10 ms·
I'm no Facebook fan but the reasons behind the lawsuit are bad and could set a bad precedent. Cambridge Analytica used the Facebook API to ask users to share d
by Nextgrid 6y ago
I'm no Facebook fan but the reasons behind the lawsuit are bad and could set a bad precedent.
Cambridge Analytica used the Facebook API to ask users to share data about them & their friends. Stupid users agreed to that.
The argument here isn't that Facebook is playing fast and loose with tracking & user data (which would be a legitimate argument), it's that Facebook is allowing people to grant access to their data to third-parties and Facebook should somehow be faulted for that. Facebook is a neutral carrier here, and they acted on behalf of the user - he decided that Cambridge Analytica should have had access to his data. Facebook should not be forced to somehow be the arbiter of this.
This lawsuit will give even more reasons to platforms to restrict API access which would impact legitimate usage much more than nefarious abuse (stupid people will always find a way to screw up, API or not - if the API is gone they'd happily enter their Facebook credentials directly instead).
- manux 6y ago> Facebook is allowing people to grant access to their data to third-parties and Facebook should somehow be faulted for that. It's not clear to me that they shouldn't be faulted. How many people read terms and conditions? How many people lack the technological literacy to understand what it means to share their facebook data with third-parties? It seems to me like we should make our systems robust to the average user, especially systems as big as Facebook. > Facebook should not be forced to somehow be the arbiter of this. I kind of agree, but at the same time Facebook has some moral responsibility as the holder of the data. Perhaps it's not on Facebook to implement regulatory mechanisms, but if these mechanisms are implemented (e.g. by the "State") then it should probably be on Facebook's dime.
- lupire 6y agoReading the EULA and T&C are irrelevant, because what CA did wrong was violate the EULA and T&C. Anyway, You are making an argument for regulations requiring disclosures, like in mortgages and nutrition labels, not an argument that Facebook is at fault for letting users interact with 3rd parties, which could have been a browser extension that scraped the same data that the FB API provides.
- manux 6y agoTrue, but until these regulations exists, I'm not sure why we shouldn't hold Facebook accountable, at least morally -- and in the example you give, why we shouldn't hold browser extension providers accountable.
- Nextgrid 6y agoWhy should Facebook be accountable here instead of the party that acted maliciously? Facebook acted as a neutral carrier. Users told them to share their data with CA, and they did. CA lied to both their users and even to Facebook itself (I think they breached FB API's terms and conditions), why should it be Facebook that's at fault? In your argument, if a car is used in a robbery, should the car dealership or manufacturer be also at fault, even though the manufacturer had no idea this particular customer was going to use the car for malicious purposes?
- manux 6y agoIf a car has parts that are easily hacked/broken into, leading to injury to its user while the user "chose" to drive, shouldn't the manufacturer be at fault? This is what happened with CA and Facebook's API. I'm not saying CA shouldn't be held accountable, I'm saying Facebook also has part of the blame.
- hunter-gatherer 6y ago> It's not clear to me that they shouldn't be faulted. How many people read terms and conditions? How many people lack the technological literacy to understand what it means to share their facebook data with third-parties? I'm not trying to argue here, but I see this argument pop up often when discussing big tech and user data. I'm curious why the tone is so different when it comes to mortgages or auto loans, for example. It seems society is content with the notion that I must do my ow due diligence when buying a home, but for whatever reason that responsibility seems to slide away when I'm dealing with social media. Why is that? To clarify, I'm being sincere, not argumentative. I'm not a normal internet user and never have been. I haven't been on social media for a decade, use all the ad blockers, and so on.
- manux 6y ago[Not an expert on this, just my opinion as well] Well, for one afaik mortgages and auto loans are regulated and have been for a long time. They're also simpler to understand for _most_ people, since most people interact with money daily, they see their income, they understand interest, etc. Most people don't need to understand how banks trade mortgages and such because in all likelihood, well except in 2008, it will only affect them marginally. I suspect that most people similarly only have a very superficial functional understanding of data. They see other people's data daily, they understand that if they post something, other people will see it. Where this differs is that, at scale data is not well regulated, and can affect users much more directly and non-marginally, in non-obvious ways. Targeted ads, political manipulation, identity theft, etc.
