15 ms·
Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sharing into Omnibus Bill
- scanny 6y agoIt' a shame the rest of the world has can be impacted at the whim of U.S lawmakers given that so many major sites are U.S based. I wonder what it would take to have a more global distribution of hosts? Or is it impossible for a creator/developer who is based in the U.S. to avoid this even if the site were to be hosted elsewhere?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- croes 6y agoThe US enforce their laws on other countries. But similar laws are already in place e.g. in the EU.
- Laarlf 6y agoWhich kinda shows that you cannot escape the madness.
- sschueller 6y agoThe US already holds the balls of the rest of the world in their hands. Countries raid homes of torrent downloaders because they are afraid of loosing access to the almighty dollar.
- pm90 6y agoFinancial sanctions (mostly just the threat of them) are usually enough to coerce any country that’s integrated in the global market to do the bidding of US lawmakers.
- TheHypnotist 6y agoDon't most pirate stream facilitators sit offshore?
- fatbird 6y agoThis is a problem of legislative mechanism. The way U.S. and state gov'ts create and pass legislation is a playground of perverse incentives, opaque procedure, and the worst aspects of gamesmanship. One immediate fix would be for strict party line votes being the norm. It would remove horse trading from the equation: a majority party would pass the legislation it wants to, without adding extreme elements to negotiate away, or riders to buy critical swing votes. The result would be more coherent legislation that can be judged on its merits.
- learc83 6y agoWith that system you effectively remote one or the biggest advantages of the rule of law—predictability. At the very least you’d need to massively increase the term length of Congress. Radical swings back and forth every 2 years would be a nightmare for planning anything. It would also basically ensure that any policy that took more than a few years to make a positive impact was doa.
- jabl 6y agoLike diapers, politicians become dirty and need to be changed. I don't think drastically longer terms are a solution. Systems with proportional representation tend to be much less susceptible to this, as a few seats changing won't tip the balance from one extreme to the other. I have no idea how such a thing could be enacted though, as legislative power is in the hands of the two parties that would be the major losers in a switch away from FPTP.
- zachrose 6y agoBut wouldn’t that just move the horse trading into the even more opaque process of deciding party positions?
- fatbird 6y agoParty positions are decided by party leadership--an even smaller and clearer group to hold accountable for particular laws. You already have an opaque process of deciding party positions amongst insiders. What party-line votes do is cause 1) clearer legislation to be passed that's 2) entirely the responsibility of a single party.
- shmerl 6y agoWhat should be a criminal offense is such practice of sneaking horrendous policy into some massive bill to hide it from the public and make it easier to pass. Now corrupt politicians can pass such garbage without any repercussion.
- EnderWT 6y agoThis isn't anything new[1][2], though it's a shame it's allowed. Apparently congressmen had to vote on it two hours[3] after receiving the 5000 page bill. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omnibus_bill https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Omnibus_bill [2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rider_(legislation) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rider_(legislation) [3]https://twitter.com/AOC/status/1341145260014100480 https://twitter.com/AOC/status/1341145260014100480
- shmerl 6y agoPretty conductive for corruption.
- jml7c5 6y agoThe question isn't how long they had to read the final version of the bill, the question is how long they had to read all of the components of the bill. If this final bill was only a 50 page modification to some draft that had been discussed for weeks, then it's really not that surprising.
- clort 6y agoImagine if there was a commit log which could be inspected to see what had changed, rather than getting a 5000 page document with no indication.
- _underfl0w_ 6y agoIf only they had the equivalent of `git diff`. Side note, who mandates these time constraints? Why are seemingly arbitrary deadlines applied? If a bill can stand on its own, why rush it at all unless you intend to enable surreptitious changes that will hopefully be missed?
- bilegeek 6y agoIs it even possible to win this battle? Things like this keep coming up year after year, whittling down opposition; then once in place, it is 10x as hard to overturn, aka effectively impossible. I feel as though the only thing we can do is dig in simply to delay the inevitable.
