be expensive, it'll be worth nearly nothing when/if you go to sell it. (That's why I've hesitated to buy a house here...)
- BurningFrog 6y agoSounds like you can get a "second hand" house very cheaply. Or is the catch that they're so cheaply built that you don't want to live in them?
- brigandish 6y ago> Or is the catch that they're so cheaply built that you don't want to live in them? Yes, or at least they'll need a big refurb.
- bobthepanda 6y agoKeep in mind that one factor the rest of the world probably doesn’t have is earthquake codes. Japan has very stringent building regulations and they usually get updated after major events. The most recent revisions were in 1981 and 2000; a house is going to have poor resale value if it will kill you in the event of an earthquake.
- baybal2 6y agoWell, yet they still build with wood...
- Tor3 6y agoBut these days there's a steel frame keeping the top storey from falling down into the lower storey, as will typically happen in an earthquake with older style homes.
- bluGill 6y agoWood works well in earthquakes - when you design for it. Wood is flexible so shaking it won't damage anything structural and so repair is cosmetic. (the above is strongly an over simplification!) That is why Japan builds with wood a lot instead of brick/rock: after the earthquake you have a safe place to live while you repair it. Repairs might be so expensive that you rebuild, but at least you can a safe roof while building the new place. Not to mention if you were inside you don't die of building collapse.
- baybal2 6y ago> Wood works well in earthquakes - when you design for it. I highly doubt that "designing for it" really beats inherently stronger building materials to specifically choose wood with its many, many other disadvantages over something else.
- bobthepanda 6y agoThe long commute can be explained, IMO, in part by the transportation allowance, where employers are allowed to subsidize up to 1000USD/mo of commuting costs. It makes “commute until you qualify” longer than it might otherwise be. And it doesn’t help that there has long been a tendency to overcentralize in Tokyo, which is very large and can take a while to commute around.
- rirarobo 6y agoI also find this strange. Not only are prefab homes done everywhere else in the world, but prefab homes and single family homes in general are not that common in Japan. If you were going to take any lessons from Japan regarding housing, wouldn't it be more along the lines of how to build high density housing cost effectively in coordination with world class public transportation infrastructure?
- imwillofficial 6y agoFrom a US perspective, this article was quite eye opening. I was actually walking around a prefab home lot this afternoon. They firmly occupy the poorest rung of the housing market. In Japan the cultural and build quality issues seem to have been surmounted. Very interesting.
- SV_BubbleTime 6y agoAdding, I’d be a lot more impressed with the idea we should “learn lessons” from Japanese Prefab if they had even a remotely volatile climate like most of the USA does. What is the average temp swing per year in Japan? Like a 40 degree (F) swing over the year? Lol, ok, show me those amazing looking modern prefabs for places there you get 60 degree (F) swing in day and let’s see how they’re doing. Or that cool aluminum place with 2ft of snow on it. Etc. Not that we can’t learn lessons, but I think structures just need a lot less engineering in Asia compared to other places.
- Izikiel43 6y agoWell, it depends where in Japan you go to, like the US. Hokkaido in the north gets lots of snow, the south like Osaka and beyond gets hot in the summer.
- imwillofficial 6y agoI don’t know what your attitude is about, but while prefab homes are done the world over, in the west they are often the poorest parts of society forced to live there due to no other options. Culturally, this seems to be quite different.
- psychstudio 6y agoThis isn't really true unless you are equating the US with "the west". There are many German and Dutch companies that make high-end pre-fabricated houses and walls that sell not only locally, but abroad. Many factors contribute to the purchasing decisions of quality pre-fabricated housing materials, of which price is only one (and probably isn't even a factor at the high-end).
- sjg007 6y agoA big thing in the US is the housing construction and related service industry. That's a lot of voters.
- zdragnar 6y agoI would imagine that insurance companies have much more influence over government regulation of building codes than construction crews do. After all, insurance companies are the ones that have to pay out if the house doesn't hold up.
