7 ms·
This same story is playing out in the Videogame Industry. That industry is arguably booming too, making more than it ever has in the past and growing wildly ye
by bluefirebrand 6y ago
This same story is playing out in the Videogame Industry.
That industry is arguably booming too, making more than it ever has in the past and growing wildly year over year.
And yet game programmers make some of the lowest salaries among all devs, last I checked. Especially at entry level.
To me, that entire industry seems geared towards grabbing fresh faced grads who are loaded up on dreams of making games, putting them in infinite crunch, and discarding them later when they are burned out.
- m8s 6y agoNot only do they make some of the lowest salaries in the industry, they work the longest hours as well. Employers that allow people to "work on their passions" use that as a bargaining chip to lower salaries.
- trentnix 6y agoEmployers use the reality that someone equally talented will do it for the same wages or less. It's that simple.
- coldtea 6y ago"If you have large profits you should share more with your employees [1]" could also be a reality encoded into law woth harsh penalties for doing otherwise... ([1] "And don't try to bypass it by building in another country and then come to sell your wares here")
- chongli 6y agoIf you have large profits you should share more with your employees [1]" could also be a reality encoded into law woth harsh penalties for doing otherwise Hollywood is already one step ahead of you [1]. No reason game studios wouldn’t follow suit, given a law like that to incentivize them. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_accounting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hollywood_accounting
- gamblor956 6y agoHollywood accounting doesn't actually work anymore. It depends, in part, on the people getting played not being willing to sue for their correct share and just taking their lumps. In part, this is because so many people were burned in the past that it's now standard for contracts to include provisions specifying which profits the talents/investors are getting a % of. There's also many A-list talent that simply refuse to work for a studio which uses Hollywood accounting. And finally, the public-trading status of so many studios today basically renders Hollywood accounting impossible at a legal and financial level. But the primary killer of the Hollywood accounting system is the big switch to streaming, in which royalties/etc are paid upfront (at a time-value discount) rather than over time, which essentially eliminates all of the opportunity to include "costs" (like usurious interest or marketing expenses) that had been used to generate paper losses on otherwise successful films.
- chongli 6y agoA lot of what you said doesn’t apply to game developers or animators in the anime industry. Hollywood workers, famous and otherwise, are all represented by powerful unions. Game developers and anime animators (cf. western animators) are not.
- gamblor956 6y agoThe Hollywood guilds were fine with Hollywood accounting for decades. It was individual actors and directors and producers that filed the lawsuits that made Hollywood accounting too much of a risk for the big studios. And more importantly, unlike Hollywood talent, game developers and anime animators as a group have never been entitled to a share of the profits of the products they helped create.
- anm89 6y agoDefine large, more, share, and should. There is a reason this is not what laws look like.
- sigstoat 6y agogee, shouldn't they be required to reduce their costs for the consumer, first? a lot of the folks buying video games have even less money than video game developers.
- motogpjimbo 6y agoWould you also argue that when companies need additional funding during hard times or to expand, the employees should be forced by law to invest their own money into the company? With harsh penalties if they refuse? If not, then it seems like someone else is taking all the risk but the employees are reaping all the rewards. It would be great for me personally if my employer was forced to share his profits with me during the good times. But the reality is that during the hard times - when there's a global pandemic for example - he's the one who has to remortgage his house and max out his credit cards to make payroll, whereas I'm just a guy who can walk away with a month's notice.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoRight, putting your time into working for a struggling company isn't taking any risk, and the executives deserve further rewards than just their salary.
- analognoise 6y agoOh boo hoo for the ownership class, somebody might have to sell a yacht to make payroll! They got 40 years of sending labor to developing countries, dismantled our infrastructure to privatize it, ALREADY got a 1.9T tax break (from Trump, even though almost all economists were AGAINST it) now they might have to SCROUNGE DEEP as...as people flock to the information services they largely own? Boo hoo for them! Oh no! They might lose a house, something the millions of people who are going to be evicted as soon as the moratoriums end will also get to experience! They'll be left without their SUMMER home! What a terrible loss! We'd better give them another tax loophole! I know programmers are insulated and have a very warped view of the world, but let's not forget we're (generally) labor, and let's not lick the boot that's on all of labor's collective necks TOO hard, neh?
