7 ms·
Are the Persian Gulf city-states slave societies?
- cmrdporcupine 6y ago"The kafala (sponsorship) system binds all low-status migrant workers in the Gulf to their employers. Generally, the kafala system requires the worker to obtain the employer’s permission to travel or leave the worksite to look for other employment. Regulations require a minimum of two years of work for the sponsor (kafeel) before such permission will even be considered. This encourages widespread wage suppression and conspiracies to deny such permission. Such ‘labour bans’ effectively bind the worker to the employer for a long period of time. More significantly, a worker can’t get an exit visa from the government without permission of the kafeel. "
- api 6y agoYes, that is slavery. You could argue that a less organized de facto system of slavery exists for migrant workers in many other countries including the USA. Migrants roam in and work but really have no rights as they are undocumented. People can intimidate them or worse largely with impunity because who would bother investigating? Sure technically it’s illegal to abuse migrants but nobody’s watching. Migrant work is something that really demands a coordinated international effort to reform. Then you have Uyghur forced labor in China. Slavery has not been abolished in anything but name.
- pk_kinetic 6y agoNot to mention the prison-industrial complex in the US.
- threatofrain 6y agoWhere does the wealth from such labor go?
- humbledrone 6y agoThe shareholders for the private prisons in which they are incarcerated: https://www.currentaffairs.org/2020/10/how-private-prisons-profit-from-forced-labor https://www.currentaffairs.org/2020/10/how-private-prisons-p... :(
- garrettgrimsley 6y ago“In 2015, just 8% of the nearly 1.53 million state and federal prisoners in the U.S. were in private facilities” [0]. Prison slavery is not concentrated in and won’t disappear by closing private prisons. [1] [0]https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/04/11/u-s-private-prison-population-has-declined-in-recent-years/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/04/11/u-s-private... [1]https://corpaccountabilitylab.org/calblog/2020/8/5/private-companies-producing-with-us-prison-labor-in-2020-prison-labor-in-the-us-part-ii https://corpaccountabilitylab.org/calblog/2020/8/5/private-c...
- rrsmtz 6y agoSometimes it's used by the state itself for cost savings, as in California under then-attorney general Kamala Harris (now Vice President): > “Extending 2-for-1 credits to all minimum custody inmates at this time would severely impact fire camp participation — a dangerous outcome while California is in the middle of a difficult fire season and severe drought,” lawyers from Harris’s office wrote in a filing. https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/politics/kamala-harris-office-sought-to-keep-inmates-locked-up-so-that-california-could-use-them-for-cheap-labor https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/politics/kamala-harris-of...
- Tiktaalik 6y agoThe benefits of reduced labour costs are the middle class. Similarly the middle class benefits from the lower working class wages that come from exploitation of illegal immigrants.
- lupire 6y agoWell, the upper middle class who have higher tier jobs. Not the working middle class. (In USA everyone is "middle" class, because most are too proud to have class consciousness.)
- stonecraftwolf 6y agoIIRC the first prison in the US was established in Auburn, NY specifically because slavery had been outlawed and some sociopath was like “ok, yeah, technically, but if we just convict them of a crime first...”
- ceejayoz 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Louisiana_State_Penitentiary https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Louisiana_State_Penitentiary serves as a notable modern example.
- lupire 6y agoNo. The Auburn prison was not the first prison, and it employed prisoner slave labor before slavery was outlawed. Prison slavery existed before chattel slavery was rerouted through the prison system. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Auburn_system https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Auburn_system
- boxmonster 6y agoI see nothing wrong with making prisoners earn their keep
- coldtea 6y agoDo you see anything wrong with having the most incancerated population in the world (25% of the global prison population for just 5% of the world population), or having the most horrendous prison conditions in all the western world? Do you see anything wrong with blacks and latinos being overrepresented? Do you see anything wrong with being such a backwater that you still have the death penalty, not to mention BS like "three strikes" laws? Do you see anything wrong with forced prison labor undercutting regular businesses in the same areas?
- trianglem 6y agoWhen they work for a $1/hr and put actual contractors out of business you understand why it’s like slave labor.
- Animats 6y agoEven Alcatraz didn't do that. "You are entitled to food, clothing, shelter, and medical care. Everything else is a privilege" - Alcatraz rules.
