16 ms·
Drawbacks of P2P and a defense of Signal
- zrm 6y agoMost of these criticisms are solvable problems. If you make a direct connection to other users, they see your IP address. So use Tor or a VPN. Many P2P lookup systems assign identifiers for routing etc. So assign ephemeral ones for anything that doesn't need a persistent one, and make sure persistent ones aren't suitable for correlation, either by not using the same identifier for multiple services by the same person, or by using the same identifier for multiple services operated by a large number of unrelated people, or both.
- rapsey 6y agoThat is however just another layer of complexity when the article already talks about the complexity of running a matrix server.
- zrm 6y agoRunning a Matrix server is complex because the software could be better, not from some inherent user-facing complexity. Encouraging users to use a VPN can be as simple as bundling the WireGuard installer with your software and providing a list of recommended non-shady VPN providers. This makes things less complicated for the user, because they benefit from having a VPN whether they use your software or not (to hide their current IP address from any centralized services they still use), but now they have someone they trust providing a vetted selection of them to choose from. And on top of that it gives a free software developer the opportunity to fund some development through the use of affiliate links.
- subsubsub 6y agoThis response has been written a thousand times, but here goes again... Using a VPN or Tor is not a viable option for the average person.
- ajconway 6y agoTor can be embedded into an application. Sadly, the service quality over Tor would be much worse than over a regular Internet connection.
- ulucs 6y agoSo can VPN's! There is a reason why Opera still has market share in some countries.
- ajconway 6y agoUsing a VPN given to you by a service provider from whom you are trying to hide your IP seems to not achieve the goal. Letting users select their own VPN before using your service is too much friction. The advantage of Tor is that it's run by multiple parties and does not need any interactive setup.
- catmanjan 6y agoUsing TCP/IP used to not be a viable option for the average person either?
- codemac 6y agoSure, but what about in 1992? How much did you need to understand about TCP/IP when you got AOL? Very little. And what happened when you got online? You could communicate online, suddenly reaching millions and then billions of humans. So learning just a little bit about IP (let's be real, you didn't need to know shit about TCP) Compare that to a VPN or Tor. What do you need to understand to use it, and what is the payoff for knowing it? It's nowhere near the same situation as IP and the beginning of consumer internet.
- catmanjan 6y agoYep all it took was some usability products and it was easier... See what I'm saying...
- freddie_mercury 6y agoThe article never claimed they are impossible to solve. It even mentions Tor. You seem to trying to argue something different than what the article is actually about.
- zrm 6y ago> The article never claimed they are impossible to solve. If they aren't impossible to solve then why should we not just solve them instead of abandoning decentralization?
- infogulch 6y agoWhat about Matrix over I2P? Seems like an ideal pairing, especially since Matrix' robust history syncing may combine nicely with i2p delayed forwarding and other advanced traffic mixing strategies.
- rapsey 6y agoA bit annoying how servers meant to be run by people themselves are written in awfully slow languages. Python for matrix server is a terrible choice. Even worse for home assistant. If it can't fit on raspberry pi it's useless.
- ReactiveJelly 6y agoThey're working on a Go server impl, "Dendrite" which is supposed to be far faster and use less RAM. I was hoping for Rust, and I think there is a 3rd-party Rust server, but anything's better than Python. Node.js would probably be better than Python.
- runiq 6y agoThe 3rd party Rust server is Conduit: https://conduit.rs https://conduit.rs
- Macha 6y ago> Note: This project is work-in-progress and is still missing some features like joining private rooms over federation I'm hopeful it will get there somewhere, but I hestitate to recommend it while "easy to get working without issues" is a bar that it doesn't yet reach.
- eternalban 6y agohttps://github.com/matrix-org/dendrite https://github.com/matrix-org/dendrite /aside: this is a curious comment in their readme: "A PostgreSQL database engine, which will perform better than SQLite with many users and/or larger rooms"
- neolog 6y agoI can't see how it would matter for home assistant. It's not a CPU-bound application.
