8 ms·
U.S. Senators propose limiting liability shield for social media platforms
- dang 6y agohttps://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&query=by%3Adang%20bills&sort=byDate&type=comment https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...
- Afforess 6y agoGood. It is bizarre to me that one could post literal death threats online endlessly without fear of any consquences, yet if you were to yell the same threats in a public location, the police would be summoned. My main concern would be that any regulations that punish companies for allowing threatening material on their site punish in proportion to the audience who was exposed to it. Big fines for big tech, tiny fines for a startup.
- cataphract 6y ago> It is bizarre to me that one could post literal death threats online endlessly without fear of any consquences Maybe you phrased it wrong, but the user cannot post death threats online without fear of consequences, it's just not the platform who the consequences fall upon. A better analogy to a public location would be holding the city liable for not removing a death threat someone affixed into some city-owned monument.
- gruez 6y ago>Good. It is bizarre to me that one could post literal death threats online endlessly without fear of any consquences, yet if you were to yell the same threats in a public location, the police would be summoned. That's only because the former is done anonymously and the latter can be easily be attributed to you, right? If a kid sent death threats to his classmates using his real-life facebook account, the police would be summoned too.
- onewhonknocks 6y agoThe liability should reside solely with the person making the death threats, not with the communication tool they use to make the threats IMHO.
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoI mostly agree. But if the communication tool's owner knows or ought to know of the death threats, then perhaps they should bear some liability. (If I were the communication tool, I'd add some term to my TOS that the user indemnifies me against losses due to speech the user made. So if I get sued because of something you said, I can come after you for the losses. Of course, this requires that you KYC . . . so anonymity might become harder in a post-S230 world. I sure wouldn't want to be someone running e.g. an anonymous far right or militia forum if I could be held liable for wrongful death or harassment claims.)
- kmeisthax 6y agoI should point out that we didn't tolerate this level of liability protection when Hollywood was involved. The safe harbor for copyright infringement has a notice-and-takedown requirement that CDA 230 doesn't have. If someone publishes my home address and an incitement to violence on a web forum, the platform doesn't have to do anything in order to maintain their safe harbor. However, if that same person were to copy a photo I took of my house in order to demonstrate where to go, then they have to accept a DMCA 512 takedown request or I can sue them for damages. (Assuming I jumped through all the necessary copyright hoops in order to do so.)
- KingMachiavelli 6y agoDeath threats are just as valid online (or at least are in many places) as they are in the physical world. There is a difference in terms of whether the threat is genuine or not; if one anonymous person threatens another anonymous person - can it really be believed that the threat is credible despite its obviously impractical nature? Just like in the real world, the venue is not responsible. Walmart is not responsible if someone shouts death threats inside. Walmart or other users/customers can call the police but it's not Walmart's job to tackle the guy. The really only difference is that local & state law enforcement is less inclined to enforce the law against online individuals given the time & energy required in addition the the threat being significantly less likely to be credible.
- prepend 6y agoDeath threats posted online are just as illegal as if they are yelled in public. Police (FBI) investigate and prosecute lots of death threats and there’s lots of examples of people who thought they were anonymous being found and prosecuted for criminal threat. [0] So I suppose it’s regulated in that it’s criminal and criminal actions are prohibited. I’m not sure how you would fine Twitter because one of its users made a death threat, not how you would fine a McDonald’s because someone in their restaurant yelled a death threat. Or a megaphone manufacturer, etc etc. [0] https://www.justice.gov/usao-wdnc/pr/federal-jury-convicts-black-mountain-nc-man-communicating-death-threat-twitter https://www.justice.gov/usao-wdnc/pr/federal-jury-convicts-b...
- jfengel 6y agoThat threat was issued against a political candidate, which raised it to the FBI's attention. The vast majority of violent threats receive zero attention. So it's technically correct to say that it's "just as illegal", but that's not the best kind of correct. While I'd be very interested in a directive that the FBI should take all violent threats online seriously, they don't have anywhere near that kind of resources. And I have a feeling that if they did start making numerous requests to unmask anonymous users, a lot of HN readers would oppose that as well.