- michaelmrose 6y agoPrivate businesses pay private prisons far more than the prisoners get paid but less than legit labor driving out fairly paid labor. Everyone who is benefiting lobbies far stricter laws and harsher sentences not for societies benefit but so their labor force can grow. This slave labor is disproportionately taken from minorities and the poor who it is more acceptable to enslave. Mostly by patrolling areas which have lots of minorities and shaking them down in hopes of finding drugs. See the fact that black and white people do drugs at the same rate but white people are far less likely to be prosecuted. In one case they actually caught 2 judges taking bribes from private detention to hand juvenile offenders maximum sentences. Effectively selling other people's kids. Banning private prisons only removes a fraction of the incentive.
- AndyMcConachie 6y agoYou can buy products from American prison slaves here. https://unicor.gov/index.aspx https://unicor.gov/index.aspx
- goatinaboat 6y agoNot to mention the prison-industrial complex in the US. Kept well supplied with labour thanks to Kamala Harris and her draconian persecution of marijuana related “crimes”.
- cheph 6y ago> Migrants roam in and work but really have no rights as they are undocumented. If they don't want that situation they could always just not enter the US illegally.
- ch4s3 6y ago> they could always immigrate legally The current immigration system makes that impossible for most workers without degrees and from outside of a few select countries.
- cheph 6y agoSo then they can go somewhere else. There are billion of people living outside of the US. To suggest they are slaves because they chose to illegally enter the US makes no sense.
- ch4s3 6y agoI never said that, just that legal immigration to the US is basically closed to everyone, which is historically unusual for the US. I also think it's antithetical to the American project.
- cheph 6y agoSo then how are these people slaves if they could just not voluntarily choose to illegally enter a systemically racist country where people of color are hunted by cops like dogs and treated as subhuman trash by all white people?
- blix 6y agoIn many ancient Roman and Greek societies, migrant labor was actually lower on the totem pole than slavery. If you are a slave, at least your owner theoretically has an interest in your survival.
- antman 6y agoLet's point out that being a slave in those societies until very late in their existence did not always mean being locked with a chain. You would take out a loan or lose a costly war and there were whole shopping districts like Keramikos (pottery shops area) in Athens where the slaves had shops and tried to earn their way out of slavery. Any similarities with present societal structures purely circumstancial ofcourse.
- sudosysgen 6y agoIt's actually really depressing reading about this :/
- andrewjl 6y agoSounds really close to the current student loan regime in the US when you think about it.
- lupire 6y agoNo it doesn't. You came do whatever you want while you pay back loans.
- sudosysgen 6y agoIt was actually the same way. Outside of their slavery obligations, they were allowed to do whatever they wanted to pay back their sum to earn freedom, more or less. And of course, they did have their housing and food covered meanwhile.
- fuzzfactor 6y ago
- rgbrenner 6y agoMigrants, even illegal migrants, in the United States DO have rights. The bill of rights covers all people in our country, whether they are undocumented, tourists, students, or whatever. If you abuse them, they may be deported, but you can be prosecuted and serve prison time for abusing them. Taking away someone Visa is a crime too.. and preventing them from leaving is a felony. And we prosecute people all the time for that.. human traffickers, for example.
- m463 6y agoYou should read about migrants from central or south america - what they go through while traveling through intervening countries and mexico and then coyotes. And deportation back to that is a real threat which means they will shut up in the US. EDIT: wasn't picking on the US, just saying it's only part of their journey, and once they're in the US, lots of stuff goes unreported.
- rgbrenner 6y agoThere is a power imbalance between the employer and an illegal immigrant... they can certainly push that further than they could with a us citizen, but since they do have rights, there are limits to the abuse. The immigrant always has a way out, with the worst case penalty being deportation. Additionally: - In some cities ("sanctuary cities"), reporting a crime does not lead to deportation. - They can also apply for amnesty if the conditions in their home country are that bad. - Agencies accept anonymous reports. The immigrant doesnt even need to be working at the place at the time of the report. So depending on the circumstances of the abuse, there may be no consequences to the illegal immigrant for reporting.
- pseudo0 6y agoSounds like the real issue is the pull factor of lax immigration enforcement and widespread under the table employment in the US. We should be emulating the Australian model which has saved thousands of lives by effectively deterring dangerous human trafficking. With robust work visa verification and strict border security, coyotes and other human traffickers would be put out of business. Solve the problem of employers hiring illegal immigrants, and the issue of these employers abusing the inherent power imbalance disappears as well.
