21 ms·
Why “Trusting the Science” Is Complicated
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- imperio59 6y agoPrediction of phenomena in a repeatable fashion is the hallmark of all good science. Very few of what pass for sciences today in our world, save for the sciences of chemistry and large parts of physics, have achieved such precision of prediction in the laws they have been able to come up with to describe the universe. Parts of Medicine largely fit the bill but other parts aren't yet that far along. Psychology and psychiatry are at best a crap shoot and do not have solutions that work for all, in a repeatable fashion. Economics and social "sciences" are at best a set of theories with varying degrees of merit or applicability but are mostly a set of opinions and authorities who like to argue with each other about their own pet theory. It's amazing how far humanity has come thanks to the advance of true science but it's important to not forget we have a long ways to go still.
- skizm 6y agoYou say that but the fact that dark patterns in games, apps, websites, and advertising are so effective would seem to contradict this. Also, a psychiatrist is an MD and completely different that a psychologist who usually has a PhD and is actually running experiments. That said, psychology does have a repeatability problem for sure. The sheer volume of papers submitted is so much noise that picking out the signal is a hard problem with no good solution at the moment.
- Robotbeat 6y agoScience is about the idea that ideas are tested by experiment (or more generally, some objective empirical validation ). Economics, while traditionally a scene of some combination of occasional mathematical rigor combined with ideological opinion, has as of late been going through an empirical renaissance of late. Economics is changing.
- redisman 6y agoTrust the scientific method.
- acidburnNSA 6y agoExactly this. The method should be highlighted and discussed. Statements like "we believe in science in this household" are weak. I wish we talked more about hypotheses and measurements than numbers of scientists in things like e.g. climate change. Then again as Alvin Weinberg wrote in the 1970s, there are questions that can be posed scientifically but whose definitive answers are beyond the normal scientific method to answer. He called this "trans-science"
- cloogshicer 6y agoIf I may add: And understand its limits. I think most people don't, and that's why it gets more and more religious. I think that's actually why conspiracy theories are on the rise, because both 'sides' are becoming more dogmatic. If someone reading this is curious and wants to learn more, I recommend getting books on theory of science.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- neonological 6y agoScience is the best method we have for interpreting reality but there is a huge and fundamental flaw that most people don't know about. Yes I am differentiating the scientific method and the politics surrounding science and saying there is a huge flaw in the method. The scientific method cannot actually Prove anything to be true. That's right. Nothing can actually be proven to be true with science. If you have a hypothesis it is fundamentally impossible with science to prove that the hypothesis is true. It is only possible to disprove the hypothesis. I'm not making this up from some obscure philosophical conjecture. See this quote from Einstein: "No amount of experimentation can ever prove me right; a single experiment can prove me wrong." Literally, all of Einsteins theories have never been proven to be true by science. This occurs because the domain for evidence is literally unknown. At any point in time someone can discover new evidence that can disprove a theory. Thus relativity will always be a target for disproof. What we do have is evidence supporting Einsteins theory but we currently (nor will we ever) have anything that can prove relativity to be True. Know the distinction. I feel "Science" is just a cover word. To truly understand the magnitude of this you need to rephrase the saying and get rid of the word "science": "It is fundamentally impossible to prove anything to be true in reality as we know it. Proof is the domain of maths and logic." Once you thoroughly understand this, then you will know the limits of science and why people always talk about "falsifying" things: Because like I said earlier "true-ifying" anything is fundamentally impossible in reality as we know it!
- rubyist5eva 6y agoIf someone is saying “the science is settled”, I immediately dismiss them. That’s how how science works, and when you use that phrase you are making a religious statement not a scientific one.
- Nursie 6y agoIs that never context dependent? What about in a rebuttal to flat-earth "Theory"?
- fatsdomino001 6y agoIt's better to use different language, like saying how we're exceedingly confident that the earth is round, rather than it being an absolute. Sort of like our confidence asymptotically approaches absolute but never actually reaches it. This is similar to Hume's argument for our belief that the sun will rise tomorrow. Obviously, we all believe (even flat-earthers) that the sun will rise tomorrow and we have much science to indicate this will continue to be the case for a long time. Still, that doesn't mean we can be 100% confident this is the case. It's frankly just exceedingly difficult to be 100% absolutely sure about anything, unless it's first order mathematics.
- betwixthewires 6y agoIn that conversation, nobody flat out says "the science is settled" because it is easy to explain the science behind the earth being round. No, "the science is settled" is only ever used as a way to end a discussion without explaining the details of one's position. Not that they're necessarily wrong, but just that they don't know the answers. It is always an attempt to end a conversation on an authoritative basis.
