19 ms·
There's two kinds of freedom: freedom from and freedom to. These are some children's books that contain illustrations that some people find offensive and the p
by helsinkiandrew 6y ago
There's two kinds of freedom: freedom from and freedom to.
These are some children's books that contain illustrations that some people find offensive and the publisher (and sellers) are deciding they no longer want to be associated with and sell to children. There are internet forums where the images are available and people can view them without the police knocking your door down, and I'm sure these are available in 2nd hand bookshops.
The actions of the publisher and ebay enhance the first (freedom from) without inhibiting the second much (freedom to) for those that really want to view the images.
There's a difference between "utterly repugnant" content being available and it being casually given to children, and people and companies being forced to sell it.
- Udik 6y ago> "utterly repugnant" You forgot to add: "to someone, probably a minority, possibly entirely wrong".
- pineaux 6y agoI have never understood why people add sentences like: "probably a minority" to their arguments. This is something that weakens your stand. Let me explain: If a minority (nerds/D&D-players,etc) gets bullied in school. Is them being a minority: A) a fact that aggrieves the bullying B) a non-relevant fact C) a fact that absolves the bullies from their wrong-doing? Because it seems like you are implying that it's option C by making this comment.
- Udik 6y agoYou went from someone claiming to find something "utterly repugnant" to a minority "being bullied". There's no necessary relation between the two. Because you don't know if the bullying is real, and if the minorities match. The relationship can easily go the other way around, for example a minority can claim to find gay marriage "utterly repugnant".
- pineaux 6y agoSemantics. The real question is: does it matter that it is a minority that "finds gay marriage utterly repugnant"? Because I think it DOESN'T matter. It could have been said by a minority or a majority, you are the one that is implying that it's important that a minority said this. That means that you think that's important. Tell me, how is that important?
- brabel 6y agoWhether it's only a minority that takes a certain view is not just important: it's fundamental to a society's set of morals, which is what the question really is about. What is a culture if not the rules and customs a large majority of a certain population agrees on? Some cultures try to accomodate minorities, but there's always a threshold to what's tolerated even in the most open societies. A certain minority may not like something the majority does, but unless there's very little cost for the majority to stop doing that, they won't, even if that offends some groups. There's no way around this because there will always be groups who take offense in things you may consider completely and utterly harmless (I gave the example of Australia aborigines not being comfortable with talking about or depicting deceased people - obviously a problem in the age of movies and books). A society that tried to acommodate every group's sensibilities would be completely unable to function. The more distant the groups, the more patently obvious this becomes. If you are not sure what I am talking about you probably should try to learn more about other cultures.
- pineaux 6y agoI don't care what society thinks I have my own moral compass that is partly my own and partly shaped by society. I do my best to shape society to my truth and don't care what "the majority" or "the minority" thinks. You make many claims about "society" and what would work or wouldn't. But these are just assumptions. I like experiments. My question remains why is it relevant that a minority asks for the removal of something. 100 years ago slave owners said society would collapse without slaves and that black people were too stupid to do more that physical work. A minority of people from "society" objected to this at first. And slowly the old truths were replaced by new ones. This is happening now as well. You presume many things but you are not talking about the justness or inherent truths. I ask you: Why shouldn't we let books that are implicitly discriminatory fade into obscurity?
- buran77 6y agoThere's a bit of a discussion here, you can promote either option depending on how you frame your hypothetical which means this particular framing doesn't add to the conversation. Take "medicine" and "side effects on a minority". Suddenly you can consider option C) as a perfectly reasonable one. The problem is you didn't focus on the real critical issue: why do the ends justify the means? "The ends" for medicine is saving thousands of lives. The ends for bullying is making one person feel better about themselves (maybe?). This is the question you need to ask when you wonder "should we ban a book".
- pineaux 6y agoI am not making a point I am asking why he adds the "minority" remark in passing. I think this is not very relevant. But adding such a remark in passing tells me that the OP does think it is important. This triggers me into investigating why it matters
- buran77 6y agoI objected just to the framing of the example. The question "why would minority change anything in the case of books?" is a good one. And I believe it makes a hell of a difference in this particular case (while it did not in the bullying example). The reason is simple: if a minority being offended is a good enough reason to ban a book then you can see how it could very easily be used to arbitrarily ban any book. Books on global warming, round Earth, on evolution, on religion, or any controversial topic could easily be targeted as there are already large established groups ready to object. Someone will always be offended rightfully or not. Maybe it's more important to look at the overall impact on society as it is right now, and in the context of where we want it to evolve, rather than what particular individuals may like.
