45 ms·
The new Google Pay repeats all the same mistakes of Google Allo
- Clewza313 6y ago> theoretically makes signing up for the service easier in India Not entirely sure why this story is throwing shade at Google Pay in India, since the service there has been a runaway success. It's a furiously contested space, but GPay came out of nowhere to grab the #1 or #2 spot depending on what metric you use: https://yourstory.com/2020/12/google-pay-phonepe-upi-market-share-november https://yourstory.com/2020/12/google-pay-phonepe-upi-market-... But I agree with the article that while going aggressively mobile-first/only makes a lot of sense in India, it's going to be quite different in a mature market like the US and the transition is going to ruffle a lot of feathers. The biggest sticking point is really how dysfunctional US banking is: in India, thanks to UPI you can pay anybody if you know their phone number, but this is not a thing in the US and that's why you can only do P2P transfers to other GPay users. For what it's worth, though, I've been using GPay (outside the US) for quite a while now and I've never found myself wishing for a desktop client. P2P payments are almost always to people you're already messaging from your phone or physically interacting with.
- nym3r0s 6y agoPerson living in India here. GPay gained success by offering scratch cards (giving you money) and cashbacks for making payments through GPay. From a UX perspective, it has been notoriously slow and is prone to failures. For example, if the transaction could not go through, it remains pending for 3-ish days while Google retries internally. For real-time transactions, like buying groceries from a street vendor, it isn't practical to wait so long to find out - and mostly results in people paying twice for a product. Aside from marketing gimmicks and usage by vendors, who by the way use a single QR across 5 different UPI vendors, I'm not sure it really is a "runaway success". Edit: Another point to note is that GPay (and other vendors like PhonePe) went around sticking their own QR codes on every shop. This meant that if you wanted to pay by UPI at that shop, you had to install GPay. This prompted NPCI to issue a circular and ensure QR codes were interoperable across UPI apps - but as I've seen, there still remain tons of shops which have only the GPay proprietary QR Code. Ref: https://razorpay.com/blog/npci-circular-on-upi-interoperability/ https://razorpay.com/blog/npci-circular-on-upi-interoperabil... Lethargy by vendors to move over to the new QR could also be one of the reasons why these 2 players hold the lions share in the UPI market.
- blueblisters 6y ago> GPay gained success by offering scratch cards (giving you money) and cashbacks for making payments through GPay. I remember reading about some anecdote where a network of friends were doing thousands of transactions a day to game the scratch card system. I'm sure they plugged that loophole (if there was ever one) pretty quickly.
- aitchnyu 6y agoScratch cards "drawing dates" several days after the transaction. Enough time to figure out ring transactions. Google once targeted a friend by making his meal nearly free. He talked about that to several friends for months. His circle got much smaller rewards. Its not truly random.
- Clewza313 6y agoThe link above, which has data from NPCI, says it processed Rs 1,61,418.19 crore in Nov, 2nd only to PhonePe at Rs 1,75,453.85 crore.
- lstamour 6y agoPerson living in Canada here. I can confirm that Google Pay can take up to 3 days of internal retries here also. I once called and asked about a payment that didn’t go through and if they could just cancel it but apparently after I fixed the issue I was told I just had to wait for the system to retry again on its schedule, not mine. It’s some quirk about Google Pay in that it seems to affect any consumer services whose billing goes through Google Pay. The closest help article I can find on the subject is https://support.google.com/pay/answer/7644013#zippy=%2Csend-money%2Creceive-money https://support.google.com/pay/answer/7644013#zippy=%2Csend-... but they really don’t publicize this quirk, that the system retries automatically. It sounds reasonable to do this for a subscription service, say, and when dealing with non-real-time cash transfers between bank accounts, it’s understandable, but paying with a credit card, for example? I expect that to be basically binary for each transaction: it succeeds or it fails. This “pending” with retry just complicated things…
- vishnugupta 6y ago
- quetzthecoatl 6y agoThey did misuse their place as the company that owns the software platform that runs on 75% of the mobile devices to do this though. When they launched google pay, it was called "tez" (not sure what it means - probably hindi for speed), only to be changed it to google pay so that when people search "pay" for the paytm app that was the market leader in this space, "google pay" comes first. They did have much better UX than paytm and bhim upi (government provided app for UPI interface) apps, but they still had to rely on unethical app renaming to corner the market.