- sjg007 6y agoIt's State governments that cover residential construction issues. All of them have laws and limitations and in fact have an pooled insurance fund (paid for by contractor license fees etc...)
- imwillofficial 6y agoThem being made doesn’t mean them being used. Can you share your personal experience with prefab homes and social strata in other countries?
- brigandish 6y ago> it is an excuse to not focus on the real problem > the housing market and the insane amount of speculation around it Couldn't agree more. > i don't understand this pseudo fascination for japan Because people who've not lived there usually have entirely the wrong idea about it, and articles like this one with its buzzwords (the first paragraph is almost parody) and lack of context (number one would be the low quality of housing in Japan, it'd be literally criminal if anyone with the power to look into it would), add in a mix of (seemingly) impenetrable language, stereotypes from the 1980s about futuristic technology, and endless animes about robots deepening that, and you end up at "wow, Japan!" Meanwhile, I freeze my arse off every winter and curse the build quality daily.
- Aeolun 6y agoI’m not sure what to take from this. In all my 8 years of living in Japan I have yet to see any prefabricated homes being built (and I’ve probably seen hundreds of houses under construction).
- rtpg 6y agoI suppose for appartments unit baths are prefab? Like just a sealed block with your toilet and bathtub, all in one package. There's also just like... the shower room itself, even in nicer appartments, that ends up just being a block (see video of installation). Seems like a pretty good way of reducing issues like leaks or weird plumbing issues. [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CB3wl4LWSJU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CB3wl4LWSJU
- bschwindHN 6y ago> the shower room itself, even in nicer appartments, that ends up just being a block These are the best! One of my favorite parts of Japanese apartments. They make so much more sense than standing in a narrow bathtub, next to a toilet, in a room where you can't splash water everywhere. With that being said, I'll take the insulation and central heating/cooling from western housing.
- franciscop 6y agoI live in Japan as well and this it the thing I hate the most! You have half a shower and half a bathtub (unless you go very high end). I'd rather prefer a full shower or a full bathtub instead. Same happens with the toilet, it's a claustrophobic "room" under 1 sqmt, smaller than a ryanair seat. I would strongly prefer either having a bigger shower (no bathtub) + bigger toilet, or a bigger bathtub (no shower floor) + bigger toilet! Though some Japanese people really want/need a bathtub, so I guess it's just cultural.
- fomine3 6y agoShower + bathtub style is unacceptable for traditional Japanese lifestyle. All people on family take a bath everyday after a shower. They shares same bath water on a day because replacing water on a bath every time is huge waste of water and energy. It's fine for single person who don't take a bath but just a shower, but it seems to not majority. Most Japanese hates shower/bathtub + toilet style because it seems to completely nonsense, small space is relatively not a problem. While bathing, why should we see toilet and sniff toilet smell? Also toilet paper and cloths wets by bath. It's more problem for a family because Japanese house very rarely has multiple shower rooms.
- znpy 6y agoprefab houses look cool and everything... untill you start get numbers into the pictures. it's not always clear if thermal performance/efficiency will be better, and they usually are very expensive. they might be cheaper than building a 700 square meters house, but that doesn't help a lot people looking for 70 square meters homes. meh.
- imwillofficial 6y agoAs somebody who chose the RV life because TinyHomes in the Us are a mess, I found this article riveting (heh). This is def on my “to buy” list!
- nullserver 6y agoIsn’t the major issue with Prefab everything else? Building Foundation Buying Land Electric, water, sewer.
- pottertheotter 6y agoWhat do you mean by major issue? You still have to do those things, but not sure what the issue is you're thinking of.
- nullserver 6y agoIdea is that actually building a house isn’t a big deal. It’s mostly the prep work for the land. So prefab only gets you so much.
- djrogers 6y agoI’ve been hearing for decades about how great and cheap prefab homes are, so when I recently started looking I to adding a second home on my lot (~800sq ft or so), I looked into it. What I found was very disappointing - costs were the same or higher when compared to a custom unit built in-place, and the options for style, layout, and size were much less. There is some advantage in speed, but at this size it’s a matter of a few months difference- not enough for the trade offs.
