20 ms·
TurboTax’s 20-Year Fight to Stop Americans from Filing Taxes for Free (2019)
- nodesocket 6y agoUltimately this is not up companies to decided, but for lawmakers to simplify taxes and reduce loopholes and complications. I am self employed, and it took me a few years to figure out properly how to pay and not overpay for all my taxes. The entire tax system is insane, depreciated assets, tracking car mileage, LLC fees and taxes, annual report filings, and paying quarterly taxes.
- whatthesmack 6y agoThis is so true. I don't think most folks understand how complex it all is, otherwise there would be more pushback to legislators that "allow" (through inaction) the tax code to be so complicated. It certainly has discouraged some from running their own business, because complying with it all costs time and money, which are resources large corporations have plenty of, but small businesses have precious little of.
- sebmellen 6y agoThe leaked internal slides from Intuit are really disgusting [0][1]. From the article: > Internal presentations lay out company tactics for fighting “encroachment,” Intuit’s catchall term for any government initiative to make filing taxes easier — such as creating a free government filing system or pre-filling people’s returns with payroll or other data the IRS already has. “For a decade proposals have sought to create IRS tax software or a ReturnFree Tax System; All were stopped,” reads a confidential 2007 PowerPoint presentation from an Intuit board of directors meeting. The company’s 2014-15 plan included manufacturing “3rd-party grass roots” support. “Buy ads for op-eds/editorials/stories in African American and Latino media,” one internal PowerPoint slide states. I'm always stunned and disappointed at how easy it is to game the American political system. I say that with great respect for this country and the freedoms it affords me, but those freedoms mean little if skullduggery like this goes on. [0]: https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/6483065-Intuit-board-of-directors-presentation-2007.html https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/6483065-Intuit-board... [1]: https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/6483061-Intuit-TurboTax-2014-15-Encroachment-Strategy.html https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/6483061-Intuit-Turbo...
- macjohnmcc 6y agoAnd it is relatively inexpensive.
- sebmellen 6y agoAnd a good investment. For example, an 86,000% return on $43,000 in campaign donations: https://truthout.org/articles/you-too-can-buy-a-congressman/ https://truthout.org/articles/you-too-can-buy-a-congressman/.
- csharpminor 6y agoOne of the major points I took away from Lessig’s Republic, Lost is that these campaign donations trackers are unable to factor in the credible threat of a donor funding an opponent. The dollar amount may be relatively low, but the value to an incumbent politician is that wealthy stakeholders will not fund a challenger.
- sebmellen 6y agoThat's a very interesting game-theoretic view of the issue. I've got to read that book, thank you for the recommendation.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> One of the major points I took away from Lessig’s Republic, Lost is that these campaign donations trackers are unable to factor in the credible threat of a donor funding an opponent. They also aren't able to factor in independent expenditures (especially direct independent expenditures), or facilitation of donations (bundling) as opposed to direct donation, as well as the credible threat of doing those things, as well as direct donation, in the opposite direction.
- ultimoo 6y agoI was taken aback by this the most when I saw some lobbying dollar amounts earlier this year — I don’t recollect the specifics but most are probably rounding errors for multi-billion dollar Fortune 500 companies, let alone trillion dollar tech juggernauts.
- throe455 6y agoIn here we file taxes over internet. Tax administration takes about 10 hours every year. I am self employed dev, deal with multiple countries.
- Twirrim 6y agoIn the UK most people never file taxes. It's all done Pay As You Earn (PAYE), i.e. taken out of your monthly pay check. You get an annual summary of your tax payments every year, as well as it being detailed each month on your pay stub. People that are self employed tend to need to do self-file, or those with slightly more complicated investment approaches but even then that's generally not a particular hard task. One of the other advantages of it, is it discourages a rebate based approach to incentives. With most people not needing to file taxes each year, rebates wouldn't be particularly effective at encouraging behaviour. The government instead opts for subsidies, so the item is cheaper _at the time of purchase_. No shelling out the extra money and then eventually clawing it back, without any interest it might have accrued for you. It was quite a shock when I moved to the US and got to experience the "delights" of filing taxes here.