- perryizgr8 6y agoIIRC it was already a hit as Google Tez, probably because it is a much better name. The google pay re-branding was done when it had already proven to be a huge success, probably with a long-term goal of merging it with the international Google Pay.
- dustypotato 6y ago> in India, thanks to UPI you can pay anybody if you know their phone number Or their UPI ID. it looks something like "myname@bankname"
- perryizgr8 6y agoGpay is also extremely easy to set up in India IFF all your government data is in order. Your bank accounts must have your phone number and Adhaar UID linked. This is usually properly setup if you have a good/proactive bank, because they will pester you to link your phone and UID. With the above in place, it is just a matter of inputting your phone number into gpay, and it will send and receive a flurry of SMSes, figure out all your bank accounts and their details, and add them into the app. Very seamless and kind of scary.
- wtmt 6y agoThere is no requirement to link Aadhaar with bank accounts or provide it to banks. That coercion was banned by the Supreme Court in its 2018 verdict. UPI is a mobile solution that requires a mobile phone number that’s linked to one’s bank account. It doesn’t need anything else (other than the account holder’s consent for UPI).
- perryizgr8 6y agoI know. Only the account discovery works way better if your adhar and mobile number are linked to all your accounts. I've seen it fail otherwise.
- wtmt 6y agoBanks cannot store Aadhaar numbers and allow it to be used for or enable better discovery. Phone number linked to the account is what’s important. Aadhaar is required only if/when receiving government subsidies in one’s bank account. It has nothing to do with person to person transfers.
- softveda 6y agoIn Australia you can do it too using what is called PayID. But it doesn't require any special 3rd party app. Almost every bank's own app or online banking allows you to do it and payment is instant.
- foobar33333 6y agoOnly thanks to the government making it a requirement. We would still be stuck in the stone age if it was up to the banks to organize this themselves.
- fredzel 6y agoIn Poland such system (Blik) was created by cooperation of multiple banks. You can pay online, in stores, withdraw cash from ATM or just send money P2P using other person phone number. It works like 2FA (you have to enter code generated in app on pinpad and confirm on phone) so it's a bit more of a hussle than qr codes, but... it just works.
- manojlds 6y agoI exclusively pay with Gpay these days here in India.
- wtmt 6y ago> in India, thanks to UPI you can pay anybody if you know their phone number Not true. You need the UPI ID of the person, which may probably be phone@bank or phone@paymentsbank. If you assume that everyone is using only Google Pay (or Paytm or PhonePe or Amazon Pay or pick another provider), then those providers would know the UPI ID to connect people to for payments. For people who don’t use these payment services but do have a bank account (say, HDFC or SBI or ICICI), there’s no way you could pay them only by knowing their phone numbers without knowing the bank they have the account with and the bank suffix they use for the UPI ID.
- kevincox 6y agoI don't think it is really throwing shade at Google Play in India (other than that luke-warm line). I think the main argument is that they didn't really adapt the app to the US market. It would have been trivial to be able to look up an account by email OR phone number OR username but they didn't even bother. They also could have transitioned user accounts but didn't care enough. The article mostly seems to be complaining that good in India != good in US and that Google needs to adapt to the different markets.
- grumple 6y agoMy bank integrates with this service, which seems to let you send money to anyone via their phone or email: https://www.zellepay.com/ https://www.zellepay.com/
- NewLogic 6y agoGoogle takes not invented here to an extreme cross-team level. Their internal promotion/reward structure must be utterly broken that this exact scenario seems to keep playing out time and time again. I'm honestly surprised shareholders haven't started asking questions about the serious mismanagement of capital allocation.
- z92 6y agoToo large a company. Their cross-team is like other's cross-company.
- arduinomancer 6y agoIt makes you wonder, what’s the incentive to have a promo structure that only favours launching new features. Is it that new products/features == growth in share value for shareholders?
- lmm 6y agoAnything that helps distract the public from the fact that they're an ad company is good for Google and their shareholders.
