24 ms·
The Bit Short: Inside Crypto’s Doomsday Machine
- leppr 6y agoRelated: Tether’s bank Deltec says it invests customer funds in Bitcoin https://www.deltecbank.com/2021/01/14/a-covid-year-in-review/ https://www.deltecbank.com/2021/01/14/a-covid-year-in-review... https://www.coindesk.com/tethers-bank-says-it-invests-customer-funds-in-bitcoin https://www.coindesk.com/tethers-bank-says-it-invests-custom... https://twitter.com/patio11/status/1349873798078558209 https://twitter.com/patio11/status/1349873798078558209 The next weeks/months are going to be fascinating to watch, as US regulators and invested institutions fight to both regulate and protect their crypto investments. Maintaining the inflated cryptocurrency valuations propped up by Tether while simultaneously removing it from the game before too many eyes set on it, will surely require subtle maneuvering. Ultimately I do suspect OP indeed, sold early, as the game theory mechanics strongly favor just participating in the Ponzi rather than trying to bring it down, especially when this has the potential to be the one last great bubble before a major recession.
- qeternity 6y agoUS equities are the one last great bubble. But crypto are a symptom of the same disease.
- azeirah 6y agoThe OP said that he got out 100% right? Why not get out with something along the lines of 96% of your portfolio if you made over 600% profit anyway? Eh, I would never bet 100% of my investment in a market based on knowledge I obtained myself, there's no no noo way I can see the entire picture.
- JohnJamesRambo 6y ago>On January 9th, 2021, I liquidated my crypto position for USD. Crypto Anonymous, you sold extremely early, I'm sorry. https://digitalik.net/btc/ https://digitalik.net/btc/
- asimilator 6y ago> Most of my wealth was exposed in the form of Bitcoin Yikes.
- H8crilA 6y ago> For the rest of 2020, my inflationary thesis looked right Just to make it clear: there's absolutely no broad inflation almost everywhere in the world, certainly not in the United States. It may still come, but inflation is not why Bitcoin is on such a tear. Look at CPI or PPI of you don't believe me. Although this does remind me of the Green Lumber Trader story from Taleb. Congrats on the trade!
- alcio 6y agoinflation in consumer goods might not be high, but financial assets have clearly inflated: a quick look at gold denominated SPY shows it.
- H8crilA 6y agoWhy not TSLA/gold? That proves there is inflation! Or I know, BTC/USD, that clearly proves there's lots inflation and look at that bitcoin price is perfectly correlated with it! (I am only half-joking here, the point is that broad inflation is much much more important than some bull market in this or that asset class) On a more serious note a lot of commodities are looking really bullish, including some foodstuffs, and that's obviously not good news ...
- nivenkos 6y agoReal estate inflation is the real driver behind practical inflation all over the world though. Real estate bubble -> High deposits for house purchases -> High rents -> Effective inflation Most governments don't include real estate (or even rent payments) in their inflation calculations to keep it artificially low.
- H8crilA 6y ago> Most governments don't include real estate (or even rent payments) in their inflation calculations to keep it artificially low. Housing is > 40% of the US CPI: https://www.bls.gov/cpi/tables/relative-importance/2019.pdf https://www.bls.gov/cpi/tables/relative-importance/2019.pdf
- comboy 6y agoI don't get it. tether sucks. If you hold tether it may turn into air. But your bitcoin is still bitcoin. Also, when tether is going down wouldn't you want to sell it thus creating pressure in btc/tether market and value of of tether/btc going up? It's always been clear to me that USD/BTC and USDT/BTC are two different markets. USDT is just another cryptocurrency. Many of them were scams and disappeared and many more will. Same with exchanges. It seems like describing somebody maliciously selling fake or paper gold and concluding that gold is bad.
- leppr 6y agoDid you read the article? The author doesn't concluse that Bitcoin in itself is bad, they simply realized by themselves that most of the dollar value increase was caused by Tether, and they fear Tether eventually going down might be a black swan event causing prices to tumble. But 1 BTC = 1 BTC, yes.
- comboy 6y agoMany value increases are irrational, whatever that means, I understand how it can be used to pump the price. I just don't understand how it takes bitcoin with it when collapsing.
- quickthrower2 6y agoIf tether is pumping BTC then it’ll stop pumping BTC when it’s taken away. Weak hands will fold and then there will be a crash
- comboy 6y agoOK, yes, that's a fair point. But it's not clear to me that pumping being taken away would be a bigger change than people trying to get out of USDT and buying BTC. Also we've been there (mtgox's willy etc). I don't think bitcoin will be much less volatile any time soon. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XbZ8zDpX2Mg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XbZ8zDpX2Mg
- BelenusMordred 6y agoThe naivety of this post is just great. It's crypto conspiracy theorist Q, financial anti-vaxxer and monetary flat earth all rolled into one. Sell everything my friend and never look back. Happy for your wins here. Enjoy your "life-changing" investment decision. > This is a one-time-use account. I won’t be responding to messages or inquiries on this platform. If you aren't willing to put your real name to it, guessing you're not that confident about it either and are just another market timer looking for easy kudos over the centruries of proclamations. Crypto is basically ground zero for the biggest flaseflagging and ubershill campaigns on the planet. Without proving what you sold, this is a fairytale, and you know damn well you can cryptographically prove right now how much and when you held it. Tether holds far more than your bank or many bluechips in backing, try not to forget that one.
- EliRivers 6y ago"Tether holds far more than your bank or many bluechips in backing, try not to forget that one." The author writes right there in the article why he thinks Tether is full of shit. He states that the bank they claim to be putting all their dollars in simply doesn't have that many dollars. So you can now put your money where your mouth is and explain why he's mistaken about that. Addeundum, some time later: dylkil has done it for you. Now there a commenter who actually comes armed with facts.
- phyalow 6y agoDevils advocate, (I think tether is B/S) but the Bahamas deposits sheet they mention wont include securities like TBills and Corporate Credit, which I expect Tether would hold as collateral...
