11 ms·
Cambridge Analytica psychologist advising Covid19 disinformation network
- uncledave 6y agoI still don’t understand what people have to gain from this line of thought and applying your skills to promoting it. Surely it’s an evolutionary and career dead end?
- Veen 6y agoA lot of it is motivated by libertarianism. They don’t like the idea that the Government can unilaterally impose a form of house arrest on the entire population while mandating what people wear(masks) and who they can meet. I don’t agree, but I don’t think it’s an entirely crazy position either.
- avereveard 6y agoAnd the position is multifaceted. I agree with the curfew but not with the business limitations, or at the very least not in the way they implemented it here trough a legislative decree, since the Italian Constitution is built around the right to work an has no exception for health issues.
- Closi 6y agoI agree with the viewpoint (somewhat). I agree with mask mandates and commerce closures, but when the government starts making it illegal to meet my family, including outside and in own house, then that crosses a civil liberties line for me personally. A reasonable person could hold the opposite view. A reasonable person could hold the 'total lockdown' view. But if you hold the 'anti-lockdown' viewpoint you risk being told you have just been reading 'disinformation' these days. I don't see anti-lockdown as disinformation, that's a policy option. I also don't see it as disinformation to believe that governments are utilising propaganda to either make Covid sound worse / better according to what fits their policy narrative - that's what governments do! There is lots of genuine disinformation about Covid, but we have to be careful that we don't just brand opposing opinions as disinformation and fake news. > The network is using tried and tested techniques of psychological propaganda to manipulate the public and cast pressure on governments. It has already arguably paved the way for more than 100,000 COVID-19 deaths in the UK – and will likely lead to many more. Now ironically THIS is ACTUAL misinformation. To blame the 'network' for ALL Covid deaths in the UK is just ridiculous. I personally don't think the use of 'arguably' here absolves them from the fact the claim is clearly false.
- willvarfar 6y agoGoing off on a tangent, the kind of people who don’t like the government mandating masks are also the kind of people most against men wearing skirts and people wearing nothing at all?
- exporectomy 6y agoUnless you can show that any such person exists, you're just making them up. Even if they do exist, what's wrong with being opposed to a government imposed dress code while also having your own personal preference for how you like people to dress?
- Closi 6y agoThat assumes that there is some sort of intentional disinformation here. It seems to me that this guy genuinely believes what he is saying.
- krona 6y agoDisinformation is intentional. There is no evidence provided in the article that anything presented is disinformation. Guilt by tentative association seems to count as investigative journalism these days, but really it's just seeding a conspiracy.
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoBrexit and Trump-won were both driven by engines of disinformation. And there are plenty of other examples, from climate denial to examples that seem even more ridiculous today - like the smoking industry's campaign to pretend that smoking is safe and doesn't kill people. If you trace the links you'll see the same names, the same organisations, and the same funding sources appearing again and again. When someone lies consistently, it's irrational to conclude on the basis of no evidence at all that they've suddenly gone white hat and are now acting entirely in a public-spirited and wholly reputable way.
- exporectomy 6y ago> Brexit and Trump-won were both driven by engines of disinformation. Is that true or are you a victim of disinformation yourself? How do you know they would have lost had it not been for "engines of disinformation"? I'm not saying there wasn't disinformation used to promote them, but did they win because of it or despite it?
- pjc50 6y agoTrump's 4 year term is a convincing argument that people realised they'd been lied to. As is the rolling up of the people who stormed the capitol over disinformation.
- xuhu 6y agoPeople have more power when they form a group. And some will promote any conviction as long as it tips the scales in their favor. It's A/B testing driven politics.
- exporectomy 6y agoMaybe they simply have an opinion, like everyone else does. Do you really not understand why people think this:? "“Again, with my tinfoil conspiracy hat on, these things all distance us and isolate us from each other and make us easier to control I think.”" Just look at the common ideas about the increased security after 9/11. It was similar "conspiracy theories" about the government using terrorism as an excuse to spy on people until Snowden showed they actually were. It used to be popular to use the quote "Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety.". Surely you can understand why some people feel that way? It's OK to not be a conformist and it's good that we have people brave enough to do so openly.
- uncledave 6y agoI can understand why that is the case. But I have also buried two members of my family. So quite frankly they can fuck off. There’s a compromise somewhere in the middle in the grey area which is actually the situation that we’re in despite it being explained as black and white but these nut cases. We also in this case have to consider cultural differences. America is obsessed with a somewhat bent and selfish form of personal Liberty which ends up as another lever on which compromise is impossible. Liberty for the other person is their right not to be harmed by your liberty as well don’t forget. America just ends up ending up having a right to the highest body count.
- pjc50 6y agoThere's money in it. An entire alternate world where you can say what you like without regard to the facts on the ground.
- macawfish 6y agoIs it just me or are some of these billionaires serious misanthropists?
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoPerhaps calling them psychopaths is too severe. Although given recent events, perhaps it isn't.
- Veen 6y ago> hard-right politicians in the Conservative Party and Nigel Farage’s Brexit Party. It’s an interesting article, but there are no hard-right politicians in either of those parties, unless you consider everyone right of Tony Blair to be a borderline fascist.
- zpeti 6y agoYou've got it right. Far right IS anyone right of Tony Blair. (according to these people)
- estaseuropano 6y agoWhat would be hard right if not the nationalist brexit party and the literal right wing of the Tories? If you look in the national context or in comparison to any EU country they fall in the hard right, with farage certainly on the far right. When they were still in the EU parliament Cameron even split from the conservative group (Merkel, Sarkozy) to found a new more right group jointly with the far right polish government party and a few nationalist groups from other countries, with Farage leading an even more right group jointly with the French Front National. There's also the literal Nazis/BNP on the further fringe, but in any context Farage and the right side of the Tories fall on the hard/far right
- krona 6y agoWhat would be hard right if not the nationalist brexit party Compared to what? The Brexit Party has several ex-members of the Revolutionary Communist Party.