- chasil 6y agoThe market leader of prefab homes in the U.S. (afaik) is Clayton Homes, a subsidiary of Berkshire Hathaway, "run" by Warren Buffet. Clayton Homes was in the news earlier this decade for abusive loan practices. They are likely best avoided, and I say this as a Berkshire stockholder. https://money.com/warren-buffett-berkshire-hathaway-clayton-homes-scandal/ https://money.com/warren-buffett-berkshire-hathaway-clayton-... I have been to Omaha for a few shareholders' meetings, and I've toured a Clayton prefab home erected in the convention center. I do like the aesthetics of the Japanese prefab home that is in the article, but I cannot imagine anyone using the glass shower or tub that open to the entire neighborhood in this picture (to say nothing of having it behind my desk): https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/dwell-ugc/photos/6063391372700811264/6774759862847479808/large.jpg https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/dwell-ugc/photos/60633913... Glass in the shower needs far too much cleaning anyway, so that really isn't a good idea from several perspectives.
- oh_sigh 6y agoThis doesn't even look like a house to me. It kind of looks like a law firm's office with a bathtub inexplicably placed in the middle.
- bin_bash 6y agoit might be "smart glass" that can frost over: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jrtfsSNGPKc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jrtfsSNGPKc
- J_cst 6y agoGlass shower can be kept clean and perfect in 30 seconds using this cheap tool just after taking the shower: https://www.arredobagno360.it/media/catalog/product/cache/1/image/800x800/9df78eab33525d08d6e5fb8d27136e95/5/3/53290.jpg https://www.arredobagno360.it/media/catalog/product/cache/1/... That's my personal experience :)
- supernova87a 6y agoWell, one thing to keep in mind while reading this is that in Japan, house turnover is unusually high. In the sense that often (or at least much more than in US), a family will tear down and construct a new home when buying a property. So in such an environment, innovative / different construction techniques are much more testable and able to be experimented with. And when the costs are being compared against full build, the cost of an even expensive prefab unit is not so bad.
- emodendroket 6y agoAlso, high estate taxes mean that usually a house is sold off when the owner dies and whatever stood there is torn down.
- eric-hu 6y agoCould you explain how the estate taxes drive that? I’m not quite following the connection.
- edrxty 6y agoI think the implication is that if estate taxes are high, then when someone dies their estate is calculated as hard assets + cash and they have to split that somehow to pay the tax. If taxes were 25% and the house was worth 200k and the deceased had 20k in cash, you'd end up paying 55k in taxes but only have 20k in cash to pay it with unless the descendants used their own funds. As such, it's easier to sell the house, take the 220k and pay the taxes.
- emodendroket 6y agoThat's how I understand it. Often a single-family home gets replaced with multi-unit housing.
- edrxty 6y agoWhat's the cause of this tendency?
- imgabe 6y agoI don't understand the obsession with prefab homes. Constructing homes is a well-understood, mostly solved problem. The cost of housing is not high because homes are difficult or expensive to build, it's because the land underneath the house in desirable areas is expensive, and various regulations make it difficult to build high density housing. No amount of streamlining the construction process is going to change that.
- jonny383 6y agoBuilding houses on site is definitely slow and potentially a logistics nightmare between different trades people. Prefab doesn't solve that one hundred percent, but I assume it would significantly increase build speed and predictions of completion date.
- andy_ppp 6y agoUntil you get to site and things don’t quite fit, then the installer bodges it or you wait 3 weeks for the factory to make a new bit. Making stuff on site isn’t as subject to disasters.
- edrxty 6y agoJudging by the number of homes that have been in progress in my area for several years now, I don't think this is 100% the case. It's also worth noting that even for a "solved problem", driving down costs is still beneficial in the end.
- imgabe 6y agoIf it’s been years the problem is definitely not the difficulty of construction. Probably funding issues or unreliable contractor.