- nmlnn 6y agoUh.. one little problem with this kid's analysis. There are multiple USDT/USD markets (https://www.tradingview.com/symbols/USDTUSD/ https://www.tradingview.com/symbols/USDTUSD/)
- leppr 6y agoYes, three other markets accounting for a total of... $4 million daily volume. That's less than many random Uniswap tokens, and could consist entirely of some minimal market making. I've done stablecoin market making myself, it's not very profitable but the low inventory risk makes it attractive, as the ratio always trends back to 1:1.
- alcio 6y agoUSDT-USD markets are indeed marginal. however, implied USDT price using BTC as a cross shows USDT is valued pretty much at parity with the dollar by the market: https://www.tradingview.com/symbols/spread/BINANCE%3ABTCUSDT%2FCOINBASE%3ABTCUSD/ https://www.tradingview.com/symbols/spread/BINANCE%3ABTCUSDT...
- leppr 6y agoYes, and that parity is precisely the thesis behind the author's contrarian short position.
- nmlnn 6y agoIf people want to short bitcoin or tether, they should do so. However, I don't really get all the internet whining. If they're right they'll make a lot of money. I don't buy these concerned citizen FUD posts though, they reek of manipulation. If there's one thing I've learned over the last 25 years it's.. don't trust random people on the internet.
- leppr 6y agoTaking a position and then publicizing the position and the thesis behind it is standard procedure everywhere in finance. It's a way of accelerating pricing-in of the information. You can indeed just short an artificially inflated asset, but if the sham is only revealed long after you're insolvent, you lose your money. BTW, your bull case for Bitcoin wasn't built from trusting random people on the internet?
- quickthrower2 6y agoHe should definitely send tether a Christmas card this year.
- Yizahi 6y agoOf course Tethers are backed up, it's done in a novel and modern way of driving a garbage trucks full of small denomination dollars to a back alley in Bangkok by institutional investors.
- dannyw 6y agoThis is nothing more than FUD designed to benefit a short position. The reason why exchanges like Binance and Bybit have their inflows from Tether... is because (as the author explains) they only take Tether! Why do they only take Tether? Because US banking is incredibly expensive and a regulatory nightmare. Why do people use Tether exchanges, over Coinbase? Not just because of leverage, but also because many do not AML/KYC, especially if you only deal with crypto. A LOT of people in the crypto community don't like to pay taxes, and we've known this from day one. Many crypto enthusiasts also boycott "regulated" exchanges like Coinbase, because they shut down accounts if you use it to gamble on a sportsbook, or whatever their surveillance doesn't like. So it should not be a surprise that many people in the crypto community, me being one of them, actually prefer to use Tether and Tether exchanges.
- ur-whale 6y agoThe "all the banks in <random caribeean island> only hold a tiny fraction of the cash Tether claims to own" argument is a fairly solid one. Care to deconstruct it?
- anfogoat 6y ago> Why do people use Tether exchanges, over Coinbase? Not just because of leverage, but also because many do not AML/KYC, especially if you only deal with crypto. A LOT of people in the crypto community don't like to pay taxes, and we've known this from day one. I don't know if evading taxes is the main reason but it is definitely not the only one. Going through KYC is an embarrassing and demeaning experience, unless you like prancing in front of a camera. It is also close to equivalent to just plastering your picture and ID all over the public Internet as that is exactly where they'll end up when your exchange of choice is eventually broken into. Just another gift from the anointed ones.
- doggosphere 6y agoHow about Tether's refusal to do an open audit of its books? Or when they had some funds seized and loaned funds between Bitfinex and Tether, breaking the 1:1 peg?
- yeneek 6y agoCrypto today is pretty wild. Most of the crypto currencies are trash with good intentions or straightforward scam. On the other hand, the flaws make it a great opportunity for those who dare.
- yawniek 6y agoinaccessible. anyone got a cached version?
- yawniek 6y agohttps://archive.is/aEiLp https://archive.is/aEiLp
- JackFr 6y agoI’ve always been, and remain still, a skeptic of all things crypto. I typically skip the crypto-focused articles on HN. I’m sure glad I didn’t today. > The US Treasury should enforce 100% reserve requirements on all USD-pegged crypto stablecoins, with mandatory audits. Laughter is really the best way to start my day.
- spottybanana 6y agoSo, you are glad to see articles that support your viewpoint? Don't you regret at all missing all the gains you have made along the years by not buying small amount of BTC? In the end the guy who wrote this article made quite good amount bu buying BTC low and selling high. Lets see how it ages.
- JackFr 6y agoHonestly I don't care about articles that support my skepticism, they largely bore me as well. What made this article and others like so amusing is the tremendous irony of demanding regulation, irony that the author seems completely oblivious to. Do I regret missing out on all of the crypto gains I could have had? Honestly I don't really think about it that often and when I do it's largely because I work in tech and I'm often forced to work with people who won't shut up about it. But I lived through similar periods with the first dotcom bubble, and the housing market in the run up to the financial crisis. I don't like 'greater fool' investing as a strategy (but certainly some people have gotten very rich with it) so no I guess I don't regret it. (One sidelong observation there are a lot more paper gains than realized gains. I've worked with a number of bitcoin millionaires. But if I filter the count to those who have > $1mm in USD, in a US domiciled bank, the number drops top zero. Who knows? Maybe it's adverse selection. Maybe the real winners aren't working anymore.)
- garmaine 6y agoWhat irony? I've been involved with bitcoin since 2010, and I too think all exchanges should have reserves enforced and audited. Not all bitcoin enthusiasts are anarcho-capitalist extremists.