- notafraudster 6y agoI think sometimes it's out of recognition that the amount of effort required to convince someone -- who probably isn't even arguing in good faith -- of something sometimes exceeds the amount of effort required to dismiss them. Which is really sort of the main issue with ongoing discussions about settled topics (creationism, flat earth, young earth, anti-vax, etc.)... it's just miserable from a signal-to-noise POV
- zarkov99 6y agoTrust science, but, unfortunately, not scientists, many of who have shown to be just as capable of letting their biases override their reason as the rest of the unwashed masses.
- collyw 6y agoMy problem in the current pandemic is we are told to listen to scientists, who if they were honest would admit they don't know a great deal about what will happen. So we are getting a scientists opinion about things such as lockdown, for which there was practically no evidence (it's the fist time this experiment has been tried), just Neil Ferguson and his demonstrably wrong computer models and his opinion that lockdown is the way forward.
- giantg2 6y agoEven if we trust the science, the results of those experiments don't necessarily correspond to a political policy in a straightforward or 1-to-1 fashion. I think a lot of the science today is not easily reproducible, which makes it hard to trust.
- Proziam 6y agoI am not fond of the way people refer to science. It's common to see people say 'believe the science' as if science is a person making one specific claim. The scientific method is a process practiced by humans. Humans are prone to error and dishonesty depending on the circumstances. They are also able, on occasion, to make brilliant discoveries. I find the framing of conversations about science to be dishonest and intended to make one party in the discussion look like a fool.
- jennyyang 6y agoSometimes, the "science" is wrong. Everything from low-fat diets, to high sodium diets, to DDT, to MSG. Many of the things that we have literally been indoctrinated with have been fully wrong. Most recently, when the government, most especially the Surgeon General and even Fauci, told people that masks don't work. That infuriated me and they instantly lost credibility with me. And it caused a split in Americans where too many believed that masks didn't work, even after they changed their tune. It was absolutely unnecessary to lie and it killed people. So read the science. Listen to the science. But read up further, and make educated decisions. Don't just listen to "experts" blindly.
- redisman 6y agoScience is always wrong to begin with and it gets close to a correct answer with iteration. It’s actually not at all a solved problem how to communicate “science” to the public. Your comment is a perfect example of one of these annoying fallacies I see around covid messaging. Don’t you think they “changed their tune” because they got better data that showed that masks are helpful? You seem mad that they couldn’t conjure clinical data in early 2020 that showed that masks cut the transmission by X%
- OrangeMonkey 6y agoIn general, I think you are right. In this case, the person involved admitted in an interview with "The Street" 6/12/2020 that it was to keep the supply for healthcare workers. > "Well, the reason for that is that we were concerned the public health community, and many people were saying this, were concerned that it was at a time when personal protective equipment, including the N95 masks and the surgical masks, were in very short supply. And we wanted to make sure that the people namely, the health care workers, who were brave enough to put themselves in a harm way, to take care of people who you know were infected with the coronavirus and the danger of them getting infected."
- choward 6y ago> it was to keep the supply for healthcare workers I've heard this argument several times. I don't buy it at all. They could have instructed people to make their own masks especially since everyone was stuck at home. There is no shortage of fabric that I'm aware of. It also would have given manufacturers more time to produce masks. Also, it's not okay to lie to the public, especially if you're supposed to be non-political. They deliberately lied and didn't apologize. There's no way I can trust someone who does that. That's not how my brain works.
- cloogshicer 6y agoInteresting related fact: Meteorites (as in: Rocks falling from the Sky) were not acknowledged as real until 1803. Only then did a large meteorite shower in France give enough evidence for the general public to acknowledge their existence. Of course meteorites had fallen before and were even in people's homes (who just picked them up). But they were dismissed as conspiracy theories/hoax. However, please don't misunderstand this comment as me saying you should believe in flat-earth theories and similar nonsense.
- naniwaduni 6y agoAll sorts of things like this. Rogue waves essentially weren't believed to be possible until 1995. Conflating failure of imagination (lack of proposed mechanism) and impossibility is a rather common failure mode. Heck, it took a decade for biologists to just agree on the Hardy-Weinberg theorem!
- ufmace 6y agoIt feels to me like "science" has become something of a religion unto itself. We started out with the well and good ability of science and engineering to understand some things and produce revolutionary useful goods. Now it seems like other fields where such principles aren't really applicable have attempted to borrow the trappings of science in order to co-opt the trust that people have given it. The only time a phrase like "trust the science" starts to seem necessary is when this scheme has been found out, and somebody is trying to preserve it. Many of the big society-level issues that we grapple with are more properly questions of economics than science. It's more about how we choose to value various courses of action and potential consequences against each other, and there's rarely a clear, obvious, or simple answer. "Science" can only give us an estimate of what the results of a particular course of action might be, it cannot compare once against another and tell us with certainty which one is better. "Trust the science" is usually a rhetorical weapon used by a side that is attempting to show one particular potential outcome as the worst thing imaginable that must be avoided at all costs, but in reality there are rarely things that bad. I'd like to have a world where we can look at the actual science and economic costs of all choices and rationally debate exactly which road to take, but it sure feels like we're only moving further away from that world.