- pjc50 6y agoThey are, bizarrely, hard-right these days; they pivoted straight round the horseshoe in the mid-90s. Claire Fox is now a baroness, which tells you exactly how revolutionary or communist she is.
- underslung 6y agoOk. So what would constitute as hard/far left? Under your definitions' it seems like being a nationalist (believing in the nation-state and sovereignty) & white supremacy are synonymous — which obviously they are not, unless you are suggesting all nationalists are racist or something.
- jonplackett 6y agoWhat are these people’s agenda? Do they actually believe this crap or are they trying to create instability?
- krona 6y agoThere's very little substance to the article and it reads like it was designed to gaslight the reader. There's no evidence of disinformation - being incorrect and talking about it doesn't imply intent or motivation to deceive.
- zpeti 6y agoPeople in HN need to start understanding, that while most of us can work from home, earn a living, be fairly happy (especially if you're living with someone). You simply cannot even begin to asses the financial and psychological damage of every single waiter, or coffee shop barrista, dance artist, theatre actor, or god forbid business owner who might have spent decades building a business that is now bankrupt, sitting at home, with nothing to do, no one to speak to, doing what? Its well known in psychology that spending too much time alone basically makes you go crazy. Look at the numbers on domestic abuse, drug abuse, mental health issues. Have a little empathy. There are legitimate viewpoints about whether these lockdowns are worth it, and especially for how long. This isn't disinformation. It's just people who are different from you.
- mantap 6y agoWhat about the damage of not having a functional healthcare system? The only reason that the death rate is so low is because people can get to hospital and get treatment. If we just let the thing rip then hospitals would have to start having policies of not providing care to people with covid-19, or we just say goodbye to the concept of emergency care in general.
- zpeti 6y agoPlease don’t make out like my comment is some black and white anti lockdown comment. It’s not. It’s not saying let’s not lockdown. It’s saying there are serious consequences on the other end. That many people who still have their livelihoods and happiness dismiss as “misinformation”
- cerebellum42 6y agoHave you read the link? This is not about dismissing the genuine plight of people affected by the lockdown. This is about actual, literal, disinformation being spread. We need to weigh the consequences of restrictions against the consequences of not having those restrictions, and this kind of disinformation is simply trying to tip the scales by diluting the factual basis on which we all make that assessment with lies.
- s314159265358 6y agoRight wing is turning into a terrorist organization worldwide. This type of thing should be illegal and political parties should not be doing this. The right has basically denounced common sense and good of the commu by it because it realizes that without fearmongering, fake news and brainwashing, no one is going to vote for them. I'm really sad this is the case. If you censor them, that's against free speech, and if you dont, they do stuff like this.
- refurb 6y agoAgreed. Considering how effective drones are in the Middle East, I'm wondering if they might be useful here? We could use them to keep an eye on right wing domestic terrorists at a very low cost. If we see that they are planning another insurrection, we could hit them with a few missiles. If we're worried about collateral damage we could use those missiles with blades from Israel. Either that or round them up in camps. Maybe re-education through labor? We could take care of the infrastructure issues at the same time and don't have to worry about OSHA regulations!
- throwaway3699 6y agoSorry, but, yeah censorship is against free speech. Free speech is what prevents radicalisation because left and right will be talking with each other. The only reason we're seeing this is because of the online censorship, which has been ramping up for years now.
- herewegoagain2 6y agoThat article is hate speech. How can I be sure that it is not "bylinetimes" that is part of a "disinformation network"?
- makomk 6y agoByline Times pretty much are, if I remember rightly, but they're disinformation in support of the correct political cause so they don't get all the frightened articles in the mainstream press. Ah yes, the wildly viral and completely bogus conspiracy theory article from them I remember in particular was this: https://fullfact.org/economy/short-positions/ https://fullfact.org/economy/short-positions/ Which they kept on doubling down on after people pointed out their fuck-up, and which became part of the standard narrative on Brexit despite being utter bullshit.
- iso1210 6y agoOn the whole lockdown. If we had culled the over 65s in March, the economy could function just fine, hospitals would be mostly empty, and while younger people would get covid and might even need hospital treatment, it would be a very low level. The IFR for 45-65s is 1 in 300, for 25-45s it's 1 in 3000, and 15-25s 1 in 30,000. But that would be a barbaric approach. The main beneficierays of lockdowns are the over 65s, who as a generation 1) Have the most wealth 2) Have no income The main losers of lockdowns are the younger people who have 1) Very little wealth 2) Years of income to pay The cost of lockdowns should therefore come from the beneficiaries, the ones who are the wealthiest, can afford it, and who benefit the most The cost of lockdowns will actually come from government spending though, which is primarilly funded by income related tax
- heavenlyblue 6y agoIn the UK the older generation also voted for Brexit; so I am still surprised no one in politics made the argument for “let them then die during COVID as they didn’t seem to think about youth when they were voting for Brexit”.
- throwaway3699 6y agoThat's because there's no comparison between letting old people die and young people having to get an EU passport... or whatever downsides Brexit will bring us.
- iso1210 6y agoOld people run the world so get policies that benefit them. Young people are far more empathic and actually care about "not killing grandma" Farage did try to push his populist views on young people, it didn't go down well. There aren't any prominent young people calling for say a rebate on rent paid to say boomer house owners in university towns.
- user5994461 6y agoJust a tidbit on the over 65s having "no income". They actually have a lot of income, from collecting pensions and rents. Neither of these income streams were cut by COVID.