- rapsey 6y ago
- gorgonzolachz 6y agoCan anyone chime in on their experiences hosting a synapse server? I have close to a dozen people on mine (although we don't federate much with the network as a whole, I set it up initially for a couple of groupchats/DMs with friends) and I'm not even close to hitting the limits of the $5/mo Digitalocean server I put it on. Does federating with the greater Matrix ecosystem cost that much extra processing power, that one user's chats are taking multiple gigs of RAM and gigabytes of space? It looks like the author's using multiple bridges, which could be a problem, but my understanding is that bridges are separate programs that hook into synapse via an API. I will agree that voip/video isn't there yet, tried it with some friends and none of us could get anything working. I did go out and set up a TURN server afterwards, but once a piece of tech fails as badly as element did for us the damage is done. E2EE could definitely be done better as well, but in another post on here I saw a comment detailing a bunch of clients (many of which were abandonware) that didn't support E2EE at all. That's going to kill mass adoption, since you have no idea how many people are on those zombie clients that you still need to support. I wonder if the Matrix API has a way to define versions for these purposes, to advertise the highest supported version by both the client and server?
- omnimus 6y agoYes the federation completely killed my 5usd vps last time ive tried it. Ive been running synapse for 5+ years for about 20 active users. I have it running on 4gb 8core arm sbc nowadays and i dont dare to federate. When somebody connects to a federated room with history and many users it explodes. It seems future will be federated but with beefy servers. Considering Matrix supposed to be the answer to decentralization... its mostly used on one main instance or in centralised silos like companies.
- genewitch 6y agoI just set up synapse last week. The config file has 93,000 characters in it, which i joked is worse than IRCd. I'm running it on gentoo, pretty bare system, probably equivalent to double an rpi4. I did notice that the database file grows quickly. Currently the entire machine is using 272MB RAM, 0.8% CPU peaks, 0.01 15 minute load average. Every part of setting up a server that will federate/host repeats again and again that you need a TURN server (and they recommend coturn) - which is another 26,000 character config file - in order to do VOIP. If you've ever run or used a pbx before, STUN is needed 100% of the time for nat traversal between clients. Coturn even says it won't run if it's NAT'd (it will, but that's irrelevant to most people.) This is the fourth concurrent tech trial of chat daemons, with rocket.chat and mattermost being a couple of the other ones that we're testing. synapse/element/matrix has the benefit of forced e2ee by my configuration. I don't know of any other matrix federated servers, so i haven't tried that yet, but an associate says it works on my configuration - which means it's not as big of a pig as i thought it was based on the outlandishly, comically large config file - where whitespace matters!
- alexmingoia 6y agoWhy compare the privacy implications of IPFS and Signal? They are intended for entirely different purposes.
- number6 6y agoThe Article compares p2p vs centralized and uses IPFS as an example and signal as the other example. Both distribute information. True this is a high level perspective...
- nielsole 6y agohttps://matrix.org/blog/2020/02/01/on-privacy-versus-freedom/ https://matrix.org/blog/2020/02/01/on-privacy-versus-freedom... Matrix on this topic and their view
- Thorentis 6y agoI think a half-way point is needed for something to be truely durable. I agree with the criticisms of P2P in that you need to make some privacy tradeoffs. But durability is another concern (as we've seen recently with the takedown of Element from the Play Store). Is it possible for somebody else to spin-up a new centralised Signal server? Why isn't the server code-base open source? Signal would grow immensely in my eyes if they made the server code open source [SEE EDIT], and allowed an easy way to set the centralised server address in the Signal app. The current server would be the default, and perhaps changing the server would be hidden in Advanced Options for now. But the capability would be there. That way, if x government chooses to go after Signal's servers, the availability of all the code needed to run a replacement is already available. As it stands, we are placing a lot of trust in the Signal Foundation for communication (assuming we rely on the Signal app/service). I have no problem with a central server being used for communication if I can communicate data in a zero-trust way. But I want assurance that that server can be quickly and easily replaced in the event it goes down. EDIT: I stand corrected. Server code is here: https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Server https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Server Unfortunately, you cannot change the server address in the app as downloaded from any app store, so my criticism remains.