- amirkdv 6y ago> It feels to me like "science" has become something of a religion unto itself I think this is true but I doubt it's anything new. I think the fundamental similarity between religious belief and "trusting the science" is the psychological simplicity of delegation to authority, and probably a deep seated property of the human mind. Not knowing the right answer to questions we deem important, or worse the mental state of doubting what we've been raised to consider foundational and "obvious", is just too uncomfortable for the majority of people (I would've said all people, but I can't be sure).
- dmingod666 6y agoTrue, but the problem is that religion can not be questioned, changed or reasoned with in any meaningful way. Science can. If we lose this distinction between the 2, then we just end up with a new religion with more modern priests.
- marcodiego 6y agoScience is something you should use, learn, study but not trust or believe. If you're looking for something to believe, maybe religion is possibility, science should continually be tested. Science is important because you know it can be wrong. It evolves when mistakes or errors are found, not when it is confirmed.
- pella 6y agodifferent paradigms -> different results see: "Will COVID-19 be evidence-based medicine’s nemesis?" (June 30, 2020) https://journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/journal.pmed.1003266 https://journals.plos.org/plosmedicine/article?id=10.1371/jo... "Once defined in rhetorical but ultimately meaningless terms as “the conscientious, judicious and explicit use of current best evidence in making decisions about the care of individual patients” [1], evidence-based medicine rests on certain philosophical assumptions: a singular truth, ascertainable through empirical enquiry; a linear logic of causality in which interventions have particular effect sizes; rigour defined primarily in methodological terms (especially, a hierarchy of preferred study designs and tools for detecting bias); and a deconstructive approach to problem-solving (the evidence base is built by answering focused questions, typically framed as ‘PICO’—population-intervention-comparison-outcome) [2]. The trouble with pandemics is that these assumptions rarely hold. A pandemic-sized problem can be framed and contested in multiple ways. Some research questions around COVID-19, most notably relating to drugs and vaccines, are amenable to randomised controlled trials (and where such trials were possible, they were established with impressive speed and efficiency [3, 4]). But many knowledge gaps are broader and cannot be reduced to PICO-style questions. Were care home deaths avoidable [5]? Why did the global supply chain for personal protective equipment break down [6]? What role does health system resilience play in controlling the pandemic [7]? And so on." ... "It is surely time to turn to a more fit-for-purpose scientific paradigm. Complex adaptive systems theory proposes that precise quantification of particular cause-effect relationships is both impossible (because such relationships are not constant and cannot be meaningfully isolated) and unnecessary (because what matters is what emerges in a particular real-world situation). This paradigm proposes that where multiple factors are interacting in dynamic and unpredictable ways, naturalistic methods and rapid-cycle evaluation are the preferred study design. The 20th-century logic of evidence-based medicine, in which scientists pursued the goals of certainty, predictability and linear causality, remains useful in some circumstances (for example, the drug and vaccine trials referred to above). But at a population and system level, we need to embrace 21st-century epistemology and methods to study how best to cope with uncertainty, unpredictability and non-linear causality" "In a complex system, the question driving scientific inquiry is not “what is the effect size and is it statistically significant once other variables have been controlled for?” but “does this intervention contribute, along with other factors, to a desirable outcome?”. Multiple interventions might each contribute to an overall beneficial effect through heterogeneous effects on disparate causal pathways, even though none would have a statistically significant impact on any predefined variable [11]. To illuminate such influences, we need to apply research designs that foreground dynamic interactions and emergence. These include in-depth, mixed-method case studies (primary research) and narrative reviews (secondary research) that tease out interconnections and highlight generative causality across the system [16, 17]." .... "In the current fast-moving pandemic, where the cost of inaction is counted in the grim mortality figures announced daily, implementing new policy interventions in the absence of randomized trial evidence has become both a scientific and moral imperative. Whilst it is hard to predict anything in real time, history will one day tell us whether adherence to “evidence-based practice” helped or hindered the public health response to Covid-19—or whether an apparent slackening of standards to accommodate “practice-based evidence” was ultimately a more effective strategy."
- alexfromapex 6y agoI think about this all the time because of recent revelations about the micro biome. It was right under our noses but we assumed the clues were all in the human body’s own cellular machinery.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- TameAntelope 6y agoI feel like the author of this article is simplifying "falsifiability". Yes, it's not easy to identify, but getting unexpected results from an experiment, I don't think, has ever been the line. You have to understand those results as well, before you can interpret them, and while "understanding" is surely fuzzy, it's completely missing in his commentary, as if Popper suggested at any point that the moment something unexpected happens, the whole house of cards comes tumbling down. "Wobbly philosophy would become part of legal doctrine." It's only wobbly if you leave out large parts of it, as the author has... The title of the article suggested nuance, but I don't see much of it in the article itself. It seems as if the author attempted to take down a basic tenant of science, and feeling satisfied that he had, moved on to draw further conclusions that result. I don't think he succeeded in that set up, however, which makes the second half of the book review (the part about the actual book) less interesting or compelling.