- refurb 6y agoHow many people go through the process of making sure the gov’ts calculations are right? And for those that don’t, how many are losing out on money because of an error?
- recursive 6y agoHow many people that do their own calculations actually come up with a lower number than the government would have charged them in the first place?
- cranekam 6y agoAlmost none, because that’s highly unlikely for most people. The system is designed such that most tax-related things don’t need a return and end of year squaring up. Income is taxed monthly by subtracting the correct amount. Interest is tax free to a threshold then has automatic withholding. Investments and savings can be held in tax-free wrappers with no reporting requirement. Benefits are paid outside of the tax system, etc.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- MattGaiser 6y agoThere is another interesting angle to Free File. If you are really annoyed at having to pay to file your taxes, there is a pressure relief value you will inevitably find that will make you reasonably content. Anyone who really wants to not pay doesn't, so there is never a critical mass of passionate people.
- yalogin 6y agoThere is really no losing for them here. They make the whole thing more complicated and make money. As part of this they "lobby" lawmakers and so the lawmakers are happy. The candidates running for office get to use "streamining tax filing" as an election promise from time to time. Its a win-win all around for them. There is no way this changes.
- ehsankia 6y agoYou can tell there's no losing by the fact that these kind of reporting about how the whole thing is rigged has been around for years now and nothing has changed. That generally shows how locked in this whole situation is.
- ibdf 6y agoI’ve been paying for it for years and honestly I don’t regret it. There’s a lot that goes into their software that makes filing taxes really easy. Their site also provides so much help during the filing that I would probably spend hours researching otherwise. It’s not for everyone and yes I agree their taxes are deceiving, but does save me time each year.
- dboreham 6y agoI think the point is that tax filing being difficult, hence software to "make it really easy" is in some part their fault.
- 2Gkashmiri 6y agowhy cant the govt build a frigging excel sheet or a website for filing taxes because "THEY MAKE THE RULES" of what goes into a tax software. This is one of those things that is used by companies to force people into their ecosystem. in india, the govt makes 4/6 tax returns available to be filed on the govt portal itself. It has a simple workflow based approach, asks you a few questions and in minutes you are done. Software companies exist alongside them but there is no "bad blood" between the two because they both do the same thing. the software companies products make it easier for tax professionals to keep a record and such but otherwise millions of users just dont bother with paid offerings. that is a much better alternative than the one US has
- croutonwagon 6y agoI think the issue is less the truth I. Your statement (it’s undeniable really). But more that it’s by design. Intuit lobbies the govt to make the tax system over complicated, and the gov provided tax documents half asses as hell. And then along with few others (H&R Block for example) make a killing by having software that easily navigated the shit hurricane they otherwise would be a tax filing. Hell H&R Block can literally hire part time meth heads and window washers to fill out the forms, while without the software a Bonaire accountant can fuck up a filing.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 6y ago
- esturk 6y agoI often do my taxes twice with a cheaper competitor and then use Turbo Tax to double check my results. Let me tell you, Turbo Tax often gets a worse off final result. For example, I changed jobs in Q2 and exceeded my Social Security contribution last year. For some reason, the cheaper competitor actually caught that and got me a better result than Turbo Tax.
- mydj 6y agowho is the cheaper competitor?
- ghoward 6y agoI don't know who the cheaper competitor that the GP refers to, but I use freetaxusa.com, and they are great. (Disclaimer: my wife is an employee, and they are great as employers too.)
- prossercj 6y agoJust want to stop by and say that I love FreeTaxUsa too. They have exceeded my expectations these last three years. No gimmicks or upselling, just straightforward forms with labelled boxes matching those on the government forms. Free federal filing, $13 for my state filing. Remembers my AGI and other relevant info (i.e. employer's address) from year to year. Less than an hour to file everything this year. They do also offer a deluxe product which includes assistance in case of an audit. I have no formal connection to them, just a very satisfied customer.
- ghoward 6y agoI let my wife know. Thank you. :)
- dietr1ch 6y agoI did this with freetaxusa.com and turbotax on 2019 and ended up ditching turbotax for a better return with lower fees. I now have to copy fields, but I double checked them anyways, so I think it's faser to input them myself. It's just triple clicking on a pdf and middle clicking on the browser
- giantDinosaur 6y agoAmazing. The most difficult thing I had to do with tax last year was wait until my employer pressed a button they had forgotten to press on some web form. Then it all filled out instantly.
