9 ms·
Animation of a blue whale trying to avoid ships
- joncrane 6y agoI believe I saw this on reddit last week and I feel it's disingenuous. It's sped up and meant to make it look like the whale is frantically trying to escape while being hemmed in by ships, but a more plausible explanation is that the whale is attracted to the wakes of the passing ships. This speaks to some kind of phenomenon that creates a feeding opportunity for the whale. Perhaps a marine biologist can speak more intelligently to this.
- dukeofdoom 6y agoI took a ferry once, and the Seagulls followed the ship and prayed on the fish stirred up to the surface by the ships propeller. This is a very plausible explanation.
- arendtio 6y agoIf the whale would want to follow a ship he would do that. Instead the pattern looks more like he bounces off as soon as he comes close to a ship. Looks more like he wants to avoid ships. Seagulls on the other hand, have a very different pattern. They also use ships to rest on them and tend to travel along side.
- atoav 6y agoI am not a marine biologist, but worked in VFX: Of course this is sped up, watching those ships travel their routes in realtime would be a bit like watching paint dry. Certain aspects/patterns of movement will only become visible when the playback speed is changed (early 20th century theorist Walter Benjamin called this the Optical-Unconscious). So e.g. it is easier to judge patterns in the traffic flow of vehicles in a sped up video than in real time footage. Both display the same movement but something else becomes visible.
- darkerside 6y agoThe choice of speed seems consciously intended to make it seem more frantic than it is. It's too fast to make out what's going on. If they played it half speed, it would be closer to reality and also easier to see and understand, so why is it this fast?
- atoav 6y agoOr this was the speed things came out when converted to video. I think attributing this to malice is really not a great move, given that we can only guess here and a lot of people without advanced video knowledge wouldn't make this a conscious choice unless it is much too slow or fast
- dan-robertson 6y agoAnother simple hypothesis: a frantic-looking animation is more likely to get upvoted on Reddit so if 5 people posted animations at different speeds, a frantic-looking one might have a better chance at surviving
- darkerside 6y agoI often default to arguments like this. But I make an exception when the mistake is both inaccurate and seems to favor the conclusion chosen by the author. They should have realized this and slowed the video to avoid even the appearance of attempting to create a false implication. In my opinion.
- darkerside 6y agoThat's why I say "seems" instead of "was". I don't want to assume it's on purpose. But I'm sure they had control over the speed of the animation. If they didn't make it look frenetic on purpose, they were incompetent in their attempt to make it describe reality. If they didn't mean it to seem that way, the responsibility is on them to fix it. This is only my opinion, but I'm sure I'm not alone.
- WORMS_EAT_WORMS 6y agoI saw it too there. Another commented suggested that it actually might be following to these points/paths as the ship stirs krill or used as distance markers or something. I don't really know if I believe that and haven't had a chance to read the associated study. To be fair, the ocean is a big place so I am a bit skeptical overall. I do know though, anything from the independent.co.uk URL is almost guarenteed to be heavily sensationalized. Always the most outlandish and emotional headlines. So if it's running here, my first instinct is to just move along.
- notjtrig 6y agoThe ocean is a big place but the animation is a congested area near Chile about 35x35 miles. I've never sailed the golf of Ancud but in the summer on Long Island Sound in a sailboat you might have to change course 5-10 times a day or more due to traffic, and there not a lot of it. If you don't see the informal lanes and you're trying to keep away from boats, you could spend the day taking evasive action. My location relative to other boats is the top thing on my mind out there.
- shkkmo 6y agoThe conditions the encourage whale feeding and an analysis of current models for whale movement was the purpose of the study was discussed in the study that collected the data the animation is based on. Our current best understanding is that whales are drawn to the region due to a thermal fronts in the water and concentrations of chlorophyll (from their food source) that make it easy for the whales to feed efficiently. If this is a topic that you are curious about, give reading the study a try. I don't think "armchair science" from people that don't bother to read the source material adds much value to any discussion.