- brabel 6y agoAustralia has a case where this is very relevant: most of the aboriginal people of Australia consider the direct mention or depiction of dead people in photographs and videos very disrespectful[1]. Because of that, it's common in Australian TV for almost any program to include warning for native Australian viewers about that. Imagine if Australia bookstores followed the principle that even if a minority (and in this case, a very important minority as the aboriginal people are the "original owners" of the land) does not like a book, it should not be made available... you wouldn't be allowed to sell any books that contained or even mentioned deceased people. But now, imagine that the British had not invaded and forcibly taken over Australia, so that the aboriginal people would be the current rules of the country. Now, you would probably expect no bookstores to want to offend their customers, so they would, presumably, avoid selling most books, arguably. So, yes, I think that whether or not it's a minority that takes a certain stand makes a whole world of difference. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Australian_Aboriginal_avoidance_practices https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Australian_Aboriginal_avoidanc...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Aeolun 6y agoNobody is forced to sell it, but ebay is a website that consumers list their stuff on. They’re clearly going out of their way to remove it. I don’t think that falls under ‘freedom to’, because nobody can list it going forward either.
- growse 6y agoSo you think eBay should be forced to host ads selling it?
- drdeca 6y agoWhat do you think of the compromise of “direct links to the listing work, but it doesn’t appear in searches”?
- ithkuil 6y agoIt would be a compromise that some would accept and some would yell at as unacceptable
- pineaux 6y agoEbay is not the government. Just start your own red-pilled eBay and sell Mein Kampf and Dr. Seuss
- lovecg 6y agoOf course, that wouldn’t work. Any platform that is “X, but with slightly relaxed rules” becomes a magnet for people who really really care about those particular rules not being enforced. If the enforcement effort is nontrivial (e.g., moderating a global social media platform), this dynamic is a moat for the company doing the enforcement. Every time they introduce a new rule that the majority of their users don’t care much about, they strengthen the moat. So over time they’ll find an equilibrium with the strictest rules they can get away with. I don’t mean this happens intentionally, but rather in an evolutionary, survival of the fittest sort of way.
- garmaine 6y ago> and I'm sure these are available in 2nd hand bookshops What do you think eBay is?
- helsinkiandrew 6y agoOther 2nd hand bookshops...
- krona 6y agoEbay isn't forcing people to read the books, and ebay isn't forcing people to sell the books, so you're making a fairly fallacious argument, in my humble opinion.
- h0l0cube 6y agoTo be fair these books ought to live on Archive.org, because they are basically 'classics' at this point. Plenty of problematic and dated books live there. While it has some Dr. Seuss books, it doesn't have the problematic ones, but for at least historical reasons, it should. https://archive.org/details/texts?and%5B%5D=dr+seuss&sin= https://archive.org/details/texts?and%5B%5D=dr+seuss&sin=
- newacct583 6y agoTo be genuinely fair, the six books we're actually talking about are minor works that no one reads to kids anymore. We're not talking about Green Eggs or the Lorax here. Even absent any controversy about racially insensitive artwork (I mean seriously: there are africans drawn as half-monkeys and a chinese man whose eyes are slanted lines! This is not stuff modern kids should be presented with), these definitely aren't "classics". But as far as a place to find them for adults who want to read them, that will curate them for posterity: have you tried the library?
