20 ms·
> The notification, seen by Reuters, said without detail that the group violated policies on “adult sexual exploitation.” That's some bullshit right there. Spi
by paxys 6y ago
> The notification, seen by Reuters, said without detail that the group violated policies on “adult sexual exploitation.”
That's some bullshit right there. Spin the wheel, come up with a random charge, and ban the entire community with zero recourse and no way to appeal.
- TeeMassive 6y agoLaughs in conservative. It musts be your first time.
- morlockabove 6y ago"It's a private company, they can do what they want!"
- mattigames 6y agoI don't think the people who came up with that rule really accounted for one company becoming the main channel of communication for the human race.
- morlockabove 6y agoPeople were using the argument five years ago, 4,3,2, yesterday. Whenever one of these monopolies does something to A that B approves of and A objects, B comes out with IAPCTCDWTW. People generally seem love to make excuses for Power when it's stepping on people they don't like, and are then somehow surprised when Power turns around and crushes them.
- mattigames 6y agoI never mentioned no sides so I'm not following you here; but to answer to your argument even if the government gets control of FB and decides to silence some group I support (e.g. homosexuals) and therefore I disagree with such decision I still would prefer that control of a main communication platform to be in hands of the government and not random executives, in such case my focus (and people's) would be to have a less homophobic government where at least my vote counts and not some random execs that I have no minor influence upon.
- tomp 6y agoIf you don’t like it, build your own stock market.
- gruez 6y agoYou literally can't because of government regulations, although spinning up your own self-hosted community hasn't been regulated yet and is fairly easy.
- SulfurHexaFluri 6y agoJust build your own country on an island to run your stock market.
- dudul 6y agoAre there still islands that have not been claimed by a country?
- ttt0 6y agoNo one is stopping you from building your own island. Stop whining.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mcosta 6y agoItaly does not agree with that. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republic_of_Rose_Island https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Republic_of_Rose_Island
- SulfurHexaFluri 6y agoThe problem was that he didn't make his own military to defend the land
- 6y ago
- iab 6y agoThis is going to be the rallying cry of the apocalypse, isn’t it
- ihsw 6y agoIt already is, the anti-lockdown folks are pointing to it as hypocrisy and duplicity. Social media can do as it pleases because "it's a private company" but restaurants that comply with every regulation under the sun are crushed under the weight of lockdown mania.
- Simulacra 6y agoSo businesses can reopen?
- morlockabove 6y agoSorry, they can do what they want if they're funded by venture capital.
- google234123 6y agoJust build your own website bro Just build your own host bro Just build your own financial banking system bro just build your own social media platform bro just build your own payment processing platform bro just build your own internet infrastructure bro
- grecy 6y agoToday I saw: Common Folk: We want a chance at financial stability." Rich Folk: "Invest your money." Common Folk: "OK, GME it is." Rich Folk: "Wait. Not like that. Stop. This clearly must be outlawed."
- perl4ever 6y agoSometimes people ask, why do rich people keep striving for more money? What is the point of having $1B instead of $100M, or $10B instead of $1B, or $100B instead of $10B? Sometimes the answer is given, that it's the same impulse as playing a computer game and money is the score. But the last few days, something else occurred to me, watching the kind of disarray of various billionaire hedge fund types. A big attraction of wealth on that level must be the sense that you're smarter than nearly anyone else. This situation punctures that and it seems like a lot of quotes in the news are about scrambling to save face and protect peoples' self images. I don't think they are actually outraged over monetary losses as such. It's interesting that people are comparing it to Occupy Wall Street.
- rokhayakebe 6y agoMoney is the score
- perl4ever 6y agoWhen playing a computer game, of course, after you get a high score, you start over at zero, and there's a good chance you switch to a different game.
- gruez 6y ago
- SulfurHexaFluri 6y agoFacebook is kind of fucked both ways tbh. If they don't remove anything they get blasted for hosting violence and abuse and if they remove too much they get blasted for censorship. Its impossible for them to remove just the right amount of stuff since thats subjective and they could never train a million moderators on how to apply it. I think the real solution here is we need to break up the social media companies. Have each community be its own self hosted website again where the moderators of the community take responsibility for it and apply their own rules. The government can then step in and take action if the communities are illegal.
- morlockabove 6y agoIf we can get federated solutions to be nice enough, maybe that'll do it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Calamity 6y agoAgree on the first part, but the second part doesn't seem as though it would practically work. Subreddits are the closest approximation and they still fall under a monolithic umbrella (and struggle to cope). Also, in terms of balance of power, breaking up all the different communities into separate smaller units gives too much power to the government IMO. It's essentially the ideal situation for a government who would like to pressure anyu one smaller community. Much harder to shush/gag/silence/stealth takedown a Facebook or a Reddit than it is a small entity. Divide & Conquer. Facebook is definitely stuck between a rock and a hard place here though. This is why I think Mark Zuckerberg is actually being authentic when he says that "Facebook needs more regulation". He's already seen this problem and knows that having that subjective burden offloaded onto the government is the only true solution, i.e. "just tell me what the rules are and I shall play by them". Conveniently, these additional rules would also make it much harder for a new entrant to come unseat Facebook. So more regulation from the government is, in reality, win-win for Facebook.
