24 ms·
Bitfinex and Tether required to end all trading activity with New Yorkers
- rtrdea 6y agoBitfinex isn't an American company. This is ridiculous
- Spooky23 6y agoWhat’s ridiculous? That the company’s home jurisdiction allowed them to defraud the public?
- robjan 6y agoIt's not even clear where the company is physically located. It's a Hong Kong company but all of the addresses here are just virtual offices and shell companies.
- bonzini 6y agoThe full title ends with "Illegal Activities in New York", not sure why it was removed.
- dgellow 6y agoBecause it's too long for HN (I instead replaced "Attorney General" by "NYAG", not ideal but an ok compromise IMHO)
- im3w1l 6y ago"Bitfinex banned from New York." Edit: I'm getting downvoted but I went soft on him. You know what, I'll say it. The choice of which words to retain (virtual currency trading platform??) and which to drop (in New York) is really bad and veering into suspicious, seems like it's trying to stir up panic.
- dgellow 6y agoIt's the title of the linked press release, with a minor change to fit the maximum length required for HN submissions.
- im3w1l 6y agoYou make it sound like they have been taken down globally. That's not a "minor change".
- dgellow 6y agoHow would the New York attorney general shut down the company globally? That doesn't make sense. But feel free to contact dang or other moderators and ask for a change of the title if you think that can be improved.
- im3w1l 6y agoPeople here are from every part of the world. Many wont know what a "NYAG" is or what powers they have, in fact I bet quite a few Americans don't know either. Oh well.. the new title is good.
- kasey_junk 6y agoNote the headline should add “in New York” or the like.
- GavinMcG 6y agoDo you expect to get away with illegal activity when you travel abroad?
- jobigoud 6y agoA lot of people do. For example driving over the speed limit because they can't be fined.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dgellow 6y agoSettlement agreement available here: https://ag.ny.gov/sites/default/files/2021.02.17_-_settlement_agreement_-_execution_version.b-t_signed-c2_oag_signed.pdf https://ag.ny.gov/sites/default/files/2021.02.17_-_settlemen...
- raiyu 6y agoIs this the first official ruling on tether that shows it isn’t backed 1:1 by the US dollar? That has long been speculated, but if this is the first official verification how does that affect the Market. Especially the self dealing of Bitfinex.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoTether themselves essentially admitted that it wasn’t fully backed in 2019: https://www.coindesk.com/tether-lawyer-confirms-stablecoin-74-percent-backed-by-cash-and-equivalents https://www.coindesk.com/tether-lawyer-confirms-stablecoin-7... The strangest part of the Tether story is how much of it was obvious or even out in the open. Cryptocurrency proponents were happy to look the other way as long as prices were only going up. I suspect cryptocurrency proponents and Bitfinex are working hard to spin this as a win for Tether right.
- bhouston 6y agoGetting rid of the fraud (tether) at the core of btc will strengthen btc. This cryptocurrency proponents should be all for it. I have honestly been surprised how long this obvious tether saga has gone on.
- ForHackernews 6y agoThis is only true if we accept your unstated premise that BTC itself isn't a big ole Ponzi scheme. I guess we could argue, "It's good news for our slightly more subtle fraud if the blatant, obvious fraud gets stamped out."
- CarelessExpert 6y ago> This is only true if we accept your unstated premise that BTC itself isn't a big ole Ponzi scheme. Let's be clear, here: There's a substantial difference between Bitfinex engaging in outright financial fraud vs a bunch of people buying into the value of a virtual currency for reasons no one can understand. BTC is not a ponzi. It's just a long-running speculative bubble. A collective delusion. You can disagree with that, sure, but it's certainly no more a fraud than Beanie Babies or tulip bulbs.
- andreaorru 6y ago"Contrary to online speculation, there was no finding that Tether ever issued tethers [USDT] without backing, or to manipulate crypto prices," said Weinstein, a former federal prosecutor. [0] [0] https://www.theblockcrypto.com/post/95207/bitfinex-tether-new-york-ag-settlement-lawsuit https://www.theblockcrypto.com/post/95207/bitfinex-tether-ne... EDIT: For some reason I'm being downvoted, but I'm genuinely curious to understand why this news is being simultaneously interpreted in two opposite ways.
- Clewza313 6y agoHuh? The NYAG press release literally says: "Tether’s claims that its virtual currency was fully backed by U.S. dollars at all times was a lie." Edit: The difference between the two statements is that Tether can still be "backed" by something other than USD, notably crypto. And the PR is silent on what exactly Tether is backed by. This saga isn't over yet.
- andreaorru 6y agoI'm also confused by the contradicting news. CryptoTwitter (and the markets) reacted enthusiastically...