- BlackFly 6y agoWell for one, I expect the bank not to have snuck in a clause that allows them to unilaterally change the contract without providing me with a physical copy thereof. I expect that if the bank tried that that the courts would rule it unconscionable. I expect that if I modify terms in the contract such as typos that the representative will ok them and accept the modification. I expect that they will keep a physical copy of the license or a digital scan thereof so they can track which version I received and whether such modifications were made and to keep track of the witness. I expect the bank to insist on having a translator present since I reside in a land where my proficiency in the language is suspect. I expect that there is a meaningful exchange embodied by the contract and that there is some sense in which I can seek redress if the bank fails to provide the agreed upon funds. If you are sincere, you should compare more people trying to make payday loans illegal with the fight against Facebook's EULA. Banks have always showed much more diligence to receive meaningful consent for a mortgage than Facebook even comes close to. With Payday loans, a predatory lender is trying to rope someone into a contract and then wants to use the courts to extract much more money out of individuals knowing that the individual may be so far in debt that they have no more disposable income. There are many people who would argue that such things should be illegal (or already are) in the same grain as loansharking. Once upon a time people signed contracts whereupon they became slaves or indentured. Clearly not all contractual terms should be honored by a just society. Facebook is seen by some as closer to the predatory lender than a typical mortgage provider. People are free to disagree with where to place the line, but clearly society places the line somewhere on the acceptability of contractual terms.
- inetknght 6y ago> Cambridge Analytica used the Facebook API to ask users to share data about them & their friends. Stupid users agreed to that. Not reading a 1000 page EULA doesn't make users stupid. It makes Facebook predatory.
- bzb6 6y agoThere’s no thousand page EULA. Just a screen that says “do you want to allow this app to access your profile data and your friend list” and they clicked yes.
- at-fates-hands 6y agoShould Cambridge Analytica then be held accountable for being dubious in what users were giving access to and what they would do with that data? Do you think if they knew the full scope of Cambridge Analytica's work they would've allowed them to access the data?
- Nextgrid 6y agoAbsolutely, but if I remember correctly Cambridge Analytica is no more and the law doesn't seem to be going after whoever was behind the company. > Do you think if they knew the full scope of Cambridge Analytica's work they would've allowed them to access the data? Honestly? I'm not sure - a lot of people already dismiss privacy concerns and ad tracking as "I've got nothing to hide" or "it's just ads, no big deal". Unfortunately I wouldn't be surprised if people opted in even if CA was fully transparent with their intentions. However, CA even broke Facebook's API terms of use, so at least if CA was transparent Facebook wouldn't have allowed them API access to begin with (though I'm sure they would've worked around that, with malicious apps/browser extensions or just asking for raw Facebook credentials, bypassing the API completely).
- bzb6 6y agoIf I tell you to go on Facebook and take screenshots of your friends’ profiles and send them to me and then I do dubious things using that information, whose fault is it? I’d split it between you and me. Facebook is not at fault at all.
- ginko 6y ago>The argument here isn't that Facebook is playing fast and loose with tracking & user data (which would be a legitimate argument), it's that Facebook is allowing people to grant access to their data to third-parties and Facebook should somehow be faulted for that. Even so you wrote yourself that users shared data about their friends. Why does Facebook allow people to share the data of others who didn't agree to this?