- vorticalbox 6y agoServer is open source too. https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Server https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Server
- crossroadsguy 6y agoOnly one branch: master Last updated: 9 months ago Unless I am missing something obvious in GitHub UI.
- epse 6y agoThey don't actually develop on github, but code goes there every now and then. Not ideal, but better than nothing imo
- ece 6y agoElement/Matrix/Gitter is a great IRC-replacement and public chat, Mastodon is great as a decentralized Twitter alternative, IPFS is great for decentralized public file sharing. Default-public services like this probably have an easier time being decentralized. It'd actually be nice to see thoughtful integrations between these three IMO. The greatest advantage Signal has is probably doing same-day updates for all clients while being dead simple to use well. A decentralized protocol could achieve these things, but none have yet. Still I hope someday soon we can have everything be decentralized, but like the blog post says, we can't let the perfect be the enemy of the good.
- natchy 6y ago> Mastodon is great as a decentralized Twitter Federated, not decentralized. Decentralized is peer2peer like torrents. Federated is like email where there are little fiefdoms like Gmail, yahoo, or self-hosted.
- kitkat_new 6y agothat definition seems like a bit of a stretch: decentralized does not mean anything more than not being centralized. Federation implies decentralization.
- natchy 6y ago> Federation implies decentralization. No it doesn’t. Gmail is a centralized instance of a federated network. You can have a federated node that becomes so popular that it’s basically centralized. This federated/decentralized distinction is pretty common. You’re dwelling on literal definitions but there are more semantic differences those words have picked up in the communities involved.
- klik99 6y agoBe kinder, these semantics differences are newer(ish) developments and not everyone knows the area. It's a bit confusing to say federation does imply decentralization point blank. For a long time, federated architecture was seen as special case of decentralized, for example in designing stuff for internal use. It still makes sense in that context. In the context of larger external facing systems, I've found it useful to think of federated as "partly decentralized", and "decentralized" is short-hand for "fully decentralized".
- Jkvngt 6y agoSignal needs your phone number and is run by a "former" Twitter person. It just smells funny.
- Dumbdo 6y agoOn the other hand Signal is encouraged by people like Edward Snowden (who I assume is paranoid enough about American big corps). The clients are open source and feature a strong E2EE, which is called the Signal protocol and is used by many other clients nowadays because it has such a good reputation. There are lot of efforts to reduce metadata further. Just dismissing it as "smells funny" is not a valid criticism.
- tylermenezes 6y ago> The clients are open source But you can't verify that the open-source matches what's on the Play Store, you can't link to the official server with your own build, and you can't run your own because the server is no longer open source. (Last released a year ago)
- codethief 6y ago> But you can't verify that the open-source matches what's on the Play Store According to their blog, builds are reproducible[0]. Am I missing anything? > you can't link to the official server with your own build Why not? (I know Moxie discouraged publishing custom builds while linking them against the official Signal server but this is not the same thing.) [0]: https://signal.org/blog/reproducible-android/ https://signal.org/blog/reproducible-android/
- Jkvngt 6y agoRosenfeld’s admitted that they don’t NEED need your phone number, so why does he still need it? I didn’t give Zucc my phone number, I didn’t give it to Suzy, Jeff, Larry, or Sergei. So why’s Rosenfeld need it? He doesn’t, but he does. It’s “easier” this way.
- dinoqqq 6y ago
- GNU_James 6y agoAll apps that require a phone number are a scam, privacy-wise. Use Matrix.
- vinay427 6y agoWhat does "scam" even mean here? I know what I'm signing up for, privacy-wise, when I provide Signal my phone number and access to some of my contacts, and I clearly get something in exchange.
- m4rtink 6y agoI would not call passing phone numbers (or reversivle hashes thereof) of my friends to a third part a scam. I would call it treason.
- GNU_James 6y agoWhy are you providing your phone number to anyone? Software should be free.
- growse 6y agoThe software is free...?
