7 ms·
This is interesting because having layoffs at a company that should be going off like a rocket during a pandemic is odd. What is going on at Dropbox that preve
by jedberg 6y ago
This is interesting because having layoffs at a company that should be going off like a rocket during a pandemic is odd. What is going on at Dropbox that prevented them from taking advantage of the huge shift to remote work?
- webwielder2 6y agoWhy should they be going off like a rocket?
- jypepin 6y agomore people are working remotely which probably requires more people looking for ways to share files more efficiently.
- levosmetalo 6y agoMost of the people do need to find a ways to share files more efficiently, but hardly any sane company would choose Dropbox given their security proposal.
- dheera 6y agoI imagine that sharing files would be the same regardless of whether you are remote or not. Even in a real office people don't usually hand USB sticks back and forth.
- jypepin 6y agoI have no data, but more remote people either has 0 impact, or impact on more data sharing online. Lots of businesses still work a lot on paper (think lawyers, notaries, etc) especially while working with clients, and are not forced to share docs differently.
- bombcar 6y agoFor me and my company and friends this has meant more realizing the features of things we already paid for (Office 365, etc) rather than paying for Dropbox. The last thing my free account does is sync my 1Password - and I’ll likely go cloud on that soon anyway
- spoonjim 6y agoAll remote collaboration software is growing like bonkers during the pandemic because of remote work.
- MrRiddle 6y agoHow workflow changes regarding storage when employees start working remotely? People will just share the same way they shared while in the office.
- jedberg 6y agoBecause they are core piece of remote work culture, like Zoom and Box.
- MrRiddle 6y agoThey’re a core piece of regular office work as well. Apps like Zoom were not part of the office life, while Dropbox was.
- CedarMills 6y agoTheir UX has become worse, questionable design choices, and 2 GB limit is almost a joke. Chances are, if you're in the market, you just use something like Box which provides a lot more value for free.
- santoshalper 6y agoI'm a long time user and when people talk about the UX (many, not just you), I am always puzzled. What UX are you speaking of? For me, Dropbox is just a folder on my hard drive with no real UX to speak of. It's the ultimate "gets out of my way and just works". Are you talking about the web site?
- remir 6y agoDropbox tried to branch out into the "collaboration space" with their Paper feature/product and since then, the web UI has got worse.
- cfeduke 6y agoThere's a challenging to use UI that has become part of the installation process on recent updates. Most of the time it tries to advertise to me that I need to use Dropbox Paper rather than making it easy to copy/manage folders from external sources. (I need to do a bit more than just manage files/folders, like handle external shares, so I have to use the UI they provide for doing this.)
- jarek83 6y agoI use only their online app and it's where their UX got much worse recently.
- crazydoggers 6y agoIt’s a commoditized space and the competition has easier access to new users... Microsoft, Google, Apple... all offer similar services bundled in.
- cgearhart 6y agoI think Box ate their lunch in the corporate sphere and they have a lot more competition in the consumer space from things like OneDrive and iCloud Drive. The only reason I still have Dropbox at all is because I don’t have a reason to pull the plug—and it wouldn’t have to be much of an excuse.
- soneil 6y agoTheir device limit gave me my reason to leave them. When they started haemorrhaging corporate customers, they attacked their consumer users. I can't say I find the result hugely shocking.
- shmoogy 6y agoI actually just moved all my stuff from Dropbox to B2 buckets. My December bill was like $0.09
- rolleiflex 6y agoI'm interested in moving off Dropbox in the same way, and B2 sounds interesting. Is there an app comparable to Dropbox working with B2, or did you have to build that app yourself?
- pyrophane 6y agoNot the parent, but you can do this with Nextcloud. It supports using object storage as a backend, and B2 is compatible with S3.
- shmoogy 6y agoI used RClone to sync to B2. They've got an iPhone app that you can download to browse + download from the bucket, else the website itself. There might be further reasons for it, but I mostly use it as an offsite backup that my wife could upload to -- so usability was a plus -- but not worth that kind of premium.
- surajrmal 6y agoI wonder if the omission is due to HN bias of disliking Google, but Google Drive has the largest market share in the segment Dropbox competes in.
- mc32 6y agoThey are consumer oriented. Companies scaled up their Box instances, so they are likely doing well. But Dropbox never really had the Corp customer. And with people having access to Box, why would they bother with Dropbox?
- aksss 6y agoWe see a lot of SMBs using Dropbox and have rarely encountered Box out in the wild. In both cases, they are often converting over to OneDrive - the Office Suite is still a very, very strong play in that most companies need/prefer it to alternatives, and since OneDrive is bundled the question inevitably gets asked, "why am I paying for DropBox if I have OneDrive/SharePoint included in this cost over here?". No good answer, really. I mean there are things that DropBox does better, but for a lot of businesses those strengths aren't valuable enough to pay the premium.
- weeboid 6y agoStorage-as-a-service is a commodity and race to the bottom. Check $BOX and $DBX 5 year charts. Good luck competing with GAFA on this, best hope is a buyout. Firesale on depreciating assets. On the consumer side, storage will become an appliance, like a (stick of butter sized) fridge. Or just included in your centralized home + family control center.