- Izkata 6y agoThose two quotes aren't necessarily contradictory, they're about different timings. Tether could have been fully backed when issuing new tethers, and stopped issuing tethers during period(s) when it wasn't fully backed.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoWhen was the last time CryptoTwitter didn’t try to spin something as good for Bitcoin?
- jkhdigital 6y agoThat statement was made by their counsel, so it should probably be taken with a grain of salt.
- bronzeage 6y agoI'm waiting patiently for the whole Tether printing scheme to fall and crush to finally purchase Bitcoin / Ether. However I'm not viewing them as inflation hedges so long as Bitfinex / etc. are allowed to continue with their obvious money printing scheme. When most crypto trading volume is traded at trustworthy exchanges which actually hold dollars as much as they say they do, I'll trust $/BTC to be a fair market. It's dumb escaping from Powell's printing machine straight into Bitfinex tether printing machine. BTC isn't the hedge people think it is so long as it's traded against fictional dollars. Tether's volume exceeds Bitcoin, so that's the scale of fictional dollars supporting Bitcoin right now.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoCryptocurrency isn’t the only way to escape USD inflation. Investors have been investing to avoid inflation long before Bitcoin was invented. Investing in virtually any asset other than cash will, almost by definition, shield you from inflation. Inflation is an increase in asset prices, resulted in reduced buying power. You only need to invest in assets (stocks for example) and minimize holdings in cash if your goal is simply to avoid losing buying power of your cash. Cryptocurrency currently functions as a speculative instrument, not a stable store of value. Cryptocurrency in general is only deflationary if we pretend only a single cryptocurrency exists and ignore all of the increasingly brazen financial instruments offered by exchanges. As it stands, the ever expanding list of crypto currencies, NFTs, crypto lending products, and new crypto currencies represents a general inflation in the cryptocurrency space.
- api 6y ago> Investing in virtually any asset other than cash will, almost by definition, shield you from inflation. ... which is why virtually every nation on Earth adopted some kind of inflationary fiat currency. It pushes money to be invested, not held. Wealth is a verb, not a noun.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoThe world would certainly be a strange and sad place if the best thing for everyone to do with their wealth was hoard it in currency. Not holding wealth in cash has been investing 101 material long before cryptocurrency. It is fascinating how crypto proponents took over that narrative to imply that crypto was the only investment that could escape inflation. They’ve also spread an idea that money printing is the singular source of inflation, which isn’t true at all. Bitcoin, for example, is an inflating asset due to hype-driven demand. It hasn’t spiked upward 100% of the time because USD became 50% less valuable overnight
- temp 6y agoSo even back in 2017, Tether was backed only by a fraction of USD. >Until September 15, 2017, the only U.S. dollars held by Tether ostensibly backing the approximately 442 million tethers in circulation was the approximately $61 million on deposit at the Bank of Montreal. Wonder how much of the tether they pumped out through last year has been backed?
- londons_explore 6y agoNearly none I would guess... Which large company, investment firm or rich individual will wire Tether Inc millions of dollars in return for a promise from a bunch of people that look like arrest warrants will shortly be issued for them...
- BelenusMordred 6y agoDo people here not realise that people give them bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies for that in exchange for tethers? If they were only a week late in converting it to USD they'd be up tens of billion in profit this year. The lack of critical thinking and mindless mob mentality around tether is amusing and has been going on for years now. Proven wrong everytime.[1][2][3] Even this announcement is dumb politiking that people seem to lap up. Bitfinex has banned US customers since 2017.[4] [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14934874 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14934874 [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16252365 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16252365 [3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16182423 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16182423 [4] https://www.coindesk.com/bitfinex-suspends-sale-select-ico-tokens-citing-sec-concerns https://www.coindesk.com/bitfinex-suspends-sale-select-ico-t...
- bhouston 6y agoAnd if they used made up tether to buy a bit of extra btc or a lot they would be even further ahead. The easily exploitable opportunities for fraud surrounding tether is huge. Bernie Madoff should be jealous.
- tootahe45 6y agoA 145m sell just sent BTC down 13k. It's not so easy to just sell your ~30b worth of buttcoin. If anything it's shocking that "we checked and it's all fraud" is seen as a win for crypto.
- filleokus 6y agoSo there are 34B outstanding USDT right now. In the documents I see talk about some 850M USD is missing. Are all the other ≈ 33B USDT backed? Will we only know that on the first report they obliged to do each quarter? Will those reports be made public? I'm confused what to make of this.
- Clewza313 6y agoThe NYAG investigation is about what happened up to 2019 or so. What has happened since (which includes printing 33 of those 34 billion) is a separate matter, and NYAG is basically saying it's irrelevant because nobody in NY should be able to use Tether/Bitfinex anymore.