- piyushpr134 6y agoIt is a shame that some parts of American govt is such a slave of big businesses that they keep public good behind corporate good. For instance: gun ownership, monopoly of car dealerships for unfair & opaque practice, not upgrading railroads to help it compete with airlines, state & non-investment in public transport in non major cities, allowing large wall street cos to manipulate the markets
- masonic 6y agogun ownership You think big business that actively contributes to politicians favors gun ownership? The opposite is true. Michael Bloomberg's spending alone against gun ownership dwarfs the spending of the entire "gun lobby" combined.
- jsweojtj 6y agoI wonder if some hedge funds looking to short their next target might do a cost benefit analysis of how much a hit to Intuit's stock price might occur for $X spent in lobbying for widespread free tax return prep.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vmception 6y agololol thats a good play, they are now
- teach 6y ago[2019]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mmaunder 6y agoThis was published October 2019.
- jzer0cool 6y agoI forget from what country. Years ago with a bunch of international friends one mentioned you don't really do taxes at all. If you received wages, it is the company's duty to file them and it's done. Filing taxes does seem complicated here in the U.S. when you may have also other forms of ordinary income. So many rules, forms, etc. I wonder if people use something like TurboTax because they are just not aware how to complete this task, unless, systematically hand held in a way and just walk through getting it done before the deadline.
- mtrower 6y agoThat's seriously a large part of it.
- junon 6y agoEx-pat American living in Germany. Unless you have some slightly less common situation, you don't have to worry about taxe filing here.
- kall 6y agoYou really should though. I would say it‘s only a safe bet if you worked the same job for the entire year, got no bonuses and had no other income at all (even from the state). Otherwise you either have to do it or you are missing out on credits. It‘s pretty straightforward too. If you want you can only file your basic personal data and bank account and have the information already submitted by the employer electronically picked up. That way you can get any obvious credits for e.g. uneven earnings.
- junon 6y ago> if you worked the same job for the entire year, got no bonuses and had no other income at all I would wager this is most people working a 9-5. That's my point. It's optional, entirely. In the US, it is not. You are forced to file, every year, by penalty of law (really nasty IRS calls/visits/audits). And in order to file, you must wade through endless forms and confusing tax law, usually missing a tax break costing you more - unless, that is, you use software. And that's the rub - those software vendors are the ones lobbying against simplifying tax processess so that citizens are forced into using their software. It's not a "maybe this is happening". This is a "definitely happening" thing for decades now.
- vyrotek 6y agoHow much of this mess would go away if we didn't have income tax and increased sales tax?
- sdenton4 6y agoMy foot was hurting, so I cut it off and now just walk on my hands. Which is to say, that's a terribly obtuse way to deal with the problem, and does nothing to keep this kind of abuse from surfacing in other domains.
- vyrotek 6y agoThe idea here is to shift the work to more streamlined systems already ran by businesses instead of relying on individual citizens to figure this all out. Citizens are not equipped with the time and money to deal with these abuses. Large private businesses who are already optimizing these expenses might keep things in check. It's not a unique idea. In fact, I first heard it from IRS employees themselves.
- conanbatt 6y agoThere is no reason for pushing tax accounting into businesses to be better than for it to be on the citizens. It does not make it a better tax, it does not make necesarily make it cheaper to manage, and it has the gravest of dangers of misaligning the incentives between the net tax payer and the net tax consumer.
- imtringued 6y agoHere is a simple example. You buy 10 stocks from Robinhood for $50. You sell them for $75. You now have to pay taxes on this. The broker can just inform the government of this taxable event and thus automatically deduct the tax for you. One argument in favor of filing taxes yourself is that you can transfer the stocks to a different broker. No single broker knows what you have been doing with your stocks. However, the government already exists as a central entity and it can simply receive a full record of all taxable events from all brokers. Where do you see this misaligning the incentives between the net tax payer and the net tax consumer? If anything, it would make cryptocurrency based credit cards viable as a means of payment because the taxation problem is no longer intractable for the individual tax payer.