- toomuchtodo 6y ago> On the consumer side, storage will become an appliance, like a (stick of butter sized) fridge. Or just included in your centralized home + family control center. You can already get an inexpensive Synology NAS with a slick UI and backups to a cloud provider of your choice, or Nextcloud, although there's probably room on both for one click import from your existing Dropbox account using your auth and their API to migrate contents.
- tinyhouse 6y agoThis is not backed up by anything besides your opinion. The main chart you should look at is the increase in number of paying customers month after month. Dropbox is much more than just storage. They also have their own infrastructure and don't depend on GAFA. They made a decision to not compete on the consumer side. I didn't like it but you cannot blame them given the large pockets of the competition and the fact they can monetize those costumers with their other products unlike Dropbox. They compete in enterprise where price is not the main factor like it's for consumers and doing it successfully. I will ping you in 5 years... (they might indeed get acquired though. If that happens it's gonna be for at least double of what $dbx is worth today)
- rchaud 6y agoIt makes no sense not to compete on the consumer side. The enterprise side has enormous barriers to entry, like a long sales cycle, RFPs, security audits etc. Office 365 simply offers more, plus with a familiar interface that doesn't require extra training for end-users. Who is going to be championing Dropbox on the enterprise buyer's side? Employees that are satisfied consumers or the IT office that uses the same 4-5 vendors for everything?
- dgellow 6y agoFor individuals Dropbox is quite expensive compared to services like OneDrive. Microsoft 365 Personal is 70$/year and gives you 1TB on OneDrive and full access to the Office offering. Dropbox for individuals is 200$/year for 3TB. And nothing else. Unless you're hoarding data or want to avoid Microsoft, the choice is simple. And I'm sure you have even cheaper services.
- brightball 6y agoNot entirely accurate. I didn’t even realize this was a thing, but on the Dropbox web interface you can now open docs, slideshows and spreadsheets in either Office365 or Google Office without accounts on either.
- dgellow 6y agoOh, I didn’t know this. Thanks for sharing
- brightball 6y agoI been using Dropbox since the beginning and I only discovered it last week.
- rapht 6y agoI actually switched to OneDrive when Dropbox changed their pricing a while ago. Microsoft's offering was way more competitive on both price (€100/yr for 5x1TB) and features (Office access and integration, etc.)
- 2ion 6y agoYes, but I have 1 gbit uplink and upload speads are 3 megabytes per second at best. Actually, I tried via rclone from VPSs at various locations also and no change. Frankly, that's shit. I've been paying the 2€/month 100GB storage plan simply because the OneDrive Android app does its job of offloading photos quickly well but that's really it's good for. That, and uploading 100K-1M Office documents. As soon as I noticed this issue, the deal of 1TB storage with a O365 subscription also went sour. 1TB I can't really use -- no deal. This problem is well known; it's all over the internet -- OneDrive is a sloth. It doesn't affect downloads, btw.
- simplemen 6y agoAt one time, Dropbox was the easiest and best solution if you were using Android, MacOS, and Windows. I used to pay for 1TB account although Apple offered 2TB for same monthly fee. But the Dropbox destroyed their simple UI to this ugliness clusterfuck. That was the motivation for me to cancel it and move 100% into Apple's ecosystem.
- ubermonkey 6y agoI'm still not sure what I could migrate to that would give me solid and trustworthy sync/access across Windows, Mac, iOS, and Linux. I'm happy to pay whatever I pay for Dropbox -- I don't actually remember what it is -- but I'd rather they stop throwing in bullshit kitchen-sink features.
- akvadrako 6y agoI still use Dropbox because I care about what you mentioned, but I think the next best thing is Seafile, however it has bad symlink handling.
- benhurmarcel 6y agoNextcloud. You can buy the service directly at various providers, such as Hetzner. Another solution is Google Drive, adding Insync for desktop sync.
- ubermonkey 6y agoI have zero interest in administering my own services like it appears Nextcloud, even with Hetzner, would require. I've been there and done that, but I'm too far out of the sysadmin game now to do a good job of it. It's a bad use of my time, and not something I enjoy as a hobby. I'm unwilling to use Google services if I can avoid it.
- benhurmarcel 6y agoThe service I mentioned (Hetzner, but there are others) do all the administration for you. You get a login and password into a Nextcloud instance, that's it. No administration required. See here: https://www.hetzner.com/storage/storage-share https://www.hetzner.com/storage/storage-share
- jshawl 6y agoI churned when Dropbox started removing features and asking for more money. e.g. limits on number of devices, more frequent nags, forcing me to unlink devices that had already been linked. I'm not going to be bullied into being a paying customer.
- bluescrn 6y agoWhen they limited the number of devices I looked at the paid plans. But the lowest-end plan costs about the same as Netflix, and I have too many subscriptions in my life already.
- apple4ever 6y agoThat's what a lot of people are saying up and down this thread. Limited devices (ugh) and high cost to unlimit (ugh). That didn't have to happen.
- bombcar 6y agoMakes me wonder why Amazon hasn’t throw together a Dropbox like competitor free with Prime.
- edoceo 6y agoThey are switching from growth to revenue mode. It smells to me like priming for a deal.
- hyperpallium2 6y agoI'm guessing because they solve interop problem between systems, which is going away. Great idea and execution, very valuable but seemed valued even higer than that to me (i.e overvalued). They were well-placed for app hosting - but lots of competition and it's hard to hit the jackpot twice (even google hasn't managed it, nor apple, arguably).