12 ms·
Cryptocurreny crime is way ahead of regulators and law enforcement
- traeregan 6y agoThe article is from mid 2019, and is also paywalled.
- shemnon42 6y agoIt's also by Nouriel Roubini, a well known crypto critic. Keep those biases in mind as you read his work.
- loceng 6y agoSo he's not financially incentivized to talk positively about Bitcoin et al - which everyone reading anything positive about Bitcoin et al should keep in mind?
- louwrentius 6y agoFrankly, I have yet to find a site/person that writes positive about any cryptocurrency and not have some stake in it. To me, it feels like a multi level marketing scheme, where all these sites and sources and people just try to drive up the price.
- JaggerFoo 6y agoYou should view the Cryptocurrency lecture at MIT, which was given by Gary Gensler, who will be the new leader of the SEC. There are references and readings for both sides and good discussions. Very good overview of cryptocurrencies, even some students have created cryptocurrencies.
- loceng 6y agoDownvotes for you but no one providing evidence to the contrary..
- hanniabu 6y agoThere's no evidence you can provide to someone like this. You show them some statements from the incoming SEC chairman and you'll be met with either "well here probably owns crypto" or "what he's saying isn't true".
- loceng 6y agoWhy should the incoming SEC chairman saying positive things about Bitcoin be received as credible though? You do understand that regulatory capture is a problem in all industries, and the structure of Bitcoin overlays perfectly with Pyramid/MLM schemes, right? Those are simply truths, just because someone reaches a certain position in society doesn't make what they say automatically valid or void of bias and indoctrination.
- CryptoPunk 6y agoIt'd be very unlikely for someone to see merit in cryptocurrency and not subsequently acquire a stake in it.
- traeregan 6y agoNon-paywalled version: https://www.barrons.com/amp/articles/cryptocurreny-crime-is-way-ahead-of-regulators-and-law-enforcement-51563710700 https://www.barrons.com/amp/articles/cryptocurreny-crime-is-... This is an old article though, and BitMex has been indicted for the very things mentioned in this article.
- anthony_barker 6y agoBitcoin stuff is a smaller market than gambling. That you can gamble in BTC doesn't mean than it is any different than Contract For Difference shitty companies running out of Cyprus , Seychelles etc that allow you to trade 100 to one on Tesla. NDF (Non deliverable forwards) in traditional FX are levered like crazy. Most regulators get crypto now... Its all about KYC (know your client) and custodianship.
- xwdv 6y agoBut will there ever truly be a reckoning?
- Barrin92 6y agowell in this case there was. The article is from summer 2019. Hayes is facing 10 years in prison and is currently camping out in Hong Kong I think.
- 29athrowaway 6y agoWhen you piss off the wrong authorities or the wrong people, there is no place to hide. Even with cryptocurrencies. Even with Tor. Even if you hide in a remote place in the planet. Piss off the wrong people and they will spend resources until they find you. Like the Silk Road guy, Ross Ulbricht.
- hsuduebc2 6y agoWell he tried to hire assassin to murder his companion. Not exactly technology fault.
- FDSGSG 6y agoThe silk road guy logged into his servers without Tor... Ulbricht just happened to do a particularly shit job hiding. On the other hand the operator of Dream Market is still free, after operating his site for almost 7(!) years.
- bpodgursky 6y agoNot really true. Ulbricht messed up, possibly just once: > The connection was made by linking the username "altoid", used during Silk Road's early days to announce the website, and a forum post in which Ulbricht, posting under the nickname "altoid", asked for programming help and gave his email address, which contained his full name. It's really hard to live a digital life for a decade and not once accidentally break opsec between your public and private lives.
- kortilla 6y agoIt’s not hard if you start out assuming you’re going to be wanted by the government at some point. The problem is when you stumble into crime much later and have a bunch of online identity you have to dissociate from cold turkey.
- FDSGSG 6y agoIt really is true. Ulbricht repeatedly made the incomprehensible mistake of logging into SR servers without using Tor. He would've been caught sooner or later because of just that. He even used his own photo on the fake IDs for SR server rentals!
- saagarjha 6y agoThere’s a typo in the title :(
- RurouniK 6y agoPeople who say this is from 2019. It doesn't matter. Apparently Bitcoin critics have limited imagination so it's the same FUD resurfacing every time Bitcoin hits a new ATH. It's either that or something about tulips, or Bitcoin's CO2 emissions etc. It's practically the same debunked myths since Bitcoin first hit $100, and then again at $1000, and then at $20k, and now at $40k...
- Clewza313 6y ago(2019) Regulators are slowly catching up, but as you see from Tether, still have a long way to go.