- roelschroeven 6y agoMy feeling exactly. I stopped reading after a while because of it. He gives an example of a theory that's falsified, so it's clearly falsifiable! And yet it's not science! Well duh, if it's falsified it's obviously not correct. A robust theory is a theory that is falsifiable but isn't falsified even under heavy scrutiny.
- esotericn 6y agoThe scientific method does not give us a sort of monolithic, hierarchical entity, into which everyone collaborates and then an answer pops out from the top of the pyramid. That's the role that politics serves. To take into account all of the data we're given, think about outcomes across all scientific fields, take into account the opinion of the population and execute on it. I think that for the most part, snappy soundbites like "follow the science" are a result of social media and reactionaries breaking our normal, carefully considered methods of discourse. Physics tells us that the Universe has enough space for an unfathomable number of humans. Biology tells us that the conditions aren't there. Psychology tells us that even if they were, people wouldn't be happy plugged into capsules. Behavioural science tells us that, regardless of the other three, we might just have to work out a solution anyway, because we're gonna breed. Politicians... well, from what I can tell usually they just sort of do whatever they want and manipulate the population into wanting it. :)
- dba7dba 6y ago"Science is essentially what a few large donors or institutions or interest groups want to fund." Quote from a disillusioned researcher.
- undefined1 6y ago> proposed drinking bleach speaking of trust. here's a PSA for those, who like myself, had trusted the media and thought that happened: https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2020/jul/11/joe-biden/no-trump-didnt-tell-americans-infected-coronavirus/ https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2020/jul/11/joe-biden/...
- jonas21 6y agoSure, it's not quite correct -- what he actually proposed was injecting bleach, which is even worse. You can watch the entire press conference here [1]. The relevant portion, starting at 27:04, is: ----- Bill Bryan: We’re also testing disinfectants readily available. We’ve tested bleach, we’ve tested isopropyl alcohol on the virus specifically in saliva or in respiratory fluids and I can tell you that bleach will kill the virus in five minutes. Isopropyl alcohol will kill the virus in 30 seconds and that’s with no manipulation, no rubbing. Just spraying it on and leaving it go. You rub it and it goes away even faster ... Donald Trump: A question that probably some of you are thinking of if you’re totally into that world, which I find to be very interesting. So, supposing we hit the body with a tremendous, whether it’s ultraviolet or just very powerful light, and I think you said that hasn’t been checked, but you’re going to test it. And then I said supposing you brought the light inside the body, which you can do either through the skin or in some other way. And I think you said you’re going to test that too. Sounds interesting, right? And then I see the disinfectant, where it knocks it out in one minute. And is there a way we can do something like that by injection inside or almost a cleaning because you see it gets in the lungs and it does a tremendous number on the lungs, so it’d be interesting to check that so that you’re going to have to use medical doctors with, but it sounds interesting to me. ----- This matches my recollection of what was being reported at the time. The fact check you linked to is about a claim by Joe Biden, not a media report. [1] https://youtu.be/YqsGjWNXB2M https://youtu.be/YqsGjWNXB2M
- kbelder 6y agoI wonder why you posted that, since it shows him clearly not proposing injecting bleach. That quote shows him wondering if there is some way some disinfectant can be injected into the bloodstream to destroy the virus, and that it would be interesting for doctors to look into that. He was obviously told that UV light is a disinfectant that has been used to directly treat blood (which is true). I really dislike Trump, but I feel like I end up defending him quite often against people who are just completely uncharitable in their interpretations of everything he's ever said or done.
- throwawaysea 6y agoScience is a human process. Trusting the science means trusting humans. Research performed by humans has many opportunities for biases to slip in. There's no one monitoring or auditing raw data collection for example - whether that is measured observations in scientific research or survey data in social research. Most students also have poor statistical knowledge and make numerous mistakes in drawing their conclusion, and some even misstate their findings in more deliberate ways (like p hacking). Then there's the ecosystem around the people performing the science. Journals with poor review processes, magazines that publish headlines that lack the intended nuance/context, and so forth. The calls to "trust the science" also often extend beyond what the scientific material states. For instance, the science might tell us that the coronavirus poses a particular level of risk in terms of mortality. But deciding whether or not to react to that risk with heavy measures is still a human decision that crosses value systems, economic considerations, moral considerations, etc. Still, somehow you see people in social media or news media attaching the "science" label to their opinion on what must be done, even though that final consideration is an opinion or judgment call.