- bartread 6y ago> ...and I feel it's disingenuous. I think you're probably right. Unfortunately that does accurately sum up the quality of reporting in The Independent pretty well. Every newspaper in the UK has an axe to grind but, in terms of torturing the facts to suit a particular narrative, The Independent is right up there with The Daily Mail and The Express. All of them are really shoddy publications that thoughtful human beings would do well to avoid. I also am not a marine biologist but your explanation sounds more plausible to me, especially given the size of the area represented on that map. The whale is covering pretty large distances and it's quite clear that a bunch of those movements, and oddly a lot of those where the motion seems to speed up, may well not be triggered at all by the distant movement of ships, or could just as well be it trying to catch up to ships.
- partingshots 6y agoAre there any reputable news publications you read? Subscription required is fine.
- bartread 6y agoUnfortunately I can't answer that with a strong "yes". I've been considering the FT, based on a couple of recommendations (one of which was on here), but you have to go in with your eyes open: it does lean right. Newsweek isn't too bad, and the fact that it's a weekly does give it at least the sense of a bit more distance and objectivity. The BBC is supposed to be balanced and unopinionated but they implement it in the most passive-aggressive way imaginable. What I mean by that is that sometimes their coverage simply has massive holes in it, which makes it very hard to keep abreast of unfolding events (bear in mind I don't watch the TV channels, only look at the news website). I presume that's because they won't report on something if it would give them impression of bias, but it can be pretty frustrating. A recent example is the attack on the US Capitol: the BBC's coverage was constantly out of date, missing tons of key information. CNN, The Guardian, plenty of other news sites across the political spectrum, and even Twitter (!) were better sources of information. Basically the BBC, at present, implements the letter of its charter whilst completely ignoring its spirit. Super-annoying.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- scubazealous 6y agoDisclaimer: Not a marine biologist by trade but took several classes and have close friends in the profession. What people do not realize is that these whales communicate by sound and have very sensitive hearing. Boats, especially the larger ones you see being used for fishing/shipping generate a lot of noise due to powerful engines and underwater cavitation caused by their propeller spinning. This can drown out whales communications between pods. Researchers are not sure what the long term ramifications of this will be but have observed whales avoiding shipping lanes[0]. It worries me how other marine life, which we do not have the same resources or public support to track, reacts to this. Lastly, here is a video of a scuba diver underneath a freighter to give an idea of what goes on underwater. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QIPMfHUIVvk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QIPMfHUIVvk [0]https://www.nbcnews.com/sciencemain/shipping-lanes-are-getting-too-noisy-whales-coastal-survey-shows-8C11453571 https://www.nbcnews.com/sciencemain/shipping-lanes-are-getti...
- scubazealous 6y agoI was trying to think of an analogy and came up with this: imagine trying to complete grocery shopping in a large store except all the other shoppers are blasting air horns constantly. Of course, you avoid them but it does not matter which aisle you escape to, another shopper will enter and you will need to find another place to avoid the sound. Its a weird analogy but is the closest to normal life I can come up with.
- kortilla 6y ago> Boats, especially the larger ones you see being used for fishing/shipping generate a lot of noise due to powerful engines and underwater cavitation caused by their propeller spinning. A couple of things. First, that video shows you how relatively quiet the ships are unless you are right underneath the back. You can’t even hear the engine noise towards the front of the ship (which is likely why a ship the size of a city block snuck up on a scuba diver). Second, propellers on those ships don’t cavitate unless they are misconfigured. Cavitation is inefficient and causes vibration the shipping companies are absolutely incentivized to eliminate. There are many problems with commercial shipping (the pollution, etc), but the noise is not realistically one of them. The much bigger noise problem is sonar.
- imtringued 6y ago> It's sped up and meant to make it look like the whale is frantically trying to escape while being hemmed in by ships, When I watched the video at full speed I thought: this whale doesn't give a damn if there are other ships nearby When I watched the video at 1/10 speed my opinion didn't change. Except the video was boring. You are reading too much into this video.