- nexthash 6y agoGosh, Intuit has gone on a total advertising offensive recently! It seems every ad on YouTube nowadays has the same jingle: 'free free freefree freefreefree'. They are advertising their free tax filing service and advisors, which I'm sure everybody here knows is a Trojan horse disguising their lobbying to take away actual free filing provided by the government. Here's the catch: they make it really difficult to use their software for free: you have to have a very specific financial status (under $66k a year in income) and for a long time they just blatantly hid it [1]. Those ads make my blood boil whenever they come up, but the production quality/creativity is Geico-level. They must've spent a lot of money to steer people from the truth... [1] https://www.propublica.org/article/turbotax-just-tricked-you-into-paying-to-file-your-taxes https://www.propublica.org/article/turbotax-just-tricked-you...
- eel 6y agoI don't qualify for "Free File" tax software, but I still file my taxes for free using the IRS forms. It's easy. Yes, it could be easier, and yes, Intuit's tactics are repulsive, but the fact remains that filing individual income taxes is easy and free. I would not be surprised if articles like these are just another form of PR for tax preparation companies. The goal of these articles seem to be to convince us that taxes are complicated and difficult.
- qwertay 6y agoHow easy is it? The system here in Australia seems super well done. They already have all my data. I just look through it and confirm its correct and add in any deductions I want to make.
- ac29 6y agoIts not terribly difficult if you only have say wage income and some interest on a bank account [0]. But, it can get very complex very quickly if you have other sources of income, or want to be sure to take all of the deductions you might be eligible for. On top of that, each state has their own set of taxes (though in my experience, they are simpler and largely rely on information from the federal taxes). Hence why most people use software or pay tax professionals to prepare their taxes for them. The IRS probably could provide a more or less pre-filled form for many people. They have the information on most taxable income already. However, they dont. The reasons for this are complex, like the tax code, but mostly boil down to "politics". [0] Here's the main tax form: https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f1040.pdf https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f1040.pdf
- jimsug 6y agoI think that it's straightforward enough in Australia, but that's partially because we file and pay only federal taxes, with states levying payroll tax, land tax (or stamp duty), etc, but those are less frequent transactions and generally accountants are involved. For federal taxes, payroll systems typically transmit your data to our taxation office on each payrun, and then a few weeks (or sometimes, immediately) after the end of the financial year, your details are already in the system and you just need to hit the button to submit. Our tax office has also tried to make it easier for individuals with simple requirements to keep records of work-related tax deductions, etc, such that you can use a mobile app to record them, and then it can also be imported into your return with a single click. I think for many people - myself included - it's easy enough that you can (and I have) complete it on your phone on the way to work on July 1st (the first day of our income tax year, and the first day you can file for the prior year).
- EnderWT 6y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21281411 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21281411
- jb775 6y agoI swear I've read some version of this headline yearly for at least the past 5 years. They are clearly winning this fight.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoThis reminds me: I was kind of late in reading Lean Startup only two years ago, and I was surprised to see Intuit to be described there as length and in positives, pretty much a role model for innovation. I guess the book needs an update to this example, a chapter on what it means to take innovation too far.
- HotVector 6y agoAt this point it's not innovation, just American politics.
- tristor 6y agoIntuit is truly a scummy company with the way they behave here and elsewhere. A simple example of one of these behaviors is that you cannot export data as CSV from Quickbooks Online, instead if only exports as a PDF or as an Excel XLSX file. But the XLSX is carefully crafted so it reads out zeroes (0s) in all value fields if opened with LibreOffice or any conversion tools to get a CSV. Why do I know this? I don't have any Windows computers, I mostly work on a Mac, and Intuit doesn't make TurboTax Business for Mac, only for Windows. TaxAct has an online service for filing 1120S/K-1 for LLCs which can import data via CSV that works on any OS, so Intuit responded by no longer offering CSV exports and ensuring they're broken using F/OSS tools. Really is making it a challenge to comply with the law this year for my LLC without me having to have Windows + Office 365 licenses.
- morpheuskafka 6y agoHmm that's really obnoxious, but why would Intuit benefit from forcing people to buy Excel? They don't make any money from that.
