19 ms·
Silicon Valley is shutting down speech loopholes. Latest target: live content
- thebible 6y agoThis is a good thing. It was only a matter of time before the perceived total unlimited sense of freedom of speech that pervaded the internet turned toxic. There's an expression "free as in speech or free as in beer," but in reality both of those things cost money.
- klyrs 6y ago"Free as in pony" is my favorite phrase to convey cost of otherwise "free" things
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoI am gonna steal that, its neat
- emptyparadise 6y agoPony theft is a serious crime.
- cbozeman 6y agoMy God this is truly the best phrase. It works on so many levels... "Free", but there's the associated cost of upkeep... a barn, it has to be washed, dried, groomed, fed, vaccinated, check-ups, exercised, and lastly, you have to deal with the horseshit... and best part of your expression, is it means you have to deal with both the literal and metaphorical horseshit. :) Bravo sir or madam.
- teddyh 6y agoI would suggest “Free as a white elephant.”: https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/white_elephant https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/white_elephant
- chrisco255 6y agoI for one, welcome our corporate overlords deciding what ideas are good for us and what ideas are bad for us. Thinking is difficult!
- AmericanChopper 6y agoDon’t worry. Once all the speech loopholes have been closed, I’m sure they’ll figure out how to fix the remaining thought loopholes too.
- chrisco255 6y agoYes, I think Neuralink is working on that problem! I'll just connect mine directly to Google Cloud!
- tjr225 6y agoIn a free market you can choose who your corporate “overlords” are. So; which are you for? Should the government prevent monopolies from having free speech? Because telling google or whoever what or what not they allow in their private platforms is anti free speech. 0r should the government simply prevent monopolies so you have the choice to go somewhere else to consume whatever frothing angry garbage you wish to consume? You don’t get to have it both ways but both are contrarian to ridiculous libertarian ideals- funny how that works.
- AmericanChopper 6y agoJust need to make your own social media platform, right? Let the market decide?
- devmunchies 6y agoor Option C: we continue to complain so public opinion can change thus creating enough demand for alternatives and then we leave google to die. We get the law, no need to bring it up every chance you get. All these BigCorp white knights aren't doing the public any favors with your wet-blanketry.
- emtel 6y agoThis article is about someone whose livestream was shut down while attempting to cover rallies where participants were carrying firearms. Why is it a good thing this was shut down?
- alfalfasprout 6y agoAh, and internet mobs and companies should decide for us? This is a very, very troubling perspective.
- admiralspoo 6y agoI pity anyone with a conscience who works at one of the FANGs.
- SixDouble5321 6y agoYet another example of Google trying to solve all problems algorithmically. It's not useful to say "if firearm then block content."
- koolba 6y agoI had to squint to read the email, but I think it’s specific to live streams. I’m going to guess that the original intention was to block suicide / snuff live streams. Though that’s pure speculation on my part.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- megous 6y agohttps://www.moneycontrol.com/news/world/new-zealand-mosque-shooter-was-radicalised-on-youtube-report-6204331.html https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/world/new-zealand-mosque-s... Maybe they don't want livestreams like this?
- cbozeman 6y agoWell too goddamn bad. That's part of life in a post-Enlightenment world. You don't get to have the all the great shit without all the worst shit along with it. The very nature of freedom means at some point, someone is going to do something you don't like. And I don't mean the mosque shooting. That was illegal. I mean part of having a free society means you have put up with people saying crazy nonsensical bullshit that any reasonable person would laugh at and then click on a new video. And you're going to have some group of people who are just dumb, or are easily impressionable, or are easily persuaded, or are whatever. Maybe the sickness isn't in the platform, either... maybe the sickness is somewhere else... and nobody wants to bother with it because its actually hard, and will actually cost money to deal with it. And to that, I also say, "Too goddamn bad." Its not a buffet and you don't get to choose, you have to accept the whole dinner, the hákarl along with the strawberry cheesecake.