- dflock 6y ago> I'm honestly surprised shareholders haven't started asking questions about the serious mismanagement of capital allocation. I'm sorry I can't hear you over all this money roaring past my ears! Beside Adsense the rest is just a hobby/status game for employees - and it shows.
- pas 6y agoWith this approach nothing else will be there besides Adsense. And when Adsense's eventual, but certain death spiral starts, there will be nothing to gently pivot to. Though it's understandable that shareholders are just looking at the next quarter.
- 6y ago
- oezi 6y agoThis is really sad. I have given up on Google over the last years. Them taking away Inbox hurt most, but I am still most furious for them disabling the link between Photos and Drive (you can no longer easily get your Google Photos to sync to a desktop). What remains? Gmail and a bit of search, where DDG is encroaching.
- post_below 6y agoI agree that Google is slipping... but DDG is essentially just a Bing syndicator, which means their result quality will compete at the rate of Bing. Hard to see a threat there.
- perryizgr8 6y agoBing is pretty good though. The results are different from Google's but not necessarily worse or better.
- ZiiS 6y agoDDG do far more work then just syndicating Bing. The have their own crawl, combine many sources, and are much stronger at down weighting low vaulue content. For many they also have an up hill battle against Google as personalising search results to your interests is a double edged sword.
- jamiek88 6y agoPlus !bangs they kept it useful for me before I got used to their search. I rarely !g nowadays and being able to quickly dip in and out of sites for specific things is great. Like a super ‘I’m feeling lucky’ with parameters.
- rjzzleep 6y agoUnfortunately DDG is really only useful for english search results. I tried running it as my default search engine, but in most places it's more or less useless.
- mavhc 6y agoAs someone who hates phone number based authentication, I'm surprised how much the author hates phone number based authentication. Whatsapp won because it realised for normal people phone number based authentication is way way easier than username/password. It's almost impossible to hack, can't forget your password, and it's way easier to use.
- 411111111111111 6y ago> It's almost impossible to hack It's actually extremely easy to hack in a targeted manner... You can either do it with social engineering at range or even intercept the sms if you're physically close enough to the recipient
- PurpleFoxy 6y agoBut for most people it’s more secure since they can’t reuse the same password everywhere
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Dma54rhs 6y agoI'm sure one can come up with more social engineering tactics, but if we talk about countries where people have and use proper documents, the American style sim swap is unheard of.
- pas 6y agoThose documents are not that hard to forge though. It's simply more likely that the US has more high value targets, has more criminals/grifters doing this kind of fraud/scam, and non-US media talks less about these identity theft events.
- Dma54rhs 6y agoI'm sure U.S has more valuable targets, but it's not the document itself that has to be fake in quite a few countries out there, you would also need forged chips etc. that go with it. Rogue employee is way easier than going this route. Self identification in the USA is way behind the world, the archaic voting system is a good example of it.
- Farbklex 6y agoI own a Google Pixel 3a. Google Play Music is the default, preinstalled music app. It's discontinued and can't even play my local MP3s anymore. YouTube Music is unfortunately worse. Play Music can't be uninstalled. Google Photos is the default, preinstalled Photo Gallery app. Part of its service is discontinued. It can't be uninstalled.
- PurpleFoxy 6y agoThis is the actual state of google and android right now. Not missing my pixel 2.
- Farbklex 6y agoSome missinformation on my side: I checked the Google Photos app and opened my account settings. According to the information in the app, free & unlimited storage of photos in "high" (not original) quality will still be available for me after June 1st 2021. But uploads from other devices will count toward the available space quota. So Google Photos works as always on the Google Pixel 3a.
- xorcist 6y agoThis may be a stupid question ("why not eat cake instead") but why not install LineageOS on it? It's a clean Android and it's utterly well supported on the Pixel line of phones. Google only supports these phones for a few years. That is useless to me, who intend to use my tools for much longer than that. LineageOS has provided that support with a minimum of fuss.
- mb7733 6y agoWhat part of Google Photos is discontinued?
- aspaviento 6y agoUnlimited storage?
- 1023bytes 6y agoThe unlimited plan
- perryizgr8 6y agoInteresting that one of the marquee features of flutter is that the same code should work for web, but google pay's flutter re-write has dropped the web entirely. Maybe flutter is not so portable after all?