- sigstoat 6y ago> I know programmers are insulated and have a very warped view of the world look in the mirror. most businesses aren't giant megacorps owned by folks with yachts. and, hell, the megacorps? large chunks of them are owned by folks without yachts, too. https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/AAPL/holders?p=AAPL https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/AAPL/holders?p=AAPL this sort of hyperbolic rage only makes understanding and improving things harder.
- trentnix 6y agoStrangely there is always lots of talk about “profit sharing” and not “profit and loss sharing”. And I’ve never had to sign a business loan guarantee as an employee, but I’ve done so as a business owner.
- webmaven 6y ago> Strangely there is always lots of talk about “profit sharing” and not “profit and loss sharing”. That's because corporate limited liability shields stakeholders from losses beyond their sunk costs. As an employee, you probably are close to last in line behind most of the other creditors, and may have to just write off that last (missed) paycheck. But that paycheck you are never going to get is the full extent of your liability for the company's losses, even theoretically. Not that it encompasses all the risks you're exposed to (time not working, looking for a new job, etc.) But those are the same regardless.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- sigstoat 6y ago> As an employee, you probably are close to last in line behind most of the other creditors, and may have to just write off that last (missed) paycheck. you're simply making things up. stop it. you can look up the hierarchy of creditors, and see where employee compensation lands. they're fourth priority, after domestic support obligations (probably not relevant to a business), administrative expenses (gotta pay the courts and court-appointed bankruptcy trustee), and claims from involuntary bankruptcy. employee benefits are in the fifth priority. there are four more priority levels (6 through 10), and then all of the unsecured creditors.
- webmaven 6y agoLook, businesses don't go bankrupt completely out of the blue. There are so many ways to ensure that various parties get their pound of flesh while loading up the company with additional liabilities that it is ridiculous. Sure, technically employees are near the top, but that doesn't help if all the cash and assets are long gone.
- omginternets 6y agoI think most people agree with this in general, but the difficulty is in the specifics. How large of a profit are we talking? How much sharing do we expect? On the one hand we want to incentivize risk-taking and entrepreneurship. On the other, we recognize that it takes a village to launch a successful company, and we want to share the wealth. On the one hand we recognize that all work is not equally valuable. On the other, we we value people beyond their work. Abstract discussion of this is always disappointing and policy based on abstract discussion is always disastrous. I really wish we could be more precise in our language, because then we would at least recognize the tremendous difficulty at hand.
- mejutoco 6y agoSeems difficult to implement. Suddenly a lot of small companies could appear, each barely making any profit. Maybe an easier incentive would be to give tax breaks to cooperatives?
- jlawson 6y agoIt is encoded into law, except instead of sharing just with employees, you share it with everyone through taxes. There's no reason that an employee who just happens to work at a firm that becomes successful should get profits from that, while a similar employee doing the same work who just happens to work at a failing company should get nothing. How could you justify that? Putting business profit taxes in a big pot and spending them on everyone evens this out. Fundamentally all you're really saying is you want corporate taxes to be higher. Which is arguable given the well-understood negative consequences of that which hurt everyone (e.g. taxes dissuade business formation, which means no jobs at all).
- koolba 6y ago> Employers that allow people to "work on their passions" use that as a bargaining chip to lower salaries. That sounds like every startup job pitch.
- bluefirebrand 6y agoBig difference is that Startups usually offer some amount of equity. Instead of just being exploited, you're gambling on taking a lower salary now and having it pay off later. It never really pays off later for game programmers.
- neonological 6y agoHonestly it’s a losing gamble too. You rarely win those options.
- willcipriano 6y agoOften the dice are loaded, you can find many stories on here on about some financial trickery whereby the options become low value or worthless as the founders and VC's cash out. I personally evaluate them at $0 because of this. It's a shame too because that sounds like my ideal work setup.
