20 ms·
Apple redirects Google Safe Browsing traffic through proxy servers in iOS 14.5
- IceWreck 6y agoSo Apples going to war with Facebook and Google citing privacy. Google violates privacy, yes but so does Apple. Real privacy on phones means removing google play services from your phone, using fdroid, not using any proprietary apps and self hosting services instead of relying on gsuite or ms365. Not the fake privacy shit that Apple does, where they move the power from Google to themselves.
- jmnicolas 6y agoWhat about your ISP? They know every websites you consult, every phone calls and texts and they triangulate your position...
- metiscus 6y agoFor all but the position aspect of that, switching to a trustworthy VPN provider (e.g. ProtonVPN or Mozilla VPN) and using Signal or another VOIP system can provide mitigation. For the position data, that is harder to mitigate but you have to consider your threat profile. The truly paranoid keep their phones with battery removed (when possible) and/or in a faraday bag unless they are actively using them. You do, of course, pay for this privacy with significantly reduced convenience.
- jmnicolas 6y agoI'm not sure who I distrust more between a VPN provider and my ISP, but for sure I don't trust either. Signal has received financing from the CIA so my trust level isn't high (even though I use it). My point is that privacy is an illusion on any connected system and particularly a smartphone. You can make less privacy damaging choices but IMHO there's no panacea.
- ViViDboarder 6y ago> Signal has received financing from the CIA so my trust level isn't high (even though I use it). More like Signal once received funding from a fund that included funding from an organization that was once run by the CIA. Still, I agree with your overall point. To be truly private, you need to disconnect. Other than that, you need to consider each trade off. Historically, this was difficult because companies barely disclosed what they did. Since GDPR and CCPA, a lot of the veil has been lifted.
- gggtt 6y agoAgreed. On the long-term, Apple is the one which might harm Privacy the most because they will kill the real Privacy alternatives by pretending they are one. People use Google & Facebook because they are dependent on their services but some of them know they are unethical (for e.g the recent WhatsApp scandal shows that at least some people are kinda aware). Apple on the other hand lies and does propaganda about their fake Privacy and people (even on HN) think they are the solution, and that's far more dangerous I think. Many people think real Privacy solutions are not worth supporting because they have Safari, IOS & Icloud. Well guess what, ICloud is not even (end2end) encrypted, employees have been listening to your Siri conversation, HomeKit doorbells are doing nonconsenting facial recognition on you & your friends, Apple tracks every app you lunch & when (and no that's not necessary for security, you could just download a blacklist instead of sending Apple your history), and no, Apple does not audit or read any line of code of the apps on the store. It's killing me that my friends think it's okay to install Facebook, Instagram & Snapchat or whatever on their phone because "No but it's okay, I have an IPhone so Apple has checked the app and everything". For them, Apple is magically going to protect them whatever they do. That's where you see their lies & propaganda really worked. Apple is like a polluting gas car that sells & market itself as a green clean ecological electrical car so that people can use without conscience issues
- kgin 6y agoYour bar for privacy is very high and accessible only to nerds. That's great, but not helpful for average users. Apple is not absolute, ironclad privacy. Don't rely on them for covert ops missions. But they ARE providing a very reasonable model of doing business that requires no special skills on the part of the user and does not engage in the unrelenting surveillance that other companies bake into every corner of their products. Is it "privacy"? I'm not sure. But it is definitely "not surveillance". And that's a very reasonable place to start.
- onlyrealcuzzo 6y agoWhere does privacy end and surveillance start?
- kgin 6y agoI think many are defining privacy as “no one has even the possibility of accessing your data”. To me, surveillance is actively instrumenting and recording data from a user . Apple seems live in a middle zone where the do not engage in surveillance, but sometimes make technical choices where they could in theory access or intercept data from you, though they have they have promised not to.
- gerash 6y agoWhat Apple does is partly "privacy theatre" in my opinion. They shame third party apps you have given background location permission for using your location in the background (eg. gps dog collar app) while never alerting you when the first party Apple apps do the same "Apple maps / friend finder / Siri / etc. used your location in the background"
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- jmull 6y agoWhat you're suggesting isn't that far from "don't use the internet". That's fine -- your privacy will go way up -- but I don't think that's the solution very many people are looking for.
- majestik 6y agoiProxy - a breakthrough proxy, safeguard, and internet communications device. Revolutionize web browsing by not doing it yourself!