- TacticalCoder 6y agoWhat's confusing is that in addition to the slap on the wrist of 18.5m and the prohibition for BitFinex to operate in NY, it is written: "agreement with iFinex, Tether, and their related entities will require them to cease any further trading activity with New Yorkers, as well as force the companies to pay $18.5 million in penalties, in addition to requiring a number of steps to increase transparency." What are these steps to "increase transparency"? On activities related to these 850m or on the 33 bn+ printed since then? To benefit whom? New Yorkers cannot use BitFinex anymore. If it's now irrelevant to the NYAG because from NY's point of view BitFinex is out, why ask for "a number of steps to increase transparency"?
- raiyu 6y agoThe minting of tether accelerated in 2020 and continues in to 2021 including one week alone where $2B was minted. https://www.coindesk.com/tether-mints-record-2b-usdt-in-one-week https://www.coindesk.com/tether-mints-record-2b-usdt-in-one-...
- lovedswain 6y agoThe most damning detail I've seen comes from US treasury TIC reports, which fail to reveal matching bond ownership inflow to the country that is the reputed host of Tether's segregated bank account. It is possible that Tether holds funds in some kind of strange non-interest-bearing account, but that seems highly unlikely. Another possibility is that the primary bank is actually a wrapper around some overseas correspondent bank where the funds are really held. Occam's razor: a company selling a 1:1 hedged coin should have absolutely no difficulty whatsoever proving on a daily or hourly basis that all coins are verifiably fully hedged. It should literally be the company's prime directive, and in this particular case, especially following the endless stream of controversy. The fact they haven't managed to convincingly achieve this even once in 7 years is all I need to know. The whole thing stinks terribly. Good luck for those who invest in it, but I'll be there if/when it blows up to quietly feel smug about it all
- Clewza313 6y agoMeanwhile, a group of hackers claim to have penetrated Bitfinex/Tether's bank Deltec: https://deltecexposed.medium.com/deltec-bank-trust-and-their-relationship-to-tether-and-ifinex-be41be43b1e3 https://deltecexposed.medium.com/deltec-bank-trust-and-their... Grab some popcorn, the show is only getting started.
- capnorange 6y agono evidence. looks like some random post.
- capnorange 6y agowait.. this seems contradictory to this -- https://www.theblockcrypto.com/post/95207/bitfinex-tether-new-york-ag-settlement-lawsuit https://www.theblockcrypto.com/post/95207/bitfinex-tether-ne...
- londons_explore 6y agoI think I trust ag.ny.gov much more than theblockcrypto.com... It suggests the latter is 100% made up news, possibly with the aim of market manipulation by sentiment bots who will be fooled for a few minutes until humans intervene.
- celticninja 6y agoI would also prefer to trust that source, however it is written as a press release. So they write it to make them look as positive as they can and stress the Bitfinex bad points. The blockcrypto article seems to indicate that the accounts were now balanced, but the ag.ny.gov makes no mention of it, which is expected if they are still trying to paint bitfinex as a wrongdoer, but calls into question their impartiality, so it becomes difficult to accept either at face value.
- FireBeyond 6y ago> I would also prefer to trust that source, however it is written as a press release. So they write it to make them look as positive as they can and stress the Bitfinex bad points. Whereas theblockcrypto is quoting Bitfinex's counsel who is weasel wording over people's understanding of what a "finding" is at law? > The blockcrypto article seems to indicate that the accounts were now balanced Given that in 2019, Tether's lifetime holdings were $2.1B and even that was not fully backed, and they're now printing $3.5B a week, I'm intensely curious how they are comfortable drawing that conclusion.
- londons_explore 6y agoI'm also very interested in the $18.5M number in the settlement... It seems surprisingly small for someone who can't explain where $200M+ has gone to...
- londons_explore 6y agoThe price of bitcoin dropped substantially yesterday. I wonder who was trading on this information before release...
- zaxu 6y agoIt was always public information that this was coming out today or tomorrow.
- jkhdigital 6y agoHonestly, this is kind of a nothingburger. The press release seems to merely reinforce what was an open secret in the cryptocurrency world, which is that Bitfinex and Tether have played fast and loose with whatever reserves they received for their Tether issuance. Which is, of course, utterly unremarkable to anyone who knows anything about how financial sausage is really made. Bitfinex and Tether are shady. Caveat emptor, and carry on hodling.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoIt’s more important than that. Cryptocurrency proponents have been trying to downplay the Tether situation for years. One of the common dismissals was the idea that if what Tether was doing was truly fraudulent, some government institution would step in to intervene. Proponents pointed to the lack of intervention as a signal that Tether was operating above board. This also reveals new facts and numbers about the scale of what has been going on. We still don’t know the full story, but it’s clear that reality is even worse than we thought.