- hedberg10 6y agoNo. Pick up the can, citizen.
- RpFLCL 6y agoI often wonder if it's possible to encourage lawmakers to pass laws in the opposite direction. I.e., to instead pass laws that guarantee the right of citizens to share information, make content, etc in ways that shall not be infringed. Laws that affirm freedom of expression and free speech in the digital space, instead of laws that increasingly punish common behavior in the name of copyright or "think of the children" type rhetoric. I don't have much experience in law so I don't know if something like this is even possible. Can laws only dictate punishments? Is it possible to use legislation to make encroachments of freedom harder, or does that require a constitutional amendment? Is it a question of financial lobbying power? Perhaps a more legally informed user could chime in about how feasible it is to push for legislation in the other direction.
- bilegeek 6y ago> Is it possible to use legislation to make encroachments of freedom harder, or does that require a constitutional amendment? This phrase just drags me into darkness. Things are so broken, that such legislation is impossible to imagine today. IANAL, but theoretically, yes, we have the ability to pass and enforce laws that would protect individual and societal rights. In practice, you would need a complete overhaul of both the rules and incentives of the current political system; however, such an overhaul would need a fair and just system to be here in the first place, otherwise it'll just entrench the authoritarianism and/or refuse to enforce the good parts, put in there only as platitudes. So, actually, no.
- blargmaster42_8 6y agoAnti meme is clearly from butt hurt leftist!
- pg_bot 6y agoWe need to pass the single subject amendment. Legislation needs to be able to stand on its own.
- RpFLCL 6y agoYes. I could not agree more. The mind absolutely boggles trying to understand how a legislator can force an unpopular act like this into an unrelated appropriations bill and think they're doing something good. I don't know if they're acting on greed, malice, or if their campaign funding is somehow tied into the companies and lobbies that push for these bills, but they know as well as we do that this would never pass if citizens had the opportunity to lobby against it and other legislators had the opportunity to question it. It's a failure of our system.
- DubiousPusher 6y ago> their campaign funding is somehow tied into the companies and lobbies that push for these bills It is. But there is more to it than that. Most people in elected office aren't robots just following the biggest diner checks. A lot of times they believe in what these amendments. The lobbying and whatnot actually works. Because just like you and me, they are susceptible to the environment in which they dwell. A lobbyist can't buy a legislator's vote but they can buy you a legislator's time. That time let's you create the information environment that can influence any person. Which is of course why these lobbying relationships become so long and so entangling. Mark my words, the people behind this amendment believe pirates are cheating honest companies out of something.
- ramphastidae 6y agoNonsense. What is more likely — innocent legislators looking out for the best interests of their people are caught under the spell of uniquely persuasive lobbyists who paid for dinner that one time — or that this game has been being played for decades and that both sides know exactly what’s going on? Lobbyists donate to the politician’s campaign or foundation in exchange for political favors. If things go well, the bribe is increased to insider trading tips, a board position, or a cushy private job at the lobbying firm after their term is up. It’s that simple.
- cinquemb 6y agoNot surprising, wanting to legislate what tech has made increasingly cheaper and more available over time for decades… hastening more people to invest in distributed architectures for both storage and distribution…
- akersten 6y ago"Felony streaming." Consider the absurdity of that concept. Categorizing the re-transmission of someone else's imaginary property in the same bucket as committing murder. Looks like it's going to the Senate, poised to pass. There's not much else an average person can do than call in and object. I would encourage anyone in a position of power to enforce laws like this to say No. Do not implement systems to enable this. Make it as hard as possible for the copyright mafia to extort ordinary internet users. Civilly disobey. It's a tough fight, but it's one we can't give up - or one day your device will have to run ContentID before you can Ctrl-V.
- jml7c5 6y ago>Consider the absurdity of that concept. Categorizing the re-transmission of someone else's imaginary property in the same bucket as committing murder. Printing funny green pieces of paper is a felony too. I get the rhetorical effect you're going for, but it's silly to pretend that all felonies are as severe as murder.