- vinay427 6y agoI prefer free/libre software as well. I'm really not trying to sound inane when I say that I provide my phone number for the same reason I provide my phone number directly to my friends with whom I would like to communicate. It allows people I know to identify me among the billions of other people who have phone numbers. To repeat my question, how are apps that require a phone number scamming users?
- dikaio 6y agoAgree. Googles in bed with the Government and they make sure to make near impossible to have any normal search experience while using Tor. Wasn’t it Google that wanted to make all information available on the web through their site? This is almost as bad as censorship.
- kiwidrew 6y agoYet another "Matrix isn't mature enough so just give up and use a centralized service" post that completely ignores the fact that XMPP is still alive and kicking. With multiple independent implementations (both client and server) that all work together pretty decently. We're never ever going to tear ourselves away from this death by centralization if we keep inventing excuses for why we don't use the federated/distributed systems that we already have! Edit: for those who are interested in using XMPP in 2021, there is a good list of public servers available at https://list.jabber.at/ https://list.jabber.at/ and a list of clients that support modern OMEMO end-to-end encryption at https://omemo.top/ https://omemo.top/
- vasco 6y agoHow much of the daily volume of internet chat-type messages do you estimate flow over XMPP versus alternative protocols and proprietary implementations?
- twelvechairs 6y agoI think it would be better if you made your point rather than asked it rhetorically. To me your argument reads like 'internet chat is currently proprietary so it always will be' but maybe I'm missing a step you'll need to fill in.
- vasco 6y agoAnd I think part of internet discourse should allow to posit questions without actually having a big point to make. Why is it necessary to pontificate about everything? In any case, if you want a point, whenever technical people bring up the technical superiority of X protocol or tool in a discussion, I like to ask myself this question. How many people actually use the thing that someone is telling me is so much better for the world? If it's so good, why is nobody using it for practical things? Have they used it before and there's a decline, or is it a new up and comer and it just hasn't caught on? I think just asking the question sparks a valuable train of thought.
- atemerev 6y agoOK. How can you guarantee that your favorite three-letter agency does not have an agreement with Signal, so they can MITM you transparently, or deliver a custom-built app to you? Trustless is the only way to fly. I don’t need to trust any central authority to pay someone with Bitcoin or other cryptocurrencies. Why should I trust someone to route my messages?
- IshKebab 6y agoIt is actually possible because Signal is 1. Open source. 2. Has verifiable builds (just being open source isn't enough). 3. Uses end to end encryption. You need all three of those to get what you want. Also you need to spend a ton of time building Signal from source and auditing it, which I doubt you're going to bother with but at least in theory it is possible.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- kitkat_new 6y ago4. Verification
- heldergg 6y agoWhat's running server side?
- IshKebab 6y ago
- neiman 6y ago> The advantages of P2P are undeniable and profound, but few are effectively addressing the privacy implications. The one I know of that is, Briar, routes all traffic over Tor; every node is reached by a Tor onion service. Bisq (p2p exchange) does the same thing.
- neiman 6y agoA benevolent dictatorship would always be more effective than a democracy, but what happens once it stops being benevolent? Same here. A centralized app (like Signal) is more effective than distributed/decentralized approach. But what would happen if Signal would ever stop being benevolent? Remember the days Google were "do no evil"?
- oblio 6y agoIsn't Signal a non profit? Much different incentives.
- neiman 6y agoAre all non-profit organizations good? What stops Signal from becoming for-profit in the future?
- awestroke 6y ago> "[...] we've structured the project as a non-profit entity, so it can never be bought, has no investors, and isn't "owned" by anyone. We did this because we wanted to be "for" something other than profit, and we wanted to make sure the organization was only incentivized to create something that is in the best interest of the people who depend on it." https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/kt91qk/comment/gikrk2p https://www.reddit.com/r/technology/comments/kt91qk/comment/...
- neiman 6y agoYes, but I have structured my message so it can never be criticized :-) Their intention is good, but I fail to see how it ensures that Signal, the project or the management of the app, would never fall into bad hands. Promising such a thing is somewhere between naive and misleading.
- thekyle 6y agoGood point. OpenAI was a non-profit, but then they changed to be for-profit and were acquired by Microsoft. Same could happen to Signal.