- jkhdigital 6y agoI don't disagree that Tether is likely a big fraud, but my point is that even the regulated financial system is full of questionable accounting and long-running, undiscovered fraud. Remember Bernie Madoff? His fraud lasted 17 years before falling apart. It would be nice if Tether eventually falls apart too, but the world will never run out of fraudsters and hucksters.
- mumblemumble 6y agoBernie Madoff's fraud was big and awful, but, if the allegations about Tether are true, then (edit: for the purposes of this particular discussion) comparing the two is a category error. Madoff's fraud never raised any questions about whether the exchange rate between USD and some other currency was legitimate.
- saalweachter 6y agoThe innovation of Bitcoin is that it is a decentralized Ponzi scheme. Bernie Madoff's scheme fell apart because it was centralized, and so, once you arrested Madoff, it was over. The end. There's no one at the center of Bitcoin. There are big players, sure, but they are all replaceable. It's happened before and it will happen again. And each time one exchange or big player is arrested, shut down, or slinks away having stolen enough money to sate themselves, someone new can seamlessly slip in and start hyping Bitcoin and taking a percentage from the new rubes without missing a beat. I honestly don't think it will ever go away, completely, for good, no matter how often it booms and busts. When I'm in a nursing home I'm going to be getting calls from boiler rooms trying to convince me to move my retirement savings into Bitcoin, I'm convinced.
- cbhl 6y agoIf I'm reading the settlement correctly, Bitfinex will now have even less USD to back Tethers, since they'll have to wire an $18,500,000 transfer to the State of New York.
- ardy42 6y agoBut if there are 34 billion tethers, $18 million is like a rounding error.
- charcircuit 6y agoTether is over collateralized. If they paid that $18.5M from their collateral it would still be over collateralized by $145.9M https://wallet.tether.to/transparency https://wallet.tether.to/transparency
- freeAgent 6y agoTether claim to be over collateralized. This settlement contains numerous instances of Tether lying about their collateral situation. Why trust them without evidence at this point? They’re required to submit a report on their specific reserve holdings within 90 days. We’ll see then.
- cwhiz 6y agoMeanwhile, daily Tether volume is $170B. The entire crypto ecosystem is reliant upon the Tether scam.
- cdiddy2 6y agono its not. that is bad data from no name exchanges lying about their volume
- cwhiz 6y agoHa. The exchange reporting the highest volume is... Bitfinex. I believe you that Bitfinex would lie. Coinbase is reporting $210 billion daily volume. Is every market lying? Or are you just personally wrong?
- cdiddy2 6y agowhere on earth are you seeing coinbase doing $210 billion daily volume? Coinbase has only done 94 billion of volume for the month of February so far monthly volumes by exchange: https://www.theblockcrypto.com/data/crypto-markets/spot/cryptocurrency-exchange-volume-monthly https://www.theblockcrypto.com/data/crypto-markets/spot/cryp...
- cwhiz 6y agoI didn't say Coinbase was doing $210 billion 24h volume. I said Coinbase is reporting that Tether had $210 billion 24h volume. It's right there on the Coinbase tether page. https://www.coinbase.com/price/tether https://www.coinbase.com/price/tether
- cdiddy2 6y agoya that is wrong. not sure where coinbase is getting their data from. keep in mind the total crypto market cap is 1.5 triilion. so tether alone doing 200b is an absurd statement. Total daily volume across all exchanges is only just getting to 50b these days
- stefan_ 6y agoFeels like the NYAG preferred to take an easy win over fully exposing the fraudulent scheme. But I guess in the grand scheme of things it's better to get $18M for state coffers now than be another bag holder when Tether inevitably combusts.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoThis particular lawsuit started in 2019 and was narrowly scoped. They don’t have infinite jurisdiction over Tether’s global operations.
- dgellow 6y agoSomething to note: they only had data from 2017 to 2019. Tether printed the majority of their coins in 2020/2021.
- NelsonMinar 6y agoI bet they pinkie-swear those new coins are really really backed by dollars this time.
- christiansakai 6y agoDoes this mean that Tether is not buyable by NYers in Coinbase and Gemini?
- TacticalCoder 6y agoGemini offered/offers USDT?
- christiansakai 6y agoOh actually maybe only Coinbase
- charcircuit 6y agoNo, Coinbase has their own stable coin USDC.
- arberx 6y agoHave no idea why ycombinator is so salty towards anything crypto. Yes, tether was wrong when they said USDT was backed by “US Dollars”. But, the conclusion is USDT is backed by something, the likes of which is probably a fractional reserve. Case is resolved, with Tether admitting no fault.
- joshuakelly 6y agoIt's pretty amusing in the context of YC specifically, and less so HN, given that Coinbase is very likely to become the most valuable YC company to date.
- Clewza313 6y ago"Backed by something"! It sounds so reassuring when you phrase it that way.