- hef19898 6y agoA friend of mine worked there in the 70s. German civil engineer, and the conditions, albeit luxurious, have been what I would call a labour camp. There seems to be a pattern there.
- oblio 6y agoAnd don't forget Europeans and Westerners in general have a super privileged position compared to the other workers.
- fakedang 6y agoThree things: a.) your German friend would likely have not been in the kafala system since that is for the labour force. b.) the kafala system has been banned in the UAE since 2005, with a pretty punitive fine regime, although that hasn't done enough to eliminate it (Govt. lenient treatment for its cronies vs independent contractors, both who follow the practice). It's still in force in other countries in the region. c.) Your friend will likely have been staying at a township for workers, which is often the common pattern for mining towns in most countries in Asia. Conditions usually tend to be luxuriant, and nowhere near the labour camps (which are actual camps).
- hef19898 6y agoOh yes, his position was absolutely privilged. It was the stories of how the local powerful people treated women and the fact that all f them had to turn over their passports. And the curfew covering leave from the compound, that bothered me. Pay was very good so. And yeah, the actual "workforce", e.g. manual labor, construction workers and so on had it way worse. I had a project in Dubai a couple of years ago, and all the people I was inc contact with were foreigners, on all levels. GM of logistics companies, warehouse workers, manaement, everyone was a foreigner. At the higher levels of management that changes, so.
- trianglem 6y agoSounds like the H1-B
- Animats 6y agoThe US lets immigrants leave if they want. Most US immigration issues revolve around people being forced to leave.
- nradov 6y agoOr around people being prevented from working rather than forced to work.
- dominotw 6y agoI didn't have to get permission from my employer to look for another job. Not sure if you are trolling. Flagged the comment.
- JohnBooty 6y agoH1-B is far from ideal to put it mildly, but it's about an order of magnitude away from what's described in the article.
- citizenkeen 6y agoNo it doesn't. Please educate yourself before contributing further.
- grecy 6y agoWhen I tried to get residency in Canada as a Software Engineer I was told by my local MP to get a minimum wage job for two years at Walmart, McDonalds or Canadian Tire because they had rubber-stamp approval with the government, and it was the easiest way. In my town, all the immigrants worked at those places, and they lived 15 to a small house. Not surprisingly, no Canadian was willing to do those jobs. While obviously not nearly as bad as the conditions in the article, it's certainly in a similar vein.
- mr_toad 6y agoSounds a lot like the way the serfs were treated in medieval Europe.
- 1996 6y agoNo, the kafala makes it indentured servitude, as was done in the US hundreds of years ago to pay for the expansive one-way trip. Migrant workers generally benefitted from it, which is why it never ran short of volunteers. Slavery does not benefit workers, which is why it requires physical capture and subjugation.
- khuey 6y agoDo these people get to stay in and become citizens of the host country after the term of their contract is up? I've never heard of that happening.
- 1996 6y agoCan anyone at all become a citizen of the persian countries? No, because they care about preserving their political system and way of life- a bit like Japan We may disagree, but it's their country. And people who don't like it can always leave (yes, I have heard the stories about passports being taken, I'd call that enforcing the contract for the initial term period, and it's not like consulates don't exist)
- AlotOfReading 6y agoYou can't preemptively "enforce a contract" by denying someone their basic human rights. Can you explain the ethical system that could possibly lead you to believe otherwise?
- michaelmrose 6y agoI'll take libertarian fantasies safely incubated in a society that won't allow the worst abuses that their philosophy would lead to unchecked for 500 Alex
- danans 6y ago> Can anyone at all become a citizen of the persian countries? They are not Persian countries. They are Arab countries that lie on the southwest shore of the Persian Gulf. There are huge cultural and linguistic differences between the two, to say nothing of the political differences, both historically and down to current moment. Furthermore, those Arab countries have been trying to change the international standard name of the body of water to "Arabian Gulf" to counter their adversary Iran. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persian_Gulf_naming_dispute#:~:text=The%20National%20Geographic%20Society%20uses,to%20this%20body%20of%20water.&text=%22Some%20Arab%20nations%20call%20it,known%20as%20the%20Persian%20Gulf.%22 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persian_Gulf_naming_dispute#:~... > Can anyone at all become a citizen No, unless you are ancestrally connected to the country or it's co-ethnic neighbors, or are a foreign woman who marries an Arab UAE citizen. Some selected naturalization requirements from the UAE's website (https://u.ae/en/information-and-services/passports-and-traveling/uae-nationality https://u.ae/en/information-and-services/passports-and-trave...): - An Arab individual from Omani, Qatari or Bahraini origin - Arab individual who enjoys full legal capacity, has continuously and lawfully resided in the member emirates for at least seven years - Any person, other than those mentioned above, who enjoys full legal capacity if he has continuously and legally resided in the member emirates for a period of no less than 30 years - A foreign woman married to a UAE National may be granted nationality by citizenship after the lapse of seven years As out of touch as this might seem with modernity, remember that the United States had anti-miscegenation laws on the books until 1967, and only opened immigration from non-white countries in 1965. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-miscegenation_laws_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-miscegenation_laws_in_the... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_and_Nationality_Act_of_1965 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_and_Nationality_Ac...