- CGamesPlay 6y agoAlthough to me "categorizing the re-transmission of someone else's imaginary property in the same bucket as counterfeiting currency" also has a pretty strong rhetorical effect.
- swebs 6y agoThey're both pretty similar actually. With money, its just that the government owns the copyright.
- spacemanmatt 6y agoIf we're really going to conflate counterfeiting currency with streaming then I'll get out the ketchup and my finest silver to stick a fork in the very well-done HN.
- 6y ago
- nynx 6y agoThis is absolutely infuriating. Something is rotten in the state of the United States.
- hamandcheese 6y agoIs there any accountability re: which congressman actually added which piece of language to a bill?
- ARandomerDude 6y agoProbably not. Most voters have extremely short political memories and we just finished an election. From a politician's perspective, this is the perfect moment to do something outrageous. Besides, other issues probably impact which way constituents are likely to vote more than copyright law.
- thayne 6y agoNo. Every election I try to figure out how the candidates have voted on issues I care about, like digital freedoms. And every time I fail to find anything useful. Maybe in theory it is possible with enough time and patience, but for the ordinary citizen, it is practically impossible.
- alexilliamson 6y agoJust curious, have you checked the congressional record? It's free text, but everything that is said in congress is recorded there. I think Bill Amendments are included, but not sure.
- thayne 6y agoAnd who has time to read through all of that?
- alexilliamson 6y agoA machine could perhaps learn to do it!
- ARandomerDude 6y agoAdding this to my ever-growing list of reasons I stopped using Facebook and Twitter...
- NiceWayToDoIT 6y agoHacker news are for polite and rational an above intelligent conversation, but some things that are coming from politicians nowadays are so, in lack of more polite words, mindless, that sheer gravity of their actions leaves me speechless. It is like a constant stream of attack on freedom of speech by dictatorship and fascism 2.0 (better, stronger upgraded version, more sneaker and cunning). It begins to look like a rise of condition before second world war. Before you know it, we stand in line and exclaim 'Hail to Y'. Sometimes, I think evil has a game called, attempts, if you try X number of times at the end something corrupt will pass. Interesting enough in the same week in Serbia they want to pass law that will "Forbid people insulting high government official if that could cause deep emotional stress to their family members"
- LordDragonfang 6y ago>fascism 2.0 (better, stronger upgraded version, more sneaker and cunning) I think you're both giving too little credit to the original fascists, and to much credit to the people falling for it a second time. Fascism was plenty good at deception and bending of truths the first time around, and at this point in the second go around, they've stopped being subtle about it. Remember that a) plenty of people supported the Nazis, and that Hitler's party was voted into power, and b) people on the left have been pointing out the proto-fascist rhetoric since Trump's first campaign, and moderate liberals are all acting surprised that the neo-fascists are suggesting fascist things (like subverting a democratic election with military force)
- NiceWayToDoIT 6y agoI agree, for now community is vigilant, but I am afraid does'n need much for those same forces to flip a coin. My issue is that I perceive world as accumulation of knowledge and acting upon what is learned for the benefit of all. Then, when what should be considered a serious group of people, proposes a law that is just like introduction of malicious code withing OS, I am left dumbfounded with question "Why?!"
- nightcracker 6y ago> Hitler's party was voted into power This is a misrepresentation of what happened. They first tried a coup in 1920. When that failed they tried gathering votes. They won a plurality, not a majority. After that this guy is responsible for the transformation into a dictatorship: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_von_Hindenburg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_von_Hindenburg > In 1925, Hindenburg returned to public life to become the second elected President of the German Weimar Republic. Despite being personally opposed to Hitler and his Nazi party, he was nonetheless a major player in the political instability that resulted in their rise to power. Upon twice dissolving the Reichstag in 1932, Hindenburg ultimately agreed to appoint Hitler as Chancellor of Germany in January 1933 when the Nazis won a plurality in the November elections. In response to the Reichstag Fire allegedly committed by a communist arsonist, he approved the Reichstag Fire Decree in February 1933 which suspended various civil liberties. Later in March, he signed the Enabling Act of 1933 which gave Hitler's regime emergency powers. After Hindenburg died the following year, Hitler combined the Presidency with his office as Chancellor before proceeding to declare himself Führer und Reichskanzler des deutschen Volkes (i.e. "Leader and Reich Chancellor of the German People") and transform Germany into a totalitarian state.