- ajnin 6y agoI witnessed an interesting phenomenon : invariably when information is presented from some article that hints at either animal intelligence or harmful influence of humans on animals, some armchair commentator will come forward with an alternate explanations that reduces the observed behaviour to a basic mechanistic instinct related to feeding or reproduction or survival. That comment will also be the most upvoted one. The commentator does not present additional information, but for some reason his opinion is given more value than that of the experts who wrote the original study. That phenomenon is particularly prevalent on Reddit.
- kortilla 6y ago> The commentator does not present additional information The commentator pointed out that the video is literally sped up which changes the entire meaning. Have you considered this has nothing to do with hating animals and entirely to do with hating articles written to create drama and/or crisis where there is none?
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoThe commenter has unsubstabtiated opinion, no expertiese and has brought no extra factual information to support his point the discussion. Its literwlly just soreading FUD
- ajnin 6y agoThe fact that the video is sped up is not new information. It is immediately known when you watch it, it says that the video shows a week in the life of a whale yet the video lasts only 45s. You can only pretend in bad faith that it is not immediately obvious that whales and boats don't travel at tens of thousands of kilometers per hour across the ocean.
- olefoo 6y agoIt could be a collective defense mechanism. The idea of animal intelligence being a threat to what many people perceive as the necessary status quo of being able to endlessly consume the resources of nature without consequence.
- pvaldes 6y agoWhales can talk with other whales at several km. I'm unsure about what I'm seeing in the small scaled video, but there is not necessarily a physical collision here. A "Sonic wave collision" is much more probable. Also the ocean is a 3D mass of water. A sperm whale crossing the path of a ship could be perfectly at 800m of distance while doing it. (Probably not this particular case, I assume that the antenna can only work at surface, but we should take a look to the article methodology before to conclude that the whale is moving to avoid to crash with the ship).
- witherk 6y agoI'm open to an explanation. But, I think a lot of the effect of the animation is created by the dots representing the whale and ships being huge. In reality the dots would be tiny and almost never come into visible range of each other.
- ryeights 6y agoAnd the massive trails on the ships! What purpose does that serve other than to mislead?
- edoceo 6y agoI thought it was wake indicator or intended as a tracer
- runarberg 6y agoOn twitter they say it is an indicator of speed. If sound is the main culprit in deterring the whale from the natural pattern, then it makes sense for a faster moving ships to have a more dramatic visual weight. That is a whale should be just as stressed of hearing something loud come at it with a high speed as we would be at seeing something big come at us on high speed.
- hansvm 6y agoShipping noise can travel much further underwater than through the air. If the effect being shown is real then I wouldn't be shocked if sound were the culprit.
- ironmagma 6y agoFurthermore, vessel noise has been shown [1] to be significantly detrimental to several species of whale already. [1] https://www.sanjuanjournal.com/news/how-vessel-noise-affects-killer-whales/ https://www.sanjuanjournal.com/news/how-vessel-noise-affects...
- tgsovlerkhgsel 6y ago
- dynamite-ready 6y agoIt's sped up and edited, sure. But as (relatively) simple visualisations go, that was pretty emotional.
- mrfusion 6y agoMaybe more emotional than it needs to be though. In real time the whale would have hours or even days to get out of the way.
- TaylorAlexander 6y agoFolks in this thread are real quick to dismiss any concern for the animal and it’s habitat and that’s pretty sad. Is it so hard to believe human activity is harming these animals?
- imtringued 6y agoIt's very easy to believe and it has absolutely nothing to do with the speed and motion of ships and instead with the presence of sonar and engine and propeller noises.
- TaylorAlexander 6y agoWhat struck me about the data was how congested the area seems. We know about noise problems but I found the data very helpful in visualizing the size of the whales habitat compared to the quantity of boat traffic.
- ben509 6y agoIt's not an inability to believe it's true. It's more being burnt out by ritualized concern. It comes from seeing something awful that we're all supposed to be concerned about, listening to people beat their chest about it, and then the next day it's something else and those people have moved on to that and forgotten about yesterday's crisis.
- arminiusreturns 6y agoAmp built in without the normal way to remove it from the url and get a normal page!? No thank you, not worth viewing then. When did the independent start doing that?
- chordalkeyboard 6y agoDidn’t watch, took too long to load. Let this be a lesson to web developers.
