11 ms·
A 10-second video clip sold for $6.6M
- tablespoon 6y agoThere seems to have been a steady stream of posts hyping NFTs lately. > In October 2020, Miami-based art collector Pablo Rodriguez-Fraile spent almost $67,000 on a 10-second video artwork that he could have watched for free online. Last week, he sold it for $6.6 million. And I believe in several comments, it's been explained that fake "sales" (really transfers from someone's left hand to right hand) are really easy to implement in order to inflate the "price" of an NFT on the blockchain. So did someone really part with $6.6 million for this token, and if so did that person actually earn that money, or just win it from the Bitcoin slot machine?
- krageon 6y ago> did that person actually earn that money Every time I make the point that the entire "financial" system and all it's associated people are shameless parasites everyone falls over each other to tell me that is a load of nonsense. The same goes for you here.
- duxup 6y agoCan you explain what your comment has to do with the parent comment you replied to?
- capableweb 6y agoThat whatever people say is happening with NFTs today has been happening elsewhere for a very long time already. NFTs on the blockchain might suffer the same issue, but it'll be easier to track down what actually happened, both in real time and retrospectively.
- duxup 6y agoI feel like it's almost a meme where anytime this topic comes up there's a lot of comments that argue that whatever new thing 'this is just like the existing system'. I don't think that's the point, and meanwhile everyone else is actually asking more specific questions. But the meme continues on in every discussion.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- krageon 6y agoThere's no profound discussion going on in the parent thread, it's all rehashing of the same arguments. People saying "well this is worse" and folks responding with "it's not worse, because it's the same". Fundamentally I just don't see why it's different, and nobody has been able to explain the difference in a way that doesn't sound like a scam artist. Therefore, it must be the same. I don't see why one system must be criticised above and beyond the other when they do the exact same thing.
- ketamine__ 6y agoThe terms of many of these auctions give a percentage of the sale to the original creator. I don't know the terms but it's possible Mike Winkelmann got quite a bit from the resale.
- tablespoon 6y ago> The terms of many of these auctions give a percentage of the sale to the original creator. I don't know the terms but it's possible Mike Winkelmann got quite a bit from the resale. I guess the suspicion I have is that someone who's heavily invested in NFT marketplaces may have arranged this to hype them. And that category may even include this artist, Mike Winkelmann. According to the article linked here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26303420 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26303420, he'd only ever sold his artwork once before listing it for sale on some NFT marketplace in December 2020 and immediately hitting jackpot. > Mike Winkelmann never used to call himself an artist. But that was before he made $3.5 million in a single weekend from selling his artworks. In December, he auctioned off multiple editions of three digital artworks, each priced at $969, and 21 unique works, most of which sold for about $100,000 each. It was only the second time he had put his art on sale. The alternative, which is I think is also very possible, is this is just lucky cryptocurrency money hoping luck strikes twice.
- notretarded 6y ago>win it from the Bitcoin slot machine Jealous much
- anm89 6y ago> did that person actually earn that money, or just win it from the Bitcoin slot machine? Is it convertible to USD which can easily be used to buy kitchen appliances, and pants and flights? If so who cares?
- tablespoon 6y ago> Is it convertible to USD which can easily be used to buy kitchen appliances, and pants and flights? If so who cares. $6.6 million is going to be treated a lot differently by someone who worked hard to build that fortune, vs. someone who won it (e.g. from a lotto ticket or by buying $1000 of bitcoins on Mt. Gox on a lark for a $1/per).
- anm89 6y agoSure. I hope they commission a $6 million dollar painting of themself with Napoleon's body and unicorns in the background. It's their money. They can waste it however they want. And unlike your extremely simplistic worldview, it's very possible they'll do something that will create long term value for them. They don't owe it to you to do that though.