- dbtc 6y agoThe way I see it, science has nothing to do with trust (or faith). Or, if anything it is all about mistrust! When I trust a person, that means, even when I cannot possibly know, I still believe that they are telling the truth. I tell you the results of an experiment, you say, "ok, prove it," or "I'll see for myself." That's science. The rest is PR and politics. The royal society's motto: "nullius in verba" = "take nobody's word for it" but then, there are multiple meanings for "science", and I was only thinking of the method, not the institution or "scientific community", or even the body of knowledge that all get lumped together.
- 4eor0 6y agoTeach science, trust the students
- soloninja 6y agobetter said than done. I think the main issue with people is science changes a lot
- benbenolson 6y agoIt's worth noting that his tired claim-- that Trump suggested drinking bleach to cure COVID-- is false. He did not say this; at best, the author is willfully ignorant of his actual comments, and at worst, he's purposefully lying. Here are his full comments, so that readers may decide for themselves whether or not they believe this claim. "A question that probably some of you are thinking of if you’re totally into that world, which I find to be very interesting. So, supposedly we hit the body with a tremendous, whether it’s ultraviolet or just very powerful light, and I think you said that hasn’t been checked, but you’re going to test it. And then I said supposing you brought the light inside the body, which you can do either through the skin or in some other way. (To Bryan) And I think you said you’re going to test that,too. Sounds interesting, right?" "And then I see the disinfectant, where it knocks it out in one minute. And is there a way we can do something like that, by injection inside or almost a cleaning, because you see it gets in the lungs and it does a tremendous number on the lungs, so it’d be interesting to check that, so that you’re going to have to use medical doctors with, but it sounds interesting to me. So, we’ll see, but the whole concept of the light, the way it kills it in one minute. That’s pretty powerful." Then, later, after asked directly by a reporter if he meant that people should inject disinfectants: "It wouldn’t be through injections, almost a cleaning and sterilization of an area. Maybe it works, maybe it doesn’t work, but it certainly has a big effect if it’s on a stationary object."
- hackeraccount 6y agoI think the general belief is that it never hurts to beat a kind - they're either coming from trouble or going to it. Or as the Russians say, "When you see an Uzbek punch him - he'll know why."
- flying_kiwi 6y agoThis is a _ridiculously_ charitable interpretation. These comments were immediately following other presenters talking about success in sterilising surfaces in hospitals etc. "bringing the [powerful surface-sterilising UV] light inside the body" and "injection inside or a cleaning [of, again, powerful surface disinfectant]" is a five-year-old's idea of how stuff works. And "oh it wouldn't be through injections, almost a cleansing and sterilization of an area" - what does that even _mean_? Clearly just backtracking once people started making fun of how dumb the original statement is.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoI saved this HN comment from a few months ago, it helps remind me why the subject of science gets difficult to communicate when humans don’t have real or ethical means to randomly control variables: “ Correlations are a profound part of our universe. When observing the universe, humans can never prove any facts about the universe. We can only establish correlations. Correlations between events that occur in our universe is the furthest "truth" we can establish about the universe short of a full on proof. What this means is that nothing in the physical universe can be proven. Proof is the domain of maths and logic, correlations is the domain of science. Science cannot prove anything, it can only establish correlations and causations. The reason this occurs is because at any time in the future one can observe an event that contradicts a hypothesis. You can hypothesize that all birds have wings and observe 2 trillion birds with wings but you never know when one day you'll observe a bird without wings disproving your entire hypothesis. That is why nothing can be proven, you can only correlate things through observation. The other interesting part about correlation is what it isn't: Causation. People often talk about how correlation is not causation but people never talk about what causation is and how to establish it. If I can't empirically use correlation to establish causation how on earth is causation ever formally established? People rarely question this disconnect. The fact is, causation is rarely formally established but a method does exist and it's subtle. If I observe that whenever Bob flicks a switch the light comes on then I established that the light coming on is correlated with Bob flipping the switch. This is as far as I can go with just observation. To establish causation I must make myself both an observer and an entity that is part of the system itself. I have to take control and flip the switch randomly and observe that when I don't flip the switch nothing happens and when I do flip the switch the lights come on. By doing this I establish causation. To establish causation to higher and higher degrees I need to Cause (keyword) random events and make sure that a cause influences an effect AND absence of a cause and therefore absence of an effect occurs. Also note that establishing causation is not proof. At any point in time in the future I can flip the switch and the light may not come on which is contradictory evidence for causation. Causation in the statistical sense is like correlation, you establish it to a degree of confidence but you can never Prove A caused B. Note that there are ways to test causal hypotheses without intervening. For example, suppose we wish to test the hypothesis that smoking causes lung cancer via the main mechanism of tar buildup in the lungs, against the alternative hypothesis that smoking is correlated with lung cancer because of a gene that predisposes people to both smoking and lung cancer (this example comes from Judea Pearl’s Book of Why). If the former hypothesis is true, then we should see a correlation between smoking behavior and tar deposits, and we should also see a correlation between tar deposits and lung cancer even after controlling for smoking behavior. Composing the causal effects at each stage, we can then calculate the indirect causal effect of smoking on lung cancer. If this suffixes to explain the correlation, then that rules out the alternative genetic explanation for the correlation. Of course, we can always propose ad-hoc further hypotheses that complicate the analysis: maybe the correlation between smoking and tar deposits is itself non-causative, etc. This only goes to show that scientific inquiry must be done with judgment and with expert domain knowledge, testing plausible hypotheses in good faith. But that’s true for detecting mere correlations too — we can always doubt our instruments, or claim the data is a statistical fluke. And it’s true in randomized controlled trials: it’s conceivable we didn’t properly randomize, for example. * This (causation as correlation) revelation was highlighted by Hume and this and other work by him had profound influence on Kant (famously awaking him from his "dogmatic slumbers") and scientists like Darwin and Einstein - the latter obviously in a more healthy scientific age when those at the forefront of physics were not so disdainful of philosophers. “
- AzzieElbab 6y ago‘Trusting the Science’ is mostly used by people who can’t write a line of code in python or figure out basics of linear algebra. It is scientism not science, just cherry picking theories to support politicised narratives
- mcguire 6y agoThat's what the anti-climate-change folks keep telling us.