- tmpz22 6y agoJust 3 hours ago a group of teens live streamed themselves stabbing a 15 year old girl to death in Louisiana [1]. Like twitch swatting this is not a new phenomenon. Clearly something needs to be done to discourage or eliminate such content. [1]: https://www.fox13memphis.com/news/trending/4-teen-girls-charged-walmart-stabbing-death-15-year-old-girl-streamed-facebook-live/QTAQM5N3LVC6ZCOEKWM3DC4PM4/ https://www.fox13memphis.com/news/trending/4-teen-girls-char...
- bpodgursky 6y agoDo you have any evidence that this contributed to the actual act? If anything, this just provides good evidence that will put the idiots in prison.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- edbob 6y agoThe article is talking about Google's suppression of independent reporting content that regularly appears on the news. It has nothing to do with anyone being killed.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- emptyparadise 6y agoYou won't believe how many disturbing murders are not live streamed. Let's try to deal with the "murder" and not the "content" part.
- cbozeman 6y ago> Clearly something needs to be done to discourage or eliminate such content. What do you plan to do, Dr. Manhattan? Because you're talking about human nature... and even you can't change that. You said so yourself.
- mamon 6y agoWhat did you expect? Several years ago Google openly declared that they are turning evil :)
- onion2k 6y agoThe "And remember… don’t be evil, and if you see something that you think isn’t right – speak up!"[1] line is still in Google's Code of Conduct. All they did is remove a line from near the start; it's always been there at the end as well. [1] https://abc.xyz/investor/other/google-code-of-conduct/ https://abc.xyz/investor/other/google-code-of-conduct/
- creata 6y agoTo Jordan Chariton exclaiming in all caps: > How are journalists supposed to chronicle history if YouTube — and others — are outlawing it? Regardless of what YouTube says, they are an advertiser-friendly entertainment website. Why in God's name would you use it to "chronicle history"?
- Swizec 6y ago> Why in God's name would you use it to "chronicle history"? Because for better or for worse these platforms have become the public square. They are where modern life happens.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cbsks 6y agoClearly YouTube doesn’t want to be a public square.
- honest_guy 6y agoIn that case, they should forgo their section 230 protections and stand boldly as the *publisher* they want to be.
- pwinnski 6y agoThat's not how the CDA works. https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20200531/23325444617/hello-youve-been-referred-here-because-youre-wrong-about-section-230-communications-decency-act.shtml https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20200531/23325444617/hello...
- paxys 6y agoWhat makes you think publishers don’t have section 230 protections? Have you ever been to the opinion or comments sections on Fox News?
- deleted 6y ago
- yew 6y agoIt's simply irresponsible for so-called "independent journalists" to cover material that neither they nor their audiences are in a position to understand. We've seen what several decades of totally unregulated broadcasting have done, to the detriment of our society - without well-funded expert guidance, conspiracy theories and extremism run rampant. Platforms must be restricted to those who prove they can use them appropriately.
- dadzilla 6y agoAnd you are qualified to express this view how?
- yew 6y agoExperts are usually vetted by regulators and other experts, not random members of the public. As anyone is presently free to say whatever they please, I see no reason to share my personal information with the world.
- vimy 6y agoLike the experts who said the virus wasn’t a problem and also that masks are useless?
- yew 6y ago> Like the experts who said the virus wasn’t a problem and also that masks are useless? This being a wonderful example of the right-wing propaganda so prominent (though I won't say universal) in this mess. Cause a problem, then blame others for it. We've all had more than enough of correcting it at every turn. Why not do something about that?