- Melting_Harps 6y ago> Even absent any controversy about racially insensitive artwork (I mean seriously: there are africans drawn as half-monkeys and a chinese man whose eyes are slanted lines! This is not stuff modern kids should be presented with), these definitely aren't "classics". We all grew up with those bugs bunny cartoons with the same depictions, some even going so far as to depict them as cannibals, and I can't say either of those made our generation really think that of either of those ethnic groups. I think it was a realistic trope that 90s kids usually watched cartoons in groups after school with every ethnic group, that Sunny Delight commercial comes to mind [0], as does Dave Chapelle's joke about purple drink. People need to realize that the World is messy, and racism and prejudice exits in all walks of life: none greater than in social class, which transcends ethnicity. And the sooner children realize that the sooner they will be able to acknowledge it and develop a sense of agency in the World to deal with an imperfect World. Instead, all this re-enforces is a helicopter parents 'Karen' antics on to their children in which complaining to no end is the only way to get one's point of view, that ultimately drives to discord in Society: be it person or on social media--with the latter being critical to sustaining it's way over-valuations which mask their Black Mirroresque business models which that often provoke this type of behaviour and should really be the focus here and not canceling Dr. Suess books. Sidenote: I'm sure their is some SJW interpretation for canceling Sunny Delight to be made about this as well as the kid was 'accosted only after a white aggressor perpetuated violence which provoked the black one to do the same' type narrative, but either way it's just best to ignore them. 0: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z1ddM-FpiMg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z1ddM-FpiMg
- nathias 6y agoFreedom of speech is the most essential negative freedom (freedom from), it means you are not bound and limited by something external, while positive freedom is a right to something, like education or similar institutions. The freedom of a publisher to control what happens to sold books isn't at all part of negative freedom (freedom from). I'm basing my understanding on the Two Concepts of Liberty by Isaiah Berlin.
- pharke 6y agoWhy is this being downvoted? It's providing necessary clarification of a concept that was being misused in the parent.
- Supermancho 6y agoSee if you can find something intrinsically flawed with this (simplified) belief: > Freedom of speech ... means you are not bound and limited by something external https://www.uscourts.gov/about-federal-courts/educational-resources/about-educational-outreach/activity-resources/what-does https://www.uscourts.gov/about-federal-courts/educational-re...
- nathias 6y agoI'm not talking about anything US related, I'm talking about the concept of negative/positive freedom in philosophy. And no, there isn't anything intrinsically wrong with this concept, freedom of speech if essentially a negative freedom if your constitution has some exceptions that doesn't change that...
- lgleason 6y agoThe reason is that postmodernist philosophy has lead to a lot of mental gymnastics that have either been proven wrong.... for example the fallacy of the slipper slope, which has indeed happened and continues to happen and has been proven to not be a fallacy and the paradox of tolerance which has been used to rationalize censorship among other things. Thus many people are understandably skeptical of arguments that use it as it's basis.
- dabbledash 6y agoI never found this a very useful analytical framework, especially once you define “the freedom to interfere with third parties” as a “freedom from.” It’s too easy to move things from category to category by describing them differently. And I just don’t see what you get out of it anyway. It doesn’t affect the importance of the relevant interests.
- tsimionescu 6y agoI understand the publisher deciding not to publish these books as children's books anymore (it could make sense to publish a special edition as 'Racially insensitive Seuss books', but that's another matter). However, why would eBay prevent sellers from selling them? I view eBay as a second hand book market, would I not be allowed to sell a copy of Mein Kampf there?
- NeverFade 6y agoThese are market-dominating book distributors like Amazon and eBay effectively deciding what people can and cannot read. The fact that a few people might still be able to view images of these books (illegally, as they are copyrighted) on some tiny closed forum on the internet isn't a real comfort. In the Soviet Union, there were also tiny isolated pockets where "forbidden books" were surreptitiously copied and read. However, the project to ban them was still very successful overall. The average subject of the Soviet regime would not have access to these books. This is very much what is happening in the US right now. These books are being banned, and the next generations of US readers will have no access to them. The fact that one person in ten thousand might be able to find a used copy at a rare used bookstore (and pay pay thousands of dollars for it) doesn't really change anything, and it's dishonest to pretend otherwise. This is book-banning, pure and simple. > The actions of the publisher and ebay enhance the first (freedom from) I would also like to thank our cultural commissars at Amazon and eBay for "freeing" us from dangerous ideas by forcibly preventing us from buying and selling the books which contain them. eBay just took away the freedom of private individuals to sell books they legally own to each other. You are calling this "freedom", using the word to refer to its exact opposite. This is Newspeak.
- UncleMeat 6y ago> These are huge book distributors like Amazon and eBay effectively deciding what people can and cannot read. The books are available on Amazon. > This is book-banning, pure and simple. I'd wager that sales of these six books will be higher in the next week than they were in the last two years combined.