- staltz 6y ago> Similar can be said from everything like Scuttlebutt to GNU Jami; any service that operates on a P2P basis will likely reveal your IP, and tie your identity to it (and your IP address history). In some cases, as with Jami, this would be limited to friends you add; in others, as with Scuttlebutt and IPFS, it could be revealed to anyone. Regarding Scuttlebutt (SSB), this isn't quite true. While IPFS requires a DHT, SSB's primary mode of updating content is via servers such as pubs and rooms, the DHT in SSB is optional and not the most common mode of updating content. In SSB you can and should choose the servers which you're connecting to, so in that sense it's closer to the federated model. It's not entirely fair that the article equates "P2P" to "DHT", there are many ways you can do P2P connections, a DHT is only used for discovery. IP leakage is a problem in all these models (centralized, P2P, federated, etc): some computer somewhere will see your IP address, and you have to trust them not to do bad stuff with it. For a comprehensive overview of privacy in DHTs and P2P, watch this talk: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nCCkwU4JPcY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nCCkwU4JPcY
- happybeing 6y agohttps://SafeNetwork.tech https://SafeNetwork.tech is thoroughly p2p and doesn't reveal IP addresses because it's designed from the ground up to be decentralised, anonymous and censorship resistant.
- zepto 6y agoIs there a reason this comment has been downvoted? I know this is usually not a good question to ask, but since this comment looks reasonable to me in context, I am wondering if there is something about safenetwork.tech that makes it a bad example or even a scam?
- billyjobob 6y agoLast time it was featured on HN the top comment accused it of being another crypto currency scam. Unfortunately there didn’t seem to be any consensus one way or the other on the technical merit, but clearly some people are not fond of it.
- apichat 6y ago> "Signal brings encryption and privacy to meet people where they’re at, not the other way around. People don’t have to choose a server, it can automatically recognize contacts that use Signal, it has emojis, attachments, secure voice and video calling, and (aside from the Musk incident), it all just works. It feels like, and is, a polished, modern experience with the bells and whistles people are used to." Quicksy offer EXACTLY the same functionalities but it's federated and standardized, based on XMPP : you can discuss with people that are not using Quicksy and its services, people outside Quicksy even can link their address to their phone to make it automatically recognize as contacts using quicksy/XMPP : https://quicksy.im/#get-listed https://quicksy.im/#get-listed And instead of Matrix, Quicksy IT IS THERE YET : https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=im.quicksy.client https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=im.quicksy.cli...
- stereolambda 6y agoI'm annoyed that the comments here pile on the "ease of use" part, while largely ignoring what is more original here. (I don't know what I expected.) The critiques of p2p identity leaking and big hungry servers are valid and I'm glad they are raised. As a Matrix user, I could respond to the first point that yes, it's a tradeoff depending on your threat model. I think that having a tractable identity is less bad than having one point of failure and moderation, on the broad social scale. If you are more concerned about very strong security now, you may decide differently. I think in the future, you could use an unfederated server of Matrix if you want something like Signal for sensitive connections. And yes, maybe pure p2p with no server nodes will never be viable for some use cases, with some threat models. I do hope that in the future there will be an optimized Matrix server implementation in a faster language. (I'm saying Matrix, but of course my "loyalty" is ultimately more to the type of vision than some specific project.) I'm willing to cut some slack (pun unintended) to people having to iron out their big visions in an easier, more lenient language first. It's more important to have the features people want first. As to the difficulty part, again, this is a legitimate concern, but I feel in HN comments and similar places it degenerated into a complete meme. All technology is "hard" for most/some people. I know older folks who drive to a clerk in a store to ask them to show how to do stuff on IPhone. There is always some greasing and other people having to tell you how to use it, not everything can be intuited. But you can simplify: point folks to a specific client (Element), which will point them to one server (Matrix.org). (Or, say, a random wallet like Ethereum does it?) I've done it with success with a bunch of "non-technical" people. No decisions needed on their part, but they could make them if they wanted to research (and not everyone has to want to!). It was no different in the era of email expansion and Outlook.