- cbozeman 6y agoDo you remember when Hank Paulson said he had the utmost confidence in the stability and resiliency of our markets? Right before a literally historic housing market crash occurred, that then became an enormous stock market crash. How much more of an expert would you want than Hank Paulson, who added billions of value to Goldman Sachs bottom line, who he himself made $1bn working there, and who had been in the financial industry for 30+ years at the time, and who was the Secretary of the Treasury? What kind of "expertise" should he have had in your perfect utopia? I should remind you that Paulson was indeed vetted by regulators, other experts, and Congress, and was widely considered a great choice as SecTres. We see how that worked out. An autistic medical doctor predicted the housing market crash 3 years before Paulson made that statement, so as far as I can see, so much for your so-called experts. In fact, I think if you'll try less to defer to experts and more to defer to history, you'll find a very long list of people who were held in the highest esteem who continually got shit wrong, and very very few who got it right.
- condomhacker 6y agoI think that politics and extreme content should live on their own sites and should not be discussed on sites like twitter. Just like how porn is not readily available on the platforms, politics should be the same, be it left or right.
- jancsika 6y agoGoogle is like a virtual version of Walmart, if Walmart had cornered U.S. flea markets and installed trapdoors in each stall to flush vendors down into the sewer at a moments notice. The best part is that everybody starts quoting the first amendment, and Google is like, "Look, we hear you. Just tell us where our intractable flushing procedure fucked up, and we will promise to never again accidentally flush that vendor into the sewer."
- SulfurHexaFluri 6y agoBasically. I get the "its their service, and you agreed to the terms" but these tech corps are so big and powerful its on a scale unimaginable when these laws and ideas were originally created and its probably time to rethink how we let corporations run when they basically control the world.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoIt seems to me that the first step is to stop letting the tech corps control your world. If the range of opinion on popular platforms is too restricted, make a deliberate effort to step back from popular platforms onto group chats and random blogs and web forums, the same way we used to a decade ago. Most people who do this, in my experience, realize that it's actually pretty easy to see and talk about what you want these days. Youtube's content policies are still a problem, but they're the same kind of problem as CBS's content policies, not an existential threat to free speech.
- SulfurHexaFluri 6y agoThese tech companies make it harder and harder to avoid their lock in platforms. They crush and buy all the competitors and end up with userbases so big that if you do not participate you will be missing out. I never wish to sign up for facebook but they have crippled the alternative buy and sell sites, obsoleted most forums and are now invading the VR space with their spyware. At some point we need to stop blaming the user and look at what we can do to curb the size and power of these companies.
- tylerjwilk00 6y agoPeaceful gun rights advocates doesn't fit the "Guns are bad, mkay." narrative.
- barnaclejive 6y agonah. fuck em, mkay?
- emptyparadise 6y agoMy question to everyone supporting restrictions on speech and supporting privacy violations, even for good reasons, is this: are you prepared to have these tools fall into the wrong hands? The same methods used to quickly shut down a dangerous website or to track down a terrorist by their online posts can be used to silence protests and to hunt down political opposition.
- scrollaway 6y agoI would agree with you in the context of a government or public body. But in the context of private companies, these "tools" were always available. The wrong hands were always able to use them. And did, many times, in fact. Like, the problems you're describing are real but they aren't new, and aren't particularly a bigger threat now than they were before.
- thisiscorrect 6y agoMarket concentration might make them a bigger problem today than before, though.
- duxup 6y agoI'm not prepared to have them 'fall into the wrong hands'. But these platforms are owned by these companies. What rules do we put in place that they have to host some of this content? Blatant misinformation, vague encouragement of violence... hate? Is the price of free speech that someone has to host it? Who doesn't want to?
- revnode 6y ago> What rules do we put in place that they have to host some of this content? Blatant misinformation, vague encouragement of violence... hate? Why do they have to be rules? Why can't we have a culture of tolerance? Robots aren't running these companies. They're people, just like you and me. They can choose to be tolerant. Tolerance is about tolerating the most horrid things. Not because it's nice or those things have some value. They're horrid, they have no value. It's because the alternative is worse. Because censorship is worse. Because when a person is censored, when they can't speak, they resort to violence and through censorship, you encourage violence. And violence can't be censored. It can only be suppressed with further violence.