- arberx 6y agoThat was the conclusion of the AG. Case is moot. Tether is definitely sketch, but it’s not this massive money laundering/conspiracy HN thinks it is.
- FireBeyond 6y ago"Partially backed by something" was indeed one of the conclusions of the AG in this limited scope investigation. Meanwhile, Tether is, was, claiming "Fully backed by USD!". And yet you are acting like the AG was supportive of Tether's claims, "Oh, yes, even the AG says so!"
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- divs1210 6y agoAmerica lied to the world when it claimed each dollar was backed by gold. When the world figured it out and there was a bank run, the gold standard was "temporarily" put off by Nixon in 1970. Bitfinex just seems to be playing the same game America has always been playing.
- lifty 6y agoThis news is so funny. Tether detractors see this as confirmation that they were right all along, while crypto currency fans say that this is confirmation that it was FUD all along. No bridges were built in this endeavour.
- bhouston 6y agoI like btc but in a declaring that tether is fraud isn’t about building bridges, it is about being correct. Getting rid of tether is the best way to legitimize btc. The sooner the better. It is confusing why you care about bridges with regards to fraud. When was fraud related to consensus building activities? Huh?
- lifty 6y agoI meant it as a figure of speech, in that the 2 parts can't see eye to eye. I care about the legitimacy of the space and I am not a big fan of these backed stable coins, because they can't be easily verified.
- baby 6y agoThe same way the fascists and the democrats can't seem to unify?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ketamine__ 6y agoTether isn't decentralized but as it turns out users prefer convenience over ideology. This is pretty apparent from the rise of Binance. If you want to blame anyone though it's probably the folks that have been working on layer 2 since 2017 but haven't delivered in a major way.
- jMyles 6y ago> Tether detractors see this... while crypto currency fans Be reminded that the overlap in this venn diagram is enormous.
- psychlops 6y agoHere we are again, with a steady stream of nocoiner comments validating their long held positions while bitcoin slowly marches ahead year after year.
- ceejayoz 6y agoMadoff’s fraud took decades to unravel, too. You’d have looked silly declining to invest there, until the collapse.
- psychlops 6y agoMadoff took in large sums of money, gave out little and lied about solvency. Tether is 1/30th the market cap of bitcoin, yet there is a magical belief (based on anonymous articles) that it's the primary source of price levitation. If true, Grayscale would have this same power.
- ceejayoz 6y ago> Madoff took in large sums of money, gave out little and lied about solvency. That's exactly what Tether has done? Large sums? Check - tens of billions. Gave out little? Check - https://cointelegraph.com/news/tether-explains-why-it-hasnt-burned-any-usdt https://cointelegraph.com/news/tether-explains-why-it-hasnt-.... Lied about solvency? They admit in this suit that they weren't 1:1 backed, despite asserting it on their website. They also claimed to be regularly audited, until they had to admit they'd never completed one. (Still haven't, to my knowledge?)
- psychlops 6y agoOh, don't get me wrong, I'm not supporting Tether. Tether may completely fall off the edge of the world and nobody would care. There would be a minor impact on the price of bitcoin and things will move on. As I mentioned, I believe the proof of insolvency is weak, but I don't think it matters long term either way. Better alternatives will supercede them soon enough. USDC and possibly Libra will be excellent choices.
- lettergram 6y agoIt appears from the link in the settlement agreement: https://ag.ny.gov/sites/default/files/2021.02.17_-_settlement_agreement_-_execution_version.b-t_signed-c2_oag_signed.pdf https://ag.ny.gov/sites/default/files/2021.02.17_-_settlemen... Tether wasn’t backed at all times. The argument was that this happened due to asset seizures in Poland and Portugal in 2017-2018. https://www.theblockcrypto.com/post/95207/bitfinex-tether-new-york-ag-settlement-lawsuit https://www.theblockcrypto.com/post/95207/bitfinex-tether-ne... Seems to me they couldn’t prove malicious intent, so they suggested they stop trading. Frankly this seems a bit of a click-bait title with the whole “illegal activities”. Sure, tether wasn’t backed at all times (probably is now), due to governments seizing their funds. Also banks do this all the time, every time they issue a loan for instance. The bank only keeps 10-30% collateral on your home.
- bhouston 6y agoThe issue is that if it isn’t backed they can print more at any time. But they claim it is backed to avoid inflation devaluation of the currency. Banks are not lower to print currency but tether can at any time. The potential for fraud sufrounding tether is huge and no one is checking over them. Do you trust them? They are already known for lying. This is why banking regulations exist.