- geofft 6y agoIsn't part of the point of owning cryptocurrency that you want less government involvement - including government-funded protection from crime - than you would with government-run currencies? Like, it's always pitched as a positive that a transaction is irrevocable. If I put some money in a smart contract, it behaves exactly as specified in the smart contract. If I decide to invest in some overly complicated ICO (for which I can fully read the programmatic contract before I invest), and I lose money, and then I say "I am a poor unsophisticated investor who was taken advantage of, I want my money back," doesn't that fundamentally imperil the value proposition of having a smart, programmatic contract? Now only most of the contract is on the blockchain and there's also some hidden caselaw - and "mostly deterministic" means nondeterministic. That is - shouldn't people who believe in cryptocurrency be saying this is fine and good and working as intended, and not a problem to "fix"?
- pfraze 6y agoThe most interesting thing I’ve seen from smart contracts is using them to structure funds management for international FOSS projects without having to create a legal entity. That saves a ton of cost and legal overhead which is otherwise very tedious. That said, the interesting question this raises is, what happens when disagreements happen over those smart contracts? It seems like inevitably lawsuits and regulations will arrive, potentially removing the upside of using smart contracts. This leaves me asking a couple questions. One, is the culture around “no reversable transactions!” a kind of defense mechanism against introducing legal overhead which could harm the value prop of crypto. Two, should legal overhead arrive, could the smart contracts still provide some value compared to old solutions?
- CryptoPunk 6y ago>>could the smart contracts still provide some value compared to old solutions? Yes, because possession is 9/10ths of the law, and so a smart contract's automatic assignment of possession, according to its terms, will in most cases be legally decisive.
- cormacrelf 6y ago
- dehrmann 6y agoWhat's even worse for things like cryptocurrency trading is existing securities laws are basically a list of market manipulation techniques that also work for cryptocurrencies.
- heywintermute 6y agoExcept it's even worse for crypto because many tokens don't nearly have the same liquidity as traditional stocks so market manipulation is even easier with crypto.
- space_rock 6y agoIlliquid markets are a magnett for scammers
- anm89 6y agoIf you are talking about shit coins sure. There is no shortage of liquidity in major crypto markets.
- tempsy 6y agoWho needs bitcoin when Deutsche Bank and HSBC exist?
- 1996 6y agoThis, so much! But politicians have friends & famility working at DB and HSBC - so they'd rather show teeth and get votes by attacking the newcomers. Who cares if there's less illegal activity there? At least they won't have to fear retaliation by cartels!
- wslh 6y agoBecause you don't live in Latin America, Africa, etc. Probably you never experience a change of business and finance rules every few months.
- arcticbull 6y agoWhat does that have to do with Bitcoin? That literally continues to apply exactly whether Bitcoin is the currency of record or not. It's not some magical fairy sauce that solves any problem even remotely adjacent to money.
- zadler 6y agoThe key is that people in Latin American countries will use crypto to sidestep tax as well as capital controls. Whereas previously that was more difficult because of the lack of an alternative currency system on the internet.
- arcticbull 6y agoSo, crime then. Crime is still illegal, the blockchain is public and visible to everyone, it's easy to deanonymize now. So what, an express train to prison?
- anm89 6y ago
- toolz 6y agoI used to be surprised when I would read articles about this mythical legislative process which can and will protect lowly plebians like me. I'm not sure why so many people are under the impression legislation will be able to keep up with perversely motivated individuals or groups. Who are these legislators with motives so pure that they will never be bribed to only look out for my interests? Let's never forget there is only one person in jail for the 2008 crash this article is trying to convince us was the result of too little regulation. There was never enough incentive to protect us from the people who created that market crash.
- harwoodleon 6y agoFinancial regulation is and always has been two sided. To protect you from losses and to protect you from profit.
- conception 6y agoI think the problem with 2008 was that no one was doing anything illegal, just a lot of poor judgement and lack of regulations.
- anthony_barker 6y agoTell that to Madoff
- arcticbull 6y agoWell not nobody obviously, crime still happened.
- vmception 6y agoMadoff became a convict because of the crash, not because he was liquidating massive amounts or had a large portfolio of collateralized debt that would exacerbate a crash.
