9 ms·
And this is not surprising. Cryptocurrency is designed to be anti-efficient. "Proof of work" is just a synonym for "having wasted tons of energy." This is my m
by kqr 6y ago
And this is not surprising. Cryptocurrency is designed to be anti-efficient. "Proof of work" is just a synonym for "having wasted tons of energy."
This is my main beef with these systems. Gaining fundamental value from the act of wasting energy and being the one to accelerate the (local) heat death by the most is not a sensible basis for a 21st century technology.
- lmkg 6y agoMy issue with it is even more fundamental than this: it is structurally impossible for Proof of Work to become more efficient. If you find a more energy-efficient way to mine, the correct decision is not to reduce your energy usage, but rather to use the same amount of energy to compute more hashes.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- aeternum 6y agoBy computing more hashes, you raise the difficulty for everyone else mining so you do ultimately push out the less efficient miners.
- meow112012 6y agoIf someone has money and power already, they can take a better chance to get more bitcoin. How about the other guys and the other guys ... 10/20 years later?
- lxgr 6y agoThe problem is that there is, by definition, economic incentive to spend an amount of electric energy equal to the economic value of transaction confirmation to all protocol participants.
- rspeele 6y agoThat's efficient if you define efficiency as hashes computed per watt. That's the metric by which less-efficient miners are driven out. However, this does nothing for the overall energy efficiency of Bitcoin, which could be defined as transactions processed per gigawatt. If energy gets cheaper, that number only gets smaller.
- panarky 6y agoThe energy-per-transaction ratio is only relevant if the utility of Bitcoin is to compete with Visa to process transactions. However, if the ultimate utility of Bitcoin is to store trillions of dollars of value, transmit it into the future, across borders, quickly, pseudonymously, and without capital controls from coercive and corrupt governments, then energy-per-transaction is an inappropriate metric. Bitcoin is the only asset with these properties, and it doesn't need many transactions to do what it does best. If you find you're angry about Bitcoin's energy usage but you're not even more angry about the energy wasted by industries and technologies that have much less social utility, then maybe it's not the wasted energy that you're angry about after all.
- mint2 6y ago> without capital controls from coercive and corrupt governments And conversely too! letting corrupt governments and corporations transfer money with ease!
- toyg 6y agoLet's not forget druglords, illegal arms dealers, hitmen...
- meowkit 6y agoPaging argument from 2010... You would use Monero or physical cash for those activities. Bitcoin is much easier to trace once you have a lead.
- toyg 6y agoIt's just a tradeoff between opsec and ease of use. Monero is harder to turn back into cash, precisely because it carries a worse reputation. Note that my argument was pro btc - I can see underground demand sustaining its price in the long run.
- Solvitieg 6y agoBecause you definitely can't do that with fiat... This is such an old, tired take.
- optimiz3 6y agoHypothetically this could be amortized better by increasing the transactions per block. Just because Bitcoin was first doesn't mean it's the best wrt efficiency. PoW can be competitive with legacy infrastructure with good clearing design.
- kqr 6y agoI think Donatella Meadows made it quite clear a while back that fiddling with constants and coefficients doesn't really have an Effect with capital E.
- deeeeplearning 6y agoMost newer cryptos are built on proof of stake. So your criticism is mainly aimed at Btc.
- sharpneli 6y agoNaturally. While POS cryptos share many other bad sides with Bitcoin at least they don't ruin the planet so they're far far better.
- fastball 6y agoPOW only ruins the planet if you're using non-renewables / non-nuclear. It's not intrinsic.
- patrickthebold 6y agoquibble on "you're". It's a shared planet, so it gets ruined if enough mining is done on non-renewables. Most people complaining aren't mining at all.
- fastball 6y agoWas this a useful comment? "You're" is just a stand-in for "people are". The second person is a fairly common way to structure such a sentence.
- hacknat 6y agoWhich is where most energy is derived from, so it's ruining the planet.
- kqr 6y agoSure, you can argue that nuclear (or whatever) is a better way to produce energy than most/all others currently known, but that's a very low bar to clear. There are more and less sucky ways to produce energy, but let's be clear: all of them suck to some degree. There is no type of energy production where the mere act of producing that energy is a net positive. Then the argument turns to whether or not the gains from proof of wasted energy-type systems outweigh the drawbacks of producing the required energy -- even if that energy is produced in the least sucky way. I'm firmly in the no camp.