- tablespoon 6y ago> Sure. I hope they commission a $6 million dollar painting of themself with Napoleon's body and unicorns in the background. It's their money. They can waste it however they want. You're missing the point: the question is what this $6.6 million transaction for this token mean? Does it mean these NFTs are starting to be taken seriously? Does it mean someone's hyping the tech through a shady transaction? Or does it mean some bozo who won the lotto was willing to blow some money on one? Winning lotto tickets can also be convertible to USD, which can easily be used to buy kitchen appliances, and pants and flights. Noting that doesn't reveal anything about the differences between how lotto winners spend vs. other people. > And unlike your extremely simplistic worldview Excuse me?
- anm89 6y ago
- godelzilla 6y ago>did that person actually earn that money, or just win it from the Bitcoin slot machine? Adults actually believe that people "earn" money? smh.
- notyourday 6y ago> So did someone really part with $6.6 million for this token, and if so did that person actually earn that money, or just win it from the Bitcoin slot machine? The solution to that problem is amazingly simple: IRS. Whoever made that money, fake or not, gets to pay taxes on $6.6M USD.
- ac29 6y agoFlorida has a state sales tax as well, and I'm sure they'd like their cut.
- baobabKoodaa 6y agoNope. Even if the "seller" pays taxes on that 6.6M we still won't know if he just paid himself that money. If you have 6.6M of dirty money, this seems like a nice way of washing it clean.
- CryptoPunk 6y ago>>So did someone really part with $6.6 million for this token, and if so did that person actually earn that money, or just win it from the Bitcoin slot machine? When you dismiss the concept of cryptocurrency, and another party sings its praises, and argues it will attain massive market value, and the latter ends up profiting from their judgment, they earned their gains. Now when you claim they won the slot machine, you're trying to diminish their accomplishment, and delegitimize their moral right to their success.
- marakv2 6y agoI'm not familiar with the example you gave, but what if it's just an old school tax write-off? "Buy" something for crazy value, whilw knowing the buyer, then later get that money back and claim (some strange tax law) it on tax? Edit: Ahh I missed you part about other comments, I guess I was pretty close
- NhanH 6y agoSo, how can I see the artwork itself? My Google-fu failed me since none of the major newspaper has a link to it, and they kinda dominated the result
- glenmorangie_14 6y agoI think this is it https://mobile.twitter.com/niftygateway/status/1364745727889530883 https://mobile.twitter.com/niftygateway/status/1364745727889...
- darkcha0s 6y agoWhat in the everloving f** is that and why would anyone pay for ownership of that?
- capableweb 6y agoArt is in the eye of the beholder ultimately. People been saying the same thing about art since the dawn of art, NFT are just newer so not as accepted as abstract paintings just yet, but eventually it seems we'll end up there.
- UncleMeat 6y agoWhat? Moving film, even CGI film, has been a well studied artistic medium for nearly a century. The mechanisms to analyze and critique this kind of art exist. The novelty here is the mechanism of attributing ownership - not the piece itself.
- darkcha0s 6y agoNothing to disagree with there-- but in terms of what's actually possible with animation / 3d graphics, this looks like it was done in paint (and I'm questioning why anyone would pay money for that standard of work)
- Smithalicious 6y agoThat's what I think of most modern art, so I would be very careful making an argument from aesthetic sense here
- williesleg 6y agoWhat a waste.
- ausbah 6y agoI can imagine this enabling massive amounts of virtual rent seeking by "renting" digital "commodities" at some point
- evanphamilton 6y agoAm I correct that unlike owning a physical piece of artwork, "owning" the registration of a work on the blockchain only proves that no one else "owns" said work -- I suppose what makes this a trade-able financial asset -- but nothing is stopping someone else from seeing the work?
- loceng 6y agoTrust networks or tools used to keep track of it all are only as effective based on the integrity of the physical accountability and security systems of a nation; if the people in power that you need to care to enforce/protect ownership, then however it's kept track of doesn't matter.
- gegtik 6y agoIt could be possible to host it in some way to require proof of ownership as access credentials?
- capableweb 6y agoYes, that would be possible. Authenticate users based on them signing messages with their keys, and you can safely see if they are the owner of a NFT or not.