- roenxi 6y agoBitcoin was created by people who were so peeved at the regulator's interventions in the '08 crisis that they decided that bypassing the entire financial system was the best option. Forever immortalising "The Times 03/Jan/2009 Chancellor on brink of second bailout for banks" just as a reminder of why they were doing what they did [0]. We don't need better regulation. We need, when financial firms muck up on a global scale, to replace the people who run those firms with different people. There is an easy way to do that, let them go broke. The biggest problem in the room is that the regulators have bought in to the idea that some companies are "too big to fail". That is a stupid idea, fundamentally unfair, completely throwing out the best part of capitalism which is that recognised idiots aren't allowed to be in charge. That problem will certainly not be solved by giving the regulators more power. [0] https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Genesis_block https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Genesis_block
- blunte 6y agoThe crypto world is rife with scams and thieves, but so too are the traditional financial systems. There are two key differences, however: 1. The scale of wrongdoing in the crypto world is insignificant compared to in traditional systems. 2. Some of what is deemed "criminal" in crypto systems is only criminal because it bypasses traditional controls. In the first case, small investors and taxpayers have been on the losing end of many financial disasters which were not of their own making. But as evidenced by the multiple bailouts in the US, those negligent or intentionally malfeasant rarely suffer the consequences of their actions; on the contrary, they often profit from it. To be sure, there are plenty of really lame scams in the crypto world - either outright frauds or ponzi schemes. And the losses to customers and clients is significant. However, if the losses in traditional system failures and thefts were calculated, we would be much better served by focusing on the traditional system problems. In the second case, some of the criminal crypto activities (such as the transparent lotteries and ponzis operating in the Ethereum network) are arguably less risky than legal gambling or equities and futures trading. Small investors in traditional markets get cheated in invisible ways that would not be possible on a system with blockchain-published smart contracts. (That's not to imply that many people can truly grasp exactly how a given smart contract works, edge cases and all - but at least it is visible.) I personally dislike the crypto world. In the very early days, it was a place of hope and possibility. But that was quickly buried by the waves of unethical people who were fixated on quick riches. And unfortunately, little of the potential or promises of cryptocurrencies have panned out. Meanwhile, at least in some places (Europe for example), financial transaction speed and associated costs have been reduced to well below what even crypto can offer. For example, I can move money from a Dutch account to a German account in one second, at no cost. There is no room for improvement there - ignoring the concept of anonymity of course... but that isn't really something crypto actually offers. In the places where the banks themselves have not improved, new players have stepped in. Transferwise has saved me thousands per year for several years compared to international bank wires. Crypto can do that as well, but both endpoints then have to manage the fiat to crypto exchange. To be fair to cryptocurrency in this regard, there has been intentional pressure from traditional financial systems to create laws that make it more difficult to exchange fiat and crypto, and that has greatly hindered some of the potential uses. Even that is evidence of how much more corrupt traditional systems are compared to cryptocurrencies.
- cecida 6y agoMy main issue with Bitcoin isn't how it attracts libertarian sociopaths to it like flies on shit, but the enormous environmental impact it is having. Proof of Work is a morally and ethically repugnant form of computing. Not enough of us speak up about it.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoHow about the thousands of millions that are spent on machine learning or overall data centers to collect the information of millions for resale and for service ads? If you had carbon taxes in place, this "environmentally unfriendly" activity would go away.
- AWildC182 6y agoAlso morally repugnant? Whataboutism.
- louwrentius 6y agoI agree, just Whataboutism. That something else is bad doesn't make 'your thing' right.
- AWildC182 6y agoThis cannot be repeated enough. Bitcoin is consuming as much energy as a small-medium sized country and all so a tiny minority can speculate on it.
- louwrentius 6y agoI can't respond to cecidia because of the downvotes but I fully agree with their statement. I also agree with the insanity that is the energy consumption associated with bitcoin mining.
- gjs278 6y agoyou just wasted a good amount of electrons responding to copypasta
- afrojack123 6y agoBuy bitcoin
- ledeplorible 6y agoThat's the freedom you get when you allow Turkish economists formulate "free market" policy.
- elevenoh 6y agoencryption* is in the long run unregulatable
- FabHK 6y agoThere's something to that (though with more and more people having walled-garden smartphones, but no more computer, even that is debatable), but what has it got to do with the topic at hand?
- trident5000 6y agoRoubini is a clown heavily mocked even by the traditional finance world and this article is from 2019. “95% of btc volume is fake” weve known about asian exchange wash trading for the better part of the decade, its why their volume is excluded in aggregates. Theres still undeniable substantial real volume on the top 10 exchanges by users. Coinbase is not committing investor fraud as a fiduciary by reporting false numbers.
- grapehut 6y agoI am personally responsible for 100e1000 US dollar trade volume per day. Taken with the above statement, >99.999% of all US dollar trade volume is fake. I guess USD must be a joke currency.
- genericacct 6y agoNouriel Roubini teaches at New York University's Stern School of Business, that's a pretty solid credential.
- trident5000 6y agoWho cares. I went to an elite university on par with nyu. Half my professors were idiots.