- dimitar 6y agoWhat percentage of the migrant labourers are slaves? The article seems to site examples of abuse (no doubt existing and still horrible), but seems to extrapolate them into the norm. I'm skeptical that it is the majority of cases since migrants send a huge amount of remittances to their home countries and a lot of people depend on this labor. In the article it was mentioned that a builder gets paid $28k per year which is still great for the majority of the world. This is one article on the dependence of some areas of India to remittances from the Gulf states: https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/nri/forex-and-remittance/how-economic-downturn-in-gulf-states-has-resulted-in-a-drop-in-remittances-into-india/articleshow/61511605.cms https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/nri/forex-and-remittanc...
- r00f 6y agoThe article says that it is not your traditional slavery. Yes they are getting paid and they support their families back home, and yet I am not surprised that they die in such numbers (according to article). You would understand if you came and just witnessed their living and working conditions. I've worked in Dubai for 4 years and despite I was paid well (and no income tax), it really felt like slavery. And seeing those poor souls in construction sites didnt add to my happiness either. Btw, i personally knew people who were paid 300$ per month (hotel room cleaning staff). That $28k average per year seems more like officially reported number, not the real one.
- isaacremuant 6y agoMaybe. Funnily enough. With the authoritarian and extremely damaging lockdowns in Europe, places like UAE feel 10 times more free than supposed democracies with a lot of freedom. Specially when it looks like dissenting in public (freedom of the press) might destroy your livelihood.
- sabujp 6y agoThis has been happening for decades, if western govt's look the other way then no one will do anything
- jeffreyrogers 6y agoI'm not sure things will improve much if Western governments start paying attention either.
- netsharc 6y agoI remember a reddit response to someone saying "Why would you live there, you're just condoning the slavery", the person wrote (I'll paraphrase), "Look around you, who made your clothes (probably underpaid Bangladeshi working in unsafe factories), who made your tech [or who mined the rare-earth metals needed], the difference is, in the West, you're a few steps further from this slavery.".
- hardlianotion 6y agoI guess the principled response to this is to take responsibility for what you use and wear. The responder is right but glib - his observation should not be a spur to silence and insensitivity to other people's living conditions make societies at all scales more unstable.
- justnotworthit 6y agosurely, the more "steps further from", the better.
- saiya-jin 6y agoAnybody who transferred flights in places like Dubai could see huge asymmetry in employees of airport between natives and foreign workers mostly from south east asia. Natives hardly do any work, look utterly bored and either chat or stare at phones all day long. Foreigners do all the actual hard work (unless they can't like security/immigration work). I am not surprised, after many stories how badly folks from ie Nepal are treated there. I don't see even a slight international pressure from big players like US or EU. Maybe similar reasons like with China - don't mess with important players, in this case oil providers? Man, I sure do miss traveling...
- smabie 6y agoAll Emiraties in Dubai get paid huge salaries and as you say, do pretty much nothing. Police officers might make 200k/yr. It's pretty much a giant welfare state. Many foreigners do very well over there as well, but a much larger percent (Africans, Indians, and southeast Asians) do not. Also the number of women imported on tourist visas for prostitution is staggering.
- grecy 6y ago> Anybody who transferred flights in places like Dubai could see huge asymmetry in employees of airport between natives and foreign workers mostly from south east asia. Natives hardly do any work, look utterly bored and either chat or stare at phones all day long. Every time I go to the USA I'm shocked when I see that exact same asymmetry between service workers and the white-collar class.