- indigochill 6y agoIf I put on my blinders against this being Facebook for a moment, supposing that you're on a social network in which your friend is someone you personally trust, then it's not that ridiculous to trust that person with the decision to share your data. In a very limited way, you kind of expect this (your friend giving your number to someone who they think you'll get along with, or whatever). This goes a bit sideways on Facebook in two main ways, I think: 1. People are way too fast and loose with who they keep as "friends" on Facebook 2. Facebook has way too much data to warrant a blanket "Yeah, please share -all- of that at once" agreement. Something more granular, like "The phone numbers of your friends who have themselves granted permissions for their friends to share their numbers" would be more reasonable.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- PeterisP 6y agoThe thing here is that "you're on a social network in which your friend is someone you personally trust, then it's not that ridiculous to trust that person with the decision to share your data" does not match the legal expectation. If my friend allows Facebook to give my data to Cambridge Analytica, that does not give Facebook any legal grounds to do that - so as Facebook did it, it would be a violation at least of the current laws (the UK pre-GDPR legislation was more limited). You are required to inform the data subject and, if you use consent as the basis, you're required to get consent from the data subject (or their legal guardian), not some other person, even if that person is their friend or family member. My spouse or parent can't consent to sharing data on my behalf, and any terms and conditions to which they agree can't waive my rights. Also, it's worth noting that there is a big difference between "your friend giving your number to someone who they think you'll get along with" and your friend sharing your name and number to some company - for GDPR, the first is covered by the "personal activity" clause 2.2(d), and the latter is not, so GDPR applies and the consent of that friend isn't sufficient, i.e. the friend is permitted to click "share", however, that does not necessarily mean that the company is permitted to use the data shared in this manner. So every company that expects EU users to share their phone contact lists had better be very careful on what and how they do it - you can't rely on informing users or getting consent as you're informing someone else and getting someone else's consent.
- Rygian 6y agoIf "stupid" user A can tell Facebook to share user B's information with a third party, then I see Facebook evidently at fault. Only user B has the right to consent to such processing.
- lm28469 6y ago> Stupid users agreed to that. This is on the level of "poor people should just stop being poor" or "she was raped because she didn't dress decently enough" On on side you have a mega corp doing all it can to harvest as much data as possible, backed by behavioural analysis, AB testing, and all kind of studies on how to trick people's brain into feeding the algorithm with more data points. On the other hand you have "stupid users" The role of governments, at least in Europe, is, in part and in theory, to protect "stupid" people from mega corp sharks and other predators
- manux 6y agoYeah, this whole "people are stupid" argument is incredibly dismissive. Not surprising of tech people's giant ego. Do people really want their doctor to invest several hours a week understanding the latest shenanigans and dangers of technology? Or should we just let our doctors be good doctors? Replace "doctor" by any other non-tech profession you respect, and you get my point. This isn't even about protecting "stupid" people, it's about letting people be useful members of society even if they're not tech experts.
- Nextgrid 6y agoI absolutely think regulation should be in place to protect against people/companies acting maliciously (thus preventing a Cambridge Analytica from existing in the first place), and I guess the reason people were so trusting is because they do expect such regulations to exist. However, I disagree with modifying/removing a legitimate feature (API access) just because it can be abused. Otherwise, why not go further and also ban knives (or go after supermarkets that sell them) to solve knife crime?
- manux 6y ago> Otherwise, why not go further and also ban knives (or go after supermarkets that sell them) to solve knife crime? That sounds like a very slippery argument, but no, the way to solve knife crime is not to ban knifes, it's to understand and "fix" the reasons (systems) why people do knife crimes in the first place (e.g. poverty, poor mental health resources). In this case, we need to understand how the systems (e.g. the API) allowed for this to happen, and perhaps yes, get rid of it (or perhaps some other solution, I don't know, but beyond CA it seems that even a "legitimate" use of the API can easily cause harm).
- dkarp 6y ago> Cambridge Analytica used the Facebook API to ask users to share data about them & their friends This may be true technically, but if it was not made clear to the users what they were sharing and what their data would be used for then the users cannot legitimately agree. Facebook, as platform owners, can force organisation to be clear about what will be disclosed and what for. This is one of the goals of European GDPR and personally I don't think it needs to hinder legitimate usage. It just forces you to consider why you're collecting data, have a legitimate reason and disclose it to the user. Without that, companies have been hoovering up any user data they can get their hands on. User data should be a liability, rather than an asset.
- Nextgrid 6y ago> if it was not made clear to the users what they were sharing The Facebook OAuth consent prompt is pretty clear. > what their data would be used for This is an issue with Cambridge Analytica, not Facebook. Similarly, if a seller on eBay asks you to wire them money and then scams you, why should the bank be liable? Furthermore, Cambridge Analytica's actions apparently broke the Facebook API terms of use. There's nothing Facebook could've done here unless they can predict the future and retroactively deny access to companies that they know will break the rules in the future.