- dd36 6y agoOh no. What else is in there?
- esalman 6y agoHR1044, repealing per-country cap on employment based immigration. I have heard about strong lobbying in support of this. If enacted, it will increase wait time for immigration from 1-2 years to at least 17 years. It will benefit certain countries who are lobbying in support, but render legal immigration nearly impossible for everyone else.
- sschueller 6y agoSo streaming someone ripping a statue down will be illegal? Good luck finding the person who actually committed the crime since no one will be filming if they can't live stream...
- kart23 6y agoSigh. Guess which democrat tried to institute this bill ten years ago? Amy Klobuchar. And thankfully it got shot down then. But anyway, I think there's more to this headline, does anyone have the actual text of the felony streaming part? All I've seen are these clickbaity headlines with no real substance. Looks like it was Senator Tillis that proposed the idea and got it included. I'm hopeful the law will be enforced in a reasonable way. However, its very deceptive to sneak legislation by in this way, and something should be done about it. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_S.978 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_S.978 https://twitter.com/SenThomTillis/status/1341133844712480769 https://twitter.com/SenThomTillis/status/1341133844712480769
- viraptor 6y agoFrom the tweet: > It will end commercial piracy by criminal organizations and will not apply to internet users. I guess it's aimed at putlocker & co in that case? I'm surprised that they both lasted so long and that we need any extra laws to regulate them. If mega got prosecuted, that seems like a proof we don't need more rules.
- TheKarateKid 6y agoMost of the illicit streaming services are run from abroad anyway, so it's not like this will change anything. Perhaps it will allow easier extradition since its now a felony, but they didn't seem to have a problem doing that already.
- syntaxing 6y agoYou. Must. Vote. This is extremely infuriating but it’s even more maddening that we as a country, voted for this. We voted for our representative. We voted for what they stand for. There’s no one to blame but ourselves (even though you didn’t “directly” vote for them, we still bear the brunt of the decision, that’s how a democracy works). But I’m honestly hopeful that voters will get wiser as the current state of technology becomes a commodity. The thing that does concern me, is the irreversible damage that will take generations to heal.
- frongpik 6y agoWe've been given an illusion of choice between a few carefully preselected candidates. Most of positions in today's ballots are like this: a really bad candidate and a bunch of lunatics or outright fakes as an alternative.
- jedmeyers 6y ago> You. Must. Vote. Of course, but there is very little utility to it when the vote counting is hidden behind an opaque software system, and you have no way of confirming that the vote counting is secure. So sure, go vote, but with absence of verified and secure counting it's almost pointless.
- LockAndLol 6y agoPromote open source and vote for those that do. It takes time but it isn't that hard. Of course you have to execute what you preach and use more open source yourself otherwise that'd just be hypocrisy.
- xyzzyz 6y agoInstead of blaming yourself for the actions of the elected officials you voted for, consider that you have absolutely no control over what that official does, beyond literally one bit of data you’re allowed to send every 2 or 4 years. That’s one of the problems with democracy: it gives illusion of control and provides legitimacy that politicians need to do what they want.