- NeverFade 6y agoAmazon has started to remove books on political grounds as well: https://ncac.org/news/amazon-book-removal https://ncac.org/news/amazon-book-removal The Dr. Seuss books were banned not just by eBay but also by their publisher, which holds the copyright, so you can still buy them used on Amazon... for $1,500+ per copy: https://www.wane.com/news/prices-skyrocket-for-dr-seuss-books-on-amazon/ https://www.wane.com/news/prices-skyrocket-for-dr-seuss-book... The reality is that these books will not be accessible to the vast majority of future American readers. This is just a fact at this point. It doesn't even matter if Amazon keeps selling them, as the publisher banned them, so the number of (legal) copies will dwindle to zero. Also, with Amazon starting to ban books on similar political grounds, saying "but Amazon didn't ban this specific book (yet)" or "you can still get a copy at some obscure second-hand stores" is burying our heads in the sand and ignoring the reality of what is happening.
- lanevorockz 6y agoEverything is offensive one way or another. It's a personal opinion and there are way too many people in the world. Even Good Morning can be seen as sarcastic or any text in English can be see as colonialist.
- eternalban 6y ago> These are some children's books that contain illustrations that some people find offensive and the publisher (and sellers) are deciding they no longer want to be associated with and sell to children. There are internet forums where the images are available and people can view them without the police knocking your door down, and I'm sure these are available in 2nd hand bookshops. Here is something from 1981 for your daily dose of irony: https://www.edweek.org/policy-politics/opinion-censors-play-the-role-of-guardians-of-morality/1981/09 https://www.edweek.org/policy-politics/opinion-censors-play-... "The Pico case is only part of a pattern of intense local battles erupting around the country as opposing forces arm themselves for what could become a destructive war over books in America’s schools and school libraries. The insurgents, whose ideological supply lines extend deep into the right wing and its quasi-religious satellites, are well organized; and the advocates of civil liberty in the nation’s schools are reading reports from the front with alarm. “The community of the book,” as Random House vice president Anthony Shulte calls it, is beginning to prepare for a long struggle whose outcome is by no means clear." ... "Unfortunately for the nation’s authors, their publishers, and readers, the AAP report understates the magnitude of the movement to ban books. Ira Glasser, executive director of the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), calls the proliferating challenges to books “an epidemic of future shock” among individuals who “have little more in common than insecurity and fear of a world they can no longer understand.” Judith Krug, director of the ALA’s Intellectual Freedom Committee, is alarmed that the number of reported incidents of attempted book censorship in school and public libraries ballooned immediately after the Nov. 4 election of Ronald Reagan, and has continued at a record rate along with the rising fortunes of the new right." [p.s. I'ts even better than I thought. I missed the sidebar on the above 1981 page on Seuss: https://www.edweek.org/teaching-learning/the-dr-seuss-controversy-what-educators-need-to-know/2021/03 https://www.edweek.org/teaching-learning/the-dr-seuss-contro...]
- mc32 6y agoWe know lots of people find all kinds of books offensive for all sorts of reasons (see the banned book week). Are you saying your bannings are the true bannings and others are illegitimate bannings? Or should they all be equally banned? Are religious conservatives okay to get their list of bad books banned?
- helsinkiandrew 6y agoTo be clear the "freedom from" I'm referring to here is the freedom for innocent bystanders - children in this case - not to see lazy racial stereotypes surreptitiously in what should be a funny book that either offends them or gives them a false/bad impression of those races. Throughout history society has decided what (legal) things are acceptable in public - public executions, graphic sexuality, violence. Today, (I think) the majority of society seem to have accepted that racism and racist stereotypes are bad and don't want to see them in childrens books, TV programs and films etc. This is different from Mein Kampf or Marquis de Sade, or Lolita being available in bookshops - the majority of people reading them would know what they were getting into.
- NeverFade 6y ago> To be clear the "freedom from" I'm referring to here is the freedom for innocent bystanders - children in this case - not to see lazy racial stereotypes surreptitiously in what should be a funny book that either offends them or gives them a false/bad impression of those races. You do realize your comment perverts the very meaning of the word "freedom" to mean the opposite of its actual meaning, right? You are "freeing" people from the freedom to access information and ideas you find unacceptable. That is not freedom, that is the opposite of freedom. Banning "unacceptable" ideas is the staple of Orwell's 1984, and appropriately, we are starting to use Newspeak as well: "Freedom is Slavery". > Throughout history society has decided what (legal) things are acceptable in public This is a dominant used book seller banning private individuals from selling a book to each other to read in private settings. Nothing about this is "public". > This is different from Mein Kampf or Marquis de Sade, or Lolita As if anyone will be surprised when our new commissar overlords at eBay and Amazon ban these books next.
