8 ms·
The thing is nobody asked voters again since then to see if they haven't changed their mind. Mistake of Cameron was asking without the ability to ensure asking
by scotty79 6y ago
The thing is nobody asked voters again since then to see if they haven't changed their mind.
Mistake of Cameron was asking without the ability to ensure asking again when costs of leaving become apparent to the public.
- nradov 6y agoHow many times should voters be asked to vote on each issue? Everyone loves democracy until the voters make the "wrong" choice.
- alisonkisk 6y ago52-48 is a poor democracy. 48% of the demos ("half") didn't get a cracy. And the 52 were plainly lied to by the politicians who claimed to have a Leave plan but followed up with 4 years of mass confusion and a last minute rushed agreement 11 months after it was due. A good democracy finds a compromise that gets a much larger majority vote.
- sanity31415 6y agoDemocracies are ruled with the consent of the governed. The majority of the British people withdrew their consent to be governed by the EU.
- RestlessMind 6y agoSweden joined EU with a 52.3-47.7 vote. Malta's vote was 53.6-46.4. Should those countries have another round of voting as well before they are admitted to EU?
- LordIllidan 6y agoAs it turns out, Malta did just that - the referendum result was not accepted by the opposition party, and it was settled by an early general election.
- megablast 6y agoSame in the Uk really.
- scotty79 6y agoIf it turned out that it will be horrible costly mess then sure, you'd want to ask again if they still want to do it.
- disabled 6y agoAgreed. The EU is where countries go after empire, and is a solution to that problem (along with all of the lost wars and preventing more lost wars). It also deals with the populism problem far better than America, for example. The UK is going to become a Russian and American playground when Brexit occurs. It will be a paradise for oligarchs to play the populace even more. Oligarchs thrive from the chaos of these sorts of situations and especially financially. I understand why Americans want to come to the UK. A lot of them come for the sole purpose of having access to better and guaranteed healthcare (you can have good insurance and still owe tens of thousands to millions if you have either cancer or a rare disease and both are statistically common—-also the third leading cause of death is believed to be medical errors according to Johns Hopkins and others—-you can go to the best institutions and still very easily die unnecessarily in the US as that kind of statistic cannot be evaded), but the lifespan of the UK population is going to lag hardcore compared to other countries on the European continent, especially ones in or aligned with the EU. Getting UK citizenship can be hard too. They are not immigration friendly at all, unless you were an EU citizen (at least in the past). There are some really esoteric rules, and there are people who have been denied citizenship for having a misdemeanor moving traffic violation, with no arrest or criminal record, who paid the fine on time. If you really want to have access to the UK, become a citizen of the Republic of Ireland, which is part of the EU. By being an EU citizen, you can live/work/retire in over 30 European countries, including all of the EU countries. It is far easier to become an Irish citizen too. They are also very pro-EU. Not only that, citizens of the Republic of Ireland have rights to live/work/retire in the UK due to a common agreement.
- nradov 6y agoThere is very little medical tourism from the US to the UK. In fact patients tend to go the other way. The US has higher 5 year survival rates for most types of cancer.
- disabled 6y agoAmericans frequently emigrate to the UK to eventually have guaranteed lifelong access to healthcare. Tourism is a totally different matter. You go to the “eastern” EU countries in that case. As for the cancer patient survival, in the US, 42% of patients lose their life savings within 2 years and the amount was typically around $92,000. That alone screws American cancer patients over long term, and it can cause them to die. EDIT forgot to add link for further information: https://www.truthorfiction.com/do-four-in-ten-cancer-patients-really-lose-their-life-savings/ https://www.truthorfiction.com/do-four-in-ten-cancer-patient... You can cherry pick data, but your logic does not add up. Spend some time on HealthData.org examining the US versus other developed countries. We may have better cancer survival rates, but when you look at deaths attributed to amenable and non-amenable medical errors (believed to be the US #3 leading cause of death by multiple studies), the average American life expectancy, and anticipated life expectancies in the future (in addition to disability free years of life), it is 100% clear that we fail as a system. A lot of these patients probably had missed or late cancer diagnoses too, due to the lack of preventative care and also just the lack of public health regulations in the US. Pretty much every developed country has a better healthcare system than the US. We do not have a normal system, and many like to think of it as normal, but it is far from that. You can cherry pick data all day, but you are not seeing the big picture here, and you do not realize how easy it is to become a statistic. I nearly died from medical errors in the US healthcare system myself, and from sepsis at age 23. I am a dual US|EU citizen (culturally American) living in the EU, and I never plan on working in the US or living there long term.