- znpy 6y agoGoogle pay looked cool but I never bothered because I knew google has this bad habit of messing up perfectly fine things that just work. Meh, I guess I was right. So at this point I just ignore new google stuff. Even assuming that they're any good, google itself will mess them up eventually.
- The_rationalist 6y agoI uninstall any app that feels like the typical janks and uncanny Valley of flutter.
- lxgr 6y agoAt this point, Google has become a paperclip optimizer for chat apps.
- TheWaywardProf 6y agoThe new Google Pay won't work with Google Apps for Your Domain / Google Enterprise / Google whatever they are accounts, which I think means my new pixel 4a will lose NFC payment capabilities soon. I'm devastated. I've owned virtually every Nexus/Pixel phone, and have been an android user for 10 years. When I purchased my original Motorola Droid (after standing in line outside the Verizon store in 2009) I also decided to pay for gmail via (what was then branded) Google Apps for your Domain, under the assumption that if you're paying for it, you have more control, you can move the email address away from the custom domain, etc. I've been nothing but happy with it for 10+ years. Sure, every now and then some newly-launched google product wouldn't quite integrate well, but especially over the past 5 years or so it has been "just another google account". When I try and install the new Google Pay, I receive an "Account not supported: Enterprise accounts are not supported on Google Pay, please sign in with a personal account" message. I really hope this is fixed soon, or an error, or there will be some alternative. I literally have given google money at every opportunity, but soon they will take away my ability to give _other people_ money with my phone.
- koolhaas 6y agoSounds like it’s time for you to exercise the end-game move you smartly prepared for since day 1: move your email to a new service and begin the painful but necessary task of decoupling yourself from Google. Their suite of consumer services is a RNG at this point, not to be relied on.
- throwaways885 6y agoI know it's not a perfect solution, but you should be able to create a Gmail account just for NFC payments.
- jfengel 6y agoUnless they're going to reject your credit card for being associated with another account. Which seems entirely possible, though I don't know if they will or not. You could also get another credit card, but what a hassle.
- 6y ago
- elbowjack65 6y agoThe article it not based on concrete numbers or facts besides the author own sentiment. He didn't offer the any stats such as app store downloads, or anything else that uses facts to suggest the new Google pay us a step backwards. Last time I read the new app was actually doing very well. 1.https://www.pymnts.com/news/mobile-payments/2020/google-pay-revamp-boosts-it-to-top-finance-app-in-google-play-store/ https://www.pymnts.com/news/mobile-payments/2020/google-pay-...
- squaresmile 6y agoI mean they depreciate the old app and force upon us the new app. I don't think you can look too much into the download number.
- xvector 6y agoHow can so many highly-paid and bright employees routinely fuck up products so terribly and so often? It boggles the mind.
- indy 6y agoIt might be because of the "so many" part.
- jayd16 6y agoI wonder what the product manager hiring process and role is like at Google. Leet-code doesn't necessarily help you maintain a healthy product road map.
- cambalache 6y agoMany (not all) of those kids are great at playing the "getting credentials" games, not so good at the "let's make a great product" game. The objectives are not 100% aligned either.
- onion2k 6y agoA significant problem with intelligent people is that they're repeatedly told they're good at everything throughout their early life, but being clever doesn't automatically make you good at everything. Some things take experience and knowledge that takes years to attain. Tech is full of people who did well at school, went to a good university and did great, and then went to work at a tech company. They have no experience of the world outside of their very limited experiences. But they don't realise that. So they fuck products up a lot because outside of tech people couldn't give a damn about the same things clever nerds give a damn about. The reason I know this is because I was the same. I did well at school, did well at university, got good jobs in tech, and then tried to do a startup and failed hard because I wasn't nearly as clever as I thought I was, and I had completely misunderstood the product I tried to make. It was quite the lesson.
- remir 6y agoIn my opinion, being clever or "bright" means having high intellect, retaining information and making the necessary mind connections, but it doesn't automatically means intelligence. You can be considered bright by other people or some metrics, yet make very poor life choices.
- boxingdog 6y ago...another messenger app by Google?