- hhjinks 6y agoPretty sure this article was posted on HN, which is why I remembered it: https://marker.medium.com/my-company-sold-for-100-million-and-i-got-zilch-how-can-that-be-f7be0563f1f8 https://marker.medium.com/my-company-sold-for-100-million-an...
- xiphias2 6y agoWhat startups fail to disclose is that the equity they offer is not the same class as the investors have, even though they are taking a huge risk of the startup failing.
- 6y ago
- jonnycomputer 6y agoThey should unionize.
- IQunder130 6y agoSo what you're saying is that when supply goes up, market price goes down? Not much of an insight there. Not something you really could (or even should) fix.
- GVIrish 6y agoAlso why the games industry remains stuck on a lot of bad practices. The experienced people keep getting driven out.
- bluefirebrand 6y agoThat's actually something kind of funny to me. I've never worked in the game industry but I have done game jams in the past and I am very interested in making games as a hobby. One of the biggest barriers to me is getting over my need to make code that I think is clean. And every time I try to read about best practices in game code I come across the same mentality: Who cares, write code quick and dirty, as long as it works it's fine. And that's fine, it's just intimidating for me to write code like that. Too much perfectionism or something. Maybe too much "What if I do it wrong and introduce a bug so entangled in everything that I can't unravel it". I wish there were even some bare minimum best practices suggestions for game code.
- slowmovintarget 6y agoLook into Jonathan Blow's work. He doesn't churn out garbage code. He cares about his craft and that includes artisanship in the games he builds.
- smrq 6y agoWith all due respect to Jon Blow (and I respect him a whole lot!)-- I don't think he'd be able to do what he does if he didn't make a boatload of money off of Braid.
- slifin 6y agoBraid itself was novel because it took game state and made it immutable, immutability often needs a lot of consideration This is definitely speculation on my part but maybe he didn't become a coder focused on his craft because of the finances afforded to him from Braid, maybe he created Braid a quality game because he was a coder focused on his craft?
- jerf 6y agoIt's because there are so many young people who think that they absolutely want to be video game developers, so it simply doesn't matter how much the companies abuse them, there's a fresh horde of possibly-misguided fresh faces right behind them. Pretty much every other programming job is in a shortage, but here there's a glut. I say "possibly-misguided" because there are some people for whom that is their one and only dream, and if that is their choice, hey, great. Go for it. I just want people to go into it with open eyes. However, I think the bulk of such people are simply misinformed about A: the nature of game programming and B: the nature of non-game programming. For the most part, they're a lot more similar than a lot of young people realize. You don't go into games programming and get to "design games"; you're going to consume tickets and do a lot of repetitive scut work. Frankly your odds of finding a good job where you're self-directed and not entirely doing scut work is better outside of the game industry. So... do your part... spread the word that the games industry is mostly bad jobs and the non-games industry actually has a lot of good stuff in it, so that by giving young people a better understanding of the real situation they can make better choice, and help starve the games industry of its continuous supply of fresh-faced naive grads to exploit.
- bluefirebrand 6y agoThis is absolutely the trajectory I took. I wanted so badly to make games. Still do, one of my life goals is to make a game that I actually publish. But I had some great professors in university that steered me away from the game industry. I'm quite happy working as a web dev now and I can do games as a hobby.
- finikytou 6y agoI don't think that is the reason. The main reason is that there isn't enough competition. Video Game Companies are pretty much in a monopoly. No one is making a game like GTA. No one else is making a football game (You need the license), No one else is making doom. No one else is making Counter Strike. Games became brands. The only thing that drives you out of business is your own greed of recycling your franchises/ideas. Oh and also many of those companies do not need that many of the "expensive" devs because many of those video game companies are using middlewares like unity or unreal engine. With more competitions better video game companies would hire better engineer at better salaries. that will lift everyone else.