- shdbdnd 6y agoIndeed, like every other election the EU has lost. Ignore the result. Remind me how the Lisbon treaty was passed when it was known as the EI constitution? Most voters didn’t get a chance to vote on the most fundamental change of their countries’ being. The voters who did get to vote rejected it. Margins of 10% (France) And 20% (Holland). So what did the EU do? Cancel the referendums in Portugal and the UK to avoid further embarrassment. Then they pretended to have won Brezhnev level margins and passed the constitution anyway. That is how the Lisbon treaty was passed, right?
- _-___________-_ 6y ago> That is how the Lisbon treaty was passed, right? Nope
- disgruntledphd2 6y agoI mean, you are technically correct, in that the alterations to TFEU etc known as lisbon were different from the constitution that was rejected in France and the Netherlands. However, the text was almost the same, and it was a dodge to remove the need for referendums in many EU countries. Additionally, the Irish people voted twice on Lisbon, so it's not true that nobody in the EU got a vote.
- agensaequivocum 6y agoThis is why the American system is superior. The representational nature of it allows minority voices. While sweeping changes, e.g., constitutional amendments, require a 3/5s majority of the states. The grid lock is by design.
- disabled 6y agoIt’s not a superior system when Americans’ votes carry an unequal weight or are outright suppressed. That is not a properly functioning democracy, and what you described above can be exploited to the extreme in such a case. Ultimately, we got lucky this past election, as in “unicorn levels”. What is going on in America is far from over and is going to ultimately be a generational struggle.
- agensaequivocum 6y agoNo that is the literal design, as we are not a pure democratic system. The whole point is that states are sovereign except in a few specific areas, e.g., foreign relations, interstate commerce. The founders were terrified of a tyranny of the majority. So they designed a system that made it difficult. We did not get lucky.
- martimarkov 6y agoWhen my vote != everyone else's vote that is not a democracy. Just because everyone gets a say but we listen to these people more doesn't mean you have a democratic system. If anything you can for sure say it's not democratic.
- refurb 6y agoThat's because you're ignoring that it's the united states. Not one massive state. And again, that's intentional.
- agensaequivocum 6y agoYeah because we are a constitutional republic. The founders were not a fan of pure democracy for good reasons.
- hcayless 6y agoMore to the point, two of the four countries in the union voted to stay, but are being dragged out anyway against their will.
- oska 6y agoOne of those countries, Scotland, had the opportunity to leave the UK two years prior. They chose not to (a result I personally was disappointed by). But having chosen to stay, that also meant they had chosen to be bound by national decisions, at the level of things like continued membership of the EU.
- scotty79 6y agoNot how many times but how often. And the answer is, as often as is needed to ensure that lawmakers are aligned with the public on particular issue, before they do something costly and possibly irreversible.
- mantap 6y agoSystems of democracy require legislators to vote often, frequently on the same issue several times. For instance, in the UK a bill has at least a first, second and third reading. In a direct democracy, where voters take on the role of legislators, voters are certainly expected to vote on the same subject more than once. Of course, the UK isn't a direct democracy. And that is exactly the problem. People in the UK generally don't understand how direct democracies work, and forgivably so since there's no constitutional law regulating direct democracy in the UK, only subjective feelings.
- onion2k 6y agoHow many times should voters be asked to vote on each issue? Just once, but "Do you want to leave Europe in general, without knowing the deal?" and "Do you want to leave on these specific terms that will have this specific impact on the UK?" are different issues.
- nradov 6y agoThat wasn't as available option. The EU was unwilling to negotiate a provisional exit deal prior to the UK referendum. And after the referendum passed and was implemented by Parliament, there's no way the EU would have negotiated a binding deal if it could have been vetoed by a second UK referendum.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoIt's not black and white. Voters can vote 'yes' once, but you have to vote 'no' a hundred times. No is never no. Its 'not yet'. So there's a tremendous constant pressure to change things. Thus it seems reasonable to put some brakes on some of the 'yesses'.
- nradov 6y agoThings can change again. In theory the UK could rejoin the EU. I wouldn't be surprised if that happens in a few decades after the demographics shift. Younger UK voters were generally in favor of remaining in the EU.
- maest 6y agoThe ideal answer is, clearly, closer to continuous voting rather than voting a single time. Circumstances change all the time, so voting a single time makes no sense. Arguably, that's why certain issues should be decided with a supermajority only. That way, you allow for some people to change their mind without affecting what the majority thinks.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- tacocataco 6y agoSo should all elected representatives should serve life appointments? Huge tangent, I started searching if joining the EU (European Economic Community) was a simple majority or a super majority and wound up here: https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2016-09-05/debates/580694B7-CD84-4929-8DCF-BAF46D47AF64/ExitingTheEuropeanUnion https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2016-09-05/debates/580... it's fascinating to me to read how optimistic people were about brexit in 2016. Hope it's ok if I link what I'm reading. Just trying to catch up as a 'merican.