- archon 6y agoThey benefit by preventing easy access to an export of the user’s data that could then be importied into a competitor’s software, thereby (presumably) locking in a non-trivial number of their own user base who don’t want to deal with the hassle of re-entering all of their financial data in a new product.
- TeMPOraL 6y agoIIRC, they have an Excel plugin. So it's more like: stick with our SaaS; if you really prefer a desktop app, stick to Excel (and our plugin).
- fladrif 6y agoI'm not sure why it doesn't seem to be more well known, but CreditKarma has allowed free filing of taxes (incl. capital gains), and was recently acquired by Intuit. Last I read they were under investigation by the Department of Justice because of the implications they were eliminating a competitor. Comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24038559 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24038559 I've used it for the past 2 years, and it has worked great for me, albeit I don't have very complicated taxes. I'm actually afraid of what happens if the acquisition goes through, definitely expecting the free tax filing to disappear soon after that occurs.
- tdhoot 6y agoThis has already been settled; Square will take Credit Karma Tax to prevent Intuit from absorbing a competitor. https://www.forbes.com/sites/jonathanponciano/2020/11/25/doj-forces-credit-karma-to-sell-tax-unit-to-square-71-billion-intuit-turbotax-takeover-antitrust/?sh=1da79ccf2dc8 https://www.forbes.com/sites/jonathanponciano/2020/11/25/doj...
- tzs 6y agoI wonder how they are going to handle the Credit Karma Tax name? According to this announcement [1] from 2020-12-03, Intuit has completed the acquisition of Credit Karma. I logged in to Credit Karma today to do my taxes, and the tax link on the main page took me to tax.creditkarma.com where I found the familiar Credit Karma tax stuff, with a notice on the bottom of the page that says: > Tax preparation services are provided by Credit Karma Tax, Inc. a subsidiary of Square, Inc. So, it appears that Square is indeed now handling it, but it is still tied in with Intuit's Credit Karma. I wonder if that is just some transitory thing for the 2020 tax year and for 2021 it will be on a Square domain, and the Credit Karma mail site will link to TurboTax for tax prep instead? [1] https://investors.intuit.com/news/news-details/2020/Intuit-Completes-Acquisition-of-Credit-Karma/default.aspx https://investors.intuit.com/news/news-details/2020/Intuit-C...
- petejames 6y agoIn Ireland, employees pay as they go through the year and don't have to file return. For self employed there is very simple online system provided by the Government. I despise the US tax system.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tadfisher 6y agoTechnically the system is pay-as-you-go in the US; employers are required to withhold estimated tax from paychecks and pay the IRS in the employee's name, or quarterly payments are made if self-employed. The broken part is that you will receive penalties if you withhold too little, or you end up loaning cash to the IRS until you file for a refund; and there are far too many variables that change the actual tax you owe for the year, so there's no way to get the number exact except in limited circumstances. A "cheap" fix would be to eliminate deductions, and automate marginal withholding. An expensive fix would be to service deductions on a rolling basis, applying them to future income withholding.
- the_arun 6y agoThis is an old article already discussed last year - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21281411 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21281411. We should mention year in the title.
- hilbert42 6y agoIt's little wonder that democracy is in a state of decline and that faith in our public institutions is at an all time low when government can be so easily corrupted by disingenuous carpetbaggers such as Intuit. It's not as if this corruption of process by Intuit is an isolated instance, the trouble is that it's commonplace. It seems to me that the first step in citizens reclaiming their democracy back and having our faith and integrity restored in our institutions is to take charge of the lobbying process and rescue it from corporate interests and other bad influences. I would go so far as to suggest all lobbying of politicians be done in public and that to bypass the system of public scrutiny be made a felony. This may sound like highfalutin idealism and overkill but after what we've witnessed in Washington in recent weeks we can no longer ignore the fact that trust in our governance is at an alltime low - and that as citizens we have a collective responsibility to ensure we fix the problem. We have to break the nexus of mistrust between the Citizenry and Government and desperate times call for desperate measures.