- ur-whale 6y agoReally good article, recommended read for anyone interested in crypto. For me, it's almost 100% aligned with what I've felt was going on with Tether in the last 2 years. Also, it sort of crystallized an answer to a question I've had about Binance for quite a while: how did they manage to get so big, so fast. Answer: easy, they never had to establish proper on and off ramps to the traditional banking system and lured customers with unreasonable leveraged offers (which BTW is another Tether-related scam in itself: if you are an exchange with a shit ton of USDT, you can manipulate the price up and down, and trigger artificial margin calls whenever you damn please). The real interesting question is though: what will happen when (not if) Tether explodes. There will be a sudden huge demand for exiting from USDT, and the only way looks like buying BTC on semi or fully fraudulent unbanked exchanges (good luck with that). This will also trigger a big price unbalance between exchanges, and it remains to be seen if arbitrage channels will be able to weather the storm and if so for how long. If you hold USDT, better get out quick unless you want to be left holding the bag. If you hold BTC (as in: for real, in your own wallet, not on some shady exchange, not your keys not your coins), it's likely the BTC ecosystem is going to undergo a very large "event". Up or down, who knows. If you hold BTC on an exchange, especially a shady one with 100x leverage type offerings, get your coins out of there ASAP before you get BTC-E'd [1] [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BTC-e https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BTC-e
- pjc50 6y ago> it's likely the BTC ecosystem is going to undergo a very large "event". Up or down, who knows. This seems to be one constant of BTC: "events" which you might expect to have a negative effect on the price often don't.
- qeternity 6y ago...because Tether has been there to ensure that.
- leppr 6y ago> it sort of crystallized an answer to a question I've had about Binance for quite a while: how did they manage to get so big, so fast. ... No, Binance didn't get big because of Tether or leverage. It was already eating most of the crypto-only exchanges volume when altcoins were almost exclusively paired with BTC and before it acquired its perpetual futures business. The main reason they managed to attract so many users is flamboyant altcoin pump and dumps orchestrated with ICO teams and Chinese whales, and pioneering exchange coins with the securities/utility token mash-up called BNB. Users came to chase the pumps, and stayed when they were invested in the platform itself. Binance's thriving in its later phase even as Coinbase ramped up its altcoin listings can certainly be attributed to Tether though.
- rwmj 6y agoTether has to produce evidence in the New York court case today, right?
- atemerev 6y agoIt is not “doomsday machine”, it is “Tuesday”. Yes, Bitcoin is volatile, and crypto markets are manipulated (just like all other markets, e.g. tech stocks with Softbank-originated program trading right now). If tomorrow Bitcoin will cost $10000, nobody will be surprised. Neither if it will be $70000. We are not building crypto systems for speculation.
- ur-whale 6y agoThis. If you're really interested in Bitcoin and the crypto space, paying attention to the price should only be relevant because it is volatile and slows down adoption. Its absolute value is essentially boring.
- PaulAJ 6y agoSo if I understand this correctly, you can go to one of these pyramid scheme exchanges, tank up on highly leveraged tethers, and then go sell them on Kraken. Do this often enough and you will drain the resources of the pyramid scheme, causing it to collapse. So you make a profit and provide a social good all on one smooth move. Have I got that right?
- Erlich_Bachman 6y agoHow exactly do you plan to make a profit in this scenario?
- PaulAJ 6y agoWell, if I understand the OP correctly, it sounds like tethers are basically being printed and sold cheap in return for real money, so lots of people think they have a profit because they have more tethers than the dollars they started with. So if you can get in to that situation and then quickly sell the tethers before the whole thing collapses then you should be in the money. OTOH if that isn't possible then the allegation that this whole thing is a pyramid scheme fails.
- Erlich_Bachman 6y ago> sold cheap Where? Find a place that consistently sells tether cheap. If anything, the lack of this place is a sign of poor research base for the original article. They mention that some exchanges give tether "prises" sometimes, on some occasions, to a select number of users. I don't see how that is so bad, and neither do I see how you could consistently profit from that. Those incentives are likely to be once per user, or once per referred customer, etc. There are likely protections in the form of "you have to trade for this much in order to realize the total prise amount". I don't see how this is any different from bonuses that many online casinos give out, and no one takes that as a sign that a given casino that does this is insolvent.
- azeirah 6y ago
- dylkil 6y ago>But during the same period, total issued Tethers increased by almost $5.4 billion — going from $4.6B to $10B >The implication was shocking: there weren’t nearly enough dollars in all the domestic banks in the Bahamas to >back the Tethers that were floating around in the crypto market. Doesn't match up with whats shown here[1], Bahamas banks are holding 110bn in customer deposits. [1]https://stats.bis.org/statx/srs/tseries/LBS_D_PUB/Q:S:L:A:USD:F:5J:A:BS:A:5J:N?t=A5&c=BS&m=S&p=20202&x=L_POSITION.2.CL_L_POSITION&o=s:line,z:1 https://stats.bis.org/statx/srs/tseries/LBS_D_PUB/Q:S:L:A:US...
- EliRivers 6y agoUpvoted for coming armed with an actual fact related to the article, disagreeing with the author's premise based on some actual evidence. Might be right, might be wrong, but it's something other than just more opinion. Wish I could upvote more than once.
- piva00 6y agoI'd like to point out for you to refrain commenting in this style, it reeks of reddit-ism. Also, another comment [1] clarified why the original commenter's analysis might be flawed. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25789949 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25789949
- acoustic 6y agoThose numbers are for all bank offices located in the Bahamas, most of which are foreign bank branches. The numbers in the row "By type of bank - Domestic banks" [1] appear consistent with the article. [1] https://stats.bis.org/statx/srs/table/A5?c=BS&m=S&p=20202&o=s:line,z:1 https://stats.bis.org/statx/srs/table/A5?c=BS&m=S&p=20202&o=...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cryptoanonymous 6y agoAuthor here; this is the correct answer. The larger number refers to all banks. Deltec is known to be a domestic bank, so we can use the smaller number to get tighter uncertainty bounds on its currency flows.
- csomar 6y agoI'd be very careful to take advice from this guy. 1. He's definitively bad at investing. He doesn't have an investment strategy, and probably never heard of portfolio re-balancing. 2. He got in lucky and made some good returns. Now he thinks he is a genius because of that, and as a result can predict the next market move. 3. He didn't do good market research. For example, most of the volume in USDT is faked by the exchanges. Coinbase, GBTC, and CME each one of these is are probably bigger than USDT in size and volume. Unregulated derivatives are an alternative to USDT for more sophisticated traders and they are also huge. 4.USDT is now also used outside of the crypto-market. Not because it is great, but because of the practicality. This offshore unregulated market of USD is worth in the $ trillions. USDT having a market cap of a dozen billions is really peanuts. That being said, I'd be more interested in an investigative journalism on how Tether has succeeded in moving such amounts of money while avoiding all the KYC bonanza a regular joe (or business) has to go through.