- sschueller 6y agoI would assume Google uses this data to optimise its blocklist and determine impact. By Apple blocking this data they are reducing the effectiveness of the Safe Browsing list. This is one item I would not block, we already have huge issues with this list providing false positives. Giving Google even less data to make adjustments make this worse.
- tonfa 6y agoI don't think that's even correct, the article is somewhat contradictory: > Since Apple uses a hashed prefix, Google cannot learn which website the user is trying to visit. Up until iOS 14.5, Google could also see the IP address of where that request is coming from. > And setting up a proxy server to filter Google Safe Browsing traffic just so Google cannot users’ browsing activity will be a welcome move for a lot of users. IIRC the safe browsing was designed to avoid disclosing user traffic: https://developers.google.com/safe-browsing/v4/update-api https://developers.google.com/safe-browsing/v4/update-api > The Update API is designed for clients that require high frequency, low-latency verdicts. Several web browsers and software platforms use this API to protect large sets of users. > If you are concerned about the privacy of the queried URLs or the latency induced by a network request, use the Update API.
- ViViDboarder 6y agoThis only prevents Google from harvesting IP address of the users. They don’t need that information to tell if the place I’m going is bad.
- Camillo 6y ago> However, since Apple now proxies Google Safe Browsing traffic, it further safeguards users’ privacy while browsing using Safari. It still shares the same amount of information, it's just being shared with Apple instead of Google. If it was a privacy problem before, it remains so.
- sanxiyn 6y agoThis is a significant improvement if you trust Apple more than Google.
- sschueller 6y agoFor the US Government it's just a different phone number they have to call to get your data...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- stqism 6y agoTypically, people who are trying to defend themselves from nation state threat actors aren’t using iPhones or stock Android phones, and absolutely wouldn’t use safe browsing if they did.
- nuker 6y agoNext fonts and jquery stuff, please. These requests have Referrer in them. And can we have it for MacOS too?
- emptyparadise 6y agoI've seen some browser extensions that use local copies of the usual CDN scripts and such. I wonder how much better that could be if it was a proper browser feature coupled with some sort of a privacy proxy? Though I imagine that the same local cache fingerprinting issues might still apply here.
- sofixa 6y agoDon't all browsers cache ( common, like jQuery) js and css stuff locally?
- FrontAid 6y agoMost browsers changed that to a site-based cache instead of a global one. https://www.zdnet.com/article/firefox-to-ship-network-partitioning-as-a-new-anti-tracking-defense/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/firefox-to-ship-network-partit...
- dolmen 6y agoThey might cache it if the server allows them to cache it. But evil servers don't. Example: gravatar.com gives an expiration time of 5 minutes. curl -q -i --output - https://www.gravatar.com/avatar/70d9b050bfe39350c234d710fadfcd39 https://www.gravatar.com/avatar/70d9b050bfe39350c234d710fadf... | grep -a xpires expires: Fri, 12 Feb 2021 11:54:40 GMT
- nuker 6y agoI suspected it, thanks for confirming. What about fonts.googleapis.com, is it cached client side?
- bzb6 6y ago
- Daho0n 6y agoApple is going to extremes to get more power over users and force others to have less. Of course it can be painted as being "for privacy" but, really, anyone believe that coming from Apple? EDIT: Come-on HN. Google has nothing to do with how trustworthy Apple is. You can distrust both. This whole "for privacy" push from Apple is clearly more about hurting others than protecting users. I'm surprised HN'ers are buying into this marketing ploy.
- apples_oranges 6y agoI do unless proven otherwise
- wp381640 6y agoYep. Absolutely - trust them a lot more than I trust Google. I love what 14.5 is doing to shake up the privacy invading practices of the large internet co's.
- Daho0n 6y agoYou can distrust both. >I love what 14.5 is doing to shake up the privacy invading practices of the large internet co's. Sure, but just don't believe it is for your privacy's sake.
- JBorrow 6y agoWhy not? It seems like a pretty clear cut move to increase privacy, drive up consumer satisfaction and loyalty, and increase sales. Yeah, they're doing it to sell more iPhones, sure, but I don't see how that's a bad thing.
- roylez 6y agoApple makes money selling devices; Google makes money selling targeted ads. Making devices more secure will benefit Apple's business, so is collecting more user data to Google's business.