- nvoid 6y ago> I'm no Facebook fan I like how we have to preface our opinions with this now. I think if you're on HN it's a given at this point. I would agree with you that there are a lot of stupid people on the site and they will still find away to do something stupid. But I despise harsh regulation and I don't think that's necessarily the solution. However, when the stakes are so high (elections) I think there is something to be said for forcing Facebook to be accountable. Akin to a parent being responsible for a child, you shouldn't let them get into a situation where they can be that badly behaved.
- Nasrudith 6y agoThe stakes change nothing about who is actually responsible. If a terrorist steals your car and uses it for an attack does that mean it is right to hold you accountable because the matter is so serious? Facebook is not your parent. That logic, that others need to be "held accountable" and that voters are children who cannot be trusted to make up their own minds is far more dangerous to democracy than the Cambridge Analytica ratfucking.
- nvoid 6y agoSorry, should have made it clearer that Cambridge Analytica are the child in my analogy, but I think your point still stands. I don't think voters are children and I agree with you that that is dangerous thinking, but I do think that showing advertisements based off of data they didn't know they gave in order to change their vote is not the way to allow them to make their own decisions.
- hshshs2 6y agoIt’s not that voters can’t be trusted, they’re simply outgunned. To keep up everyone would need a personal lawyer reading every TOS they encounter. It’s insurmountable. Facebook has thousands of lawyers and engineers acting against your best interest when it comes to data privacy because they profit off of it. Very few people actually understand what they’re giving up and that’s by design. Hell there are lots of people on HN that don’t seem to understand the extent of control facebook exercises over you and your friends’ data, and I wouldn’t be surprised if that extended to some of the people actually building this stuff.
- neya 6y agoHere's a counter argument - API access is just one aspect of Facebook selling user data, as far as I know, Facebook will license its data via customized methods (eg. a custom API) if you pay a fee for its access. There are even vendors who provide data from Facebook that isn't available via what you see as public on their documentation. Governments around the world use this to get user data access from Facebook. To me, that is the real definition of selling user data. I think Facebook should be held responsible for that and also in general for being a sneaky leech of user data.
- Nextgrid 6y agoFacebook does not "sell" data and has absolutely nothing to gain by selling it or sharing it with Cambridge Analytica. CA abused a legitimate feature that allowed users to delegate access to their accounts. My comment is about how this lawsuit will set a bad precedent and restrict API access even further (hindering legitimate usage) without doing much to prevent abuse (because people can just share their credentials instead).
- soulofmischief 6y agoNo, I am not stupid, and I did not agree for my friends to sell out my personal data to the lowest bidder. This comment is not in good faith.
- dschuetz 6y agoAs Mr. Zuckerberg stated personally, the main product of Facebook are ads. That means, everything around ads and user tracking is their core business. Not whatever users do, but whatever users see and click when an ad is up. Making privacy settings more restrictive or convenient goes directly against Facebook's business model, as does transparency about data brokerage and third parties. Saying that basically the users are to blame, because they are sharing their data completely misses the motivation behind Facebook's pretense, that it's all about users, social media and making the world better. In reality it is about collecting and selling as much data and as much ads as possible, all while blatantly violating their users privacy.
- Nextgrid 6y agoThe Cambridge Analytica scandal has nothing to do with Facebook's business model and Facebook did not gain anything from this. To the best of my knowledge CA abused a free feature (API access) designed for legitimate usage to collect user data for nefarious purposes. Facebook was acting as a neutral carrier here and respected the user's intention of sharing their data with CA.