- dagw 6y agoDo you also get the copyrights for the work? Could you in theory send DMCA takedowns to anybody showing the work without your permission?
- iamben 6y agoFrom what I gather, unless specified, you don't.
- hn8788 6y agoYeah, I've seen them sold before in "lootboxes" where you can see the artwork that you are gambling to get. The cryptographic proof of ownership is all your paying for.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ForHackernews 6y agoIs this any different than the certificate I got for my tenth birthday that says I own a star? Does having some random bit set on some random blockchain grant me any actual legal rights or privileges?
- quercusa 6y agoThat was the analog version; this is digital.
- tablespoon 6y ago> Is this any different than the certificate I got for my tenth birthday that says I own a star? Very real. The Zircon Confederacy on the fourth planet of my star system immediately submitted to my hegemony on account of my $10 certificate, and now I earn a steady income of 4 billion quadrooons of gold in tribute per annum. However, due to the difficulty in transport across interstellar space, they've helpfully represented my ownership interest in the tribute using NFTs.
- cies 6y ago> he could have watched for free online. No link? Reuters you are such a dinosaur!
- tyingq 6y agoHis previous sales were much lower, per-piece: "Mike Winkelmann never used to call himself an artist. But that was before he made $3.5 million in a single weekend from selling his artworks. In December, he auctioned off multiple editions of three digital artworks, each priced at $969, and 21 unique works, most of which sold for about $100,000 each. It was only the second time he had put his art on sale." https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/24/arts/design/christies-beeple-auction-blockchain-art.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/02/24/arts/design/christies-bee... So from $100k/piece up to $6.6M.
- fullstop 6y agoThis reminds me of the "million dollar homepage" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Million_Dollar_Homepage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Million_Dollar_Homepage
- geswit2x 6y agoIs this a f* joke?
- smcl 6y agoMy reaction too. Even "beeple" the name reminds me of some (fake) names on a semi-famous pic https://twitter.com/leyawn/status/445926596143095809 https://twitter.com/leyawn/status/445926596143095809 I periodically have the need to find that picture every now and again, and I usually find it by searching "Curbes Lurb" or "Mmm...mlurp"
- dgellow 6y agoBeeple is a well known digital artist.
- bondarchuk 6y agoI think I finally get it. You know how with some modern art the main value of some artworks is just the fact that people get very mad about it because something they don't like/get is being displayed in a museum and treated as art? It's the same with NFTs. Yeah, sure, if you dig deep down to the essentials it doesn't really make sense, but there's still nothing you can do to stop others from trading these for large sums of money. Teehee! If you are mad or confused, you've lost the game.
- jjoonathan 6y agoIn what proportion are they trolling, flexing, money laundering, and avoiding taxes? My guess is that trolling accounts for a tiny fraction of the spend compared to the other factors.
- ACAVJW4H 6y agoFrom Wikipedia: In 1636 A single Tulip bulb was exchanged with Two lasts of wheat 448ƒ Four lasts of rye 558ƒ Four fat oxen 480ƒ Eight fat swine 240ƒ Twelve fat sheep 120ƒ Two hogsheads of wine 70ƒ Four tuns of beer 32ƒ Two tuns of butter 192ƒ 1,000 lbs. of cheese 120ƒ A complete bed 100ƒ A suit of clothes 80ƒ A silver drinking cup 60ƒ Total 2500ƒ One heck of a Tulip it must have been
- soared 6y agoCan someone play devils advocate and explain why NFTs might be the next big thing? From what I can tell it’s really the only way to prove ownership of a digital good and have the ability to sell it (outside of the legal system). Kind of seems like dogecoin or other meme/shitcoins? You own a digital asset that you think will go up in value. Coins are currency while NFTs are more like.. rights to a song?
- tantalor 6y agoIn the same way that baseball cards, collectible coins, and postage stamps are sound investments.