- 6y ago
- sneak 6y agoI'm really tired of how much phone-home Apple products do these days. At this point I don't even put a SIM in my phones any longer, and only permit them access via a travel router (which does have a SIM, for LTE backhaul) which runs a VPN client and on which I have root to inspect/block traffic. My latest blog post shows the dozens of dozens of connections that a Mac running Big Sur will make just sitting idle at the desktop on a fresh install. Apple's products are only private if you want privacy from their commercial competitors. If you want privacy from Apple or the US federal government to which they provide tons of user data (without warrants(!) or due process), you're in for a constant uphill battle. Using everyday devices should not be creating hardware-serial-linked permanent records that the state can download at any time; to me that's stuff of a true dystopia. Apple has not yet integrated this viewpoint, and seem to regard privacy as only important against companies that aren't Apple. Device backups (full message history and attachments), as well as Photos stored in iCloud, are not end to end encrypted permitting Apple (and by extension the state) to read and access all of it without your involvement. It's a bummer they're extending this attitude to browser-related traffic too. There seems to be a new trend inside of Apple that they're still figuring out here (see also: the addition of ContentFilterExclusionList in 11.0, and then its quick removal in 11.2). Did you know that if you entirely block access to all Apple hosts, you can't even add a Gmail account to an iPhone?
- ricardobayes 6y agoReally nice post there! Enjoyed reading it. (Also agree with the bit regarding xps 13. I was given one at work and they expected me to have a 'wow' reaction to it and made remarks what a 'beast of a machine' I was getting. Lol.) edit: typo.
- ricardobayes 6y agoTo all the kind people downvoting, I am referring his blog post, not his post here. https://sneak.berlin/20210202/macos-11.2-network-privacy/ https://sneak.berlin/20210202/macos-11.2-network-privacy/
- dygd 6y agoLink to the actual blog post: https://sneak.berlin/20210202/macos-11.2-network-privacy/ https://sneak.berlin/20210202/macos-11.2-network-privacy/
- freakynit 6y agoJust my thought: "So, these behemoths have now started to eat each other to satisfy their never ending appetite for money and control. What next? Remaining ones colluding together to prevent entrance of new competitors?"
- m12k 6y agoI'm hoping what's next is: "With mobile and social media platforms having finished their market expansion, and their product categories having settled, privacy-respecting open source alternatives catch up in functionality and usability. Anti-trust and regulation to enforce privacy and interoperability ensure these new entrants get a chance in the market, and consumers have a real chance to escape the clutches of the behemoths" Tall order? Sure - but all progress starts with a dream.
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y agoThe problem is they have enormous budgets for promotion and marketing, and they already own multiple direct channels. And the inertia effect is enormous - people simply don't like to change their habits without a very good reason. So the decisive factor is for people to understand they already have a good reason. I don't think this understanding is something mainstream yet though.
- wkearney99 6y agounderstanding isn't mainstream so, yeah, inertia is certainly a factor, but the staggering level of tech incompetence among the masses is also a likely factor.
- AshamedCaptain 6y agoI'm not sure social media platforms will ever settle. I have already seen one round of proprietary IM networks being toppled and replaced with Jabber. Only for some evil bastard to apply a EEE strategy to Jabber and actually succeed, so we end up in the current situation of yet another round of proprietary IM networks. It is also not a matter of "catching up in functionality and usability". It will never catch up. Proprietary networks can build on top of free ones, but not viceversa. Also, every pseudo-feature introduced by a proprietary network soon becomes mission-critical (e.g. people will say free network X is not "up to the task" because one cannot easily send animated cat pictures with it, in the same way IRC suddenly became "not up to the task"). In summary, it is absurd to wait until free networks "catch up". They will never "catch up", for some users definition of "functionality and usability", and network effects will take care of the rest of users. The only way this works is if users are willing to actually prioritize free-ness and to actually trade off some features to gain it. Boycott closed networks, even. But that will never happen.
- saagarjha 6y agoAm I the only one who thinks that this is a neutral move with some pedestrian reason like "we'd like to be able to dynamically change our Safe Browsing endpoint in the future" or "let's not hardcode our API keys into Safari"?
- ComodoHacker 6y agoApple servers are whitelisted in adblocking and firewall APIs, so this move makes sure Safe Browsing works when the user or some app messes up with those.
- gruez 6y agoWhy would apple's servers be whitelisted but not google's? Considering all the google devices/software out there (eg. android, chrome), not whitelisting google is probably going to cause more issues than not whitelisting apple.
- CodesInChaos 6y agoI think Apple software (like Safari) shouldn't talk to google servers by default, so this move makes sense.
- lrem 6y agoWhat makes this pair special?
