6 ms·
The evidence linking nitrates and nitrites to cancer
- michaelt 6y ago> But learning that consumption of processed meat causes an additional 34,000 worldwide cancer deaths a year is much more chilling. According to Cancer Research UK, if no one ate processed or red meat in Britain, there would be 8,800 fewer cases of cancer. (That is four times the number of people killed annually on Britain’s roads.) Is this trying to say that 23% of worldwide cancer deaths due to meat eating are in the UK? Or is this just shitty writing?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tekstar 6y agoI can't speak to what they actually mean, but not all of the 8800 British cancer cases will die from cancer, so I guess you missed that difference in the sentence.
- InitialLastName 6y agoRight, the most sympathetic reading of that paragraph I can think of is that they're intentionally grouping numbers of cases and comparing them to numbers of deaths to be intentionally misleading about the scale of the problem.
- fuzxi 6y agoIt reads like they're just vomiting statistics to try to scare the reader.
- andrewmcwatters 6y agoSee also https://www.cdc.gov/cancer/dcpc/research/update-on-cancer-deaths/index.htm https://www.cdc.gov/cancer/dcpc/research/update-on-cancer-de...
- cheschire 6y agoWow smokers went from 42% to 14%?! I knew I noticed fewer smokers but had no idea it was that dramatic. edit: ahh the 42% stat was from 1965, not 1999 like the rest of the information.
- idhypueijk 6y agoThat data makes it seem that cancer is highly associated with corpulence.
- jpcooper 6y agoI always thought Francis Bacon was a decent chap. The artist, that is.
- drannex 6y agoEvery time another post comes up about this I hate to the bearer of bad (good?) news, but the entire concept is predicated on the fact that it increases risk of colorectal cancer by 18%. That doesn't mean your chance of cancer is 18%, that means your chance of that type of cancer goes from below 5% (4.3% for men, and 4% for women)[1] to <5.07%. A change of at the most .9% difference risk. Colorectal is also one of most treatable, and curable cancers there are. And this isn't just bacon, this is for all processed meats, to reduce your chance you would have to eliminate all processed meat for a reduction of less than 1% in your chance at that specific type of cancer. I hate to compare anything to tobacco, but smoking tobacco increases your risk of cancer not by 18%, but 2,500%. To quote a Wired article on this very topic that keeps getting rehashed [2]: > The IARC is an organization of scientists, not policy makers. It publishes monographs to identify hazards and sift them into five piles: group 1 (carcinogenic), group 2A (probably carcinogenic), group 2B (possibly carcinogenic), group 3 (not classifiable), and group 4 (probably not carcinogenic.) Group 1 includes processed meat, and also asbestos. Also alcohol (boo!) and sunlight (yup!). Identifying hazards involves looking at existing data—lots and lots of it—to do essentially a meta-analysis of studies already out there. And it’s relatively objective. “Hazard identification is the process that is the closest to the generation of scientific data,” say Paolo Boffetta, a cancer epidemiologist at Mount Sinai who has served on similar WHO panels. In other words, IARC studies the studies and generates numbers. > What the IARC doesn’t do—and where things get a lot fuzzier—is risk assessment, or figuring out the danger to humans in the real world. [1] https://www.cancer.org/cancer/colon-rectal-cancer/about/key-statistics.html https://www.cancer.org/cancer/colon-rectal-cancer/about/key-... [2] https://www.wired.com/2015/10/who-does-bacon-cause-cancer-sort-of-but-not-really/ https://www.wired.com/2015/10/who-does-bacon-cause-cancer-so... Edit: Added source for cancer risk and fixed my rounding mistake (5.9% -> 5.07%)
- pjc50 6y agoI think a big lesson of the COVID era is that people care about this kind of thing - statistical mortality - a lot less than you'd expect.
- dabbledash 6y agoAnd conversely that many people are willing to give up quality of life, perhaps indefinitely, to decrease risk. To state the obvious, there’s an inherent tension in the fact that some of the things that make life pleasurable increase the chances of cutting that life short. People reach different conclusions about how to strike the balance, and I don’t think there’s one right answer.
- Gibbon1 6y ago> People reach different conclusions about how to strike the balance, and I don’t think there’s one right answer. Yes Certainly. For instance if my dad had died of covid the decrease in my quality of life from that would have been permanently effected. Where yours had, your quality of life would be unchanged.
- NovaJehovah 6y agoI think it's mainly been an experiment in how much the average person will limit their own pursuit of happiness for the sake of lowering the mortality risk of others. The answer appears to be: to some extent, but there are limits. And I don't think that's new information. People do things all the time that involve some risk to others. They're more careful about risks to themselves and their families, but there are still limits. Anyone who smokes cigarettes or sometimes drives under the influence (massive numbers of people) already demonstrated that they're willing to inflict much higher degrees of risk on themselves and others than being lax on covid protocols would entail.
- snapetom 6y agoAs stated in the article, the core problem is nitrates/nitrites. This isn't a bacon-specific problem. It's a problem in all cured meats - hot dogs, SPAM, salami, etc. Fortunately, there's plenty of "uncured" bacon and hot dog options in grocery stores these days. You just have to read the packaging.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kevinmchugh 6y agoNote that lots of those products say "no added nitrites or nitrates except those naturally occurring" in other ingredients. And then one of the ingredients is celery powder, which is only added for its nitrates. It's awfully misleading packaging. If you're eating bacon and it tastes like bacon, it's cured.