- have_faith 6y agoI'm guessing the same reason owning the rights to song lyrics can be very valuable, despite the fact that the lyrics are easy to copy and paste. You can say in legal terms "I own that" which gives you monetisation options you might not otherwise have in the regular economy. It's obviously a bit tenuous because of the digital only nature. A real Banksy that physically exists with proof of originality affords control and exclusivity over it's access. A digital Banksy is provably yours as an NFT, but doesn't actually prevent others from viewing it trivially and perfect copies obfuscate the nature of "original". So you own it, and assumedly have exclusive rights to sell it, but it's also very easy to copy and distribute. I'd be very interested to see if the recent push to artificially inflate the price of NFT's in order to set a precedence for what people should expect as their innate value works.
- sorbits 6y ago> So you own it, and assumedly have exclusive rights to sell it, but it's also very easy to copy and distribute And this is also questionable. I mean, anyone can make a perfect copy and sell it. They cannot get that sale recorded on some blockchain, but who cares? There are no legal ramifications, because the legal system does not recognize some random blockchain as authoritative regarding ownership, instead most jurisdictions have their own (central) database about registered/copyrighted works.
- 6y ago
- RIMR 6y agoNothing quite illustrates the current state of wealth inequality like seeing this news story next to one about the eviction crisis. $6.6M pays 2021 rent for 500+ struggling people, but for the wealthy, the opportunity cost is that of vaguely owning a 10-second anti-Trump video loop...
- raldi 6y agoI don’t understand what was purchased.
- sdevonoes 6y agoThis exactly was purchased: your certainty. They are speculating about NFTs: the more they are get to know, the more people will buy NFT with the hope they can sell them later at a higher price.
- raldi 6y agoWhat am I certain about?
- sdevonoes 6y agoSorry, it was an hyperbole I guess :) What I meant is that they are just speculating about NFTs and that what was actually sold is of no importance. They could as well have sold a 1x1 pixel image, nobody really cares about the digital asset itself...
- raldi 6y agoRight but selling the copyright to a small image, I understand. Or a license to use it. But what was sold here?
- mym1990 6y agoI think to re-phrase, people are speculating that the artist will become well known sometime in the future and the artwork will appreciate. What I don't understand is how ownership is enforced and if a DMCA is filed, who will work that case? I guess there are some bitcoin lawyers out there for that!
- raldi 6y agoSo what was purchased? A trademark? A copyright? A usage license?
- fasteddie31003 6y agoEveryone says this NFT craze is money laundering. Can someone explain how the money laundering scheme works with NFTs? I know people first hand who have bought NFTs and I'm pretty sure they are not money laundering.
- donkeyd 6y agoThe fact that you know people who are legitimately buying that stuff makes it a great money laundering scheme. If only people laundering were buying them, it would be obvious, but the fact that it's picking up steam makes high sales prices seem legitimate. Say, you have a bunch of money made from selling cocaine and you want to buy a house. It's really hard, because people will want to know how you made the money without a job. So you buy some NFT for about 10k with your clean money. Two months later, you sell the NFT for 500k to an anonymous buyer online, who pays through crypto. The buyer is you, buy nobody knows that, because they're anonymous. You now have 500k cash, you will need to pay some taxes over your gains, but then the money is clean and when you buy the house you say you got the money through an investment in NFT. Meanwhile, some random people read about how you made 10k into 500k in two months by trading NFT. So people will start investing in it, making your money laundering less obvious. This is a bit of a simplification of what could be happening, but it does seem feasible.
- M5x7wI3CmbEem10 6y agocouldn’t this be audited unless using monero?
- notum 6y agoHere's a nice article about Beeple, featuring some of his work: https://www.esquire.com/entertainment/a35500985/who-is-beeple-mike-winkelmann-nft-interview/ https://www.esquire.com/entertainment/a35500985/who-is-beepl... The $6.6M video itself: https://odysee.com/WvmIn9XyiNHMn3Tc:2 https://odysee.com/WvmIn9XyiNHMn3Tc:2
- itcrowd 6y agoInterestingly, it looks as if the video is meant to be played in a continuous loop. The first frame and the last frame seem identical. Edit: right-click on the video and select 'loop'. couldn't find the option before.