- tester34 6y ago
- tarkin2 6y agoYes. They are a private company. Yes they can do what they want. And people can critizise. It was the same with Trump and it is the same now.
- morlockabove 6y agoHow does zuck's zuckle taste?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 6y agoNo, see, what you don't get is that they're a big company and people really want to use their product, so the rules are different... for some reason, I guess?
- dudul 6y agoI was joking today with one of my buddies: "Give it 24 to 48 hours and they're gonna start claiming that WSB are pedophiles or something".
- swader999 6y agoThey're more into each other's wive's boyfriends.
- tony101 6y ago> "with zero recourse and no way to appeal" Actually, they can try to appeal to the new Facebook Oversight Board.[1] They released their first set of decisions today, overturning some Facebook removals.[2] [1] https://oversightboard.com/appeals-process/ https://oversightboard.com/appeals-process/ [2] https://www.oversightboard.com/decision/ https://www.oversightboard.com/decision/ More info: https://www.npr.org/2021/01/28/961391277/facebook-supreme-court-orders-social-network-to-restore-4-posts-in-first-rulings https://www.npr.org/2021/01/28/961391277/facebook-supreme-co...
- hourislate 6y agoIt's too bad the same doesn't apply to them. Like the Gov or someone coming along and saying that there is adult sexual exploitation going on on their platform, we're shutting you down and banning you. Fuck I only wish....can you imagine how much healthier society would be without farcebook.
- pfraze 6y agoOkay so I completely agree but I want to add something to what’s going on Half the fun of WSB is that it is enormously offensive. The foundation of the community is that a forum talking about stock investing strategies is, at its heart, really dumb. It’s harder than most people can manage to evaluate all the “DD” flying around and any advice other than playing it safe (r/investing) is stupid to take from a rando on a forum. WSB’s culture is a reaction which embraces how stupid the exercise is, and then races to the bottom on rhetoric, which makes it all about meme irony. So they (excuse the language) call themselves “retards,” “degenerates,” and “autists” (again, their words). It sometimes gets more offensive from there, but they try to keep the insults self-targeted. Generally speaking they’re pretty clever and witty in their behavior, but you know how this gets when it goes mainstream. Less clever people show up and attach to the “offensive” part without bringing along the “clever” part. My general sense is that WSB works hard to moderate within its sensibility so it stays enjoyable, but with the big influx, I’d bet Facebook and Discord are either reacting to behavior which is slipping past the WSB mods due to the influxes, or they’re reacting to the aesthetic without understanding the underlying wit. Another side-effect of going mainstream: it becomes political, and politics is perception. Frankly though, I think most people would enjoy WSB culture right now, given the underdog narrative and the embrace of the irreverent. If I were Facebook or Discord, I’d trust WSB mods to get things back under control and help them protect the community, not ban it. That said, I’d bet good money their reasons for banning are not evidence-free. So the real question is, why aren’t these platforms helping WSB mods instead of banning the community.
- aquaticsunset 6y agoDiscord has since taken the stance of helping the mods, instead of permaban. I liked hearing that news earlier today. https://www.theverge.com/2021/1/28/22254339/discord-r-wallstreetbets-server-help-moderation-ban https://www.theverge.com/2021/1/28/22254339/discord-r-wallst...
- pfraze 6y agoThat’s really encouraging to hear
- kardianos 6y agoIn Soviet Russia, if you were caught with religious literature, they would charge you with possession of pornography.
- dalbasal 6y agoWhen everyone is a criminal, anyone can be arrested. The reddit mods have basically made this charge, in their own special WSB way. It's impossible for moderators to fully control large groups, subs and such. Some bannable comments will always be present, and they are limited by whatever moderation tools they get from reddit. Meanwhile, the idea that discord, reddit (throttled not banned) and FB all simultaneously and coincidentally took these actions during the gamestop maneuver is not even 1% believable. WTF.
- mike00632 6y agoIt's kind of all over the news and getting a lot of attention. Couldn't that easily explain the attention Facebook now gives?
- lenkite 6y agoYou just need a few saboteurs coming in and posting "hate speech" on your forum and then reporting the same. Before you know it, you are banned, you have (several) news articles objectifying you as nazis and you are doxxed to high-heaven. The only way you can get back is if you are "friends" with the big-boys or the mainstream media.
- paxys 6y agoThe oldest trick in the book for governments and large organizations. Large peaceful protest happening? Send some goons to blend in and cause trouble, and arrest everyone.