- legohead 6y agoBoth of you are missing a key ingredient that the article goes over -- fanboyism. “A lot of people just felt that there was value in being able to work on anime that they loved,” Mr. Hirakimoto said. “No matter how little they got paid, they were willing to do the work.” Looking back at his departure, he said, “I don’t regret the decision at all.” And the same story is in the video game industry. Take Blizzard for example. When I moved to SoCal I applied for lots of tech companies including Blizzard, and got several offers. Blizzard was by far the lowest offer. And I noticed during the interview process, everyone I talked to kept asking what I thought about Blizzard, and it wasn't the standard "why do you want to work here?" I got the impression they were testing how much of a fanboy I was. And from others I've talked to afterwards, that is exactly what they were doing.
- nend 6y ago>To me, that entire industry seems geared towards grabbing fresh faced grads who are loaded up on dreams of making games, putting them in infinite crunch, and discarding them later when they are burned out. This is the way it's "always been" for game development. When I was in college 15 years ago, it was the same environment. It turned me off from pursuing a career in game development (among other factors). I'm sure more senior people than me have similar anecdotes.
- jasonwatkinspdx 6y agoYour take is pretty accurate from what I've seen. A friend is on the Call of Duty team, and Medal of Honor before that. The way MoH turned into CoD is the owner of the studio that made MoH was unwilling to sufficiently share the profits, so basically the entire team walked out in mass, got their own publishing deal and made CoD. But only the people who've made a runaway hit have that kind of bargaining power. The other 90% of the industry is pretty grim. Things are a lot better on the indie/casual/mobile side, as those tend to be smaller studios with close friendships/partnerships.
- alaties 6y agoWhile there are similarities within the videogame industry, one has to understand that the plight of a developer is no where near as tragic as that of an animator in Japan. For a developer, the skills learned for working in the videogame industry are highly transferable to better paying jobs outside of video games. Skills learned on the job are also equally valuable outside of industry. When a developer is ready to leave the videogame industry, they have skills that are in demand and are able to get positions equal to their experience. For a 2D animator, keyframing and tweening are not well-payed skills outside of the anime industry. Skills learned on the job are equally not well payed. When an animator is ready to leave the anime industry, they have to start at the entry level of whatever new industry they're entering. To find that the last few years of your life are deemed meaningless by the job market after working your ass off day and night... That is a real gut punch.
- YinglingLight 6y agoThat's when you market out your skills to satisfying niche fetishes on the Japanese equivalent of Patreon. On a serious note, there's a slew of skills an animator has on their Talent Stack (https://personalexcellence.co/blog/talent-stack/ https://personalexcellence.co/blog/talent-stack/). Mere fluency of Photoshop, Illustrator, being able to DRAW period, work ethic, are no mere skills at all.
- Bakary 6y agoIt sounds like they could make the transition to graphic design or similar industries. They would be jumping into dangerous waters but at least it wouldn't be from scratch
- SkyPuncher 6y agoYou see similar pan out in medicine. Physicians at "renown" institutions actually tend to make less (on average) than the average physician. They can do it because so many physicians are willing to move to a high CoL location, work more, and take a pay cut. The best jobs actually tend to be in rural states and areas. Pay is better and work/life balance tends to be better. CNN article: https://money.cnn.com/2016/01/27/pf/jobs/doctors-pay/index.html https://money.cnn.com/2016/01/27/pf/jobs/doctors-pay/index.h...
- jonnycomputer 6y agoUnionize. Seriously, just do it. Do your passion and earn a decent living.
- cercatrova 6y agoI mean, they know what they're getting into, it's supply and demand. More people simply want the job more than there is demand, so they'll be paid less.
- georgeecollins 6y agoIt is also true that it was once really hard, from a technical knowledge and skills point of view, to make video games. There were no engines like Unity or Unreal. Every feature your game needed had to be written from scratch. The artistic tools, particularly for 3d modeling, were crude and had to be adapted by people who understood what the engine was doing. Now all those things are much easier to do and understand. There are thousands of tutorials on the internet. So making games is becoming more like writing books, putting on plays, making a low budget movie. More people can do it than there is an audience. The best are still very valuable, in every discipline. But the supply of average people is almost limitless.
- BlargMcLarg 6y agoOne could argue the same for almost any field in software development. Despite that, game development has always been lower paying thanks to its passion industry roots. Meanwhile, web development still dominates most of the job market and makes big bank even for average developers doing mostly data plumbing.