- AzzieElbab 6y agoPeople who doubt that we are all going to die in 12 years are not anti-climate change folks
- hackeraccount 6y agoI remember reading Stephan Jay Gould writing about multiple magisteria - science and religion. That you shouldn't use one in the domain of the other. It struck me as idealistic because there's another magisteria that he didn't mention. Politics. Politics looks at science and religion and sees a precious and innocent teenager. It smiles and nods and knows that it can grab either or both, hand it a gun and it will happily run out to do whatever it's manipulated into doing. My personal definition of politics is "help your friends and hurt your enemies." Anytime I read an argument from a disinterested source - science or religion - and the end result is one or both of those things I get suspicious. It's not to say I don't agree with it. Frequently you need to one, the other or both but once it's a question of politics you have to think about the issue in political terms. You have to consider about compromises that have nothing to do with science or religion.
- biztos 6y ago> help your friends and hurt your enemies That, in turn, seems ripe for exploitation by the not insignificant set of people who see politics as simply a route to power.
- throwanem 6y agoPolitics is a route to power. It is only that. Its virtue, inasmuch as it has one, is that when properly performed it involves no violence, or at least much less violence than any other route to power commonly encountered in human history.
- _tom_ 6y agoI recommend the book "Wrong", which talks about a number of failings in our current research system, why invalid results persist, and how people game the system to get the results they want. https://www.amazon.com/Wrong-us-Scientists-relationship-consultants/dp/0316023787 https://www.amazon.com/Wrong-us-Scientists-relationship-cons...
- pdimitar 6y agoScience is about facts. Modern scientific articles have been often fluff opinionated pieces. It's extremely normal not to believe in the morally twisted, incomplete, politically-charged, with perverse incentives and written in a clickbait language modern scientific journalism. I am not doubting the unbiased science. But I can't find it almost anywhere.
- nradov 6y agoScience is about probabilities, not facts.
- TeeMassive 6y agoIf you trust science then you are not doing science, by definition. The scientific process is an ever self-critical experiment of additions and improvements. Trusting the scientists for questions of policy is just plain folly that has led to disastrous consequences.
- mcguire 6y agoAbsolutely! Policy should be set by Ouija board.
- TeeMassive 6y agoNice strawman. I'm just saying, science doesn't tell you what policies you should make, ever. That's not what it is about. There are a few countries who "believed in science" and believing "things should be as nature is", that didn't end very well.
