13 ms·
Trading Time for Money
- gotem 6y agoThis doesn’t make sense. If someone makes $10 an hour, then they would be better off if they made $20 an hour. That’s because $20 > (GREATER THAN) $10. However if it was only $5 (five), then they wouldn’t want to work for $5 an hour because $5 < (LESS THAN) $10. You can check it with your calculator if you’re skeptical. $20-$10 = + number so $20 is grater $5 - $10 = - number so $5 is less
- nicbou 6y agoI'm not sure if I understand your comment, or how it relates to the article.
- greatgib 6y agoIf I understand well the comment, I have the same feeling that the math of the article are wrong. For exemple, it says that you spare money by doing the things and that this money will buy you time later. But if you still work, and do not pay someone to do your chores, you will have to do them in week end and free time. So you lose free time now for potential free time later. Also, it does not make any sense to compare fixed personal costs like groceries and co with the difference in costs between what you earn with your work compared to paying someone half of your salary.
- xupybd 6y agoLooking at the comments by gotem I suspect the account is a clever bot.
- dilippkumar 6y agoSo roughly, the author is saying something like: if ( outsourcing_cost * alpha > opportunity_cost ) { outsource(); } and discusses how that alpha should be calculated. The author also mentions some side benefits of doing some tasks and getting better at them. Does HN have any thoughts about living a smaller life by doing fewer things and having more time to just live and enjoy life? If spending time figuring out how to optimize money/time in more complicated ways could produce a more efficient path, wouldn’t such knowledge spread quickly and become common knowledge? In other words, are there any real life hacks that are not obvious that result in significant quality of life improvements?
- nicbou 6y ago> wouldn’t such knowledge spread quickly and become common knowledge How to lose weight is open knowledge, but that doesn't make it easier, doubly so if you are also fighting other battles. Sometimes there is a solution, but it's just not attainable for everyone. > are there any real life hacks that are not obvious that result in significant quality of life improvements? I didn't want to make this post about my own lifestyle, but it might qualify as an answer: 1. I reduced my expenses. You don't need to earn the money you don't spend. I've always been frugal, but I recently took more drastic steps with point #2 in mind. For instance, I cut my rent by 42% by moving to the edge of the city into an older apartment. Well, actually 30% because I have a garage - a lifelong dream of mine. 2. I went freelance to have more control on how much time I sell. I didn't think this was possible, until a contractor at my old job said he took 3 month vacations between contracts. The more you earn and the less you spend, the longer you can go between contracts. At the average rate [1], I could cover my expenses in 3 months. The 4th month pays for a nice trip. 3. Decouple your income from your time. I built a website, and it grew enough to pay the bills. Now I live from it. I spend 20-30 hours a month on it (though it requires about 10). This was a stroke of luck. I couldn't reproduce that if you asked me. That's about it. I'm well aware that this could only happen in specific conditions with a healthy amount of arbitrary luck. However, it did result in significant quality of life improvements. Anyone can appreciate the value of having so much free time. It's only a matter of using it well. I don't know if there's any wisdom to extract from this, but I hope it helps. [1] https://allaboutberlin.com/guides/freelance-developer-rate https://allaboutberlin.com/guides/freelance-developer-rate
- pwarner 6y agoI suggest finding something you like, and do it. I like gardening and cleaning so I do those, but don't like changing oil so I outsource that. I would change my oil it I could stand up doing it!
- xupybd 6y agoMe too, I've tried explaining this to people. The hard part of an oil change is getting to the oil filter. It's way easier in a pit. You also have to deal with oil disposal and potential spills in the driveway. It makes so much sense to pay someone who is setup to do this. There are specialist oil changers in my town. I drive in an 30 mins later I drive out. Paying about 150% of what it would cost me to do it.
- nicbou 6y agoThat's why my dad pays someone else to do it, but rebuilds engines in his garage. I only do motorcycle oil changes, but those are easy.
- mft_ 6y agoFair additional point about having to spend time/mental energy on dealing with the oil disposal. Not a criticism, though - I'm very much in the same 'place' as you - trying to find a better balance of what to do myself vs. outsource... and I fear I often get the balance wrong, on the side of not outsourcing enough. Case in point: I recently changed my GF's car wheels, over to the winter wheel/tyre set. Ahead of time, it's an easy calculation: a few minutes per wheel (I've got good tools including an impact wrench already) saves her a decent amount of money, plus the time to/from/waiting at the garage. But it's easy to underestimate: it may well be 10 minutes-ish per wheel, but this ignores the time spent wrestling the 8 wheels from/to their storage space, plus the relative hassle of having to have somewhere to store them at home. I should have probably not interfered: she'd not really have missed the money, and I could have spent that hour+ doing something more fulfilling (maybe).