- mathgenius 6y ago> For example, most of the volume in USDT is faked by the exchanges. I agree this volume cannot be trusted. Much like the asian volume in 2017 turned out to be mostly fake. I find it hard to believe that Binance got so big so fast.
- cryptoanonymous 6y agoHi, I'm the author. > He doesn't have an investment strategy, and probably never heard of portfolio re-balancing. This is perhaps a reasonable inference to draw based only on the information in the article, but it is incorrect. Without going into too much detail, the missing context is that I have effective long exposure to certain markets through my ownership of founder stock in a startup that operates in those markets. And while I place a high expectation value on that stock, it's also illiquid and can't be easily hedged. For reasons I didn't go into in the piece, I believed Bitcoin would also serve as a partial hedge for that market exposure, which justified a higher allocation than one might naively expect. (I'll also observe that portfolio rebalancing isn't the right decision in all situations. Startup founders rationally concentrate their net worths into their companies, which is justified by their overwhelming informational advantage.) > He got in lucky and made some good returns. Now he thinks he is a genius because of that, and as a result can predict the next market move. I agree with the first sentence. I would strongly dispute the second. It's precisely because I don't think I can predict what will happen next that I've zeroed my exposure to this entire ecosystem. > He didn't do good market research. For example, most of the volume in USDT is faked by the exchanges. Coinbase, GBTC, and CME each one of these is are probably bigger than USDT in size and volume. Unregulated derivatives are an alternative to USDT for more sophisticated traders and they are also huge. I'm aware of these claims — there are rumors of wash trading by the big unbanked exchanges that I consider quite credible. I didn't include those in the piece because I wasn't able to find confirmatory evidence in the time I'd allocated to research it. I would be extremely interested if you could share any evidence you may have collected about these claims.
- shawabawa3 6y agoArticle seems mostly accurate but there's a mistake in understanding about the Whale Alert tweets > What’s more, the supposed USD inputs (e.g., 401,431,056 USD in the top left transaction) are giving perfectly round Tether outputs (e.g., 400,000,000 USDT in the same transaction) in every block — regardless of the prevailing exchange rate or anything else. Whale Alert uses exchange rates to convert currencies in the post. The "USD inputs" are simply the USDT that was minted converted using a USD/USDT exchange price (I'm not sure which one) Whale Alert has also hard-coded USD/USDC to 1:1, which is why the coinbase pro minting Tweets match exactly
- rmtech 6y agoWe are due a cryptocurrency correction. The question is, how low will Bitcoin go on Tether collapse? $20k? $10k? Or will things get even crazier with $100k bitcoin crashing to $60k?
- jdjfjtkfkf 6y agoThe real USDT/USD market is not the Kraken one (or similar ones), but the implied synthetic market creating by arbing BTC/USDT and BTC/USD. Companies like Alameda trade billions arbing this synthetic USDT/USD market close to peg: https://twitter.com/AlamedaTrabucco/status/1348773027639562241 https://twitter.com/AlamedaTrabucco/status/13487730276395622...
- nik_s 6y agoThe author implies that the recent growth in tether's market cap is an indication of an incoming exit scam. A cursory glance at Coinbase's USDC's market cap [1] shows that it too is growing at almost exactly the same pace as tether's [2]. I think most players in this market would agree that Coinbase, for all of it's failings, is unlikely to be planning an exit scam at this point. It doesn't disprove the whole thesis, and some elements of it might have merit, but at least one element of it seems weak to me. [1] https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/usd-coin/ https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/usd-coin/ [2] https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/tether/ https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/tether/
- traumivator 6y agoCheck the volume for USDC/USDT. It has been increasing the last couple of weeks. So one could argue that people are trading largely unbacked USDT for backed and audited USDC. Which increases the demand for USDC and the USDC minting.
- qeternity 6y agoNo, it doesn’t. In fact it’s exactly what you’d expect if Tether is fraudulent. Stablecoins are a great way to transact in dollars that you otherwise wouldn’t be able to, for instance the proceeds of illegal activity. The author notes the exact mechanism: print USDT, buy BTC on sham exchanges, send BTC to Coinbase, sell for USDC. You would expect them to increase in lock step if this is happening. If it were legitimate flows, you would actually expect USDC to far outpace USDT given the much greater ease of conversion and trust in the sponsors.
- jcfrei 6y ago> print USDT, buy BTC on sham exchanges, send BTC to Coinbase, sell for USDC. The steps you described don't result in new USDC being minted. That happens only when people send dollars to Coinbase and change them to USDC. > If it were legitimate flows, you would actually expect USDC to far outpace USDT given the much greater ease of conversion and trust in the sponsors. No, USDT has been around for a lot longer and lots of very liquid trading pairs are based on it. So if you need to buy lots of crypto currency you might need tethers so you can buy on an exchange with a liquid trading pair (BTC/USDT on Binance being the most liquid trading pair).
- gokhan 6y agoSeems like the article is flagged as hell. That's disgusting if you're flagging because you're long BTC.
- mckirk 6y agoThanks for this article, I've gotten out of crypto for the moment for the exact same reason. The probability that something fishy is going on which would trigger a panic-sale when it's discovered is too high until we know more about the court case against Tether, imho. Though all the people insisting on calling this FUD do make me wonder whether I'm seeing things or this is an "emperor's new clothes" situation.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- robinhoodexe 6y agoOn kraken, one can short Tether against the US Dollar. Since Tether is usually pretty close to $1, I wonder if it’s worth it to open a short in case it’s all falling apart. I mean, in case of a crash the price of tether would most certainly fall, right?
- ric2b 6y agoThat's a good point, there's almost no downside to shorting Tether besides the interest, since it would never go much above USD. Given that the interest must be wild, no?
- dragontamer 6y agoCounterparty risk. If Tether controls the price of Tether, they can simply cause Tether to spike to $2 or $10 for a few days or weeks, before leaving. Tether may drop below $1 afterwards, but you might get short-squeezed on the way out. There's no way you can win vs an entity that fully controls the price.