- lettergram 6y ago> The issue is that if it isn’t backed they can print more at any time. That’s how all banking works. China, for instance, never even publish how much money they click into existence. Not saying it’s correct, just explaining how the system really works. They really do “create” money. Even synthetic shares are created on the stock market (largely when creating ETF blocks), see “naked shorts”. It happens all the time. Here’s an explanation on how banking & interest work in a digestible way: http://anuparty.org/on-interest-slavery/ http://anuparty.org/on-interest-slavery/
- dgellow 6y agoTether isn't a bank. It's a stable coin supposed to be backed by real dollars. But that's of course not the case in practice.
- nateberkopec 6y agoAre there any other active government investigations of Tether/iFinex that we know about?
- raiyu 6y agoLooks like Tether is taking the settlement as an agreement of no wrong doing and that no tether coins were issued without backing. https://tether.to/tether-and-bitfinex-reach-settlement-with-new-york-attorney-generals-office/ https://tether.to/tether-and-bitfinex-reach-settlement-with-...
- kryogen1c 6y agoLOL "Contrary to online speculation, after two and half years there was no finding that Tether ever issued tethers without backing, or to manipulate crypto prices." I like how they say "this report doesnt include wrong-doing" instead of saying "we didnt do anything wrong"
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoThey’re moving the goalposts. The issue was that they didn’t have the money at some point, but they continued operating as if they did. I’d be even more concerned if they think this is okay now. Tether isn’t useful if they’re only backed at time of issue. They also printed the majority of Tethers after this 2019 lawsuit.
- jcfrei 6y ago"Contrary to online speculation, there was no finding that Tether ever issued tethers [USDT] without backing, or to manipulate crypto prices" I hope that ends the spreading of FUD - claiming that bitcoin and other cryptos are propped up by the printing of fake tethers - which seems to spread here every time there is a sharp rise in prices.
- dgellow 6y agoRead the settlement agreement: https://ag.ny.gov/sites/default/files/2021.02.17_-_settlement_agreement_-_execution_version.b-t_signed-c2_oag_signed.pdf https://ag.ny.gov/sites/default/files/2021.02.17_-_settlemen... Page 4 of the agreement: > 20. Because of Tether’s inability to conduct significant banking activity during this time, it could not itself hold dollars sufficient to back the hundreds of millions of new tethers that had entered the market. Until September 15, 2017, the only U.S. dollars held by Tether ostensibly backing the approximately 442 million tethers in circulation was the approximately $61 million on deposit at the Bank of Montreal. That's 14% of the cash required to back the issued Tether.
- tectec 6y agoWhere is that quote from? I don't see it in the linked article
- dgellow 6y agoIt's from https://www.theblockcrypto.com/post/95207/bitfinex-tether-new-york-ag-settlement-lawsuit https://www.theblockcrypto.com/post/95207/bitfinex-tether-ne....
- 35fbe7d3d5b9 6y agohttps://www.theblockcrypto.com/post/95207/bitfinex-tether-new-york-ag-settlement-lawsuit https://www.theblockcrypto.com/post/95207/bitfinex-tether-ne... > Jason Weinstein, a partner at Steptoe & Johnson and counsel to Bitfinex and Tether
- FireBeyond 6y ago
- jstrong 6y agousdt/usd market at kraken holding at ~$1 https://cryptowat.ch/charts/KRAKEN:USDT-USD https://cryptowat.ch/charts/KRAKEN:USDT-USD
- olalonde 6y agoThe hypocrisy. Tether was pushed to the "darkest corners of the financial system" *because* of regulators. It seems they tried their best to remain solvent and didn't steal cash reserves. But regulators made their life hard at every turn. If you care about protecting USDT holders, maybe stop interfering with their operations and stop seizing their funds? And now, they have to submit regular reports to the NY regulators while being banned from doing any business in NY? I doubt many USDT holders are very happy today about the NYAG's attempts to protect them.
- aplummer 6y agoFrom the article: > Bitfinex and Tether recklessly and unlawfully covered-up massive financial losses to keep their scheme going and protect their bottom lines,” said Attorney General James. “Tether’s claims that its virtual currency was fully backed by U.S. dollars at all times was a lie Are you claiming this is false and they paid the 18.5m penalty for not lying about USD reserves?
- olalonde 6y agoPart of their USD reserves were frozen by regulators in Poland and Portugal. It is debatable whether having funds frozen by regulators can be de accurately described as sustaining "massive financial losses". Sure, they could have been more transparent about what was going on. But so far, it seems that all their issues originate from regulators making it impossible for them to run a legitimate business, not fraudulent intentions (which is what they are often accused of).
- nickthemagicman 6y agoThis is why I like Stellar Lumens. The exchange is built in!