- timthorn 6y agoNot in a referendum, but both a European election and at least one general election provided evidence to suggest that the voters hadn't changed their minds.
- shard972 6y agoSince when do we redo elections to see if people changed their minds? Seems like its only when a progressive type of person doesn't get their way under democracy.
- jodrellblank 6y agoWe redo elections every ~4 years in the US and UK to see if people changed their minds, don't we?
- fortnum 6y agoThat is not exactly true. There was no second referendum, but there were two general elections and in both the party pushing for Brexit decisively won. Labour would have probably stopped Brexit and people could have voted for them, but they did not.
- scotty79 6y agoWhat people shown is that local politics matter to them more than EU membership. Very few people decided to forget their political preferences just for 'probably'. So fair enough. UK citizens probably earned what they got into.
- yardstick 6y agoThe British electoral system is fundamentally broken in its first past the post system. It disenfranchises millions of voters in safe seats throughout the country. My seat is super safe, hasn’t changed hands since 1974, possibly longer. Still, the 25% of voters who didn’t support the winner won’t have their voices heard, and in other marginal electorates it’s just under half of the voters underrepresented. The solution for the UK (and US) would be to adopt a proportional representation voting system. Not the single transferable vote of Australia like what was proposed years ago. I’m talking about Mixed Member Proportional representation (MMP), used in NZ and other countries. You have two votes, one for your local MP and one for a party. They don’t need to be for the same political group. Parliament is then made up of a combination of electorate MPs and party vote MPs (roughly two thirds electorate one third party). So even if you are in a safe seat, at least one of your two votes still counts. It makes coalitions more likely, which means more viewpoints are considered. In NZ this has led to parties like the Greens having a bit of influence in govt, whereas under FPTP those green voters were completely disenfranchised. More info https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/428085/election-2020-our-mmp-voting-system-explained https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/national/428085/election-2020-our...
- techsupporter 6y ago> Labour would have probably stopped Brexit and people could have voted for them, but they did not. Except that Labour did not campaign on stopping Brexit; quite the opposite. Corbyn (who, depending on who you ask, is possibly a bigger Euroskeptic than David Cameron ever was) pointedly did not position Labour's election stance as being anti-Brexit. That was up to the LibDems who, in a FPTP system, were not going to win anyway largely because everyone still hates them over the college fees reversal. Corbyn's Labour party always insisted that it would negotiate the "best possible Brexit," one that was more or less a "soft Brexit" but, just like the Tories, still a Brexit with all that entails. People were pleading with Corbyn to do exactly as you described and make the GE a mini-referendum on Brexit by Labour campaigning to reject Brexit...but Corbyn didn't.
- Iwan-Zotow 6y agoSurely asked and answered - BoJo, well-known Brexit guy, led conservative party to decisive victory in 2019 elections and rightfully became PM How much more are you going to ask?
- ed_elliott_asc 6y agoThe 2019 election was less a vote for bojo and brexit and more not a vote for corbyn
- ern 6y agoI don’t have any strong opinions about this since I’m not from the UK (if anything I’d probably be mildly pro-remain), but the Conservatives scored a fairly convincing victory in the 2019 General Election. I’d say that is strong evidence (Labour weakness aside) that the British public didn’t change their minds about Brexit.
- desertedisland 6y agoThe voters were asked three times: one referendum and two general elections, the last of which was won overwhelmingly by the party which had a single message - to 'get brexit done' - and lost by the party which denied the democratic wishes of every single region in England except London.
- yardstick 6y agoThe general elections aren’t a fair representation of voting in Brexit again. Labour’s policy and leadership was always unclear on their Brexit position, and the party itself and especially its leadership was perceived (or unfairly portrayed, you pick) by many as too extremist left for many centrists to stomach voting for. The only fair vote on Brexit is a referendum, and we botched the parameters of that (52% yes means in a room of people the person opposite you disagreed with your decision, not a great place to start!)
- zionic 6y agoMisleading garbage narrative from 2016. The last elections were a landslide for a reason: the voters wanted Brexit. You can disagree all you like, but they want it.
- katbyte 6y ago52% is a landslide?
- gorgoiler 6y agoIn a first-past-the-post representative democracy enthralled with partisan party politics, one party having a majority of 80 votes over all others combined is a landslide. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/f/f1/UK_House_of_Commons_2020.svg/1280px-UK_House_of_Commons_2020.svg.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/f/f1/UK...
- Symbiote 6y agoThough they got the 80 seat majority with less than half of the popular vote (43%).