- johnisgood 6y agoI use Element with some people and the reason they do not like it is that it takes a noticeable amount of time to send a message. It is annoying to me, too. What exactly is the reason for it? Can it be improved? This happens with both the desktop and Android client.
- southerntofu 6y ago> you could use an unfederated server of Matrix if you want something like Signal for sensitive connections In the Jabber federation, we've had servers federating over tor onion services for about 8 years now, if that can be of interest to you (see prosody's mod_onions).
- Arathorn 6y agoThis is all a bit depressing, speaking as the project lead for Matrix. 1. It's true that Synapse can use a lot of RAM. - The biggest cause of this is due to spikes in RAM during state resolution (the merge resolution algorithm used to converge your server's view of a room with the other servers in a room), which Python doesn't always recover nicely. We fixed the main cause of this in Synapse 1.26, which was released on Wednesday: https://github.com/matrix-org/synapse/issues/8622 https://github.com/matrix-org/synapse/issues/8622 is interesting reading on the details. - Another cause is that by default we cache a lot of data in RAM in order to avoid hammering the DB. Currently you have to manually tune the size of that cache, which should be done automatically - we're hoping to get to this shortly. - The other main cause is that the resource requirements depends on the complexity of the rooms its users participate in, not the number of users on the server. So a single user server can use serious RAM if that one user goes and joins a bunch of busy rooms with hundreds of thousands of users in them. This can be surprising to sysadmins, and we haven't figured out a good way of solving it other than just keeping making Synapse go faster. - Finally, even though we're continuing to polish Synapse hard, we're also working on Dendrite, which uses roughly 5x less RAM than Synapse (thanks to relying on the DB for caching, using a smarter DB schema; passing all strings around as enums called NIDs, and Go's GC being smarter than Python's). For instance, dendrite.matrix.org uses a relatively stable 480MB of RAM, despite being in thousands of rooms spanning tens of thousands of users. It's still beta, but progressing fast. 2. In terms of choosing a Matrix server: "Well, you could just tell a person to use matrix.org. But then it spent a good portion of last year unable to federate with other popular nodes due to Synapse limitations." - yes, at the beginning of 2020 we hit a performance ceiling on Synapse on matrix.org which caused federation to fall behind during heavy traffic. *So we fixed it*. https://matrix.org/blog/2020/11/03/how-we-fixed-synapses-scalability/ https://matrix.org/blog/2020/11/03/how-we-fixed-synapses-sca... has the details. Meanwhile, more and more other folks are spinning up reliable Matrix providing services. 3. In terms of "Voice and video calling are not there yet in Matrix", again: we've been working our asses off to fix this. Since September we've had a dedicated fulltime VoIP team going through reworking 1:1 VoIP, implementing the work at https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix-doc/blob/dbkr/msc2746/proposals/2746-reliable-voip.md https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix-doc/blob/dbkr/msc2746/p.... This has been landing over the last few weeks (although there's still some stuff left), but it should already be noticeably more robust. Meanwhile, integration to Jitsi for video conferencing has also improved a bunch - we're counting on it for running FOSDEM next weekend, after all. In terms of NAT: yes, you have to correctly set up a TURN server. We're building https://github.com/matrix-org/voip-tester https://github.com/matrix-org/voip-tester to help folks test that they've got it right. 4. "Matrix is so hard to set up on a server that there is matrix-docker-ansible-deploy". This is bogus, imo. The ansible project is useful if you want to quickly run tonnes of bridges without understanding how to admin them, but for a typical Matrix server you should be able to `pip install matrix-synapse` and off you go. It's a fair point that Synapse doesn't yet ship with an admin tool, just an admin API, but there are folks filling this gap (https://github.com/Awesome-Technologies/synapse-admin https://github.com/Awesome-Technologies/synapse-admin is good). 5. "Encryption isn’t mandatory in Matrix". This is because, unlike Signal, Matrix supports public chatrooms. It makes *NO* sense to end-to-end encrypt a public chatroom which by definition is intended to be indexed and visible and smeared all over the wider world. All it would do is waste significant CPU on the clients, and hit up against resource limits given how large public chatrooms can get. Meanwhile, all private conversations are E2EE by default, assuming your client supports E2EE. TL;DR: It feels like we're being judged on Matrix as it was in early 2020, ignoring all the sprinting we've been doing throughout the last year to address these criticisms, so it's all rather frustrating.