- not2b 6y agoIt seems that this guy decided to go heavily into Bitcoin because of a mistaken belief that seems all too common: "At the time, I saw a market dislocation and the likelihood of significant dollar inflation due to the US Government’s likely response to the unfolding pandemic." He thought that government responses to severe crises that inject lots of money into the economy will cause "significant dollar inflation". In the real world, over the full year of 2020 inflation was 1.4% in the US (food costs went up a bit more, energy costs went down). Failure to inject money into a failing economy results in massive deflation. That's because money was rapidly disappearing from the economy. Money isn't created primarily because governments print it; whenever a bank creates a loan money is created, and when they call in loans money disappears. Central banks control the money supply by regulating banks, and their goal is to keep things stable. Source: https://www.bls.gov/news.release/cpi.nr0.htm https://www.bls.gov/news.release/cpi.nr0.htm
- mountainb 6y agoPeople often don't understand the implications of an elastic monetary system that is also decentralized because of the way that the Fed and member banks are structured. There are things the Fed or the government could do to frogmarch devaluation (like, for example, encouraging banks to pay people to carry credit card balances through negative interest rate policy or encouraging no-doc/no-credit check loans of all kinds) but that is not their prerogative.
- qeternity 6y agoPeople also don’t realize that moderate inflation is a good thing. You want a gentle inbuilt mechanism to encourage consumption. And we have good tools to combat inflation whereas we don’t really have any tools to combat deflation. There’s a reason nobody spends Bitcoin and it’s mostly not about fees or block size.
- jasonhoch 6y agoWhy do you want a gentle inbuilt mechanism to encourage consumption?
- christiansakai 6y agoI wonder what will happen to DeFi and the entire Ethereum network, because Tether is largely used in DeFi transactions.
- ForHackernews 6y agoIs there any way to "short" bitcoin? I don't really trust any of the fly-by-night cryptocurrency exchanges, but is there a real derivatives market somewhere?
- gwbas1c 6y agoSee if someone will loan you Bitcoin, paid back in Bitcoin. Then you sell the Bitcoin, wait for the price to go down, and buy some to pay back the loan.
- garmaine 6y agoLedgerX options.
- doggosphere 6y agoShort on Coinbase Pro, or Kraken
- DSingularity 6y agoYou can short on pro?
- doggosphere 6y agoMy bad, you can go margin but not short. Kraken can short though.
- ForHackernews 6y agoIs Kraken SEC regulated?
- doggosphere 6y agoAssume so, based in US, available for 48 states. https://support.kraken.com/hc/en-us/articles/360031282351-Is-Kraken-licensed-or-regulated- https://support.kraken.com/hc/en-us/articles/360031282351-Is...
- cryptoanonymous 6y agoHi, I'm the author. Using a throwaway for all the obvious reasons. I'll try to dive into this thread over the next few hours to answer any questions folks may have about this. Please feel free to ask.
- Animats 6y agoToday, January 15th is the court-ordered disclosure date for Tether. So soon we should know how big the Tether bubble is. Clearly, it's time to get out of USDT. There's no upside potential, and there's a big downside potential.
- soneca 6y agoBut there will be no news for some time until the attorney general’s office review all the delivered documents right? Or should there be relevant news in the next few days already?
- dgellow 6y agoWe don’t know yet
- Tsotsi 6y agoI thought the same, then realised Courts move very slowly. May be months before we have any reaction or statement. What IS fascinating and will be very telling is to closely watch Tether issue from ‘Treasury’. Seems they have stopped as they KNOW what is in the millions of pages they delivered to AG and from now on need to be much more careful. If Tether issuance decreases, crypto prices should fall. Must also watch Tether volume per day. Two scenarios: 1. Tether decides to go legit: mild short term crypto price fall. Tether actually has an independent audit as much promised. Audit reveals not good, but not catastrophic. 2. Tether execs have decided to delay / obfuscate and exit when forced: continued fraudulent Tether issue and price bubble accelerates. Something is already up: BTC price rocketed every holiday and long weekend recently. This one it is falling = no support from Tether printing?
- ikeboy 6y ago>What’s more, the supposed USD inputs (e.g., 401,431,056 USD in the top left transaction) are giving perfectly round Tether outputs (e.g., 400,000,000 USDT in the same transaction) in every block — regardless of the prevailing exchange rate or anything else. You're misunderstanding. There's no USD input. They're simply looking at the exchange value of USDT and converting it into dollars. Their data source says that USDC = $1 USD, so USDC minting is in round numbers.
- ceedan 6y agoBitcoin & the crypto world has always felt like a cult to me.
- kneel 6y agoStandard FUD. Anonymous blogs with heavy dialogue to reach a conclusion? Where is the evidence? Oh it’s just a narrative. Tether is used heavily in Asia. The fact that they cannot audit Chinese inflows is to be expected. This reminds me of all the FUD around Tesla in 2018. Just loading up the spring even more.
- chomper 6y agoI am afraid of Bitcoin because of Tether. However, there is one part of this argument that I don't quite understand: If we woke up tomorrow to find out that Tether caused a disruptive event overnight and BTC/USD fell from $30,000 to $10,000 or $3,000..... Wouldn't there be a gigantic line of people who have been experiencing FOMO for the last 6 months ready to jump in at the new attractive price level, driving the price straight back up? Or is the side of people who could lose out on Tether just so huge that the newcomers would not be able to cover them all?
- DSingularity 6y agoIf tether crashed I would expect bitcoins price to go up not down. It would suck for people holding tether because nobody would want their tether.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> If tether crashed I would expect bitcoins price to go up not down. Bitcoin’s price in what reference currency? USDT? Clearly. USDC? Actual USD (probably measured indirectly via intermediary currencies)? Something else? For anything but USDT, the reason for such an expectation could use some explanation.
- ric2b 6y agoAll of the above if most of the demand from people fleeing from USDT goes into Bitcoin, which is likely. More people chasing the same thing -> price goes up. But obviously the BTC/USDT price would go up a lot more because USDT would be going down at the same time.