- prepend 6y agoThere are many threats from normal people to normal people that result in conviction. [0] I didn’t intend for my example to be representative for all. If you report a death threat to the police and fbi it will be investigated. I think the problem is they have to be substantiated. If I just run around the town square saying “I’m going to kill you” that’s not actually a criminal death threat. So someone saying “#diaf” is not a death threat, it’s obnoxious but not a crime. Fortunately murder rate is not correlated to internet death threats or we’d all be dead. This doesn’t mean that platforms shouldn’t stop boorish behavior, but it’s not a crime and we probably don’t want the FBI investigating stuff that’s not a crime. But when it is, when I think someone is going to kill me, I feel confident that I can call the law and they’ll do what they can. [0] https://elkodaily.com/news/local/man-arrested-for-online-death-threats/article_1d752063-eb05-5d5f-b4cb-e488aa06abee.html https://elkodaily.com/news/local/man-arrested-for-online-dea...
- Person5478 6y agothreat of harm is protected speech. It has to be shown that there is both intent and the ability to carry it out before it starts entering the territory of illegal. Which makes sense if you think about it. A 5 year old child threatening you with violence is not the same as a 25 year old man with a bat in their hand. The reason threats of violence online are not illegal is because they have no ability to carry it out. This is actually a large reason why doxxing is such a big deal online. Suddenly, these people DO have the ability to carry out the threats. If you REALLY want to go at it from that perspective, these companies leaking/selling PII should make them legally liable.
- bcrosby95 6y agoI'm generally fairly hesitant about restricting 230 protection, but removing it for paid content, such as ads, makes a lot of sense to me.
- sharemywin 6y agoI think it's fair to sue to take stuff down. Although you should be able to sue to put stuff back up too
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoThe failure though is the government isn't accounting for content next to ads. Ad companies are likely to keep user generated content that drives good ad revenue, even if it's also harmful. This is a start, but the solution is to revoke 230 entirely.
- disgruntledphd2 6y agoPresumably this would lead to this site shutting down. Do you think that's an acceptable trade-off?
- colejohnson66 6y agoThis. If you make a website liable for what someone posts, the sites will be much more heavy handed in their moderation approach and start taking down content with even a hint of a problem. Just look at YouTube with kids. They’ve taken such a heavy handed approach to content moderation regarding kids content simply because of laws like COPPA. But then videos not involving kids get swept up into the mess because the algorithm decided their video is about kids. Even simple 10 second clips of Spongebob get flagged because of this.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoFirst, your presumption is completely bull----. HN isn't ad supported. And every other class of business has normal liability, tech companies are the only business that claims to need magical immunity to lawsuits, and for some reason, people believe them. Second, if websites shutting down is the tradeoff for harmful websites being able to be sued, yes, absolutely that's acceptable. Websites that propagate mass harm and disinformation need not exist, and their replacements will be better.
- f430 6y agoWhile this looks good on paper, it would severely hinder free speech on these platforms if not already.
- xpe 6y agoWhen you say "free speech", are you referring to the First Amendment (1A)? If so, are you claiming that the bill would conflict with 1A? If so, on what basis?
- peytn 6y agoNot the OP, but I believe the freedom of speech is a concept that exists outside of the Constitution. The OP may be referring to a principle or ideal instead of a constitutional construction.
- ocdtrekkie 6y agoWell, given corporate personhood, the parent may be worried this law would harm Google and Facebook's legal right to speak paid promotions for racists.
- dangerbird2 6y agoObviously how a social media platform moderates itself has virtually nothing to do with 1A. Limiting or eliminating section 230 would place more legal liability on the platforms over users' content. They would have a much greater incentive to limit users speech whenever there is the slightest risk of putting the platform in legal jeopardy. The fact that social media platforms aren't considered "publishers" means that the financial benefit for having a quasi free-speech community overrides their legal risk.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoRestricting advertising that is deemed harmful is not unprecedented, for instance tobacco ads in much of the world or prescription drug ads in sane countries. This doesn't even restrict any new kind of ad, it just opens these platforms up to liability for the ads they run. Seems pretty reasonable to me. It means if my system was exploited via an ad on Facebook[0], I can sue Facebook for showing me that ad. [0] Situation is hypothetical, I don't actually use Facebook.