- tribby 6y agoindependent media would probably do well to look at independent infrastructure. owncast[1] is an interesting project (no affiliation), I’d be curious if there are more like it. 1. https://github.com/owncast/owncast https://github.com/owncast/owncast
- colllectorof 6y agoThe fact that an "independent infrastructure" project gets referenced by linking to GitHub should tell you everything you need to know about the state of "independent infrastructure" in 2021.
- seanp2k2 6y agoIt’s not that it’s so hard to set up Redmine, just again that GitHub has strong network effects and a lot of convenience. I can go star stuff and come back later. Bookmarking a random open source project that self-hosts and hoping it’s still there when I need it is less convenient.
- bjt2n3904 6y ago...speech loopholes? Oh that's right... The first amendment only applies to printed materials and live spoken word. The founding fathers couldn't have foreseen social media, and certainly would have worded the amendment differently if they saw how powerful Twitter was.
- ghayes 6y agoThe First Amendment to the Constitution explicitly forbids "Congress" from "abridging the freedom of speech." It goes no further. There's certainly a question of public policy here, but that result will be unlikely to turn on the First Amendment.
- bloaf 6y agoOn whether a private company could prohibit the distribution of written materials in a town that they owned: https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/326/501/ https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/326/501/ > Ownership does not always mean absolute dominion. The more an owner, for his advantage, opens up his property for use by the public in general, the more do his rights become circumscribed by the statutory and constitutional rights of those who use it.
- bjt2n3904 6y agoThat is a fascinating case. Thank you for sharing it!
- thaumasiotes 6y ago> The First Amendment to the Constitution explicitly forbids "Congress" from "abridging the freedom of speech." It goes no further. True but meaningless; the text goes no further than that, as to freedom of speech -- actually, it doesn't even go that far[1] -- but the amendment does go much further than that. For example, it is considered to be binding on the states through "incorporation" under the 14th amendment. [1] The text prohibits Congress from making laws which abridge the freedom of speech. This is one reason I don't really understand the argument that the first amendment should protect Trump from being impeached over a speech which is unquestionably protected by the first amendment -- the legislative power and the impeachment power are two separate grants of authority.
- technick 6y agoI'm starting to look forward to the downfall of any of the FAANGs that become censorship happy. This shit has to stop and I know the 1st wasn't mean for private business, but now that private business has such a reach, it needs to be forced on them.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- SV_BubbleTime 6y agoI feel like I must be crazy that “speech loophole” is a serious term being thrown around at all. We can wish them gone all we want, but man I just don’t see it happening.
- erikpukinskis 6y agoWhere would your law end? I’m curious how you’d write it... Would it be something like: “No person may delete content which has been made publically accessible on a server they administer without a court order demanding that content’s removal”? Would you have a certain size threshold, like the law kicks in when you hit 1 million monthly uniques?
- stale2002 6y ago> Where would your law end? I’m curious how you’d write it... There is an easy answer to this. We could just model this stuff after other similar laws, that apply to other networks. Those similar laws, are called common carrier laws, and they could be expanded to apply to more things.
- andrewprock 6y agoThe first step in that process is restoring net neutrality.
- Const-me 6y agoI support net neutrality, but why do you think that should be the first step?
- root_axis 6y agoYouTube's content policy is clearly a failure in the case of journalists covering firearms, but if you're doing serious journalism you need to pay for your own hosting and stop relying on corporate ad delivery networks to give you a free platform.
- nl 6y agoWhy does all discussion on HN devolve into a "yes; all speech should be free" vs "no; any censorship is reasonable" discussion. There are sophisticated discussions around the limits of free speech available (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance#Tolerance_and_freedom_of_speech https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance#Tolerance...) and yet no one attempts to address them. It's pretty frustrating to see another "oh no censorship = bad", which is a complete strawman argument.