- 6y ago
- Thorentis 6y ago> By comparison, my grocery bill is 5€ a day. Do you live on rice and beans? That sounds like you're trading enjoyment for money. We (2 adults) spend about US$150 a week on groceries, and still eat out about once a week. Those groceries include three meals a day, with the leftovers of the night before being taken for lunch the next day. How on earth do people eat healthily and only spend $5 a day?
- cko 6y agoRice, beans, pasta, oats, eggs, nuts, chicken thighs, tomatoes, paprika, onions, potatoes, olive oil, etc. All quite cheap. Requires a bit of initial thought and planning, and maybe experimenting with ingredients. Carbs and fat are both cheap, and protein can be in the form of chicken and eggs. Vegetables are kinda expensive so I go with mostly broccoli, cabbage, and stuff from the Asian supermarket. As for groceries, things like hygiene and cleaning products bring up total "grocery" bill, but $5 a day is very possible if it's pure food expenditure. German groceries are quite cheap actually. When I visited, I bought a kg of sauerkraut for 1 euro and a liter of soy milk for 1.5.
- sdenton4 6y agoAnd you can get even cheaper kraut for the price of a head of cabbage and a bit of salt...
- nicbou 6y agoTwo or three square meals a day with a lot of meat and cheese. I am not careful about price at all, but I do cook from scratch. Base ingredients are usually cheap.
- Emma_Goldman 6y agoI'm from the UK but while I was doing my PhD I spent the equivalent of US$30-40 a week on food. It's very easy, vegetables and staple carbohydrates - pasta, rice and potatoes - are all inexpensive, and I'm a vegetarian so I bought pulses, beans, eggs, soy and nuts for protein. You just buy what you strictly need, and nothing more. It does come at the expense of some enjoyment, but I still spend no more than US$50 a week now - even though I don't really have to think about the cost of my groceries anymore. US$150 seems high to me, I'd struggle to spend that much with my partner if I tried?
- aphroz 6y agoI would probably do what I am doing for a living if I wasn't getting paid for it tho
- nicbou 6y agoMe too, but I'd skip a few meetings and choose more interesting projects. My job nearly killed my passion for programming.
- NiceWayToDoIT 6y agoFor a long time I had an idea that "A real salary is what is left after expenses" so if you earn monthly £2000 but your expenses are £1500 then £500 is your salary. If you earn £1500 but your expenses are £500 effectively you earn £1000 month or more than those that are paid more. So, solution is to earn more or learn how to live more frugal? Of course it is not possible to reduce some expenses, and some expenses are in % (as taxes) so more you earn you will pay more. At one point you could get to the point you do not think how much are your expenses, but for most of the people until that time you will realized that you sold so much time that your life has passed in front of your eyes. Anyhow, it is good advice to find something you love and do it, as often 300 hours of unpaid hobby can give more joy and satisfaction than, all the money in of the best paid job in the world you could earn during that same time.
- devtosales 6y agoCan’t trade joy for a house or clothes for the kids. ... or 5 star holidays along the Mediterranean.
- NiceWayToDoIT 6y agoFor the first one I agree having kids is obligation and duty one must fulfill, (I am single). For the second one, different folks different strokes, I traveled the world and I have not found that 5 stars holidays will give me more joy than random traveling on tight budget. As I enjoy nature and free time - so, super expensive wine, cars or fancy hotels does not mean much to me. Again, I can understand that for some people they do, although I do not know why, but I respect that...
- simonbarker87 6y agoThe extreme savings/retire early website/guy (can’t remember the name and googling is failing me) essentially uses this for working out how early you can retire by focussing on the percentage of your take home that can be saved/invested rather than out right figures. It’s the thing we (my wife and I) focus on, the percentage left over as discretionary money to be saved, invested or spent as we see fit that matters the most to us.
- quickthrower2 6y agoThis might relate to the “look at cash flows not profit” type thinking. Paying people with your post tax money is often expensive. Also paying someone to do my dishes so I can code more is in theory effective, but my brain might be tired and doing dishes myself might be the optimal thing from a humanistic point of view
- keiferski 6y agoAnalyses like this just make me think Basic Income will radically shake up civilization more than most people realize. In particular, it will help divorce this ubiquitous cultural association between time and money. This reason alone may explain some of the hostility toward implementing even a rudimentary form of UBI. Some of the most rewarding human experiences have zero financial value and subsequently are dismissed or ignored as "irrelevant" by a significant amount of people. It would be fantastic if we evaluated the worth of an activity on its beauty, meaning, or another hundred adjectives other than how much money we're losing by doing it. There is also a pretty robust history of academic literature arguing that culture, art, religion, and pretty much everything else arises from leisure time. Leisure: The Basis of Culture by Pieper is a good read on this.
- valvar 6y ago>it will help divorce this ubiquitous cultural association between time and money I think this is naïve at best, and horribly misguided at worst. Time is money is not just a saying. The fundamental currency, the one thing that ever person needs and wants, is time. That's why it's so tightly coupled with other valuable things such as money. Time and money are essentially the same thing, though of course time is less fungible. And different people with different circumstances are able to expedite their actions with varying efficiency. Time is a more fundamental economic concept than money. UBI is essentially just socialist redistribution policy in a different guise, and all it will do is obscure (but of course not erase) existing incentive structures.