- ralston3 6y ago> The Cambridge Analytica scandal has nothing to do with Facebook's business model and Facebook did not gain anything from this. Hilarious. The Cambridge Analytica scandal is in regards to a nefarious 3rd party using Facebook's pipes in a way that violated Facebook's policy. There are emails to show that Facebook knew about this, and did not act to remove CA's access to said pipes (no, [1] there are literally emails about this that were found during discovery). You even mentioned it > To the best of my knowledge CA abused a free feature (API access) designed for legitimate usage to collect user data for nefarious purposes Yes. They abused it. They abused it and were allowed to continue abusing it because Facebook's business model is data, not user privacy. You're blaming CA for what FB quite literally (and I mean quite literally) allowed them to do, told them to stop doing, then turned a blind eye when CA _continued_ to do it. Again. Not my opinion. It's a matter of factual record. Links - https://www.businessinsider.com/facebook-emails-show-workers-knew-cambridge-analytica-2015-2019-8 https://www.businessinsider.com/facebook-emails-show-workers... - https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/social-media/newly-released-messages-reveal-when-facebook-first-knew-about-cambridge-n1045861 https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/social-media/newly-released-mes... Edit: Formatting
- dfxm12 6y agoCambridge Analytica used the Facebook API to ask users to share data about them & their friends. Stupid users agreed to that. According to Facebook, this is not what happened and CA's collection of this data represented a breach in their platform policies [0]: In 2015, we learned that a psychology professor at the University of Cambridge named Dr. Aleksandr Kogan lied to us and violated our Platform Policies by passing data from an app that was using Facebook Login to SCL/Cambridge Analytica ... He also passed that data to Christopher Wylie of Eunoia Technologies, Inc. [Kogan] did not subsequently abide by our rules. By passing information on to a third party, including SCL/Cambridge Analytica and Christopher Wylie of Eunoia Technologies, he violated our platform policies. 0 - https://about.fb.com/news/2018/03/suspending-cambridge-analytica/ https://about.fb.com/news/2018/03/suspending-cambridge-analy...
- ysavir 6y agoAnd does anything about this make Facebook liable for the way CA used the data willingly given to them by their users? Facebook is either: 1. a neutral party, acting on the wishes of its users, who asked to grant CA access to their data. The victims are users and the aggressor is CA for misusing data. Or: 2. a victim party, after CA went against their policies. CA is the aggressor in this scenario, and the users are not part of the equation.
- dragontamer 6y agoOr 3: The law works differently than you expect. Asking for a victim to find the "root cause" of a problem is too much to ask. If X wronged Y causes a wrong to happen to Z... the legal system is largely designed for "Z sues Y" then "Y sues X". Asking for Z to sue X directly is asking for too much. There's no way for Z to even know that X exists.
- ysavir 6y ago> There's no way for Z to even know that X exists Other than the time that X explicitly and directly asked Z for access to their data, you mean. This isn't similar to a case where I stored my users' info in a database on Cloud Hosting Service Inc machines, CHS's lax security allowed the data to be hacked, and I am now accountable to my users because I used an insecure service. Facebook's role in this situation was, literally speaking, a permissions broker between the end users and Dr. Kogan. The end users granted Dr. Kogan permission with every opportunity to learn about Dr. Kogan. Edit: Correction that users had a chance to learn about Dr. Kogan, not CA.
- Alex3917 6y agoBefore the Cambridge Analytica thing, everyone was saying that Facebook was evil because they were a walled garden. So they created an API, and now everyone is saying they're evil because they created an API. Go figure. There's even a Gaping Void cartoon memorializing the sentiment: http://vhirsch.com/blog/2011/10/06/walled-gardens/ http://vhirsch.com/blog/2011/10/06/walled-gardens/
- shuntress 6y agoThe API is criticized because (in addition to enabling malicious actions) it does nothing to increase the wall's permeability to users.
- Alex3917 6y ago> The API is criticized because (in addition to enabling malicious actions) it does nothing to increase the wall's permeability to users. Now, sure. Less so in 2010 or whenever.
- coding123 6y agoMaybe they are just evil...?
- leothecool 6y agoFacebook processed data without the consent of the subject of the data, right? (The friends of the user who agreed)
- hshshs2 6y agoWow you should really think twice before you start calling people stupid, it has the opposite effect that you intend... especially considering you’re not right in this case. Do you read the TOS of every service you sign up for? regardless, CA was found in violation of the TOS so there wasn’t much many people caught up in that scandal could have possibly done.