- bluGill 6y agoDriving costs down is only good if quality isn't compromised too much. In Japan they can compromise quality to the point where they don't expect things to last more than 20 year. In most of the rest of the world people expect a house to last several lifetimes. What is acceptable is an important question. I've been in houses from 100 years ago, most had significant remodels that clearly did things not anticipated originally and so it is obvious to a knowing eye where the different parts are. On the other hand, construction is expensive and the throw away culture seems wrong too. I'll let you decide where the trade off should be made.
- chrisjharris 6y agoIt would be nice if they covered the environmental cost of constantly re-building houses, which is to my understanding quite significant.
- JasonFruit 6y agoAnd, if I understand correctly, the huge amount of lumber imported into Japan each year. When there are shortages of prime building lumber or even more so high-quality wood, such as aircraft spruce, in the US, it is usually blamed, accurately or not, on exports to Japan.
- ksec 6y agoThe site doesn't work with Adblock or NextDNS, turning off both causes my CPU temperature shoot up to 70C. Scrolling is Janky.
- bryananderson 6y agoThere isn’t too much in the article about cost (“affordable” is vaguely mentioned in passing), but it seems like prefab isn’t generally cheap. Does anyone have any insight into why prefab construction isn’t much, much cheaper than a traditional stick build? It just seems so obvious that it should be cheaper to do as much work in a factory as possible. Home construction seems like one of the few large industries still stuck in the time before the Industrial Revolution: work done by hand by a variety of highly-skilled artisans instead of mass-produced at scale. Land isn’t the main driver of cost (unless you’re in one of a handful of ultra-desirable locations). Nor is the sitework or the foundation. From a few quick sources, it seems like the structural and finishing work (everything starting with a slab and ending with a finished house) is roughly 80% of the cost. This is exactly the part that seems like it could be done in a factory with a high degree of automation, like with cars and furniture and most manufactured goods. What am I missing here?
- fy20 6y agoI think it's just too little volume for the savings to trickle down. The majority of houses built today are still done in traditional ways, very few new homes are prefab homes (in the US and Europe). Most of the people buying prefab homes in these regions today are doing so because it's faster (weeks to months instead of 6 months+) or easier (only need heavy equipment on site for a couple of days), so those benefits can be sold as a premium service. I am having a new home built right now, and the costs are roughly 50% for the 'shell', e.g. to the level where you have a water proof building with roof and windows, and 50% for all the work inside. For the 'shell' it's actually quite simple work, and doesn't take too much time, it's basically just LEGO :D The complicated parts like doors and windows are made off-site, so when they arrive you just need to fit the house around them. We are having a traditional A-style roof, so the roof joists are made off site too. Most of the costs are on the materials, not the work. Materials that reduce the work like ICF or SIPPs also increase the material costs - in my case to a point greater than what you save in labour costs. For the interiors nothing can really be prefabricated at volume, as everything is completely custom to the project. That's not going to change unless these Japanese standard measurements that article talks about spread elsewhere. For large projects its a bit different though, I've heard for hotels they sometimes prefabricate large parts of the bathroom and lift it into place before the next floor is put on. That makes sense though as you are building a few hundred things that are exactly the same.
- emptysongglass 6y agoCan anyone recommend good prefab companies that deliver to Scandinavia? The ideal would be a prefab that includes almost everything for a self-sufficient remote life (solar, waste disposal, water treatment).
- kwhitefoot 6y agoScandinavia has its own prefab house manufacturers. For instance https://www.norgeshus.eu/factory-package/ https://www.norgeshus.eu/factory-package/ (well Baltic), https://karmod.no/produkter/ferdighytter https://karmod.no/produkter/ferdighytter, https://norskemicrohus.no/ https://norskemicrohus.no/, etc.
- cjg_ 6y agoBasically all major house manufacturers in Sweden prefab walls etc and deliver them and assemble. Assembling of one of them in a day: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f4ndJF64M3I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f4ndJF64M3I
- sjg007 6y agoOk now that is pretty amazing.