- feanaro 6y agoI'm not actually able to find the animation in the article. Not a good source.
- Kuinox 6y agoIt's litteraly the first piece of content.
- swimfar 6y agoBut the last piece of content to load for me.
- Kuinox 6y agoUse uBlock origin and it will load right after the text of the article.
- sm4rk0 6y agoThere's just a black rectangle at the top of the page when opened with Firefox for Android or Firefox Klar (Focus for German-speaking countries, telemetry disabled by default) -- even with tracking protection off. Edit: turning uBlock Origin off helped!
- feanaro 6y agoIt wasn't loading for me. Disabling uBlock Origin didn't help either.
- sm4rk0 6y agoAlt source: https://twitter.com/ballenaschile/status/1356703048270249985 https://twitter.com/ballenaschile/status/1356703048270249985
- thegreyone 6y agoGlobalization is so unnatural. Humans need to learn to make do with what has been placed in their own, natural habitats. No more unnatural migration. No more globalization. It's killing the planet and all the bio-diversity nature has blessed us with. I can't imagine the terror this whale is experiencing. We need to learn to live within the confines of nature. That needs to be enough.
- mrfusion 6y agoWhat region is this? What does it look like in real time? It’s a bit misleading to speed it up 1000x.
- elSidCampeador 6y agoSurely ships' wakes don't go on for that long? What would the image look like if the tracers of the ships were reduced to a quarter of their size, which would be much closer to reality?
- runarberg 6y agoOn twitter they explain the tail represents speed, not wake. https://twitter.com/NiklasAstrand/status/1358321916369592321 https://twitter.com/NiklasAstrand/status/1358321916369592321
- economusty 6y agoSeems like the long trail on the ships is misleading, the whale arrived to the position of the ships long after they are gone.
- corobo 6y agoFuck me, Independent. I've not got all day. Want to load some content in at any point or are we just gonna get a few more random videos and other guff loaded in first?
- matt-attack 6y agoI think to properly interpret this, you’d need to see a control case where the same whale is the same or similar area with zero ships. Do they normally just swim in that pattern? Perhaps that’s the normal manner in which they troll for krill.
- advisedwang 6y agoSadly I don't think we can get that control case without shutting down all shipping in a huge area.
- dredmorbius 6y agoShipping traffic is surprisingly concentrated into high-traffic sea lanes. Ships (like aircraft) follow least-energy, shortest-distance paths between economical (high-traffic) ports. The Southern Ocean in particular sees exceptionally little shipping traffic.
- learnstats2 6y agoI don't need a control case to observe that the whale's movement pattern at least identifies the drawn wakes.
- ornornor 6y ago“That’s horrible!” Most people say while reading this on their way to the sushi restaurant. We’re ruining the world for all living things (and ourselves but we don’t seem to have fully grasped it yet). I have nothing to add except that it’s very sad. I could say “quit buying fish if you’re at all concerned about the situation” but I expect to be downvoted to oblivion for stating such a radical idea.
- TaylorAlexander 6y agoPlenty of us are vegan and think human influence on animal habitats is horrible. I can’t tell if you’re projecting your own unwillingness to make change onto others.
- pvaldes 6y agoNon sequitur. Most (if not all) of those are clearly maritime traffic connecting two points of the shore in an endless loop, not fishing ships.
- Emendo 6y agoEach travelling ship leaves behind a tail that's much longer than what I would expect if it was meant to represent the wake. Does anyone know the significance of the tail?
- calylex 6y agoWhy do we get sensationalist articles on HN? Surely the reason this is interesting is not the animation quality. I really hope certain sites would not even appear due to their poor reputation score focusing sensationalism. Here is a few to name: quantamagazine.org, nautil.us masquerading as science journals phys.org masquerading as physics journal indepenedent.com, et al not masquerading as anything they are just crap
- annexrichmond 6y agoMaybe it's moving away from the ships after they realize they're competing too much for food
- Gustomaximus 6y agoCould it be krill or whatever food source are hemmed in by the sound of ships and the whale is following food. This might be more about krill than whales?