- olefoo 6y agoThere is also the viewpoint that bitcoin was a crime from beginning to end. That the goals of it's creation were to provide an unpreventable vector for money laundering. That it's current function of undermining the dollar order is also an intended result. And let us not; in this age of ecological collapse, forget the emissions impact of cryptocurrencies.
- pontus 6y agoThese energy/CO2 costs existed before crypto. The carbon footprint of something like Bank of America or VISA are not zero, it's just that we are more comfortable accepting these as "productive" because they're way less direct. For example, the CO2 cost of heating the Bank of America tower in Manhattan during the winter or cooling it in the summer feels different than the energy consumed by various mining rigs. In fact, I wouldn't be surprised if crypto was actually way more efficient energy-wise than the centralized institutions that are needed to support the current system.
- erostrate 6y agoI googled some orders of magnitudes. Bank of America total scope 1 and scope 2 emissions (all buildings + travel + other stuff) were about 1 million tons co2 per year [1]. A lower bound on Bitcoin mining emissions was 20 million tons in 2018. [2] Of course there are more than one bank, banks perform a lot of functions that crypto doesn't, etc. [1] https://about.bankofamerica.com/assets/pdf/Bank-of-America-2018-ESG-Performance-Data-Summary.pdf https://about.bankofamerica.com/assets/pdf/Bank-of-America-2... [2] http://ceepr.mit.edu/files/papers/2018-018.pdf http://ceepr.mit.edu/files/papers/2018-018.pdf
- pontus 6y agoThat's interesting, thanks for the calculation!
- anm89 6y agoI believe this is part of a disingenuous attempt to link crypto currencies with crime. Crypto currencies are undoubtedly used for money laundering and hiding. Dollars are undoubtedly used for money laundering and hiding. Euros and gold and car washes are all undoubtedly used for money laundering. The question is, does the fact that an asset is used in money laundering mean it should be outlawed. I think the answer is fairly transparently no. But this is seen as the easiest rhetorical tool in the event that someone is already looking for basis to argue for banning crypto currency. Think of the children! And Terrorism! Imagine a new country came into existence except it held no physical land, it produced no physical goods, it built no physical infrastructure, it paid no welfare, it's just an internet country. Well this country's currency is just as usable for money laundering as every other currency assuming it freely floats but because it has no structural economy behind it, money laundering makes up a disproportionate portion of it's total use. Does that mean it was invented just to launder money? The point is: of course a new internet currency is mostly used for money laundering. That's one easy thing to do with an internet currency and the other use cases are still developing. In the end it doesn't matter though, I believe the ability of governments to censor cryptocurrencies is drastically less than they project. They can turn off the on ramps but they also know that could cause a rush on those assets that they could never reverse. And as the drug war taught us, throwing endless resources at preventing the sale of a commodity for currency on black markets works much better in principle than it does in reality.And in a world of floating converting convertible currencies, if they don't all coordinate a ban at once in an effective manner it's going to fail spectacularly, because there's always another currency on ramp that's just a money transfer away.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> In the end it doesn't matter though, I believe the ability of governments to censor cryptocurrencies is drastically less than they project. The real problem is that they can interfere severely in the ability of ordinary people to use it for legitimate purposes while still not making the slightest dent in its use for criminal activity. Because for ordinary people to use it, it would have to be accepted by e.g. Amazon, who is not going to break the law in order to accept it. But in order to be used by criminals, it only has to be used by other criminals.
- programmarchy 6y agoThese regulatory scares happen from time to time and I am betting it’s coming from highly capitalized investor classes lobbying state actors to issue threats in order to crash prices. This will lead to a low exit from dumb money and allow for capital to centralize more wealth. It’s a form of economic terrorism.
- CryptoPunk 6y agoRoubini has staked his reputation on Bitcoin failing, so as cryptocurrency advances, his predictions, along with his professional reputation, get dragged through the mud. It appears he is now resorting to producing a dishonest and inflammatory appeal to the political and regulatory class, to intervene with heavy handed restrictions that would all but make any peer-to-peer use of cryptocurrency illegal, in order to make his predictions of Bitcoin's failure come true. I hope that the top-down controlled regulatory apparatus that he supports and which impedes commerce, and exacerbates income inequality and financial exclusion, fails, and his entire political philosophy is made obsolete by cryptocurrency becoming ubiquitous.
- Animats 6y agoA big concern is Tether. Tether is supposed to be backed by USD, but it's not. Tether does seem to be pumping Bitcoin. The risk is that when the next recession comes along, there will be a net outflow from Tether, and just what assets are behind Tether will be revealed. Unless you're a crook, there's no reason to keep funds in Tether. There's zero upside, and a significant downside.