- claudiawerner 6y ago>You do realize your comment perverts the very meaning of the word "freedom" to mean the opposite of its actual meaning, right? It's not a perversion at all; in fact, this sense of freedom being more than raw ability to "do whatever you want" was recognized as early as Rousseau and possibly even earlier. This also led to the creation of the concepts of positive and negative liberty. "Freedom from" is absolutely a valid form of freedom, and a core one in our society. It's why things which aren't harms (and sometimes barely even hurts) are prohibited - public nudity, playing loud music on a bus, and other forms of nuisance. The canonical example is the fact that there is no harm-based reason to ban corpse desecration. In fact, it's a law based on the offence principle. There is some space in our society for laws like that, but we need to be careful with them, of course. This case is even more benign - we have here a company refusing to sell these items. You speak of 'information and ideas', but these ideas can still manifest even on Ebay. No 'unacceptable idea' has been 'banned'. I'm not sure who you're saying is using Newspeak. As was pointed out by Marcuse in the 60s we're well past Orwell - now the contradiction is hidden in the noun itself. What we describe as 'free societies' are full of restrictions on some freedom to ensure the development and use of greater freedoms. That's a core part of liberal society.
- mancerayder 6y ago>There's two kinds of freedom: freedom from and freedom to. Wonderful. And where do tech monopolies figure in the world view you've expounded ?
- pitspotter 6y agoIndeed. Giant technology companies are effectively part of government now. They make and enforce the rules about public discourse. The libertarian argument used to support censorship is that a private group or business is free to do what it wants. However this misses the increasingly apparent fact that an insufficiently politically correct business in this environment is quickly targeted and perhaps even 'cancelled'. So we have a systemic problem. Private entities are not truly free just as the de facto government is not truly accountable.
- mancerayder 6y agoThat's a good point. Not to mention that mobile providers and tech companies can, and do, volunteer private data to police and authorities without a warrant. I believe Apple was one that pushed back on this. It is time to declare the old argument, since it's a private company it can do what it wants, and free speech should not apply, dead and outmoded. Yes, the 1st Amendment. But it's time to rethink the entire moral fabric that has informed us before the Internet Age. What I find positively shocking is that, myself as a lifelong progressive, am seeing Woke people using that free market argument, to promote censorship and what they call antiracism. I think it goes hand in hand with large megacorporations like Amazon and Bloomberg promoting wokist ideology. Bottom line, they want more, not less control over our minds. They know what's good. We must ask someone with a Ph.D. in __ Studies to tell us what our ethical path should be. It's positively insane.
- zdragnar 6y ago> they no longer want to be associated with and sell to children Though you are largely correct, the "think of the children" angle is unnecessary to your argument and fundamentally flawed. Pornography and other materials that ought not end up in the hands of children are available on both eBay and Amazon, neither of which allow young children to have their own accounts.
- blackoil 6y agoUnlike pornography, these are actively targeted towards children.
- grapecookie 6y agoHow the fcuk is a rare out of print book on ebay targeting children? You mean like if I kid sees it he might pick it up because of the friendly art on the cover?
- skyde 6y agoI understand the main problem with the book is the "China man" Caricature. Can someone (ideally Chinese) explain why it's offensive? Is it more offensive or racist than a painting like this https://imgur.com/a/4k0IFDG https://imgur.com/a/4k0IFDG ? If so could you explain why? How is my 6 years old son supposed to draw an ancient Chinese villager without being racist ?
- hayd 6y agoCompare to Charlie Hebdo. Suppose, after the massacre, retailers "chose" not offer it in stores (because if they didn't there may be fatal consequences). Should that really be celebrated as "freedom to"? Isn't Ebay acting here similarly over a preemptive concern of blowback from a small group of determined activists? Freedom to cower.
- tired-dev 6y agoAre you actually comparing literal murder by religious extremists to "big corporation doesn't want to sell these racist caricatures"?
- bardan 6y agoSeems strange that eBay would delist these though, given they still list items like this https://www.ebay.com/itm/Antique-Cast-Iron-Jolly-African-Man-Bank-Shepherds-Hardware-1880s-Cast-Iron/124614287419?hash=item1d0397203b:g:VmEAAOSwWENgQqXI https://www.ebay.com/itm/Antique-Cast-Iron-Jolly-African-Man... as well as books like "Little Black Sambo". Seems like they are more interested in following the latest trends than purging their platform of objectionable content.