- staz 6y agoIIRC the issue with CA was that a friend could share my data without me knowing. It could have been data that I uploaded and not my friend (and maybe the friend didn't even know the existence of this data). I remember Facebook permissions for Apps in the past were quite laxes. I wonder even if theren't were data accessible to apps that were not visible from the browser interface.
- JustSomeNobody 6y ago> Stupid users agreed to that. Can we not do this, please? People are being manipulated like never before. Almost anyone is susceptible.
- Nextgrid 6y agoThere's plenty of manipulation out there (including by Facebook themselves), but I wouldn't consider an OAuth consent prompt as manipulation? Cambridge Analytica may have lied about their intentions, but when requesting access, the Facebook consent prompt is very clear about what data would be shared. Why should Facebook be on the hook for CA's lies?
- smolder 6y agoBeing able to share your friends data or even your own so coarsely was a bad design. If it were me designing an API for Facebook apps, you'd only be able to present user data to users from packaged queries, none of the user data would be directly accessible to the app maker, and monetization would only be through ad display or in-app purchases. It'd be a much less popular API since you can't extract users data, but IMO, it's the only sensible form such an API can take.
- TheRealDunkirk 6y ago> could set a bad precedent You're absolutely right. Holding companies responsible for bad outcomes due to their their products and practices would be very bad for our corporatocracy. So don't worry. I'm quite sure we're not going to start trifling with such nonsense now.
- DyslexicAtheist 6y agoto me the transcending point in all discussions about FB (or any company that peddles Ad-tech) is that they should not exist as a business in the first place. Targeted advertising as well as UE dark-patterns that lead to addiction and radicalization of vulnerable groups should be illegal. Problem solved.
- matsemann 6y ago> Facebook is a neutral carrier here, and they acted on behalf of the user - he decided that Cambridge Analytica should have had access to his data. You say that like it's okay that anyone else can press a button and then share my data. It's not my friends' to share, I'd say fb is at fault here for providing this to third parties.
- intricatedetail 6y agoJust because there is no law specifying exactly what happened it doesn't mean something is legal. Like there is no law that says it's illegal to hit people wearing yellow hats, but if you did that you'd certainly get in trouble. The same way you cannot agree for someone to murder you. Just because users agreed it means nothing.
- Daho0n 6y ago>Cambridge Analytica used the Facebook API to ask users to share data about them & their friends. Stupid users agreed to that. Stupid users aren't allowed to say yes to share personal information on their friends. Only the friends are. That is how it should be. An API should never give access to other users data than the one who agreed. Luckily because of GDPR they now can't, though the same rules were there in most of the EU already so it was always illegal at least some of it. IMO the rules should be even tighter and the punishments harsher.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y ago"Facebook is a neutral carrier here, and they acted on behalf of the user..." I think that argument is fatally flawed. The issue with all these user data cases is that the license between the user and Facebook does not restrict how Facebook can use the data. Not simply the data the user submits[1] but the data that Facebook involuntarily collects from the user. 1. This always seems to be how outside observers define "the user's data". They believe it is the data (e.g., photos, etc.) that the user has submitted to Facebook. Facebook may be an optimal place to store photos, etc. Regardless of whether that is true, that is not what is at issue. The issue is what use Facebook is permitted. Can it use the data a user submits any way that it chooses. Yes, it can. Can Facebook collect data on the user, based on their usage, and other sources. Yes, they can. The user has no control over how Facebook uses that data. This is the "loss of control". It is not always concerned with "transfers" of data, necessarily. It is concerned with how Facebook may use the data it receives from users (knowingly/voluntarily or unknowingly/involuntarily) to support its business. Users pay nothing to Facebook so obviously the data, Facebook's primary asset, is going to be used in ways that generate revenue for Facebook. Users have no say in the decisions over how the data will be used, yet it is "their data" (or data about them). Can it be used in academic research. Yes, it can. Market research. Yes. Users have no control over these uses. It is not simply a matter of changing some setting, which Facebook is constantly fiddling with. It is a matter of the the license the user has with Facebook. The user has no enforceable rights throught that license to control how the data is used.