- 1023bytes 6y agoHas there even been a successful new Google product in the past 5 years?
- whywhywhywhy 6y agoTheir barrier for success is so high they kill off anything before it even has a chance. Look at Stadia was it even out a year before it was effectively canned? Imagine if Microsoft had taken that approach when they built Xbox, they knew some products are a marathon not a race. Starting to wonder if any of the decision makers there even remember what the early moments of a product can be like.
- 45ure 6y ago>Imagine if Microsoft had taken that approach when they built Xbox, they knew some products are a marathon not a race. Xbox nearly died in development, as Bill Gates was none too pleased with the decision. Fries recalls Microsoft's "Valentine's Day Massacre" in which Bill Gates furiously ripped apart the development team for circumventing his original idea. https://gamerant.com/bill-gates-xbox-story/ https://gamerant.com/bill-gates-xbox-story/
- remir 6y agoStadia wasn't canned. They shut down their first party game studio that was making exclusive title for the platform. But yeah, it doesn't exactly inspire confidence either...
- mdoms 6y agoIt was effectively canned. Without first party exclusive games to bring people onto the system it has no chance of success.
- indy 6y agoGoogle has a magic money fountain so they can afford to fail with new products. Besides a lot of the products were 'successful' for the employees who received pay rises and promotions
- pjmlp 6y agoAt least someone might have been promoted by driving the Flutter rewrite effort. https://developers.googleblog.com/2020/09/google-pay-picks-flutter-to-drive-its.html https://developers.googleblog.com/2020/09/google-pay-picks-f...
- mjevans 6y agoSo, I'm never using this. "Instead, you have to sign up for the new Google Pay using your carrier's phone number." My preferred phone number lives in Google Voice, and I have a grandfathered T-mobile 'net30' plan, with a phone number I give to no one, prefer to never use, and only get junk calls and spam on. Which I'll probably use forever unless there's real competition again... or several cellphone technologies come out and they refuse to support newer connection types.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 6y agoThis is financial law's requirement. They need to be able to find and arrest you, in case you used your account for financing terrorism. So Google Voice probably won't cut it, they need a real number tied to your physical identity.
- izacus 6y agoSo instead you'd prefer to be forced to use a Google account? I feel like not having to have my financial transactions streamed through the same bannable Google account is a positive. At least here in Switzerland I've found TWINT, which is pretty much the same as this new GPay, to be significantly more widely useable because all you need for a transfer is the phone number. It even works with iPhone users who don't necessarily have a Google account. I find these different wishes kinda funny - neighbouring HN topic will have people complaining how everything is bound to a single Google account and this topic has people complaining why their financials aren't bound to a Google account :)
- mjevans 6y agoWhat if someone wanted to change their phone number because E.G. retire to somewhere else? work in another country for a bit? evaid a stalker? This service is destined to fail in the long term, and doesn't fit my own needs in the short term. It's all but become a personal religious level belief for me to not sign up with anything that requires a phone number.
- izacus 6y ago
- hiisukun 6y agoI occasionally use Google Pay on my phone (by way of a credit card added to the app), but I'm in Australia and have no idea if this story impacts me. In fact, I have no idea if the 'Google Pay' that I know and use is the same as the one mentioned in this story. Do people in other countries have different apps from google, but named the same as my local apps? That's pretty confusing. I cannot see any P2P (person to person?) features in my app, just the 'add credit or debit card' functionality. If I traveled to India and saw Google Pay was supported at a checkout, I'd absolutely try and use my app.. but perhaps would be in for a bad time. Who knows?
- sapphire_tomb 6y agoSame in the UK. The Google Pay app on my phone allows me to add credit cards and use them for NFC payments and that's about it. I can't see a way to send money to someone else using it either.
- wasmitnetzen 6y agoYou can find the canonical name of your installed "Google Pay" if you click on "Share" in the app view of Google Play. I live in Europe and had the same reaction as you, and I have com.google.android.apps.walletnfcrel installed, which shows up as the mentioned (old app) in the US Play store[1]. So I guess, as usual with Google: Maybe we're affected? [1]: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.google.android.apps.walletnfcrel&hl=en_US&gl=US https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.google.and...