- CodesInChaos 6y agoThat it's the one this post is about. In general software should avoid using third party servers as much as possible, because they're outside of its control.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- eznzt 6y agoAccording to the Apple documentation, if the user is in China this check "may" be done via Tencent. https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT210675 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT210675 >For users with China mainland set as their region in Settings > General > Language and Region, Safari may also use Tencent Safe Browsing to do this check. Are these checks proxified as well?
- nooneknowswhy 6y agoIt's highly unlikely. It is required by CCP law to record user activities up to 90 (or 30? vague memories) days.
- BelenusMordred 6y ago> 90 days Actually sounds pretty good. In Australia it is 730 days.
- ardy42 6y ago>> It's highly unlikely. It is required by CCP law to record user activities up to 90 (or 30? vague memories) days. > Actually sounds pretty good. In Australia it is 730 days. No, it doesn't. China requires the content of user activities to be saved, so your chat history is literally being sent to the local police in real time for scanning. The result is stuff like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MiMLVYK4hEc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MiMLVYK4hEc (Chinese police casually asserting their dominance by locking some poor guy in a tiger chair for badmouthing them on a private WeChat chat). A few years back someone found an analyzed an unsecured Mongo DB that was storing these messages: https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/open-mongodb-databases-expose-chinese-surveillance-data/ https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/open-mongodb-... IIRC, Australia only has metadata retention requirements.
- La1n 6y agoI am sorry, but how do we know that youtube video is real? The channel it is uploaded to doesn't seem trustworthy at all. >China requires the content of user activities to be saved, Do you have a source for this? I find it hard to find information on this, I assume it's because I don't speak Chinese.
- dolmen 6y agoFrom the article: > According to Apple, before visiting a website, Safari may send hashed prefixes of the URL (Apple terms it “information calculated from the website address”) to Google Safe Browsing to check if there’s a match. Does anyone have links to algorithms for such "hashed prefixes of an URL"?
- bennyp101 6y agoI assume it's the same as when it was mentioned in 2019 "A 32-bit hash prefix like "ba7816bf" would represent the first eight characters of a 256-bit, 64-character SHA256 digest of a full URL. Before it loads a requested website, Safari, like other browsers that implement a safe browsing lookup system, will hash the URL of the website to be visited and compare its hash prefix to the received hash segments of malicious sites." https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21254166 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21254166 https://www.theregister.com/2019/10/14/apple_china_tencent/ https://www.theregister.com/2019/10/14/apple_china_tencent/ https://developers.google.com/safe-browsing/v4/urls-hashing#hash-computations https://developers.google.com/safe-browsing/v4/urls-hashing#...
- legacynl 6y ago"A 32-bit hash prefix like "ba7816bf" would represent the first eight characters of a 256-bit, 64-character SHA256 digest of a full URL." Is this done for 'privacy'? Pretty thinly veiled attempt, because they could easily create hashes for every url their crawlers come across, and do some statistical wizardry to try to find out which of the 1000 urls with that prefix you visited. Right?
- jaywalk 6y agoIt's as good as you can get without resorting to maintaining the database on the client.
- kccqzy 6y agoOf course it's done for privacy. If Google created hashes for every single URL it crawled, the hash prefixes that are downloaded by clients would be enormously large, wasting multi gigabytes for on-device storage of these hash prefixes.
- officiadil 6y agoIt definitely uses Tencent Servers for China.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ryanisnan 6y agoHow many of human-kind's inventions been to thwart our own bad behaviours? I hate this kind of tech purely because the reason we have to do it at all is to thwart nefarious behaviour. Google Safe Browsing exists because people are shit heads. Apple proxy servers exist because Google is a shit head.
- forty 6y agoSoon: TOR by the GAFAM ;)
- vinay_ys 6y agoIf it is not open-source, and if it is not offline-functional, then it is not privacy-first design. Safe browsing updates can be served like software updates. Apple could demonstrate they serve software updates from servers that don't log any PII data. Only then they would have actually improved the situation.
- kccqzy 6y agoThe whole point of the complicated safe browsing protocol with hash prefixes is to avoid downloading the entire blocklists to the device.
- mleonhard 6y ago> Since Apple uses a hashed prefix, Google cannot learn which website the user is trying to visit. That is false. Google produces the hashes and can easily reverse them.
- anderiv 6y agoIIRC a non-identifiable portion of the hash is given to the Google, then Google returns a bunch of potential matches with associated safety score, and then it’s up to the client to either block or not.