- xpe 6y agoWashPo has a more detailed article: https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2021/02/04/technology-202-klobuchar-new-antitrust-bill-may-hit-big-tech-where-it-hurts/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2021/02/04/technolog... Correction as of 12:57 pm EST: Based on a comment below, I see now that the link above is talking about a different bill from Senator Klobuchar with an anti-trust focus. She's been busy.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI don't think this is the same bill.
- xpe 6y agoThanks for the correction. Here is the correct bill: https://www.warner.senate.gov/public/_cache/files/4/f/4fa9c9ba-2b34-4854-8c19-59a0a9676a31/66DECFBC0D6E6958C2520C3A6A69EAF6.safe-tech-act---final.pdf https://www.warner.senate.gov/public/_cache/files/4/f/4fa9c9...
- hartator 6y agoI think we should do the reverse: No moderation outside of court orders or you risk losing 230 protections.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- JaimeThompson 6y agoWhat do you think would happen to Hacker News if that was the law?
- FDSGSG 6y agoNo spam filtering? Presumably no DDoS protection either? Sounds exciting!
- bcrosby95 6y agoThen you may as well repeal it because Section 230 is redundant if you don't moderate content.
- DavidAdams 6y agoThat's a great idea, if your goal is to impel every website to either get rid of its forums or devolve into 4chan.
- FDSGSG 6y agoEven 4chan would be veeeeery different without moderation.
- klmadfejno 6y agoI'd imagine Hacker News would be a much less pleasant place if dang was outlawed.
- ardy42 6y ago> I think we should do the reverse: No moderation outside of court orders or you risk losing 230 protections. I hope you like spam. Also, what you propose is equivalent to forcing you to pay thousands of dollars and wait weeks or months to take down an obnoxious sign that I put up in your yard. How workable does that sound to you?
- gruez 6y ago>The bill would make it clear that Section 230, [...] does not apply to ads or other paid content seems reasonable >does not impair the enforcement of civil rights laws what types of civil rights abuses were protected by section 230? I'm under the impression that saying/posting racial slurs isn't illegal. > and does not bar wrongful-death actions. what's the current bar for suing an establishment for wrongful death? if a bunch of radicals met at a bar and plotted to murder someone, would the bar be responsible if they didn't intervene?
- krapp 6y ago>what types of civil rights abuses were protected by section 230? I'm under the impression that saying/posting racial slurs isn't illegal. Many people seem to believe that moderating platforms and banning accounts or otherwise enforcing terms of service for any content or behavior which isn't strictly illegal is a violation of their civil rights, and that this abuse is enabled by Section 230. They believe that any alteration of user submitted content makes the "platform" no longer a "platform" but a "publisher" and that they should be legally liable for that content.
- 0xB31B1B 6y agothe "meet at a bar to plot a murder" metaphor isn't at all how the the tech companies faciliate these things. Its more like if the group meets at a bar, and exclusively communicated through with each other through the bartender. In that case, would the bartender have an obligation to tell law enforcement that a group at the bar was planning a murder? I think so.
- cmdli 6y agoI think "communicating through the barkeeper" makes the barkeeper's involvement sound much more intentional than it actually would be. It's more like if a group regularly gathered at the bar, using the barkeeper's space and supplies, and planned a murder. The barkeeper might have a responsibility to listen in to the conversation and report if they are planning a crime, and the group is using the barkeeper's space to organize, but it's not like the barkeeper ever agreed for that specific group to use their space.
- offtop5 6y ago>Called the SAFE TECH Act, the bill would mark the latest effort to make social media companies like Alphabet Inc’s Google, Twitter Inc and Facebook Inc more accountable for “enabling cyber-stalking, targeted harassment, and discrimination on their platforms,” Senators Mark Warner, Mazie Hirono and Amy Klobuchar said in a statement. Ehh. Slippery slope theory, if you don't want to be subject to these behaviors don't use social media. While a good bar tender will cut off patrons who are clearly drunk, if you then hop in your truck and run into a tree, you can't sue the bar.
- yladiz 6y ago> if you then hop in your truck and run into a tree, you can't sue the bar Actually I don't think that's entirely true. I'm pretty sure there are laws in some places that if the bar knows a person is drunk and knows that they will drive, and does not prevent it, then the bar or the bartender (or both) can be held liable if the person then gets into an accident.