- notum 6y agoSo technically it's an infinitely long video. Not a bad deal!
- amelius 6y agoHow can an enlightened place like HN be so susceptible to click-baity articles like how can I make $1M with the least possible amount of work?
- sergiotapia 6y agoThis is just money laundering.
- andreygrehov 6y agoJust to make sure everyone is on the same page. Beeple is a cult digital artist who has been making digital art, releasing an asset per day, for 13 years straight. Yes, you read that right. One asset per day for 13 years. Most of his works were free. So, $6.6M is not just an overnight luck. It's the return for what he has been investing in for 13 years.
- Voloskaya 6y agothe $6.6M didn't go to Beeple, this art was bought from him for 67k$ last year. $6.6M is the transaction between two collectors.
- ant6n 6y ago> $6.6M is the transaction between two collectors. Or possibly, the transaction between one collector interested in news of the $6.6M transaction.
- kpierce 6y agoYeah there is definitely some shady stuff going on. NFT appeared on my radar a month ago and now its everywhere. IMO this a bubble being artificially inflated by rich marketers. Also in general, people with wealth have given up on investing in real value business. Its high speculation crypto/stocks/shorts now. Not a good sign for the future when some of those risks fall apart.
- cryptica 6y agoTrue. People never cease to underestimate the value of capturing people's attention. Strange considering that attention is the only thing which gives these things any value at all in the first place.
- djanogo 6y agoArtistic money laundering
- Orochikaku 6y agoAm I misunderstanding something about NFT’s? Aren’t they essentially just ERC-721 tokens? (Which have been around forever, what’s the reason for the current hype)
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- CryptoPunk 6y agoYes, most NFTs are ERC721 tokens, which is Ethereum's primary NFT standard. The one notable exception is NBA HotShots, which is on the application-specific Flow blockchain. The Beeple video clip is an ERC721 token.
- cseleborg 6y agoDo I understand this correctly? Without NFTs, I would sign a contract with the artist (or current owner) of a digital artwork that transfers the ownership and all rights to the work to me. Since it's a digital artwork, the contract would include a secure hash fingerprint of the artwork to ensure we know what artwork we're talking about. Now, somebody somewhere could fraudulently claim to own the artwork and try to sell it, but the prospective buyer could check with the original author and track down the current owner (through the contracts trace) to ensure they're dealing with the legitimate owner. NFTs make this easier by putting all that stuff on the blockchain. Did I get it correctly?
- iamben 6y agoI asked this in another NFT post the other day. As far as I could understand unless specified it still doesn't include the rights to the image (like you can't reproduce it on t-shirts), it's just you own a (for want of a better phrase) 'digital original'.
- fl0wenol 6y agoThis alone makes me really uncomfortable because then what the hell are you paying for? On the one hand it's a way to give an artist more money directly, sure, and tie it to the specific work. But you could just do that publicly or anonymously anyway. On the other hand it seems entirely performative, in that it only servers to signal to wealthy peers (in this case, crypto bros) that you are an "art patron" without the messiness that comes with a real work on canvas that can get damaged by sun, fire, moisture... where's all the risk? The value is all declarative and speculative. As others have offered, this is like land on the moon. I could sort of see the logic if this was tied to a massively popular online game where it enforced your ability to have the one custom skin and no one else can use it, with the cooperation of the game itself. But in general this is not what's happening. It seems primarily driven by speculation and probably a criminal element... crypto bros wanting in on the money laundering and tax evasion possibilities of art collecting without all the business of actually you know, having it.
- jobigoud 6y ago
- duxup 6y agoIs there some legal protection here that this person 'owns' this video or something?
- waterside81 6y agoNBA Topshot (https://www.nbatopshot.com/packs https://www.nbatopshot.com/packs) is going through a similar rise. Kind of like digital trading cards.