- Liskni_si 6y agoNew new one [1] says "This app is not available for your device" so it seems it can be anything from "we're not affected" to "we're affected much more than US". :-/ [1]: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.google.android.apps.nbu.paisa.user https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.google.and...
- ohazi 6y agoNo mention of the previous Google Pay fuck-up, which graced us with two apps: "Google Pay" and "Google Pay Send." I still haven't figured that one out, and I'm not going to bother with whatever the hell this is.
- lxgr 6y agoThe distinction absolutely makes sense from a product perspective; they serve two very different purposes. The mistake was naming them both "Google Pay".
- kahirsch 6y agoGoogle Pay was a great way to send money to my kid in college. Since we both had debit cards, it was instantaneous and free. It was easy to use from the web interface. Now they're doing away with the web interface. They don't say why, so the reason has to be pretty shady. There was some bad UI with the web. It would pop up a window to warn you to only send money to people you know, but it was a window you couldn't move to see who you were sending money to, in case you clicked the wrong person! But that's better than the experience I had with the app when I paid at a McDonald's recently. I was expecting a screen which said something like "You are about to pay $9.72 to McDonald's Corporation. CONTINUE/Cancel. Instead, when I put my thumb on my phone's fingerprint sensor, here's the feedback I got: (vibrate) No information on who I was about to pay or how much I was about to pay. And afterward, absolutely no information about who I just paid or how much I paid them. I went into the payment history screen and they payment wasn't there either, although it showed up about a minute later. How is that acceptable? I would NEVER use the app unless I lost my wallet! Using the Google Pay app at a point of sale was a terrifying experience.
- lxgr 6y ago> absolutely no information about who I just paid or how much I paid them. That's unfortunately how the contactless payments protocol works. Chip cards don't have a display, so user-visible on-device payment confirmation was never a design goal. There's been some attempts in introducing it (apparently with mixed/bad results, since it's not a thing anymore), but it's ultimately not possible: Since the final payment amount is often not known at the time you tap/dip/swipe your card, what you'd see on your phone would differ from what is ultimately charged. Arguably, not showing an amount rather than an estimate that will usually be either way over or under the actual amount is better.
- brmgb 6y ago> Since the final payment amount is often not known at the time you tap/dip/swipe your card As a foreigner, I have trouble understanding this. How can the final amount of a transaction not be known when you are paying it? Is that one of the usual nonsensical shenanigans stores like to play with taxes in the USA?
- shaoonb 6y agoSo what's the use case for this service now that there are fees? Cross border payments? Or is the banking infrastructure in the US so terrible that people would pay to send money in a way that isn't a bank transfer?
- v7p1Qbt1im 6y agoBanking infrastructure is pretty terrible by default. Almost everywhere. It‘s 2021, instantaneous transactions should be the default. If you send a SEPA payment in Europe (most modern standard) it still takes one business day. And intercontinental transactions take even longer. I get the whole interbank exchange weirdness, but still. Banks basically transfer money akin to using analogue switchboards.
- Strom 6y ago> If you send a SEPA payment in Europe (most modern standard) it still takes one business day. The most modern standard is SEPA Instant Credit Transfer [1] which does transfers in under 10 seconds. As of right now 57% of European payment service providers have joined with this scheme. -- [1] https://www.europeanpaymentscouncil.eu/what-we-do/sepa-instant-credit-transfer https://www.europeanpaymentscouncil.eu/what-we-do/sepa-insta...
- kergonath 6y agoThe most recent standard is instant, but in some countries banks take this as an opportunity to get fees. In France for example you can usually pay ~€1 to make an instant transfer, but even non-instant ones are usually much faster than one day; in the U.K. it seems everyone gets instant transfers for free.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 6y agoThat's not Google Pay's fault. The changes are mandated by financial authorities in order to fight terrorism, money laundering and child pornography.
- AlexandrB 6y agoI hadn't heard that. Any links that explain what happened?
- mdoms 6y agoSorry what are the mandated changes which require phone-based authentication which can't be tied to a Google account? Which authorities? Why did this require the website to be locked down?
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 6y agoBecause you can create a Google account anonymously. The financial law requires KYC - Know Your Customer. So that every illegal transaction can be traced to a real person.