- craigc 6y ago“Trust the science” in the age of Covid is more or less a euphemism for “Fall in line and don’t question what the ’experts’ say”. When you look at what has happened to people who have questioned things such as lockdowns and mask wearing, it makes it even less likely that more will. Some have been fired from their jobs, banned or censored on social media, demonetized on YouTube, etc. We should always encourage people to question things and think outside the box because that is the only way we make progress. The speed at which people shoot down competing ideas and ideas they don’t like in this day and age is very dangerous especially when the “experts” we are listening to often have financial incentives to keep things working the way they are. This article is pretty good on the surface, but I wanted to point out that terms the author uses such as “climate change denialism” and “anti-vaxxer” are themselves derogatory terms meant to attack and demean people who question official established scientific narratives. For example, Robert F. Kennedy was recently banned from Instagram for his views on vaccines. It is the mainstream consensus that he is an “anti-vaxxer”, but if you actually read what he writes and watch videos where he talks, all he wants is transparency and accountability for big pharmaceutical companies who have rushed Vaccines to market with minimal testing, have legal indemnity against lawsuits due to emergency use authorizations, and stand to make many billions of dollars in profits. I urge people to read this post from him: https://childrenshealthdefense.org/defender/robert-kenney-jr-instagram-removal-account/ https://childrenshealthdefense.org/defender/robert-kenney-jr... I hope one day we will be able able to speak our minds once again without worrying about the repercussions
- abernard1 6y ago"Science is the belief in the ignorance of experts". - Richard Feynman [1] The problem trusting the "Science" has is that the moment we anoint an institution of people as the holders of truth, we diminish lower-case "science", which is the activity useful for determining truth in an objective way. [1] http://www.feynman.com/science/what-is-science/ http://www.feynman.com/science/what-is-science/
- ghoward 6y agoI read: > We might require that they have reasonable arguments concerning the theory or data’s flaws that do not presuppose, as some anti-vaccine arguments do, the existence of a large-scale conspiracy to distort the truth. Fair enough. Then the _very next sentence_, I read: > And we would be well within our rights to demand that they argue in good faith and not...as professional water-muddiers, following a playbook first written by cigarette companies attempting to obfuscate a known connection between smoking and cancer. Wait, we're not allowed to muddy the waters with allegations of conspiracies, and yet, it is admitted that conspiracies exist? I mean, not just the tobacco industry, but HN just discussed a conspiracy by the sugar industry. (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26126183 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26126183) I understand that strong allegations require strong evidence. But to say that strong allegations will be dismissed even though the evidence is strong is an admission of being disingenuous. Also, "science" is the process, not the body of Knowledge or the consensus. (https://gavinhoward.com/2019/11/what-science-is/ https://gavinhoward.com/2019/11/what-science-is/) On top of that, people will often test only one factor, such as the effectiveness of double masks in blocking aerosols, and then claim that since double masks are better, we should all wear two masks. But that ignores the other factors. In science, _true_ science, all factors matter! (https://gavinhoward.com/2020/08/in-science-all-factors-matter/ https://gavinhoward.com/2020/08/in-science-all-factors-matte...) They matter even if they don't because you _never know_ if they actually matter until you test them. And to go even further, why in the world should we trust the scientific consensus when in the face of all of the scandals in the scientific community? Besides the outright (admitted) lies, or the failure of "experts" or "scientists" to be apolitical, there are two more scandals: the Replication Crisis and the Retraction Crisis. (https://gavinhoward.com/2019/12/replication-and-retraction-crises-in-science/ https://gavinhoward.com/2019/12/replication-and-retraction-c...) "Trusting the Science" is not complicated; it's impossible. Trusting the _process_ of science, going so far as to learn statistics, how to read scientific papers, and to test hypotheses for yourself, is hard but not too complicated. And it is what I do.
- stall84 6y agogod finally an article with some moderated sense! I'm beyond sick of seeing social media posts and politicians (most recently here in GA) touting they "follow the science".. As if 'the science' is some monolithic book of f*cking truth that one can 'choose' to read from.
- akhilcacharya 6y agoWhat set of tradeoffs do you see as being better to follow then?
- ThomPete 6y agoTrusting the science is meaningless and more akin to scientism, a kind of religion. Science says very little about the things we actually care about.
- phoinix 6y agoExactly that. Science can never tell us what is a worthy purpose to pursuit. Say for example we want to decapitate all of the HN crowd. Science provides us, with overwhelming evidence that an axe is the way to go, and not say a fork. Anyone who disagrees with it, the decapitating of the HN crowd with an axe, is not against science. There is a hidden presupposition that we all want to decapitate the HN crowd, and that is the purpose we all are pursuing. The purpose of making a 90 year old person live another 2 years, i am not sure we are all pursuing it. Is there a scientific evidence that there is a way for that 90 year old man to live another 2 years? I bet there is. However who said that is a worthy endeavor to invest money and time on? Well the proponents of the Covid hoax, that's who. However science provides us with an infinity of evidence, that we didn't do even that, in any country. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uNKn5d_yUrg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uNKn5d_yUrg
- TedShiller 6y agoAlso, consensus science is BS. If it's science, there does not need to be any consensus for something to be true. It's not like science is evaluated democratically. Unless, of course, the science says something nobody likes to admit is true.
- umvi 6y agoWell what if the science is still developing and is extremely complex and the predictive models require petabytes of data and supercomputers and expert interpretation? Like, say, with climate change. Doesn't seem like there's an easy way for an individual scientist to take in all that info and make accurate predictions. Hence groups of scientists reach a "consensus" of what the current best interpretation of the complexity is. The consensus might still be wrong, but at least it signals "all the experts are currently thinking the data means X, Y, Z"
- lmm 6y ago> Well what if the science is still developing and is extremely complex and the predictive models require petabytes of data and supercomputers and expert interpretation? Then the public and policymakers should be aware that there isn't a consensus. If there are question marks about a lot of points of detail, then we can't just average everyone and then be confident in the result of that.