- keiferski 6y agoI don’t think you’ve quite understood my comment. I am saying that if a significant portion of the population becomes able to survive without needing a job, the overall culture will shift and things that aren’t immediately lucrative will become more popular. Many of these things are fundamentally important but are brushed aside because they fulfill no role in an economically-oriented society.
- drevil-v2 6y ago
- tempestn 6y agoLooking at net income makes sense, but when it gets into expenses I'm not sure I follow. The idea behind outsourcing is that you can spend additional hours doing paid work. You can't look at your fixed expenses in terms of a fixed amount of each hour's wage if you're increasing the number of hours worked. Of course, it also assumes that people can choose exactly how many hours they work at their regular hourly rate, which isn't usually the case, but that's a separate quibble.
- jpttsn 6y agoYup this is where this article went off the rails for me. After-tax income makes sense when income is what you’re taxed by; the day job creates the income and the tax. But the day job shouldn’t be laden with all costs of living: only the costs of the day job. The author must know either way more economics than me or way less.
- nicbou 6y ago> The idea behind outsourcing is that you can spend additional hours doing paid work There's a whole section of the article that argues that this is not possible. You can't scale your income up and down on a whim. > Of course, it also assumes that people can choose exactly how many hours they work at their regular hourly rate, which isn't usually the case, but that's a separate quibble. It doesn't. There's a whole section just about it. Have you read the whole post? > You can't look at your fixed expenses in terms of a fixed amount of each hour's wage if you're increasing the number of hours worked. There isn't a linear relationship between your gross income and your disposable income, but that doesn't invalidate the calculation. You could say the same about health insurance and income tax. The former is capped (in Germany) to a certain amount, so it becomes a fixed expense past 56250€ per year. The latter is a progressive tax, so it doesn't grow linearly with your income.
- throwaway2245 6y ago> Of course, it also assumes that people can choose exactly how many hours they work at their regular hourly rate, which isn't usually the case It can be the case, but then the trade-off is even worse: This article suggests calculating your net income as an average rate across all your hours worked. If you have chosen to increase your hours, you are taxed at the marginal rate on these increased hours, i.e. the highest possible tax rate. Your net income per hour is reduced - as such, you are undervaluing your own time.
- dmantis 6y agoAs mostly said in the article, the first and biggest expense is taxes. However, taxes amount heavily depends on location you live and possible tax optimisations you can use in your position. For example it may vary in 10x+ times between entrepreneur/nomad in low tax jurisdiction and hired worker in high-tax jurisdiction. Maybe it's smarter to choose country (state in US case) with lowest taxes/highest return than suffering from 30%+ cut. I agree with the author about skills in general, but not every thing we do apart from the job bring us joy and satisfaction. Sometimes it's more convenient to just pay for the work.
- forgotmypw17 6y agoWhen you do it yourself, you have the ability to ensure it is done right. When you pay someone else, they,re bound to cut corners as soon as you turn your head. The choice is obvious to me.
- nicbou 6y agoProfessionals cut corners to cut costs. I accidentally chop them off because I'm tired and incompetent.
- forgotmypw17 6y agotired because you have traded away your sleeping time for money?
- nicbou 6y agoTired because I am stuck maintaining a bunch of dumb things I decided to build, if we're being honest.
- forgotmypw17 6y agowow! i looked at your (?) github, and it,s very cool and impressive. thank you for sharing your work. may you find work-rest-play balance which works for you in thw near future )
- poma88 6y agoPay someone to keep fridge full and house clean. You gain half a life more.
- isamuel 6y agoThe only correct points in here are 3 and 4 but they’re said in a really roundabout way. You don’t sell “time” for money. You sell labor. To do that you need a buyer. Most buyers purchase in bulk, and in many fields, want “requirements agreements”—you’ll produce as much as we need. Selling a little bit of labor power is often like trying to sell one bean. Doesn’t work that way. That’s all you need.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- depablo 6y agoI don't agree with the point you made about groceries. These costs are always fixed. No matter how much you earn. And therefore they are irrelevant to the opportunity cost. For reference, if you earn 20k a month, your grocery expenses will roughly stay the same to earning 5k a month. They won't be 35% of your income (that would be 7000€ of groceries for 20k of income). Working more hours does not result in higher grocery costs.
- nicbou 6y agoStatic expenses also affect your disposable income. You can't pay someone with the money that's allocated to rent. Insurance is also a static cost past a certain income. Income tax is progressive. You still consider those. It just makes the gross/disposable income relationship non-linear.
- depablo 6y agoYes, but static expenses don't make a difference for opportunity costs. You have to pay these costs either way.