- TacticalCoder 6y agoWhat many people believe is that there's not anywhere near the demand to justify a 35 K USD price and that's it's tether printing which pumped the price of BTC to these levels. So if the tether printing press stops, the price would crash back to 3K USD or something in a hurry. Crypto investors/gamblers concerned about tether/USDT already own zero USDT. What they're concerned about is that it would take the entire crypto market down. Now on the very short term it may cause a BTC price spike: should it be true and USDT going down a lot, people hodling them may desperately try to get out and buy any BTC they can, shortly raising BTC's price. But if tether is the reason the BTC price is so high, it won't take long before "zero new issuance of USDT to pump the price" would totally crash the market. In any case it's an interesting story to follow...
- lurker619 6y agoSo everybody's sure it's gonna drop, and everyone's gonna buy the dip at $25k? Get ready to FOMO back in at $50k...
- DSingularity 6y agoIf tether started crashing people would buy Bitcoin/eth like crazy to avoid holding tether. What would that do to the price of tether?
- qeternity 6y agoYou would likely see crypto on unbanked exchanges skyrocket as the USDT denominator to most pairs goes to zero. This crypto would presumably be moved off exchange and sold elsewhere. So on legit exchanges, crypto crashes and on sham exchanges it moons.
- DSingularity 6y agoThanks. Seems obvious now that you write it.
- T-A 6y agoNot exactly news: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3195066 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3195066
- TacticalCoder 6y agoGreat article "cryptoanonymous" (welcome to HN btw): really lots of information in there but... Aren't you writing this because now that you could get out and got the (real) USD on your bank account, you actually want the price to crash very badly to buy much more coins? If the price were to crash back to, say, 3K USD, wouldn't you be tempted to put a few millions back in and ride to 15K and more again?
- Majromax 6y ago> Now fast-forward one year. In March of 2020, I bought a large amount of Bitcoin. At the time, I saw a market dislocation and the likelihood of significant dollar inflation due to the US Government’s likely response to the unfolding pandemic. I'm frustrated by this statement. If you predict inflation in the USD that is not currently priced into the market, then there are already plenty of conventional ways to make money on the prediction. For example, go long on real-return (inflation-adjusted) bonds, and go short on nominal bonds. Or purchase call options on commodities (preferably ones like food or energy that would be directly part of the predicted inflation). Or just invest in less-speculative equities like utilities or transport. There's no need to structure investments to also bring in the entire unhinged, speculative nature of cryptocurrencies just to place a bet on inflation. Bitcoin (vs the USD) has had tenfold increases (year-over-year) and larger than 50% drops, all against a USD that has not in fact experienced abrupt price-level swings (expressed in terms of consumer goods).
- optimiz3 6y agoMy favorite way to short the dollar is to use fixed-rate debt to buy productive assets (real-estate, etc.). Double whammy. Assets in general should keep pace with inflation and fixed-rate debt gets inflated away.
- throwawaypali 6y agoDoes this actually work if you're being paid a salary in USD that wont likely rise with inflation?
- optimiz3 6y agoNot to be flippant, but it's on you to negotiate better salary terms if that's how you get paid.
- throwawaypali 6y agoUh, like most people I get around a 5% raise per anum, if inflation is higher than the CPIU estimates I'm treading water, like most people. If you're getting 10% per anum those are very unusual terms even for a high performer
- wslh 6y agoA complementary paper from 2018 investigating how Tether (USDT) influenced Bitcoin and other cryptocurrency prices during the 2017 boom: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3195066 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3195066
- mattxvrsmith 6y agoSome people want Bitcoin to fail so much that they‘ll believe in literal conspiracy theories if it supports their priors. A legitimate market for hard money is impossible for these people to believe, it must be fraud.
- gfrangakis 6y agoOn the other hand, some people want Bitcoin to succeed so much - or rather want the price of Bitcoin to succeed because they speculate on it - that they'll engineer some fraudulent schemes in a relatively unregulated market to support their bank accounts. I think it's likely a bit of both, but you can't deny there is something unsavory going on with Tether and these offshore exchanges
- fortran77 6y ago> There’s a scene in The Big Short where Mike Baum meets a stripper who’s taken out mortgages on five properties. The stripper doesn’t think there’s anything wrong with doing that, because her mortgage broker told her she could always refinance her mortgages when the prices of her houses went up. And housing prices would always go up. Of course, our Government ended up bailing out people like the "stripper" who would complain that they "lost their homes." Let's hope the new administration doesn't bail out crypto specu-vestors.
- thorwasdfasdf 6y agoOk, for everyone here worried about the value of their BTC, please consider this. At the end of the day, all that really matters is what percentage of BTC bought was from HODLERS. If 80% of all BTC bought was from HODLERS, it means the market cap of BTC can NOT drop anymore than 20%, at the very maximum drop, and since the number of BTC coins in existance is constant, it means the drop in value of BTC is at MOST 20%. The last bitcoin bubble was mostly bought up by speculators who eventually sell very quickly, which what allowed the price drop to occur so much because most BTC holders were not hodlers and most were just speculators. You can sidestep all the concerns about Tether and USDT and conversion, etc. Just figure out what percentage of BTC is bought by HODLERS or get some kind of estimate, and that will tell you your downside risk. I for one, am long BTC, because I know this time around a much higher percentage of BTC was bought by HODLRs and there's a whole lot more coming in 2021.
- owenversteeg 6y agoSorry, but this comment is wrong on every level. First: that is very much not how prices work. If everyone else stayed on the sidelines and did not sell or buy any Bitcoin, the price could be set by two people - one buyer and one seller. Second: you have no way to know who bought BTC. You can get a guess from various media, but you can never truly know. Large amounts of Bitcoin frequently change hands in entirely private transactions. Lots of volume is on shady exchanges, and of the volume on legitimate exchanges - what's to say that those are all "HODLERS"? I have no idea what the price of Bitcoin will be in the future, but your comment is definitely not correct - downside risk is certainly not limited by the type of people who bought in.