- sharemywin 6y agoCRIMINAL PENALTIES The Liquor Control Act prohibits alcoholic liquor permittees or their employees from selling or delivering alcohol to intoxicated persons (CGS § 30-86(b)(1)). Although the statute does not define "intoxicated persons," the Connecticut Supreme Court held in 1937 that someone can conclude that a defendant is intoxicated if he or she is staggering and not able to run very well (State v. Katz, 122 Conn. 439). Violations are punishable by up to a $1,000 fine, up to one year imprisonment, or both, for each offense
- rhcom2 6y agoKnown as "Dram shop laws": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dram_shop https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dram_shop
- 23B1 6y ago> if you don't want to be subject to these behaviors don't use social media It is nearly impossible to engage in modern democracy without engaging in social media. I'm not saying this isn't a slippery slope, but when the only way to participate in our economy and government is online... well, there's a general public good element that needs to be considered by society. I'm not a big fan of government regulation, but the socials clearly aren't going to do it fairly.
- everdrive 6y agoWhen I was young, I realized that eventually the problems of the real world would catch up to the internet. It was in the mid-2000s that I realized a well-staffed company, with people working on problems for 8+ hours a day, for years, could always outpace individuals. Just as has been true with all human affairs: better-resourced groups can overpower lesser-resourced groups. It has been true for years now that the problems of the real world have spilled onto the internet. In its infancy, the internet was an "island of sanity," a (socially and intellectually) secure enclave from the real world. In the 2010s, (and particularly the late 2010s) this problem accelerated, and now rather than merely bringing the problems of the real world to the net, the net is home to brand new problems which would have been impossible without the net. It's no surprise that government wants to step in. It should be telling that both the left and right have plans for the government to regulate the internet. (and at least in my estimation, both of these plans are not well founded: either eliminate section 230, or enforce some kind of "fairness," or simply do more for censorship) I honestly believe this is mostly a losing battle. Companies and the government, (and really people) will not have any reason to become less invested in the internet, and so the interests of individuals will be steamrolled. It's a totally unavoidable problem for most people, although a tech-savvy elite can avoid a lot of these problems.
- munificent 6y agoI had this realization later than you. What finally clicked for me is that power dynamics form a positive feedback loop that naturally compounds inequality. If you have a little more power, the natural thing do with that power is to coerce/force/encourage/persuade others to give you a little more. The longer you let that system iterate, the greater the power imbalance. This is why the majority of human history has had massive inequality. Every now and then, an event happens that goes against that. For example, WWII destroyed massive amounts of physical infrastructure, so it was a force towards equality. Those with more to lose did lose more. (Heart-breakingly, the pandemic is the exact opposite, since COVID-19 doesn't harm material goods, just people.) One kind of event is a rapid technological change. These work sort of like a rainstorm for power. All of a sudden, bits of empowerment from the new technology rain down semi-randomly onto humanity. Anyone with a cup to catch it gets some. The early Internet was like this. But, eventually, the system iterates like it always does and eventually those with a bit more power use it to build the rain catchment systems and gutters to route that new power over to themselves. Sometimes, this gets routed to new powerful people who were the ones who caught a lot of the early rain. But the technology itself ceases to be a force for equality. This is where we are today with the Internet.
- xpe 6y agoToo many people do not understand the First Amendment (1A). In case you have not reviewed the 1A recently, please read this carefully: https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/first_amendment https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/first_amendment > The First Amendment of the United States Constitution protects the right to freedom of religion and freedom of expression from government interference. It prohibits any laws that establish a national religion, impede the free exercise of religion, abridge the freedom of speech, infringe upon the freedom of the press, interfere with the right to peaceably assemble, or prohibit citizens from petitioning for a governmental redress of grievances. It was adopted into the Bill of Rights in 1791. The Supreme Court interprets the extent of the protection afforded to these rights. The First Amendment has been interpreted by the Court as applying to the entire federal government even though it is only expressly applicable to Congress. Furthermore, the Court has interpreted the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment as protecting the rights in the First Amendment from interference by state governments. Please pay particular attention to whom and what 1A applies.