- emptysongglass 6y agoI was thinking more "cool" in the manner of a singular vision in a creative execution like https://www.kodasema.com/ https://www.kodasema.com/ or https://vipp.com/en/hotel/vipp-shelter https://vipp.com/en/hotel/vipp-shelter
- mbank 6y agoWe have recently finished planning a prefab home in Germany and hopefully soon the actual building process will start. Just a couple of insights: * roughly a third of private homes are build like this * prices are a little lower than custom build (although not as much as when you start the planning) * very extensive customization is possible * walls are high tech versions of a century old building technique (wooden frame with heat preserving insulation) * energy efficiency (walls, heating system, solar) is brought to an extreme * due to regulations and and extensive planning (Germany, right?) it takes 9-15 months * The building itself only takes a couple of days * Building brick by brick wasn't an option to us due to a current lack of qualified crafts men and women (you end up with 90%, waiting months for the rest to be finished) My thoughts looking at the Japanese ones: Nice minimalistic architecture but some (already mentioned) things seem unhandy. Also doubt that they are as energy efficient as their german counterparts ;)
- RayVR 6y agoThe Japanese buildings are absolutely not energy efficient. They are horrible in terms of energy efficiency and durability. Not to mention, the homes in this article represent something like 0.01% or less of actual Japanese prefab homes. Most have very few windows, which are very small. The interior spaces tend to be fairly small as well. Not these open styles. This is all due to earthquake planning. Studies have consistently found lightweight exterior walls with lots of interior support are most likely to remain standing in a severe earthquake. The small windows reduce weight and are also more efficient since the sun in Japan will roast your house in the summer if you have big windows.
- TheCoelacanth 6y agoIs most of the 9-15 months just design/planning/approvals/etc.? If you were tearing down your current house to put up a new one, how much of that would you have to be moved out for?
- nottorp 6y agoHmm is the weather in Japan so mild? The houses in the article look like they would cost a fortune to heat in winter.
- Clewza313 6y agoThe traditional Japanese solution is not to heat the house, but only the table you're sitting at. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kotatsu https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kotatsu Even these days it's common to use gas heaters that are turned off for the night, meaning that it's freezing cold particularly in the mornings.
- nottorp 6y agoUmm... ouch. To each their own, I suppose.
- pezezin 6y agoNot mild at all, winters in Hokkaido and the Tohoku region are really cold. Not as much as Siberia or Alaska, of course, but given the lack of proper insulation, either you pay a fortune to heat it up, or be prepared to suffer.
- vonwoodson 6y agoThis [isn’t the best](1) article] on it but it’s worth saying that there’s a cultural element to crappy Japanese prefab homes: they scrap and rebuilt when they buy property. What we should learn from Japan is to *not do this*. Most of the world is not on the Pacific Rim and doesn’t have as many earthquakes, sure. But also, this excavates wealth from working class homeowners. Most Americans’ wealth is tied to their homes, and apparently our willingness to live in an old home. Can you imagine if a home depreciated like a car?! “You loose 20% of your home’s vale as soon as you cross the threshold.” AHH!!! No! [1] : https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2017/nov/16/japan-reusable-housing-revolution https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2017/nov/16/japan-reusabl...
- lotsofpulp 6y ago> Most Americans’ wealth is tied to their homes It’s not the same wealth as having $500k in cash or investments, as you always need a roof over your head. It’s not nothing either, as you might be able to sell and move somewhere cheaper, but that’s costing you in maybe moving somewhere you don’t want to be. The “wealth” of being in a $400k house that goes up to $500k isn’t all that great when the house you were aiming to move into goes from $500k to $700k.
- staticman2 6y agoYou can also sell and rent or get a reverse mortgage. Your speaking from a place of relative wealth compared to most Americans when you say a 400k house isn't all that great.