- frongpik 6y agoThese clowns have been trying so hard the entire year that I wonder if they're trying to distract us from something really important. Given how coordinated the entire world is, it must be no less than an alien spaceship.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 6y agoFrom the PDF: TITLE II - INTELLECTUAL PROPERTY Subtitle A - Copyrights SEC. 211. - UNAUTHORIZED STREAMING. (a) AMENDMENT. Chapter 113 of title 18, United States Code, is amended by inserting after section 2319B the following: 2319C. Illicit digital transmission services (a) DEFINITIONS. In this section (1) the terms "audiovisual work", "computer program", "copies", "copyright owner", "digital transmission", "financial gain", "motion picture", "motion picture exhibition facility", "perform", "phonorecords", "publicly" (with respect to performing a work), "sound recording", and "transmit" have the meanings given those terms in section 101 of title 17; (2) the term "digital transmission service" means a service that has the primary purpose of publicly performing works by digital transmission; (3) the terms "publicly perform" and "public performance" refer to the exclusive rights of a copyright owner under paragraphs (4) and (6) of section 106 (relating to exclusive rights in copyrighted works) of title 17, as limited by sections 107 through 122 of title 17; and (4) the term "work being prepared for commercial public performance" means (A) a computer program, a musical work, a motion picture or other audiovisual work, or a sound recording, if, at the time of unauthorized public performance (i) the copyright owner has a reasonable expectation of commercial public performance; and (ii) the copies or phonorecords of the work have not been commercially publicly performed in the United States by or with the authorization of the copyright owner; or (B) a motion picture, if, at the time of unauthorized public performance, the motion picture (i)(I) has been made available for viewing in a motion picture exhibition facility; and (II) has not been made available in copies for sale to the general public in the United States by or with the authorization of the copyright owner in a format intended to permit viewing outside a motion picture exhibition facility; or (ii) had not been commercially publicly performed in the United States by or with the authorization of the copyright owner more than 24 hours before the unauthorized public performance. (b) PROHIBITED ACT. It shall be unlawful for a person to willfully, and for purposes of commercial advantage or private financial gain, offer or provide to the public a digital transmission service that (1) is primarily designed or provided for the purpose of publicly performing works protected under title 17 by means of a digital transmission without the authority of the copyright owner or the law; (2) has no commercially significant purpose or use other than to publicly perform works protected under title 17 by means of a digital transmission without the authority of the copyright owner or the law; or (3) is intentionally marketed by or at the direction of that person to promote its use in publicly performing works protected under title 17 by means of a digital transmission without the authority of the copyright owner or the law. (c) PENALTIES. Any person who violates subsection (b) shall be, in addition to any penalties provided for under title 17 or any other law (1) fined under this title, imprisoned not more than 3 years, or both; (2) fined under this title, imprisoned not more than 5 years, or both, if (A) the offense was committed in connection with 1 or more works being prepared for commercial public performance; and (B) the person knew or should have known that the work was being prepared for commercial public performance; and (3) fined under this title, imprisoned not more than 10 years, or both, if the offense is a second or subsequent offense under this section or section 2319(a). (d) RULE OF CONSTRUCTION. Nothing in this section shall be construed to (1) affect the interpretation of any other provision of civil copyright law, including the limitations of liability set forth in section 512 of title 17, or principles of secondary liability; or (2) prevent any Federal or State authority from enforcing cable theft or theft of service laws that are not subject to preemption under section 301 of title 17. (b) TABLE OF SECTIONS AMENDMENT. The table of section for chapter 113 of title 18, United States Code, is amended by inserting after the item relating to section 2319B the following: 2319C. Illicit digital transmission services.
- freakynit 6y ago"I believe" - there's a grand plan underway to make all major governments run in dictatorship-like fashion, and make all small businesses to shutdown and large corporates working with these governments to overtake everything, even the very basic human rights. India, the largest democracy, is going through a period right now where one party is running the country and the law in almost a dictatorship-like manner. For reference, google "India farm bills". A set of bills inacted into the law without thorough discussions, which opens up the door for total corporate control of the major occupation of majority in the country, the agriculture. Disclaimer - above are personal views only, and maybe 100% wrong. Do your own research.