- Tangokat 6y agoThis is the important part going forward: "Tether must offer public disclosures, by category, of the assets backing tethers, including disclosure of any loans or receivables to or from affiliated entities. The companies will also provide greater transparency and mandatory reporting regarding the use of non-bank “payment processors” or other entities used to transmit client funds." So from now on Tether must be backed 1:1 and provide transparency. This should severely limit the risk of Tether blowing up the crypto ecosystem.
- topynate 6y ago"Because of Tether’s inability to conduct significant banking activity during this time, it could not itself hold dollars sufficient to back the hundreds of millions of new tethers that had entered the market." The word "itself" is doing heavy duty in this sentence. Was there another entity holding dollars in this period? Did Tether issue USDT without a corresponding inflow of USD? We don't know. One would hope that the transparency agreement actually answers these questions for its future operations. It's those questions that matter, after all, not Ms. Letitia James' "efforts".
- IG_Semmelweiss 6y agoquestion for HN. If tether has been so successful at avoiding scrutiny while also making money, why is it that we don't see more tethers? It seems like a very easy way to make money.. given the authorities are asleep at the wheel ?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- graeme 6y agoWell the issue is eventually if DOJ steps in and convicts the founders can all go to jail. Jail is a good deterrent.
- dudus 6y agoI've been following Tether for quite a long time. I have no absolute proof it is a scam but the writing is on the wall. Here are some facts. - The current Market Cap of USDT is 34 Billion Dollars. It was 4B this time last year. Since the value is pegged this means there has been an influx of cash of 30 B into this shady company in the last year alone. Who invested this money? We have no idea since Tether doesn't disclose, but we're supposed to believe all this money entered USDT even with the red flags we see. - There's a correlation between Tether printing new USDT and the Bitcoin Price. - There's no way to transfer USDT into USD. The few exchanges that say they offer withdraws actually don't if you go and try. - Daily volume of transaction is in the 100 B mark. Twice that of Bitcoin and 3 times Tether daily volume this time last year. - BitFinex is included in the NY decision because it's proven now that Bitfinex and Tether are operated by the same people. Note that a few years ago this was not only undisclosed but actively denied by Tether. - Tether initially told its investors it was 100% backed by dollar reserves and that it would be subjected to constant audits. The audits never happened, and they eventually conceded only ~70% was backed by "short term cash reserves". My conclusion is that the folks at BitFinex came up with a new currency, printed billions of it and used it to wash trade against itself and other crypto, creating an artificial demand that drove the prices up. It's textbook Ponzi scheme and will inevitably come crashing down, killing Tether, BitFinex and a chunk of the Crypto Market. Crypto folks will counter argue that people has been saying this for years but Tether is still chugging along and crypto is healthier than ever. Personally I won't touch any crypto with a 10 foot pole until this thing blows over. If that means missing out on a lot of possible gains so be it.
- zby 6y ago"There's no way to transfer USDT into USD. The few exchanges that say they offer withdraws actually don't if you go and try." How about Bitfinex? I had some problems with withdrawals there in the past - but now it seems to work.
- vmception 6y agoAlmost all fiat deposits into Bitfinex create USDT. Thats an additional fact that the amount is in line with the amounts that would be deposited into any big exchange. If Coinbase minted USDC whenever someone deposited, you would see the same kind of growth. The basis of your entire post is assuming impropriety based on pretty normal behavior with the addition of the business quirk of when USDT is created. The ability for impropriety is a good enough reason to avoid it, and their unilateral willingness to do so without any discussion can reinforce that. But people thought everything you thought since the beginning of Tether in like 2014 or so, but the reality is that it “only went fractional reserve” in 2018. Its kind of like they threw up their hands and said “well people think its a ponzi anyway might as well cover this business debt!” The irony being that the NY AG investigation actually proved that prior to 2018 it functioned exactly as promised, barring their 2017 distress by having nowhere to put their fiat deposits. But if you assume that it hasnt come crashing down because Bitfinex does what they said, then it still does make sense: crypto prices pump after Tether mints because it is people depositing into the exchange and then buying crypto. Any way glad USDC and DAI are growing a lot now, which have grown by the same orders of magnitude.
- jiveturkey 6y agoHopefully this isn't drowned out by all the crypto discussion. How can NY require mandatory reporting on core business, if both entities are forbidden now to transact with New Yorkers? How would this even be enforceable? "Sorry, we don't do business in your state."
- dragonwriter 6y ago> How can NY require mandatory reporting on core business, if both entities are forbidden now to transact with New Yorkers? They can because that's the term the firms agreed to to settle the investigation and avoid a suit over misconduct identified by the OAG. > How would this even be enforceable? The OAG takes the firms back to court for violating the settlement agreement, which can include filing charges for any misconduct preceding and covered by the agreement, for which the statute of limitations is suspended by the agreement. > "Sorry, we don't do business in your state." That...doesn't help them at all.
- rednerrus 6y agoIt's weird that this has sent the price through the floor.