- sunstone 6y agoHaving lived in Japan for a few years I don't think their typical housing construction is a good model to follow for other countries. To begin with houses in Japan are usually not built to last because typhoons, earthquakes, fires and mud slides have historically destroyed them in the course of a few decades. Japanese homes have very few windows and those they have are for light rather than looking out. Japanese are very conscious of their privacy and are not comfortable with windows that others can see into their homes. Waterfront property with windows is not in demand at all. My experience of new housing is was that it uses primarily whole wood that is visible in the finished structure rather than engineered wood or framing that would be covered with plaster or gyp rock and paint in the finished home. Japanese homes are often drafty which is ok because they are not heated through out but usually have a kotatsu to heat the occupants locally. This works well enough for heat in winter but not as well with air conditioning in summer which are a killer in most cities. Most houses have dark gray or dark brown exteriors but one in a thousand will be bright yellow. What's with that?
- pezezin 6y agoI'm currently living in Aomori prefecture, and I agree with you, Japanese housing is horrible. > Most houses have dark gray or dark brown exteriors but one in a thousand will be bright yellow. What's with that? This is so really depressing. Here in the north most days are cloudy, even in summer, so in addition to the lack of light and the sky being gray, the land is also gray. I have even seen black houses, what's wrong with them.
- DyslexicAtheist 6y ago> To begin with houses in Japan are usually not built to last because typhoons, earthquakes, fires and mud slides have historically destroyed them in the course of a few decades. other reasons that resale homes are not very good business in Japan: - Japanese believe it's not clean to buy a home others lived in before, they obsess over ultra-modern brand-new places the same way Apple fans like their newest gadget. - houses fully depreciate in 2-3 decades - ghosts (this is not a joke. it includes the believe that the house isn't just an object but has a "soul" (this believe extends to cars and other inanimate objects)) See also https://holdblog.com/resale-homes-are-not-a-good-business-in-japan/ https://holdblog.com/resale-homes-are-not-a-good-business-in...
- cmonagle 6y agoIf you're interested in the economics and history of home construction, with a focus on different levels of prefabrication, Brian Potter has a very relevant substack. Below are a some articles I think are relevant to North Americans looking to understand the state of prefabrication: [1] reviews prefabrication systems, broken down by technology. The conclusion suggests it's difficult for these systems to reach the scale necessary for success. [2] explains the primacy of balloon frame construction in North America through the frame of "worse is better." [3] most recently, a survey of componentization technologies. 1: (Two parts) https://constructionphysics.substack.com/p/book-review-industrialized-building https://constructionphysics.substack.com/p/book-review-indus... and https://constructionphysics.substack.com/p/industrialized-building-part-2 https://constructionphysics.substack.com/p/industrialized-bu... 2: https://constructionphysics.substack.com/p/balloon-framing-is-worse-is-better https://constructionphysics.substack.com/p/balloon-framing-i... 3: https://constructionphysics.substack.com/p/building-components-and-the-past https://constructionphysics.substack.com/p/building-componen...
- stdbrouw 6y agoA lot of the comments seem to conflate three or four different things: * built on-site vs. fabricated in (usually) a big woodworking shop * built according to an off-the-rack architectural design vs. built to the architect and clients' desires * finished with standard materials (on site) vs. finished with custom floors, kitchen cabinets, paints, triple glazing, whatever (on site) * completely built (modular) units that are just moved into place -- rare, but it exists, e.g. container homes For residential construction, as far as I can tell there aren't really any cost savings associated with remote fabrication, but the house might be up faster, quality control is a bit better and foul weather is less likely to mess with the schedule. However, it's completely custom, with no limitations whatsoever. The shell itself might be prefab, but it will be finished on-site with a brick facade or render or wood boards or, heck, quarried stone if you like. Using a standard design as well as the builder's default choice for your tiles, cabinets, toilets, what have you, will save money because these "start to finish" builders (or sometimes general contractors) buy in bulk and pass on some of the savings, but the more you want to customize, the less you save. The article talks about a very specific kind of prefab that is highly standardized but where nevertheless even the floor plans can be customized, albeit limited to certain standardized sizes and a small set of options, sort of like how you buy a car.
- bluGill 6y agoMost custom houses have standard sizes as well. If you want a 8.5 foot wall it will cost more than the standard 8 or 9 foot walls.