- upofadown 6y agoThis is mostly about anonymity. Signal is not really intended to provide anonymity. Most encrypted messaging is not intended to provide anonymity. That is because anonymity is harder to do than privacy and privacy is hard. Fortunately, most people do not need anonymity in their day to day lives. They just need to live in a country with good privacy laws to prevent the commercial exploitation of their data. So if you live in a place with little or no legal privacy protection like the USA things will be fundamentally different. There are a bunch of XMPP servers running on Tor hidden services: * https://gist.github.com/dllud/a46d4a555e31dfeff6ad41dcf20729ac https://gist.github.com/dllud/a46d4a555e31dfeff6ad41dcf20729... ... but the article talks about Matrix instead for some reason.
- johnchristopher 6y agoOn the topic of anonymity I do like this stance: > Just for the hell of it: Anonymity is fundamentally about removing context. You can't provide anonymity you can only provide protocols that endeavour to remove context. Attacks on anonymity system always come down to injecting or deriving context. > In an adversarial environment (just so we are all on the same page, life is an adversarial environment), there are few limitations on the kinds of context attackers are allowed to inject or derive context from. > No anonymity system is absolute because there is always context. The majority of my research in this space centers around the context that people add on top of robust protocols that ultimately undermine them. I'm interested in practical failures, not theoretical restrictions. > Privacy will always been an active choice, not a passive tool. That doesn't make it impossible or out of reach or "dead", it makes it a fight worth fighting. https://twitter.com/SarahJamieLewis/status/1273743630801371137 https://twitter.com/SarahJamieLewis/status/12737436308013711... https://twitter.com/SarahJamieLewis https://twitter.com/SarahJamieLewis Sarah Jamie Lewis @SarahJamieLewis Executive Director @OpenPriv Anonymity hasn't the same requirements as secrecy does.
- fiatjaf 6y agoBetween inefficient and bad for privacy P2P DHTs and completely centralized or federated models from which you can be banned very easily, there exists a solution that takes the best of both worlds: https://github.com/fiatjaf/nostr https://github.com/fiatjaf/nostr. Basically it works like this: > Everybody runs a client. It can be a native client, a web client, etc. To publish something, you write a post, sign it with your key and send it to multiple relays (servers hosted by someone else, or yourself). To get updates from other people, you ask multiple relays if they know anything about these other people. Anyone can run a relay. A relay is very simple and dumb. It does nothing besides accepting posts from some people and forwarding to others. Relays don't have to be trusted. Signatures are verified on the client side.
- sneak 6y agoNote that due to the way APNS works, the notifications path on things like Element/Matrix, as well as XMPP/etc must be centralized with the (iOS) app developer anyway, even if the server isn’t.
- inshadows 6y agoLet me just quote n-gate: Signal is having technical difficulties January 15, 2021 (comments) Signal (business model: "Uber for texting") falls over. Most communications protocols are federated, and would survive one company's servers eating dirt, but Signal's owner/operator has decided this would degrade the user experience, presumably worse than the entire service shitting the bed out loud. Hackernews assumes that Signal is incapable of paying its hosting fees, and comes to the rescue by sending their money to a company that can't spin up cloud nodes fast enough to serve text messages. Other Hackernews bemoan the fact that once again they look like idiots, since they just conned half their friends and family into signing up for this mess.
- summm 6y agoThe author specifically criticizes IPFS and others, who do not care for privacy, and rightly so. However, this is not inherent to the technology. There are others who do, such as https://gnunet.org https://gnunet.org
- clankyclanker 6y agoAlso worth noting: https://briarproject.org https://briarproject.org
- jarbus 6y agoA great talk by Moxie on this very topic: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nj3YFprqAr8& https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Nj3YFprqAr8&