- dang 6y agoPlease see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25972311 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25972311 and stop posting nationalistic flamebait to HN. It doesn't matter which country you have a problem with—you're breaking the site guidelines and it needs to stop. Please don't do it again.
- preommr 6y agoI think a really big problem with these discussions is that "slavery" is too broad a term. There's a huge difference between the brutal chattel slavery of black people in early American history and what some people call being "corporate slave" where someone has to work long hours in a white collar job. And yet, people still use the word "slave" for both. And the usage is both serious and unironic.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoThe actual article goes into a lot of analysis of exactly what they mean by slavery in relation to ancient slave societies.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- vixen99 6y agoThe 'problem' is introduced by you. The subtitle is "The glittering city-states of the Persian Gulf fit the classicist Moses Finley’s criteria of genuine slave societies" and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery_in_the_21st_century https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery_in_the_21st_century which expands on the topic worldwide, isn't about working long hours in a white collar job.
- monadic3 6y agoDid you mean blue collar? The articulation of american wage slavery does not typically orient around white collar jobs.
- tokai 6y agoNo it's not a broad term. It is precisely defined by international conventions. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1926_Slavery_Convention https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1926_Slavery_Convention
- amir734jj 6y agoAs someone who grew up in the middle east near the gulf countries, this is a well-known problem for a long time. The labor is extremely cheap there and none of the Arab natives of these countries work as laborers. Unfortunately it doesn't stop at labor workers, there is a lot of human trafficking there as well. The skyscrapers and the shiny downtowns don't get built by themselves. Someone pays the price.
- Ericson2314 6y agoObviously what goes on there is a whole other level, but even in the the rest of the world, we should realize that allowing someone to a live and work in a country without enfranchising them is an affront to democracy.
- jhbadger 6y agoBut when? Immediately? As somebody who has worked abroad myself I wouldn't think it appropriate if I suddenly was granted citizenship in a country for just working there for a few years. There should always be a path to citizenship, but I think it is reasonable that you have to live somewhere a decade or so and show that you have a basic understanding of the culture and language first.
- Ericson2314 6y agoI'm pretty materialist. So let's igmore culture/language: if you have a job, they are getting benefits of your presence immediately. So shouldn't you get some franchise immediately? If you don't vote, aren't you effectively a scab on democracy? The US is kinda hypocritical in that on one hand there is a tacit desire to lord it over non-citizens, and in the other hand there is a vocal concern about exacerbating the glut of labor. Well, an individual American can't have it both ways: you're either a net worker or net owner.
- Ericson2314 6y agoAnother nest trick, what if instead of waiting to accrue the franchise, there was a way to retroactively remove the franchise of those that leave. Why should the past rule over the future?
- chmod600 6y agoWhat do you mean exactly and how would that work?
- 6y ago
- eplanit 6y agoThis is well-depicted in the movie "Syriana". One of the characters and his uncle are working for the oil industry in such circumstances. Spoiler alert: the nephew becomes and extremist/terrorist, showing how easy it is for a young person with no options and in such circumstances to be so persuaded.
- ficklepickle 6y agoYou are dangerously close to empathizing with terrorists, citizen. How dare you try and understand them. We have always been at war with terrorism. This incidence of extremism has been added to your social credit report. /s
- mellosouls 6y agoThat's a terrific film, but a bit misleading in its central message; many of the most infamous terrorists and extremists in the real world (bin Laden an example) seem to have middle-class/privileged backgrounds.
- fakedang 6y agoActually I think it was really good at showing exactly that. The young Pakistani guy was just a pawn in the game controlled by somebody way above, whom we don't even see in the movie. His immediate superior in the militant ranks, the Arab, looks clearly more educated than he is. That is exactly how these terrorist organizations are structured.
- afrcnc 6y agoshort answer, yes, if you're a migrant
- monadic3 6y agoYes.
- hkai 6y agoAs a general rule, if the headline of an article is a question, the answer is "No".
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoI believe Kurt Gödel once wrote an article called "Is Betteridge's Law Of Headlines Always Correct?"
- joejohnson 6y agoNo more than any capitalist society. The gulf states are just an extreme examples of exploitation, but capitalism necessitates treating a slice of society as expendable labor.
