8 ms·
You should always be very suspicious when a team of archeologists with a TV production team finds something new and revolutionary on the exact topic they were m
by londons_explore 6y ago
You should always be very suspicious when a team of archeologists with a TV production team finds something new and revolutionary on the exact topic they were making a TV program about...
Seems a bit too convenient!
Especially when the evidence is a muddy hole nearly the same shape and size as a rock 150 miles away...
Oh, and look - it just so happens to be on the only farm you could get permission to dig on!
- kijin 6y agoThe article doesn't say that the TV crew surreptitiously discovered the hole. It's just as likely that archeologists unaffiliated with BBC came up with this theory months or even years earlier, wanted funding and a bit of publicity for their pet project, got hooked up with BBC, and scheduled the most important part of the excavation to coincide with the arrival of the TV crew as per the funding agreement. The whole point is to maximize the likelihood that an interesting discovery will take place during filming. NatGeo does this all the time, and I'm sure BBC does, too.
- tim333 6y agoYeah some info: (from https://www.irishmirror.ie/tv/extraordinary-stonehenge-discovery-unveiled-historians-23486093 https://www.irishmirror.ie/tv/extraordinary-stonehenge-disco...) Professor Mike says he had long held the theory that the smaller bluestones which surrounded Stonehenge in a wide circle during its earliest phase, had started life as a monument in Wales. But finding the site of a stone circle which no longer exists, 5,000 years after it was moved, is no mean feat. The research started in 2010, with excavations beginning in 2012 but as they years went by they experienced many set-backs involving bronze and iron age circles which weren’t what they were looking for. Mike, 63, did a deal with a TV company to film their progress in 2015. Two years later, it was a despondent group led by Dave Shaw, who decided to excavate Waun Mawn, an “unpromising” marshy site described as “small and unremarkable” which had turned up nothing in the geophysics surveys. ... [goes on to describe finding it]
- dmurray 6y ago> surreptitiously serendipitously?
- kijin 6y agoUh, yeah. I wonder what kind of typo triggered an autocorrect into that word...
- wswope 6y agoI'm finding this whole comment thread a bit hard to read, because this is at least the third Stonehenge special Mike Pearson has done with the BBC at this point, not to mention plenty of appearances on Time Team. You're pretty spot on - this is a well-known archaeologist with an established record as a television presenter. From what I remember of the previous Stonehenge specials, the filming process appeared to be: academic research team does the excavation for a few months, camera crew comes in when a "big moment" is expected, and also films a rollup where the researchers talk over exciting discoveries made in the past months while they're there. They've been digging near Stonehenge and on associated sites along the river for years and years.
- simonh 6y agoOh and look there just happen to be several bluestones that geologically match the ones at Stonehenge still on the site, and radiocarbon dating puts the site a few hundred years older than Stonehenge so the timeline happens to line up perfectly. How convenient! I'm not saying I believe them for sure, but yours is in no way a fair characterisation.
- throwawaylolx 6y ago>radiocarbon dating puts the site a few hundred years older than Stonehenge Is it really that reliable to make such precise statements?
- simonh 6y agoSamples at the site were dated to around 3400 BC, which is 400 years earlier than the earliest samples from Stonehenge. Ive not seen the papers, but given standard techniques I expect there should be at least a couple of centuries gap between the error ranges.
- sandworm101 6y ago>>Is it really that reliable to make such precise statements? Carbon dating is never enough in itself. They are not saying that carbon dating proves that one thing happened before the other. They are saying that carbon dating does not disprove it, that the narrative they propose is not contradicted by carbon evidence. The fact that there are multi-century error bands means it can never be solid proof, but the fact that one error band is centered years later than the other does add weight to their proposed timeline. Carbon dating is a fuzzy telescope, but lack of perfect resolution doesn't mean it cannot produce useful evidence.
- yread 6y agoThey haven't used radiocarbon that much, it seems that OSL was more important
- canjobear 6y agoHow do you radiocarbon-date a rock?
- Waterluvian 6y agoRegardless of camera crews, I have a perpetual skepticism of entire disciplines, partly because of my own ignorance, I'm sure. But also partly because I have a BS detector and it goes off a lot. Largely about all these inferences made about history using so few data points and a brilliant imagination. Really? You could tell all these things about this specific household because of a pot you found? I'm not sure I have a beef with the scientists themselves. There is value in guesstimating what dinosaurs looked like. But at some point these guesstimates get sold as scientific discovery.
- tobylane 6y agoI agree with you on skepticism. But there’s a lot more than just a pot behind theories. The pot is just something they can hold in front of the camera. It’s also the ashy layers in the fireplace, the bone pile outside the building, the greater findings at other digs of the same age and culture.
- yvdriess 6y agoExactly, the context in which the object is found is more informative that the object itself. The moment this context is disturbed, e.g. artifacts being pillaged from the site and sold on the black market, the object loses almost all archeological scientific value.