- fpoling 6y agoCryptocurrency are inefficient by the design only at creation. But once mined, in principle with the right setup transactions can be arbitrary cheap. It is similarly as with gold. It is expensive to dig it once, but once a coin is minted, it can be used for millions of transaction making transaction cost rather low.
- newswasboring 6y agoActually your analogy is flawed. Because the way bitcoin works you have to pay some energy cost per block and you have a limited time to use that block because the next block will be coming in in 10 mins. It would be more like we had to make new coins every 10 mins. Or am I missing something here?
- fpoling 6y agoBitcoin probably is not fixable, but other designs are much better at supporting cheap transactions. There is nothing inherently expensive in maintaining the block chain.
- newswasboring 6y agothis thread is about bitcoins. So I thought its implied we are talking about bitcoin. Maintaining a POW block chain is inherently wasteful, but yes POS blockchains can maybe save this.
- fpoling 6y agoEven with bitcoins just consider what happens once all bitcoins are mined. Does the whole thing collapse? Or do bitcoins continue to be used similar to POS?
- newswasboring 6y agoThe block mining algorithm doesn't change, right? So I don't see how it will move to POS. That will require some sort of buy in from the users. Every time something new is introduced in Bitcoin the legacy remains and the new ideas fork the chain into their own thing. Usually these alternatives either die or ignored.
- Lambdanaut 6y agoYou may be interested in Ada coin. It uses a "proof of stake" algorithm instead which does not rely on processing power. Virtually infinitely more eco-friendly.
- flopunctro 6y agoIn the grand scheme, the "tons" (or rather, gigajoules) of energy wasted by the Proof-of-Work are nothing. The Sun radiation that hits Earth every second dwarfs this consumption. Also, one of the definitions of life is "a local decrease in entropy, at the cost of a global, larger, increase in entropy". By this criteria, every living being is a bad thing for the universe, because it accelerates the global heat death ever so slightly. I guess my point is, some uses of energy are acceptable, even desirable. And every use of energy accelerates the heat death of the universe, but we humans are insignificant on this scale; there is really nothing that we can do to even accelerate our Sun's death. We're not even Kardashev-1 :)
- vruiz 6y agoI was going to point that the universe is not relevant here, only humans, the energy we produce and how we produce it matters. But then I realized that either your comment must be tongue in cheek or you are trying to hard to rationalize this than there is no point on try to convince you.
- flopunctro 6y agoOkay, I admit my comment was a bit rushed, and I apologize for that. It's not tongue-in-cheek, and I don't feel that I'm rationalizing things (but then, I guess I wouldn't feel it even if I were). I was trying to view things in a bigger picture. Ofcourse we are using too much fossil fuels at this time. Ofcourse our functioning is pretty unsustainable. What I am trying to say, is that sometimes high energy usage is acceptable. Should we stop launching things in orbit? Should we stop the LHC? I think that for _some_ people, having a thing such as bitcoin is worth the energy expenditure. It is perfectly okay that for you, it _isn't_ acceptable. I am not trying to convince you of anything. Just affirming that there exists a subset of humans that find value in it, and therefore are willing to allocate resources -- be that electrical energy, fiat money, or mindshare.
- danans 6y ago> Also, one of the definitions of life is "a local decrease in entropy, at the cost of a global, larger, increase in entropy". By this criteria, every living being is a bad thing for the universe, because it accelerates the global heat death ever so slightly. The discussion about energy use of Bitcoin is within the context of the effectively closed system of Earth. Until such a time that solar generated electricity is too plentiful to meter and ubiquitous, Bitcoin mining will cause huge demand for fossil fuel based energy, with the associated consequences for climate change.
- dsco 6y agoThere’s also proof of stake which requires a lot less energy. I think a lot of nuance is missed when discussing Bitcoin and its consensus mechanism as the only way of running a blockchain
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> I think a lot of nuance is missed when discussing Bitcoin and its consensus mechanism as the only way of running a blockchain Bitcoin holders are financially incentivized to steer everyone else toward Bitcoin. As long as early adopters are financially invested in alternative currencies failing, we’re going to continue seeing a focus on Bitcoin.
- chaostheory 6y agoWhen is that rolling out for Ethereum
- hacknat 6y agoIt's a really complicated transition, but it's already started. The estimate is that there's probably about $1.5B worth of transactions left to mine, but most transactions will be switching over to PoS in the coming year. No one knows for sure when the full transition will occur, it's more of a gradual phase-out.