- hmcdona1 6y agoI'm so confused why everyone just blindly believes Tether is this whole big conspiracy. I am by no means defending the organization but let's just take a step back here: > Where does the funding come from to print tether? When they mint 1 Tether they sell it on an exchange for $1. They don't need anyone to upfront lock up $1 and then also sell it for $1... Are stablecoins not just essentially an interest free loan to the minter? That's why hundreds of them are popping up all over the place. Minters can go invest that money however conservatively they want and just rack up free interest on billions. Why the hell would they NOT print more if there is demand. Consequently, why the hell would they need to participate in any illegal activity when the can print interest free loans whenever they want? Yes, ideally you'd prefer someone with this position to be overcollatorized and not simply ensure $1 = 1 tether. But that is the risk you take holding that stablecoin. Pick up DAI if you want an overcollatorized asset. I just don't see the incentive for some of the other arguments out there - many imply they are just printing it and selling it for $0 I guess? Or is the argument they just siphon the money to another organization? Because that would be a more valid concern. There just seems to be this assumption that somehow someone is fronting or magically creating value from nothing. No, the market is by buying newly minted Tether on exchanges. That's where the funding comes from. How is this not obvious? There is probably a lot more depth to this topic than I am aware of, but some of the top upvoted comments here just seem to be spewing nonsense. tldr; If a stablecoin minter sells a newly minted coin for $1...then by definition there is now $1 available to back that coin. Stop conspiring where the funds are coming from. The worry should be how they are investing said collateral backing the coins from there.
- eightysixfour 6y ago> When they mint 1 Tether they sell it on an exchange for $1. They don't need anyone to upfront lock up $1 and then also sell it for $1... According to the argument against Tether, your first principal here is wrong. In this argument, Tether mints a USDT and trades with someone who has bitcoin or other crypto and wants a stablecoin. What the trader believes they are getting is a coin which is 1:1 backed by USD. In this situation, it is not. Tether gets bitcoin. Tether can then print more USDT which they trade for bitcoin at a higher price. They would then have an infinite money cheat for buying crypto assets (as long as people believe a USDT = $1) which enables them to drive the price of crypto upward. Tether claims that the pattern is "Someone gives us USD, we give them Tether, they trade for whatever they want", this was provably false at some points in time.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ldbooth 6y agoSo let's assume tether is a fraud. All they have to do is buy bitcoin with their cash received for tether and they are out of reach of us regulators. Is it Fraud or is it Genius? Yes.
- qertoip 6y agoAccording to the agreement with NYAG Tether admitted no wrongdoing. The statement: https://tether.to/tether-and-bitfinex-reach-settlement-with-new-york-attorney-generals-office/ https://tether.to/tether-and-bitfinex-reach-settlement-with-...
- freeAgent 6y agoThey also don’t deny wrongdoing. That’s frequently how settlements work even though it’s clear to anyone who reads the settlement findings that there was wrongdoing on Tether’s part.
- technick 6y agoDoes it ever feel like the government is using the excuse of protecting the consumer, as a reason to shake down exchanges for tax purposes?
- labrador 6y ago"Junk" bonds seemed like an appropriate term for questionable bonds back in the 1980's... By the same logic, cryptocurrencies should be called Junk currencies
- futevolei 6y agoLots of dead bodies in this camp going back years. I used to be one myself. At this point if the ny ag can’t outright bring this supposed scam down then you have to admit it’s not a scam and move on.
- freeAgent 6y agoWhat!? NYAG’s jurisdiction is New York. Tether and Bitfinex are barred from doing any business in New York or with New York entities. They went almost as far as they could go without criminal charges against the executives personally. The US justice system is not necessarily done with them.
- dfjklgj45985 6y agoNew Yorkers haven't been allowed to trade on Bitfinex since 2017. That's when they updated their terms to discriminate against US entities. If US persons are illegally and fraudulently trading on Bitfinex, that does not give any US authority jurisdiction over Bitfinex. How grandiose. https://www.bitfinex.com/posts/227 https://www.bitfinex.com/posts/227 https://www.bitfinex.com/legal/exchange/terms https://www.bitfinex.com/legal/exchange/terms
- CryptoPunk 6y agoAbsolutely absurd. The degree to which the people of New York are being infantilized, when the state is telling outside parties to not allow them to trade their digital assets, is a textbook example of why the philosophical underpinnning of the modern regulatory system are illiberal. How trustworthy Tether is is completely incidental to my comment on the New York regulator.
- Ambix 6y agoTether is scam and even use of Bitcoin looks unethical when you know that: >> the power consumption of bitcoin is 160% times the energy use of Amazon, Google, Microsoft, Facebook and Apple all combined
- xtat 6y agoThis is how the US continues to lose to Asia.