- sandworm101 6y agoThey aren't using the word "fungible" correctly. These aren't non-fungible objects. They are fungible objects with a DRM scheme attached to them. It is a very good DRM scheme, authenticated via blockchain, but nevertheless is not fundamentally different than any other. The art can be easily copied, making the copies fungible. This is like paying millions for a the one "legitimate" steam key to a game that everyone else is playing for free. I want to meet these people. I have some bridges I need to offload.
- woah 6y agoYou’re completely wrong. It’s called “non fungible token” because a given token has unique metadata (DRM associated with the media). Thus, the tokens are not fungible with one another.
- sandworm101 6y ago>> Thus, the tokens are not fungible with one another So they are steam keys, verified by blockchain, but just numbers associated with a piece of art. Sounds like DRM to me. Fungible doesn't mean identical. Every US 100$ bill has a unique number attached. The bills are still fungible. The numbers are not identical but serve the same functional purpose, so they too are fungible. Nobody cares what number is on their money. One bill/number can be swapped for another without impacting any function. Fungibility. "able to replace or be replaced by another identical item; mutually interchangeable." Oxford law.
- bsanr2 6y agoThey're called NFTs, not NFA. Even real-life artwork is fungible (consider the multi-million dollar appraisal industry, which exists in part to establish provenance of prospective purchases). You're not paying those exorbitant costs for the physical artwork (though it's nice that it comes along); you're paying for the story behind it, and what your ability to put wealth up for that story says about you and the artwork and artist.
- asciimo 6y agoDRM isn't a good analogy, because no one is prohibited from experiencing most NFTs. You can't legally watch a DRM protected movie or listen to a DRM protected audio file if you didn't buy the privilege. But you can look at NFT GIFs, JPGs, movies all you want without paying a penny. Though the DRM analogy may work in applications that interact with NFTs. For example, games with unique items. The application would limit the full experience of a tokenized object to the owner alone. For example, only n00b5lay3r may equip the Golden Sword of Evisceration, because it's in their wallet.
- nlh 6y agoA friend said something the other day about NFTs that rings just about exactly right: Humans seem to be in this perpetual fight to artificially reestablish scarcity from the physical world in the digital world. DRM. Invite-only apps. And now NFTs. The thing that's wonderful about digital is that it should make everything MORE accessible to all, not less.
- asciimo 6y agoNFTs remain fully accessible to everyone, unlike DRM assets and invite-only apps. The difference is that a human can pull out their wallet and prove that they have a high level of status linked to the NFT. This is even better than famous paintings, baseball cards, or Cabbage Patch kids because everyone can have the exact same experience with the thing as the "owner. Though, without the dizzying ego high.
- tablespoon 6y agoYou can say the exact same thing about fake deeds to moon land (e.g. https://lunarland.com/ https://lunarland.com/).
- manigandham 6y agoThese are luxury goods, and luxury has always been built on exclusivity. When real supply is more than enough for demand, marketing and other artificial means are employed and have been used in many industries for a long time. Limited editions, invite-only sales, waiting lists, etc.
- grishka 6y agoSo how does this work exactly? How could you "sell" a digital artwork that's apparently freely available to everyone according to this thread, because just this thread has two different links to said video? What is it exactly that changed hands then? What exactly does it mean to "own" a digital artwork? I don't understand it. edit: this explanation https://niftygateway.com/whatisanifty https://niftygateway.com/whatisanifty doesn't make it any clearer.
- umvi 6y agoThis seems like another high level money laundering method for the rich (i.e. attributing insane value to essentially worthless things)
- dgritsko 6y agoOr just a speculative bubble. I can't help being reminded of Tulip mania[1] every time I read about NFTs. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tulip_mania https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tulip_mania
- twox2 6y agoNot everything NFT related is speculative. Use cases include things like gaming as well. Also, the majority of NFT sales are not these insane sums. A lot are happening in the $10-$200 range and it's a way for people with money to spend to support artists they like, akin to Patreon.
- godelzilla 6y agoMaybe, but the same is true of money, stocks, etc. Attributing insane value to essentially worthless things is a major foundation of the economy.