- spiralx 6y agoLabelling one side of the arguments as "pro-censorship" is hardly a good faith interpretation of said positions that is likely to lead to nuanced discussion now is it? Discussion of this issue on HN started semi-reasonably and has gotten worse and worse rapidly. There's nothing to be gained on the subject here other than occasionally satisfying my morbid curiosity about whether it has gotten even worse than the last time I looked.
- 2Gkashmiri 6y agoI think Peertube with its decentralized live streaming where the moderator of the instances and moderator of remote instances where their videos are federated to are the way forward. You dont like some instances' moderation rules, go and set up your own and then federate with only like minded people and servers. Will it "support" extremism, probably, but will it cause them to get stuck in their own defederated bubble where no outsider can be influenced by those views? Yes most definitely. That is a good way forward, atleast one option and the good thing about it is, its already here
- pdx6 6y agoI see from their blog that they support live stream now. Very interesting solution, but it lacks a community (at least at first glance). I wonder what a good social pairing with it would be to help drive traffic between federations.
- 2Gkashmiri 6y agoinstances are federated with similar instances. one video on instance A goes to all instances in its network. everyone from those nstances or from any activitypub account like mastodon or pleroma can interact, comment, like...
- chroem- 6y agoAh yes, the classic approach of renaming "rights" to "loopholes" and then eliminating them.
- milkrocks 6y ago^ this
- Thorrez 6y ago>jumped to encyrpted sites like Signal and Telegram. AFAIK Telegram is usually not E2E encrypted.
- CivBase 6y agoThe constitution protects our freedom of speech from the government, not from private entities on their own private property. Make no mistake, that's what centralized social media platforms are - private property. Freedom of speech is not protected by the constitution on social media platforms and, frankly, I don't want 100% free speech on social media. Take a look at HN. HN mods do a brilliant job of moderating. We don't have 100% free speech here and the platform is better for it. The discussions here tend to be much higher quality than on similar platforms like Reddit. That's probably a big reason why you're here reading this comment thread. However... I've noticed a difference between HN and the likes of Facebook or Twitter. As far as I can tell, HN mods focus more on how you say something rather than what you say. If you're civil, respectful, and on-topic you're seemingly allowed to present just about any idea. Meanwhile, most other social media platforms seem content to let other people be complete pricks to eachother as long as they don't present any ideas which the platform have decided are wrong or "dangerous". I think the HN moderation strategy makes for a much better platform. I'd rather talk with a respectful person who I disagree with than a jerk with whome I agree.
- artificialLimbs 6y ago*incoming nitpick >If you're civil, respectful, and on-topic you're seemingly allowed to present just about any idea. HN heavily follows the religion of scientism. If you reject science, you will be downvoted nearly immediately. HN forgets that the reason that we don't fog our kids with DDT anymore is because 'settled science' was questioned. Yes I am generalizing by using "HN". This is still, however, one of my favorite platforms to read.
- rebuilder 6y agoI find myself being more sympathetic to YouTube than most commenters here. It seems we want YT to both provide editorial oversight so that e.g. mass murderers are not given a platform to flaunt their crimes, and to provide a platform where anyone can start livestreaming at any time, anywhere. The way broadcast media handles this is they have an editorial policy that is applied by humans producing a single stream at a time. There are multiple people monitoring everything a news station puts out at all times. It's kind of hard to see that happening with YouTube. So while I think YT policies can probably be improved, I don't think it's ever going to be a great environment for content that depends on editorial staff to exist. Any moderation policy YT takes has to be applied to what must be billions of videos now. Complaining that they're not doing what broadcast media does feels like going to McDonalds and complaining that the chicken McNuggets aren't made of filet. It's part of the product, not a kink that can be ironed out.
- dang 6y agoIf anyone can suggest a more accurate and neutral title, preferably using representative language from the article, I'd appreciate it. I think the story is about an interesting new phenomenon and therefore on topic for HN (https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html), but I don't think "Silicon Valley" is the right subject for that sentence, and it's not clear to me if the article is only about YouTube or just primarily. We could change it to the article's main title, but it's a lot more obscure.