- joejohnson 6y agoLook at an example from the other end of the spectrum, Switzerland, a capitalist society with a good human rights record (at least that’s the general consensus among western nations). One of their largest multinationals, Nestlé, successfully fought a policy proposal last year that would require Swiss corporations to follow environmental and human rights regulations across their entire supply chain (the Konzernverantwortungsinitiative [1]). Weeks after this initiative barely failed to pass, Nestlé won a decision in the US Supreme Court meaning the country could not be sued by former child slaves in US court [2]. 1. https://www.srf.ch/news/abstimmung-29-november-2020/konzernverantwortung/menschenrechte-und-wirtschaft-die-schweiz-ist-kein-sonderfall https://www.srf.ch/news/abstimmung-29-november-2020/konzernv... (German) 2. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-court-slavery-idUSKBN28B5X9 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-court-slavery-idUSKBN...
- estaseuropano 6y agoOne company finding its way around the rules and manipulating lawmakers to change the rules for them is still far from the systemic and structural slavery in the UAE.
- joejohnson 6y agoCompanies finding their way around rules by manipulating lawmakers sounds “systemic” or “structural”. And the example I gave was literally a law banning use of slave labor. Only difference is where the slaves are located.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ibn_khaldun 6y agoThere is no doubt that the conditions in these areas are horrid. But trying to rectify them under an Islamic pretense will prove fruitless because the countries involved are not Islamic territories.
- johnyzee 6y agoMaybe. But singling them out while happily consuming products produced under similar, or worse, conditions reeks hippocracy. It is fully in our power to force companies to source manufacturing to places where you have more than one day off in a year, or are paid in more than lodging and rice, but we don't like to talk about this, although that is actually within our power to change. Why is this? And, preemptively, this is not 'whataboutism'. As I said, our own consumption patterns are in our hands to change (arguably this includes enabling these gulf states with our tourism dollars but that's another point). But we hear a lot of whining about this 'slavery', however accurate that may be, but hardly any discussion about the outsourced manufacturing processes that we wholly depend on, which almost certainly fit the bill as much as anything.
- rayiner 6y agoWhat’s deeply messed up is that in Bangladesh, where I’m from, people are way more outraged at Israel (which they have zero connection to personally) than quasi-slavery of other Bangladeshis in the Gulf States. It’s the product of powerful propaganda. It’s kind of horrifying to see the effect of that same propaganda here in the US recently.
- danans 6y ago> than quasi-slavery of other Bangladeshis in the Gulf States. It’s the product of powerful propaganda. Why is it surprising? It's not complicated. Gulf states - not Israel - pay the bills in Bangladesh. It also throws in religious fundamentalist indoctrination schools for free, schools that preach hatred of Israel. > It’s kind of horrifying to see the effect of that same propaganda here in the US recently. The majority of the US supports both Israel's and the Palestinians' right to exist without oppression and fear of attack. People are largely opposed to either party violating that principle. Perhaps you missed the outrage in the US at the murder of Jamal Khashoggi, or the bipartisan condemnation of the Saudis' war against Yemen while the previous president and his family courted them, or the US renewable energy industry that is trying to decouple us from Gulf petroleum dependency. The US public has deeply soured on the Gulf States across the political spectrum. The only people who are still warm to them, as ever, are those who seek access to their immense capital or are enamored with their theocratic and authoritarian system of government.
- rayiner 6y agoI wonder if Khashoggi’s murder would have gotten a much attention if Trump hadn’t commented about it.
- danans 6y agoThat's a diversionary hypothetical, and not a very effective one. Especially given the obvious reality that Khashoggi's employer was the Washington Post, which clearly had a reason call out for the truth about his disappearance and murder, and the means to distribute that call on it's opinion pages. Furthermore, the previous President addressed his killing in the mildest possible terms, claiming (laughably) that the Saudi ruler had no involvement. https://mobile.twitter.com/Acosta/status/1064939271113637890?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1064939271113637890%7Ctwgr%5E%7Ctwcon%5Es1_&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fd-3411137493539362486.ampproject.net%2F2101211748002%2Fframe.html https://mobile.twitter.com/Acosta/status/1064939271113637890...
- aaron695 6y ago> 2022 FIFA World Cup, more than 4,000 migrant workers will die in workplace accidents on FIFA projects before the event takes place. This is clearly made up. So if you want to believe they are slave states you have to ask why do they need fake statements like this. Also why are they slave states just because the workers are next door. There's no moral difference for us using their oil or buying shoes or seafood from Asia.