- thorwasdfasdf 6y agoWhat you're saying is only partially correct. Imagine if everyone stayed on the sidelines and did not sell any bitcoin (the HODLRS), as the number of sellers continues to diminish more and more and more, this puts upward pressure on bitcoin as the percentage of buyers outnumber the selllers more and more. It's like trying to buy a house in the bay area. there's very few people who can afford to buy a bay area house but there's even fewer houses for sale and so the prices keep going up and up and up. What matters is the ratio of buyers to sellers. and once you run out of sellers, the price starts going up again.
- TimMeade 6y agoExcellent Excellent. I have been trying to explain this to people. Now i can just send a link to this. Excellent.
- adn37 6y ago> The first red arrow on the chart points to April 25th, 2019: the announcement of the OAG’s investigation. Notice how, as the investigation progresses, the issuance rate of Tether begins to rise — initially in large single blocks, of around $1B, every few months. The below is an analysis of printed tethers vs known institutional buyers for 2020. I find a ratio of 4 to 1. Tether market cap for 2020: march: 4.6B$, april: 6.3B$, may 8.8B$, july: 9.9B$, 29August: 10B$, 1stSept: 13B$, 28Sept: 15B$, Jan21: 24B$ Compared to known institutional buyers: Grayscale: march: 500M$, april: 600M$, may: 1B$, july: 1.4B$, 31August: 1.8B$ (approx), 28Sept: 2B$ Microstrategy: 1.1B$ average price (august to september, as per https://bitcointreasuries.org/ https://bitcointreasuries.org/) Difference: between march-september 2020, Tether printed 10B$ while the biggest known institutional buyers spent 2.6B$ (grayscale+microstrategy=1.5B$+1.1B$=2.6B$) That is to say, Tether prints appear to be 4 times the big buyers amount. ref for grayscale buy amounts: https://hackernoon.com/grayscales-gbtc-pump-effect-means-2021-will-start-slow-0gu340l https://hackernoon.com/grayscales-gbtc-pump-effect-means-202...
- willward1 6y agoThis article really changed my view and caused my to sell most BTC. Two things can be true: that BTC is a good long term inflation hedge AND the price is being manipulated short term by the tether scam. I just think the risk reward of tether being shut down within the next year makes it pruden to take some gains off the table here - hopefully to get back in at a lower cost basis when the market clears.
- gge 6y ago> Bob: Leverage. I personally only use 2–3X leverage, but they let you leverage your positions up to 100X if you want. You can’t do that on Coinbase. > Me: Gasps audibly Hahahaha Binance offers 125x leverage. Imagine thinking $20B of USDT is enough to drive BTC up $600B in market cap. Wait till he hears about algorithmic stablecoins.
- gge 6y ago> The US Treasury should enforce 100% reserve requirements on all USD-pegged crypto stablecoins, with mandatory audits. Lmao. Have you heard of decentralised stablecoins? There are many types of decentralised stablecoins such as overcollateralised ones, fraction reserve ones, algorithmic ones etc. Overcollateralised ones like DAI (backed by ETH/USDC/WBTC etc) and sUSD (backed by SNX) are the most popular ones. How will you enforce a reserve requirement on a decentralised stablecoin like this?
- otiose_tortoise 6y agoIt is very likely that Tether is a scam -- the evidence has been mounting for years -- but the peg won't break until the market believes it. Unfortunately, there isn't a good way to short Tether. You can short the Kraken USDT/USD pair on margin, but the margin rates are ~20% a year. You can borrow tethers on compound.finance, but the rates are ~15% a year. I think part of the reason we haven't seen the unwind of tether is simply because it's too expensive to short. Also, no one will loan you their tether if you tell them you're going to break the peg and give them back a worthless token. (I actually had a kraken short on for a while in ~2018 but gave up because it's just too expensive.)
- tzone 6y agoThere seem to be quite a lot of misunderstandings in this post. Not sure how familiar author really is with inner workings of crypto markets. First thing first, is Tether sketchy? Yeah, pretty sketchy. But not for the reasons provided in the article. USDT is the most traded asset against other crypto because it is the easiest vehicle to use for all sorts of arbitrage. USDT is available to trade with on every non-US exchange and it is the easiest asset to move around. As overall market size increases, it makes sense that demand for USDT is increasing because it is used in most of the trading/arbitraging/etc... When looking for highest USDT/USD trading volume, it isn't Kraken that you should be looking at, but Curve. Curve is a DEX that does largest amounts of stable coin trading volume. Curve also has incredible liquidity depth. Right now, you can go there and exchange: 10 million USDT to 9.99 million USDC in a single transaction. USDC can be cashed out for USD very easily and is regulated not just by regular US regulators but also NY financial department too, which is the most aggressive regulator to ever exist probably. If you wanted to, you would be able to cash out billions of USDT to other NY regulated stable coins in a single day. While USDT is certainly very sketchy, it is the dominant market player specifically because of its sketchiness (and due to it being the first one). USDT's independence from US regulators is a huge plus for most of the major non-US crypto players. Those players would be more worried about holding USD (or USDC) directly, because they are more worried about US government freezing their funds, rather than Tether going insolvent.
- skybrian 6y agoAre USDC transactions less private or decentralized than USDT? It looks like it's possible to freeze an account [1], but I'm wondering how that's done. [1] https://news.bitcoin.com/centre-obliges-government-request-freezes-address-with-100000-usdc/ https://news.bitcoin.com/centre-obliges-government-request-f...
- therunningone98 6y ago"Note that Twitter appears to be intermittently suspending certain accounts that raise questions about Tether." What is the reason for Twitter suspending these accounts?
- shibleyb 6y agoOk, so let's say Tether is a scam, unbacked, and everyone dumps it. How does this affect Bitcoin? In my opinion it would send it to the moon. When Tether is exited, where will it be exited to? Not the USD, maybe some into alt coins or USDC, but mostly into Bitcoin. Tether is scammy indeed, but it doesn't change the scarcity of Bitcoin, and the fact that there is still a huge demand and a constant supply for BTC.
- ehhuang 6y agoWhen everyone is dumping tether, who’s trading BTC for tether?