- Lammy 6y ago> if you are "friends" with the big-boys or the mainstream media For example: Bohemian Club was originally founded by San Francisco newspapermen in 1872, and you can see how many friends they have in very very high places. Manufacturing Consent is not a new phenomenon. https://web.archive.org/web/20110720044742/http://library.sonoma.edu/regional/faculty/phillips/bohemian.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20110720044742/http://library.so...
- sneak 6y ago
- rufus_foreman 6y agoFirst they came for the Trump supporters, and I did not speak out - because I was not a Trump supporter.
- throwaway8582 6y agoThat's a new one. I'm surprised they didn't go with the usual "hate speech" or "white supremacy".
- H_Pylori 6y agoMake the rules arbitrary and impossible to follow, then selectively enforce them. Oldest trick in the book, works like a charm.
- WClayFerguson 6y agoBigTech has been treating conservatives like this for a few years now. Welcome to the club, democrats. Glad you can finally see clearly now.
- dang 6y agoPlease stop posting ideological flamebait. You've done a ton of it in the last 24 hours, it's not what this site is for, and we ban accounts that do it—regardless of which flavor you favor or how strongly you feel about it. Fortunately your recent account history doesn't show much of this before the current episode, and many of your comments seem downright excellent. That's great. Please go back to that and don't do any more of this. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html, we'd appreciate it. The idea here is substantive, thoughtful conversation on topics of intellectual curiosity.
- WClayFerguson 6y agoI have no idea whether you're an admin, or just a prankster "dang", but it's true no one should kick the progressives while they're down. The important thing is they now realize BigTech censorship is a problem for all Americans, and not just conservatives.
- dang 6y agoI'm an admin and unfortunately I have to ban people who contribute to destroying this place. You did a lot of that in the last 24 hours. I don't think that's hard to see. I don't want to ban you, so please go back to using HN as intended so I don't have to. > The important thing is they now realize If you want people to realize something, you need to explain it to them patiently and respectfully, and include a certain amount of overlap with what they already know and feel. That's a totally different mode of communication than flaming rhetoric. People don't learn when beaten with flaming sticks (verbally any more than physically). They just go rigid, double down, and lash back. If you actually want them to learn, that is the worst way to make it happen. Flaming is something we do to other people, not for them. We do it for ourselves, to vent our anger and frustration (not that it really helps us either, but it at least provides a little temporary relief). That's partly why it contributes to destroying communication and community. We want communication and community here, so please do the opposite from now on.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoWhile I won't say the punishment is fair, it would not surprise me to learn people we're selling themselves for stock tips/shares on the group.
- danboarder 6y agoAs the saying goes, "if it's free, you're the product". And all of these de-platforming moves are in response to 'defective product'. The community they sell to advertisers is acting defective and becomes unsellable, thus that community is tossed out/shut down. Enough other communities remain manageable & sellable, so business continues on.
- pylua 6y agoThey should really ban links and cut ties to twitter then. Has anyone seen want people post on there? It's crazy. My problem is that they bully small platforms but big platforms that also have huge problems with their users must be too big too fail. They should probably just shut themselves down also because of the capitol riots. Do the right thing facebook, shut yourself down.
- beaner 6y agoThis is exactly how many Trump-supporting forums were shut down.
- quantummkv 6y agoThe slippery slope is in full effect. Platforms engaged in mass, coordinated de-platformings and people lapped it up because orange man bad. Now the orange man is gone, but the mass coordinated de-platformings still remain and are now being wielded for YOLO reasons. I have been on wsb subreddit and discord server for a long time. There has been zero change in the culture or the type of content or the tone of the conversations in all that while, right uptill the discord server was banned. Either these platforms knew there was bad content but did nothing, or they know there is no bad content but are using it as a flimsy excuse to help out their fellow Harvard MBA's. Ironically the orange man would be the one laughing at all of this today.
- ceilingcorner 6y agoWe all said this when it was happening. No one listened.
- Yizahi 6y agoAs if it started with orange man or if it was his political program at any point before 2019. He never advocated regulating megacorps and started his whining only when he himself got hit. Cutting and regulating megacorps was always initiative from the left side. Orange man just appropriated that idea recently to ride the outrage train.
- stjohnswarts 6y agoIt seems they got a taste of power and like it. Zucked.
- downandout 6y agoThe issue is that in any group of sufficient size, someone at some point will use a slur or phrase that someone who is really reaching can turn into a claim like this. The excuse in WSB’s case with Discord was “hate speech”. This then overflowed into the Financial Times falsely labeling WSB as an “alt-right” group [1]. Unfortunately in today’s hyper-PC environment, this is such an easy way to instantly deplatform your enemies that it will continue to be abused. Any large group can be shutdown at any time should the powers that be decide they don’t like it - they just have to find a single post that the PC police would find objectionable. It’s one of the dangers of allowing such thin claims to have such instant, fatal effects with with no ability to fight or appeal. [1] https://twitter.com/wsbmod/status/1354720831218339845?s=21 https://twitter.com/wsbmod/status/1354720831218339845?s=21
- chris123 6y agoThat's what you voted for.