- jt2190 6y agoNot quite sure how to craft this into a headline, but this is the gist of the article: > Indie journalist live streams taken down due to “lack of moderation” and “non-authoritative content”
- steele 6y agogood.gif -- drive the violent and bigoted to coalesce in the fringe.
- milkrocks 6y agoRadicalize them further, and give them nothing to lose... I bet that will work out well.
- pdx6 6y agoThe article only mentions Rokfin, but what other live stream alternatives are there? Youtube has the most draw and algo suggestions, along with a huge community. I pay for YT because it offers a lot of great content and a good value, so I understand why creators would want to stick to that platform. And what about indie streaming? Is there some package that glues some open source components, either to the cloud or bare metal? I feel like there is a space for another livestream community, like YT, like Twitch, and like a Podcast, but without the main stream market filters. Maybe there is and I'm not aware of it. When Defcon did their 'live stream' last year, they did a torrent of the pre-recorded content, YT, and Twitch because they were worried something might go wrong. By wrong it could have been anything from knocking over the service to getting banned for ... Defcon ideas. I don't think the Defcon shoot out was on there. They added live Q&A with Discord and YT. But that was it -- the only open source part was Discord (which did fall over).
- Outdoorsman 6y agoIn my opinion, live content is often on target, just as often poorly thought out. The citizenry votes with ballots . . . and dollars. One is often as effective as the other in steering a nation toward ethical behavior. Keep in mind: A representative democracy is a grand historical experiment. If you value it, value the things that keep it going.
- treeman79 6y agoHave watched ad tech exes go out of there way to cut off any form of revenue to any center or right leaning site. Was shocked out how routine it was for them. To them shutting down alt view points was just fighting the good fight. Zero effort to comprehend the other side.
- cudgy 6y agoI understand perhaps sole enterprise or small partnership having the right to control who they serve. However, if it is a public corporation, it is no longer an individual entity, a citizen entitled to control over whom you serve. Once your company is public and traded on markets within the United States, it is now available to any individual to become a partial owner. To claim that you represent an individual opinion about whom you want to serve is only figurative. These companies are owned by thousands maybe even millions of people with all types of beliefs. What I am seeing right now with big tech are the voices of a dominant billionaire leader and noisy, radical employees steering decisions about who should be served by the company. This minority of people in a public corporation should not have this kind of power. Their decisions should be driven entirely by the legal system and what is legally allowed and who can be legally served.
- milkrocks 6y agoThe fact that they're called loopholes at all is problematic.
- 452345435 6y agoBiden's DoJ just arrested a guy for posting misleading election memes back in 2016: > https://nypost.com/2021/01/27/alt-right-twitter-troll-ricky-vaughn-busted-for-voter-disinformation/ https://nypost.com/2021/01/27/alt-right-twitter-troll-ricky-... > Written on the photograph was the message, “Avoid the Line. Vote from Home. Text ‘Hillary’ to 59925. Vote for Hillary and be a part of history,” the complaint states. > More than 4,900 people, encouraged by the misinformation campaign, cast their vote via text, officials said. > “There is no place in public discourse for lies and misinformation to defraud citizens of their right to vote,” said Acting US Attorney for the Eastern District of New York Seth DuCharme. Anyone dumb enough to think they could vote by sending a text message frankly shouldn't be voting. (I didn't vote in 2016, if it matters.) And lies and disinfo are traditionally protected speech. Even lying about military service (without any intent to defraud) is protected: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Alvarez https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Alvarez The "it's a private company" argument is out the window.
- 452345435 6y agoTo the downvoters: posting nasty, misleading memes on Twitter shouldn't warrant a prison sentence of upto 10 years. This will be a test case, not just for the First Amendment, but for the leftists who until now have been able to dodge the issue with the "it's a private company" line.