- fscaramanga 6y agoAssuming the Tether exchanges remain functional, yes, everyone will try to get out of Tethers and coins are the only option. People would then try to get their coins off the exchange. It will be a terrible scramble. The question is, what happens to BTC/USD on USD exchanges. My best guess is that panic and additional supply withdrawn from tether exchanges (for those who manage to get out) will crash the price.
- MacroChip 6y agoI don't understand the section about minting tethers. Couldn't Tether Ltd choose to mint in round numbers legitimately? If they aren't continuously creating and destroying individual tethers then the minting process could be in round numbers but only released to the wild in a controlled manner. The Bahama bank evidence is a lot more compelling. Did the NY court order have a typo in the extension being to January of last year?
- mag300 6y agoFrom Whitney Tilson newsletter today (22/1/2021) A good example of the latter was Tuesday's e-mail, where I included this article, The Bit Short: Inside Crypto's Doomsday Machine, and asked the question: "Is bitcoin about to collapse?" This prompted an old friend to e-mail this response: //We started buying bitcoin for our fund in early 2013 and have been closely following and analyzing cryptoassets for eight years. I'm reaching out because the article you included in your recent e-mail is wrong and easily addressed. Everyone paying attention to cryptocurrencies has been aware of the Tether shenanigans, and its potential risk to crypto prices and infrastructures, for four years. We have been following and analyzing this issue during this entire period. Despite that prior knowledge, I spent about four hours yesterday tracking down all the new details, to make sure I wasn't missing anything important that changed the answer. After doing so, I concluded I wasn't. Tether is only a modest and temporary risk for cryptoassets. The Doomsday Machine analysis has at least a dozen problems. I'll stick to the biggest three (which are all simple conceptual mistakes) and point you to sources addressing the others. The author's core thesis is that Tether Ltd. is committing a massive fraud because (1) they don't in fact have a dollar for every Tether, and (2) they have been selling a lot of Tethers based on the promise that they do. But wait a minute, the author's fear is that they sell Tethers for bitcoin, which they then sell for dollars. To repeat: they trade Tethers for dollars. So, um... they have the dollars. Or more precisely, they probably have most of the dollars, and other assets worth nearly, or even more than, all outstanding Tethers. If I had to bet, which I don't, I would bet the assets are now worth more than the Tethers. The real issue is that, several years ago, they probably didn't have all the dollars. They are shady offshore guys who have never revealed what they actually have. The bitcoin hack and then the probable fraud at Crypto Capital (their payments processor) blew a ~$1.5 billion hole in their balance sheet. The best guess from available evidence is that they decided to (fraudulently) earn their way out of the hole by backing some amount of their Tether liabilities with bitcoin, possibly other cryptoassets, and stocks, instead of 100% with dollars as promised. So they probably made a massive fraudulent gamble on trading profits... and they won. No matter what they chose to own, all those asset prices have risen massively such that I think they've probably earned their way out of their balance sheet hole. But let's say they didn't commit this fraud and instead continued to own only dollars. In that case, the hole's size, relative to their liabilities, has still shrunk by 80%-90%. They used to have, say, a ~$1.5 billion hole in a $5 billion balance sheet. The hole's absolute size shrunk when they swapped their probably-totally-worthless account balance at Crypto Capital into a loan from Bitfinex, which is not at all worthless. And they have sold another $20 billion of Tether for dollars. So even with no gambling, they would now have a ~$1.0 billion hole in a $25 billion balance sheet. Tethers would now be 96% backed, and at a realistic tactical level, Tether Ltd. should now have plenty of assets to buy back however many Tethers people try to sell. There is another theoretical risk that, because the Tether guys are shady, they could be siphoning assets out of Tether Ltd. and leaving it insolvent. But they have zero incentive to do so. They also own Bitfinex, the largest crypto exchange, which is gushing profits, making it is worth many multiples what Tether-looting could be worth – and if Tether collapses, Bitfinex collapses. The second problem with the Doomsday Machine analysis is the assumption that the fraud can perpetuate because there's no exchange link today between Tethers and dollars, apart from Kraken. But wait a minute – I can't directly trade Tether for dollars easily except for on Kraken, but I can trade Tether for bitcoin (or several other major cryptoassets) on many exchanges, almost immediately transfer it to another exchange that allows bitcoin/dollar trading, and almost immediately trade my bitcoin for dollars. Tether is freely exchangeable for dollars, in three quick and easy steps. The necessity of other steps isn't enough of a hindrance to matter. The third major problem is the assumption that a $1.5 billion balance-sheet hole in Tether (or even $5 billion, or $10 billion) is going to collapse the $700 billion market cap of bitcoin and $1.1 trillion market cap of all crypto. That assumption is built on the conflation bitcoin/Tether trading volume with the buying power behind bitcoin. That's badly wrong. The Tethers are merely the short-term medium of exchange, not the source of the buying power. Every purchase of bitcoin with Tether is also a sale of bitcoin for Tether. If Tether stops trading overnight, bitcoin trading volumes will temporarily collapse, but the directly-resulting collapse in buying pressure will be equaled by the collapse in selling pressure. The true source of funds pushing bitcoin's price higher is new dollars, Euro, and Yen flowing from real investors. I'm not saying there would be no effect on bitcoin's price in the short term. Some of the small minority of bitcoin holders who trade on margin and hold Tether may need to sell bitcoin if their Tether is suddenly valued at less than $1. Also, crypto prices usually fall on headlines of crypto hacks, revealed Ponzi schemes, exchange shut-downs, etc., no matter how unrelated or trivial. Then the prices recover. The real Tether risk to other cryptoassets is the pure regulatory risk. The Tether guys have clearly been engaged in shenanigans that could get them banned from the U.S. and potentially other jurisdictions. There's a smaller chance that the U.S. or EU could eventually get Bitfinex shut down. It would cause disruption in crypto markets. But in the end, that disruption would probably look like the collapse of Mt. Gox, then the world's largest cryptoasset exchange, in 2014: moderate short-term price pain, accompanied by the removal or cleaning up of a big player that everyone already knew was shady and that responsible parties were already avoiding to the extent possible. The primary crypto-market-participant reaction to Mt. Gox's collapse was "good riddance"; we'll feel similarly about Tether if it happens. // Thank you!