- tehjoker 6y agoJust a tangential historical note: the carpetbaggers were the good guys. They went from the North to the defeated Confederacy to take advantage of the votes of newly freed slaves. The acquired such disdain for precisely that reason. https://www.britannica.com/topic/carpetbagger https://www.britannica.com/topic/carpetbagger
- hilbert42 6y agoRight, like so many other things these days, the term has been corrupted. Guilty as changed. ;-)
- hilbert42 6y agoDuh! I meant 'as charged' (damn edit doesn't stay active long enough).
- fastball 6y agoI'm not sure "good guys" is correct. They went seeking to further their own fortunes (whether financial or political), which is mostly amoral – you can increase your own fortune by collaborating with others but you can also increase your fortune by taking advantage of others. I think the carpetbagger comparison is rather apropos. In the same way as carpetbaggers, you can be a lobbyist who genuinely suggests things that are good for the American people and also are good for the corporate interests you represent. Alternatively you can lobby for things which benefit your corporate interests at the expense of the American people. Unfortunately seems like lobbying in the US is almost entirely the latter. And maybe postbellum carpetbaggers were in fact more of the former. But it's a similar scenario.
- doorty 6y agoSame story every year around tax filing time but nothing changes.
- tal8d 6y agoTheir letters and journals make it clear that the founders knew that lobbyists would be a threat to the integrity of the republic, but they thought that all the competing interests would largely cancel each other out. They could have used a little game theory to show that wasn't the case, as it will always be far more profitable to be the aggressor than the defender. If I want to take a penny from every tax payer in the country, I'm far more motivated than you are to guard your one penny. Even if the tax base were to unite in opposition, I have an infinite number of opportunities to try again. Power words: MPAA, SOPA, PIPA, DMCA, Tipper Gore.
- HotVector 6y agoI would love to see some sources on this.
- sircastor 6y agoI’m annoyed at Intuit’s purchase of Credit Karma last year. Even with the obligatory sale of its tax division to Square, Intuit eliminated a competitor. Square will have to build up the customer base and visibility of the tax product, provided they intend to do anything with it similar to what CreditKarma was. Intuit should simply not have been allowed to buy them.
- paulpan 6y agoAbsolutely this. The purchase of Credit Karma is textbook "buying out a competitor", especially since Credit Karma's tax solution was offered for "free" to customers. Why did the government not intervene? There's hardly better evidence of political capture by the corporate America as that one.
- airstrike 6y agoGenerally, the DOJ won't block "buying out a competitor" unless you're approaching monopoly levels of consolidation. It's fine by the DOJ to have the number of players reduced from even 4 to just 3 and they are only really forced to act when it comes down to an attempt to reduce from 3 to 2
- dataflow 6y agoIf anyone here has Credit Karma: get off it. Use free monitoring services from Discover/Chase/Experian/etc.
- leetcrew 6y agoif you're a chase/amex/discover customer, by all means use their free service. I particularly like the amex one that lets you do hypothetical projections. I can't recommend experian though. I just made an account with them out of curiosity, and since then I have received emails from them pretty much every day trying to upsell me on their (worthless, as far as I can tell) "premium" features. the website itself is full of dark patterns trying to make the same upsell.
- FrozenVoid 6y agoThe root of the problem is a tax system that requires complex software to use optimally. Remove this complexity and the need for specialized, expensive software companies will disappear.
- milofeynman 6y agoI have had bad experience with RSUs and ESPP through TurboTax. Do any competitors handle it better? Should I just seek out a professional?
- neilfrndes 6y agoThis is a nice NPR episode about how a professor tried fighting back against Intuit in California and almost won. https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2017/03/22/521132960/episode-760-tax-hero https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2017/03/22/521132960/epis...
- zindlerb 6y agoSomeone needs to start a non-profit competitor to TurboTax that uses its fees to advocate for simplifying tax policy.