- piplikoc 6y agoIt's coming with Ethereum 2.0. The transition process to Eth2 is on the way, it is estimated that they will finish by 2022.
- mrits 6y agoI like Ethereum not just because of the more responsible PoS but also because mining is currently asic resistant. A lot of the waste going into bitcoin right now is building specialized miners that will go into a landfill after a generation or two. Eth can still be mined with hardware you already own.
- xorcist 6y ago
- hacknat 6y agoEthereum has already started transitioning to proof-of-stake which will significantly lower transaction costs in Ethereum.
- arithmomachist 6y agoAt the very least the proof of work ought to compute something useful.
- lxgr 6y agoThat would be great, but unfortunately the structure of problems that are well suited to proof of work (hard to compute but easy to verify in a decentralized way) doesn't seem to have too many practical applications.
- arithmomachist 6y agoAren't there lots of NP problems that have this property?
- root_axis 6y agoIt can't be made useful because the output of a useful calculation can't be known in advance - otherwise it wouldn't be useful.
- minsc__and__boo 6y agoYou can gain use computing to gain specificity from complexity though, and recognize that new specificity - i.e. brute force protein folding calculations.
- freebreakfast 6y agoI think Gridcoin offers a happy medium. It's proof of stake, but it also offers rewards for participating in BOINC-based research projects. https://gridcoin.us/ https://gridcoin.us/ Not exactly "proof of work" in the same sense its being used, but I wish that the project would get more attention.
- jkuria 6y agoMining for gold is even more inefficient. You've got dig earth several kilometers down, build massive infrastructure, use harmful chemicals to purify it, lose lives etc etc
- wonnage 6y agoAt least gold is useful for something though
- kosievdmerwe 6y agoGold also doesn't require constant electricity expenditure to keep it's value and "utility"z A kilo of gold once mined is perpetual. A bitcoin needs the whole network to keep running (and be large enough so that miners can't collude) to keep it's value.
- minsc__and__boo 6y agoThat's falsely equating fixed and variable costs. A mined bitcoin is useless if the network isn't burning electricity, whereas mined gold is continually useful after mining.
- hardtke 6y agoIt's really hard to see how BTC does not get outlawed by most governments. Since financial transactions are zero sum and provide no economic value, it's the equivalent of a giant methane leak.
- 2112 6y ago> "Proof of work" is just a synonym for "having wasted tons of energy." This is my main beef with these systems. Gaining fundamental value from the act of wasting energy [...] is not a sensible basis for a 21st century technology. This is my main beef with the system we live in already. See ; Bullshit Jobs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullshit_jobs https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullshit_jobs "Bullshit Jobs: A Theory is a 2018 book by anthropologist David Graeber that argues for the existence and societal harm of meaningless jobs. He contends that over half of societal work is pointless, which becomes psychologically destructive when paired with a work ethic that associates work with self-worth." I am not contesting the Bitcoin situation is ... interesting. (edit = comment layout )
- kerng 6y agoIndeed, the comment shows how valuable Bitcoin actually really is - it's pretty impressive.
- rspeele 6y agoInteresting take. Does the amount of money spent on Herbalife show how valuable it actually really is? What about essential oils or healing crystals? In a tautological way, sure, everything's worth what somebody's willing to pay for it. But the above examples must call into question whether there is a distinction between what something is worth in dollars, and what its merit is.
- kerng 6y agoGood points. To give it a totally different spin, imagine Bitcoin's value is pretty constant actually and what changes is the dollar (its being devalued at a rapid pace at the moment). There is only a limited supply of Bitcoin, but there will be more and more dollars printed over the next decades (making the dollar even less valuable compare to the constant Bitcoin). So Bitcoin will be interesting to watch - quite exciting for future and to see what's gonna happen.
- ChainOfFools 6y agoproof of work is cleverly misnamed, because what's actually going on is proof of wasted work, or simply proof of waste. you are proving you threw a precise measure of something valuable away (money/resources/energy... whether your own or someone else's). the behavioral econ assumption is that you will seek to recover that loss someday, thus requiring you to hold and protect the receipt token representing it until that time.
- fthssht 6y agoThe correct comparison is with the transaction and storage costs, in electricity, of storing gold in fort knox and moving it once a century in a boat across the ocean. Tesla's 1.5 billion USD in bitcoin probably won't move in your lifetime.
- dang 6y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26090317 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26090317.