- alksdfkasdf123 6y agoSCOTUS also ruled that black people are not people[0], so their opinion on to whom and to what freedom applies is irrelevant. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dred_Scott https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dred_Scott
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- asdfasgasdgasdg 6y agoTheir opinion is relevant as long as it is enforced, whether or not you personally like it.
- artful-hacker 6y agoConsidering they are the highest court in the USA, I would say their opinion is most relevant. That doesn't mean they can't be wrong morally or ethically, but their opinion is definitely relevant.
- deleted 6y ago
- IG_Semmelweiss 6y agoIm worried this would codify fine power for whatever way the political wind blows, which seems to be incremented by increasing the size of payroll particularly at the FTC. Here is an idea for better oversight of big tech that does not involve more regulation: a deacentralized moderation system that replicates the us court system. If something is flagged, then a jury made up of randomly selected users decide if the comment is inciting violence / etc. If 1 user says it does not , then there is no ban/deletion etc. You can iterate many times off that into a system that is scalable, cost effective, descentralized, transparent, and just.
- NoodleIncident 6y agoAren't you describing Parler's failed attempt at pretending they moderate their content?
- IG_Semmelweiss 6y agoBy definition, if they pretended, it means they were not serious about getting to a solution that the average person would find reasonable Note that it doesnt mean aws or gcp or cnn had to agree, it just means that it really resembled the process that we have for the us court system In fact something well implemented would potentially threaten (and by definition, by attacked by) the twitters fb, aws , etc, because it would become a more reliable predictor of content moderation than what currently exists via ToS. It would effectively obsolte catchall ToS, and decidely be a vote against centralized control We can likely agree that the words "well implemented" and "parler" do not belong in the same sentence
- xpe 6y ago> I'm worried this would codify fine power for whatever way the political wind blows It depends on how the legislation is written, which will determine who makes various decisions and how the decisions are made. Can you tell me about examples of legislation that you think have been done well? And what is your idea of 'well done'? Should I interpret your comment as meaning that you don't like arbitrary changes in political opinion -- that you think legislation should have deeper standards or principles? In the case of social media and speech, what do you think the standards should be? Can you also give an example of legislation that has not been done well.
- Person5478 6y agoJust break them up, this type of legislation is going to harm everyone.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoThe bill (https://www.warner.senate.gov/public/_cache/files/4/f/4fa9c9ba-2b34-4854-8c19-59a0a9676a31/66DECFBC0D6E6958C2520C3A6A69EAF6.safe-tech-act---final.pdf https://www.warner.senate.gov/public/_cache/files/4/f/4fa9c9...) would exclude not only the things listed in the source article but also any kind of injuctive relief. Doesn't this end up being basically a full repeal? I'm sure Stratton Oakmont would have been satisfied with an injunction requiring Prodigy to take down the critical messages on their bulletin board.
- eunos 6y agoBill Clinton said in 2000 that limiting Internet is like nailing jello to the wall. Now, not only China managed to do so, even the US starts trying to nail the jello as well.
- traveler01 6y agoIs China really limiting Internet though?
- eunos 6y agoIs not 100%, but enough to nourish homegrown player. As we have seen from the tech war and Twitter mass bans, having a homegrown viable ecosystem is very important.
- xpe 6y agoHere is the full text of the bill: https://www.warner.senate.gov/public/_cache/files/4/f/4fa9c9ba-2b34-4854-8c19-59a0a9676a31/66DECFBC0D6E6958C2520C3A6A69EAF6.safe-tech-act---final.pdf https://www.warner.senate.gov/public/_cache/files/4/f/4fa9c9...
- grawprog 6y agoThe first part of the bill seems reasonable... This part >Under the SAFE TECH Act, the word "information" would be swapped out for the word "speech," narrowing the law and potentially erasing liability protections for a range of other illicit information-sharing that happens on online platforms. I worry about. Who gets to decide what's classed as speech or not? What's the definition of 'speech'? Will it end up being left to a judge to determine on a case by case basis?