- asdff 6y agoIntuit will acquire or break the company before it gets legs
- crowf 6y agoI don't live in America, and haven't lived there for nearly my entire life. But my parents are citizens, and they graciously gave me US citizenship. Now, while I earn money abroad, live abroad, receive support from my government abroad, I still have to file taxes in the US. For the most part I don't have to pay, but I end up paying a couple hundred dollars for someone to file my taxes. Most of the online tools don't know what to do about people not living in the US. Also, as a fortunate Hi-Tech worker, I will soon earn enough money that I will have to pay the US government taxes for money that I earned abroad. I've looked into renouncing my US citizenship, but that costs a few thousand dollars. And, the US can reject it for several reasons, one of which is tax avoidance. Also, as per the rumors, it is nearly impossible to get a US Visa after that (and I still have American relatives who I would like to see). Seeing as us expats don't have a senator or congressman, we don't really have someone to fight for us. At least I am still allowed to vote. Before every election that I am eligible to vote in, I email the candidates and ask them what their stance is on taxing foreigners (and don't get me started on the fbar). Based on their response I vote.
- icefrakker 6y agoTldr: you care only about how much you are taxed.
- divbzero 6y agoThe American system of worldwide taxation based on citizenship is extremely strange and shared by just a handful of other nations such as Eritrea, Hungary, and Myanmar. [1] Even more odd was the decision to shift to territorial taxation with the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017, but only for corporations and only for income earned with tangible assets overseas. [2] [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_taxation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_taxation [2]: https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/what-territorial-tax-and-does-united-states-have-one-now https://www.taxpolicycenter.org/briefing-book/what-territori...
- crowf 6y agoThanks for the second link. I remember hearing rumors about how the Trump administration would finally remove worldwide taxation. I guess the result was the end (or ease) of worldwide taxation for corporations only.
- leafmeal 6y ago> “Dark patterns are something that are spoken of with pride and encouraged in design all hands” meetings, said one former designer.
- PaulStatezny 6y agoIt's repulsing that this kind of thing happens. It's because of the greed and sleaziness of companies like that that we end up needing regulation.
- alew1 6y agoI've always been under the IRS Free File income threshold (I've worked as a high school teacher and am now in grad school), but last year after reading this article was the first time I actually filed for free. That was after 5 years of paying for deluxe TurboTax. I had heard the government required TurboTax to have a free edition. But back in 2019 (and before), if you Googled "TurboTax free" you'd be taken to a decoy free edition; the real one was called their "freedom edition," and was hidden from Google's listings. If your tax situation is 'too complicated,' the free edition tries to upsell you to the "deluxe edition," even if the "freedom edition" could have handled the situation just fine. Thankfully now you can find the actual free version on Google, but it's still very confusing that the "free edition" is less free than the (still somewhat hidden) IRS Free File ("freedom") version. And the faux Free Edition is still being heavily advertised.
- divbzero 6y agoGood for you. I’ve made an effort to avoid TurboTax for similar reasons, just can’t stand the thought of giving money to a company that lobbies to keep our taxes complicated. Spreadsheet, PDF, and snail mail have worked fine for me so far but I would eagerly welcome a saner tax system. For anyone else looking to stop paying Intuit, the IRS provides an intro and links to their official Free File options. [1] [1]: https://www.irs.gov/filing/free-file-do-your-federal-taxes-for-free https://www.irs.gov/filing/free-file-do-your-federal-taxes-f...
- segfaultbuserr 6y ago> if you Googled "TurboTax free" you'd be taken to a decoy free edition; the real one was called their "freedom edition," TurboTax sounds like Free Software Foundation's evil twin... "When we speak of freedom, it's a matter of price, not liberty. You should think of freedom as in free beer, not free speech!"
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vidarh 6y agoPatriot Act with Hasan Minhaj did a segment on this, and also set up a site to link to the real free programs of various companies. It's here: https://www.turbotaxsucksass.com/ https://www.turbotaxsucksass.com/
- loycombinate 6y agoCredit Karma’s free file could be the end of paid tax filing. We may see an ad supported model, or synergies, like if Microsoft gives free tax software for office users. History has shown many software that was once paid become free, as entrepreneurs figure out a way to give it away and still monetize it.
- atemerev 6y agoI have had my taxes filled incorrectly by the government about 5 times, each time about 300-400% of the right amount (Switzerland). Thanks but no thanks. This is like "why do you need an attorney if the government can give you one for free"?
- known 6y ago"Never let your inferiors do you a favor. It'll be extremely costly" --Mencken (b. 1880)