- peter_d_sherman 6y ago>"The video by digital artist Beeple, whose real name is Mike Winkelmann, was authenticated by blockchain, which serves as a digital signature to certify who owns it and that it is the original work. It’s a new type of digital asset - known as a non-fungible token (NFT) - that has exploded in popularity during the pandemic as enthusiasts and investors scramble to spend enormous sums of money on items that only exist online. Blockchain technology allows the items to be publicly authenticated as one-of-a-kind, unlike traditional online objects which can be endlessly reproduced. “You can go in the Louvre and take a picture of the Mona Lisa and you can have it there, but it doesn’t have any value because it doesn’t have the provenance or the history of the work,” said Rodriguez-Fraile, who said he first bought Beeple’s piece because of his knowledge of the U.S.-based artist’s work." [...] >"The start of the rush for NFTs has been linked with the launch of the U.S. National Basketball Association’s Top Shot website, which allows users to buy and trade NFTs in the form of video highlights of games. Five months after its launch, the platform says it has over 100,000 buyers and nearly $250 million in sales. The majority of sales take place in the site’s peer-to-peer marketplace, with the NBA getting a royalty on every sale. The volume is rapidly rising: February has seen sales totalling $198 million as of Friday, heading for a fivefold increase from January’s $44 million, Top Shot said. Each collectible has “a unique serial number with guaranteed scarcity and protected ownership guaranteed by blockchain”, the site says. “When you own #23/49 of a legendary LeBron James dunk, you’re the only person in the world who does.” The biggest transaction to date was on Feb. 22, when a user paid $208,000 for a video of a LeBron James slam dunk. One major NFT enthusiast, who goes by the pseudonym “Pranksy” told Reuters he had invested $600 in an early NFT project in 2017 and has now built that up to a portfolio “worth seven figures” in NFTs and cryptocurrencies. He asked to be anonymous to protect his family’s privacy."
- Bakary 6y agoI don't know how you can look at this and tell me that our system is efficient, stable, non-parasitical, rational, less wasteful... It will interesting to consider the effect of randomness on our minds in the coming decades. It has always been possible to become wealthy through luck, but in this current context it has intensified to a different level altogether. Every minute you spend doing something else could have been the minute that would have let you discover the next get-rich-quick bullshit/random fluctuation/new bubble/new craze etc. Hard work over long periods of time can be rendered meaningless in an instant. Creating actual value to be rewarded by a small quantity of inflation-prone currency each month is a sucker's game in comparison.
- twox2 6y agoHard work over time never really guaranteed success to begin with. Luck has always been a factor on top of that hard work. Luck is also enough on its own.
- Bakary 6y agoIt's more about the relative change in the weight of the factors. Luck has always been important, but often required extra effort to go with it. Generally if there was an opportunity to be seized you had to do some active seizing. The arena is now a lot more volatile and virtualized. The methods to capture surplus are a lot more random and granular. The surplus itself is bigger and more diversified. Lottery tickets are an old institution, but now you have tickets lying around in random chatrooms all over the place. This is reflected in modern investing strategies. It's now all about throwing money and hoping some of it sticks to a unicorn.
- twox2 6y agoI don't disagree with you, but also I'm not sure I have issue with this new paradigm.
- motohagiography 6y agoI was interested in this, and I haven't used ethereum, but you'd think with the billions of dollars floating around in it ethereum.org might hire a technical writer?
- moistly 6y agoThen there’s this bit of stupidity/money laundering: https://www.larvalabs.com/cryptopunks https://www.larvalabs.com/cryptopunks Million bucks for a small pixel art. Such garbage.
- imwillofficial 6y agoThis looks more and more like money laundering the more I look into it.
- krysp 6y agoStrangely, I can reproducibly crash my phone by playing the video on this link. It goes into a "lockdown" loop and eventually reboots to recovery mode with a warning about data loss. (Pixel 3, Firefox mobile, Android 11 with latest patch)