- garyd 6y agoTake my guns but not my memes!
- coolspot 6y agoMilitary-grade memes have no place in our communities!
- PenisBanana 6y agoOnly pre-release is covered. Post-release is not attacked in this bill: | | ... the copies or phonorecords of the work have not been commercially publicly performed in the United States by or with the authorization of the copyright owner; or | (B) a motion picture, if, at the time of unauthorized public performance, the motion picture | (i) | (I) has been made available for viewing in a motion picture exhibition facility; and | (II) has not been made available in copies for sale to the general public in the United States by or with the authorization of the copyright owner in a format intended to permit viewing outside a motion picture exhibition facility;
- thinkingemote 6y agoThat is from the definitions part of the document, which defines what "work being prepared for commercial public performance" means. EDITS - on page 2543 https://rules.house.gov/sites/democrats.rules.house.gov/files/BILLS-116HR133SA-RCP-116-68.pdf https://rules.house.gov/sites/democrats.rules.house.gov/file... 3 years for released works. 5 years for unreleased stuff. So it's not just for pre-release. Pre-release just gives you an additional 2 years in prison!
- not_a_moth 6y agoOur political establishment class is so detached from the will of the people I don't even know how to categorize the type of society America has become.
- s5300 6y agoMostly playground for the rich, duh.
- ur-whale 6y agoOne has to wonder if such a law would even have been proposed under a Trump second term.
- spacemanmatt 6y agoIt happened under his first term, so I don't see exactly see the room for doubt regarding a second term.
- ur-whale 6y agoIf there ever was an illusion left that America was a democracy, here's a blatant example that control has been wrestled away from you and I by corporate interest groups. Crony capitalism at its finest.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- rmrfstar 6y agoThe FBI is going to be mining NSA intercepts to catch people streaming Michael Radford's production of "1984" without a permit. The security state is a jobs program, and Congress delivers the bacon. Will they have probable cause for a wiretap if I talk about watching a movie, but my credit card data (which they have) shows no evidence of purchasing that movie? Now we see why they tried so hard to ruin at Aaron Swartz. Had he survived his encounter with the Justice Department, Aaron would probably be a member of Congress leading the charge against this monstrosity. They are shutting down the Open Technology Fund as well, an important early supporter of both signal and tor.
- elmo2you 6y agoOn a fundamental level, how can the adoption of laws in bulk (like with such omnibus bills) ever be considered democratic and not just (at best) pretty much an open invitation for all kinds of corruptions? Isn't it essential for democracy that lawmakers decide on laws based on merits, instead of their adoption being dependent on all kind of unrelated laws and other external factors? How did this practice ever become a defensible one? I guess there will plenty of US citizens who have found a way to rationalize/defend this process, but I sincerely wonder if that might not be the most fundamental mistake of them all. Seriously though .. why does anyone consider the USA a democratic state of law? I mean, both in absolute terms and in comparison with many other countries, it simply appears to be neither .. that despite unparalleled volumes of systemic propaganda to the contrary and many of its citizens stubbornly holding on to this belief that the USA is somehow a beacon and example to the rest of the world. I grew up, as many others who grew up in NATO countries during the 80s, with horror stories about USSR and Chinese state propaganda. I have no doubt that a lot of that was actually true and certainly devastating. However, with the years, it increasingly appears as if the USA might actually be (and may always have been) the worst of them all. Just that most of its propaganda hides in plain sight, under banners of individual freedom and prosperity. Sure, you can say whatever you want, as long as you don't pose any real threat to anything of importance. But that is actually not all that different in most parts of the world (Russia and China included; despite the US trying to convince everyone to the contrary). Sure, the USA appears to act less oppressive towards its citizens (or at least compared to the stories they tell about events in other countries). But with a population so thoroughly brainwashed since birth, and being able to do what they do (most lucrative/criminal things almost exclusive in other countries) unopposed either way, maybe they just don't need it as much. Feel free to down vote and flag, I honestly don't care (anymore). In fact, I would prefer to delete this account if HN allowed that. Because sincerely, I'm done with this site and this "community". Good luck to you all. Just don't expect any sympathy, for anyone who will argue something along the lines of "we didn't know" or "we could not have seen that coming".