- hanoz 6y agoSo it's not just some cracked pot theory?
- throwaway189262 6y agoReminds me of the complete skeletons produced using things like jaw fragments. Especially for popular species like dinosaurs and ancient hominids. Like 20 years ago we didn't even know that most dinosaurs had feathers. Most reconstructions are just wishful thinking IMO
- Hoasi 6y ago
- DyslexicAtheist 6y agoI'd like to think the English stole it like all the other things sitting in London museums. Now put it back to where it was!
- meigwilym 6y agoCoal, steel, water - and now this?
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoIt was the British who stole it, and put it in the British Museum. "Great" British imperialism was common to all areas of GB, and probably of the UK (though Northern Irish history is not in my scope). Probably safe to argue that one is not from Upper Class/Aristicratic stock to avoid ancestral culpability though.
- flukus 6y agoIt was the Britons that stole it, the "English" were still chilling over in Scandinavia or eastern Europe.
- joosters 6y agoOh, and look - it just so happens to be on the only farm you could get permission to dig on! This is somewhat tautological - of course archaeologists make discoveries on the sites they are digging on. It's very hard to make discoveries at sites that you aren't allowed on!
- hanoz 6y ago> It's very hard to make discoveries at sites that you aren't allowed on! Not as hard as it used to be: https://houseprices.io/lidar/SU1025069970 https://houseprices.io/lidar/SU1025069970
- adambcn 6y agoIs that Avebury?
- Mikushi 6y agoCorrect, you can see Silbury hill as well as a few of the barrows in the area.
- mikhailfranco 6y agoYes, here is Stonehenge: https://houseprices.io/lab/lidar/map?ref=SU11914213 https://houseprices.io/lab/lidar/map?ref=SU11914213 Glastonbury Tor 3D: https://houseprices.io/lidar/ST5125038630/3d https://houseprices.io/lidar/ST5125038630/3d Maiden Castle: https://houseprices.io/lab/lidar/map?ref=SY669884 https://houseprices.io/lab/lidar/map?ref=SY669884
- mikhailfranco 6y agoAnd Wittenham Clumps: https://houseprices.io/lab/lidar/map?ref=SU567924 https://houseprices.io/lab/lidar/map?ref=SU567924 in the news for discovery of Iron Age settlement: https://www.theguardian.com/science/2021/feb/14/astonishing-dig-reveals-domestic-life-in-the-iron-age https://www.theguardian.com/science/2021/feb/14/astonishing-...
- gorgoiler 6y agoI was sceptical but saw the phrase “peer reviewed” and “journal”. Should I un-allay my suspicions?
- Doctor_Fegg 6y agoHere's the bona fides of the archaeologist quoted in the article: https://www.ucl.ac.uk/archaeology/people/mike-parker-pearson-professor-british-later-prehistory https://www.ucl.ac.uk/archaeology/people/mike-parker-pearson... BA, PhD, FBA, FSA, FSA Scot, MIFA. Professor of British Later Prehistory. Do I believe him or a random software engineer on HN who thinks it might be "a bit too convenient"? Hmm. Tricky one. I know a guy who crossed the Channel on a tiny little narrowboat meant for 3ft-deep canals. The entire thing was filmed. The TV programme hammed it up and made it seem like an entirely haphazard endeavour. Of course it was playing to the camera. That doesn't mean he didn't cross the Channel. He did.
- shiftpgdn 6y agoAdding a bunch of letters to the end of your name doesn't make you less susceptible to the allure of fame and money. In fact the type of person to add alphabet soup to the end of their name might be even more susceptible!
- RicoElectrico 6y agoCase in point: Andrew Wakefield of vaccines-cause-autism infamy.
- mhh__ 6y agoHe was a medical doctor, right? I can't be bothered to argue it in public but I don't really listen to doctors on anything outside what they practice in - they aren't scientists and aren't trained as such.
- fao_ 6y agoUhhh, yes. But only in fields where they are not already an expert. What you're referring to is Nobel Prize disease, and that is essentially the implicit human assumption that when you become an expert at one thing, you're an expert at everything. However it notably does not happen when someone is an expert at something, because well, they're an expert -- they know enough about the field to separate the wheat from the chaff https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Nobel_disease https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Nobel_disease Like the parent says, I'm not sure why you'd rather believe a software engineer on Hacker News -- who unless they are unusual, has zero experience with archeology outside of watching Time Team occasionally -- versus someone who is actually qualified in that field. This is the kind of thinking that led to the catastrophe that was MetaMed -- software engineers and mathematicians not realising that they needed to actually learn things about other fields to be an expert in it (Unlike computer science where you can read a few well-curated blogposts and understand most of the problems in a week), and deciding to go into Medicine with that mindset (https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/MetaMed https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/MetaMed).
- bodhi_mind 6y agoThis reminds me of a natgeo documentary on disney+ called Into the Okavango. It was interesting and I love anything that promotes wild habitats but this came off as more of a production than a documentary.