- lol768 6y ago> If you're eating bacon and it tastes like bacon, it's cured. In Northern Ireland there's a producer (Finnebrogue) which sells nitrite-free bacon (no, it doesn't contain celery - "adding nitrites from vegetable extracts for a technological function and/or as a preservative, is banned by the European Union") . It's pretty decent, tastes like bacon. > The range replaces the nitrites commonly used to cure bacon and give them their recognisable colour with a Mediterranean fruit and spice extract it claims matches the shelf life of traditionally produced bacon and ham. They seem to be mostly useless at preventing Botlusim anyway: https://www.theguardian.com/food/2019/mar/23/nitrites-ham-bacon-cancer-risk-additives-meat-industry-confidential--report https://www.theguardian.com/food/2019/mar/23/nitrites-ham-ba...
- YeGoblynQueenne 6y ago>> It's pretty decent, tastes like bacon. What I've found is that peoples' tastes develop according to what we usually eat, so "tastes like bacon" is different if you're used to eating meats cured with nitrites, than what it would be if you didn't. I've said this story before on HN: in Greece, where I'm currently at, about 80% of the milk in supermarket refrigerated isles is UHT (Ultra Heat Treated). UHT milk doesn't need to be stored in a refrigerator, in fact that's the whole point. But, I guess, they [1] put it there so people will buy it thinking it's "fresh" (i.e. low-heat pasteurised and about a week old). The fact that so much of the milk sold in supermarkets is UHT -and so little is "fresh"- tells me that it basically works and people buy it. The interesting thing is that, if you ask Greeks whether they prefer "fresh" milk or UHT milk, the chances are they'll tell you they prefer "fresh" milk. There was a study at some point -sorry that I don't have a reference- that said I think that consumers around the EU, including Greeks, prefer "fresh" milk. Conclusion: at least Greeks drink UHT milk and have no idea it's UHT. ... even though it tastes distinctly unlike fresh milk. They're probably used to the taste and think that's what fresh milk tastes like. And don't let me get started on how most "fresh" milk doesn't taste of anything... ____________ [1] "They" is the dairy industry that ask for it - and the supermarkets that don't care and comply.
- tsdlts 6y agoI wonder why the conversation is all about avoiding nitrates and nitrites in bacon and never about avoiding celery, beets, radishes, chard, lettuce, spinach, etc. which contain far higher amounts. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6240834/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6240834/ Nice table: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6240834/table/table001/?report=objectonly https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6240834/table/t...
- bengale 6y agoIt is covered in the article that the problem is how it interacts with red meat.
- lordnacho 6y agoAccording to the article: " After all, nitrate is naturally present in many green vegetables, including celery and spinach, something that bacon manufacturers often jubilantly point out. As one British bacon-maker told me, “There’s nitrate in lettuce and no one is telling us not to eat that!” But something different happens when nitrates are used in meat processing. When nitrates interact with certain components in red meat (haem iron, amines and amides), they form N-nitroso compounds, which cause cancer. The best known of these compounds is nitrosamine. "
- shirakawasuna 6y agoPlease repeat this explanation but for me, a person who can't read.
- dimitrios1 6y agoCall me crazy but I've never considered eating bacon "safe" in as much as I considered eating a Ribeye "safe". Also who are these mythological deep bacon state actors convincing everyone eating bacon is safe? I question the premise of the subtitle. I went deep into the article searching for clues, but all the only substance there was some squabbles around nitrite based curing versus traditional salt curing.
- ping_pong 6y ago> But learning that consumption of processed meat causes an additional 34,000 worldwide cancer deaths a year is much more chilling. I'm sorry but 34,000 worldwide deaths a year is literally nothing. The US has over 30,000 auto deaths per year. Around the world, there are over 1 million auto deaths per year. If 34,000 deaths a year from processed foods is important, then there are many, many things that are a much easier way to save lives than getting rid of hot dogs and bacon.
- DoingIsLearning 6y agoYou are trying to draw usefulness from the article but the point of the article is not to inform but to generate anxiety and with it ad revenue. I remember reading a Cochrane Review meta-analysis confirming a link between processed meat consumption and recto-colon cancer, from memory this probably more than 10 years ago. None of this is new information. I am all for reducing meat consumption but these 'informational' articles from the guardian and often even the bbc and nyt should be banned as low-value adding submissions. Unless there are reporting about a recent major world event these sites have (in my opinion) no place in HN.
- tartoran 6y agoI stay away form processed meats as a genetal rule. I used to love processed meats when growing up especially lunchon pork meats, weiners, saussages and salamies but I almost stopped eating these altogether. I still do but very rarely and I think it’d be better to eat less of processed foods in general. Over the years I started lowering my food portions such that Im not full when finishing a meal, the satiety feeling follows shortly after. This has had very good effects on my stomach in particular
- 1-6 6y agoI was a bit curious about nitrate/nitrite sources and I was surprised to find them in everyday foods including vegetables. After some Google searches, fermented veggies do have less nitrate/nitrite content when compared to their raw counterpart. Cheers to Kimchi and Sauerkraut!
- shalmanese 6y agoExcept Kim Chi has been linked to gastric cancer: https://en.goodtimes.my/2019/06/04/eating-kimchi-increases-the-risk-of-cancer-studies-show-a-positive-link-between-pickled-food-stomach-cancer/ https://en.goodtimes.my/2019/06/04/eating-kimchi-increases-t... So less colon cancer, more stomach cancer.
- 1-6 6y agoInteresting, the reseachers were from Chungbuk Univ. too. I guess with everything, moderation is also key. Colonoscopies are pretty common in Korea so in general, you’ll catch more adenomas early on if you’re Korean. The docs in the US hardly send people to do colonoscopies and will give you a CT at best. So less colon cancer could be due to early intervention and snipping of adenomas.