- SeanBean62 6y agoYou are lucky - I hate my nation now - my place of birth I have Native American ancestors they were not any better really I do envy people born in Canada or even Poland because I could move to Germany I do love the weather and when I can get high enough to forget about the republicans I like it I like that we have the Grand Canyon and New York but if you are stuck in a job for a pension and health insurance and can’t leave it sucks - yeah fuck being American it sucks deep inside
- afrojack123 6y agoThey are mixing up a stimulus bill with all sorts of other things they want like military foreign aid and freedom of speech. The public thinks this is about stimulus. Not at all and the politicians know this.
- api 6y agoWe really need a one-bill-one-topic amendment to the constitution. I think that one be one of the most effective reforms we could possibly make to reduce both idiotic laws and wasteful spending. Both of these things often get shoehorned into other bills that "must" pass. The line item veto is a backhanded way to try to do this, but isn't the best solution.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- yowlingcat 6y agoFor any of the more legally erudite commenters here: what are the chances that something like this survives court scrutiny? Something like this seems to run afoul of free speech vis a vis the fair use doctrine as I understand it [1] so how large of a threat is something like this long term outside of it being able to cause an immense amount of pain and corporatist bludgeoning in the meantime? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_use#U.S._fair_use_factors https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fair_use#U.S._fair_use_factors
- ac29 6y agoThe law expressly says "as limited by sections 107 through 122 of title 17". Section 107 covers fair use, so this new law does not override or otherwise conflict with it.
- nasalgoat 6y agoThe main problem with this is that the streaming platforms don't offer any way for streamers to do it legally. For instance, Jack Danger is a pinball streamer who does the newest games, and Stern just released a Led Zeppelin game, and his stream was cut off mid-way through because the fully licensed game plays LZ tunes. Not only does this fall under fair use, he is more than willing to pay a fee to legally stream these games and the music they play. But Twitch doesn't offer this option. Neither does YouTube, or Facebook.
- hakfoo 6y agoI feel like one of the problems here is that we don't have some concept of "license exhaustion." There needs to be a point where we can say "you got paid once for this, and you can't keep inventing new fragmentary rights and segmentations to get another bite at the same apple." It feels like that point should be when Stern paid to include the songs in the machine.. That minimizes the burden on everyone else, trying to guess what is permissible and having to cut things up to satisfy the licensing bureaucracy. It reminds me of the situation where we have crappy TV box sets where the music gets replaced because the concept of a home-video release wasn't even on the radar to consider when the original series was prepared and paid for. Again, the license should have been paid for and exhausted at that point. I really believe the ultimate answer is a mandatory (presumably state-run) IP clearinghouse-- whether you want to pay 10 cents to buy cover for the neighbour's TV audio bleeding into your livestream, or a bajillion dollars for "every movie ever made" to populate your streaming service, there should be a way to cut out the complexity of "who do I speak with" and "what do I do if they're dead/unreachable/intentionally uncooperative". Twitch writes a cheque for a few hundred grand a month to for blanket coverage, and the IP cartels fight behind the scenes to slice it up.
- tmaly 6y agoHow would this impact fair use? I could see someone sharing something on a monetized YouTube channel that would open you up to potentially being fined.
- greyhair 6y agoReading this article takes me back to my youth when a couple of very attractive coeds were staffing a table asking people to sign a petition banning nuclear weapons. I cannot recall the details (40 years ago) but I asked to see the actual full text of the petition, and it was just loaded with so much baggage, that it was only vaguely related to banning nuclear weapons, and was loaded with a bunch of socialist dogma. But hey, you know, banning nuclear weapons. And they were really attractive. So wow, the number of signatures.