- medium_burrito 6y agoNo shit, it's just someone's project to get a promotion, again. Nobody cares, nobody will use it, and it'll go into the graveyard in a year or two.
- Demigod33 6y agoWhy would it be less successful compared to Apple Pay? Isn't it the same functionality?
- creativeembassy 6y agoI used the old Google Pay for both tap-to-pay and for organizing my various membership cards. Gas, grocery, coupons, things like that. Since sticking various memberships cards in it, some of the old physical cards have been lost and I hope the rest are still in my filing cabinet. Because with "new" Google Pay, all of those membership cards are gone. They didn't just not migrate the data over; this isn't a feature present in the new one. I don't see any reason to continue using it. Apple Pay is working better for me for tap-to-pay, and I'm instead trying to replicate some of the old membership card organization with Apple Wallet, albeit without much success yet. (Can't believe we have to use "old"/"new" delimiters here either, while Google gets to pretend it's the same thing.)
- mattkevan 6y agoThere's apps that let you add store cards to Apple Wallet. Once added they stay there, even if the app isn't installed.
- beart 6y agoI definitely had my membership cards migrated to the new app. I can see them by clicking on the credit card displayed next to my user icon in the top right. This opens a new screen with the loyalty cards listed at the bottom.
- abraham 6y agoThe new app supports membership cards and at least personally they were migrated from the old app. https://support.google.com/googlepay/topic/10167683?hl=en https://support.google.com/googlepay/topic/10167683?hl=en * I work at Google but not on Google Pay
- jariel 6y agoGoogle has reached it's terminal innovation phase, it cannot seem to launch and maintain coherent products. It's bureaucracy from here on in. The CEO is a McKinsey consultant, smart guy, nice, but he's a politician on top of what are layers of well-meaning politicians. Google was never a highly organized company, which was advantageous the start, but eventually the lack of real corporate product discipline overcomes the ability of the otherwise great product leaders to maintain coherence over time. Even established products like YouTube, gosh it hasn't improved in a long time. The 'creator section' is abysmal and was in beta for years. Think of how much more innovation has happened in a short time on TikTok. Most top-down orgs fail, or turn into other kinds of beasts like Oracle. Apple has been able to maintain fidelity thanks to a long-running founder who established quite a lot of cultural consistency. It's frankly weird how they fire well enough on so many cylinders but they are only 1 CEO out from the founder. Even Microsoft's Product/Competitive focused approach has been consistent for them. Google will still make a lot of money for now so there won't be any pressure to change for the foreseeable future but I really can't imagine anyone but the founders coming in to make that happen, but I don't think it's in their DNA.
- creativeembassy 6y agoGoogle seems determined to lose me as a customer altogether. - 2013: Google kills Google Reader for RSS feeds. Never found a replacement I was as happy with. - 2014: I loved the first version of AngularJS. Angular 2.0 was a complete rewrite of the first version. Switched to learning React instead (now I'm a huge Svelte fan, for the record.) - 2017-2018?: Forget what it was called now, but Google's services for domains stops being free. I've got several family members on that and didn't want us to all lose Gmail, so I'm currently paying ~$6 per person and pretending our family is a "business". - 2019: Google kills off Inbox. My email organization goes to shit. I'm trying hey.com currently, but still waiting/hoping I can use my google "business" on that so emails come from that domain, not hey.com... - 2019: Google kills off the Works with Nest API, and my new Home Assistant installation can't talk to my smoke alarm. I cancel plans to buy a Nest Thermostat and get an EcoBee instead. - 2019: I migrated off of Google Play Music and over to Spotify when they started dismantling the former and pushed people to use Youtube Music instead. - 2019: Google Chrome slowly turning into surveillance software pushed me to switch back to Firefox. - 2020: Google Fit used to track reps/rest time when weight lifting, but they removed that for some reason. Along with everything else they removed, I used FitnessSyncer to migrate all my health data to Apple Health. - 2021: Now, the "new" Google Pay doesn't have the membership card feature from the "old" Google Pay, so I've lost all that data now. I'm going back to a wallet full of membership cards unless I can figure out how to add arbitrary cards to Apple Wallet. I lost most of my faith in Google years ago, and they're still finding innovative ways to disappoint me.