- renewiltord 6y agoThe scientific consensus is so that the guy who doesn't want to know the details can see what most experts believe. That's a perfectly reasonable way to develop knowledge if you weight it correctly. It's like when I want a TV, I want it to be big enough and show a nice enough picture. I just go to Wirecutter. I don't go buy and return a bunch of TVs till I'm content. That's because I've only got 80 years on this Earth. No one who uses first principles experiments for anything is capable of forming higher-level hypotheses. Heck, I've never even really formally tested if rain causes the roads to be wet.
- techbio 6y agoTangentially related, political science is not science.
- ankurdhama 6y agoThere is no such thing as "the science". Science doesn't say anything, people say thing. You don't follow science, you follow what some people said in their research. The world needs to understand that science is nothing but a set of guidelines/principles to discover knowledge and it is up-to the people to follow them properly or cut corners and let their biases take over.
- 6nf 6y agoScience tells us what is true, it does not tell us what to do about it. What to do is up to people - we need to get together and look at the situation and the trade-offs and agree on a way forward. 'Trust the science' is a lame excuse for not engaging with the discussion.
- tux1968 6y agoScience is a process for inspecting and then describing phenomenon. It does not say what is true, it only does its best to accurately and meticulously describe reality. It does not, and can not, know if it has missed something, or if the things it has described will be changed by nature tomorrow and invalidate everything that went before. The results of the scientific process are always provisional and subject to revision. We need to be humble about what science can actually achieve. Yes, it's the absolute best humans can do given the limitations of our senses and no signed contract from the universe to always behave as it did yesterday. But we need to stop treating the "facts" it produces as divine revelation that we can beat the congregation into submission with.
- sega_sai 6y agoI disagree with this claim in the article: "Not all falsifiable claims, then, are scientific, and not all scientific claims are falsifiable. How would one directly test the Big Bang Theory, which seeks to explain the origins of the universe?" I think all useful scientific claims must be falsifiable. And the Big Bang theory is falsifiable as it made predictions of the Cosmic Microwave background. But overall, for sure, boundaries what's scientific or non-scientific are a bit fuzzy. And Popper criterion is not the only criterion for definition whether something is scientific or not. But still I think they key point is making verifyiable predictions.
- every 6y ago"I believe that only scientists can understand the universe. It is not so much that I have confidence in scientists being right, but that I have so much in non-scientists being wrong." --- Isaac Asimov
- CivBase 6y agoScience is a process. I repeat: science is a process. It is not a collection of special knowledge. It is not "truth". It is not the opinion of some expert or group of experts. Science is a process. I get so sick of people talking about "trusting science". What they always seem to mean is "trusting some specific scientist or group of scientists". At this point I'm inherently cynical regarding anyone who claims to have "science" on their side. Science is a process for establishing trust in an idea. It is a process for evaluating theories. It is a process for creating evidence. Science is a process.
- max_ 6y agoMost people don't know these process. The notion of what science exactly is, and how to use it isn't even taught in schools. (Stuff like Popper's falsification techniques) As a result people find that the only way they can verify information is through appealing to authority, which of cause manipulates them to their own will.
- nmaleki 6y agoI can further clarify that process by saying "Science is the evolution of answering questions."
- tgv 6y agoYes, but ... there are degrees of trustworthiness. Results in physics tend to be very trustworthy and can withstand time well. On the other end of the spectrum, there are academic disciplines that have little more to offer than opinions. And there's a lot in between. You can only trust a discipline to the degree it has shown to be trustworthy. That, of course, says nothing about trusting individuals or daring new hypotheses, which is what the article seems to address rather pointlessly, with some hand-waiving, and avoiding the difficult issues: you might want to apply the proposals to physics, precisely because it is so trustworthy, but probably not to the other disciplines.
- adrianb 6y agoWhat worries me the most is when people use the phrase "a majority of experts agree that..." and imply that is the absolute truth. It's not. A majority of experts, in their day, agreed that the sun is rotating around the earth. A majority of experts agreed that time and space are absolute. And since it's trendy these days to declare absolute medical truths, a majority of experts agreed that disease is caused by imbalances of bodily fluids and that bloodletting is the cure to any disease.
- greypowerOz 6y agosurely the big picture for "trust the science" is not "science is always right" (as the writer notes,) but that the PROCESS of testing and revising scientific theories can be trusted. As sabine hossenfelder says.. science doesn't tell you not to pee on electric fences, it just points out that urine is a decent conductor of electricity... (or words to that effect) I trust the "best available science"... as a rule. (YMMV)
- collyw 6y agoScience should have nothing to do with "trust".
- nathias 6y agoWhen you politicize truth in discourse bad things tend to happen.
- kgin 6y agoIt's not "trust the science because it is 100% correct all the time and will never steer you wrong" It's "trust the science more than guessing because at any given moment, it has a much greater chance of giving you useful information than guessing". Science is the least bad way we have of learning true things (or at least useful approximations of truth) about the world.