- kart23 6y agoI used to believe that 230 is a good thing in all cases. But I have absolutely no sympathy for the people who post others addresses or family members information with the intent of bringing harm. That is one case I think it goes way too far, and social media platforms should absolutely be held liable for that type of harassment which can cross into the real world. This bill seems like a good step in that direction. And I do think platforms should be able to get sued and held liable for targeted violence against individuals that is incited on their platforms. The reuters article is light on information, but heres something that goes into a bit more detail. https://royalexaminer.com/warner-announces-the-safe-tech-act-to-reform-section-230/ https://royalexaminer.com/warner-announces-the-safe-tech-act...
- whack 6y agoIronically, this law would give tech companies vastly more power to censor and police online speech. As soon as tech companies are made legally liable for any speech that occurs on their platform, they would be both legally and morally justified in using draconian measures to preemptively block activities that could expose them to liability. For example, banning all controversial hashtags, automatically banning anyone who promotes controversial hashtags, or deleting tweets/individuals that their algorithms have flagged as being problematic. In all of these cases, Twitter and Facebook would argue that they don't have the manpower to quickly and thoroughly review every single interaction that occurs on their platform. And they don't have the luxury of being permissive in allowing free speech. And they would be right. If you're afraid of online free speech being aggressively policed by tech companies, their customer-service reps, and their automated algorithms, then such proposals should absolutely scare you. You could very well see a 21st century where Mark Zuck becomes the next Rupert Murdoch.
- xpe 6y agoI don't think this is ironic. It seems to me the intention is to encourage tech companies to be more selective in what they allow. I do not agree with your claim that "they would be both legally and morally justified in using draconian measures". Here's why: 1. Morality is different from legality, especially in this context 2. Draconian means "excessively harsh and severe". I don't think the bill if passed would provide protections for companies that are "excessively harsh or severe". These companies still operate in a broader context that includes market forces, public perception, and internal leadership in addition to regulation.
- bastawhiz 6y agoThis is absolutely the truth. I've talked with attorneys about what this would mean for my side hustle (podcast hosting) and their advice is to have tools for doing exhaustive moderation ready to go. The risk of being sued for user content is large enough to be business-ending for startups of my size. I sincerely hope that this is just political theater that never manifests into law. Section 230 is a blessing to the modern internet which goes wildly unappreciated, and is terribly misunderstood by the folks who benefit from it most.
- boardwaalk 6y agoIf we’re going to adjust 230, it’s a perfect chance to favor smaller platforms. e.g. if you are under a certain size, you get to keep full 230 protections. The size and power of these companies needs to be addressed.
- krapp 6y agoSo all I need to do is have a bot register n+1 accounts, then I can legally force them to publish whatever I want them to or else they have to go under to avoid legal liability? Neat.
- boardwaalk 6y agoMy single sentence obviously doesn’t capture the nuance that would be put into a law. And there are many ways to measure the size of a company. Also, removing limiting liability doesn’t force companies to post things. That’s just 100% not what that is.
- hypersoar 6y agoSection 230 reform feels to me like gnawing around the edges of the problem. I've started thinking that we should consider going nuclear on online platforms with some version of "social networking platforms funded substantially by advertising revenue are prohibited". Something that will restrict, as powerfully as we can, the existence of platforms incentivized to solely maximize user engagement. Congress can strip them of their liability shields. Facebook can set up all the moderators and review boards it wants. In the end, we all know how their bread is buttered.
- xpe 6y agoFor the sake of argument, assume I agree with you. Next, would you be willing to talk about the complexities of gathering places, free speech, and who funds those gathering places? Would you be able to formulate one, two, or three basic theories (or models) of how these factors relate? Could you test them? The reason I ask is this: I think there are some recurring patterns that connect these factors. I won't claim these patterns are universal, but I would expect to find useful patterns across many regions and many periods of time. Having a tested, applicable model of how these are connected can help find the leverage points to target with regulation to achieve particular goals. Caveat: what I've stated above is, more or less, a compact statement of how I think public policy should be made, at least for the most significant issues that we face. And, if an issue is not deemed significant enough to warrant this kind of analysis, that's understandable. However, I don't think anyone should fool themselves into thinking that some 'obvious' action will also be verifiable *solution*. It might happen to seem effective to some people, but that doesn't make it an effective policy or decision -- very few of us are provably good at separating association from cause and effect.