- iaml 6y agoThere's an app called Stocard that can add apple wallet entries for certain types of cards.
- cletus 6y agoGooglers are like toddlers with all the toys in the world: they quickly get bored and move on. I'm reminded of Paul Graham's essays about this and payments ticks two of the major themes: it's both unsexy and it's a schlep. And that's why Google won't succeed in this space. Apple uniquely seems to have maintained the ability to tackle these problems. I remember when Apple Pay launched and was derided (here and elsewhere) but every few weeks there'd be another announcement where another group of financial institutions were brought in to the ecosystem. You keep plugging away at that, customers will start using it and after years of schlep you'll have mature payments infrastructure. Google chat apps were a meme internally even when I was still there (2017). Deprecating Hangouts features, copying Slack, creating new orgs to make the same mistakes all over again (but hey, lots of people got promoted). It was a joke and still is. And all they had to do was copy iMessage. That's it. Apple had the foresight, market power and wherewithal to push iMessage onto resistant network operators (who were all too happy to continue nickel-and-diming customers with massively profitable SMS charges long after any cost arguments had disappeared).
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoMy 2c is that something else is contributing to this problem at Google. Search advertising by far dominates revenue so that pretty much everything else is a "rounding error". So projects that aren't part of, or very tightly related to, search advertising are easy to fuck up without really any significant consequences to Google. I mean, have millions of pissed off users when you're a startup and you're probably toast. Have millions of pissed off users at Google, and as long as they are still using Google search, and viewing webpages where Google ads are displayed, and it probably doesn't matter, at least in the short term.
- sangnoir 6y ago> So projects that aren't part of, or very tightly related to, search advertising are easy to fuck up without really any significant consequences to Google. Not only that, but Google monetarily incentivizes frequent product (re)launches - it's the quickest way of getting a promotion and/or more bonuses, but maintaining an old product does nothing for your career or your team (unless you're Search). At some point, I assume the Google brand will lose enough goodwill that someone in leadership will finally address this. Disclaimer: I'm not a Googler, but information on how Google measures performance and promotes staff is pretty much public information now.
- nromiun 6y agoI can't speak for other countries, but at least in India it has been a huge success. At this point I think it is even bigger then PayTM. When it was first released it was very smooth compared to all the competition and the cashback was also pretty good. But just a few months ago they released a new update (GPay) and I don't know what they did but it is now unbearably slow. Checking bank balance only works in 2 or 3 tries and transactions can fail multiple times. Instead of focusing on that they decided to make an UI update that made the interface incredibly slow. Unbelievable. I have moved on to PayTM for now (it is much better), but I will continue to keep an eye on it. Maybe it will get better.
- geodel 6y ago> I don't know what they did but it is now unbearably slow There was this announcement about GPay is reimplemented in Flutter. It could be related to that.
- nromiun 6y agoYeah, I also noticed that on the app version when it was released. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26315915 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26315915 I don't know why they would ruin such a fast, successful app like this.
- kaszanka 6y agoFlutter applications start insanely slowly. I only tried it once and a tiny, one-screen app with barely any interactivity took like 2.5 seconds to load on a Snapdragon 845 phone.
- mrbonner 6y agoThe culture of "Promotion-oriented development" is a dismay across this industry. My take is that the prospect of getting promoted to Principal/Staff SE is close to none if you are not aiming for a moon-shot project. Naturally, people tend to just invent "just-another-moonshot" project for the sake of getting a promotion instead of thinking about the long-term implication of such decision.
- dmix 6y ago> Existing Google Pay users are about to go through a transition reminiscent of the recent move from Google Music to YouTube Music: Google is killing one perfectly fine service and replacing it with a worse, less functional service. Yeah but I'm sure that dev team used the latest technology, like Flutter or Kotlin or something, and had an excellent well paid team. Now the repo isn't some old dirty Java codebase either (made by another team of half-genuises 5yrs ago, gross!). Don't want our users having to deal with old codebases, with all of those fully battle-tested features and quirks figured out (yawn), written in some boring language and using old frameworks! It's bad for business.